TASK 42. Biorefining Sustainable Processing of Biomass into a Spectrum of Marketable Bio-based Products and Bioenergy

Transcription

1 ExCo73 Doc TASK 42 Biorefining Sustainable Processing of Biomass into a Spectrum of Marketable Bio-based Products and Bioenergy Progress eport ExCo74 Brussels, Belgium October 2014 Prepared by: ené van ee, Task Leader, Checked by: Kees Kwant, Operating Agent

2 TASK 42 POGESS EPOT 1. ADMINISTATIVE TASK INFOMATION Operating Agent: Task Leader: Assistant Task Leader: National Team Leaders: Kees Kwant ené van ee Ed de Jong Geoff Bell (Australia) Gerfried Jungmeier (Austria) Maria Wellisch (Canada) Claus Felby, Henning Jorgensen (Denmark) Heinz Stichnothe (Germany) Matthew Clancy a.i.(ireland) Isabella De Bari (Italy) Shinya Kimura (Japan) ené van ee, Ed de Jong (the Netherlands) Kirk Torr (New Zealand) Jim Spaeth (US) Annual Budget (US$) Contributions from Member Countries for , Less 2013 contribution to Strategic Fund (SF) and TC -19, Sub total 173, Funds carried forward from , funds received after 31 Dec , (Can) 2013 funds received after 31 Dec , (Can) Budget for 2014 (US$) 210, Budget for 2014 ( ) 152, = US$ (exchange rate ) Budget break down Category Budget 2014 Budget 2014 US$ Spent as by 01/10/14 Operational daily Task management Salaries and Benefits 64, , Travel and Subsistence 5, , Activity 1. Market deployment aspects 5, Activity 2. Stakeholder support BioEconomy 27, , Activity 3. Sustainable biomass valorisation 7, * 20, * Activity 4. Policy advice 5, Activity 5. Knowledge dissemination Poster, reports, brochure 10, Task/stakeholder meetings (4) 9, Website and database maintenance 7, , International events 5, , Training 5, , emaining Budget Total 152, , , % Spent as by 01/10/14 US$ 148, % 1 = US$ (exchange rate ) * Additional hire AT/IT (20 k ) for ExCo BioEconomy Activity (will be compensated by savings elsewhere) Page 1

3 Biorefining to sustainably co-produce food & feed ingredients and bio-based products (materials, chemicals, fuels & energy) out of a variety of biomass sources [Wageningen U, 2014] Page 2

4 2. SIGNIFICANT ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE LAST EXCO MEETING Targets reached and deliverables since last reporting Activity 1. Assessing the market deployment aspects for integrated biorefineries 1.1 Technical and non-technical critical success factors (coordination: U.S.) The U.S. Task42 representative Jim Spaeth has given extensive lectures on this issue at both the 15 th and 16 th Task42 Progress Meetings in Berlin and Hamburg dealing with specifically the U.S.-situation. He also brought in a table to structure the (critical) success factors of integrated biorefineries. The other country representatives were asked to provide input from their specific countries, so that Jim can include the info in the overall report. Both lectures and the report are delivered (D1.1), and available on the Task42 website. 1.2 Disruptive/game changing technologies (coordination: the Netherlands) At the 15 th and 16 th Task Progress Meetings in Berlin and Hamburg this activity was extensively discussed. It was decided to modify the title of this activity to The influence of game changing developments on the market deployment of biorefineries. Because not only technology (and impact) is game changing the word technologies is changed to developments (i.e. including policies etc.). Instead of a report a slide-deck (a set of power-point slides) is made. The full slide-deck is available for the partners on the intranet, and a more generic one including a 1-2 summarising paper on the Task42 website for wider knowledge dissemination. 1.3 Central vs. decentral processing (coordination: the Netherlands.) This activity originally was put into the work programme by France. As France finally decided not to join Task42 for this triennium no budget is available to extensively execute this activity. Instead of this Wageningen U will prepare a short 1-2 pager text on this issue based on its own expertise and available information. After check and possible additions by the other Task42 partners this 1-2 pager (D1.3) will be put on the website before the end of No workshop on this issue (ws1) will be organised. 1.4 Biorefinery-Complexity-Index (BCI) (coordination: Austria) All results and thoughts so far are documented in a working document The Biorefinery Complexity Index (D1.4), that is available at the Task42 website (Market Deployment BCI) for comments and the wider knowledge dissemination. Activity 2. Supporting industrial/sme stakeholders finding their position in a future BioEconomy 2.1 ole involved market sectors (coordination: Denmark) In a future BioEconomy available biomass resources will be used for a variety of both food and non-food applications, including biofuels and bioenergy. Current use patterns will change, and also the role of (industrial) stakeholders in the market sectors concerned will change. Available and potential new biomass resources will be used sustainably and as efficient as possible to meet huge future multiple market requests. A challenge is to bridge between industrial sectors that have no or only few connections before, aiming at new combinations of (industrial) stakeholders jointly responding to the specific market requests in the BioEconomy. A stakeholder workshop (ws2) with the title The role of industry in a transition towards the BioEconomy in relation to biorefinery was organised on 3 September 2014 from 13:00-16:00, as part of the i-sup (Innovation for Sustainable Production) Conference, 1-3 September 2014, Antwerp, Belgium ( Page 3

5 The minutes of this workshop are currently being made, and will be put on the website (Stakeholders Positioning ole Involved Market Sectors) as soon as available. Further, the questionnaire prepared for this Workshop is sent out to a variety of industrial/sme stakeholders (3 per country) to receive their reactions. The results of both the Workshop and the stakeholder consultation will be analysed and processed in Q4 2014, and finally will be reported (D2.1) at the Task42 website by the end of 2014 at the latest. 2.2 Upgrading strategies existing industrial infrastructures (coordination: Austria) Based on the results of the first assessments a discussion note (slide-deck) is be made (Q2 2014), see Stakeholders Positioning Upgrading of Existing Infrastructures to Biorefineries website. This discussion note is used as starting point for the set-up of a stakeholder workshop (ws2b) which is organised in Q (combined with ws2a, activity 2.1). At this workshop industrial stakeholders from different market sectors of the BioEconomy were asked to present i) their views on using existing industrial infrastructures for upgrading to high-efficiency integrated biorefineries and ii) examples of already running integrated biorefineries showing the advantages of using existing infrastructures as a point-of-departure. This workshop (ws2) with the title The role of industry in a transition towards the BioEconomy in relation to biorefinery has been organised on 3 September 2014 from 13:00-16:00 as part of the i-sup (Innovation for Sustainable Production) Conference, 1-3 September 2014, Antwerp, Belgium ( The minutes of this workshop are currently being made, and will be put on the website (Stakeholders Positioning Upgrading of Existing Infrastructures to Biorefineries) as soon as available. Further, the questionnaire prepared for this Workshop is sent out to a variety of industrial/sme stakeholders (3 per country) to receive their reactions. The results of both the Workshop and the stakeholder consultation will be analysed and processed in Q4 2014, and finally will be reported (D2.2) at the Task42 website by the end of 2014 at the latest. 2.3 Factsheets major biorefineries and national case studies (coordination: Austria) Joanneum esearch (AT) with the contribution of the other Task partners has developed a generic setup of a 4-pager factsheet (FC) to present main data of major biorefineries and national case studies. Data that are included in the factsheet are: 1. Part A (generic): classification (naming) biorefinery, description biorefinery, block scheme and/or photo biorefinery, mass balance and revenues biorefinery 2. Part B (country and site specific): quick sustainability assessment biorefinery, including cumulated energy demand [PJ/a], cumulated greenhouse gas emissions [kt CO2-eq/a], and cumulated costs/revenues [MEuros/a] 3. Annex 1: method and data sustainability assessment 4. Annex 2: Main assumptions and modelling choices The goal of this activity is to use this factsheet set-up for presenting major biorefineries and national case studies in a clear and similar way for dissemination of best-practices to stakeholders active in the BioEconomy to accelerate the market deployment. Till now 8 factsheets have been made, see Factsheets, viz. factsheets of a : 4-platform (biogas, green juice, green fibres, electricity&heat) biorefinery using grass silage and food residues for bio plastic, insulation material, fertilizer, electricity 3-platform (black liquor, pulp, electricity&heat) biorefinery using wood chips for pulp, paper, turpentine, tall oil, bark, electricity and heat 1-platform (C6 sugars) biorefinery using starch crops for bioethanol and feed 3-platform (C6&C5 sugar, electricity&heat, lignin) biorefinery using wood chips for bioethanol, electricity, heat and phenols 1-platform (oil) biorefinery using oilseed crops for biodiesel, glycerine and feed Page 4

6 1-platform (oil) biorefinery using oil based residues for biodiesel, glycerine, bio oil and fertilizer 2-platform (electricity&heat, syngas) biorefinery using wood chips for FT-biofuels, electricity, heat and waxes with steam gasification 3-platform (pyrolysis oil, syngas, electricity&heat) biorefinery using straw for FT-biofuels and methanol with oxygen gasification All Task42 partners are now actively looking for industrial stakeholders to provide data for the preparation of additional factsheets in the coming months. Also a data-input form is available at the Task42 website, to invite stakeholders from outside Task42 to provide data and/or to get in contact to prepare additional factsheets Bio-based products report: proteins for food and non-food applications (coordination: Netherlands) The main goal of this report is to give stakeholders of the BioEconomy a better insight in i) the potential economic optimisation biofuel production processes by giving higher added-value to the protein fraction of the biomass sources used (bio transportation fuel sector), and ii) the refinery options to synergistically and sustainably process protein-rich biomass sources to food/feed ingredients, bio-based products for technical applications non-food, and energy (fuels, power and/or heat). The Dutch team has set-up a first draft report with the following content: 1. Intro: BioEconomy, markets, biomass availability, biomass compositions, biomass valorisation potential, biorefining, platforms, and the role of proteins 2. Proteins: intro, conventional crops, traditional markets (human food, animal feed, technical applications), new sources (herb. biomass, algae, duckweed, others), upcoming market (food & feed ingredients, bio-based applications, amino-acids valorisation) 3. Biorefining of protein containing biomass: oil crops, starch crops, herb. biomass, aquatic biomass, meat residues, DDGS 4. Protein-driven biorefining initiatives in Task42 partnering countries 5. Sustainability assessment protein-driven biorefinery example 6. Stakeholders Task42 partnering countries eferences The first three chapters are filled-in and currently checked and finalised by some Wageningen U (NL) experts. For the fourth chapter currently descriptions are being made of some running protein-driven biorefinery plants in the NL, DEN, AT and NZ. The NL case is selected for further sustainability assessment by the Austrian partner, potentially showing the advantages of valorising protein fractions on the overall sustainability of a biomass valorisation process. All partners further are asked to complete a table showing major national protein-related stakeholders in their specific countries. It is expected that the report (D2.4.2) will be finalised in Q4 2014, and that a glossy paper copy will be available for dissemination in M24. Page 5

7 Activity 3. Optimal sustainable biomass valorisation approaches for Food and Non-food within a market pull approach 3.1 Sustainability assessment toolbox (coordination: Canada) This activity was modified to further elaboration of the LEEAFF indicators a conceptual framework used in Canada by literature review and linking this activity to the one in the inter-tasks project (act. 3.2). Country representatives are asked to use the available questionnaire (CAN) for identifying the LEEAFF sustainability indicators at those stakeholders that are contacted for delivering the factsheet data. Depending on the input received, it will be decided if this more qualitative info will be added as a fifth page to the standardised factsheet prepared by AT. The current progress is shown by the lecture given by Maria Wellisch at the Task42 Progress Meeting in Berlin, see Task42 Sustainable Biomass Valorisation LEEAFF Procedure for Biorefinery Sustainability Assessment. 3.2 Mobilising sustainable bioenergy supply chains (coordination: Germany) This strategically funded inter-task project coordinated by Task43 was kicked-off by the end of So far, Task42 is directly involved in the corn stover case (CAN) and the biogas case (D). Gerfried Jungmeier (AT) potentially will be involved later on to put the case results if possible in the factsheet methodology developed by Task42, with the goal to optimise the final knowledge dissemination, and potentially to make a proper case comparison possible. From a Task42 point-of-view this project should consider both the assessment of conventional reference supply valorisation chains (bioethanol, biogas,...) and more advanced and optimised refinery chains in which chain and process residues are valorised to added-value bio-based products to improve overall economics. 3.4 Optimal sustainable biomass valorisation (coordination: the Netherlands) This activity is replaced by the ExCo (Kwant/Sipila) request to give an overview of BioEconomy Strategies in IEA Bioenergy Implementing Agreement participating countries. The assessment has been performed by AT//IT in Q The major result of this activity will be presented at ExCo74, and be put on the Task42 website for further dissemination in Q Further, selected Task triennium results on sustainable biomass valorisation using biorefineries will be presented at the End-of-Triennium Conference (IS) of IEA Bioenergy in Berlin (Germany) in Q Page 6

8 Activity 4. Preparing policy advice on further needs 4.1 oadmap Biorefinery (coordination: the Netherlands) No activities. The ExCo-representative of the IEA Headquarters told at the 72 th ExCo-meeting in Korea that they are not planning such an activity within the short-term. 4.3 Country reporting (coordination: Netherlands) At the 15 th Task Progress Meeting in Berlin (Jan 2014) it was decided that every participating country has to prepare one country report within this triennium. ené has provided a generic Power-point set-up for the preparation of these reports. All countries were asked to deliver a first report before the next Task42 Progress Meeting in Canada in December For the time being, only Germany and Italy have delivered. The country reports will be used for knowledge dissemination at national and international events. Activity 5. Organising knowledge dissemination activities (coordination: the Netherlands) 5.1 Bi-annual Task meetings, stakeholder meetings and excursions (coordination: Netherlands) The 15 th Task42 Progress Meeting was organised from January 2014 in Berlin, Germany. This Task42 Progress Meeting was coupled to the International Conference Fuels-of-the-Future (20/ ) and a joint T42/T39 Meeting in the morning of At this joint meeting was decided to co-operate in the fields of Country eport (to be sure to report consistent data) preparation and the Factsheet Activities (T39 stakeholders provide input-data for T42 assessments). The 16 th Task42 Progress Meeting was organised on 25 June 2014, Hamburg, Germany; coupled to the 22 nd European Biomass Conference and Exhibition (EU BC&E 2014) June This was an additional Progress Meeting in the mid of this triennium period to i) overcome the long period between Q1 and Q4 and ii) to further monitor and steer the activities in the work plan. Not all partners were able to attend, however, the meeting was very efficient for progress monitoring and making additional appointments. For the other Meetings, the following locations have been selected: 17 th Task42 Progress Meeting: 4-5 December 2014, Guelph (near Toronto), Canada. Task meeting in conjunction with the Canadian Bio-Economy Summit that will be held in Toronto, December 1-3, Task42 potentially will organise a session to this conference on 3 December th Task42 Progress Meeting: Italy with excursion to the Nova Mont plant and a joint workshop with Task40, 5-7 May th Task52 Progress Meeting : Berlin, October/November 2015 (coupled to end-of-triennium conference). Page 7

9 5.2 Annual Task meetings at national level (coordination: Netherlands) Netherlands On 6 February 2014, AgentschapNL (VO) organised the so called Praktijkdag Bioenergie in de Doelen in otterdam, the Netherlands. At this event, an IEA Bioenergy information stand was organised, with the goal to disseminate international IEA Bioenergy information in general, with a focus on info produced by the Tasks in which the NL is participating in, to interested Dutch stakeholders. With a few hundred participants this event was very successful, and also the dissemination of IEA Bioenergy results made use of this large audience. Canada A biorefinery page has been established on a Canadian federal government website: Community. This page contains information on Task 42 meetings and project activities, including the inter-task project: Mobilising sustainable bioenergy supply chains. IEA Bioenergy Task 42 updates are also given at the meetings of the Federal-Provincial- Territorial Bio-products Working Group (an inter-governmental forum on the BioEconomy). 5.3 Task website (coordination: the Netherlands) At the Task42 Progress Meeting in Wageningen in April 2013 it was decided to set-up a new website for Task42. This website is in operation since December Address: Task reports An updated Task42 poster/leaflet was prepared in Q A Glossy Task42 Brochure, including: country specific biorefining challenges; vision and contribution IEA Bioenergy Task42; definition, classification and factsheets; sustainability issues biofuel-driven biorefineries; value-added products from biorefineries; training activities; website; commercial, demo and pilot plants in participating countries: more than 35 1 pager descriptions; activity plan ; table with full overview biorefinery plants in participating countries was published in September This brochure is available in H and L on the Task42 News, and Publications eports. 5.6 International conferences and workshops Van ee., co-organisation and chairing of the Biorefinery Platforms the World Biofuels Markets Conference (WBM-2013) (including a short Task42 lecture), otterdam, the Netherlands on 12 March Stichnothe H., IEA Task42 Overview 52 th Tutzing Symposium One year on: Germany s Biorefinery oadmap in an International Context, Tutzing, Germany, 11 June Jungmeier G. et al., A Biorefinery Fact Sheet for the Sustainability Assessment of Energy Driven Biorefineries Efforts of IEA Bioenergy Task 42 Biorefining, 21th EU BC&E, Copenhagen, Denmark, 3-7 June Jungmeier G., Possible ole of a Biorefinery s Syngas Platform in a Bio-based Economy Assessment in IEA Bioenergy Task 42 Biorefinery, ICPS 13 - International Conference on Polygeneration Strategies, Vienna, Austria, 3-5 September Jungmeier G., Facts & Figures of Producing Biofuels in Biorefineries Current Status and Future Perspectives, 8 th A3PS Conference Eco-Mobility 2013, Vienna, Austria, 3-4 October Jungmeier G., The Austrian Participation in IEA Bioenergy Task42 Biorefining, Austrian Stakeholder Meeting, Graz, Austria, 24 October Van ee., Achievements of IEA Bioenergy Task42 Biorefining, Austrian Stakeholder Meeting, Graz, Austria, 24 October Stichnothe H., Update of the German Biorefinery oadmap, Austrian Stakeholder Meeting, Graz, Austria, 24 October Page 8

10 Jorgensen H., Using Straw and MSW for Biorefineries in Denmark Technical Developments and Demonstration Activities, Austrian Stakeholder Meeting, Graz, Austria, 24 October De Bari I., Biorefineries and Green Chemistry in Italy Overview of Applied &D, Demo and Industrial Breakthroughs, Austrian Stakeholder Meeting, Graz, Austria, 24 October Wellisch M. et al, Building Sustainable Biomass Supply Chains, International Forest Biorefinery Symposium, Montreal, QC, 3-4 February de Jong Ed, Task42/Avantium Tomorrow s Biorefineries Event, Brussels, Belgium, February Van ee., chairing of 2 Biorefinery the World Bio Markets Conference (WBM-2014) (including a short Task42 lecture), Amsterdam, the Netherlands, 4-6 March Van ee., The role of industry in a transition towards the BioEconomy (BE) in relation to biorefinery Overview Task42, Task42 i-sup Conference, 3 September, Antwerp, Belgium. Jungmeier G., Approach for the Integration of Biorefineries in the Existing Industrial Infrastructures, Task42 i-sup Conference, 3 September, Antwerp, Belgium. 6. Developing and organising training activities The 3 rd European Biorefining Training School was organised within the framework of the EU FP7 Climate KIC Initiative by Wageningen U, INA, NTUA and a Hungarian partner, in Budapest, Hungary, 7-10 July See: Task42 has used this event as dissemination opportunity by provision of 3 lectures / training modules provided by ené, Ed and Gerfried. Page 9

11 Deliverables 2014 No. What Who Due date Status 1.1 eport Critical Success factors Biorefineries US M18 -> M21 Delivered 1.2 eport Disruptive / Game Changing Biorefinery AUS NL M12 -> M21 Delivered Technologies 1.3 eport advantages decentral biorefineries / WS1 FA M24 / M21 In progress / X NL 1.4 eport/paper Biorefinery-Complexity-Index AT M6 -> M18 Delivered 2.1.1/ WS 2a and 2b / Questionnaire D AT/DEN M12 -> M21 Delivered / In progress eport Upgrading Strategies Industrial Infrastructures D AT M12 -> M24 Delivered / In progress / 2.3 Glossy Leaflets D AT M12 -> M24 8 Delivered and in progress Bio-based Chemicals eport NL M24 -> M30 Postponed Bio-based Proteins eport NL M36 -> M24 In progress 3.1 LEEAFF Progress eports CAN M24/M36 In progress 3.2 Mobilising sustainable value chains D M36 In progress Contribution to T40/T42 report D M24 In progress Participation in related workshop (ws3) NL M12 -> M29 May International Seminar Sustainable Value Chain Dev NL M33 EOT CONF eport Sust Value Chains BioEconomy Strategies NL M36 M21 Delivered AT/IT 4.3 Country eports (ppts) IT NL M36 -> M24 In progress 5.1 Bi-annual Task Meetings, incl. industrial stakeholder meetings and excursions, agenda and reporting NL M6, M12, M18, M24 Delivered M4, M11, M13, M Integrated report Annual National Task42 Meetings Info integrated in Bi-annual Progress eport for ExCo NL M12, M24 Delivered M11, M Task website NL MO Delivered M0, new one M Task newsletters (electronically, 4 a year) NL Quarterly -> First one M24 twice a year 5.5 Task eports and Brochures, see above + NL Glossy Task42 Brochure with background, results and further work Glossy Task42 Poster to be used at conferences Glossy Task42 Leaflet with Activity M33 -> M21 M6 M3 Delivered M21 Delivered M2 Delivered M2 Programme 6. Annual Biorefining Training / Summer School NL Annually Delivered M19 Hungary Page 10

12 3. POBLEMS, DELAYS, ADDITIONAL FUNDING, AND COOPEATIONS Problems & Delays Irish representative in Task42 For the time being, the Irish ExCo Alternate Member Matthew Clancy is acting as a.i. Task42 representative. A new representing expert is currently being sought by the Irish government Updating of the Bio-chemicals eport (coordination; the Netherlands) At the 15 th Task42 Meeting in Berlin (Jan 2014) it was decided to make this update in the first half of 2015 instead of the second half of The due date for the report is rescheduled to the 1 st of July Future market demand for biomass from a BioEconomy perspective (coordination: the Netherlands) This is a joint project activity of Task40 and Task 42. Within this project the potential international supply, trade and demand for biomass for energy and fuel applications within a competing BioEconomy market will be assessed, including the identification of improved and new value chains. The project will include emerging demand regions, with an increased focus on (S)E Asia (Japan, China, Korea, Malaysia). Task 42 will contribute to this project by providing info on: which types of biorefineries are expected to be implemented as a function of the time, which feedstocks will they use, and where will they be located. Task40 will provide complementary analysis in which the possible feedstock supply in terms of available quantities, countries of origins, types of supply chains, and feedstocks cost levels at the biorefinery gate will be investigated. During 2014 Task 40 came-up with a draft set-up of a report to be prepared. Within this report Task42 will provide a chapter on Biorefineries Guiding the Global Bio-Based Economy, coordinated by Germany, and to be delivered as draft by the end of The draft results of the work will be presented at a (Italian) stakeholder workshop (ws3) that will be organised in Porto Torrres, Sicily (Italy) on the 6 th of May After the workshop the report (D3.3) will be finalised and published on the websites of both Tasks. 5.4 Task newsletters (coordination: the Netherlands) No Task newsletters were made so far. It was decided to make a newsletter in the month following the (bi-annual) Task42 Progress Meetings. The newsletter will contain biorefinery news from partnering countries (presented at roundtable Task Progress meeting), such as: new commercial/demo/pilot plants, new projects, new regional initiatives, policy issues, new publications, and biorefinery related events from the international calendar. A first one will be made directly after the Canada Progress Meeting in December Additional funding - Cooperations Task 43, 42, 40, 39, 38 and 29 in Strategic Fund activity 3.2 Task 40 and 42 in activity 3.3. a/o. workshop in Italy in Q Tasks 34/39 and 42 in activity 2.3 Task39 and Task42: Advanced Biofuels within a Biorefinery Approach workshop at the Fuels for the Future Conference, Berlin, Germany, January 2013 Page 11

13 4. GANTT CHAT OF TASK 42 FO THE CUENT TIENNIUM Activity No. Topic Status Alarm Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 1. Assessing the market deployment aspects for integrated biorefineries 1.1 Technical & non-technical critical success Planning factors 1.2 Disruptive/game changing technologies Planning 1.3 Central vs. decentral processing Planning ws1 1.4 Biorefinery-Complexity-Index Planning 2. Supporting industrial/sme stakeholders finding their position in a future BioEconomy 2.1 ole involved market sectors Planning ws ws2 2a 2.2 Upgrading strategies existing industrial Planning 2b infrastructures ws2 2.3 Factsheets major biorefineries / national case Planning FS studies FS Bio-based chemicals report Planning Bio-based products report: proteins for food Planning and non-food applications 3. Analysing optimal sustainable biomass valorisation approaches for food and non-food applications within a market-pull approach 3.1 Sustainability assessment toolbox Planning wd 3.2 Mobilising sustainable bioenergy supply Planning chains : eport; ws: workshop; FS: factsheets; IS: international seminar; tm: Task meeting; ntm: national Task meeting; nl: newsletter; TB: Task brochure; TP: Task poster; TL: Task leaflet; TS: training school Page 12

14 GANTT CHAT OF TASK 42 FO THE CUENT TIENNIUM (CONTINUED) Activity No. Topic Status Alarm Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 3. Analysing optimal sustainable biomass valorisation approaches for food and non-food applications within a market-pull approach (continued) 3.3 Future market demand for biomass from the Planning ws3 BioEconomy perspective ws3 3.4 Optimal sustainable biomass valorisation Planning IS 4. Preparing policy advice on further needs IS 4.1 oadmap Biorefinery Planning To be decided by IEA Headquarters 4.2 Biorefinery (related) policies in participating countries Planning ws4 ws4 4.3 Country reporting Planning One per country + updating One per country + updating 5. Organising knowledge dissemination activities 5.1 Bi-annual Task meetings, stakeholder Planning Tm tm tm tm tm tm meetings and excursions Tm tm tm tm tm tm tm 5.2 Annual Task meetings at national level Planning ntm Ntm ntm 5.3 Task website, incl. database Planning 5.4 Task newsletters Planning nl nl nl nl nl nl nl nl nl nl nl nl nl nl nl 5.5 Glossy Task42 brochure, poster, leaflet Planning TL TP TB 5.6 International conferences and workshops Planning 6. Developing and organising training activities TL TP TB 6.1 Annual training school on biorefining Planning TS2013 TS2014 TS2015 TS2014 : eport; ws: workshop; FS: factsheets; IS: international seminar; tm: Task meeting; ntm: national Task meeting; nl: newsletter; TB: Task brochure; TP: Task poster; TL: Task leaflet; TS: training school Page 13