MEASURING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEES 1
|
|
- Darlene Stokes
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 MEASURING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEES 1 ABSTRACT Benchmarks and methods of self-assessment can help build public confidence and strengthen the capacity of parliaments to manage increasing demands as well as assert greater institutional independence. As parliaments face increased public scepticism, it has become an imperative to re-connect with the electorate and to demonstrate how legislatures in general, and financial oversight committees in particular, can demonstrate their contribution to combatting inequality and inefficient public expenditure. The Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU), UNDP, Commonwealth Parliamentary Association (CPA), the National Democratic Institute for International Affairs (NDI) and the Canadian Parliamentary Centre have been at the forefront of working with parliaments to produce assessment frameworks. Each of these organisations have adopted different approaches to performance assessment but have all approached the task from the perspective of the legislature as a whole rather than individual committees. Very little work has so far been carried out on how to focus benchmarks on individual parliamentary committees and, especially, financial oversight committees. Recognizing the diversity of practice across legislatures globally, 23 benchmarks are proposed, which are aspirational rather than prescriptive, for a Public Accounts Committee (PAC) or other parliamentary committee exercising similar ex post oversight functions might be grouped into four broad generic areas: Organization Powers, functions and procedures Accessibility and transparency Relationships with the Supreme Audit Institution (SAI) Niall Johnston Parliamentary Strengthening Specialist Phone: niall@nialljohnston.org 1 This paper was approved by the General Assembly of the Asia Regional Association of Public Accounts Committees (ARAPAC), held in Kathmandu, 11 September
2 Background The powers and functions of legislatures vary significantly and achieving consensus on what a democratic parliament actually is (or should be) has proved difficult. In recent years a debate has begun on the potential benefit of an internationally agreed system of parliamentary benchmarking. Benchmarks and methods of self-assessment can help build public confidence and strengthen the capacity of parliaments to manage increasing demands as well as assert greater institutional independence. For donors, the use of benchmarks and standards can justify both their expenditure on parliamentary development and the effectiveness of these aid interventions. Inter-Parliamentary Organizations (IPOs) can use the assessment frameworks as an opportunity to codify their wider programmes and best practice guides and to share experience of member parliaments. Several benchmarks or good practice guides have been produced but the tools developed for legislatures to date have different purposes and ask different questions. Some sets of standards seek to codify good practice for purposes of self-assessment while others seek to identify the minimum criteria for being a democratic parliament. Both methods are more at the stage of assessing where a legislature is at the moment (against international criteria), providing examples of issues to consider, and stimulating intense debate about what kind of institution the organisation should become. Neither approach is designed to rank legislatures against others: the purpose is to improve the functioning of that legislature. In the end-of-conference statement from the March 2010 International Conference on Benchmarking and Self-Assessment for Democratic Parliaments, participants noted the paradox between the triumph of democracy both as an ideal and as a set of political institutions and practices, and the disillusionment developing with the rules of democracy in practice. There was also agreement that the core values of a democratic parliament is one that is representative of the political will and social diversity of the population, and is effective in its legislative, oversight and representational functions, at the sub-national, national and international levels. Crucially, it is also transparent, accessible, and accountable to the citizens that it represents. 2 Assessing effectiveness requires some form of criteria and measurement of performance. A benchmark is a standard by which something can be measured or judged. The benefit of using benchmarks to review performance is that, if done properly, it enables the institution to be more aware of how it can improve its performance. This requires an honest and open approach to new ideas as well as the ability to be self-reflective and self-critical: institutions that are open to change and new ways of doing things are healthier and more robust than those that are not. They also help to ensure their own relevance and effectiveness in the longterm. 3 The Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU), UNDP, Commonwealth Parliamentary Association (CPA), the National Democratic Institute for International Affairs (NDI) and the Canadian Parliamentary Centre have been at the forefront of working with parliaments to produce assessment frameworks. Each of these organisations have adopted different approaches to 2 Participants Statement at the International Conference on Benchmarking and Self-Assessment for Democratic Parliaments, Paris, 2-4 March Duffy, B & Thompson, M (2003) Innovative committee methods: Case studies from two Parliaments, Australasian Study of Parliament Group Annual Conference, July 2003, p. 47 2
3 performance assessment but have all approached the task from the perspective of the legislature as a whole rather than individual committees. Very little work has so far been carried out on how to focus benchmarks on individual parliamentary committees and, especially, financial oversight committees. References to material already available can be found at Annex A. This paper draws heavily on Commonwealth good practice. It is recognised that not all ARAPAC members come from this tradition but, given that the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) system, which can be found in a number of non-commonwealth countries across Asia, is derived from Westminster, it is hoped that Commonwealth good practice might inform the development of benchmarks appropriate for all ARAPAC members. The Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles 4 govern issues such as the harmonious balancing of power and the interaction between parliament, the Executive and the judiciary in democratic societies. They set out in detail the consensus arrived at by representatives of the three branches of government in the Commonwealth on how each of their national institutions should interrelate in the exercise of their institutional responsibility. The Principles specify restraint in the exercise of power within their respective constitutional spheres so that the legitimate discharge of constitutional functions by other institutions is not encroached upon. The Commonwealth Principles were finalised by Commonwealth law ministers and endorsed by Commonwealth Heads of Government at their summit in Abuja, Nigeria, in December The Principles have been distilled from the Latimer House Guidelines on Parliamentary Sovereignty and Judicial Independence. These were drawn up in 1998 by four prominent Commonwealth organisations: the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association, the Commonwealth Legal Education Association, the Commonwealth Magistrates' and Judges' Association and the Commonwealth Lawyers' Association. This paper provides guidance on benchmarks that could be adopted by ARAPAC. Suggested Benchmarks Recognizing the diversity of practice in ARAPAC member countries, the Study Group recommends that possible benchmarks, which are aspirational rather than prescriptive, for a PAC or other parliamentary committee exercising similar ex post oversight functions might be grouped into four broad generic areas: Organization Powers, functions and procedures Accessibility and transparency Relationships with the Supreme Audit Institution (SAI) Under each heading, a number of possible benchmarks are set out below together with the rationale for each recommendation a list of the benchmarks can be found at Annex B. 4 Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles. May
4 Organization Global good practice suggests that membership of committees should reflect the balance of political parties in the parliament this principle is common practice in many countries. There should also be a transparent method for selecting the chairs of committees. It is recommended that the assignment of committee members on each committee shall include both majority and minority party members and reflect the political composition of the legislature as far as practicable. It is further recommended that there should be a transparent method for selecting or electing the chairs of committees. Committee members may not always have the in-depth knowledge or expertise necessary to treat specific issues or complex legislation. They may therefore wish to consult or employ experts to help them in their work. Each committee should have the legal mechanisms and financial means in place to allow them to consult experts. In a number of parliaments, the mechanism to employ experts requires that committees go through the Speaker to ensure fair and proper use of financial resources. It is recommended that committees shall have the right to consult and/or employ experts. Adequate non-partisan professional staff is a prerequisite for the well functioning of any parliament. Parliamentarians may not have the expertise in a certain subject being examined in committee and they do not have the time to do research on all subjects on their own there is a need to support both individual members and committees with good quality and accessible research. It is recommended that the legislature should have an adequate nonpartisan professional staff to support its operations including the operations of its committees. It is the norm in parliaments today that distinctions are drawn between partisan and nonpartisan staff. If this does not happen, parliamentarians, particularly those in opposition, may not receive adequate staff support. It is critical to have a neutral staff to perform administrative functions, give advice on procedural issues, or provide research. Beyond the head of the parliamentary service and his or her staff, which should always be non-partisan it is for a parliament to decide which positions are partisan and which are not. It is recommended that the legislature draws and maintains a clear distinction between partisan and non-partisan staff. All legislatures need sufficient research, library and ICT facilities and, in some cases, parliaments may have agreements with outside organizations to use their libraries rather than maintaining an internal capacity. Similarly parliaments may partner with think tanks and institutes for specialized research needs. It is recommended that members and staff of committees have access to sufficient research, library, and ICT facilities. Powers, functions and Procedures MPs have a heavy workload and must be able to plan accordingly, and in advance, in order to consult the public, and prepare for and carry out their functions efficiently and effectively. It is recommended that adequate advance notice of meetings and the agenda for the meeting be provided. 4
5 The Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles state that parliaments should have: a committee structure appropriate to the size of parliament, adequately resourced and with the power to summon witnesses, including ministers. Governments should be required to announce publicly, within a defined time period, their responses to committee reports. 5 It is recommended that committees shall have the power to summon persons, papers and records, and this power shall extend to witnesses and evidence from the Executive branch, including officials and ministers. 6 While a committee may decide to invite other MPs to participate in its discussion or evidence sessions, this should not extend to participation in any votes or decision-making processes. This benchmark is seen as an agreed Commonwealth and international norm for all democratic legislatures as, should non-committee members be able to vote, a majority party in parliament could swamp a committee at the time of the vote and thus undermine the work of the committee. It is recommended that only MPs appointed to the committee should have the right to vote in the committee. Oversight of the Executive is one of the core functions of the legislature. As set out above, all committees should include both majority and minority party members and reflect the political composition of the legislature as far as practicable. It is recommended that the committees shall provide meaningful opportunities for opposition parties to engage in effective oversight of government expenditures. A legislature cannot effectively oversee the Executive if it is denied access to the necessary information held by the Executive. The Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles state that: (i) a committee structure appropriate to the size of parliament, adequately resourced and with the power to summon witnesses, including ministers. Governments should be required to announce publicly, within a defined time period, their responses to committee reports; (ii) standing orders should provide appropriate opportunities for members to question ministers and full debate on legislative proposals. 7 It is recommended that the committees shall have access to records of Executive branch accounts and related documentation sufficient to be able to meaningfully review the accuracy of Executive branch reporting on its revenues and expenditures. Committee hearings should be held in public with any exceptions being clearly defined and provided for in the Rules of Procedure although it is usual that administrative and deliberative meetings of committees will be held in private. Committees may also meet in private when reviewing sensitive material related to national security, or at the request of a witness, or for the protection of a witness, when hearing evidence on sensitive matters. It is recommended that committee hearings be held in public. It is critical to the transparency of the parliament that, while voting in a committee will take place in a closed session of the committee, the results of the votes, or the records of the proceedings, should be public. It is recommended that the record of votes of a committee shall be in public. 5 Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles. May See Annex, Art. VI, 2, a (i) 6 Within the Westminster system, it is conventional that parliament will usually summon Accounting Officers directly rather than through a Minister. 7 Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles. May See Annex Art. VI, 2, a (i) and (ii) 5
6 Witnesses, including whistleblowers, should be able to report instances of corruption or other wrongdoing without fear of reprisal. It is recommended that the legislature shall protect informants and witnesses presenting relevant information to committee inquiries about corruption or other unlawful activity. Furthermore, witnesses should have the protection of parliamentary privilege to ensure they are able to give information to the committee without fear of legal action. Accessibility and Transparency Article VIII of the Commonwealth Principles seeks to ensure broader public participation in the legislative process this is especially true for committees. In addition to individual citizens, the Commonwealth Principles also promote broader participation of civil society. Participation is essential for good governance as it improves information flow, accountability, due process, and gives voice to those most directly affected by public policy. The Constitution of South Africa states that The National Assembly must facilitate public involvement in the legislative and other processes of the Assembly and its committees. In Canada, the Estimates Committee of the House of Commons annually conducts cross-country consultations on the federal budget. In New Zealand, committees in the House of Representatives hold public hearings when examining draft legislation and attempt to hear all members of the public who wish to appear before them. It is recommended that opportunities should be given for public input into committee inquiries. Information must be given in a timely manner so that the public can participate effectively in the legislative process - both the government and the committee may choose to provide this information. Citizens and civil society groups should have adequate time to review the information, respond and have their views heard and considered by the committee. It is recommended that information is provided to the public in a timely manner regarding matters under consideration by the legislature. When considering public access to committees, it is important to underline the responsibility of MPs to reach out to their constituents and educate the public and the media on the work of the committees. Only an educated public can truly profit from access to the legislature. Such outreach would also encourage the two-way flow of information between MPs and constituents, and promote greater understanding of the work in the committees, which may in turn promote greater public confidence in the legislature as a whole. It is recommended that the committees promote the public s understanding of their work. The Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles state that Conflict of interest guidelines and codes of conduct shall require full disclosure by ministers and members of their financial and business interest. 8 For such disclosure to be effective, it must be public. It is recommended that committee members should be required to disclose relevant business interests if there is potential for a perceived conflict of interest. Many parliaments today have a non-partisan media relations office or staff tasked with communicating with the media. A media relations facility serves both as a liaison for media reporting on parliament s activities, and as a resource for parliament when seeking to provide information to the public. Committees may need to develop media strategies for reaching out to the public when holding public hearings or inquiries. It is important to underline the value 8 Commonwealth (Latimer House) Principles. May See Annex Art. V (2a). 6
7 of having a non-partisan media relations facility in order to ensure fair coverage and access. It is recommended that the legislature should have a non-partisan media relations facility. The activities of PAC s are aimed at achieving improved financial management practices and accountability within the public sector and public funded institutions in the implementation of the budget. They need to have a framework according to which they can plan, monitor implementation and assess and report on their performance. An effective performance measurement system (PMS) should specify the committee s goals, objectives, inputs, resources, activities, processes, outputs, performance indicators and outcomes. Each committee should assess its performance at least once every year in a manner that is consistent with its aspirations for performance effectiveness. It is recommended that the committees have a performance measurement system to assess their effectiveness and performance. Relationships with the SAI In many countries, the reports of the Supreme Audit Institution (SAI) are tabled late thus making effective oversight impossible. Ideally, the financial audit report should be tabled within three months of the end of the fiscal year. It is critical that the SAI s independence be protected, and that its reports be tabled expeditiously in the legislature. It is recommended that SAI reports be tabled in the legislature in a direct and timely manner. It is often observed that lack of resources is a common complaint and cause of delays in the SAI producing reports. The committee should ensure that audits are conducted, and the reports tabled, in a timely manner and that the SAI is provided with sufficient resources to accomplish this. This view is reinforced in the recommendations of a CPA Workshop on Parliamentary Oversight of Finance and Budgetary Process which concluded that, It is important that Auditors-General should submit audit reports in a timely fashion but without compromising either the content or quality of these whether they relate to annual or special reports. 9 It is recommended that the PAC ensure that the SAI shall be provided with adequate resources and legal authority to conduct audits in a timely manner. While a committee s recommendations are not binding, it is expected that the Executive will implement them. In most countries, the Executive is obliged to provide a formal response to a committee s recommendations within a specified period. Follow-up on PAC recommendations is critical to achieve improved financial management and control within the public sector and public-funded institutions. It is essential that the committee has a formal follow-up procedure to determine and monitor action taken by government on the PAC s recommendations. It is recommended that the committee has a formal procedure for following up on its recommendations. 9 CPA Workshop on Parliamentary Oversight of Finance and Budgetary Process, Nairobi Kenya, December
8 Annex A References Canadian Comprehensive Auditing Foundation Parliamentary Oversight Committees and Relationships, 2010 Canadian Parliamentary Centre African Parliamentary Index Commonwealth Parliamentary Association Recommended Benchmarks for Democratic Legislatures, 2006 Recommended Benchmarks for Asia, India and South-East Asia Regions Democratic Legislatures, 2010 European Commission Engaging and Supporting Parliaments Worldwide European Parliament Benchmarking for Parliaments International IDEA Assessing the Quality of Democracy: A Practical Guide Inter-Parliamentary Union Parliament and Democracy in the Twenty-First Century: A Guide to Good Practice, 2006 National Democratic Institute for International Affairs Toward the Development of International Standards for Democratic Legislatures, 2007 Southern Africa Development Community Organisation of PACs Good Practice Guide for Public Accounts Committees in SADC, 2009 World Bank Group Benchmarking and Self-Assessment for Parliaments UNDP Benchmarking and Self-assessment for Democratic Legislatures,
9 Annex B Recommended Benchmarks 1. The assignment of committee members on each committee includes both majority and minority party members and reflects the political composition of the legislature as far as practicable. 2. There is a transparent method for selecting or electing the chairs of committees. 3. Committees have the right to consult and/or employ experts. 4. The legislature has an adequate non-partisan professional staff to support the operations of its committees. 5. The legislature draws and maintains a clear distinction between partisan and nonpartisan staff. 6. Members and staff of committees have access to sufficient research, library, and ICT facilities. 7. Adequate advance notice of meetings and the agenda for the meeting is provided. 8. Committees have the power to summon persons, papers and records, and this power extends to witnesses and evidence from the Executive branch, including officials. 9. Only MPs appointed to a committee have the right to vote in the committee. 10. The committees provide meaningful opportunities for opposition parties to engage in effective oversight of government expenditures. 11. Committees have access to records of Executive branch accounts and related documentation sufficient to be able to meaningfully review the accuracy of Executive branch reporting on its revenues and expenditures. 12. Committee hearings are held in public. 13. The record of votes of a committee is public. 14. The legislature protects informants and witnesses presenting relevant information to committee inquiries about corruption or other unlawful activity. 15. Opportunities are given for public input into committee inquiries. 16. Information is provided to the public in a timely manner regarding matters under consideration by the legislature. 17. Committees promote the public s understanding of their work. 9
10 18. Committee members are required to disclose relevant business interests if there is potential for a perceived conflict of interest. 19. The legislature has a non-partisan media relations facility. 20. Committees have performance measurement systems to assess their effectiveness and performance. 21. SAI reports are tabled in the legislature in a timely manner. 22. The SAI is provided with adequate resources and legal authority to conduct audits in a timely manner. 23. Committees have formal procedures for following up on their recommendations. 10
International Consensus on Standards for Democratic Parliaments
International Consensus on Standards for Democratic Parliaments Workshop of the Committee on Democracy and Peace September 6, 2011 Andrew G. Mandelbaum Senior Program Officer, Governance National Democratic
More information3 RD WESTMINSTER WORKSHOP, THE PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE JUNE 2013 AIM
3 RD WESTMINSTER WORKSHOP, THE PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE 24-27 JUNE 2013 AIM 1. The aim of the four day Westminster Workshop programme is to explore the key features of an effective Public Accounts Committee
More informationParliament and Accountability. Rasheed Draman
Parliament and Accountability Rasheed Draman Perceived levels of corruption in key institutions, global average and SSA Political parties average: (Source, GCB 2010) 70% 79% Public officials/civil servants
More informationTRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MONTENEGRIN GOVERNANCE SYSTEM Summary Report of an Assessment Podgorica, February 2009
TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE MONTENEGRIN GOVERNANCE SYSTEM Summary Report of an Assessment Podgorica, February 2009 With a focus on accountability and transparency, the National Democratic Institute
More informationParliamentary Administration: Why Does it Matter? Australian and international perspectives on approaches to parliamentary administration
Parliamentary Administration: Why Does it Matter? Australian and international perspectives on approaches to parliamentary administration Dr June R Verrier, ANU The international debate about parliamentary
More informationIPU Committee on United Nations Affairs Item 4 10 October 2011
IPU Committee on United Nations Affairs UNC/2011/4-R.1 Item 4 10 October 2011 PARLIAMENTS AND THE ISTANBUL PROGRAMME OF ACTION (IPOA) FOR THE LEAST DEVELOPED COUNTRIES (LDCS) Mainstreaming the IPoA into
More informationPromoting Transparency and Accountability in the Extractive Industries: A Workshop for Legislators
Promoting Transparency and Accountability in the Extractive Industries: A Workshop for Legislators In many resource-rich countries in Africa, corruption and mismanagement in the extractive sector have
More informationPRACTICE AND PROCEDURE JUNE 2013
62 ND WESTMINSTER SEMINAR ON PARLIAMENTARY PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE 17 21 JUNE 2013 AIM 1. The aim of the seminar is to explore parliamentary practice and procedure within a Westminster-style framework in
More informationTHE PRIME MINISTER AND THE COUNCIL OF MINISTERS
THE PRIME MINISTER AND THE COUNCIL OF MINISTERS The Union Executive of India The Union Executive Our Constitution provides for a plan of democratic government. The Government at the centre is called Union
More informationPARLIAMENTARY TRANSPARENCY PLEDGE
NOTE: The following draft document was presented for discussion at a conference of parliamentary monitoring organization leaders held in Washington, D.C., from April 30 to May 2, 2012. Substantial comments
More informationFAQ s Global Connections, a Better Parliament: The New Zealand Parliament s Draft Inter-Parliamentary Relations Strategy,
FAQ s Global Connections, a Better Parliament: The New Zealand Parliament s Draft Inter-Parliamentary Relations Strategy, 2015-2019 1) What are Inter-Parliamentary Relations (IPR) and Parliamentary diplomacy?
More informationCitizen s Assessment of Parliaments Performance
Citizen s Assessment of Parliaments Performance AHMED MEHBOOB Just very briefly, PILDAT is an independent non-profit think tank dedicated to strengthening democracy and democratic institutions. There are
More informationParliamentary Representation: A Core Function
Parliamentary Representation: A Core Function Professor Mark Baskin, SUNY/CID, University at Albany Executive Training Program for Parliamentary Staff, 14 19 April 2013 Opening Questions 1. How Can Representation
More informationPARLIAMENT AND FINANCIAL SCRUTINY
PARLIAMENT AND FINANCIAL SCRUTINY THE CONSTITUTIONAL FUNCTION OF PARLIAMENT The Westminster System of Government is a representative system of government, that is, it is directly elected by the people.
More informationOpen Government and Democracy Policy
Open Government and Democracy Policy Spokesperson: James Shaw MP Updated: 16-Jan-2015 Vision The Green Party envisions an Aotearoa New Zealand in which: The government operates in a relationship with tangata
More informationWith the support of the European Union
1 Oversight Role of Parliament A publication of The Institute for Social Accountability (TISA) In partnership with CEPAD and World Vision Kenya With the support of the European Union 3 Published by: The
More informationCommission on Parliamentary Reform
Written Evidence from the Coalition for Racial Equality and Rights Introduction The Coalition for Racial Equality and Rights (CRER) is a Scottish strategic racial equality charity, based in Glasgow. We
More informationHow to do a Constitutional Convention in the UK
How to do a Constitutional Convention in the UK Updated: March 2016 Contact: Will Brett (will.brett@electoral-reform.org.uk / 07979 696 265) For more information, visit www.electoral-reform.org.uk/constitutional-convention
More informationThe Roles and Responsibilities Of Members of Parliament (MPs)
The Roles and Responsibilities Of Members of Parliament (MPs) The role of Parliament in Sierra Leone s democracy The Parliament of Sierra Leone is the legislative branch of government. As is the case with
More informationAct A law made by a legislative body and given assent by the head of state.
Glossary Act A law made by a legislative body and given assent by the head of state. Aso Rock (Nigeria) Declaration of 2003 A meeting of the high-powered experts on development and democracy that stressed
More informationPresented By: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE SAI AND FRANCOPHONE & ANGLOPHONE COMPARED NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE OF THE REPUBLIC OF THE GAMBIA
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE SAI AND PARLIAMENTARY AUDIT COMMITTEE: FRANCOPHONE & ANGLOPHONE COMPARED Presented By: KARAMBA TOURAY NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE OF THE REPUBLIC OF THE GAMBIA 4 th WAAPAC Annual
More informationInquiry into funding arrangements for Green Party liaison roles
Inquiry into funding arrangements for Green Party liaison roles This report sets out the outcome of our inquiry into the funding arrangements for the Green Party Ministerial liaison and relationship roles,
More informationAGL ENERGY LIMITED BOARD CHARTER 1. PURPOSE 2. ROLE AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF BOARD
AGL ENERGY LIMITED BOARD CHARTER 1. PURPOSE 1.1 The Board is responsible for the governance of AGL Energy Limited (AGL). This Board Charter (Charter) sets out the role, responsibilities, membership and
More informationUniversal Periodic Review: Opportunities for Parliamentary Involvement
Universal Periodic Review: Opportunities for Parliamentary Involvement The recent publication of the Scottish Government s response to the recommendations made by the UPR in 2017 is helpful and outlines
More informationUnit 10: Ministers, Members, Staff and Public Servants
Unit 10: Ministers, Members, Staff and Public Servants Learning Objectives How the Cycle of Stakeholders Interacts After studying this unit, you should be able to: Understand the responsibilities of Ministers
More informationPRINCIPLES OF GOOD DEMOCRATIC GOVERNANCE
PRINCIPLES OF GOOD DEMOCRATIC GOVERNANCE European Label of Governance Excellence (ELoGE) CENTRE OF EXPERTISE FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT REFORM 1. Participation, Representation, Fair Conduct of Elections 2. Responsiveness
More informationINTER-PARLIAMENTARY UNION
INTER-PARLIAMENTARY UNION CHEMIN DU POMMIER 5 1218 LE GRAND-SACONNEX / GENEVA (SWITZERLAND) TELEPHONE (41.22) 919 41 50 - FAX (41.22) 919 41 60 - E-MAIL postbox@mail.ipu.org THE ROLE OF PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEES
More informationPrinciples and Guidelines for Constituency Development Funds
Principles and Guidelines for Constituency Development Funds Constituency Development Fund Workshop 2011 The Commonwealth Parliamentary Association (CPA) in collaboration with the State University of New
More informationBOTSWANA ACCOUNTANCY OVERSIGHT AUTHORITY (BAOA)
BOTSWANA ACCOUNTANCY OVERSIGHT AUTHORITY (BAOA) BOARD CHARTER BOTSWANA ACCOUNTANCY OVERSIGHT AUTHORITY BOARD CHARTER 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS CONTENTS PAGE 1. OVERVIEW 3 2. PURPOSE 3 3. COMPOSITION 3 4. INDUCTION
More informationUnit 4: Strengthening Parliamentary Oversight to Prevent Conflict and Reduce Poverty
Unit 4: Strengthening Parliamentary Oversight to Prevent Conflict and Reduce Poverty Learning Objectives What does oversight have to do with conflict? After studying this unit you should be able to: Appreciate
More informationDRAFT REPORT ACP-EU JOINT PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLÉE PARLEMENTAIRE PARITAIRE ACP-UE on constitutional limits on presidential terms
ACP-EU JOINT PARLIAMTARY ASSEMBLY ASSEMBLÉE PARLEMTAIRE PARITAIRE ACP-UE Committee on Political Affairs 23.9.2016 DRAFT REPORT on constitutional limits on presidential terms Committee on Political Affairs
More informationInformation Brief. Parliamentary Autonomy. p f
Information Brief Parliamentary Autonomy 1A Wrightson Road Tower D, Port of Spain p. 624.7275 f. 625.4672 coth@ttparliament.org www.ttparliament.org INFORMATION BRIEF - MAY 2017 1 Background 1. In general,
More informationHow can ICTs help in the work of a Parliamentarian?
Regional Forum on Reinventing Government in Africa: Building Trust in Government 11-13 December 2006, Addis Ababa How can ICTs help in the work of a Parliamentarian? Joseph H. OWONA KONO Member of Parliament,
More informationWorld e-parliament Conference November Washington, D.C.
United Nations US House of Representatives Inter-Parliamentary Union Global Centre for ICT in Parliament World e-parliament Conference 2009 3-5 November 2009 - Washington, D.C. 3 November 2009 ANNOTATED
More informationAnalysis. The democratic accountability of the EU s legislative approach
Analysis The democratic accountability of the EU s legislative approach Steve Peers, Professor of Law, University of Essex The EU legislative process lacks the basic rudiments of openness and transparency
More informationFinal0501. Contents of Report
Gover nance Assistance of JICA -Toward indigenous development of democratic institutions, administrative functions and legal institutions in the developing world- Background and Purpose of Study Since
More informationAUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE CHARTER
AUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE CHARTER April 2013 1 INTRODUCTION The ABC Board has established the Audit & Risk Committee in compliance with Section 32 of the Commonwealth Authorities and Companies Act 1997 (CAC
More informationEstablishing a Multi-Stakeholder Group and National Secretariat
Construction Sector Transparency Initiative October 2013 / V1 Guidance Note: 4 Establishing a Multi-Stakeholder Group and National Secretariat Introduction An essential feature of CoST is the multi-stakeholder
More information2. Confirming that effective co-operation is only possible through effective communication;
Conclusions and recommendations of the 21 st UN/INTOSAI Symposium on effective practices of cooperation between supreme audit institutions and citizens to enhance public accountability 1. Emphasizing the
More informationKING IV APPLICATION REGISTER. We do it better
KING IV APPLICATION REGISTER 2017 We do it better 1 KING IV APPLICATION REGISTER APPLICATION OF KING IV African Rainbow Minerals Limited (ARM or the Company) supports the governance outcomes, principles
More informationONLINE PUBLIC CONSULTATION
DRAFT RECOMMENDATION OF THE COUNCIL ON PUBLIC INTEGRITY ONLINE PUBLIC CONSULTATION DEADLINE FOR COMMENT 22 MARCH 2016 The draft Recommendation of the Council on Public Integrity has been elaborated by
More informationBEUC RESPONSE TO THE STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION ON SMART REGULATION
BEUC RESPONSE TO THE STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION ON SMART REGULATION Contact: Ursula Pachl & Ilaria Passarani horizontalpolicy@beuc.eu Ref.: X/042/2010-25/06/10 EC register for interest representatives: identification
More informationINTER-PARLIAMENTARY UNION 118 th Assembly and related meetings Cape Town (South Africa), April 2008
INTER-PARLIAMENTARY UNION 118 th Assembly and related meetings Cape Town (South Africa), 13 18 April 2008 Second Standing Committee on C-II/118/DR-rev Sustainable Development, 22 February 2008 Finance
More informationThe ten-year framework of the Global Centre for ICT in Parliament
The ten-year framework of the Global Centre for ICT in Parliament 2011-2020 ECPRD Working Group on ICT Annual Meeting 18-19 November 2010 Bucharest, Romania Origins The Global Centre was launched in 2005,
More informationPierré Olivier Judge of the Supreme Court of Appeal: Bloemfontein
Appendix 1 : 4 The Latimer House Principles and Guidelines Introductory note Pierré Olivier Judge of the Supreme Court of Appeal: Bloemfontein I was privileged to attend the Joint Colloquium on Parliamentary
More informationThe Constitution and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms
6 The Constitution and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms Chapter Outline Constitutions and Constitutionality o Constitutional Functions Representation Power Rights Community, Identity, and Citizenship
More informationFeedback from the Open Government Partnership Support Unit, 7 August 2014
1 Feedback from the Open Government Partnership Support Unit, 7 August 2014 We have a few comments which I have posted below. As far as next steps, I think it is up to you whether to incorporate our feedback
More informationHow Parliaments Work: Parliamentary Processes and Procedures.
Guide to Parliaments. Paper 2. How Parliaments Work: Parliamentary Processes and Procedures. GPG s Guide to Parliaments series explores the key processes and functions of parliaments around the world.
More informationParliamentary Approaches to Corruption
Parliamentary Approaches to Corruption Query: What types of initiatives are being/have recently been undertaken on parliamentary approaches to corruption? Purpose: A colleague who is working on parliamentary
More informationCharity Governance Code. Checklist for small charities UNW LLP
Charity Governance Code UNW LLP Procedures in place Action required Organisational purpose: the board is clear about the charity s aims and ensures that these are being delivered effectively and sustainably
More informationParliamentary strengthening and the Paris Principles: Four country case studies
Parliamentary strengthening and the Paris Principles: Four country case studies A summary produced for the Wilton Park conference on Enhancing the effectiveness of parliaments: Challenges and opportunities,
More informationPublic Internal Control Systems in the European Union
Public Internal Control Systems in the European Union The three lines of defense in a Public Sector environment Discussion Paper No. 9 Ref. 2017-2 The information and views set out in this paper are those
More informationApplication of King III Corporate Governance Principles
Application of Corporate Governance Principles / 1 This table is a useful reference to each of the principles and how, in broad terms, they have been applied by the Group. The information should be read
More informationDOWNLOAD OR READ : PARLIAMENT PDF EBOOK EPUB MOBI
DOWNLOAD OR READ : PARLIAMENT PDF EBOOK EPUB MOBI Page 1 Page 2 parliament parliament pdf parliament The role of parliament in government varies depending a number of factors. This paper examines the effect
More informationKING III COMPLIANCE ANALYSIS
Principle element No Application method or explanation This document has been prepared in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements and sets out the application of the 75 Principles of the King III Report
More informationLegal Personnel. Dr Stephanie Law
Legal Personnel Dr Stephanie Law Stephanie.law@mpi.lu Constitutional Law of the United Kingdom A Brief Introduction Nature of the constitution Consitutional principles Parliament Devolution in the United
More informationADB/OECD Anti-Corruption Initiative for Asia and the Pacific
Regional Seminar on Political Economy of Corruption 9-10 September 2009, ADB Headquarters, Manila, Philippines Capacity Development and Governance Division Asian Development Bank Anti-Corruption Division
More informationSURVEY OF ANTI-CORRUPTION MEASURES IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR IN OECD COUNTRIES: KOREA
SURVEY OF ANTI-CORRUPTION MEASURES IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR IN OECD COUNTRIES: KOREA 1. What anti-corruption mechanisms exist for the public sector in your country? a) Legislation proscribing corrupt activities
More informationBoard Charter. 1.0 Purpose. 2.0 Functions and responsibilities
Board Charter 1.0 Purpose This Board Charter sets out the roles, responsibilities, composition, structure and approach of the Board the Company. The Board is responsible for the affairs and activities
More informationPost-monitoring dialogue with Monaco
Provisional version Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee) Post-monitoring dialogue with Monaco Rapporteur: Mr Jordi
More information136 th IPU Assembly. Reports on recent IPU specialized meetings #IPU136. Dhaka, Bangladesh, 1-5 April Item 7 13 February 2017
136 th IPU Assembly Dhaka, Bangladesh, 1-5 April 2017 Governing Council CL/200/7(a)-R.1 Item 7 13 February 2017 Reports on recent IPU specialized meetings (b) Parliamentary Meeting on the occasion of the
More informationSummary. The nature and scope of accounting officer appearances
Summary The nature and scope of accounting officer appearances The new accounting officer provisions of the Financial Administration Act (FAA) designate deputy ministers and deputy heads of designated
More informationTerms of Reference for Mind Committees
Terms of Reference for Mind Committees General notes relating to all committees 1. Committee Structure 1.1. The trustees at a Council of Management meeting in accordance with its Memorandum and Articles
More informationCOMMONWEALTH PARLIAMENTARY ASSOCIATION NOVEMBER, 2011 THE COMMONWEALTH AND THE ROLE OF THE CPA (SESSION NO. 1)
COMMONWEALTH PARLIAMENTARY ASSOCIATION 22 ND COMMONWEALTH PARLIAMENTARY SEMINAR NEW DELHI, INDIA 24-29 NOVEMBER, 2011 AGENDA: THE COMMONWEALTH AND THE ROLE OF THE CPA (SESSION NO. 1) FRIDAY, 25 NOVEMBER
More informationDECISION OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION
COMMISSION EUROPÉENNE SECRÉTARIAT GÉNÉRAL Direction A Greffe C(2017) 7810 Bruxelles, le 14 novembre 2017 DECISION OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION on the establishment of a Task Force on Subsidiarity,
More informationClerk Attachment to the Public Accounts Committee
Clerk Attachment to the Public Accounts Committee 9-20 April 2018 Montserrat Report Montserrat Clerk Attachment ii CONTENTS BACKGROUND KEY AREAS OF SUPPORT OUTCOMES & NEXT STEPS ONLINE PORTAL ABOUT CPA
More informationRIGHT TO INFORMATION IN INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS
RIGHT TO INFORMATION IN INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS Nepomuceno A. Malaluan Co-Director, Institute for Freedom of Information Presented at Panel on Building Community through Information Access Strategizing
More information6. Cross-Cutting Issues Indicators
6. Cross-Cutting Issues Indicators This thematic area evaluates in more detail several key topics that transcend each of the first four thematic areas. As such, the indicators in this section can be applied
More informationGovernment in Nova Scotia
Nova Scotia is one of 10 provinces and three territories that make up the federation of Canada. Canada is a constitutional monarchy, and the Head of State is Queen Elizabeth II, Sovereign of Canada. The
More informationWritten submission from Professor Gavin Little University of Stirling. Brief paper on possible common/shared frameworks and related issues 1.
Written submission from Professor Gavin Little University of Stirling Brief paper on possible common/shared frameworks and related issues 1. Context There is considerable uncertainty about the Brexit process
More informationGRADE NINE CANADA S FEDERAL POLITICAL SYSTEM CANADA PASSPORT
GRADE NINE CANADA S FEDERAL POLITICAL SYSTEM CANADA PASSPORT CHAPTER ONE How effectively does Canada s federal political system govern canada for all canadians? LEGISLATIVE BRANCH The Queen Canada is a
More informationCOATS GROUP PLC (the "Company") TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR THE AUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE Adopted by the Board on 28 July 2017
1. CONSTITUTION COATS GROUP PLC (the "Company") TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR THE AUDIT & RISK COMMITTEE Adopted by the Board on 28 July 2017 1.1 The Committee has been established by resolution of the Board
More informationCORPORATE GOVERNANCE King III - Compliance with Principles Assessment Year ending 31 December 2016
No N/A 1 Chapter 1 - Ethical leadership and corporate citizenship 1.1 The board s should provide effective leadership based on an ethical foundation 1.2 The board should ensure that the Company is and
More informationAct on the Finnish Broadcasting Company (1380/1993; amendments up to 436/2017 included)
Translation from Finnish Legally binding only in Finnish and Swedish Ministry of Transport and Communications, Finland Act on the Finnish Broadcasting Company (1380/1993; amendments up to 436/2017 included)
More informationA United Nations Parliamentary Assembly
A United Nations Parliamentary Assembly Frequently Asked Questions Introductory questions... 2 Questions on the added value and the political relevance... 3 Relationship with other UN institutions and
More informationIN CONFIDENCE. Targeted Review of the Commerce Act: Initation and Financing of Market Studies
IN CONFIDENCE OFFICE OF THE MINISTER OF COMMERCE AND CONSUMER AFFAIRS The Chair Cabinet Economic Growth and Infrastructure Committee Targeted Review of the Commerce Act: Initation and Financing of Market
More informationEFFECTIVE PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT ATTORNEY CHUCHUCHU NCHUNGA NCHUNGA DEPUTY GOVERNMENT ATTORNEY - BOTSWANA
EFFECTIVE PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT ATTORNEY CHUCHUCHU NCHUNGA NCHUNGA DEPUTY GOVERNMENT ATTORNEY - BOTSWANA What is the justification of parliamentary oversight? 1. Our constitution and representative democracy
More informationSTANDARDS, PROCEDURES AND PUBLIC APPOINTMENTS COMMITTEE INQUIRY INTO LOBBYING
STANDARDS, PROCEDURES AND PUBLIC APPOINTMENTS COMMITTEE INQUIRY INTO LOBBYING SUBMISSION RECEIVED FROM PAGODA PUBLIC RELATIONS LIMITED Q1 Have there been significant changes over the last decade in the
More information10 th WORLD CONFERENCE OF THE INTERNATIONAL OMBUDSMAN INSTITUTE WELLINGTON, NEW ZEALAND, NOVEMBER 2012
10 th WORLD CONFERENCE OF THE INTERNATIONAL OMBUDSMAN INSTITUTE WELLINGTON, NEW ZEALAND, 12-16 NOVEMBER 2012 Speaking truth to power-the role of the ombudsman in the 21 st century Session I- Innovative
More informationThe Relationship Between Parliament and the Agents of Parliament Seminar Offered by the Canadian Study of Parliament Group
Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner Commissariat aux conflits d intérêts et à l éthique PRESENTATIONS & SPEECHES CHECK AGAINST DELIVERY The Relationship Between Parliament and the
More informationRISK MANAGEMENT & AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER
RISK MANAGEMENT & AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARTER August 2014 Energy Action Limited ABN 90 137 363 636 Contents 1 Introduction.3 2 Purpose 3 3 Authority 3 4 Composition 4 5 Meetings 4 5.1 Quorum & voting 4 5.2
More informationTWENTY-THREE RECOMMENDATIONS
EUROPEAN AFFAIRS COMMITTEE DANISH PARLIAMENT JANUARY 2014 TWENTY-THREE RECOMMENDATIONS - to strengthen the role of national parliaments in a changing European governance 1 I) INTRODUCTION The European
More informationOWUSU FOSTER YEAR IV, LL.B F A C U L T Y O F L A W K W A M E N K R U M A H U N I V E R S I T Y O F S C I E N C E A N D T E C H N O L O G Y
CAN THE COMMONWEALTH (LATIMER HOUSE) PRINCPLES ON THREE BRANCHES OF GOVERNMENT 2003 SERVE AS AN EFFECTIVE FRAMEWORK FOR SAFEGUARDING DEMOCRACY AND RULE OF LAW IN COMMONWEALTH COUNTRIES? OWUSU FOSTER YEAR
More informationCode of Corporate Governance
Code of Corporate Governance 1 FOREWORD From the Chairman of the General Purposes Committee I am pleased to endorse this Code of Corporate Governance, which sets out the commitment of Cambridgeshire County
More informationThe Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections (BERSIH 2.0)
The Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections (BERSIH 2.0) Electoral Reform Action Plan May 2018 1.0 Introduction 1.1 The Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections (BERSIH 2.0) is a coalition of 92 nongovernmental
More informationJD SPORTS FASHION PLC (THE "COMPANY") AUDIT COMMITTEE TERMS OF REFERENCE
JD SPORTS FASHION PLC (THE "COMPANY") AUDIT COMMITTEE TERMS OF REFERENCE 1 CONSTITUTION 1.1 The committee has been established by resolution of the board of directors of the Company (the "Board") and is
More informationVolex plc (the "Company") Audit Committee. Terms of Reference
Volex plc (the "Company") Audit Committee Terms of Reference 1. Overview The Audit Committee has been established by resolution of the Board of Directors of the Company (the "Board"). 2. Membership 2.1
More informationIn a federal constitution, there are two sets of governments. federal and states- which are constitutionally allocated
In a federal constitution, there are two sets of governments federal and states- which are constitutionally allocated exclusive as well as shared jurisdiction. For this reason, Inter- Governmental Agencies
More informationThe Institute of Directors of South Africa ( IoDSA ) is the convener of the King Committee and the custodian of the King reports and practice notes.
ANDULELA INVESTMENT HOLDINGS LIMITED CORPORATE GOVERNANCE Corporate Governance Overview December 2016 The Board of Directors is committed to the implementation of good corporate governance within the group
More informationAction Plan for Strengthening Legislative and Oversight Role. of the Parliament of Montenegro in 2015
PARLIAMENT OF MONTENEGRO Action Plan for Strengthening Legislative and Oversight Role of the Parliament of Montenegro in 2015 February 2015 Introduction The adoption of the Action Plan for Strengthening
More informationHelp Sheet 1: Legislative Processes in the United Kingdom
1 Help Sheet 1: Legislative Processes in the United Kingdom Introduction This Help Sheet is designed for readers who are not familiar with the system of legislation in the United Kingdom. It provides a
More informationBrussels, 20 November 2018 Kees Sterk, President of the ENCJ LIBE hearing on the Rule of Law in Poland
Brussels, 20 November 2018 Kees Sterk, President of the ENCJ LIBE hearing on the Rule of Law in Poland Mr. Chairman, thank you for the kind invitation to participate in this public hearing. Let me first
More informationThe role of civil society in Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative processes. Presentation at the University of the West Indies
The role of civil society in Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative processes Presentation at the University of the West Indies St. Augustine, Trinidad & Tobago November 15, 2005 Ole Andreassen,
More informationBoard Policy 1 Division Foundation Statements
Board Policy 1 Division Foundation Statements The Board of Trustees is a democratically elected body that holds in trust the education of students on behalf of the citizens of Golden Hills and is accountable
More informationIbstock plc. (the Company) Audit Committee - Terms of Reference
Ibstock plc (the Company) Audit Committee - Terms of Reference 1. PURPOSE 1.1 The role of the Audit Committee (the Committee) is to: monitor the integrity of the financial statements and related announcements
More informationCORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES
Enacted October 30, 2015 Revised June 28, 2017 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE GUIDELINES MARUBUN Corporation CHAPTER 1 GENERAL PROVISIONS 1-1.Purpose The purpose of these Guidelines is to provide for a basic framework
More informationParliament and the budgetary process, including from a gender perspective PRACTICAL INFORMATION
Congress of the Philippines Parliament and the ary process, including from a gender perspective Regional seminar for ASEAN+3 Parliaments Manila (Philippines) 23-25 July 2002 Inter-Parliamentary Union PRACTICAL
More informationCITY OF PALO ALTO COUNCIL PROTOCOLS
CITY OF PALO ALTO COUNCIL PROTOCOLS All Council Members All members of the City Council, including those serving as Mayor and Vice Mayor, have equal votes. No Council Member has more power than any other
More informationCONSTITUTION SPECIFICATION: Shabna.Begum
SPECIFICATION: Nature of the constitution a knowledge and understanding of the features of a constitution and of the benefits of constitutional government, including the differences between codified and
More informationKING III CHECKLIST. We do it better
KING III CHECKLIST 2016 We do it better 1 KING III CHECKLIST African Rainbow Minerals Limited (ARM or the Company) supports the principles and practices set out in the King Report on Governance for South
More information