MODELING OF INDIA s NATIONAL POWER GRID ECONOMIC BENEFITS FROM COORDINATED EXPANSIONS Node Model DATA INPUTS & RESULTS

Transcription

1 MODELING OF INDIA s NATIONAL POWER GRID ECONOMIC BENEFITS FROM COORDINATED EXPANSIONS PURDUE LONG-TERM TRADING & CAPACITY EXPANSION MODEL Generation & Transmission 22 Node Model DATA INPUTS & RESULTS Brian H. Bowen Devendra Canchi Energy Center at Discovery Park Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA Em: bhbowen@purdue.edu August 12, 2008 Re: Paper Options for Strengthening India s National Power Grid Using the Purdue Long-Term Least Cost, Generation and Transmission Model Brian H. Bowen, Devendra Canchi, Paul V. Preckel, F.T. Sparrow IEEE Power India Conference, New Delhi, India, October 12-15, 2008

2 DATA INPUTS 2

3

4 Natural Gas Imports (Thousand Tons)

5 Source: Ranju Sarkar, The Pipeline Row Business World 10 Nov,

6

7 Source: Central Electricity Authority, Govt. of India

8 Note: The above grid was derived from Transmission Maps (kv) published by various Regional Power Committees, after making several suitable assumptions 8

9 2008 Existing Generation Capacity Source: Central Electricity Authority of India (2006), "Appendix A,B &C", General Review 9

10 2008 EXISTING GENERATING CAPACITY & ELECTRICITY DEMAND AT NODES 10

11 Sources GDP Projection: Dominic Wilson and Roopa Purushothaman, Dreaming with BRICs: the path to 2050 Global Economics Paper No 99, Goldmann Sachs, 1st October Electricity Demand Projection: Central Electricity Authority, Govt. of India, 16 th Electric Power Survey, Historic growth 4% Forecast growth 8%

12 India s Coal Companies Coal Entitlement ( ) Sources: Coal India Ltd., Information On Consumer wise Coal Supplies. 12

13 Price of Coal (USD/Ton) Source: Coal India Limited Estimated Cost of Coal at the Power Plant Assumption: The Coal used in power plants is assumed to be of calorific value between 3360 and 4200 kilocalories per kilogram Sources: Regulated Prices as of Dec 12, 2007, Coal India Ltd.

14 Cost of Coal at Power Plants Notes: Cost of Coal is estimated based on the distance of the node from coal mines and the current allocation profile (see slide 8 and 9). Source of Map: Location of Subsidiaries, Coal India Ltd.

15 Domestic Gas Price Since 1999 Source: CRiSi Research Impact of June 2006 Natural Gas Price Hike, July 2006 Fuel Price Comparisons Source: CRiSi Research Impact of June 2006 Natural Gas Price Hike, July 2006

16 Source: Central Electricity Authority of India, General Review 2006 Performance Data for Coal Powered Power Plants Source: Central Electricity Authority, Review of Performance of Thermal Power Stations

17 Summary of Existing Installed Power Capacity (MW) Source: Central Electricity Authority of India, General Review 2006

18 Existing & Potential Hydro-Power Sources: Existing Capacity: Central Electricity Authority (2006) General Review Hydro Potential: Central Electricity Authority (2002), "Preliminary Ranking Study of Hydro Electric Schemes Note: The Annual MWh/Year is at 60% Load Factor

19 Existing Inter-State Transmission Capacity (MW) (Purdue Approximations) Sources: Northern Regional Power Committee, Western Regional Power Committee, Southern Regional Power Committee, Eastern Regional Power Committee, North-Eastern Regional Power Committee

20

21

22 Demonstration Scenarios for the India National Model India s 11 th Expansion Plan Summary,

23 23

24 24

25 25

26 26

27 27

28 28

29 22 NODE MODEL RESULTS 29

30 RESULTS BENEFITS OF FREE TRADE Penalty cost of Unmet Demand ($5 Million/MW) is not included. Summary of Generation Expansions, Total New Transmission Expansion, (MW) 30

31 India National Grid LINE LOSSES 31

32 Results Scenario #1 32

33 Results Scenario #1 33

34 Results Scenario #1 34

35 Results Scenario #2 35

36 Results Scenario #2 36

37 Results Scenario #2 37

38 Results Scenario #3 38

39 Results Scenario #3 39

40 Results Scenario #3 40

41 Results Scenario #4 41

42 Results Scenario #4 42

43 Results Scenario #4 43

44 RESULTS UNMET DEMAND Scenario 1, Unmet Demand ,804 MW x $5 Million/MW = $ 384 Billion 44

45 10 Year Regional Model, Source: Devendra Canchi, ELECTRICITY GENERATION AND TRANSMISSION IN INDIA OPTIMIZING INFRASTRUCTURE FOR ECONOMIC GROWTH,, Global Partnerships Program Committee Meeting, June 29,

46 UNMET MW 46

47 Relaxed Government 11 th Plan 5% & 15% Reserve Margins 47

48 Relaxation of Government 11 th Plan Scenario, NT-WithGovPlan-4%Gr-15%Res 1B-NT-NoGovPlan-4%Gr-15%Res 1C-NT-NoGovPlan-4%Gr-5%Res Total Cost (Million USD) $320,060 M $264,761 M $264,106 M Note: NT=No Trade, Gr=Demand Growth, Res=Reserve Margin 48