Campaign Finance Law and the Internet: Problems Raised for Individuals Online Political Speech
|
|
- Oscar Douglas
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Campaign Finance Law and the Internet: Problems Raised for Individuals Online Political Speech John B. Morris, Jr. Center for Democracy & Technology On March 28, 2005, the Federal Election Commission ( FEC ) issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking ( NPRM ) proposing to extend campaign finance regulations to certain political speech on the Internet. The public may comments on the proposed rules until June 3, The FEC has released a helpful detailed summary of the NPRM, and CDT & IPDI have released a very brief overview of the NPRM. The main affirmative step the NPRM proposes is to define the statutory term public communication to include paid advertisements placed on third party s Internet sites, thereby bringing such advertisements within the reach of the FEC s campaign finance regulations. It is apparent that the FEC sought to confine its regulatory coverage of Internet communications to only a narrow category of speech, and to leave largely unregulated the great bulk of online political speech of ordinary people on the Internet. But notwithstanding the narrow aim of the FEC s NPRM, both the proposed new rules and existing (and unchanged) regulations fit very poorly in the Internet context. Speech on the Internet is so fundamentally different than speech on other mass media that the laws and rules crafted for old media have significant unintended consequences when imposed on new media. And nowhere are the harmful effects more clear than with the speech of ordinary people, individuals who through the Internet can reach out and speak directly to their fellow voters for the first time in our history since the town common ceased being a common meeting ground. Simply put, the campaign finance laws even with the careful efforts of the FEC impose significant burdens on individual speech, and ultimately will have the effect of chilling that speech. This discussion of problems raised by the NPRM and campaign finance laws more generally focuses only on the impact on individual speakers the ordinary voters expressing their political views on the new medium of the Internet. This discussion assumes that campaign finance laws do and should apply to some Internet speech (online speech, for example, of campaigns and party organizations), and it leaves for another debate questions about whether the online speech of large corporations and unions should be regulated exactly the same as their offline speech. Instead, the concerns discussed below focus only on burdens on online speech of ordinary men and women. The discussion below looks at two types of problems. First, generally speaking, the fact that the campaign finance laws are ill-suited for the Internet creates fundamental burdens when those laws are applied to online speech of individuals. Second, a variety of particular aspects of political speech on the Internet raise specific, detailed problems for individuals speech online.
2 I. FECA and the Internet: 500 Pages of Detailed Rules about Apples But Applied to Oranges The foundation of modern campaign finance regulation the Federal Election Campaign Act ( FECA ) was enacted by Congress in Among other things, FECA imposed limits on how much a candidate could spend on television advertising (a limit that was subsequently overturned by the Supreme Court), and bolstered rules about the disclosure of contributions and expenditures. In subsequent legislation in 1974 and 1976 Congress restructured FECA and created a far more comprehensive regime of disclosure requirements, contribution limits, and spending limits. And, critically, the 1974 FECA Amendments created the Federal Election Commission. Thus, by the mid- 1970s, Congress had launched the key elements of today s campaign finance regulatory system. Another historic development occurred in In May of that year, Vinton Cerf and Robert Kahn published A Protocol for Packet Network Intercommunication, which was the first description of what became the Transmission Control Protocol the TCP of the TCP/IP suite of protocols that form the foundation of what we now call the Internet. The first commercial dial-up Internet access was not available until 1990, and the World Wide Web was not invented until The Internet did not see broad adoption until the late 1990s. Not only did the Internet as we know it emerge long after the campaign finance system was created, but the technical and demographic characteristics of the Internet are radically different than any preceding electronic media of mass communications. As of the 1970s and the advent of modern campaign finance rules, the means of mass communications were well established as narrow channels of speech available to a very limited number of speakers. And critically, to reach a big audience, a speaker needed big money, often tens of thousands of dollars for a single advertisement. Moreover, for radio, television, and even newspapers, the listening audience had little or no control over what they heard although they could change channels, they could do little to avoid commercials including campaign advertisements. The Internet stands in stark contrast to the mass media of the 1970s. The Internet is open to literally tens of millions of speakers across the United States, and hundreds of millions of speakers around the world. To reach a vast national or global audience, one needs to spend little or no money. One can speak to millions without placing any advertisements, but even ads on the Internet can sometimes be priced at pennies per individual ad. And not only does the Internet offer the potential to speak, but millions are in fact speaking out on the Internet recent reports about the new phenomenon of blogging indicate that between 2 and 8 million Americans publish their own blog. And tens of millions of American voters are listening to political speech over the Internet Pew reports that 75 million Americans used the Internet to receive election information or discuss politics. Moreover, those receiving political information over the Internet can finely choose what blog to read or web sites to visit.
3 Even more important than the aggregate differences between the Internet and older forms of mass communications is the dramatic difference in the characteristics of the average political speaker in the different media. In the 2004 election cycle, thousands (but probably not tens of thousands) of people purchased political advertisement time on radio and television networks around the country in conjunction with a federal election race, but it is likely that the vast majority of those individuals were working for or with an organized political campaign or party. And critically, it is likely that the vast majority of those organized campaigns or parties had retained or had the resources to retain one or more attorneys to advise them about compliance with the campaign finance laws. In the 2004 election cycle, in contrast, millions (and possibly tens of millions) of individual Americans expressed their political views online, and at most a tiny fraction of those individuals were working for an organized political campaign or party. And it is certain that the vast majority of those millions of speakers had not retained attorneys to advise them on campaign finance law issues. But without attorneys (indeed, without attorneys steeped in campaign finance law) the task of determining what one s obligations are under the laws and regulations is daunting, to say the least. An uninitiated speaker wanting to comply with federal law is confronted with: 234 pages of statutes from the U.S. Code; 516 pages of FEC regulations from the Code of Federal Regulations; 702 pages of explanations and justifications of the FEC regulations; more than 1300 FEC Advisory Opinions supplementing the regulations; more than 350 federal court decisions concerning the FEC s regulations; Even if an online speaker knew precisely which regulations to review (and assuming for the sake of argument that the rules proposed in the current NPRM are adopted without change), someone planning to actively use the Internet to express his or her political views would have to consult, at a bare minimum, the following provisions from Chapter 11 of the Code of Federal Regulations ( CFR ): 11 CFR to determine if their speech would be treated as a public communication ; 11 CFR to determine if their speech qualifies as express advocacy ; 11 CFR and to determine if they qualify under the news media exemption; 11 CFR to determine if their Internet activities count as contributions subject to limits;
4 11 CFR to determine if their Internet activities count as expenditures for reporting purposes; 11 CFR to determine if their use of an employer s computer to access the Internet is permissible; 11 CFR and to determine if their bulk requires a specific type of disclaimer; and 11 CFR to determine whether their plan to collaborate with their neighbor to speak on the Internet means that they qualify as a political committee subject to registration and reporting requirements. In the face of such an array of laws and regulations, it is certain that at least some individual speakers on the Internet will choose to forgo online political speech. That many Internet speakers may in fact be oblivious to the existence of the laws and regulations (and thus may never think to consult them) does not avoid the fact that some speakers will attempt to determine their correct classification under the regulations, and decide to forgo their speech instead. The highly complex and voluminous rules will have an unavoidable chilling effect on constitutionally protected indeed, constitutionally valued political speech. The fact that the FEC has laudably sought to narrow the reach of its regulation of Internet speech also does not alter the chilling effect of the rules. Unless either Congress or the FEC breaks the mold of pre-existing campaign finance regulations and drafts a single, short and easy-to-understand exemption of individuals online speech, the complexity of the rules as a whole will chill individuals speech speech that the campaign finance laws and rules should be promoting. Congress or the FEC must draft a rule accessible to and understandable by the average Internet speaker. II. Applying Campaign Finance Law to Individuals Online Political Speech: A Series of Glitches and Anomalies Because the campaign finance laws were designed in a different era for a different type of mass communications medium, the laws map very poorly onto the Internet, and the effort leads to a broad range of problems in applying the laws. And, because of the enormous diversity of types of Internet speech, and the rapid creation and evolution of wholly new forms of online communications (such as the blog), the glitches and snags in applying campaign finance laws to the Internet are very likely to continue. The following are some of the particular problems and concerns raised by the application of the campaign finance laws to the individuals online communications. The scenarios some hypothetical and some actual all suggest that valuable speech may be chilled and diminished. None of the problems, taken alone, will likely stop enormous quantities of online speech, but taken together the burdens on speech will cause significant harm. Some of the problems below could be solved by tweaking a regulation or creating an additional narrow exception to a rule, but such tweaking and exceptions
5 will exacerbate the overarching problem of complexity of the rules and are unlikely to anticipate innovations in technology. The follow scenarios, for example, demonstrate some of the concerns that arise:: A. Twenty-Five Dollar Advertisements Expressly Advocating for a Candidate. The centerpiece of the FEC s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking is the narrow extension of the definition of public communication to include paid Internet advertisements. Superficially this seems reasonable, based on the assumption from the offline world that advertisements probably cost significant money. But in the Internet context, banner advertisements often cost in the neighborhood of $25 per 1000 displays of an ad (or less than 3 cents per ad display). While most web sites require that ad purchases be for substantially more than 1000 displays, it is likely that activists in future campaigns will purchase $5000 worth of ad displays and then resell the displays in $25 increments to individuals who want to display an online bumper sticker in support of a candidate (declaring, for example, that Bob Smith of Rockville Supports Jones for President ), with the banner ad placed on community-focused web sites. Imposing burdensome campaign finance obligations on all Internet political ads no matter how trivial the cost would certainly discourage this and other types of innovative individual political speech. Simply stated, this type of paid speech by individuals is not the type of speech at which the campaign finance laws are aimed. B. Voters Posting Online Bumper Stickers Required to Also Post a Home Address. In the Bob Smith of Rockville Supports Jones for President example above, Mr. Smith would be required to display on the banner ad a home street address a privacy invasion that may well discourage the speech entirely. Moreover, it is unlikely that a disclaimer could even fit within the confines of a banner advertisement (and some individual speakers may not operate a web site that could contain the information). C. Production of an Online Video. If an individual, without coordination with any campaign, decides to create and post a short video attacking an incumbent President running for re-election, and he or she spends $251 on the production of the video (aside from the Internet hosting costs), the individual would have to commence filing reports with the FEC (thereby likely discouraging the creation of the individual advocacy in the first place). D. Events Outside of the Control of the Individual Speaker Could Push Expenses over the $250 Threshold for Reporting Expenditures. Although the FEC has excluded many Internet costs from the calculation of expenditures by individuals, there are many Internet-related costs that are not mentioned and remain in a gray area, and some of those costs are unpredictable. If an individual makes a short video as described above, it is unclear whether cost charged by an Internet content streaming company would be exempt or not. If the individual makes the video for $100 and plans to spend $100 to stream the video (thereby avoiding the $250 reporting requirement), the $100 streaming costs could unexpectedly jump over $150 because someone publicizes
6 the link to the video without the individual s knowledge. The individual could find him or herself in violation of the law a filing deadline had passed. E. Two (or a Few) Individuals Collaborating on Internet Speech May Unwillingly or Unknowingly Become a Political Committee. If four friends get together to create and post on the Internet a video attacking an incumbent running for reelection and the video costs $1001, the friends may be considered a political committee subject to a host of burdensome rules. Such a result would very likely discourage the speech in the first place. F. An Active Political Blogger Who Incorporates For Liability Purposes Would Thereafter be Excluded from Continuing to Express Support for a Candidate. An active blogger may well want to incorporate for liability purposes, but if the blogger fails to give reasonably equal coverage to all opposing candidates the blog might not qualify for the news media exemption. Thus, that individual (incorporated as a single employee company) would be prohibited from a wide range of political speech. G. An Active Blogger Whose Blog is Affirmatively Supported by His or Her Employer. The Internet creates a much broader set of situations in which an employer might want an employee to blog, even though the employee is solely expressing the employee s opinions. For example, Lawrence Lessig is a noted law professor at a private (and incorporated) university, and he runs a very popular blog. Lessig s active online dialogue on a wide range of issues including presidential politics is certainly an informal part of Lessig s academic work, and thus it is unclear whether his blogging would be considered incidental to the corporation. The prohibition on corporate blogging could well chill academic discourse at private universities. These are examples of problems that arise with the application of the campaign finance laws to individuals speech on the Internet. Some, but not all, of these problems might be addressed by a single, short and easy-to-understand exemption of individuals online speech, as proposed above. Alternatively, some could be addressed by more regulatory exceptions and fine tuning of the rules an approach that will exacerbate the already high level of complexity. * * * * * Beyond the broad concern that the rules are simply too complex for practical application to ordinary speakers (and the complexity will chill them from speaking), and the specific problems raised above there is also the very real possibility that the FEC complaint and enforcement process will itself become a tool for political mischief. Simply by filing a complaint with the FEC, a political opponent can haul an individual speaker into a civil proceeding in Washington, D.C., one in which the speaker would be well advised to take seriously and hire an attorney. In a world where only a few thousand speakers actually used the mass media, and most had access to attorneys, the complaint process may not have been an effective means of harassing an opponent. But where the rules apply to millions of speakers who are engaged in the robust debate that the Internet
7 allows and there are numerous complex rules to determine whether some Internet speech is covered or not it is highly likely that the complaint process will be abused. Finally, and critically, it is unclear whether the Federal Election Commission has the authority to solve all of the broad and specific problems and concerns. Thus, it is likely that no matter what, Congress will need to step in to protect and promote individuals political speech online. The author appreciates the comments and input of Carol Darr and Leslie Harris on earlier drafts of this document.
June 3, Dear Mr. Deutsch:
Mr. Brad C. Deutsch Assistant General Counsel Federal Election Commission 999 E Street, NW Washington, DC 20463 By E-mail to: internet@fec.gov Re: Comments of the Center for Democracy & Technology on Notice
More informationPolitical Speech on Public Issues
Political Speech on Public Issues Even non media corporations have free speech rights under the First Amendment. The rights of corporations in terms of political speech include: The right to circulate
More informationBefore the Federal Election Commission Washington, D.C. COMMENTS OF THE COMPUTER & COMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION (CCIA) 1
Before the Federal Election Commission Washington, D.C. In the matter of Internet Communication Disclaimers and Definition of Public Communication Notice 2018 06 COMMENTS OF THE COMPUTER & COMMUNICATIONS
More informationWe encourage you to Maximize the PowerPoint to Full Screen Usage:
1 For audio participation, dial 866.802.4364 and ask for Foley s Citizens United Web Conference. Attorney Advertising Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome Models used are not 2 Housekeeping
More informationFLORIDA DEPARTMENT 01STATE
CHARLIE CRIST Governor FLORIDA DEPARTMENT 01STATE o b DAWN K. ROBERTS Interim Secretary of State Honorable R. B. Johnson, Chairman Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority 3201 Scherer Drive St. Petersburg,
More informationCharting the Course for Business Political Involvement Since 1963
Charting the Course for Business Political Involvement Since 1963 2011-2012 MARKET RESEARCH REPORT FOR BIPAC INTRODUCTION 2011-2012 BIPAC Market Research Report Moore Information, Inc. of Portland, Oregon,
More informationThe School Board s Role in Ballot Issues October 1, 2016
The School Board s Role in Ballot Issues October 1, 2016 When citizens are elected to the school board, they individually retain their First Amendment rights to freedom of speech and association. Collectively,
More informationBill 201: Election Finances Statute Law Amendment Act
Bill 201: Election Finances Statute Law Amendment Act Standing Committee on General Government Fred Hahn 7/26/2016 Introduction The Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE) Ontario is the largest union
More informationSAN JACINTO COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT (SJCD) ACTIVITIES RELATED TO ELECTIONS
SAN JACINTO COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT (SJCD) ACTIVITIES RELATED TO ELECTIONS Permissible Communications by employees while off duty and off SJCD property advocating the passage or defeat of the bond or
More informationGuide for Candidates
Wisconsin Association of School Boards Table of Contents Guide for Candidates 2015 Spring Election Edition i Supporting, Promoting and Advancing Public Education Back to Table of Contents A Message from
More informationPart 2 Transparency, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill
Part 2 Transparency, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Bill Second Reading Tuesday 3 rd September 2013 Key points: Citizens Advice has received legal advice (enclosed) that Part 2 of
More informationPolitical 101: A Broadcasters Guide to the Basics 2004 Edition
SCIARRINO & ASSOCIATES, PLLC BROADCAST LEGAL SERVICES Political 101: A Broadcasters Guide to the Basics 2004 Edition The rules governing political advertising on broadcast stations are found in statute,
More informationGuide for Candidates
Wisconsin Association of School Boards Back to Table of Contents Guide for Candidates 2016 Spring Election Edition Supporting, Promoting and Advancing Public Education i Back to Table of Contents A Message
More informationChapter 1. Reflection and Restraint in State Constitutional Amendment and Revision State University of New York Press, Albany
Chapter 1 Reflection and Restraint in State Constitutional Amendment and Revision This volume is a practical handbook for all those involved with state constitutional amendment or revision, including citizens,
More informationMarch 10, RE: Docket No. OSHA Improve Tracking of Workplace Injuries and Illnesses
March 10, 2014 OSHA Docket Office Docket No. OSHA 2013 0023 U.S. Department of Labor Room N 2625 200 Constitution Avenue NW Washington, DC 20210 RE: Docket No. OSHA 2013 0023 Improve Tracking of Workplace
More informationJANUARY 2009 (PREPARATION AND RECRUITMENT)
Students Love Campus Community Television: NUTV YES Campaign Deanna Cameron Dubuque Royal Roads University, New University Television Society (NUTV) Calgary, Alberta PROJECT SUMMARY / Incorporated in 1991,
More informationEthical Principles for City Attorneys 1 Adopted October 6, 2005 City Attorneys Department Business Session
Ethical Principles for City Attorneys 1 City Attorneys Department Business Session Preamble A city attorney occupies an important position of trust and responsibility within city government. Central to
More informationOFCCP s Veterans and Individuals with Disabilities Final Regulations Impose New Obligations on Federal Contractors and Subcontractors
A Timely Analysis of Legal Developments A S A P September 9, 2013 OFCCP s Veterans and Individuals with Disabilities Final Regulations Impose New Obligations on Federal Contractors and Subcontractors By
More informationThe Committee of Seventy s 2015 INTEGRITY AGENDA PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL
The Committee of Seventy s 2015 INTEGRITY AGENDA PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL The Committee of Seventy is asking you and the other declared candidates for Philadelphia City Council to commit to the attached
More informationCampaign Skills Trainer s Guide. Module 6 Message Development Creating Powerful and Persuasive Messages
Campaign Skills Trainer s Guide Module 6 Message Development Creating Powerful and Persuasive Messages CAMPAIGN SKILLS TRAINER S GUIDE MODULE 6: MESSAGE DEVELOPMENT Creating Powerful and Persuasive Messages
More informationThe Committee of Seventy s 2015 INTEGRITY AGENDA PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL
The Committee of Seventy s 2015 INTEGRITY AGENDA PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCIL The Committee of Seventy is asking you and the other declared candidates for Philadelphia City Council to commit to the attached
More informationA Comparison of the Recent FTC and Commerce Department Data Privacy Frameworks
A Comparison of the Recent FTC and Commerce Department Data Privacy Frameworks By Lydia Parnes & Edward Holman As the IAPP enters its second decade, the privacy landscape in the U.S. is undergoing a major
More informationHow to Make an Online Voter Guide Quick Tips for the Voter Educator. Abstract
How to Make an Online Voter Guide Quick Tips for the Voter Educator Available online: http://www.calvoter.org/manual/quicktips.html Provided by the California Voter Foundation, publisher of the California
More informationIssue Review. Do Voters Understand Super PACs? March Jason M. Farrell Center for Competitive Politics
Issue Review March 2012 Do Voters Understand Super PACs? Jason M. Farrell Center for Competitive Politics Center for Competitive Politics 124 S. West Street, Suite 201 Alexandria, Virginia 22314 http://www.campaignfreedom.org
More informationReading Essentials and Study Guide
Lesson 4 Differing Views About Federalism ESSENTIAL QUESTION How does federalism promote democracy and civic participation? Reading HELPDESK Academic Vocabulary policy a plan that includes general goals
More informationGuide to Ethical Use of Social Media for Texas Lawyers. Zach Wolfe.
I. Introduction www.fiveminutelaw.com First, the bad news. The Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct that apply to use of social media are poorly written, ambiguous, byzantine, and potentially
More informationM E M O R A N D U M. Frequently Asked Questions Regarding Employee/Officer Conduct and Comments Leading Up To a Bond Election
LAW OFFICES M c CALL, PARKHURST & HORTON L.L.P. 717 NORTH HARWOOD SUITE 900 DALLAS, TEXAS 75201-6587 TELEPHONE: 214 754-9200 FACSIMILE: 214 754-9250 600 CONGRESS AVENUE SUITE 1800 AUSTIN, TEXAS 78701-3248
More informationBobby Baker Federal Communications Commission
Political Broadcasting Looking to 2016 State Broadcast Association Webinar December 17, 2015 Bobby Baker Federal Communications Commission David Oxenford Wilkinson Barker Knauer LLP Political Broadcasting
More informationSection 2. The People of the City of Berkeley hereby amend the following sections of the Charter of the City of Berkeley as follows:
AMENDMENTS TO CITY OF BERKELEY CHARTER ARTICLE III (ELECTIONS) AND MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER 2.12 (ELECTION REFORM ACT) TO CREATE A FAIR ELECTIONS PUBLIC CAMPAIGN FINANCING SYSTEM Section 1. FINDINGS The
More informationApprenticeship Programs: Changes. to Equal Employment Opportunity. Regulations. Joint Apprenticeship Training Programs
Insights on recent legal developments and trends affecting Joint Apprenticeship Training Programs Volume 2016-1, January In This Issue New Proposed Regulations for New Proposed Regulations for Apprenticeship
More informationPolitical Broadcasting
Political Broadcasting - 2011 State Broadcast Association Webcast October 12, 2011 Bobby Baker Federal Communications Commission David Oxenford Davis Wright Tremaine LLP Political Broadcasting Issues Reasonable
More informationApril 12, Expending $49,700 Of Public Funds On Issue 3
April 12, 2017 Mark V. Guidetti City Law Director 9691 Valley View Road Macedonia, Ohio 44056 Expending $49,700 Of Public Funds On Issue 3 Dear Mr. Guidetti: For the following reasons I respectfully ask
More informationGuidance on who needs to notify
Guidance on who needs to notify Application and Scope of the Regulations for Video On Demand (VOD) services Edition 3.1 Originally published 19 October 2010 Re-published 21 March 2011 ATVOD Guidance on
More informationFrequently Asked Questions. This list of FAQs will be updated from time to time with newer FAQs appearing at the bottom.
Frequently Asked Questions The text of the Cook County Earned Sick Leave Ordinance ( Ordinance ) and the Interpretative and Procedural Rules ( ESL Regulations ) adopted by the Cook County Commission on
More informationPolitical Broadcasting
Political Broadcasting - 2010 Texas Association of Broadcasters December 2, 2009 David Oxenford Davis Wright Tremaine LLP Bobby Baker Federal Communications Commission Political Broadcasting Issues Reasonable
More informationPUERTO RICO. Silvia G. Rico Medina, Esq. Cabrera & Rico
PUERTO RICO Silvia G. Rico Medina, Esq. Cabrera & Rico sgr@cabrera-rico.com www.cabrera-rico.com 1. Case Law El Nuevo Día, Inc. vs. Department of Consumer Affairs, et al, Civil No. 00-2631 (JAG) First
More informationJuly 6, RE: File Number S Dear Ms. Murphy:
Christina Crooks Director, Tax Policy July 6, 2015 Securities and Exchange Commission 100 F Street, N.E. Washington, DC 20549-0609 VIA Internet Comment Form (http://www.sec.gov/rules/proposed.shtml) Attention:
More informationPolitical Broadcasting Questions and Answers
COMMUNICATIONS / BROADCAST Special Advisory to Broadcasters March 2004 Political Broadcasting Questions and Answers Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act Q. Does the Campaign Finance Reform decision announced
More informationCLOSING THE DIGITAL LOOPHOLES THAT PAVE THE WAY FOR FOREIGN INTERFERENCE IN U.S. ELECTIONS
April 2018 CLOSING THE DIGITAL LOOPHOLES THAT PAVE THE WAY FOR FOREIGN INTERFERENCE IN U.S. ELECTIONS New Research Study Supports the Honest Ads Act In the 2016 election cycle, 14 percent a total of $1.4
More informationRe: Comments of the Association of National Advertisers on the New gtld Program and Process
Submitted Electronically to gtld-guide@icann.org December 15, 2008 Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers 4676 Admiralty Way, Suite 330 Marina del Rey, CA 90292-6601 Attn: Paul Twomey, President
More informationCLOSING THE DIGITAL LOOPHOLES THAT PAVE THE WAY FOR FOREIGN INTERFERENCE IN U.S. ELECTIONS
April 2018 CLOSING THE DIGITAL LOOPHOLES THAT PAVE THE WAY FOR FOREIGN INTERFERENCE IN U.S. ELECTIONS New Research Study Supports the Honest Ads Act In the 2016 election cycle, 14 percent a total of $1.4
More informationUK Parliamentary general election 2017: Non-party campaigners
Overview UK Parliamentary general election 2017: Non-party campaigners This document is for non-party campaigners who want to know the details of the regulated period, spending limits and reporting requirements
More informationGuide for Candidates
Wisconsin Association of School Boards Guide for Candidates 2018 Spring Election Edition Supporting, Promoting and Advancing Public Education 2017 Published by: WISCONSIN ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL BOARDS,
More informationGuide for Candidates
Wisconsin Association of School Boards Table of Contents Guide for Candidates 2013 Spring Election Edition Fostering i Effective School Board Practices for Student Success Back to Table of Contents A Message
More informationTowards a more Deliberative Direct Democracy: Examination and Evaluation of Taiwan s Case
Towards a more Deliberative Direct Democracy: Examination and Evaluation of Taiwan s Case Jau-Yuan Hwang (Working paper in progress, to be completed) 1. Introduction Direct democracy (DD), being referendum
More informationNEIGHBOURHOOD PHARMACY ASSOCIATION OF CANADA SUBMISSION IN RESPONSE TO HEALTH SECTOR PAYMENT TRANSPARENCY ACT DRAFT REGULATIONS
NEIGHBOURHOOD PHARMACY ASSOCIATION OF CANADA SUBMISSION IN RESPONSE TO HEALTH SECTOR PAYMENT TRANSPARENCY ACT DRAFT REGULATIONS The Neighbourhood Pharmacy Association of Canada (Neighbourhood Pharmacies)
More informationLOCAL GOVERNMENT STANDARDS. Jenni Richards QC. Annabel Lee. b. Identifying the key changes from the previous regime; and
LOCAL GOVERNMENT STANDARDS Jenni Richards QC Annabel Lee Introduction 1. This talk is divided into three main sections: a. An outline of the new standards regime; b. Identifying the key changes from the
More informationCOMMENTS OF THE ELECTRONIC PRIVACY INFORMATION CENTER to the FEDERAL ELECTION COMMISSION
COMMENTS OF THE ELECTRONIC PRIVACY INFORMATION CENTER to the FEDERAL ELECTION COMMISSION Internet Communication Disclaimers and Definition of Public Communication [Notice 2018-06] The Electronic Privacy
More informationHOW TO JUDGE A CANDIDATE
HOW TO JUDGE A CANDIDATE Elections present voters with important choices. Whether it is a local race that will affect your community or a national race that could change the direction of the country, it
More informationCOMMENTS SUBMITTED FOR THE FTC GREEN GUIDES REGULATORY REVIEW, 16 CFR PART 260, PROJECT NO. P954501
COMMENTS SUBMITTED FOR THE FTC GREEN GUIDES REGULATORY REVIEW, 16 CFR PART 260, PROJECT NO. P954501 Comment Number: Received: Organization: American Association of Advertising Agencies, American Advertising
More informationEnforcing the Regulatory Reform Agenda Evaluation of Existing EPA Regulations; Docket ID No. EPA-HQ
May 15, 2017 Ms. Samantha K. Dravis Regulatory Reform Officer and Associate Administrator, Office of Policy U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Washington, DC 20460 Via
More informationCONSTITUTION OF THE REPUBLIC OF FIJI
CONSTITUTION OF THE REPUBLIC OF FIJI CHAPTER 3 PARLIAMENT Part A LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY Legislative authority and power of Parliament 46. (1) The authority and power to make laws for the State is vested
More informationPETITION FOR RULEMAKING. Pursuant to the Section 317 of the Communications Act of 1934 and Section 1.401(a) of the
Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION W ASHINGTON, DC 20554 In the Matter of ) ) No. Amendment of 47 CFR 73.1212 ) PETITION FOR RULEMAKING Pursuant to the Section 317 of the Communications Act of
More informationSubmission to. The Ministry of Community, Sport and Cultural Development. of British Columbia. On the White Paper on
Submission to The Ministry of Community, Sport and Cultural Development of British Columbia On the White Paper on Local Government Elections Reform Issued by: Canadian Bar Association British Columbia
More informationSix strategies for limiting your exposure to class action lawsuits
FLSA Class Actions Six strategies for limiting your exposure to class action lawsuits 5 Lawrence Peikes and Gregory A. Brown Largely because of its class action feature, the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
More informationNetwork Branded Prepaid Card Association
May 30, 2014 The Honorable Richard Cordray Director Consumer Financial Protection Bureau 1700 G Street, NW Washington, DC 20220 The Honorable Thomas E. Perez Secretary U.S. Department of Labor 200 Constitution
More informationBefore the Federal Election Commission Washington, D.C. COMMENTS OF THE COMPUTER & COMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION (CCIA)
Before the Federal Election Commission Washington, D.C. In the matter of Internet Communication Disclaimers; Reopening of Comment Period Notice 2017 12 COMMENTS OF THE COMPUTER & COMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY
More informationVoter Registration Guide
Voter Registration Guide Ventura County Elections Division MARK A. LUNN Clerk Recorder/Registrar of Voters 800 South Victoria Avenue Ventura, CA 93009-200 (805) 654-2664 venturavote.org Revised 6/20/7
More informationDisclosure of Material Connections in Blogs and Other Forms of Consumer-Generated Media
FTC Publishes Final Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials Prepared for the Council of Public Relations Firms by Davis & Gilbert LLP The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) announced that
More informationSeven Commonly Asked Questions About Employment and the ADA
Originally printed in... Seven Commonly Asked Questions About Employment and the ADA Timothy L. Jones Many employers have given serious thought to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and focused
More informationAmerican Payroll Association
American Payroll Association Government Relations Washington, DC March 16, 2015 STATEMENT IN OPPOSITION TO SUBSTITUTE HOUSE BILL 1211, unless amended The American Payroll Association 1 (APA) appreciates
More informationAdvertising. The Media and Advertising
Advertising Whenever people give information to the public about an event, a product, or a service, they are using advertising. A piece of advertising is called an advertisement, or ad. The goal of most
More informationGeneral Municipal Law Frequently Asked Questions
General Municipal Law Frequently Asked Questions This FAQ has been prepared to give New York charter schools an overview of General Municipal Law 800-806, which became applicable to charter schools when
More informationCampaign Skills Handbook. Module 6 Message Development Creating Powerful and Persuasive Messages
Campaign Skills Handbook Module 6 Message Development Creating Powerful and Persuasive Messages Introduction As a candidate or political party competing in an election one of your challenges will be communicating
More informationDepartment of the Interior Departmental Manual
Page 1 of 10 Department of the Interior Departmental Manual Effective Date: 03/07/2012 Series: Information Part 470: Public Communications Chapter 1: General Policy and Procedures Originating Office: Office
More informationKey findings from a statewide survey of 500 registered voters in Arizona January 13-14, Partner Vice President
09013 Key findings from a statewide survey of 500 registered voters in Arizona January 13-14, 2009. Partner lori@pos.org Vice President jim@pos.org Public Opinion Strategies is pleased to present the key
More informationPOLITICAL ADVERTISING
POLITICAL ADVERTISING What You Need To Know Revised January 12.-2015 The Texas Election Law requires certain disclosures and notices on political advertising. The lawalso prohibits certain types of misrepresentation
More informationLocal Government and Communities Committee. Planning (Scotland) Bill. Submission from Shepherd and Wedderburn LLP
Local Government and Communities Committee Planning (Scotland) Bill Submission from Shepherd and Wedderburn LLP 1. Do you think the Bill, taken as a whole, will produce a planning system for Scotland that
More informationCity of San Juan Capistrano Agenda Report. Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
101312017 City of San Juan Capistrano Agenda Report F3a TO: FROM: SUBMITTED BY: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council ~n Siegel, City Manager Jeff Ballinger, City Attorney tv\~ ~ r :re, DATE:
More informationGUIDE FOR CANDIDATES Spring Election Edition Updated November Supporting, Promoting and Advancing Public Education
GUIDE FOR CANDIDATES 2019 Spring Election Edition Updated November 2018 Supporting, Promoting and Advancing Public Education 2018 Published by: WISCONSIN ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL BOARDS, INC. 122 W. Washington
More informationMEMORANDUM \ ~- --' SUMMARY
DENNIS "J. HERRERA City Attorney MEMORANDUM FROM: ALL CITY DEPARTMENT HEAPS~ DENNIS J. HERRERA, City Att~rne ' \ ~- --' As we typically do every year in advance of the November election, the City Attorney's
More informationFor example you might say the following, either as an individual, or on behalf of an organization that you can speak for:
Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act Alliance Update United for a Barrier-Free Ontario for All People with Disabilities www.aodaalliance.org aodafeedback@gmail.com Twitter: @aodaalliance Please
More informationBefore the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C ) ) ) ) COMMENTS OF THE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INDUSTRY COUNCIL
Before the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C. 20554 In the Matter of Restoring Internet Freedom ) ) ) ) WC Docket No. 17-108 COMMENTS OF THE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY INDUSTRY COUNCIL Introduction
More informationDealing With Union Organizing
Dealing With Union Organizing Introduction ABC believes merit shop contractors and their employees have the right to choose to remain union free, in accordance with the law. A dramatic increase in union
More informationResolution for Super Delegates to Support Candidate Who Wins Caucus Passed 5/1/16 at Kitsap County Democratic Convention
Resolution for Super Delegates to Support Candidate Who Wins Caucus WHEREAS the Kitsap County Democratic Party draft 2016 platform cites values of a robust democracy governed by and for the people; and
More informationEQUAL EMPLOYMENT ADVISORY COUNCIL
EQUAL EMPLOYMENT ADVISORY COUNCIL SUITE 400 1501 M STREET, NW WASHINGTON, DC 20005 TEL 202/629-5650 FAX 202/629-5651 Via Electronic Mail to: Torrans.William@dol.gov Mr. William Torrans Office of National
More informationCHAPTER. Being a Responsible Citizen
CHAPTER 31 Being a Responsible Citizen Chapter Objectives After studying this chapter, you will be able to recognize the importance of voting in elections. explain how laws are made. name the two categories
More informationCorrelation of. EMC Publishing s. American Government, Citizenship and Power. to Indiana s United States Government Academic Standards
Correlation of EMC Publishing s American Government, Citizenship and Power to Indiana s United States Government Academic Standards Standard 1 The Nature of Politics and Government Students will identify,
More informationIdentify the positive and negative effects American federalism has on democracy. INTRODUCTION
Identify the positive and negative effects American federalism has on democracy. C HAPTER OVERVIEW INTRODUCTION The relationships among the federal, state, and local governments often confuse people, yet
More information5 Municipal Form of Government: Trends in Structure, Responsibility, and Composition
A 5 Municipal Form of Government: Trends in Structure, Responsibility, and Composition Selected Findings The current survey results show a slight increase since 2001 in the percentage reporting the council-manager
More informationNew Parental Leave Act Maternity Leave Extended to Male Employees. Prepared for the 2015 Massachusetts Municipal Association Annual Meeting
Community New Parental Leave Act Maternity Leave Extended to Male Employees Prepared for the 2015 Massachusetts Municipal Association Annual Meeting On January 7, 2015, Governor Patrick signed into law
More informationGuide for Referendum Advertising Sponsors for the Referendum 849 (18/06)
Guide for Referendum Advertising Sponsors for the 2018 Referendum on Electoral Reform 849 (18/06) Table of Contents Introduction... 1 Privacy... 1 Referendum advertising... 2 What is referendum advertising?...
More informationFreedom of Information Policy
Freedom of Information Policy Introduction The Freedom of Information (FOI) Act 2000 gives the public a general right to access recorded information held by public authorities including Further Education
More informationMINIMUM WAGE AND EARNED PAID SICK TIME FAQS: UPDATED CONTENT (REV. MAY 23, 2017)
INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION OF ARIZONA 800 W WASHINGTON STREET PHOENIX, ARIZONA 85007 (602) 542-4661 DISCLAIMER: This is an unofficial publication of the Industrial Commission of Arizona. All information provided
More information/ 73 SPEECH BY DCI OPEN SOURCE COORDINATOR OPEN SOURCE SOLUTIONS SYMPOSIUM WASHINGTON, D.C... 2 NOVEMBER 1993
SPEECH BY DCI OPEN SOURCE COORDINATOR OPEN SOURCE SOLUTIONS SYMPOSIUM WASHINGTON, D.C... 2 NOVEMBER 1993 I want to thank you for the opportunity to come to speak before you today. It's been now about a
More informationDrafting Election Statements and Reports. A Field Guide for Election Monitoring Groups
Drafting Election Statements and Reports A Field Guide for Election Monitoring Groups Drafting Election Statements and Reports This field guide is designed as an easy- reference tool for domestic non-
More informationWhat We Did. The survey was conducted May 2-3, We interviewed 800 adults, aged 18 years or older.
INTRODUCTION What We Did In the ever-shifting world of survey research, Public Opinion Strategies strives to be on the cutting edge. In conjunction with Surveys on the Go designed by MFour Mobile Research,
More informationDomestic Violence at Work: A Union Concern. CFNU Convention June 6-7, Workshop Presented by the Canadian Labour Congress
Domestic Violence at Work: A Union Concern CFNU Convention June 6-7, 2017 Workshop Presented by the Canadian Labour Congress Representing and Supporting Members Domestic violence seriously affects the
More informationMemorandum of understanding between the Competition and Markets Authority and the Office of Communications concurrent competition powers
8 February 2016 Memorandum of understanding between the Competition and Markets Authority and the Office of Communications concurrent competition powers Contents Page Foreword... 2 Memorandum of Understanding
More informationEmployee Records I A S B. Illinois Personnel Records Review Act. Understanding requirements of the
I A S B Employee Records Understanding requirements of the Illinois Personnel Records Review Act by Terrence M. Barnicle Attorney with Klein, Thorpe and Jenkins, Ltd. Chicago 2921 Baker Drive One Imperial
More informationAP&S Ethics Seminar Presentation May 10,2012. Truth in Ethics: Law v. Ethics. By John A. Tarantino and Katy A. Hynes
AP&S Ethics Seminar Presentation May 10,2012 Truth in Ethics: Law v. Ethics By John A. Tarantino and Katy A. Hynes There is, of course, a relation between law and ethics. In certain circumstances, law
More informationEXEMPT WELLS AND AGRICULTURE
JESSE J. RICHARDSON, JR. IRIS ALOI EXEMPT WELLS AND AGRICULTURE WEST VIRGINIA UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF LAW Introduction In western states, the principal of prior appropriation generally governs groundwater
More informationFORESTRY AND LAND MANAGEMENT (SCOTLAND) BILL
FORESTRY AND LAND MANAGEMENT (SCOTLAND) BILL EXPLANATORY NOTES INTRODUCTION 1. As required under Rule 9.3.2A of the Parliament s Standing Orders, these Explanatory Notes are published to accompany the
More informationStrasbourg, 2 February 1998 EUROPEAN COMMISSION FOR DEMOCRACY THROUGH LAW POWERS OF CONSTITUTIONAL COURTS OF FEDERATED ENTITIES IN GERMANY
Strasbourg, 2 February 1998 Restricted CDL-JU (97) 37 Engl. only EUROPEAN COMMISSION FOR DEMOCRACY THROUGH LAW POWERS OF CONSTITUTIONAL COURTS OF FEDERATED ENTITIES IN GERMANY
More informationBusiness Law Mid-Term (Chapters 1-4)
Class: Date: Business Law Mid-Term (Chapters 1-4) Multiple Choice Identify the letter of the choice that best completes the statement or answers the question. 1. 1. Select the best definition of ethics:
More information5 Key Ingredients: Build Your Successful Online Business 12/6/17
5 Key Ingredients: Build Your Successful Online Business 12/6/17 By working faithfully eight hours a day, you may eventually get to be a boss and work twelve hours a day. Robert Frost 1. The 5 fundamentals
More informationUNIVERSITY OF KWAZULU-NATAL, PIETERMARITZBURG EXAMINATIONS: NOVEMBER 2011 (LAWS2CS) DURATION: 3 HOURS TOTAL MARKS: 70
DURATION: 3 HOURS TOTAL MARKS: 70 External Examiner: Internal Examiners: Professor M Beukes Ms A Strode Professor W Freedman STUDENTS ARE REQUESTED, IN THEIR OWN INTERESTS, TO WRITE LEGIBLY. PLEASE NOTE:
More informationTelecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention) Bill 2014 SUPPLEMENTARY SUBMISSION
http://www.privacy.org.au Secretary@privacy.org.au http://www.privacy.org.au/about/contacts.html 31 January 2015 Committee Secretary Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security PO Box 6021
More informationBusiness Guidance Concerning Multi-Level Marketing
Business Guidance Concerning Multi-Level Marketing Do you have questions about multi-level marketing? The FTC staff has guidance to help members of the MLM industry apply core consumer protection principles
More informationGetting Organized and Staying in Compliance. January 2019
Getting Organized and Staying in Compliance January 2019 «ARKANSAS MUNICIPAL LEAGUE«GREAT CITIES MAKE A GREAT STATE Table of Contents Introduction... 2 Getting Organized... 3 Overview of elected official
More information