Emissions Inventory (EI): Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011

Transcription

1 Emissions Inventory (EI): Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 Danielle Nesvacil, Team Leader Adam Bullock, Technical Specialist Air Quality Division Presented to the Air & Waste Management Association Gulf Coast Chapter Meeting, March 6, 2012 Air Quality Division

2 Overview Role and importance of the EI Brief introduction to EI applicability reporting requirements What s new for the 2011 reporting year Key considerations when determining tank emissions Summary Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 2

3 Emissions Inventory Goals Accurate determinations of mass emissions released to the atmosphere. Accurate identification of emission species released to the atmosphere. Compounds react differently in the atmosphere to create ozone. Air toxics Continuous improvement Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 3

4 Emissions Inventory Improvement Air quality research projects have improved the quantitative understanding of emissions sources that were previously unknown or underestimated. Operation of assisted flares Tank emissions from floating roof landings Flash emissions from upstream oil and gas tanks Heated storage tanks Working and breathing losses from barges Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 4

5 Emissions Inventory Use in Planning Mandated Reports to EPA State Implementation Plan Development Control Strategy Development Modeling Predicts Ozone Formation Trends Analysis Emissions Inventory Other State Air Other Planning States Agencies Local Government t Air Planning Agencies Regional Regional Air Planning Organizations Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 5

6 Applicability Requirements 30 Texas Administrative Code (TAC) EI types, Do You Need to Submit an EI? who needs to submit, and what must be submitted, including: SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION. Major stationary source under 30 TAC , Nonattainment and Prevention of Significant Deterioration Definitions Rule defines potential to emit (PTE) thresholds Applicability is generally based on attainment status of county Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 6

7 1997 Eight-Hour Ozone Nonattainment Areas Summary of Reporting Requirements in Tons per Year for 30 TAC County Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC) Nitrogen Oxides Other Individual Hazardous Air Pollutants (HAPs) Aggregate HAPs Actual PTE Actual PTE Actual PTE Actual PTE Actual PTE Brazoria, Chambers, Fort Bend, Galveston, Harris, Liberty, Montgomery, Waller SEVERE/OZONE Collin, Dallas, Denton, Ellis, Johnson, Kaufman, Parker, Rockwall, Tarrant SERIOUS/OZONE All Other Counties Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 7

8 Applicability Summary What Does This Mean to You? What is the 2011 attainment status of the county where the site is located? What were the site s actual 2011 emissions for regulated pollutants and hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) (single and aggregate)? What were the site s PTE limits for regulated pollutants and HAPs (single and aggregate)? Is the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) conducting a special inventory? 30 TAC (b)(3) TCEQ must notify special inventory recipients Special inventories for 2011 Requirements for all counties concerning lead Ozone precursors in specified counties Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 8

9 New for 2011: Reporting Options 3 options for submitting an EI Paper Electronic text file (delta file method) Online entry (alternative to paper) Paper emissions inventory questionnaires (EIQs) and extract files will no longer be mailed to regulated entities. The TCEQ will still accept paper submittals. Printable EIQ reports can be generated through the Central Registry s Public Query tool. Instructions for Obtaining a Printable Copy of the EIQ: Extract files can be obtained from TCEQ FTP site Direct link on TCEQ point source EI Web page Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 9

10 New for 2011: Reporting Options (cont.) Electronic delta file MUST be submitted through the State of Texas Electronic Emissions Reporting System (STEERS). Electronic delta files will no longer be accepted on disk or other media. Online data entry through STEERS Great option for those sites currently using paper that would like to submit on-line. On-line Annual Emissions Inventory Report User's Guide tation/air/ie/pseiforms/aierusersguide.pdf Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 10

11 New for 2011: General Tanks emissions determination guidance updates in Technical Supplement 6 of 2011 EI Guidelines More guidance regarding structure of and reporting emissions from glycol stills Specific list of updates available at: on/air/ie/pseiforms/2011ei_request_ltr.pdf Ozone season update May 1 through September 30 for EI purposes Preference for 2011 EI submissions: adjust ozone season calculations based on May 1- Sept 30 Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 11

12 Tank Emissions Concerns Quantitative evidence 2007 TCEQ differential absorption lidar (DIAL) project measured elevated emissions from crude oil tanks City of Houston DIAL project measured elevated emissions from crude oil tanks and intermediate refinery process tanks. These studies indicate that tank VOC emissions are potentially under-reported in the annual EI. Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 12

13 Specific Tank Types Of Concern Ambient-temperature tanks: use of default data to determine emissions (e.g., crude oil tanks) Midstream, terminals, and refineries Heated tanks Refineries, terminals, and end users Intermediate process tanks with floating roofs that store material at warmer-than-ambient temperature (hot product tanks). Tanks with significant throughput variation Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 13

14 Ambient-Temperature Tanks Emissions Determination Concerns Annual emissions from tanks that store products at ambient temperatures: Concern: TANKS 4.09d (TANKS) software program does not incorporate temperature as a variable when determining unheated, fixed-roof tank working losses. Working-loss algorithm uses a fixed vapor-space temperature of 63 F. Acceptable to use TANKS with the following caveats: For annual emissions, choose Monthly time basis (instead of Annual ) and select all 12 months of the year to obtain the best possible emissions estimates. Never use default information unless it accurately represents the tank and its contents. Input detailed tank fittings, do not use defaults. Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 14

15 Ambient-Temperature Tanks (cont.) Emissions Determination Concerns (cont.) Preferred method for determining ozone season emissions: appropriate AP-42, Chapter 7 equations that use accurate vapor pressure data at higher ozone season ambient temperatures. Concerns about using TANKS to determine ozone season emissions: The working-loss algorithm error incorrectly calculates unheated, fixed-roof tank working loss emissions during the ozone season months. TANKS inaccurately uses an annual average liquid bulk temperature, even when determining monthly emissions. Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 15

16 Comparing Emissions TANKS 4.09d Default Data vs. Site-Specific Floating-roof tank storing crude oil Default: TANKS default crude profile, Reid vapor pressure (RVP) 5 Site-specific: TANKS but with user-entered, sitespecific crude oil data (RVP 7). Note: site-specific crude oil has higher RVP than default value. Contents Method Monthly sum over 12 months in pounds (lbs) Default Crude Oil Data TANKS 2,357 Site-specific Crude Oil Data TANKS 3,637 Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 16

17 Heated and Hot Product Tanks TANKS does not apply AP-42, Chapter 7 equations accurately For EI purposes, TANKS is no longer an acceptable option to determine emissions from heated and hot product tanks. TANKS contains several default routines that prevent it from properly applying the AP-42, Chapter 7 equations. Examples include: Incorrectly assumes the vapor-space and liquid-surface temperature ranges are equal Cannot determine emissions for some high molecular weight petroleum distillates if storage temperature is above 100 degrees Fahrenheit ( F) Does not compute the vapor space and liquid temperature ranges for heated tanks Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 17

18 Heated and Hot Product Tanks (cont.) TANKS will underestimate emissions from intermediate process tanks with floating roofs that store material at warmer-than-ambient temperature (hot product tanks). Use AP-42, Chapter 7 equations. Use vapor pressure at the actual storage temperature of the liquid. Do not use AP-42 defaults or permitted values for vapor pressure, liquid composition, and other relevant parameters unless representative of the stored liquid. American Society for Testing and Materials method D 2879 is suitable for determining vapor pressure for heavy liquids. Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 18

19 Comparing Emissions Part 2 Heated fuel oil tank, temperature at 150 F Comparing: Heated Tank Emissions determined using TANKS default residual oil number 6 data Emissions determined using AP-42, Chapter 7 equations and actual residual oil number 6 parameters, including vapor pressure Contents Method Monthly sum over 12 months in lbs Default Residual Oil Number 6 TANKS 55 Residual Oil Number 6 AP-42, Chapter Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 19

20 Tanks with Cutter Stock If a stored product is cut with another material, the cutter stock must be accounted for in emissions determinations. Cutter stock will impact the liquid s: composition and vapor pressure at the stored temperature. Process records should indicate amount of cutter stock added. Cutter stock emissions must be speciated in the annual EI. Process records should provide detail about the cutter stock composition. Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 20

21 Comparing Emissions Part 3 Heated fuel oil tank, temperature at 150 F Comparing: With and without cutter stock Emissions determined using TANKS default residual oil number 6 data Emissions determined using AP-42, Chapter 7 equations and the actual vapor pressure of the residual oil number 6 cut with 25% diesel Contents Method Monthly sum over 12 months in lbs Default Residual Oil Number 6 TANKS 55 Cut Residual Oil (75% Residual Oil Number 6/25% Diesel) AP-42, Chapter 7 3,511 Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 21

22 Significant Throughput Variation Because the liquid temperature remains at the annual average, even if the monthly calculation option is chosen, TANKS cannot adequately account for monthly variations in emissions. Use AP-42, Chapter 7 equations. Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 22

23 Degassing and Cleaning Acceptable determination methods: Site-specific data and material balance equations The liquid heel method is described in Section 11, Startup and Shutdown, of United States Environmental Protection Agency s (EPA) Emission Estimation Protocol for Petroleum Refineries. Degassing: American Petroleum Institute (API) Technical Report 2568, Evaporative Loss from the Cleaning of Storage Tanks (drain-dry fixed-roof) API Technical Report 2567, Evaporative Loss from Storage Tank Floating Roof Landings (drain-dry floating-roof) Cleaning: API Technical Report 2568 Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 23

24 EI Calculations and Permit Allowables If emissions determined using the procedures in the EI guidelines exceed the allowable emission rates in a site s relevant New Source Review permit: Regulated entity should apply for a permit amendment to authorize the corrected emission rates. Application should include a retrospective review to establish whether the higher level of emissions would have triggered nonattainment or prevention of significant deterioration permit review when emissions were authorized. Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 24

25 Tank Emissions Summary Due to concerns about accurate reporting of EI emissions, EPA TANKS 4.09d (or any earlier version) is no longer accepted to determine emissions for emissions inventory purposes for: tanks storing warm or hot product, heated tanks, or tanks with significant variations in throughput. Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 25

26 Tank Emissions Summary (cont.) When TANKS is an accepted emissions determination option for EI reporting, do not use default settings and parameters. Enter specific chemical or mixture data (including cutter stock) into the TANKS program s chemical database. Default chemicals cannot be used unless the default vapor pressure and composition of the material are representative of the stored material. Detailed guidance in the 2011 EI Guidelines, Appendix A, Technical Supplement 6: Aboveground Storage Tanks pubs/rg/rg360/rg36011/appendix_a.pdf Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 26

27 EI Assistance 2011 Emissions Inventory Guidelines (RG- 360A): Step-by-step instructions for completing an EI Updated annually with current reporting requirements Technical supplements for common emissions sources 2011 Emissions Inventory Forms and Instructions (RG-360B): Instructions on completing the forms Blank forms List of abatement codes and contaminant codes Point source Web page Help Line (512) , available Monday-Friday from 8 AM-5 PM Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 27

28 Contact Information Danielle Nesvacil (512) Adam Bullock (512) Help line (512) Monday-Friday from 8AM-5PM Web page Air Quality Division EI Reporting Requirements and What s New for 2011 ADB & DMN March 6, 2012 Page 28