ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE DELIVERY AND OPERATIONS DIVISION CONTRACTS AND SPECIFICATIONS SECTION TABULATION OF BIDS

Transcription

1 ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE DELIVERY AND OPERATIONS DIVISION CONTRACTS AND SPECIFICATIONS SECTION TABULATION OF BIDS CONTRACT # TRACS No. Project No. County District Gross Length Net Length Prepared By: 0000 CN FLA SZ12301C FLA-0-(219)T LOCAL COCONINO CENTRAL 1.7 Jedidiah Young Highway Termini Location Work Description CITY OF FLAGSTAFF EL PASO FLAGSTAFF RD TO FOREST PAVEMENT REHABILITATION

2 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 1 of 9 BID RESULTS FOR Bid Opening Date : 12/16/2016, Prequalification Required, Engineer Specialist : Jedidiah Young Completion Date: 120 Working Days The proposed work is located in Coconino County, in the City of Flagstaff, on Frontage Road 40 (Old Historic Route 66) between El Paso Flagstaff Road to Forest Road 791. The work consists of removing damaged PCCP slabs and replacing them with aggregate base and asphaltic concrete. Additional work includes milling and overlaying asphaltic concrete, striping, and other miscellaneous work. Bid Rank Department Estimate Bid Amount Contractor Extended Sum of s 1-9.4% $1,270, % $1,277, % $1,402, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C HECKETHORN ROAD FLAGSTAFF, AZ SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING 3002 S. PRIEST DRIVE TEMPE, AZ DEPARTMENT ESTIMATE $1,270, $1,277, $1,402, % $1,410, % $1,437, COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. P.O. BOX GLENDALE, AZ FANN CONTRACTING, INC PO BOX 4356 PRESCOTT, AZ $1,410, $1,437, Winning Bidder is 9.4% Under Department Estimate (Difference = ($132,067.60))

3 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 2 of SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (1" to 1-1/2") Bid Rank Department Estimate 16, $2.000 $33, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $1.200 $20, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $1.400 $23, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $1.800 $30, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $1.000 $16, % SQ.YD. REMOVE (FULL PCCP SLAB) Bid Rank Department Estimate 4, $ $87, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $97, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $69, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $106, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $100, % SQ.FT. REMOVE (PARTIAL PCCP SLAB) Bid Rank Department Estimate 4, $ $47, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $4.450 $20, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $2.000 $9, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $4.500 $21, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $5.000 $23, % L.FT. REMOVE LEAD-BASED STRIPING Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $6.000 $9, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $1.000 $1, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $16, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $9.000 $14, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $7.500 $12, % L.SUM DISPOSE OF LEAD-BASED PAINT MATERIALS (FORCE ACCOUNT) Bid Rank Department Estimate $5, $5, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $5, $5, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $5, $5, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $5, $5, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $5, $5, % L.FT. SHOULDER BUILD-UP (MILLED AC) Bid Rank Department Estimate 15, $0.800 $12, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.330 $5, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.250 $3, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.180 $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.500 $7, %

4 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 3 of HOUR SHOULDER BUILD-UP (COMPACTION) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $3, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $2, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $3, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $7, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $2, % SQ.YD. GRADING ROADWAY FOR PAVEMENT Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $3, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $3, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $6.500 $1, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $4, % CU.YD. AGGREGATE BASE, CLASS 2 Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $62, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $63, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $69, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $60, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $64, % TON BITUMINOUS TACK COAT Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $5, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $2, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $4, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $6, % HOUR APPLY BITUMINOUS TACK COAT Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $4, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $6, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $4, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $5, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $4, % TON ASPHALT BINDER (PG 70-22) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $112, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $107, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $76, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $106, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $117, %

5 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 4 of TON ASPHALT BINDER (PG TR+) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $90, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $102, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $93, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $97, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $112, % TON ASPHALTIC CONCRETE (END PRODUCT) (3/4 MIX) (PG 70-22)) Bid Rank Department Estimate 4, $ $269, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $269, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $262, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $269, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $287, % TON ASPHALTIC CONCRETE (END PRODUCT) (1/2 MIX) (PG TR+)) Bid Rank Department Estimate 3, $ $195, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $192, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $178, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $184, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $192, % TON MINERAL ADMIXTURE Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $6, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $6, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $6, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $6, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $6, % L.FT. TEMPORARY PAINTED MARKING (STRIPE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 29, $0.100 $2, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.100 $2, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.110 $3, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.110 $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.150 $4, % EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE II, VERT.PANEL, TUBULAR MARKER) Bid Rank Department Estimate 9, $0.300 $2, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.130 $1, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.120 $1, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.150 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.200 $1, %

6 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 5 of EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE III, HIGH LEVEL FLAG TREES) Bid Rank Department Estimate $0.500 $ C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.280 $ % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.360 $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.320 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.400 $ % EACH-DAY PORTABLE SIGN STANDS (SPRING TYPE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $0.600 $ C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.440 $ % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.400 $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.500 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.500 $ % EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE A) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $0.250 $ C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.140 $ % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.150 $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.150 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.200 $ % EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE B) Bid Rank Department Estimate $0.500 $ C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.500 $ % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.240 $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.570 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.750 $ % EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE C) Bid Rank Department Estimate 5, $0.300 $1, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.220 $1, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.180 $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.250 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.250 $1, % EACH-DAY TRUCK MOUNTED ATTENUATOR Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $3, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $1, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $1, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $4, %

7 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 6 of EACH-DAY TEMPORARY SIGN (LESS THAN 10 S.F.) Bid Rank Department Estimate 2, $0.600 $1, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.440 $ % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.300 $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.500 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.500 $1, % EACH-DAY TEMPORARY SIGN (10 S.F. OR MORE) Bid Rank Department Estimate $0.700 $ C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.500 $ % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.400 $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.550 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $1.500 $ % EACH-DAY FLASHING ARROW PANEL Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $ C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $ % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $ % EACH-DAY CHANGEABLE MESSAGE BOARD (CONTRACTOR FURNISHED) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $3, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $1, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $4, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $2, % HOUR PILOT VEHICLE WITH DRIVER Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $28, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $33, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $43, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $40, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $29, % HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (CIVILIAN) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $ $43, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $40, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $46, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $56, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $40, %

8 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 7 of HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (LOCAL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $ $93, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $103, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $122, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $82, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $109, % EACH PAVEMENT MARKING, PREFORMED, SYMBOL, TYPE I/IV Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $1, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $2, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $2, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $2, % L.FT. PERMANENT PAVEMENT MARKING (PAINTED) (WHITE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 16, $0.200 $3, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.100 $1, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.110 $1, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.120 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.120 $1, % L.FT. PERMANENT PAVEMENT MARKING (PAINTED) (YELLOW) Bid Rank Department Estimate 12, $0.200 $2, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.100 $1, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.110 $1, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.120 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.120 $1, % L.FT. DUAL COMPONENT PAVEMENT MARKING (WHITE EPOXY) Bid Rank Department Estimate 24, $0.350 $8, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.220 $5, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.250 $6, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.240 $5, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.250 $6, % L.FT. DUAL COMPONENT PAVEMENT MARKING (YELLOW EPOXY) Bid Rank Department Estimate 12, $0.350 $4, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.220 $2, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.250 $3, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.240 $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.250 $3, %

9 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 8 of SQ.YD. EROSION CONTROL (STABILIZED CONSTRUCTION ENTRANCE/EXIT GRAVEL PAD) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $3, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $ $1, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $ $2, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $ $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $4, % L.FT. EROSION CONTROL (WATTLES) (9") Bid Rank Department Estimate $2.000 $ C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $3.500 $ % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $6.500 $ % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.700 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $5.000 $ % L.SUM MOBILIZATION Bid Rank Department Estimate $140, $140, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $74, $74, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $119, $119, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $160, $160, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $170, $170, % L.SUM FORCE ACCOUNT WORK (SEALING CRACKS IN PCCP) Bid Rank Department Estimate $18, $18, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $18, $18, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $18, $18, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $18, $18, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $18, $18, % L.SUM CONTRACTOR QUALITY CONTROL Bid Rank Department Estimate $17, $17, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $16, $16, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $15, $15, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $30, $30, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $25, $25, % SQ.YD. MISCELLANEOUS WORK (CONTROL OF NOXIOUS PLANTS)(MANUAL/MECHANICAL METHODS) Bid Rank Department Estimate 64, $0.550 $35, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.390 $24, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.400 $25, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.360 $23, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.400 $25, %

10 Printed: 3/21/2017 Page 9 of SQ.YD. MISCELLANEOUS WORK (CONTROL OF NOXIOUS PLANTS)(HERBICIDE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 79, $0.350 $27, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $0.280 $22, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $0.200 $15, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $0.200 $15, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.200 $15, % L.SUM CONSTRUCTION SURVEYING AND LAYOUT Bid Rank Department Estimate $10, $10, C AND E PAVING & GRADING L.L.C. $4, $4, % 2 SUNLAND, INC. ASPHALT & SEAL COATING $10, $10, % 3 COMBS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. $29, $29, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $5, $5, %