Impacts of climate change in European forests and options for adaptation

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Impacts of climate change in European forests and options for adaptation"

Joshua Ray
6 years ago
Views:

1 Marcus Lindner and Marja Kolström Impacts of climate change in European forests and options for adaptation Report to the European Commission Directorate-General for Agriculture and Rural Development (AGRI-2007-G4-06) Joensuu Forestry Networking Week 2009

2 Objectives of the study Synthesise the existing knowledge about observed and projected impacts of climate change on forests in Europe Review the capacity of forests and forestry to adapt to climate change (adaptive capacity) Analyse vulnerability of forests and forestry to climate change in different European regions Review potential adaptation strategies and to survey existing and planned measures in EU member states

3 Forest typology Potential impacts of climate change differ between bioclimatic zones and forest types in Europe. Forest typology: EEA forest types (EEA 2006) linked with the Bioclimatic map of Europe (Rivas-Martínez et al., 2004) Selected bioclimates: o Boreal o Temperate Oceanic o Temperate Continental o Mediterranean Mountainous regions are accounted as a separate region

4 Methodological assessment framework Climate change exposure for each region Sensitivity to the key impact factors for each region Key Impact Factors depending on the region Potential Impacts on the capacity of forest to provide goods and services (i.e. Wood production, Non wood products etc..) for each region Adaptive capacity of forests and forestry for each region: Inherent adaptive capacity of forests Socio economic adaptive capacity Vulnerability of forests and forestry to climate change Impact Factors: CO2 or Temperature or Precipitation or Abiotic disturb. or Biotic disturbances

Impact Factors: Atmospheric CO 2 increase Increases photosynthesis rates Increases water use efficiency Species show variable responses Very important effects in water limited areas

5 Impact Factors: Atmospheric CO 2 increase Increases photosynthesis rates Increases water use efficiency Species show variable responses Very important effects in water limited areas like Mediterranean regions, less important in Northern latitudes FACE Experiment assessing effects of increased CO 2 levels on the structure and function of northern forest ecosystems

Impact Factors: Changes in Temperature (T) and Precipitation (P) Temperature effects can be positive or negative depending on environmental conditions in the region Higher T with sufficient P may

6 Impact Factors: Changes in Temperature (T) and Precipitation (P) Temperature effects can be positive or negative depending on environmental conditions in the region Higher T with sufficient P may improve growth Rising T without increase in P or decreasing P can lead to drought and thus reduce growth Some species more sensitive than others. In Mediterranean conditions most species will suffer from droughts

Impact Factors: Abiotic disturbances (wind, snow, fire) Extreme weather patterns (drought, flooding, wind storms) are projected to intensify and will have

age-structures Fire can have several detrimental effects on soil, e.g. loss of nutrients through volatilisation, leaching and erosion Broken and uprooted

7 Impact Factors: Abiotic disturbances (wind, snow, fire) Extreme weather patterns (drought, flooding, wind storms) are projected to intensify and will have several direct and indirect impacts Fire and wind damage affect forest productivity, partial or complete loss of wood and cause imbalanced stand age-structures Fire can have several detrimental effects on soil, e.g. loss of nutrients through volatilisation, leaching and erosion Broken and uprooted trees left in forest are breeding material for insects which cause secondary damage Harvesting salvaged wood is dangerous and expensive and the large volumes distorts markets

Impact Factors: Biotic disturbances Direct effects on

in life-cycles and suitable habitats See following

quality, plant presentation by resistance or

increase the incidence of pest outbreaks o Higher

8 Impact Factors: Biotic disturbances Direct effects on target species (herbivores and pathogens) o Changes in life-cycles and suitable habitats See following Indirect effects through changes in plant nutritional quality, plant presentation by resistance or community interactions Sigrid Netherer o Storm events increase the incidence of pest outbreaks o Higher probability of open tree wounds allows the entry of pathogen species

9 Impact Factors Summary Not all the impact factors are negative Impacts depend also on the region analysed Impact Factor Positive Impacts Negative Impacts Temperature Growth in Northern EU Growth in Mediterranean region Difficulties to forest management operations in Boreal region CO 2 or Precipitation Biotic disturbances Abiotic disturbances Water use efficiency Forest growth P in the north will increase forest growth - P in Southern areas will increase droughts and forest productivity - Forest productivity - Fires specially in Mediterranean region will forest productivity and erosion

10 CC Sensitivity and Potential Impacts in Europe + forest growth abiotic and biotic disturbances difficult winter harvesting +/ forest growth wind and fire disturbances? Shifting species composition +/ forest growth wind and fire disturbances? Shifting species composition forest growth fire disturbances erosion risk

11 Adaptive Capacity (1) Adaptive capacity has two components: 1. Inherent adaptive capacity of trees and forest ecosystems Evolutionary mechanisms and processes that permit tree species to adjust to new conditions See following presentation by Antoine Kremer Maintaining and improving the genetic adaptive capacity of populations and species is important in long term

12 Adaptive Capacity (2) 2. Socioeconomic factors determining the ability to implement adaptation measures Includes o economic development o technology and infrastructure o information, knowledge and skills o institutions o equity o social capital Has rarely been analysed in EU27 up to now

13 The adaptive capacity in the forest sector Relatively large Relatively large More strongly affected by socio-economic constraints Limited Large forest areas are only extensively managed or unmanaged

14 Vulnerability of forests the degree to which a system is susceptible to be affected by adverse effects of climate change is influenced by the climate variation to which this system is exposed (sensitivity, adaptive capacity)

15 Very few European studies have assessed climate change vulnerability of the forest sector In northern Europe: the importance of globalisation and other socio-economic changes superseding vulnerability to climate change (Keskitalo, 2008, Rees et al., 2008) Mountain forests in Austria: highly vulnerable under the current management regime (productivity and forest health decreased significantly) (Seidl et al., 2009)

16 Climate Change Impacts and Vulnerability of European forests - Conclusions Rich literature on climate change sensitivity and potential impacts, but not all regions are well covered (at least in accessible literature) Adaptive capacity rarely studied systematically Vulnerability assessments of ecosystem goods and services urgently needed in most regions

17 Study on impacts of climate change on European forests and options for adaptation Service Contract with DG Agriculture (Dec 07 Nov 08) Review of potential adaptation options for each of the region Evaluation of adaptation measures regarding: Feasibility Reliability Cost effectiveness Survey compiling existing and planned national strategies for adapting to climate change Contrasting results PART 2 Conclusions and recommendations for potential adaptation options for forests and forestry in the EU27

18 Adaptation strategies should aim to increase the flexibility in management of vulnerable ecosystems enhance the inherent adaptability of the species and ecosystem processes reduce trends in environmental and social pressures that increase vulnerability to climate variability (Hulme, P.E. 2005, J. Appl. Ecology 42, ) Reducing vulnerability involves both a reduction to the exposure to climate stress and an increase in adaptive capacity (J.-E. Parry et al. 2005)

19 Adaptation strategies at different levels Level of action Adaptation actions Stand level Forest management forest regeneration tending and thinning of stands harvesting management planning forest protection Policy level infrastructure and transport nurseries and forest tree breeding further adaptation options in risk management and policy

20 Adaptation measures review Scientific perspective expert assessment based on review of literature Ongoing and planned measures in EU member states questionnaire to Ministeries and national research institutes

susceptibility to disturbances Photo University of Tuscia Harvesting activites should take place at smaller

21 Adaptation measures Stand level In regeneration species and genetic composition of the stand gets established, diversity builds up and can be manipulated Tending and thinning improves stand structure to reduce stand susceptibility to disturbances Photo University of Tuscia Harvesting activites should take place at smaller scales; development of machinery is important to secure accessibility on wet soils Photo North Karelia Collage, Valtimo

decision support systems Forest protection benefits from establishing and

22 Adaptation measures Forest management level Forest management planning should be flexible and adaptive; high need for monitoring, co-operation, decision support systems Forest protection benefits from establishing and sustaining forest ecosystems highly diverse in tree composition, age and structure

regeneration Development and evaluation of adaptation strategies should be a participative process Quercus

23 Adaptation measures Policy level Infrastructure and transporting; restoring groundwater regimes, improving irrigation systems and road network Nurseries and tree breeding should produce well-adapted material for regeneration Development and evaluation of adaptation strategies should be a participative process Quercus ilex, photo T. La Mantia More research is needed to expand the knowledge base related to adaptive forest management strategies

24 Analysis of questionnaire answers More than 1000 adaptation measures have been identified Similar measures have been combined and grouped

25 Boreal region Earlier and stronger thinnings Shorter rotation periods Better harvesting techniques on non-frozen soils Photo: K. Sjoberg

26 Temperate Oceanic region Adapt management to increased disturbance risk Choose better adapted species and provenances Close-to-nature forestry vs. exotic plantation species Photo: T. Standovar

27 Temperate Continental region Afforestation facing new difficulties Choose drought tolerant species and provenances Close-to-nature forestry, more stable stand structures Photo: A. Barbati

28 Mediterranean region Coordinated response to increased fire risk Management for better drought tolerance Research on genetic diversity Photo: P. Corona Photo: A. Barbati

forest cover to sustain ecosystem goods and services The

29 Mountainous regions Promote small scale management Increase stability of stands against stressors and disturbances Maintain forest cover to sustain ecosystem goods and services The protective function against natural hazards and erosion is of particular importance

30 Preparedness to the CC challenge Main motive of adaptation Measure available? Preparedness Minimize impacts of disturbances Ensure wood production Ensure ecosystem services?

31 Proposed adaptation measures; trade-offs? Biodiversity - to decrease risk of pests or fire (old trees, decaying wood) Utilisation of increased growth carbon storage (rotation length) Current climate projected future climate (selecting reproductive material )

32 Do strategies match the challenge of climate change? Many measures are focusing on reducing disturbance risks Very little attention on potential benefits Risk management how to adapt to unprecedented climate change?

33 Needs to increase awareness More research is needed, especially on how/when to change species/provenances under changing climate Dissemination of information is important (Foresters, forest owners, decision makers)

34 Who needs support to implement adaptation measures? Forest goods and services are important particularly in rural areas In regions with active forest management, forest owners need support to adapt management practices in regeneration, tending of stands, and early thinnings In the Mediterranean region, communities need support to secure forest ecosystem services (ecosystem approach)

35 Conclusions Climate change poses great risks, but also some opportunities Suitable adaptation measures differ between regions Adaptive capacity is much higher in the Boreal and Temperate Oceanic regions The Mediterranean and Temperate Continental regions are most vulnerable and require specific support

36 Study outputs Report Factsheets Technical Annexes

Ricardo Reguera BOKU: Michael Maroschek, Rupert Seidl, Manfred J.

37 Thank you for your attention! Authors: EFI: Marcus Lindner, Jordi Garcia-Gonzalo, Marja Kolström, Tim Green, Ricardo Reguera BOKU: Michael Maroschek, Rupert Seidl, Manfred J. Lexer BOKU: Sigrid Netherer, Axel Schopf INRA: Antoine Kremer, Sylvain Delzon IAFS: Anna Barbati, Marco Marchetti, Piermaria Corona Contact:

Impacts of Climate Change on European Forests and Options for Adaptation

Impacts of Climate Change on European Forests and Options for Adaptation AGRI-2007-G4-06 Report to the European Commission Directorate-General for Agriculture and Rural Development Authors: European Forest