Oxford Historic Preservation Commission

Transcription

1 Oxford Historic Preservation Commission COA application: 365 Applicant: Address: COA Request: COA History: Andy Howorth 810 Lincoln Avenue 1. Front façade (north elevation) a) Enclose garage - remove garage doors/ replace with three windows b) Install stone veneer installed on existing porch and new planter c) Remove existing steps (west) on porch and relocate to front (north) 2. West elevation a) Remove two windows and one door b) Raise and replace with 3 single 3/1 windows, 1-double 3/1 window 8/ Case #223 Blake and Jamie Booth Approved Addition to the front porch Replace roof 1. Replace rot on front porch including cornice 2. Replace exterior lapboard 3. Replace doors 4. Replace windows Historic Preservation Ordinance References: Sec (2-3) Design Guideline References: 3/ Case #209 - Blake and Jamie Booth Approved 1. Removal and replacement of windows to front (forth) façade. 2. Removal of rear door and steps (south east) façade. 3. New asphalt shingle roof 4. Rear (south) addition to the residence to include an enclosed porch with metal roof and storage. Consultant Comments: SEE EXHIBIT A

2 A2H # February 2, 2016 Meeting Date: February 9, 2016 OHPC Case #365 COA for Andy Howorth Property Address: 810 Lincoln Avenue A2H PLLC Comments: 1. Alterations to north elevation: a. Enclose existing garage, remove door and replace with three windows to match existing: i. While the proposed changes to this elevation would result in a pleasing composition, they may do so at the detriment of the existing building s historic integrity. Given the building s massing, replacement of the garage door with windows would create a stronger sense of literal symmetry than what was present in the original design. The presence of a garage facing the street evidences the increased importance of the automobile at the time of the home s initial construction; removing this element would erase this part of the building s history. b. Install stone veneer on existing porch and new planter i. The proposed stone veneer would complement the recently modified front porch. While quarry tile was more common to porches on this style of house (and was present on the original porch of this home), its use here might confuse original elements with later additions. Images of the actual stone product should be submitted to determine their impact on the existing building; these new elements should stand out from, but not overwhelm, original details. c. Remove existing steps and relocate to front i. Since the existing porch has already been altered from its original condition, this change would not seriously alter the character of the building and therefore seems like an appropriate modification. 2. Alterations to west elevation: a. The modifications proposed for the west elevation would be nearly impossible to view from the street and would not dramatically alter the character of the existing building. For these reasons they appear to be appropriate changes to this property. Historic Preservation Ordinance references: Sec (1-3) Exhibit A Page 1 of 2

3 Design Guideline references: Section 6 New Construction New Additions to Historic Buildings Section 8 Outbuildings Section 11 Windows, Doors, Blinds, Awnings, and Canopies Section 14 Porches, Entrances, and Entry Steps A2H, PLLC Debbie Wilbanks Cherry, AIA, NCARB Senior Associate Principal Greg Morrison, Assoc. AIA Architectural Designer and Historic Preservationist Exhibit A Page 2 of 2

4 OXFORD HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APPLICATION 107 Courthouse Square, Oxford, MS I. APPLICANT INFORMATION: Name of Applicant: Phone: Applicant and/or Designated Agents address: Mailing Address: Applicant s Relationship to Property: Owner Architect Contractor Rent Name/Address of Owner: Name/Address of Architect: Name/Address of Contractor: II. FEE SCHEDULE: Fees shall be submitted with an application for Certificate of Appropriateness and are due 21 days before regularly scheduled Commission meetings. Minor alterations of less than $10, in total alteration costs... $25.00 Major alterations of more than $10, in total alteration costs. $ Demolition/removal of structure.. $75.00 New Construction. $ Preliminary Conference. No Charge WORK PERFORMED IN THE ABSENCE OF A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS WILL RESULT IN THE DOUBLING OF FEES OUTLINED ABOVE. III. PROPOSED WORK: (Please continue on a separate sheet of paper if necessary) Address of Property Subject to Application: Please provide a written description and photographs of each existing condition and each proposed modification. Plans and/or drawings of proposed work MUST accompany this application when filed. If request is for a demolition permit, indicate if the site is to remain vacant It is warranted in good faith that the statements above and on attached page(s) are true and correct. I understand that, if this application is approved, it becomes a part of the Certificate of Appropriateness and that I have received approval ONLY for the work specified herein, subject to any conditions or modification imposed by the Commission. I acknowledge that if the owner, contractor, or any subcontractor(s) constructs, alters, relocates, or demolishes any resource in violation of the City of Oxford Preservation Ordinance, it shall be required to restore the resource to its appearance or setting prior to the violation and that the City of Oxford may bring forth civil and/or criminal prosecution and penalties for such violation. I understand that no changes may be made to the approved drawings/plans or Certificate of Appropriateness application without prior approval from the Oxford Historic Preservation Commission and if such violation is found civil and/or criminal penalties may be brought forth for such violations. I understand that a CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS IS A PRE-REQUISITE TO OBTAINING A BUILDING PERMIT AND NO WORK MAY BEGIN UNTIL A BUILDING PERMIT IS OBTAINED. Applicant must sign: Date:

5 State of Mississippi Department of Archives and History P.O. Box 571 Jackson, MS HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY 1.a. Property Name, Historic 1.b. Property Name, Common 14. MDAH Inventory Code Lincoln Avenue Oxford 3. Legal Descri pti on 21. UTM Reference of associ ati on 23. Post Historic Changes 10, Architect 11. Bui lder/contractor 25. Architectural Style Spanish Colonial 13. Outbuildings or Secondary Features (use sep. form if important) 12. Brief Description: One-story, seven-bay, stucco veneered house with Spanish Colonial Revival influence, built ca Gable on hip roof central block covered with asphalt shingles and flush eaves, and flanking pavi 1 i ons with bui 1 t-up asphalt roof i ng behi nd pl ai n parapets topped with tile coping. Facade features a projecting exterior chimney stack and shamrock and sheild motifs on flanking wings. Windows are 2/2 metal frame replacement sashes, some -in pairs. One side pavilion encloses a two-bay 30, Historical Information: For unknown reasons, neither the 1925 nor the 1948 Sanborn map series indicated the development of residences along Lincoln Avenue west of South 11th Street. 31. Historical Contexts: 33. Sources of Information:

6 MISSISSIPPI HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY Page Additional Remarks or Information: #12, continued: garage. Entrance set beneath flat cantilevered hood and contains a multi-panel door with incised decorati ve panel sa 39. Form by Hopkins & Associates, Memphis, TN January, 2000 Attach Photograph MDAH INFORMATION 26. Category 27. Functional Type 28. Registration Status/Dates NHL Listed NR In NR District Federal DOE State Landmark Local Landmark In Local District HABS/HAER 29. District Name Rating G/N Inventory # C 42. Other HPD Information 43. Evaluation a. Already Listed NR Individually Eligible El i gi bl e i f Restored Contribute to District Apparent1 y Not El i gi bl e I nsuf f i ci ent I nf ormat i on Not Extant b. Area(s) of Significance c. Eva1 uated by/date

7

8

9

10

11

12 EXISTING NORTH ELEVATION EXISTING NORTH ELEVATION SHOWING EXISTING DRIVEWAY, GARAGE DOOR AND EXISTING PORCH STEPS EXISTING NORTH ELEVATION AT DRIVEWAY HOWORTH RESIDENCE 810 LINCOLN AVENUE OXFORD, MISSISSIPPI