Continuous Insulation Systems for Exterior Walls

Transcription

1 Continuous Insulation Systems for Exterior Walls High performance through sprayed-in-place foam insulation

2 Program Registration Icynene Inc. is a registered provider with The American Institute of Architects Continuing Education System. Credit earned upon completion of this program will be reported to CES Records for AIA members. Certificates of Completion are available for all course participants upon request. This program is registered with the AIA/CES for continuing professional education. As such, it does not include content that may be deemed or construed to be an approval or endorsement by the AIA or Icynene, Inc. of any material of construction or any method or manner of handling, using, distributing, or dealing in any material or product.

3 Copyright Materials This presentation is protected by US and international copyright laws. Reproduction, distribution, display and use of the presentation without written permission of the speaker is strictly prohibited.

4 Learning Objectives Identify Investigate Assess Recognize Identify the characteristics of high-performance spray foam continuously insulated exterior wall assemblies. Investigate the numerous opportunities to use spray foam insulation to achieve thermal performance goals. Assess the ability of spray foam insulation to act as an effective air sealing barrier that prevents unwanted air infiltration. Recognize the ways that thermal bridging can be thwarted in wall assemblies using continuous spray foam insulation.

5 Course Outline Section 3: Thermal Resistance with Spray Foam Insulation Section 4: Air Sealing with Spray Foam Insulation Section 2: Spray Foam Insulation Design Considerations Section 5: Controlling Thermal Bridging Section 1: Spray Foam Insulation Overview SECTIONS Conclusion

6 SECTION 1 Section 1: Spray Foam Insulation Overview Section 2: Spray Foam Insulation Design Considerations Section 3: Thermal Resistance with Spray Foam Insulation Section 4: Air Sealing with Spray Foam Insulation Section 5: Controlling Thermal Bridging Conclusion

7 Traditional Insulation Options When selecting building insulation, architects have a broad range of products to choose from. EXTRUDED POLYSTYRENE FOAM BOARD CELLULOSE FIBER FIBERGLASS

8 The Spray Foam Insulation Option Performs as whole building insulation Simultaneously provides insulation and air barrier in one product Controls air leakage and interstitial condensation Can bond to adjacent framing components to form an integral part of a total wall system

9 What is Spray Foam? Site applied material Liquid components are poured or sprayed in place Combined ingredients expand into a foam plastic material that insulates and air seals

10 Typical Custom On-site Application High Pressure Foam Truck Based Spray Rigs Product sold in sets of two 55 gallon drums A Side: ISO standard formulation B Side: Manufacturer s own formulation that determines a multitude of performance characteristics

11 More than just R-values Because of this full custom onsite application, spray foam insulation is generally found to be effective at boosting the energy performance of wall assemblies in multiple ways.

12 Spray Foam Insulation General Characteristics What is driving the increasing popularity of spray foam wall assemblies? Spray foam fills spaces completely Spray foam holds its shape over time - sagging, settling, gaps or voids are eliminated Air infiltration / leakage is reduced or controlled

13 All Spray Foam is not created Equal A-Side (ISO) Isocyanate Polymeric MDI (pmdi) B-Side (Resin) Polyols, Catalysts Surfactants Flame Retardants Water, Blowing Agent All foams are not the same Manufacturers material selections make foam systems very different Materials are not compatible from system to system or from one manufacturer to the next. Resin dictates physical properties (rise, yield, operating temps, water absorption etc.)

14 Two Common Types of Spray Foam Insulation 1. Medium Density Closed Cell make-up Hard, rigid foam 2. Low Density Open Cell make-up Soft, flexible foam

15 Low Density Open Cell Insulation Uses: both residential and commercial applications Weight - Low Density: one half pound per cubic foot R- Value: per inch

16 Low Density Open Cell Characteristics Typical blowing agent: Water Suitable for Interior Installations: cavity wall covered by sheathing on both sides Air sealing: softer makeup allows effective air sealing Movement: will flex and adjust as the building may settle expand or contract Acoustic control is enhanced Very favorable cost benefits, particularly when compared to labor and material for other types of insulation Life Cycle Analysis is also favorable with relatively short payback times

17 Low Density Open Cell Characteristics (cont d) Vapor permeability: Does NOT seal against water vapor, rather allowing it to pass through Vapor barrier needed in wall assemblies in cold climates (e.g. vapor retardant paint) Verify vapor permeability with manufacturers Vapor permeability means any water in assembly can dry out Mold: Material is not a food source for mold

18 Medium Density Closed Cell Insulation Uses: both residential and commercial applications Weight - Medium Density: 2 lbs. per cubic foot R-Value: per inch High Density is also available at 3 lbs. per cu. ft. mostly used in commercial roofing applications (both retrofit and new construction)

19 Medium Density Closed Cell Characteristics Blowing Agent: Dedicated, captive agent or Water Blowing Agent Suitable for both Interior and Exterior Installations: cavity walls, exterior continuous insulation Air Barrier: Serves as a full air barrier eliminating the need for a separate product to perform that function. According to the Air Barrier Association of America (ABAA), many medium-density spray foam insulations are classified as air barrier materials Vapor Barrier: Tests as a class II vapor retarder meaning it has very low permeability

20 Medium Density Closed Cell Characteristics (cont d) Rigidity: Stronger, more resistant to construction impacts Water Resistant Approved by FEMA as a flood-resistant material Does not provide food source for mold growth Continuity: Can be applied as continuous insulation outside of studs and sheathing and covered over with facade material

21 Medium Density Closed Cell Cost Benefit Achieves higher R-values in thinner wall assemblies Superior alternative to rigid foam board panels. One product provides multiple functions: insulation, air barrier, vapor barrier - no additional paint, membrane, or other material (joint tape, etc) is needed beyond this insulation Rigid and durable enough to be between masonry wythes or behind a masonry veneer

22 Spray Foam Insulation Re-cap Soft, flexible foam Half pound (½ lb.) / cu. ft. Water blowing agent Open Cell R per inch Permits drying Allows water to drain Rejects water at the surface Low Density Hard, rigid foam Two pound (2 lb.) / cu. ft. Captive blowing agent or Water blowing agent Closed Cell R per inch Barrier to vapor Barrier to bulk water Recognized by FEMA for use in flood zones Medium Density

23 General Cost Comparison Typically low density open cell insulation will cost less than medium density closed cell insulation for the same overall R-value since fewer drums are required Medium Density closed cell will require thinner wall assemblies for that R- value however and may be a more economical wall system overall Typical Usage for the Same Interior Space of the Building Project: Drums of Open Cell Insulation Required Drums of Closed Cell Insulation Required

24 SECTION 2 Section 1: Spray Foam Insulation Overview Section 2: Spray Foam Insulation Design Considerations Section 3: Thermal Resistance with Spray Foam Insulation Section 4: Air Sealing with Spray Foam Insulation Section 5: Controlling Thermal Bridging Conclusion

25 Fire Resistance and NFPA testing IBC requires exterior wall systems with foam plastic insulation of any type must pass NFPA 285 NFPA 285 is a test of the entire assembly, and not just of the component materials Details of the test assembly and materials identified in Chapter 26 of the IBC, Section Common assemblies use a 15 minute thermal barrier (gypsum board) separating foam from interior In exterior wall assembly, ASTM E119 may also be required for the assembly Containment within assembly is needed Review manufacturer data closely

26 Environmental Considerations Spray foam insulations require blowing agents - some agents are better for the environment than others. Blowing agents can be rated based on their Global Warming Potential (GWP). Carbon dioxide has a GWP rating of 1. Spray foam insulation using only water and carbon dioxide blowing agents also have a GWP rating of 1. Several low-density and one medium-density spray foam product meets this level.

27 Environmental Considerations (cont d) All rigid foam insulation and most medium-density closed cell spray foam insulation rely on blowing agents other than water and carbon dioxide. GWP rating can be very high up to around 1,430 due to its hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) make-up. Hence, some insulation contains greenhouse gas that is 1,430 times more potent than carbon dioxide. Environmental impact occurs only if it actually gets released into the air. When using closed cell spray foam insulation, seek out and specify a product with the lowest possible HFC content and the lowest possible GWP.

28 Construction Considerations Any field-applied building product is directly dependent on the experience and qualifications of the installer Use trained and certified installers Variable field conditions need to be addressed: o o o air temperature condition of the substrates installer needs to understand and adjust to field conditions There will likely be some overspray or airborne spray that needs to be contained Protect the surrounding surfaces

29 SECTION 3 Section 1: Spray Foam Insulation Overview Section 2: Spray Foam Insulation Design Considerations Section 3: Thermal Resistance with Spray Foam Insulation Section 4: Air Sealing with Spray Foam Insulation Section 5: Controlling Thermal Bridging Conclusion

30 Stud Cavity Batt Insulation Traditional approach is for batt type insulation to be placed between the framing members Insulation settles and sags over time or is loose to begin with Performance is lower as a result

31 Stud Cavity Batt Insulation The batt insulation is also often compromised due to compression by mechanical, plumbing, or electrical components embedded within the same stud cavity.

32 Stud Cavity Spray Foam Insulation Spray foam insulation overcomes these thermal issues Field applied against sheathing, it fills the cavity space completely, assuring the full thermal value Result is a more effective full R- value from the spray foam than compromised R-value for batt insulation

33 Stud Wall Insulation Limitations Stud cavity insulation systems do not provide continuous insulation across a wall assembly o Recurring thermal bridges at each of the studs Energy codes and green building standards recognize that steel studs in particular have real performance limitations due to these thermal bridges They look at overall calculated U-factor of the total assembly and either: o Set the required insulation R-values higher o Or require a maximum U-factor of the total assembly be achieved

34 Stud Wall Insulation Limitations ASHRAE 90.1 includes some very clear correction factors for thermal performance calculations EXAMPLE: A metal stud wall with 6-inch studs at 16-inch o.c. with insulation rated at R-3.5 per inch or a total of approximately R-21 Stud wall is approx. 20 percent stud and track faces and only 80 percent solid insulation This ratio compromises the overall effective wall R-value by as much as 65 percent AHSRAE 90.1 assigns a total working value for this assembly of only R- 7.4 (U-factor of 0.135) or about a third of the insulation R-value

35 Exterior Continuous Insulation Another approach: use continuous insulation on the outside of the stud wall framing and sheathing. It stops the heat transfer occurring at each stud. Continuous insulation allows every inch to be fully effective without compromises. This continuous insulation (ci) is recognized in codes. The temperature difference across the studs is less thus reducing the rate of heat transfer.

36 Combination Wall Assembly A combination of low-density open cell spray foam insulation between steel studs and a continuous layer of medium-density closed cell spray foam insulation outside of the sheathing creates an exterior wall with superior thermal performance.

37 Combination Wall Performance Comparative Example A nominal 4 inch stud wall filled with low-density spray foam insulation of R-3.5 per inch or approx. R-13 Added 2 layer of medium-density spray foam insulation on the outside at R-6.9 per inch adds approx. R-14 Combined wall assembly total R-value is approx. R-27 in the same total wall thickness as a 6 inch stud wall that only delivered the approximately R-21 Result is superior performance without increasing assembly thickness

38 Continuous Insulation Impact Thermal bridging at studs effect is dramatically reduced Energy codes recognize the higher overall U-factor of the wall assembly Directly improves the overall energy performance of wall and building Contributes energy cost savings of the building

39 Covering Continuous Insulation Exterior layer of spray foam insulation is covered with wall façade treatment of choice Attachment anchors installed to the sheathing before the spray foam insulation is applied The final wall appearance and design is not limited by spray foam use

40 Masonry Wall Applications A continuous layer of medium-density closed cell spray foam insulation in a traditional masonry wall provides durability, thermal resistance and air sealing performance.

41 Masonry Wall Construction Traditional method still applies: erect CMU wall, apply masonry ties, install insulation, install the masonry veneer The mason can focus on masonry and an insulation installer can focus on spray foam insulation

42 Masonry Wall Veneer Spray foam insulation can be used to completely fill and seal around brick ties and other irregularities in conventional construction.

43 SECTION 4 Section 1: Spray Foam Insulation Overview Section 2: Spray Foam Insulation Design Considerations Section 3: Thermal Resistance with Spray Foam Insulation Section 4: Air Sealing with Spray Foam Insulation Section 5: Controlling Thermal Bridging Conclusion

44 Air Sealing Significance U.S. Department of Energy and others have shown air infiltration is equally significant to the insulating R-values for overall energy performance in a building. The International Energy Conservation Construction Code and many standards now include air sealing requirements.

45 Air Sealing Approach Traditional approach adds an air barrier to the outside of the sheathing and taping seams This approach is less than perfect - subject to gaps, tears, and incomplete coverage around openings, penetrations, etc. Continuous layer of spray foam insulation on the outside of the wall sheathing overcomes these shortcomings Spray foam prevents air from moving through it Covers irregular places where sheet goods may not Continuous spray means no seams or junctions

46 Batt Insulation and Air Sealing Conventional fibrous batt insulation allows for air to pass through it It is a misperception that it is a way to seal up a wall assembly It is not accurate that stuffing an opening, gap, or void with fibrous batt insulation will help seal off any air leaks

47 Convection Air Currents Stud cavities are prone to convection currents inside Includes stud cavities with batt insulation Currents create an internal thermal air flow cycle Warm wall surface heats air adjacent to it inside stud cavity Warmed air rises to top, pulling cool air Warm air cools and descends This air current transfers heat directly through the cavity wall reduces performance Process is same in all seasons, just on different wall faces

48 Convection Air Currents and Insulation Convection currents reduce performance of fibrous insulation Energy needed to operate the HVAC system increases due to the poor performance of the batt insulation in the wall Spray foam insulation in a stud cavity stops convection currents Filling the stud cavity fully with spray foam insulation prevents convection currents from occurring Delivers full performance of the wall insulation Even partially filling cavity with foam will be airtight and convection currents will not be able to form

49 SECTION 5 Section 1: Spray Foam Insulation Overview Section 2: Spray Foam Insulation Design Considerations Section 3: Thermal Resistance with Spray Foam Insulation Section 4: Air Sealing with Spray Foam Insulation Section 5: Controlling Thermal Bridging Conclusion

50 Thermal Bridging at Floors Insulated walls rest on multiple floors of building Insulation in the wall studs is interrupted typically stops above and below the floor structure This is a very significant thermal bridge Concrete and metal deck floors are typically 4 6 thick and wood floors much thicker Floor edge is exposed along the full length and width of the building.

51 Continuous Spray Foam at Floor Edges Use continuous insulation across floor edges as part of overall insulation scheme Spray foam insulation both boosts the performance of stud walls and combats floor edge thermal bridge. Affects the entire height of the building across multiple floors on all sides Dramatically increases the performance of the overall building

52 Thermal Bridging at Structural Elements Studs are not often the primary structure, rather a steel frame or concrete system is used Un-insulated structural elements are direct thermal short circuits just like floor slabs Infrared photo showing warm air (bright) leaking out at column enclosure. Applies to in line structure and corner conditions

53 Continuous Spray Foam at Structure Continuous spray foam insulation applied outside of the corners and the structure of a building stops thermal bridging there.

54 Thermal Bridging at Irregular Places Spray foam insulation can fill and seal in and around areas that are difficult or complicated for other insulation systems.

55 Thermal Bridging Significance Significance of thermal bridging cannot be overstated. Thermal performance in a typical building construction without continuous insulation is compromised more than just 20 percent example in stud wall construction. Floor edges, structural components, and parapets bring total uninsulated areas up to 30, 40, or even 50 percent of facades. Continuous insulation integrated over all of these areas significantly impacts actual energy performance comfort of its occupants.

56 CONCLUSION Section 1: Spray Foam Insulation Overview Section 2: Spray Foam Insulation Design Considerations Section 3: Thermal Resistance with Spray Foam Insulation Section 4: Air Sealing with Spray Foam Insulation Section 5: Controlling Thermal Bridging Conclusion

57 Conclusion 1. Spray foam insulation offers a complete energy performance solution 2. Stud cavities can be completely filled with low-density open cell spray foam insulation providing thermal resistance, air sealing, and elimination of convection air currents 3. Continuous insulation (ci) provided with medium-density closed cell spray foam also provides complete air and vapor barrier 4. Continuous spray foam insulation covers over all energy draining thermal bridges 5. End result is a total high performance wall assembly consistent with any architectural design approach 6. Building owner reaps benefits of energy cost savings and longevity of building

58 Continuous Insulation Systems for Exterior Walls High performance through sprayed-in-place foam insulation Questions? Thank You for Attending! This concludes the American Institute of Architects Continuing Education System Program