SUSTRUS. Results from a sustainability model for Russia

Transcription

1 SUSTRUS Results from a sustainability model for Russia Christophe Heyndrickx (TML) Victoria Alexeeva-Talebi (ZEW) Natalia Tourdyeva (CEFIR) 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 1

2 Overview Sustainable Russia or SUSTRUS Overview of project results Conclusions 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 2

3 Overview Sustainable Russia or SUSTRUS Overview of project results Conclusions 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 3

4 Sustainable Russia EU Dimension Sustainable development Advantages framework to has four Threats objectives to Environmental protection sustainability sustainability Energy Social / Environment equity and Abundant cohesion natural Low energy efficiency Economic prosperity resources Demographics Meeting / Social international Highly responsibilities educated labour Unfavorable development force demographic situation Russian context? Institutions / History Economic development / Social cohesion Improvements in institutional development High growth potential Inheritance of Soviet regime Increasing income inequality Economic development / International market Diversification of economy Export dependency 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 4

5 Dimension Production sector Modelling the SUSTRUS way Characteristics 32 sectors based on NACE classification Households Regions Foreign sector Transport & trade sector Market structure Government Model structure Low, middle and high incomes Russian Federations (7 regions) Disaggregated results by country Interregional and international transport costs and margins Allows for both perfect competition and imperfect competition Federal versus regional government Based mainly on RAEM model and GEM-E-3 Dynamics Static and dynamic version of the model 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 5

6 Model database Data Input-Output table Regional production by sector Interregional trade flows Trade margins on products Labour market / social data Source Based on GTAP recalibrated (CEFIR) Goskomstat / Rosstat CEFIR calculations EXIOPOLL database (TNO) ILO database / RLMS survey International trade GTAP 7 National account data Russian central bank & Goskomstat 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 6

7 Calibration Regional account data - production -consumption - wages - import & export National SAM Regional SAMs National SAM Regional SAMs Regional account data - production - consumption - wages - import & export Transport costs Trade flows and trade margins data Balanced Regional SAMs Consistency check = Are trade flows and calculated margins correct and consistent with historical data Constrained optimization Balancing procedure Cross-entropy i p i log p g i i 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 7

8 Interrelated objectives Emissions Energy efficiency ENVIRONMENTAL MODULE Gini coefficient Atkinson Kakwani TRADE MODULE Interregional trade Trade openness Trade balance Foreign investment SOCIO-ECONOMIC MODULE GDP Equivalent variation Consumption Investment 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 8

9 Overview Sustainable Russia or SUSTRUS Overview of project results Conclusions 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 9

10 Application 1: Environment Topic Environmental concerns Policy relevance ETS accession Russia Increasing energy efficiency in Russia Economic diversification Simulation Emission tax of 38 rubles (+- 1 euro) / ton on carbon dioxide Static run Assumptions Impacts Government saves tax revenues Monopolistic competition Flexible foreign savings Reduction in energy consumption Reduction in production (GDP) Welfare effect Secondary effects on inequality 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 10

11 ENVIRONMENT % CO2 emissions Electricity Fossil fuels NOX emissions PM emissions SOX emissions ECONOMY % GDP Capita Investment 0.71 Public Savings 1.05 Tax revenues 0.58 TRADE Trade Balance 0.40 Foreign Invest 0.23 Trade Integr Trade Open 0.13 SOCIAL % Unemployment 0.63 Welfare Welfare QL Welfare QM Welfare QH Welfare GDP Tax revenues CO2 Shadow price CO2 (rubles/ ton) Unit (billion rubles) (billion rubles) (billion rubles) (Mega ton) Welfare GDP Totals /12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 11

12 Application 2: Social Topic Policy relevance Simulation Assumptions Impacts Social indicators Taxation and redistribution of income Test of social indicators Differential taxation of low, medium and high income households 10% increase in tax rate of low, medium and high income households Government saves tax income Adjustment in foreign savings to balance international market Inequality indices react to progressive or regressive taxation 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 12

13 SOCIAL (% change) Low Medium High Atkinson Consumption budget Gini Kakwani Poverty Intensity Welfare Welfare QL Welfare QM Welfare QH /12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 13

14 ECONOMY (% change) Low Medium High GDPcapitaReal Herfindahl Investment Price Index Public Savings Tax Revenues TRADE (% change) Foreign Invest Current Account Regional trade Trade Openness /12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 14

15 Application 3: WTO accession Topic Policy relevance Simulation Assumptions Impacts International market WTO accession Russian Federation Introduction of tariff cuts on import tax Reform of FDI in service sector 2012 (short term) 2015 (long term) Government reduces consumption to balance budget International closure via foreign savings adjustment Capital mobility between regions/sectors Reduction in real market prices Domestic investment and output adjustment Secondary effects on inequality 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 15

16 Tariff reform? Pre-WTO WTO Agriculture Food products Textiles and textile products Leather and leather products Wood and paper products Petrol 5 5 Chemicals Rubber and plastics Non-metallic minerals Basic metals Machinery Electrical and optical equipment Transport equipment Manufacturing n.e.c Service liberalization: -> 10% decrease in fixed cost for foreign establishment (ad valorem tax rates : source WTO 2011) 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 16

17 Main effects Scenario Welfare Tariff reform 0.26% 0.96% Service reform 0.31% 1.41% GDP Tariff reform -0.26% 0.75% Service reform -0.52% 0.83% Tax revenues Tariff reform -1.10% -0.73% Service reform -1.11% Trade Balance Tariff reform % Service reform -9.38% -0.05% % % 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 17

18 Import / export and output 2012 In absolute values 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 18

19 Import / export and output 2015 In absolute values 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 19

20 Inequality? 2012 SERVICE REFORM WITHOUT WITH Welfare 0.26% 0.31% WelfareQL 0.35% 0.39% WelfareQM 0.29% 0.33% WelfareQH 0.22% 0.29% 2015 SERVICE REFORM WITHOUT WITH Welfare 0.96% 1.41% WelfareQL 0.82% 1.17% WelfareQM 0.94% 1.35% WelfareQH Atkinson index Gini indicator 1.00% 1.48% 1.35% 1.73% 0.13% 0.14% 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 20

21 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 21

22 Regional welfare effect /12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 22

23 Regional welfare effect /12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 23

24 Conclusions SUSTRUS is a novel general equilibrium model that allows for a balanced sustainability impact analysis Tests with the environmental model show that emissions of carbon dioxide and other pollutants can be reduced at relatively low cost and with the additional benefit of tax revenues As far as taxation and redistribution are issues, we stress the importance of transfers and the recycling of tax revenues to measure welfare effects A simulation of the WTO accession shows that the current reform leads to a modest improvement in welfare and output adjustment on long term. Welfare effects of WTO accession are dependent on the accessibility of the region. Central, North West and Far East region have the largest benefits 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 24

25 Thank you For your attention 14/12/2011 SUSTRUS Moscow conference 25