Universal Service and State Aid in the European Union in the Era of NGN

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Universal Service and State Aid in the European Union in the Era of NGN"

Bennett Payne
5 years ago
Views:

1 Q,35*-,&M-509#, 2 Universal Service and State Aid in the European Union in the Era of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n 1 K=*'/:'#5#%'*(&%*&%L/#&%5*.0*'/330&.*.6%*"%.70&;8**!"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*30)#+#%'*(&%*&%L/#&%5*.0*<&07*.6%*"%.70&;* :%40"5*.6%*3&#$(.%*03.#2/2*Jn 2 K=*76%&%*2(&<#"()*+0'.*%L/()'* 2(&<#"()*/.#)#.48**C#2#)(&)4=*:%40"5*(*+%&.(#"*%-#.*30#".*Jn 3 K=* '/:'#5#%'*(&%*(<(#"*&%L/#&%5*.0*'/330&.*.6%*"%.70&;8 [K In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

4 n 1 n 2 n 3 Y/"5#"<*S*1&02*.6%*3&0+%%5'*01*3&#$(.#_(.#0"*("5*'3%+.&/2* )#+%"'%*1%%'8 I0$%&"2%".*1/"5#"<*S*$#(*<%"%&()*.(-(.#0"*&%$%"/%8!"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%'*(&%*"0.*"%+%''(&#)4*3&0$#5%5*1&%%*01* +6(&<%8**\1*%-3)#+#.*1/"5#"<*#'*(33&03&#(.%=*#.*'60/)5*+0$%&* 0")4*.6%*"%.*+0'.*01*3&0$#5#"<*.6%*'%&$#+%=*#8%8=*.6%*+0'.*"%.*01* 76(.%$%&*&%$%"/%'*.6%*'%&$#+%*3&0$#5%&*5%&#$%'*('*(*5#&%+.*0&* #"5#&%+.*&%'/).*01*3&0$#5#"<*.6%*'%&$#+%8`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

5 !"#$%&%'('&)*++,-!& C/:'#5#%'*.0*.6%*#"+/2:%".=*%'3%+#())4*#"*(&%('*01*)07*.%)%5%"'#.4=*+("*2(;%*#.*%$%"*6(&5%&*10&*+023%.#.0&'*.0*%".%&*.6%&%8**]%.(#)*3&#+%*+(3'*0"*.6%*#"+/2:%".*+("*)07%&*.6%* +023%.#.#$%*a/2:&%))(a*7#.6#"*76#+6*("*%".%&#"<*+023%.#.0&* '%%;'*.0*:%+02%*3&0,.(:)%8**96%'%*1(+.0&'*+("*6($%*.6%*.70? 10)5*%11%+.*01*10+/'#"<*.6%*#"+/2:%".'^*%"%&<#%'*0"*.6%*20'.* 3&0,.(:)%*(&%('*("5*&%5/+#"<*.6%*($(#)(:)%*#".%&"()*'/:'#5#%'*.0*)%''*3&0,.(:)%*(&%('8 L$U"#09;&VBW,950!,1!"2/4/,#=6)&/,/=6&/(- b%'3#.%*.6%*%+0"02#+*#"%1,+#%"+4*(&</2%".'=*20'.* #"5/'.&#()#_%5*"(.#0"'*3/&'/%*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*30)#+#%'* :%+(/'%*.6%4*3&05/+%*'0+#())4*5%'#&(:)%*&%'/).'8**96%* 5#'3(&#.4*01*(++%''*.0*+022/"#+(.#0"'*'%&$#+%'*#'*01.%"* 30%.#+())4*&%1%&&%5*.0*('*.6%*U5#<#.()*5#$#5%8UB%#"<*+0""%+.%5*.0*+022/"#+(.#0"'*"%.70&;*#'*"%+%''(&4*.0*($0#5*U'0+#()* %-+)/'#0"U("5*10&*#"5#$#5/()'*.0*3(&.#+#3(.%*1/))4*#"*'0+#%.48** c(&.#+#3(.#0"*<0%'*:%40"5*(++%''#"<*3/:)#+*("5*%2%&<%"+4* '%&$#+%'*.0*#"+)/5%*"%.70&;#"<*7#.6*(1,"#.4*<&0/3'=* &%+&%(.#0"=*%5/+(.#0"=*("5*3&01%''#0"()*(5$("+%2%".8 dk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e0#"'*(* +022/"#+(.#0"'*"%.70&;=*%-#'.#"<*2%2:%&'*:%"%,.*:%+(/'%* EK*.6%4*+("*+0".(+.*(*"%7*3%&'0"*J(*'0?+())%5*"%.70&;* %-.%&"()#.4K*("5*WK*.6%4*+("*&%+%#$%*+())'*1&02*.6%*"%7* 2(4*"0.*.(;%*.6%'%*%11%+.'*#".0*(++0/".=*("5*6%"+%*2(4*'.(4* 011*.6%*"%.70&;*0&*"0.*2(;%*+())'=*%$%"*.60/<6*#.*70/)5*:%* %1,+#%".*10&*.6%2*.0*e0#"*.6%*"%.70&;8* I#$%"*.6%*3&%'%"+%*01*%-.%&"()#.#%'=*.6%*/'%*01* +022/"#+(.#0"'*'%&$#+%'*+("*6($%*:&0(5%&*%11%+.'*.6&0/<60/.*.6%*%+0"0248**96%'%*%11%+.'*#"+)/5%*:00'.#"<* 3&05/+.#$#.4=*%"6("+#"<*%+0"02#+*<&07.6=*3&020.#"<* &%<#0"()*5%$%)032%".=*#"+&%('#"<*(*+0/".&4^'*(:#)#.4*.0* +023%.%*<)0:())4=*("5*&(#'#"<*'.("5(&5'*01*)#$#"<8**f07? +0'.*+022/"#+(.#0"'*+("*()'0*%"+0/&(<%*.%)%70&;#"<*("5* &%5/+%*<&%%"60/'%*<('*%2#''#0"'*("5*+0"<%'.#0"*+0'.'*1&02* +022/.#"<*.0*70&;8**96%4*2(4*()'0*%"6("+%*%+0"02#+* &%'#)#%"+%*.6&0/<6*:%..%&*'/33)4*+6(#"*2("(<%2%".=*:4* #"+&%('#"<*+023%.#.#0"*("5*#""0$(.#0"=*("5*:4*3&0$#5#"<* (5(3.(:#)#.4*.0*%-.%&"()*'60+;'*J%8<8=*.%)%70&;#"<*#"*.6%*+('%* 01*(*g/*3("5%2#+K8 hk **96%'%*.43%'*01*%11%+.'*(&%*20&%*5#1,+/).*.0*L/(".#14*("5*$()/%=*:/.*.6%4*2#<6.*:%*'/:'.(".#()8 HK!"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*#'*+&#.#+())4*#230&.(".*.0*(+6#%$#"<*.6%* :%"%,.'*01*+022/"#+(.#0"'*#"1&('.&/+./&%*.0*.6%*:&0(5%&* %+0"0248**96%&%*#'*(*'#<"#,+(".=*30'#.#$%*+(/'()*)#";* :%.7%%"*#"$%'.2%".*#"*.%)%+022/"#+(.#0"'*#"1&('.&/+./&%* ("5*2(+&0%+0"02#+*0/.3/.V*607%$%&=*(55#.#$%*%11%+.*01* +022/"#+(.#0"'*#'*0")4*3&%'%".*0"+%*(*+&#.#+()*2(''*01* #"1&('.&/+./&%*6('*:%%"*&%(+6%58 FK Q,35*-,&M-509#,

6 ###",$+-.&/0123.&-+*.2+$2%8. 9)&':.0$2,$+'$ A/&&%".*&%</)(.#0"*10&*%)%+.&0"#+*+022/"#+(.#0"'* 30)#+4*10&*.6%*Q/&03%("*!"#0"*#'*%2:05#%5*#"*(*'%.*01*,$%* b#&%+.#$%'*3&02/)<(.%5*:4*.6%*q/&03%("*c(&)#(2%".*("5*.6%*q/&03%("*a0/"+#)*#"*wggw8**96%*b#&%+.#$%'*3&0$#5%* 10&*(*6(&20"#_%5*(33&0(+6=*:/.*())07*10&*'/:'#5#(&4* 76%&%*)%<#.#2(.%*5#11%&%"+%'*#"*"(.#0"()*2(&;%.'*2(;%* #.*(33&03&#(.%8**96%*b#&%+.#$%'*6(5*.0*:%*.&("'30'%5*#".0* "(.#0"()*)(7*("5*3/.*#".0*%11%+.*:4*P/)4*WGGXV*607%$%&=*.6%* 3&0+%''*.00;*(*:#.*)0"<%&*#"*'02%*+0/".&#%'8 M$A80!,-13#&X0-,950!, **96%*!"#$%&'()*C%&$#+%*b#&%+.#$%*JUSDK*'3%+#,%'*!CT'* (.*.6%*Q/&03%("*)%$%)8 EGK **96%*&%)%$(".*'%+.#0"'*01*.6%*!Cb* &%L/#&%*.6(.*%(+6*i%2:%&*C.(.%*%"'/&%*.6(.*(.*)%('.*0"%* %".#.4*#'*&%'30"'#:)%*10&*'(.#'14#"<*())*&%('0"(:)%*&%L/%'.'* 10&*M(++%''*.0*3/:)#+)4*($(#)(:)%*.%)%360"%*'%&$#+%'*(.*(*,-%5*)0+(.#0"N*#"*%(+6*<%0<&(36#+*30&.#0"*01*.6%*"(.#0"()*.%&&#.0&48 EEK **96%*.%&2*M,-%5*)0+(.#0"N*#'*"0.%70&.64*#"*.6(.*.6%&%*#'*"0*&#<6.*.0*20:#)%*.%)%360"%*'%&$#+%=*:/.*"0.6#"<* 3&%$%".'*(*i%2:%&*C.(.%*1&02*/'#"<*(*20:#)%*'%&$#+%*.0* '(.#'14*.6%*0:)#<(.#0"8 EWK!"5%&*.6%*5%,"#.#0"*01*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%=*+0""%+.#0"*.0*.6%*3/:)#+*.%)%360"%*"%.70&;*2/'.*%"(:)%*Mj*5(.(* +022/"#+(.#0"'=*(.*5(.(*&(.%'*.6(.*(&%*'/1,+#%".*.0*3%&2#.* 1/"+.#0"()*\".%&"%.*(++%''=*.(;#"<*#".0*(++0/".*3&%$(#)#"<*.%+6"0)0<#%'*/'%5*:4*.6%*2(e0&#.4*01*'/:'+&#:%&'*("5*.%+6"0)0<#+()*1%('#:#)#.48N**96#'*0:)#<(.#0"*7('*+0"+%#$%5*#"*.%&2'*01*(*'#"<)%*"(&&07:("5*$0#+%*+6(""%)*7#.6*(*"02#"()* +(3(+#.4*01*`d*;:3'8 EXK ***B&0(5:("5*\".%&"%.*(++%''*7('* +)%(&)4*"0.*#"+)/5%5*7#.6#"*.6%*'+03%*01*.6%*!CbV*607%$%&=* #.*3&0$#5%'*10&*3%&#05#+*&%$#%7*01*.6%*'+03%*01*/"#$%&'()* '%&$#+%8 E[K **96%*b#&%+.#$%*&%L/#&%'*.6%*Q/&03%("*A022#''#0"*.0*+0"'#5%&*&%)%$(".*'0+#()=*2(&;%.*("5*.%+6"0)0<#+()* 5%$%)032%".'=*("5*3&0$#5%'*+&#.%&#(*10&*+6("<%'*.0*.6%*'+03%* 01*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%8**Z6%"*'3%+#,+*'%&$#+%'*(&%*($(#)(:)%*.0*("5*/'%5*:4*(*2(e0&#.4*01*+0"'/2%&'*("5*.6%*)(+;*01* ($(#)(:#)#.4*0&*"0"?/'%*:4*(*2#"0&#.4*01*+0"'/2%&'*+0/)5* &%'/).*#"*'0+#()*%-+)/'#0"=*#.*2#<6.*:%*3%&2#''#:)%*.0*#"+)/5%*.60'%*'%&$#+%'*7#.6#"*.6%*5%,"#.#0"8**C#2#)(&)4=*76%"*.6%* ($(#)(:#)#.4*("5*/'%*01*'3%+#,+*'%&$#+%'*+0"$%4*(*<%"%&()* "%.*:%"%,.*.0*())*+0"'/2%&'*("5*76%"*.6%*'3%+#,+*'%&$#+%'* (&%*"0.*3&0$#5%5*.0*.6%*3/:)#+*/"5%&*"0&2()*+022%&+#()* +#&+/2'.("+%'=*3/:)#+*#".%&$%".#0"*2#<6.*:%*7(&&(".%58 E`K i%2:%&*c.(.%'*2(4*'/:'#5#_%*%".#.#%'*.6(.*(&%*3&0$#5#"<* /"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*(.*3&#+%'*.6(.*(&%*%11%+.#$%)4*:%)07*.6%#&* +0'.'8 EdK **96%*'/:'#5#%'*+("*+02%*1&02*<%"%&()*.(-*&%$%"/%'* 0&*1&02*(*300)*+0))%+.%5*1&02*())*'%&$#+%*3&0$#5%&'8**T")4*(* 1%7*i%2:%&*C.(.%'*3&0$#5%*'/+6*'/:'#5#%'*.05(4=*7#.6*.6%* "0.(:)%*%-+%3.#0"'*:%#"<*Y&("+%=*C3(#"*("5*\.()48 Y#"())4=*"%7*)("</(<%*%"(+.%5*#".0*.6%*!Cb*#"*WGGF* %'.(:)#'6*2#"#2/2*)%$%)'*10&*k/()#.4*01*C%&$#+%=*.6/'* 3&%$%".#"<*/"&%('0"(:)%*5%<&(5(.#0"8*96%'%*+6("<%'*.0*.6%*!Cb*()'0*'%%;*.0*%"'/&%*.6(.*+0"'/2%&'*(&%*(5%L/(.%)4* #"10&2%5*01*("4*&%'.&#+.#0"'=*("5*<#$%*+0"'/2%&'*.6%*&#<6.*.0*+6("<%*3&0$#5%&'*7#.60/.*3%"().4*#1*(*"%.70&;*03%&(.0&* #230'%'*"%7*&%'.&#+.#0"'*0"*(++%''*.0*+0".%".=*'%&$#+%'*0&* (33)#+(.#0"'8 S$M*5/"-01350"8&X0-,950!, **96%*Authorisation Directive*&%+0<"#_%'*.6(.*)#+%"'#"<*+("* '%&$%*('*(*:(&&#%&*.0*%".&48 EhK ***\.=*.6%&%10&%=*%'.(:)#'6%'*.6%* 2(-#2/2*(20/".*01*#"10&2(.#0"*.6(.*+("*:%*&%L/#&%5*#"*(* 2/'.*&%'30"5*3&023.)4*.0*&%L/%'.'*10&*(/.60&#_(.#0"'8**\1*!"#$%&%'('&)*++,-!'

7 !"#$%&%'('&)*++,- '%&$#+%*('*#1*(*)#+%"'%*6(5*:%%"*<&(".%58**Y/&.6%&20&%=*.6%* b#&%+.#$%*()'0*%'.(:)#'6%'*.6%*2(-#2/2*0:)#<(.#0"'*76#+6* +("*:%*#230'%5*0"*+(&&#%&'*76%"R*EK*"/2:%&'*(&%*&%L/%'.%5V* WK*'3%+.&/2*#'*&%L/%'.%5V*0&*XK*"%#.6%&*#'*&%L/%'.%58**\.* &%'30"5*.0*&%L/%'.'*10&*"/2:%&'V*607%$%&=*.6#'*#'*01.%"* /"%"10&+%(:)%8 96%*b#&%+.#$%*%"(:)%'*("4*3&0$#5%&*01*("*Q)%+.&0"#+* A022/"#+(.#0"'*C%&$#+%*0&*"%.70&;*.0*(33)4*.0*:%+02%* (*3&0$#5%&*01*(*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%8 EHK **96#'*&#<6.*#'*&(&%)4* #"$0;%5=*#"('2/+6*('*3&0$#'#0"*01*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*%".(#)'* $(&#0/'*+0'.'*("5*1%7*:%"%,.'*'#"+%*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*#'* "0.*%-3)#+#.)4*1/"5%58**\"*+0"e/"+.#0"*7#.6*.6%*3&#"+#3)%*01*.%+6"0)0<#+()*"%/.&()#.4=*.6%*b#&%+.#$%*+0/)5*+0"+%#$(:)4* %"(:)%*(*3&0$#5%&*01*(*D0\c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bK8**\"*("*\c?:('%5*70&)5=* #.*#'*.6%*"%.70&;*(++%''*.6(.*#'*%-3%"'#$%*.0*5%)#$%&V*0"+%*.6%* (++%''*#'*#"*3)(+%=*.6%*$0#+%*'%&$#+%*#'*#"%-3%"'#$%*.0*5%)#$%&8 C#2#)(&)4=*.6%*5#11%&%"+%*#"*+0'.*'.&/+./&%'*("5* '/:'.#./.(:#)#.4*:%.7%%"*7#&%5*("5*7#&%)%''*"%.70&;'* 3)(+%'*1/&.6%&*'.&(#"'*0"*.6%*+&0''?'/:'#5#%'*#"6%&%".*#"* /"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*0:)#<(.#0"'8**i0:#)%*:&0(5:("5*&(#'%'* '%$%&()*L/%'.#0"'*('*7%))*#"*&%<(&5*.0*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%8** Y#&'.=*.6%&%*#'*.6%*L/%'.#0"*01*76%.6%&*20:#)%*:&0(5:("5* #'*1('.*%"0/<6=*0&*+6%(3*%"0/<6*(.*+023(&(:)%*'3%%5'=*.0* 2%("#"<1/))4*'/:'.#./.%*10&*,-%5*:&0(5:("58**96#'*#'*1/&.6%&* +023)#+(.%5*:4*.6%*1(+.*.6(.*.6%*'3%%5*01*20:#)%*:&0(5:("5* #'*'#<"#,+(".)4*5%3%"5%".*0"*+0".%".#0"*:%.7%%"*/'%&'=* 76#+6*#'*0"%*01*'%$%&()*&%('0"'*764*#.*.%"5'*.0*:%*20&%* '/#.(:)%*10&*(&%('*01*)07*.%)%5%"'#.48**96%*+0'.*01*5%)#$%&#"<* :&0(5:("5*(++%''*+("*5#11%&*<&%(.)4*1&02*0"%*3(&.*01*.6%* "(.#0"()*.%&&#.0&4*.0*("0.6%&=*:('%5*"0.*0")4*0"*.%)%5%"'#.4=* :/.*()'0*0"*.030<&(3648*96%*3&%'%"+%*0&*(:'%"+%*01*("* ()&%(54*%-#'.#"<*7#&%5*#"1&('.&/+./&%*J76%.6%&*.%)%360"4*0&* +(:)%K*#"*&%20.%*&%<#0"'*+("*6($%*("*%"0&20/'*#23(+.*0"*.6%*+0'.*01*7#&%5*:&0(5:("58**96#'*#'*(*2(e0&*+0"'#5%&(.#0"* #"*2("4*01*.6%*.7%)$%*i%2:%&*C.(.%'*76#+6*7%&%*(52#..%5*.0*.6%*Q/&03%("*!"#0"*#"*WGG[*("5*WGGh8 '%&$#+%*30)#+4*#'*.6%*1(+.*.6(.*#.*#'*30''#:)%*.6(.*("4*/"#$%&'()* '%&$#+%*30)#+4*+0/)5*M)0+;*#"N*.05(4^'*+033%&?:('%5* :&0(5:("5*.%+6"0)0<#%'=*("5*2#<6.*6#"5%&*.6%*2#<&(.#0"*.0*,:&%?:('%5*(++%''*.%+6"0)0<#%'*.6(.*(&%*)#;%)4*.0*:%* ("5*C7#._%&)("5 EFK *(&%*3)(""#"<*.0*#"+0&30&(.%*M:&0(5:("5N* '%&$#+%'*#".0*.6%#&*&%'3%+.#$%*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*0:)#<(.#0"'8** 96%'%*+0/".&#%'*6($%*5%,"%5*(*'3%+#,+*2#"#2/2*:("57#5.6* 76#+6*#'*+/&&%".)4*%L/()*.0*0&*)%''*.6("*W*i:3'8!"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*("5*:&0(5:("5*#'*()'0*0"*.6%*(<%"5(* 01*.6%*Q/&03%("*A022#''#0"8**\"*WGGH=*.6%*A022#''#0"* (503.%5*(*Q/&03%("*Q+0"02#+*]%+0$%&4*c)("=*0"%*01*.6%* Q,35*-,&M-509#,

8 +%".&()*(#2'*01*76#+6*#'*(+6#%$#"<*EGGl*6#<6*'3%%5*\".%&"%.* +0$%&(<%*10&*())*+#.#_%"'*:4*WGEG8 WGK **96%*A022#''#0"* 5%+#5%5*3(&.*01*.6%*mE8GW*:#))#0"*())0+(.%5*.0*.6%*Q/&03%("* O<&#+/)./&()*Y/"5*10&*]/&()*b%$%)032%".*JQOY]bK*:%*/'%5* 10&*5%3)04#"<*:&0(5:("5*#"1&('.&/+./&%'*#"*&/&()*(&%('*.0* 6%)3*&/&()*(&%('*<%.*0")#"%8 WEK **Y/&.6%&=*(.*.6%*.#2%*01*7&#.#"<=*.6%*Q/&03%("*A022#''#0"*)(/"+6%5*(*+0"'/).(.#0"*.0*:%* +023)%.%5*:4*i(4*WGEG*0"*76(.*#'*.6%*:%'.*(33&0(+6*.0* %"'/&%*.6(.*:('#+*.%)%+022/"#+(.#0"'*'%&$#+%'*(&%*($(#)(:)%* 10&*())*Q!*+#.#_%"'8**96%*+0"'/).(.#0"*'%%;'*#"10&2(.#0"*0"R*EK*.6%*(5%L/(+4*01*.6%*+/&&%".*5%,"#.#0"*01*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%V* WK*.6%*L/%'.#0"*76%.6%&*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*'60/)5*#"+)/5%* :&0(5:("5*10&*())V*XK*.6%*&#<6.*:()("+%*:%.7%%"*(*+00&5#"(.%5* Q/&03%("*!"#0"?7#5%*&%'30"'%*("5*.6%*"%%5*10&*"(.#0"()* g%-#:#)#.4v*("5*[k*.6%*(33&03&#(.%*2%+6("#'2'*10&*1/"5#"<* /"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%8 WWK ;"3%0%.2<+(2=)1./2+$2%8.29)&':.0$2,$+'$ M$ )535,&M06&Y*#,1&>,8,-3##; 96%*9&%(.4*%'.(:)#'6#"<*.6%*Q/&03%("*A022/"#.4*3&0$#5%'* &/)%'*<0$%&"#"<*C.(.%*(#58**\.*'.(.%'*U("4*(#5*<&(".%5*:4* (*i%2:%&*c.(.%*0&*.6&0/<6*c.(.%*&%'0/&+%'*#"*("4*10&2* 76(.'0%$%&*76#+6*5#'.0&.'*0&*.6&%(.%"'*.0*5#'.0&.*+023%.#.#0"* :4*1($0&#"<*+%&.(#"*/"5%&.(;#"<'*0&*.6%*3&05/+.#0"*01*+%&.(#"* <005'*'6())=*#"*'0*1(&*('*#.*(11%+.'*.&(5%*:%.7%%"*i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e%+.#0"*:4*(*3/:)#+*#"$%'.0&* 50%'*"0.*6($%*'/1,+#%".*3&0'3%+.'*01*3&0,.(:#)#.48 W[K 96%*Q/&03%("*A022#''#0"*&%+0<"#_%'*.6(.*C.(.%*(#5*+("* (5$("+%*+0220"*#".%&%'.'*("5*+("*&%2%54*2(&;%.*1(#)/&%'8 W`K 96%*A022#''#0"*3&%1%&'*.6%*%1,+#%".*0/.+02%'*<%"%&(.%5* :4*2(&;%.'=*("5*.6%&%10&%=*#.'*&/)%'*&%L/#&%*.6(.*C.(.%*(#5*"0.* +&075?0/.*2(&;%.*#"#.#(.#$%'8 WdK S$ )535,&M06&386&S-"36B386 \"*C%3.%2:%&*WGGF=*.6%*Q/&03%("*A022#''#0"* 3/:)#'6%5*UI/#5%)#"%'*10&*.6%*(33)#+(.#0"*01*'.(.%*(#5* &/)%'*#"*&%)(.#0"*.0*(*&(3#5*5%3)042%".*01*:&0(5:("5* "%.70&;'U WhK ***\"*.6%*I/#5%)#"%'=*.6%*A022#''#0"* %-(2#"%5*C.(.%*(#5*'/330&.#"<*:&0(5:("5*5%3)042%".* #"+)/5#"<*:/#)5#"<=*03%&(.#"<=*("5*%"(:)#"<*(++%''*.0* :&0(5:("5*#"1&('.&/+./&%8**Z6%"*C.(.%*(#5*#'*<&(".%5* 5#&%+.)4*.0*#"$%'.0&'*.6%*"%.70&;*#.*'60/)5*:%*50"%*.6&0/<6*.6%*2%("'*01*("*03%"*.%"5%&*#"*0&5%&*.0*%"'/&%*.6(.*("4*(#5*#'*)#2#.%5*.0*.6%*2#"#2/2*(20/".*"%+%''(&4* 10&*.6%*3(&.#+/)(&*3&0e%+.8 Y/&.6%&=*.6%*A022#''#0"^'*I/#5%)#"%'*%'.(:)#'6* 5#'.#"+.#0"*:%.7%%"*76(.*#.*+())'*76#.%=*:)(+;*("5*<&%4* 76%&%*.6%4*(&%*"0.*)#;%)4*.0*:%*:/#).*#"*.6%*"%(&*1/./&%*:4* C.(.%*(#5*'/330&.#"<*:&0(5:("5*"%.70&;*#'*<%"%&())4*!"#$%&%'('&)*++,- (!

9 Q,35*-,&M-509#, Q0C*-,%&L35,C"-0,1&"<&)535,&M06 NGA Area Presence of NGA State Aid White No NGA by private firms State aid permissible, consistent with law Grey Black Only 1 private NGA within 3 years More than 1 private NGA within 3 years State aid permissible, only if NGA network is insufficient State aid impermissible, absent market failure C0/&+%R*>8*A(&.%& 3%&2#''#:)%*#"*(++0&5("+%*7#.6*Q/&03%("*!"#0"*)(78**B4* +0".&('.=*#"*@IO*:)(+;*(&%('=*.6%*A022#''#0"*%-3%+.'*.6(.*C.(.%*'/330&.*10&*("*(55#.#0"()*3/:)#+)4?1/"5%5=* +023%.#"<*@IO*"%.70&;*70/)5*:%*#"+023(.#:)%*7#.6*.6%*C.(.%*(#5*&/)%'*'#"+%*#.*#'*)#;%)4*.0*5#'.0&.*+023%.#.#0"8** 96%*%-+%3.#0"*.0*.6#'*+('%*#'*#1*.6%&%*#'*'%&#0/'*2(&;%.* 1(#)/&%8**\"*@IO*<&%4*(&%('=*.6%*A022#''#0"^'*I/#5%)#"%'* &%L/#&%R*Ui%2:%&*C.(.%'*'60/)5*:%*(:)%*.0*5%20"'.&(.%* 1#&'.)4=*.6(.*.6%*%-#'.#"<*0&*3)(""%5*@IO*"%.70&;*#'*"0.* 0&*70/)5*"0.*:%*'/11#+#%".*.0*'(.#'14*.6%*"%%5'*01*+#.#_%"'* ("5*:/'#"%''*/'%&'*#"*.6%*(&%('*#"*L/%'.#0"*("5=*'%+0"5)4=*.6(.*.6%&%*(&%*"0*)%''*5#'.0&.#$%*2%("'*J#"+)/5#"<*%-*(".%* &%</)(.#0"K*.0*&%(+6*.6%*'.(.%5*<0()'8U WHK >"?'$*1)/+'$ **i("4*+0/".&#%'*3/&'/%*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*30)#+#%'*10&* +022/"#+(.#0"'*"%.70&;'*:%+(/'%*.6%#&*:%"%,.*#"*.%&2'* 01*(5$("+#"<*3/:)#+*30)#+4*<0()'*("5*6%)3#"<*.0*'.#2/)(.%* :&0(5%&*%+0"02#+*<&07.6*0/.7%#<6'*.6%*30''#:)%*%+0"02#+* #"%1,+#%"+#%'*.6%'%*30)#+#%'*+("*#".&05/+%8 o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i("4*i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g%+.*.6%*$#%7'*01*0.6%&'8*96%*(/.60&* #'*<&(.%1/)*.0*>bb\*]%'%(&+6*76#+6*'/330&.%5*.6%*3/:)#+(.#0"*01*.6#'*(&.#+)%8*\*()0"%*(2*&%'30"'#:)%*10&*("4*%&&0&'*0&* 02#''#0"'*+0".(#"%5*6%&%#"8 TQAb*JWGGdK8 QA9O=*B(5*o0""%1*JWGGHK8 `K*C%%*O&.#+)%*EX*01*.6%*!"#$%&'()*C%&$#+%*b#&%+.#$%8*\"*.6%*Q/&03%("*+0".%-.=*1/"5#"<*#'*(33&03&#(.%*0")4*76%&%*(* dk*b0..%&2("=*i=*>(6("=*pc=*$("*b%%)%"=*i8=*%.*()8=*=907(&5'*c/:)#+*d()/%r*o*d#'#0"*01*c/:)#+*d()/%*i0$%&"("+%*#"* B&0(5:("5*C.(;%60)5%&*I&0/3*JP/"%*WGGHK8 Y00."0.%'

11 Q,35*-,&M-509#, Y00."0.%' HK*Y0&"%1%)5=*i8=*b%)(/"(4=*I8=*("5*Q)#-2(""=*b8=*96%*\23(+.*01*B&0(5:("5*0"*I&07.6*("5*c&05/+.#$#.4=*C./54*10&*.6%*Q/&03%("*A022#''#0"*JWGGHK8 FK*]t))%&=*f?o8*("5*Z($%&2("=*f8=*9%)%+022/"#+(.#0"'*\"1&('.&/+./&%*("5*Q+0"02#+*b%$%)032%".R*O*C#2/).("%0/'* O33&0(+6=*O2%&#+("*Q+0"02#+*]%$#%7*J("()4_#"<*5(.(*1&02*(*WG*4%(&*3%&#05*10&*WE*TQAb*+0/".&#%'K*JWGGEK8 EGK*b#&%+.#$%*WGGWrWWrQA8 EEK*O&.#+)%*[8*96%*!Cb*&%L/#&%'*(*&("<%*01*0.6%&*'%&$#+%'*('*7%))=*#"+)/5#"<*3(4*.%)%360"%'8 EWK*C%%*]%+#.()*HR*Mj96%&%*'60/)5*:%*"0*+0"'.&(#".'*0"*.6%*.%+6"#+()*2%("'*:4*76#+6*.6%*+0""%+.#0"*#'*3&0$#5%5=* ())07#"<*10&*7#&%5*0&*7#&%)%''*.%+6"0)0<#%'=*"0&*("4*+0"'.&(#".'*0"*76#+6*03%&(.0&'*3&0$#5%*3(&.*0&*())*01*/"#$%&'()* '%&$#+%*0:)#<(.#0"'8N EXK*!Cb=*]%+#.()*H8 E[K*!Cb=*O&.#+)%*E`8 E`K*!Cb=*O""%-*D8* EdK*C%%*O&.#+)%*EXR*MZ6%&%*j"(.#0"()*&%</)(.0&4*(/.60&#.#%'*1#"5*.6(.*("*/"5%&.(;#"<*#'*'/:e%+.*.0*("*/"1(#&* :/&5%"=*i%2:%&*C.(.%'*'6())=*/30"*&%L/%'.*1&02*(*5%'#<"(.%5*/"5%&.(;#"<=*5%+#5%R*J(K*.0*#".&05/+%*(*2%+6("#'2*.0* +023%"'(.%*.6(.*/"5%&.(;#"<*10&*.6%*5%.%&2#"%5*"%.*+0'.'*/"5%&*.&("'3(&%".*+0"5#.#0"'*1&02*3/:)#+*1/"5'V*("5r0&*J:K*.0*'6(&%*.6%*"%.*+0'.*01*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*0:)#<(.#0"'*:%.7%%"*3&0$#5%&'*01*%)%+.&0"#+*+022/"#+(.#0"'*"%.70&;'*("5* '%&$#+%'8N EhK*b#&%+.#$%*WGGWrWGrQA8 EHK*O&.#+)%*[8WJ:K8 EFK*C7#._%&)("5*#'*"0.*(*Q/&03%("*!"#0"*i%2:%&*C.(.%8 WGK*A022/"#+(.#0"*1&02*.6%*A022#''#0"*.0*.6%*Q/&03%("*A0/"+#)=*ATiJWGGHK*HGG8 EWFGrWGG`*0"*.6%*,"("+#"<*01*.6%*+0220"*(<&#+/)./&()*30)#+4*JTP*f*E[[=*F8d8WGGF=*38*XK8 WWK*c&%''*&%)%('%=*A0"'/).(.#0"*0"*1/./&%*/"#$%&'()*'%&$#+%*#"*.6%*5#<#.()*%&(*J\crEGrWEHK8 WXK*O&.#+)%*HhJEK8 W[K*A('%*A?XGXrHH=*\.()4*$*A022#''#0"=*uEFFEv*QA]*\?E[XX=*(.*3(&(<&(36'*WG?WW8 W`K*C.(.%*(#5*O+.#0"*c)("*?*f%''*("5*:%..%&*.(&<%.%5*C.(.%*(#5R*(*&0(52(3*10&*C.(.%*(#5*&%10&2*WGG`?WGGF=*ATiJWGG`K* EGh*,"()8 WdK*A022/"#+(.#0"*1&02*.6%*A022#''#0"*A022/"#.4*I/#5%)#"%'*10&*.6%*(33)#+(.#0"*01*C.(.%*(#5*&/)%'*#"*&%)(.#0"*.0* &(3#5*5%3)042%".*01*:&0(5:("5*"%.70&;'*JWGGFrA*WX`rG[K8* WhK*Q/&03%("*A022#''#0"=*A022/"#.4*I/#5%)#"%'*10&*.6%*(33)#+(.#0"*01*C.(.%*(#5*&/)%'*#"*&%)(.#0"*.0*&(3#5* 5%3)042%".*01*:&0(5:("5*"%.70&;'=*JWGGFrA*WX`rG[K8