Enhancing the Haliotis iris fishery a preliminary bioeconomic evaluation
|
|
- Kelly Patterson
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Enhancing the Haliotis iris fishery a preliminary bioeconomic evaluation Dr Anthony Hart, Principal Research Scientist, Western Australian Fisheries and Marine Research Laboratories
2 Table of Contents Executive Summary Introduction An Integrated Enhancement Fishery Bioeconomic model Conditioning the Enhancefish bioeconomic model to Haliotis iris populations Reseeding scenarios (PAU 7 - whole fishery) Reseeding scenarios (PAU 7 statistical areas P721, P722, P727, P734) Effects of enhancement on wild stock genotype Sensitivity analysis Reseeding scenario results (PAU 7 whole fishery) Reseeding scenario 1 (30% of natural recruitment and LML = 118mm) Discussion - Reseeding scenario Reseeding scenario 2 (80% of natural recruitment and LML = 118mm) Discussion - Reseeding scenario Reseeding scenario 3 (150% of natural recruitment and and LML = 110 mm) Discussion - Reseeding scenario Reseeding scenario results (areas P721, P722, P727, P734) Discussion - Reseeding scenario in proposed experimental areas Sensitivity analysis General Discussion Practical implementation References Tables Figures P a g e
3 Executive Summary This report presents a preliminary bioeconomic evaluation of an integrated enhancement fishery for Haliotis iris. The approach taken was to firstly ascertain the population biology and fishing strategy of the fishery, to ensure that the proposed reseeding scenarios were commensurate with the carrying capacity of the fishery, as indexed by annual recruitment and stock biomass. Secondly, costs of fishing and management were considered in addition to the costs of culturing and releasing juvenile paua. Finally, the potential genetic effects of reseeding were also examined. Analyses were undertaken on both the whole PAU 7 fishery, and statistical areas within PAU 7 (P721, P722, P727, P734). Three main reseeding scenarios (30%, 80% and 150% of natural recruitment) were investigated under three different survival trajectories (14%, 11%, and 7%) to the legal minimum length of 12.5 cm. Survival trajectories were based on experimentally determined mortality rates of 11 mm (1.1 cm) juvenile paua. In all scenarios, the target was a 53% increase in stock biomass. Under scenario 2 for PAU 7 (80% of natural recruitment), the target equated to a biomass increase from 1500 t to 2300 t, and a yield (catch) increase from 225 t to 393 t. Sensitivity analyses of the interacting factors of target biomass, harvest rates, size-at-fishing, size-at-release, cost-of-reseeding, cost-of fishing, and value of harvest on economic viability were also undertaken. The analyses indicated that a reseeding programme for Haliotis iris has a high chance of being economically viable, if the appropriate size and density-at-release is chosen and the programme has explicit restocking and stock enhancement targets. All scenarios examined were profitable, with the exception of those where size at release was 18+ mm. Neither cost of reseeding nor cost of fishing had a significant effect on economic viability. Instead, commercial viability of reseeding was dependent primarily on harvest price, and secondarily on size-at-release. None of the scenarios investigated resulted in a serious risk to the genetically effective population size, although the biomass of the pure strain wild stock was substantially reduced in large reseeding scenarios. To implement a commercial scale reseeding programme, a range of key issues are identified for detailed investigation. First amongst these is that industry and government must accept that an enhancement fishery will, by necessity, operate in a different manner to a traditional fishery because it is about the total system, rather than the sum of the parts. This will require cultural change and adaptation from all stakeholders and recognition of its increased complexity. 2 P a g e
4 1 Introduction Reseeding, or the release of hatchery reared juveniles into the wild to increase recruitment to the fishery, has been as been a sought after industry development and management strategy in the New Zealand paua fisheries for over 20 years (Cooper, 2010; Roberts, 2005). Reseeding can used to achieve two broad management objectives. These are restocking and stock enhancement. Restocking aims to increase the biomass of depleted populations to levels that provide sustainable yields, in other words, to levels where natural recruitment alone can sustain the fishery. Stock enhancement aims to increase the yield in the fishery by adding extra recruits over and above what the stock naturally produces. Both strategies lead to increased biomass. However they differ in their duration. Restocking is a finite activity, it will cease when sufficient biomass has been attained to produce future generations of recruits. Stock enhancement can be considered an infinite strategy, a way to maintain and stabilise higher yields without compromising spawning biomass. In practice, the reseeding research options being considered by the Paua Industry Council are primarily about stock enhancement, although there will also be restocking that occurs in a few populations subject to extensive fishing, where harvest and quota has reduced over time. A summary of the main outcomes of previous experiments has concluded that, practiced properly, reseeding of paua is likely to be economically viable at a commercial scale (Cooper, 2010; Roberts, 2005). A similar conclusion was reached by Hart et al., (2013) for greenlip abalone in Western Australia. A key difference between these studies, apart from the species in question, is that Hart et al (2013) considered an integrated program, whereby fishing quota and size limits were linked to the level of reseeding being applied to the population. This approach has not been applied to paua fisheries; instead reseeding has been evaluated as a stand-alone activity, independent from the other management rules such as size-limits and quotas. The reality however is that they are linked because, once on the sea floor, reseeded paua become part of the wild population. Knowing there is additional investment on the bottom, regardless of what state the wild adult breeding biomass is considered to be in, provides management and industry with new options to maximise sustainable and economic yield. However, the additional investment is not without risk. The placing of hatchery bred-animals into a wild population brings into question the possibilities of disease introduction from a hatchery, and potential genetic changes to wild stock diversity, as the two types of stock start to breed. The scientific disciplines of restocking and stock enhancement and their application as fishery management tools have progressed significantly in the last two decades. There are now enhancement fisheries that have been certified as sustainably managed by the MSC (Marine Stewardship Council). An example of these relevant to paua fisheries is the Japanese scallop fishery in Northern Japan ( The objective of this report is to provide a preliminary bioeconomic evaluation of an integrated enhancement fishery for Haliotis iris. 1.1 An Integrated Enhancement Fishery In simple terms, an integrated enhancement fishery considers the total system. First, the population biology and fishing strategy of the fishery is ascertained, to ensure that the proposed levels of enhancement are commensurate with the carrying capacity of the fishery. This means utilising 3 P a g e
5 reliable estimates of wild stock spawning biomass, recruitment, growth, maturity, mortality and size of fishing where available. Secondly, the costs of fishing and management are considered in addition to the costs of culturing and releasing juvenile paua. Finally, the potential genetic effects of reseeding need to be examined as these cannot be assumed to be negligible in a commercial scale enhancement program. All of these can be considered in a bioeconomic model that integrates population dynamics with the economics of aquaculture and fishing. 2 Bioeconomic model In this study, bioeconomic evaluations were undertaken using the Enhancefish model developed by Lorenzen (2005) and Lorenzen and Medley (2006), with software and manuals sourced from enhancefish.html. Enhancefish uses a dynamic pool fisheries model to quantitatively assess impacts of stock enhancement on biological and economic parameters (Lorenzen and Medley, 2006). Outcomes can be evaluated against a range of fisheries management options, such as varying levels of fishing effort and size-at-harvest. The model extends traditional dynamic pool models to accommodate stock enhancement by incorporating numerous parameters including; density dependent effects in the pre-recruit stage, population regulation in the recruited phase via size-dependent mortality and density-dependent growth, and biological differences and interactions between hatchery and wild fish (Lorenzen, 2005). Full mathematical details on the model can be sourced from Lorenzen (2005), and see Hart et al., (2013) for an application to abalone fisheries in Australia. The choice of discount rate in NPV (Net Present Value) analysis can have a large impact on the outcomes of an economic assessment. When discounting flows of economic benefits from natural or environment resources, it has been argued that smaller discount rates will more accurately reflect the needs of both current and future generations (Sumaila and Walters, 2005). This contrasts with the high discount rates that are generally applied to a risky investment strategy (e.g. 10%), which reseeding of abalone is likely to qualify as, given the lack of success in commercial scale enhancement programmes. A 6% discount rate was chosen for NPV analysis in this assessment, as a compromise between the two opposing approaches. 2.1 Conditioning the Enhancefish bioeconomic model to Haliotis iris populations The Enhancefish model is a deterministic equilibrium model, meaning that it considers only the longrun average situation, and does not model year to year variability. Its outputs are the long-run expected figures after a number of years of implementation. It is useful for exploring potential future scenarios, but needs to be calibrated against existing stock assessment models to ensure enhancement options being considered are valid in the context of the fishery and biology. To ensure the Enhancefish model can accurately describe a paua population currently being fished, biological and harvest parameters were sourced from the PAU 7 stock assessment models of Breen and Kim (2005) and MacKenzie and Smith (2009a). The final Enhancefish parameters chosen to describe the biology, economics, and stock enhancement scenarios examined for the PAU 7 fishery are summarised in Table 1. In some cases the two models specified aspects of the biology differently, for example, growth in the PAU 7 model is controlled by two parameters (Ga average growth at length 75mm, and Gb 4 P a g e
6 average growth at length 120 mm (MacKenzie and Smith, 2009a), whereas the Enhancefish model specifies growth as a function of two different parameters (average maximum length [L ; cm] and a growth coefficient (K). Care was taken to ensure that the different models gave similar biological descriptions. Enhancefish uses a size-dependent mortality model to describe survivorship of annual recruits as they grow into the population and are subject to harvest. This model is critical to understanding the success of reseeding as the largest changes in mortality are experienced at the smaller sizes. It is however, a different model from that used in the PAU 7 stock assessment model, where natural mortality (M) is assumed to be constant for all size classes between 7 and 16 cm (McKenzie and Smith, 2009a). A recent review across multiple species of abalone has confirmed that mortality is significantly related to body mass (Rosetto et al., 2012) and therefore a size-dependent mortality model is an appropriate description for survivorship in Haliotis iris. Kim et. al. (2002) investigated a size-dependent mortality model for paua assessment and found that it performed similarly to the assumption of a constant M, but they only considered the larger sizes (7+ cm). A comparison of growth (a), mortality (b), current biomass (c), recruitment (d) harvest rate (e), and average catch (f) estimated by the PAU7 and Enhancefish models is provided in Figure 2. The Enhancefish model adequately estimated the main biological and fishing parameters for PAU 7 and therefore provides a useful description of the fishery (Figure 2). The Enhancefish estimate of current spawning biomass used as a base line around which to design a reseeding programme is 1500 tonnes (Figure 2c). 2.2 Reseeding scenarios (PAU 7 - whole fishery) The appropriate levels of reseeding will be cognisant of the carrying capacity of the stock, both in terms of the total biomass that can be sustained, and the annual level of recruitment. For this analysis, the total spawning biomass target being aimed for is 2300 tonnes. This is a 53% increase on the current biomass of around 1500 tonnes, and represents a value about 60% of the original virgin biomass estimate of around tonnes (Figure 26 of McKenzie and Smith, 2009a). A total biomass of 2300 tonnes is expected to result in substantial increases in daily catch rate, without encroaching on the upper limit of biomass where density dependent reductions in growth and recruitment may occur. It is therefore an appropriate spawning biomass target to aim for. In the PAU 7 fishery the long-term average recruitment (of 7 cm animals) has been estimated at 2.4 million (Figure 2d). This can be considered as the average annual recruitment capacity that the fishery can handle. Variability in annual recruitment of 7 cm animals was estimated to be in the range of 1.5 to 3.9 million (McKenzie and Smith, 2009a; Figure 12). Using this knowledge of mean recruitment and its variability, the consequences of reseeding under 3 different scenarios to achieve the 2300 tonne biomass target, was explored. Scenario (1) 30% of average natural recruitment Scenario (2) 80% of average natural recruitment Scenario (3) 150% of average natural recruitment 5 P a g e
7 These result in estimates of 0.72, 1.92, and 3.6 million x 70 mm paua annually. Importantly, all these are within the range of natural variation recruitment in the fishery (1.5 to 3.9 million). To convert estimates of recruitment at 7 cm into the equivalent recruitment at the smaller sizes of reseeded animals (1.1 cm), three estimates of survival of a 1.1 cm animal growing to 12.5 cm (legal minimum length) were applied (14%, 11%, and 7%). These were within ranges described in the literature (Cooper, 2010; Roberts, 2005, McKenzie and Smith, 2009a). Within the Enhancefish model these cumulative survival estimates equate to values of 1.6, 1.85 and 2.15 respectively, for the mortality parameter (M 1 ). Translating these figures into release densities for reseeding resulted in the following: Scenario 1 (30% of Natural recruitment): Release Densities (1.1 cm animals) are 2.4, 2.88, and 3.6 million for a 14%, 11%, and 7% survival to 125 mm respectively Scenario 2 (80% of Natural recruitment): Release Densities (1.1 cm animals) are 6.4, 7.7, and 9.6 million for a 14%, 11%, and 7% survival respectively Scenario 3 (150% of Natural recruitment): Release Densities (1.1 cm animals) are 12, 14.4, and 18 million for a 14%, 11%, and 7% survival respectively Reseeding programmes are typified by two main activities (1) hatchery culture of juveniles, and (b) deployment into the wild. Costs of culture and release were calculated in the following manner. The base cost for hatchery culture of a 1 cm (10 mm) paua was $0.45. Each extra cm above 1 cm was charged at a rate of $0.3 per cm. Deployment costs need to account for cost of release devices, packing, transport, and deployment. An assessment of deployment costs in an Australian abalone fishery was $0.07 cm -1 (Hart et. al., 2013), and a Seafic model from the mid-2000 s estimated $0.04 $0.05 cm -1 (Roberts, 2005). A figure of $0.07 per cm was assumed for this analysis. A graphical summary of reseeding costs is provided in Figure Reseeding scenarios (PAU 7 statistical areas P721, P722, P727, P734) The recent draft research proposal on commercial scale paua reseeding in PAU 7 identified these statistical areas as the most suitable experimental areas to initiate a long-term commercial reseeding programme. For the purposes of estimating annual recruitment and reseeding targets, it was assumed that the current biomass in these areas was at a similar reduced state to overall fishery biomass, and that the same proportional increase (1.53 = 2300/1500) in spawning biomass was being sought. The average long-term catch for each of these areas was used to condition the Enhancefish bioeconomic model, from which the target spawning biomass and annual recruitment for each of these areas were determined (Table 2). The model was then used to model a reseeding scenario based on 60% of annual natural recruitment for each area. The total target biomass and annual reseeding programme were 520 t and million seeds respectively (Table 2). The outcomes in terms of changes in biomass, harvest, and profitability were examined. 2.4 Effects of enhancement on wild stock genotype A significant issue with reseeding and enhancement programs is the effect of interbreeding between wild and hatchery stock on the original genetic diversity. Differences induced by selection in the 6 P a g e
8 hatchery are passed on to the following generation, then subject to natural selection that will act in the direction of the wild phenotype, and reduce differences over successive generations. The rate at which this phenotypic change occurs is given by the heritability (h 2 ) of the traits in which the wild and hatchery phenotypes differ (Lorenzen, 2005). An advantage of the Enhancefish model is that it explicitly considers this effect in two ways. First by allowing different mortality rates to be specified for wild and stocked wild animals, and secondly by calculating the effective mixing rate between wild-stock and hatchery-stock. This mixing rate is controlled by the heritability parameter (Table 1). Heritability is the change in a quantitative trait due to selection within one generation, relative to the selection differential between the current and the optimal trait value. Heritability of morphological traits is generally around 0.2, that of fitness traits tends to be lower at between 0.01 and 0.1 (Mousseau & Roff, 1987). The main outcome of a responsible reseeding programme is to preserve the potential for adaptive evolution by maintaining sufficient genetic variability in the wild stock, from which it selects its breeders. A good example of this is the chum salmon enhanced fishery in Japan, which releases 1 billion hatchery reared salmon annually, bred from 1.3 million spawners (Miyakoshi et al., 2011). In management plans for threatened and endangered species, a minimum effective breeding population size of 500 has been recommended (Tringali and Bert, 1998, Ryman and Laikre, 1991). However, this is considered a minimum, whereas an optimum is around 5000 animals, particularly if that animal is already exploited. Using an assumption that only 33% of available breeders contribute significantly to the next-generation offspring, the minimum viable wildstock population target (for genetic conservation purposes) is 15,000. This translates into a biomass of approximately 5000 kg, or 5 tonnes, which is considered a threshold value. The different reseeding scenarios were examined for % reduction in wild stock spawning biomass to see if it fell below the threshold value of 5 tonnes. 2.5 Sensitivity analysis Because of the interacting factors of target biomass, harvest rates, size-at-fishing, and differing survival rates for different size at release, it is necessary to clearly specify the objectives for the reseeding programme in order to examine the relative effects of different factors on the profitability. The reseeding programme chosen for sensitivity analysis was scenario 2 (80% of natural recruitment; 2300 tonne biomass target), with the 11% survival trajectory (from 1.1 to cm) and a legal minimum length of 11.8 cm. Sensitivity analyses exploring the effect of varying size-at-release, costs of production and enhancement, value of harvest, and cost-of-fishing on the profitability of enhancement were investigated (see Table 1 for values tested for each variable). 3 Reseeding scenario results (PAU 7 whole fishery) Results from all reseeding scenarios were compared with a No enhancement scenario (Figure 3). The no enhancement scenario was defined by a spawning biomass of 1500 t, a harvest rate of 35%, an average annual harvest of 225 tonnes, a profitability of 6 million, a GVP of 9.7 million, and an NPV (Net Present Value) of 93.9 million (Figure 3). 7 P a g e
9 It must be noted that the commercial fishery in PAU 7 fishery in 2008 only harvested 187 tonnes (McKenzie and Smith, 2009b). An annual harvest of 225 t is the assumed total catch (Table 1 of McKenzie and Smith, 2009a), which includes an estimate of non-commercial catch (18% of total). For the purpose of ensuring the biological model was correct it was necessary to use the higher catch as the No enhancement scenario. 3.1 Reseeding scenario 1 (30% of natural recruitment and LML = 118mm) Spawning biomass and harvest rate: spawning biomass was increased from 1500 to 2240 tonnes (Figure 3a). In the high survival scenario, this was achieved by reducing the harvest rate from 35% to 22% (Figure 3b). In the low survival scenario (7%), harvest rate needed to be reduced to 14% (Figure 3b). Yield: At 14% survival, harvest increased by 40% from 225 tonnes to 316 tonnes (Figure 3c). At 11% survival, average harvest increased by 3% from 229 tonnes to 236 tonnes. At 7% survival, average harvest declined by 8% to 210 tonnes (Figure 3c). Profitability: At 14% survival, profitability increased by 58% from $6 million to $9.5 million (Figure 3d). At 11% survival, profitability increased by 23% from $6 million to $7.4 million. At 7% survival, profitability increased by 3% from $6 million to $6.3 million (Figure 3d). GVP: At 14% survival, GVP increased by 23% from $9.7 million to $12 million (Figure 3e). At 11% survival, GVP decreased by 3% to $9.4 million. At 7% survival, GVP decreased by 18% to $8 million (Figure 3e). NPV: At 14% survival, Net Present Value (NPV) increased by 46% from $93.9 million to $137 million (Figure 3f). At 11% survival, NPV increased by 6% to $100 million. At 7% survival, NPV decreased by 4% to $90 million (Figure 3f). Wild stock genotype: At 14% survival, the wildstock genotype decreased from 1500 to 705 t (Figure 3g). At 11% survival, the wildstock genotype decreased to 1100 tonnes. At 7% survival, the wildstock genotype remained at 1500 t (Figure 3g) Discussion - Reseeding scenario 1 Reseeding at an annual rate of 30% of natural recruitment was a successful restocking scenario and restored the spawning biomass to 2300 tonnes. However this only occurred in conjunction with a substantial reduction in harvest rates, to as low as 14% when survival of reseeded animals was 7% (Figure 3b). Only at the highest survival rate (14%) was there any substantial improvement in the yield and economic indicators. Profitability was still slightly higher than the no enhancement scenario even at 7% survival. There were only minor effects on the existing population genotype, none of the scenarios came close to the 5 tonne threshold. Thus there would be merit in pursuing this strategy purely for restocking purposes, although the overall economic gain to the fishery is likely to be minimal. It would however, create a substantial juvenile aquaculture and reseeding industry, with around 2 3 million releases per year. A noteworthy point is the increased profitability in the low survival scenario (Figure 3d), even though other economic indicators (GVP and NPV) were slightly reduced compared to the no enhancement. This is because of two things: (a) higher catch rates caused by the increased biomass, and (b) fishing 8 P a g e
10 at a lower minimum size of 118 mm, to optimise meat yield and decrease time to harvest. On average, a 118 mm paua is harvested 1 year earlier (age 6.5) compared to a 125 mm animal (age 7.5). 3.2 Reseeding scenario 2 (80% of natural recruitment and LML = 118mm) Spawning biomass and harvest rate: spawning biomass was increased from 1500 to 2240 tonnes (Figure 3a). In the high survival scenario, this was achieved by increasing the harvest rate from 35% to 45% (Figure 3b). In the low survival scenario (7%), harvest rate needed to be reduced to 24% to achieve the target biomass (Figure 3b). Yield: At 14% survival, harvest increased by 110% from 225 tonnes to 483 tonnes (Figure 3c). At 11% survival, average harvest increased by 71% from 229 tonnes to 393 tonnes. At 7% survival, average harvest increased by 35% to 310 tonnes (Figure 3c). Profitability: At 14% survival, profitability increased by 127% from $6 million to $13.6 million (Figure 3d). At 11% survival, profitability increased by 90% from $6 million to $11.4 million. At 7% survival, profitability increased by 50% from $6 million to $9.05 million (Figure 3d). GVP: At 14% survival, GVP increased by 90% from $9.7 million to $18.4 million (Figure 3e). At 11% survival, GVP increased by 54% to $14.9 million. At 7% survival, GVP increased by 22% to $11.8 million (Figure 3e). NPV: At 14% survival, Net Present Value (NPV) increased by 136% from $93.9 million to $222 million (Figure 3f). At 11% survival, NPV increased by 87% to $176 million. At 7% survival, NPV increased by 40% to $132 million (Figure 3f). Wild stock genotype: At 14% survival, the wildstock genotype decreased from 1500 to 400 t (Figure 3g). At 11% survival, the wildstock genotype decreased to 513 tonnes. At 7% survival, the wildstock genotype decreased to 705 t (Figure 3g) Discussion - Reseeding scenario 2 Reseeding at an annual rate of 80% of natural recruitment was a successful restocking and stock enhancement scenario. It restored the spawning biomass to 2300 tonnes and substantially increased the profitability, GVP, and NPV. Even at the lowest survival (7%), a significantly enhanced GVP (by 22%), and profitability (by 50%) occurred. There was a greater reduction in the existing wild stock genotype with the higher hatchery stock survival, however none of these scenario s resulted in wild stock biomass falling anywhere near the 5 tonne threshold. Thus there would be merit in pursuing this strategy for both restocking and stock enhancement purposes as there would be substantial economic gain to the fishery and it would create a large juvenile aquaculture and reseeding industry, with around 6 9 million releases per year. To reiterate the point above, the increased profitability is driven not only by the extra animals in the water, but also by the higher catch rates and harvest rates caused by the increased biomass, and fishing at a lower minimum size of 118 mm, to optimise meat yield and decrease time to harvest. 9 P a g e
11 3.3 Reseeding scenario 3 (150% of natural recruitment and and LML = 110 mm) Spawning biomass and harvest rate: spawning biomass was increased from 1500 to 2280 tonnes (Figure 3a). In the high survival scenario, this was achieved by increasing the harvest rate from 35% to 55% (Figure 3b). In the low survival scenario (7%), harvest rate needed to be maintained at 35% to achieve the target biomass (Figure 3b). Yield: At 14% survival, harvest increased by 191% from 225 tonnes to 667 tonnes (Figure 3c). At 11% survival, average harvest increased by 148% from 229 tonnes to 568 tonnes. At 7% survival, average harvest increased by 104% to 467 tonnes (Figure 3c). Profitability: At 14% survival, profitability increased by 213% from $6 million to $18.8 million (Figure 3d). At 11% survival, profitability increased by 175% from $6 million to $16.5 million. At 7% survival, profitability increased by 131% from $6 million to $13.9 million (Figure 3d). GVP: At 14% survival, GVP increased by 160% from $9.7 million to $25.3 million (Figure 3e). At 11% survival, GVP increased by 122% to $21.6 million. At 7% survival, GVP increased by 82% to $17.7 million (Figure 3e). NPV: At 14% survival, Net Present Value (NPV) increased by 241% from $93.9 million to $321 million (Figure 3f). At 11% survival, NPV increased by 189% to $272 million. At 7% survival, NPV increased by 46% to $137 million (Figure 3f). Wild stock genotype: At 14% survival, the wildstock genotype decreased from 1500 to 240 t (Figure 3g). At 11% survival, the wildstock genotype decreased to 285 tonnes. At 7% survival, the wildstock genotype decreased to 362 t (Figure 3g) Discussion - Reseeding scenario 3 Reseeding at an annual rate of 150% of natural recruitment was a successful restocking and stock enhancement scenario. It restored the spawning biomass to 2300 tonnes and substantially increased the profitability, GVP, and NPV. There was a greater reduction in the existing wild stock genotype than in scenario 1 or 2, however none of the scenario s resulted in wild stock biomass falling anywhere near the 5 tonne threshold. Pursuing this strategy for both restocking and stock enhancement purposes would result in substantial economic gain to the fishery and create an enormous juvenile aquaculture and reseeding industry, with around million releases per year. To reiterate the point above, the increased profitability is driven not only by the extra animals in the water, but also by the higher catch rates and harvest rates caused by the increased biomass, and fishing at a lower minimum size of 110 mm, to optimise meat yield and decrease time to harvest. It is likely however, that conducting a reseeding programme of this magnitude would push the capacity limits of the fishery, and there may be reductions in wild growth and recruitment. For example, the low survival scenario (7%) resulted in less yield and GVP to the fishery than the 14% survival trajectory for Scenario P a g e
12 4 Reseeding scenario results (areas P721, P722, P727, P734) Spawning biomass and harvest rate: spawning biomass was increased from 340 to 520 tonnes (Figure 4a). This was achieved by reducing the harvest rate from 35% to 23% (Figure 4b). Yield: Average harvest increased by 36% from 55 tonnes to 75 tonnes (Figure 4c). Profitability: Profitability increased by 45% from $1.1 million to $1.6 million (Figure 4d). GVP: GVP increased by 33% from $2.1 to $2.8 million (Figure 4e). NPV: NPV increased by 19% from $18.6 to $22.1 million (Figure 4f) Discussion - Reseeding scenario in proposed experimental areas Reseeding at an annual rate of 60% of natural recruitment (1.06 million) into the sub-areas was a successful restocking and stock enhancement scenario under the assumed 11% survival trajectory. It increased the spawning biomass, profitability, GVP, and NPV. With a well-designed reseeding programme, careful mapping of the habitat and releases area, and appropriate training of personnel, the proposed experimental reseeding proposal has a reasonable chance of being cost-effective. At the very least it will generate a substantial hatchery culture industry. 5 Sensitivity analysis For the whole of PAU 7, the reseeding programme chosen for sensitivity analysis was scenario 2 (80% of natural recruitment; 2300 tonne biomass target), with the 11% survival trajectory (from 1.1 to cm ), and a legal minimum length of 11.8 cm. Size-at-release had a large effect on economic viability. Overall, the reseeding programme was profitable for size-at-release between 0.9 and 1.7 cm (Figure 5a), however highest profitability was between 0.9 and 1.1 cm size-at-release, and it declined sharply between 1.2 and 1.7 cm size-atrelease (Figure 5a). Both the costs of reseeding (Figure 5b) and of fishing (Figure 5d) had a minimal effect on profitability of the reseeding programme over the range examined. Value of harvest had the highest effect on the overall profitability of the reseeding programme, and varied between $2 million at $28/kg to $11 million at $48/kg (Figure 4c). 6 General Discussion These analyses indicate that a reseeding programme for Haliotis iris has a high chance of being economically viable, if the appropriate size and density-at-release is chosen and the programme has explicit restocking and stock enhancement targets. All scenarios examined were economically viable, with the exception of those where size at release was 18+ mm. Neither cost of reseeding nor cost of fishing had a significant effect on economic viability. Instead, viability was dependent primarily on harvest price, and secondarily on size-at-release. 11 P a g e
13 It needs to be stressed however that this analysis is a preliminary evaluation, and a detailed evaluation using local specific knowledge and properly costed parameters would be required if the decision is made to proceed with a commercial scale programme. 6.1 Practical implementation To implement a commercial scale reseeding programme, a detailed evaluation should consider the following issues. - Industry should accept that an enhancement fishery will, by necessity, operate in a different manner to the current fishery because it is about the total system, rather than the sum of the parts. Paua divers in an enhancement fishery are not just harvester s; they may also undertaking breeding, reseeding, stock surveys, and associated R&D, so as to optimise reefspecific production and enhancement targets. - A reseeding business model needs have a sustainable growth trajectory managed under clear business rules of maximising profitability, GVP, employment. It needs to build the programme incrementally, first by targeting a specific area such as the statistical areas identified in this report, and then increasing from there, with the end goal being a whole of management area approach. - A viable business model would be for current quota owners to invest (or sell) a proportion of their capital (ITQs) into an Enhancement company that has exclusive (or near to) access to both the harvest (e.g. 55 tonnes) and initial areas proposed for the reseeding programme (e.g. P721, P722, P727, P734 in PAU 7). Such a model will provide the necessary capital and cash flow so the company can obtain business loans, invest in R&D, and proceed with building the reseeding programme on a self-sufficient basis, supported by industry development grants. - The use of the current GPS dive tracking systems to ascertain accurate habitat areas, catch and biomass levels, and guide staff to the exact reef location for release will be critical to the success of the programme. - For example, an enhancement fishery may plan rotational fishing and reseeding every 2 years in order to maximise cost-benefit, particularly as a significant cost is packing and transport of the release device to the actual habitat. Deploying and harvesting 2 years worth of seed may be more cost-effective rather than annually. - The first outcome of a cost-effective reseeding program will be substantial development of the hatchery culture sector. The second outcome will be an increase in yield and value of the wild fishery. Therefore, commercial arrangements between the wild fishery and hatchery sector should be developed to enhance the chances of a successful reseeding programme. Such arrangements must ensure that appropriate breeding and biosecurity protocols are implemented to maintain wild stock genetics and minimise disease-risk. - Biomass surveys to ascertain density and size-structure information must be integrated into the programme. These will facilitate the development of bioeconomic models. - Accurate bioeconomic models that can be tailored to area specific growth and biomass production should be cornerstone of the enhancement business. They will enable different harvesting and reseeding programmes to be simultaneously tested for their costeffectiveness, as it is likely that area or reef-specific size-limits and catch targets will be the required. 12 P a g e
14 7 References Breen P.A., Kim, S.W. (2005). The 2005 stock assessment of paua (Haliotis iris) in PAU 7. New Zealand Fisheries Assessment Report 2005/ p. Cooper J (2010). Summary and review of reseeding trials in New Zealand. A report to the Paua Industry Council Ltd. Hart AM, Strain LWS, Hesp A (2013). Stock enhancement of greenlip abalone Part III: Bioeconomic evaluation. Reviews in Fisheries Science. 21(3-4): Kim, S.W., Breen, P.A. & Andrew, N.L. (2002). Evaluation of the paua stock assessment model with an individual-based operating model. Final Research Report Ministry of Fisheries Research Project PAU200l/01. Objective 2 Lorenzen K (2005). Population dynamics and potential of fisheries stock enhancement: Practical theory for assessment and policy analysis. Phil. Trans. Royal Soc. B 360: Lorenzen K., Medley P.A.H. (2006). Enhancefish Manual (Beta Release). London: Imperial College McKenzie A., Smith, A.N.H. (2009a). The 2008 stock assessment of paua (Haliotis iris) in PAU 7. New Zealand Fisheries Assessment Report 2009/ p. McKenzie A., Smith, A.N.H. (2009b). Data inputs for the PAU 7 stock assessment in New Zealand Fisheries Assessment Report 2009/ p. Mousseau, T.A. & Roff, D.A. (1987) Natural selection and the heritability of fitness components. Heredity 59: Miyakoshi Y, Nagata M, Kitada S, Kaeriyama M (2011). Current hatchery programs and future stock management of chum salmon in Hokkaido, Northern Japan. Abstract submitted to the 4 th International Symposium on Stock Enhancement and Sea Ranching, Shanghai, China. Roberts R (2005). Paua reseeding trials in Marlborough: economic model and summary of results to date. Cawthron Report No Prepared for PAUMAC 7. Rosetteo M, De Leo G. A., Bevacqua, D., Micheli F (2012). Allometric scaling of mortality rates with body mass in abalones. Oecologia. 168: Ryman N, Laikre L (1991). Effects of supportive breeding on genetically effective population size. Conservation Biology 5(3) Sumaila, U. R., and C. Walters (2005). Intergenerational discounting: A new intuitive approach. Ecol. Econ. 52: Tringali MD, Bert TM (1998). Risk to genetic effective population size should be an important consideration in fish stock enhancement programs. Bulletin of Marine Science. 62(2): P a g e
15 8 Tables Table 1. Model parameters, baseline values, and ranges used in sensitivity analysis for the Paua 7 bioeconomic enhancement model Parameter Baseline value Range Description Growth, morphometry, and reproduction L 15.9 cm Asymptotic length at biomass 0 K 0.21 Von bertalanfy growth rate g Density dependent growth / competition coefficient cm kg -1 α Length-meat weight coefficient β Length-meat weight exponent L m 9.1 Length at 50% maturity (cm) p -4 Steepness of maturity function rp 1 Relative reproductive performance of stocked fish Life History and evolution parameters L Length at settlement (cm) A Age at settlement (years) L r 7 Length at recruitment (cm) A r 3 Age at recruitment (years) h heritability of life-history traits Natural mortality and Stock Recruitment (Beverton& Holt) M1 w 1.7 Mortality of wild phenotype at L = 1 cm, equivalent to M = 0.15 at 12 cm (McKenzie& Smith, 2009a) M1 s Mortality of stocked phenotype at L = 1 cm a Maximum recruits per unit SSb (@ L r = 7 cm) b 2,663,321 Maximum recruitment (@ L r = 7 cm) r m 5 steepness parameter (maximum annual reproductive rate) Fishing parameters and economics C c 225,000 Current average catch (kg) F Fishing mortality (0.43 equates to 35% exploitation rate) L c , 11 Gear selection length (minimum harvest size; cm) q -4 Steepness of gear selectivity curve γ Cost of fishing ($ kg -1 ; whole weight) π Ex-vessel price of fish ($ kg -1 ; whole weight) ϕ 3.5 Management cost ($ kg -1 ; whole weight) δ 6% Discount rate. For NPV analysis Stock enhancement parameters and costs D S , 9.6 Density of stocking (millions) of 1.1 cm animals under three survival rates (14%, 11%, 7%) for reseeding scenario 2 L S Length-at-stocking (cm; shell length) γ $$$ 0.60 Hatchery production + enhancement costs ($ cm -1 ) Enhancement costs assumed at $0.07 cm -1 $$$ Enhancement costs include cost of release devices, packing, transport, and deployment. 14 P a g e
16 Table 2. Average catch (t), estimated biomass and recruitment from the Enhancefish model, and proposed reseeding scenarios in the PAU 7 experimental statistical areas. Statistical Area P721 P722 P727 P734 TOTAL Population and fishery statistics Average catch (numbers) 50,000 60,000 70,000 18,000 Average catch (t)(0.275 kg per paua) Current spawning biomass (t) Annual recruitment (1.1 cm) 450, , , ,000 Recruitment (1.1 cm) per t of spawners 5,300 5,200 5,200 5,200 Reseeding scenarios Target % increase in biomass 53% 53% 53% 53% Target biomass (t) Reseeding target at 11 mm (60% of annual recruitment) 270, , ,000 96,000 1,060, P a g e
17 9 Figures Figure 1. Assumed economic costs of paua production and reseeding as a function of size-atrelease. 16 P a g e
18 (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) Figure 2. Comparison of (a) growth rates [75 and 120 mm Haliotis iris], (b) mortality (shown as cumulative survival), (c) mean biomass [t], (d) mean annual recruitment [70 mm animals], (e) exploitation rate (% of available harvested), and (f) average catch [t] in the PAU 7 fishery as estimated by the PAU 7 model (McKenzie and Smith, 2009a; Breen and Kim, 2005), and the Enhancefish model. Error bars on PAU 7 model are the 5% and 95% percentiles from the model outputs. 17 P a g e
19 (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) Figure 3. Comparison of current PAU 7 stock and economic indicators (No enhancement) with three enhancement scenarios under varying survival (14%, 11%, 7%) of paua reseeded at 11 mm. Indicators are (a) spawning biomass, (b) harvest rate, (c) yield, (d) profitability, (e) GVP, (f) NPV Net Present Value, and (g) wildstock genotype biomass 18 P a g e
20 (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) Figure 4. Comparison of current stock and economic indicators in statistical areas P721, P722, P727, and P734 of PAU 7, with those resulting from an enhancement scenario of 1.06 million reseeds (11 mm) at 11% survival. Indicators are (a) spawning biomass, (b) harvest rate, (c) yield, (d) profitability, (e) GVP, and (f) NPV Net Present Value 19 P a g e
21 (a) (b) (c) (d) Figure 5. PAU 7 reseeding: Sensitivity analysis to the effect of changes in: (a) size-at-release, (b) cost of enhancement ($ cm -1 ), (c) value of harvest ($ kg -1 ), and (d) cost of fishing on the profitability of stock enhancement in the PAU 7 fishery. All sensitivity analysis is in relation to the 11% survival trajectory (M 1 = 1.85) of scenario 2, aiming for a target biomass of 2300 tonnes. 20 P a g e
Fish Conservation and Management
Fish Conservation and Management CONS 486 Traditional management use of life history information Ross Chapter 3 Traditional management use of life history information Escapement models Surplus production
More informationDetermination of paua growth in PAU 2, SA, SB, and 5D
MINISTRY OF FISHERIES Te Toufiuki i nga tini o Tongoroo Determination of paua growth in PAU 2, SA, SB, and 5D J. R Naylor N. L. Andrew New Zealand Fisheries Assessment Report 2002134 August 2002 Determination
More informationEconomic potential of sablefish aquaculture in British Columbia
Economic potential of sablefish aquaculture in British Columbia Ussif Rashid Sumaila 1, John Volpe 2 and Yajie Liu 1 1 Fisheries Economics Research Unit, Fisheries Centre, the University of British Columbia,
More informationDiscarding occurs due to catch of undersized scallops and high-grading; the latter mainly occurs in
B. SEA SCALLOP ASSESSMENT SUMMARY FOR 2014 Status of Stock: During 2013, the sea scallop stock was not overfished and overfishing was not occurring. Estimated biomass (40+ mm SH) was 132.561 thousand mt
More informationT: P: PO Box 86, Fremantle WA 6959 A: Level 3, 3 Cantonment St, Fremantle WA 6160
Company Profile Name of Company: Ocean Grown Abalone Ltd A.B.N: 52 148 155 042 Registered Office: Level 3, 3 Cantonment Street Fremantle WA 6959 Phone: +61 8 6181 8888 Email: info@oceangrown.com.au Web:
More informationGlossary of terms for harvest strategies, management procedures and management strategy evaluation
Glossary of terms for harvest strategies, management procedures and management strategy evaluation Terms commonly used in Management Strategy Evaluation or Management Procedure literature Average Annual
More informationAquaculture & Stock Enhancement:
Aquaculture & Stock Enhancement: A Solution for Protein from the Sea? (Perspective on History, Pitfalls, & Progress of Aquaculture-Based Fisheries Enhancement) Kenneth M. Leber Will the Oceans Help Feed
More informationA Guide to the Land Based Aquaculture Economics Models
A Guide to the Land Based Aquaculture Economics Models The economic models provide the user with an indication of the likely costs of establishing and running a land based fish or shellfish farming operation
More informationStock Assessment of Oysters in the Chesapeake Bay, Maryland
Stock Assessment of Oysters in the Chesapeake Bay, Maryland Maryland Department of Natural Resources in consultation with the University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science 1 300 year plan for
More informationRisk Analysis in Fishery Management
NAFO Sci. Coun. Studies. 6: 43-48 Risk Analysis in Fishery Management R. I. C. C. Francis Fisheries Research Centre. P. O. 80x 297 Wellington. New Zealand Abstract Risk analysis is shown to be a useful
More informationAbalone Recovery Priorities Second Draft
Abalone Recovery Priorities Second Draft Recovery Plan Develop a pinto abalone recovery plan for Alaska. The goal will be to produce a long-term strategy aimed at helping stocks recover to a sustainable
More informationResponsible approach to restocking and stock enhancement
Responsible approach to restocking and stock enhancement Josianne Støttrup, Dept. For Marine Ecology and Aquaculture The Responsible Approach Blankenship and Leber, 1995 10 key components essential to
More information2 Population dynamics modelling of culturebased fisheries
2 Population dynamics modelling of culturebased fisheries A population dynamics model for culture-based fisheries has been developed which is conceptually simple, yet able to address all the key management
More informationExam #2: BIOL/ECON 140 February 27, 2009
Exam #2: BIOL/ECON 140 February 27, 2009 Name: KEY 1. Imagine a case where you have 15 units of a resource. Demand for the resource is given by P = 8 0.4q and the marginal cost of harvest is constant at
More informationSELECTING FOR SUSTAINABILITY
SELECTING FOR SUSTAINABILITY presented by Michael Bruce Introduction What is selective breeding and why so important? What are the key elements of a selective breeding? programme When should it be used?
More informationPopulation Abundance Indices. LO: evaluate the ability to estimate population abundances
Population Abundance Indices LO: evaluate the ability to estimate population abundances Managing Fish Populations For mature animals, need to know rate of renewal To determine stock-recruitment relationship
More informationA Management Strategy Evaluation. for orange roughy. ISL Client Report for Deepwater Group Ltd
A Management Strategy Evaluation for orange roughy ISL Client Report for Deepwater Group Ltd P.L. Cordue August 2014 Executive summary A management strategy evaluation was performed with a generic orange
More informationSpecial request, Advice May 2013
9.3.3.1 Special request, Advice May 2013 ECOREGION SUBJECT Widely distributed and migratory stocks NEAFC request to ICES to evaluate the harvest control rule element of the long-term management plan for
More informationAdaptation responses of fisheries and fisheries managers to climate induced impacts on sockeye salmon returns to Barkley Sound, BC.
Adaptation responses of fisheries and fisheries managers to climate induced impacts on sockeye salmon returns to Barkley Sound, BC. Diana Dobson, Wilf Luedke and Kim Hyatt 1 Outline 1. Management context
More informationAdditional draft impacts of ABC control rule alternatives
Additional draft impacts of ABC control rule alternatives 4.0 Draft Environmental Impacts... 3 4.1 Summary of ABC control rule impacts (mse analysis)... 3 4.1.1 Proportion of years biomass is greater than
More informationSturgeon conservation and aquaculture
Sturgeon conservation and aquaculture a WSCS perspective on future challenges for research and development C. Balnath, J. Gessner, H. Rosenthal Szarvas, 14 th and 15 th May 2008 Contents What does WSCS
More informationChapter 25 Population Genetics
Chapter 25 Population Genetics Population Genetics -- the discipline within evolutionary biology that studies changes in allele frequencies. Population -- a group of individuals from the same species that
More informationSherry Larkin Gil Sylvia
Sherry Larkin Gil Sylvia Caveats Models need bounds which may mean ignoring known characteristics of the fishery Ecosystems Multispecies/multifisheries Risk and uncertainty Equity Efficiency Consumer behavior
More informationBackground to the Precautionary Approach framework
Background to the Precautionary Approach framework Sustainable Fisheries Framework The Sustainable Fisheries Framework provides the basis for ensuring Canadian fisheries are conducted in a manner which
More informationRenewable Resources Assessment Group, Imperial College, University of London, London, UK
Aquaculture Research, 1997, 28, 867 880 Analysing extensive fish culture systems by transparent population modelling: bighead carp, Aristichthys nobilis (Richardson 1845), culture in a Chinese reservoir
More informationDefining overfished stocks. Ray Hilborn School of Aquatic and Fishery Sciences University of Washington
Defining overfished stocks Ray Hilborn School of Aquatic and Fishery Sciences University of Washington Structure of the talk History and significant events MSY and biomass levels corresponding to overfished
More informationMaximum sustainable yield
Maximum sustainable yield Poul Degnbol Head of ICES advisory programme Sostenibilidad pesquera en los ecosistemas mrinos Santander, Spain, 1-3 sept 2010 1 Maximum sustainable yield Concept developed in
More informationFMSP stock assessment tools Training workshop. Yield Practical Session 1
FMSP stock assessment tools Training workshop Yield Practical Session 1 Yield Software Practical Session The Yield Software practical session will last half a day. During the session we will look in detail
More informationREPORT OF THE 22nd MEETING OF THE SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE
CCSBT-EC/1710/18 (EC agenda item 6) REPORT OF THE 22nd MEETING OF THE SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE Yogyakarta, Indonesia 28 Aug - 2 Sep 2017 Main topics Review of SBT fisheries and fisheries indicators Results
More informationBIOS 6150: Ecology Dr. Stephen Malcolm, Department of Biological Sciences
BIOS 6150: Ecology Dr. Stephen Malcolm, Department of Biological Sciences Week 12: Manipulating Abundance & Risk Assessment. Lecture summary: Manipulating abundance - pests and harvesting: Chapter 16 in
More informationSOUTHERN ROCK LOBSTER LIMITED BACKGROUND INDUSTRY PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (IPA)
Southern Rocklobster Limited ABN 66 108 116 847 PO Box 3450, Norwood SA 5067 T (08) 8132 0257 F (08) 8132 0161 E: justin@jp-consulting.com.au W:www.southernrocklobster.com SOUTHERN ROCK LOBSTER LIMITED
More informationLEGAL MINIMUM LENGTHS AND THE MANAGEMENT OF ABALONE FISHERIES
Journal of Shellfish Research, Vol. 32, No. 1, 197 208, 2013. LEGAL MINIMUM LENGTHS AND THE MANAGEMENT OF ABALONE FISHERIES MALCOLM HADDON 1 * AND FAY HELIDONIOTIS 2 1 CSIRO Wealth from Oceans, GPO Box
More informationVolume and Value of Fish Landings. '96 '97 '98 '99 '00 '01 '02 '03 '04 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10r '11p
Fishery The Newfoundland and Labrador seafood industry experienced a good year in 211. Higher market prices for key species, particularly snow crab and shrimp, combined with continued growth in the value
More information1 Objectives of the project
1 Objectives of the project The aims of the project as specified in the memorandum were to estimate the yield of capture fisheries based on stock enhancement programmes in small reservoirs, and to assess
More informationUsing environmental data to inform spatial stock assessment assumptions in Stock Synthesis
Using environmental data to inform spatial stock assessment assumptions in Stock Synthesis LaTreese S. Denson 1, David B. Sampson 2, Andi Stephens 3 Oregon State University Department of Fisheries and
More informationStock Assessment and ABC Calculation for Japanese Sardine (Sardinops Melanostictus) in the Northwestern Pacific under Japanese TAC System
125 Stock Assessment and ABC Calculation for Japanese Sardine (Sardinops Melanostictus) in the Northwestern Pacific under Japanese TAC System Hiroshi NISHIDA National Research Institute of Fisheries Science,
More informationDefinition of Sustainability
Sustainability Learning Goals Evaluate human behaviors in terms of how likely they are to ensure the ability to live sustainably Evaluate the concept of reduce, reuse, recycle in terms of impact on natural
More informationA Guide to Fisheries Stock Assessment using the FMSP Tools. 6 References
A Guide to Fisheries Stock Assessment using the FMSP Tools 6 References Cadima, E.L. 2003. Fish stock assessment manual. FAO Fish. Tech. Pap. 393. Rome, FAO. 161 pp. Cochrane, K.L. 2002. A fishery manager
More informationEcological Society of Australia submission on Australia s Biodiversity Conservation Strategy Consultation draft
Ecological Society of Australia submission on Australia s Biodiversity Conservation Strategy 2010-2020 Consultation draft May 2009 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The ESA commends the Australian Government on drafting
More informationR E S E A R C H I N E C O N O M I C S A N D R U R A L S O C I O L O G Y
N 1 - MAY 2010 R E S E A R C H I N E C O N O M I C S A N D R U R A L S O C I O L O G Y Viability, an approach to sustainable development aiming to avoid crises over time: the case of fisheries Nowadays,
More informationICES Special Request Advice Baltic Sea Ecoregion Published 11 February 2016 Version 2; 13 May 2016
ICES Special Request Advice Baltic Sea Ecoregion Published 11 February 2016 Version 2; 13 May 2016 9.4.1 * EU request to ICES on evaluation of the Trans-border management plan for European eel in the Polish
More informationSection 4 Environmental Impact Assessment Framework
Section 4 Environmental Impact Assessment Framework 4. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK 4.1 Environmental Impact Assessment in Western Australia The overall framework for EIA in WA is described
More informationTHOMPSON & BELL PREDICTION MODEL
THOMPSON & BELL PREDICTION MODEL Shoba J. Kizhakkudan Demersal Fisheries Division ICAR- Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute 18 Prediction or predictive models predict the effect of different levels
More informationModels for the assessment of sustainability and risk in fish and shellfish aquaculture
Models for the assessment of sustainability and risk in fish and shellfish aquaculture TABLE OF CONTENTS LONGLINE ENVIRONMENT CONTEXT & EXPERIENCE FISH FARMING: CREATING A SUSTAINABLE INDUSTRY ACCESS MARKETS
More informationObjectives, Indicators and TRPs
Objectives, Indicators and TRPs Table lists a wide range of objectives which cannot be achieved simultaneously. Many of them will not translate into a TRP or be incorporated into a HCR, but nevertheless
More informationFisheries Management under ITQs: Innovations in New Zealand s Southern Scallop Fishery
Fisheries Management under ITQs: Innovations in New Zealand s Southern Scallop Fishery Michael Arbuckle, Challenger Scallop Enhancement Company Ltd. Abstract. The Challenger Scallop Enhancement Company
More informationTopic 2: Genetics and the logistic map
Attachment A4: Project option Topic 2: Genetics and the logistic map 2. Required background: 2.1 Science To complete this project you will require some background information on two topics: constrained
More informationNew Technology to Enhance UK Farmed Seafood Production
New Technology to Enhance UK Farmed Seafood Production D. J. & I.T. Fletcher RAS Aquaculture Research Ltd Tel: 44 1286 830343 Mobile: 07970 705495 e-mail: djfletcher4@aol.com 12 March, 2014 Recirculation
More informationFishery and Aquaculture
Cod. Courtesy: Department of Fisheries and Land Resources Fishery and Aquaculture The seafood sector consisting of the harvesting and processing of both wild and farmed fisheries is an important part of
More informationFUNDY TIDAL ENERGY DEMONSTRATION PROJECT Environmental Effects Monitoring Report. APPENDIX A Environmental Impact Predictions
FUNDY TIDAL ENERGY DEMONSTRATION PROJECT Environmental Effects Monitoring Report APPENDIX A Environmental Impact Predictions 1 Environmental Impact Predictions - Fundy Tidal Energy Demonstration Project
More informationOcean acidification and its potential effect on abalone
Ocean acidification and its potential effect on abalone Vonda Cummings vonda.cummings@niwa.co.nz NIWA Wellington Fate of Anthropogenic CO 2 Emissions (2003-2012 average) 8.6 ± 0.4 GtC/yr 92% 4.3±0.1 GtC/yr
More informationEU request on criteria for CITES non-detriment finding for European eel (Anguilla anguilla)
ICES Special Request Advice Northeast Atlantic Published 30 April 2015 9.2.3.2 EU request on criteria for CITES non-detriment finding for European eel (Anguilla anguilla) Advice Summary The advice is provided
More informationComposition: Citizen, Scientist and Seafood Industry Leaders representing a broad cross-section of interests and disciplines
The Governor s Oyster Restoration and Resiliency Council ( Oyster Council ) was created by Executive Order by Governor Phil Bryant on February 2, 2015. Composition: Citizen, Scientist and Seafood Industry
More informationAddress: Level 8, 33 York St., Sydney NSW 2000 Phone: Fax: Mobile:
Address: Level 8, 33 York St., Sydney NSW 2000 Phone: +61 2 6285 1445 Fax: +61 2 6285 1445 Mobile: +61 488 950 315 AAIF Portfolio Assets Page 1 of 7 AQUACULTURE SA Ocean Abalone Short term Investment Guaranteed
More informationTestimony of James J. Anderson Associate Professor School of Fisheries University of Washington, Seattle Washington
Testimony of James J. Anderson Associate Professor School of Fisheries University of Washington, Seattle Washington before the U.S. House of Representatives Subcommittee on Water and Power in Lewiston
More informationREGIONAL MANAGEMENT OF SUSTAINABLE FISHERIES FOR GIANT CLAMS (TRIDACNIDAE) AND CITES CAPACITY BUILDING WORKSHOP 04 th 07 th August 2009.
REGIONAL MANAGEMENT OF SUSTAINABLE FISHERIES FOR GIANT CLAMS (TRIDACNIDAE) AND CITES CAPACITY BUILDING WORKSHOP 04 th 07 th August 2009 Fiji Islands Anare Luvunakoro: Fisheries Research Officer- Giant
More informationCNL(12)44. Guidelines for the Preparation and Evaluation of NASCO Implementation Plans and for Reporting on Progress
CNL(12)44 Guidelines for the Preparation and Evaluation of NASCO Implementation Plans and for Reporting on Progress 1. NASCO s Goals and Objectives NASCO and its Parties have agreed to adopt and apply
More informationAquaculture of Marine Ornamental. of Pygmy Angelfish, Year 1
Aquaculture of Marine Ornamental Species, Phase II: Techniques for Large-Scale Production of Pygmy Angelfish, Year 1 General Information Reporting Period January 1, 2004 September 30, 2004 Funding Level
More informationProvisioning wild catch seafood in Australia s ocean economy: opportunities and challenges
Provisioning wild catch seafood in Australia s ocean economy: opportunities and challenges Sarah Jennings 60 th AARES Conference February 2016 Canberra TASMANIAN SCHOOL OF BUSINESS & ECONOMICS Acknowledgements
More informationPrioritization Framework For Management Strategies in the Entiat Subbasin Plan
Prioritization Framework For Management Strategies in the Entiat Subbasin Plan November, 2004 Co-Planners: Chelan County Yakama Nation Prepared by Introduction The purpose of this report is to provide
More informationAlternative risk thresholds for South African sardine and anchovy resources
MARAM/IWS/7/Sardine/P Alternative risk thresholds for South African sardine and anchovy resources C.L. de Moor Correspondence email: carryn.demoor@uct.ac.za Background This document considers alternative
More informationTwenty years with harvest control rules in ICES - what now? Dankert W. Skagen
Twenty years with harvest control rules in ICES - what now? Dankert W. Skagen Started with North Sea herring 1997: F-rule with trigger-point F decided according to risk-evaluations Separate Fs for adults
More informationUnderstanding Fish Stock Assessment. Gary Shepherd Northeast Fisheries Science Center Woods Hole, MA
Understanding Fish Stock Assessment Gary Shepherd Northeast Fisheries Science Center Woods Hole, MA 1 What is Fisheries Stock Assessment? Ø Stock assessment is the process of assembling information to
More informationThe distribution of Northern Shelf haddock. Introduction
Evaluating the bio-economic performance of the Northern Shelf haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) fishery using age-structured harvesting strategies and variable growth trajectories Adam Delargy, University
More informationThe Shiraz model A tool for incorporating anthropogenic effects and fish habitat relationships in conservation planning
The Shiraz model A tool for incorporating anthropogenic effects and fish habitat relationships in conservation planning Mark D. Scheuerell National Marine Fisheries Service Seattle, WA Acknowledgments
More informationCONCH (Strombus gigas) STOCK ASSESSMENT MANUAL. Nelson M. Ehrhardt and Monica Valle-Esquivel
CONCH (Strombus gigas) STOCK ASSESSMENT MANUAL Nelson M. Ehrhardt and Monica Valle-Esquivel CARIBBEAN FISHERY MANAGEMENT COUNCIL 2008 1. CITES CONTROLS The Convention on International Trade in Endangered
More informationJ.C. Seijo Marist University of Merida. CLIFFMA Workshop Tromso, Norway November 27-28, 2012
J.C. Seijo Marist University of Merida CLIFFMA Workshop Tromso, Norway November 27-28, 2012 From homogeneous to heterogeneous resource distribution S-G and B-H models are based on dynamic pool assumptions,
More informationICLARM, ACIAR, National Scientists and Communities: Partners for Progress in Mariculture in the Pacific Islands
A. SUMMARY 1. Title ICLARM, ACIAR, National Scientists and Communities: Partners for Progress in Mariculture in the Pacific Islands 2. Duration Continuous since 1987. 3. Objectives Pacific island nations
More informationUnderstanding and Managing Enhancement Fisheries Systems
Reviews in Fisheries Science, 16(1 3):10 23, 2008 Copyright C Taylor and Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1064-1262 print DOI: 10.1080/10641260701790291 Understanding and Managing Enhancement Fisheries Systems
More informationQuantitative Genetics
Quantitative Genetics Polygenic traits Quantitative Genetics 1. Controlled by several to many genes 2. Continuous variation more variation not as easily characterized into classes; individuals fall into
More informationDeployment Issues & Genetic Diversity. John Russell & Alvin Yanchuk
Deployment Issues & Genetic Diversity John Russell & Alvin Yanchuk Table of Contents Introduction... 2 1. The Single Gene & Risk of Plantation Failure Approach... 2 2. Genetic Sampling Theory, Loss of
More information(Cost-)Effective Utilisation of Genomic Technologies in Beef Production. Rob Banks AGBU
(Cost-)Effective Utilisation of Genomic Technologies in Beef Production Rob Banks AGBU Long-term connections ~ Nothofagus spp: 300m!!! Contrasts and constraints $50m AUD Contrasts and constraints Effective
More informationMarine Biotechnology and Aquaculture
Marine Biotechnology and Aquaculture The salmon aquaculture sector and new breeding technologies Ashie Norris. ERA-NET Marine biotechnology Oceans of opportunity! Seafood becoming more important in food
More informationChapter 18 Conservation of Biodiversity. Tuesday, April 17, 18
Chapter 18 Conservation of Biodiversity Module 59 The Sixth Mass Extinction After reading this module you should be able to explain the global decline in the genetic diversity of wild species. discuss
More informationWATER RESOURCES ACT 1991 THE WALES ROD AND LINE (SALMON AND SEA TROUT) BYELAWS 2017 THE WALES NET FISHING (SALMON AND SEA TROUT) BYELAWS 2017
WATER RESOURCES ACT 1991 THE WALES ROD AND LINE (SALMON AND SEA TROUT) BYELAWS 2017 THE WALES NET FISHING (SALMON AND SEA TROUT) BYELAWS 2017 DOCUMENT NRW/5 PROOF OF EVIDENCE OF RUTH JENKINS HEAD OF NATURAL
More information16.2 Evolution as Genetic Change
16.2 Evolution as Genetic Change 1 of 40 16-2 Evolution as Genetic Change 16-2 Evolution as Genetic Change If an individual dies without reproducing, it does not contribute to the gene pool. If an individual
More informationInternational Workshop Danube Sturgeon, where to go? September 2018, Sf. Gheorghe, Romania
ROMANIA MINISTRY OF NATIONAL EDUCATION DUNAREA DE JOS UNIVERSITY OF GALATI Research and Development Centre for Sturgeon, Aquatic Habitats and Biodiversity International Workshop Danube Sturgeon, where
More informationWatershed Technical Workgroup Approval Decision Meeting. December 1, 2016
Oyster Best Management Practice Expert Panel Recommendations on the Oyster BMP Reduction Effectiveness Determination Decision Framework and Nitrogen and Phosphorus Assimilation in Oyster Tissue Reduction
More informationSAW/SARC-54 Summary (NEFSC CRD#12-14; #12-18) Presentation: Sept. 2012
SAW/SARC-54 Summary (NEFSC CRD#12-14; #12-18) Presentation: Sept. 2012 1 SAW/SARC Process 1. SAW Working Groups: Herring WG, SDWG 2. External Peer Review Panel: Center of Independent Experts (CIE) + SSC.
More informationDeciding on Precautionary Management Measures for a Stock Based on a Suite of Limit Reference Points (LRPs) as a Basis for a Multi-LRP Harvest Law
NAFO Sci. Coun. Studies, 32: 55 68 Deciding on Precautionary Management Measures for a Stock Based on a Suite of Limit Reference Points (LRPs) as a Basis for a Multi-LRP Harvest Law J. F. Caddy Food and
More informationEASTERN GEORGES BANK COD
Transboundary Resources Assessment Committee Status Report 2018/01 EASTERN GEORGES BANK COD [5Zjm; 551,552,561,562] 41 5Y International Boundary 42 Eastern Georges Bank Area II 4X 68 67 66 Summary Combined
More informationBreeding and reproduction in livestock systems in 2030 and beyond: How will science bring us there?
Breeding and reproduction in livestock systems in 2030 and beyond: How will science bring us there? The salmon aquaculture sector and new breeding technologies Ashie Norris. EAAP Belfast 2016 Oceans of
More informationHatchery Scientific Review Group Review and Recommendations
Hatchery Scientific Review Group Review and Recommendations Salmon - Secesh River Spring Chinook Population and Related Hatchery Programs January 31, 2009 Salmon- Secesh River Spring Chinook Population
More informationA management strategy evaluation approach for broadbill swordfish, Xiphias gladius, in the south-west Pacific Ocean
SCTB16 Working Paper BBRG-4 A management strategy evaluation approach for broadbill swordfish, Xiphias gladius, in the south-west Pacific Ocean Robert Campbell and Natalie Dowiing CSIRO, Division of Marine
More informationStock Assessment Form Demersal species Reference year: Reporting year:
Stock Assessment Form Demersal species Reference year: Reporting year: [A brief abstract may be added here] Stock Assessment Form version 1.0 (January 2014) Uploader: Please include your name Stock assessment
More informationTHE USE OF VARIABLE RATE FERTILISER APPLICATIONS IN NZ HILL COUNTRY
White, M.D., Metherell, A.K. and Roberts A.H.C., 2017. The use of variable rate fertiliser applications in NZ hill country.. In: Science and policy: nutrient management challenges for the next generation.
More informationDraft interim management plan for boarfish. Maurice Clarke, Marine Institute
Draft interim management plan for boarfish Maurice Clarke, Marine Institute Summary Recap on ICES advice 2011 Latest update on assessment of boarfish Need for a management plan Need for caution, and the
More informationLesson Overview. What would happen when genetics answered questions about how heredity works?
17.1 Darwin developed his theory of evolution without knowing how heritable traits passed from one generation to the next or where heritable variation came from. What would happen when genetics answered
More informationUPDATE AND DISCUSSION
UPDATE AND DISCUSSION Agenda Item K.2.b Supplemental NWFSC and SWFSC Presentation November 2012 Objectives Provide a brief update on the state of the California Current Integrated Ecosystem Assessment
More information25th March The Secretary Senate Standing Committee on Economics PO Box 6100 Parliament House CANBERRA ACT
25th March 2009 The Secretary Senate Standing Committee on Economics PO Box 6100 Parliament House CANBERRA ACT 2600 Email: economics.sen@aph.gov.au Australian Aluminium Council submission to Senate Standing
More informationTransmission System Capability and the Decision to Abolish the Snowy Region
9 October 2007 Issue 008 Transmission System Capability and the Decision to Abolish the Snowy Region By Andrew Campbell, Stephen Wallace and Stuart Thorncraft Preamble With the recent decision to abolish
More informationAdvice June 2012
9.4.10.2 Advice June 2012 ECOREGION STOCK Widely distributed and migratory stocks Ling (Molva molva) in Division Va Advice for 2013 and 2014 Based on the ICES approach for data-limited stocks, ICES advises
More informationCNL(18)49. Guidelines for the Preparation and Evaluation of NASCO Implementation Plans and for Reporting on Progress
CNL(18)49 Guidelines for the Preparation and Evaluation of NASCO Implementation Plans and for Reporting on Progress 1. NASCO s Goals and Objectives NASCO and its Parties have agreed to adopt and apply
More informationFund Disbursement Strategy
Fund Disbursement Strategy Executive Summary The Trust has limited funds at its disposal and is constrained by its Constitution to use those funds in the most cost-effective way to ensure the attainment
More informationSCIENCE STRATEGY Considerations to guide DEEResearch in its industry-good investments
SCIENCE STRATEGY 2015-2020 Considerations to guide DEEResearch in its industry-good investments SCIENCE STRATEGY 2015-2020 1 CONTENTS OWNERSHIP, VERSION CONTROL AND DURATION 2 BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE 2
More informationPacific Oyster Mortality Syndrome OsHV-1 University of Sydney Technical Visit to New Zealand March 2012
Pacific Oyster Mortality Syndrome OsHV-1 University of Sydney Technical Visit to New Zealand 27-29 March 2012 Background The recent emergence of ostreid herpesvirus (OsHV1 µ-var) in both Australia and
More informationInforming Puget Sound steelhead recovery goals with a life cycle model
Informing Puget Sound steelhead recovery goals with a life cycle model March 2016 Phil Sandstrom 1, Joseph Anderson 1, Ken Currens 2, Neala Kendall 1, Jeff Hard 3, and Puget Sound Steelhead Recovery Team
More informationGENOMICS, FISHERIES & AQUACULTURE
GENOMICS, FISHERIES & AQUACULTURE MANAGING AND HARVESTING OUR WATER-BASED RESOURCES GENOMICS: A TRANSFORMATIVE TOOL GENOMICS: A TRANSFORMATIVE TOOL THE POTENTIAL FOR GENOMICS TO TRANSFORM OUR KEY INDUSTRIES
More informationOriginal language: English AC29 Doc CONVENTION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN ENDANGERED SPECIES OF WILD FAUNA AND FLORA
Original language: English AC29 Doc. 25.2 CONVENTION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN ENDANGERED SPECIES OF WILD FAUNA AND FLORA Twenty-ninth meeting of the Animals Committee Geneva (Switzerland), 18-22 July
More informationMarine Biodiversity and the Health of the Oceans
Marine Biodiversity and the Health of the Oceans... Dr. Paul Snelgrove University Research Professor...... Director, Canadian Health Oceans Network Memorial University, Newfoundland Canada. P. Archambault
More information