REBUTTAL STATEMENT OF EVIDENCE OF BRETT BEAMSLEY (DREDGE DISPOSAL AND COASTAL PROCESSES)
|
|
- Aubrie Rebecca Rice
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 BEFORE THE NORTHLAND REGIONAL COUNCIL IN THE MATTER of the Resource Management Act 1991 AND IN THE MATTER APPLICATION NO: of a resource consent application by The New Zealand Refining Company Limited under section 88 of the RMA to deepen and realign the Whangarei Harbour entrance and its approaches APP REBUTTAL STATEMENT OF EVIDENCE OF BRETT BEAMSLEY (DREDGE DISPOSAL AND COASTAL PROCESSES) 1 I have read and reviewed the statement of evidence prepared by Dr Shaw Mead on coastal processes, numerical modelling and marine ecology. There is no part in his statement of evidence that would cause me to change my statement of evidence or findings. However, there are matters raised in this statement of evidence that I wish to rebut/correct. 2 In paragraph [11] Dr Mead does not accept that there will be no significant changes to waves and therefore sediment transport and geomorphology and suggests that many large-scale changes have been identified by the modelling that will impact on the form and function of the harbour entrance. 3 I disagree with this statement and do not believe that the predicted modification to the hydrodynamic and wave characteristics will impact on the form and function of the harbour entrance. I qualify this statement below. a. Firstly, I note that current mean annual wave height is approximately 0.80 m, while the predicted mean annual change to the significant wave height is ~ cm (i.e %, see Figure 1). It is highly unlikely that this scale of change could be measured using instruments, and it would not be observable. I consider these changes to be minor to less than minor.
2 Figure 1 Average annual change in significant wave height due to the deepened channel. Positive amplitudes indicate areas with a predicted increase, negative areas a decrease. b. While larger changes in the significant wave height are expected during storm events (i.e m) with wave heights exceeding 5 m, these changes still represent both a small actual change, and a relatively small percentage change (~3%). c. These modifications to the wave climate have been tested with industry standard morphological models and only minor morphological changes are predicted within the environs, and I do not expect these to change the governing dynamics. Further, storm driven morphological changes at Busby Head (for example) are noted to be within the existing natural variability of the site and do not represent a regime shift or permanent change. 4 In paragraph [12] Dr Mead accepts that industry standard models have been applied, however states his belief that the validation of the tidal model is poor and that there has been little incorporation of science and site-specific knowledge beyond the use of the models. 5 I disagree with this statement; a. Firstly, Dr Mead has fundamentally failed to understand how the various models have been applied within the context of this project. The model Dr Mead is referring to as the tidal-model (ROMS) has been principally used to define the residual current (i.e. non-tidal) component of the total current field at the offshore disposal site, and does not relate to the tidal model (SELFE) used to define the harbour hydrodynamics. b. Secondly, Dr Mead has failed to understand how these offshore current velocities have been applied within the context of this project. The ROMS model has been used to define the climatic hydrodynamics, and applied to plume and morphological responses in that context (i.e. running long period simulations to derive statistically relevant outcomes). The total bias of the ROMS model in defining the combined
3 tidal and residual current velocity is statistically small ( m.s -1 ) and as such appropriate to defining the regional hydrodynamics. c. Finally, both the regional scale ROMS model and the harbour scale SELFE model have been calibrated and validated against site-specific measured data, and both model and measured data have been used to define plume dispersions within the receiving environment. 6 In paragraph [13] Dr Mead recognises that the tools developed (inclusive of the models) have been applied considering the known impacts of channel deepening world-wide, and suggests that there is a deficit of information linking to the strong biogenic influence in the system. 7 I agree with Dr Mead s [13] statement, in that the models used have leveraged and used international studies of morphological response. 8 I accept that there is limited information available to explicitly model biological armoured substrate within the existing scientific knowledge; however model calibration and validation looked to simulate this armouring effect by assuming coarse gravel sediments over Mair Bank, thereby reproducing the overall stability of Mair Bank. Given the state of scientific knowledge, I believe this to be an acceptable approach to examine the scale of effects of the proposal. 9 In paragraph [14] Dr Mead makes reference to the large spatial scale of the changes to the wave and hydrodynamics, and consequentially the sediment transport. While spatial changes appear to be comparatively large (i.e. see Figure 1), the actual magnitude changes to waves and hydrodynamics, which govern the sediment transport, are minor to less than minor. 10 In paragraph [15] Dr Mead suggests that the proposal has potential to impact on the existing morphodynamics of the harbour which have not been well addressed, yet he acknowledges that industry standard models, which have been calibrated and validated against site-specific data, have been applied [Mead, paragraph 12]. As such I do not agree with his suggestion that the impact on the existing morphodynamics have not been well addressed. 11 Dr Mead suggests in his statement in paragraph [16] that the spatial extent of the expected changes in wave and hydrodynamics will not be absorbed within the natural variability. As I note above, while spatial changes appear to be comparatively large (i.e. see Figure 1), the actual magnitude changes to waves and hydrodynamics, which govern the sediment transport, are minor to less than minor. 12 In paragraphs [17-19], Dr Mead discusses the effect of the proposal on the tidal prism and phasing. It appears to me that Dr Mead does not seem to understand the concept of deriving a tidal phase or how models can be used to infer a potential shift (Mead, [19]). This is achieved by simulating both existing and proposed bathymetries and comparing the model outcomes. The site at which the tidal phasing change has been reported is significantly far inside the harbour such that the effect is worst case. The small phasing shift will not affect the tidal amplitudes. These model outcomes are then used to determine the potential impact of the proposed dredging on the morphological response, significantly within the entire harbour. This is accepted industry practice. 13 Dr Mead [20] suggests that the inner harbour has not been considered. This is not accurate. The modelling undertaken extended into the inner harbour regions, but no effects on those
4 areas are expected. In addition, the extensive intertidal areas are expected to be morphologically dominated by locally generated waves. 14 Dr Mead [21] notes that the fundamental laws of physics indicate that change will occur. I agree with this broad statement, and note that these physical processes are accounted for in the hydrodynamic and morphological models applied. 15 In paragraph [31] Dr Mead suggests that on the eastern flank of the channel there is a 20% increase in potential sediment flux and this is significant. I recognise that this appears to be a significant value; however increases in potential sediment flux do not mean that the sediment erosion and accretion will similarly increase, as shown in Figure 2. Dr Mead [31] goes on to note that the relative effect of changes should be related to impacts on the processes; I agree and note that the overall effect on the morphological process is expected to be minor (e.g. Figure 2). Mr Reinen-Hamill in his evidence-in-chief discussed the likely effects of these modelled changes. Figure 2 Changes in sedimentation and erosion patterns between the existing and postdeepening configurations over a 5-day storm event. 16 In paragraph [32] Dr Mead suggests that relatively small changes in the percentage of time critical shear stresses are exceeded < 5% of the time are significant and presumably occur throughout the harbour. I disagree with this statement. Comparisons between the existing and proposed deepened channel bathymetry show similar spatial patterns, and extensive areas of <5% difference are not expected (see Figure 3).
5 Figure 3 Percentage of time the bed shear stress exceeds the critical shear stress threshold for 200 µm sand at flood tide. Calculated from a 28-day simulation of the existing harbour (left) and the deepened channel (right).
6 17 Further, Dr Mead [32] criticises the use of a 28 day period to consider these modelled changes in the percentage of time critical shear stress, stating that the duration of change is not 28 days, it is permanent. I find this statement to be inflammatory and misleading. The use of 28 days captures two complete Spring-Neap tidal cycles, ensuring that the expected range of conditions are accounted for. 18 In paragraph [36] Dr Mead expresses his opinion that the modelling investigations show that there are a wide range of changes of varying magnitudes over a large spatial extent. I agree with this statement in general, but when examined in more detail, while there are spatially broad extents to the absolute wave height change (see Figure 1), as described in 3 a b and c the actual scale of change is small. Further, Dr Mead in paragraph [44] suggests that relying on the relative change of individual processes should not be solely used to interpret the model outcomes; however in paragraph [36] Dr Mead appears to do exactly that. In my experience, it is important to understand the relative changes in the underlying processes, but to also understand the effect of those processes and their relative change on the morphological response of the harbour system. Accordingly, my evidence-in-chief should be read together with that of Mr Reinen-Hamill. 19 In paragraph [39] Dr Mead discusses the predicted changes to various hydrodynamic and wave parameters (but does not explicitly state which) occurring over large areas, and goes on to note that he does not consider 20-30% change in bed shear stress to be insignificant. Dr Mead appears to be taking these values out of context, and they need to be considered with respect to the absolute magnitudes and how they relate to sediment transport (see Figure 4). I reiterate my observation that Dr Mead appears to contradict himself (paragraph 18 above) with respect to placing emphasis on the underlying processes. In my view, Dr Mead either misrepresents or misunderstands the outcomes of the modelling and the impact of the changes on the overall sediment transport capacity and morphological response of the system to predicted changes in the hydrodynamics. While changes of 20-30% may seem significant, these represent only a very small actual increase in current velocities (of the order 1-5 cm.s -1 ). As such, Dr Mead s statement does not change my position as expressed in my evidence-inchief.
7 Figure 4 Absolute (top) and relative (bottom) difference in tidal flows post-deepening during the peak spring ebb flows. Plots on the right show a zoomed in view of the entrance region. Positive values indicate a predicted increase in flow (red scale), while the negative values indicate a decrease (blue scale). 20 In paragraph [40-41] and again in [47] Dr Mead again raises questions around the impact of the proposed deepening and offshore disposal on the incident wave climate. I have addressed this in paragraphs 3 a, b and c above. 21 I agree with Dr Mead s paragraph [43], which is why morphological models have been applied in addition to wave and hydrodynamic models, which have been used to quantify the effects of the proposal on the underlying processes responsible for morphological response. I do not agree with Dr Mead [44] that quantifying the effect of the proposed deepening on the underlying processes is a major flaw in the interpretation of the modelling results, as to fully understand the processes and outcomes you must understand both cause and effect, i.e. processes and response. 22 I disagree with Dr Mead s statement in paragraph [64] that the cumulative impacts of the consented land reclamation at Northport have been down-played or disregarded by myself. Modelling has considered both the existing harbour configuration and that which would eventuate if Northport fully exercised their consent. With respect to tidal hydrodynamics, a 2- minute phase change is expected at a point significantly far inside the harbour, which represents a worst case location, if only the proposed deepening was to occur. If both the proposed deepening and the consented reclamation were realised, then a 7-minute phase change is expected at a point significantly far inside the harbour. With respect to the
8 sediment transport and morphological response, the cumulative effect has been considered and is not expected to change the outcomes presented in my evidence-in-chief. Brett Beamsley 23 February 2018
Poole Harbour Channel Deepening and Beneficial Use Review of Physical monitoring in Poole Bay Technical Note 1 WITHOUT PREJUDICE
1. Introduction Poole Harbour Channel Deepening and Beneficial Use Review of Physical monitoring in Poole Bay Technical Note 1 WITHOUT PREJUDICE This technical note reviews the physical data that was collected
More informationBerth 9 Quay Extension Environmental Statement Non-Technical Summary
Berth 9 Quay Extension Hutchison Ports UK Ltd July 2013 Final Report 9Y0150 CONTENTS Page 1 PROJECT BACKGROUND 1 2 NEED FOR THE PROPOSED SCHEME 4 3 DESCRIPTION OF THE CONSTRUCTION PHASE 4 4 DESCRIPTION
More informationEntrance Modelling and the Influence on ICOLL Flood Behaviour
Entrance Modelling and the Influence on ICOLL Flood Behaviour D Lyons 1, D Williams 1 1 BMT WBM, Newcastle, NSW ABSTRACT The morphological changes in the coastal entrance of estuaries and ICOLLs during
More informationUnderstanding and Managing Morphological Change in Estuaries
STUDY METHODS There are a number of related guides referred to in the text, which provide further detail on study methods. This chapter: Provides an overview of the study methods used in estuarine management;
More informationDRINKING WATER QUALITY FORECASTING SALINITY INTRUSION IN WHAKATANE RIVER
DRINKING WATER QUALITY FORECASTING SALINITY INTRUSION IN WHAKATANE RIVER Ben Tuckey 1, Colin Roberts 1 and Santhan Gunasantha 2. 1 DHI New Zealand, ecentre, Oaklands Road, Auckland. 2 Whakatane District
More informationThe natural hazard types that have been identified within the City include the following:
Chapter 62 NATURAL HAZARDS 62.1 INTRODUCTION Napier City, like many other cities within New Zealand, is subject to the effects of natural hazards. Since the enactment of the Resource Management Act, the
More informationA rapid response management system for assessing bathing water impacts from pollution events
A rapid response management system for assessing bathing water impacts from pollution events Richard Marlow GIS & Applications Developer 22 nd June 2016 Overview Who We Are The UK Water Industry The Use
More informationAppendix 8: Best Practicable Environmental Option (BPEO) Assessment
Appendix 8: Best Practicable Environmental Option (BPEO) Assessment ABERDEEN HARBOUR EXPANSION PROJECT BEST PRACTICABLE ENVIRONMENTAL OPTION (BPEO) ASSESSMENT October 2015 Updated April 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS
More informationMarine Turbine Project Kaipara Harbour New Zealand
Crest Energy Marine Turbine Project Kaipara Harbour New Zealand prepared for AWATEA Marine Energy Resource Consenting Workshop 2nd Annual Conference Thursday 4 December 2008; Lambton Room, Intercontinental
More informationWater Contamination Mapping Lab
Water Contamination Mapping Lab Purpose To teach basic principals of map analysis using actual Miami-Dade County spatial data and to explore the concept of environmental health, specifically in regard
More information15. Coastal Defences. Executive Summary: Chapter 15. Coastal Defences
15. Coastal Defences Executive Summary: Chapter 15. Coastal Defences The potential direct and indirect impacts that will arise from the proposed Berth 201/202 works, either through the reconstruction of
More informationAppendix 15.3 Hydraulic Assessment of Sewers
Appendix 15.3 Hydraulic Assessment of Sewers Irish Water Arklow Wastewater Treatment Plant Project EIA Report Issue September 2018 Arup \\GLOBAL\EUROPE\DUBLIN\JOBS\247000\247825-00\4. INTERNAL\4-03 DESIGN\4-03-02
More informationPlanning for Dredging and the Environment on the Tidal Thames
Planning for Dredging and the Environment on the Tidal Thames 1 INTRODUCTION This Information Note forms the final document in a set of three notes designed to inform berth operators and environmental
More informationVILLAGE OF BALD HEAD ISLAND SHORELINE PROTECTION PROJECT DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
VILLAGE OF BALD HEAD ISLAND SHORELINE PROTECTION PROJECT DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT Prepared By: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Wilmington District and Land Management Group, Inc. (Third Party
More informationMIKE 21/3 FLOW MODEL HD FM
MIKE 21/3 FLOW MODEL HD FM 2D and 3D hydrodynamic modelling using flexible mesh DHI/Photo Simon Mortensen, DHI-AUK component will teach you the fundamentals of 2D and 3D hydrodynamic modelling (HD) and
More informationNRC 1988: Coastal Hazard Identification. Whangarei County. Technical Publication No.1988/1, March 1988, held by Northland Regional Council.
56 Natural Hazards 56.1 Introduction This Chapter contains rules relating to land uses in areas mapped as hazard areas. These areas are shown on the Planning Maps by shading on the Resource Area Maps.
More informationIN THE MATTER of the Resource Management Act 1991
BEFORE THE NORTHLAND REGIONAL COUNCIL IN THE MATTER of the Resource Management Act 1991 AND IN THE MATTER APPLICATION of a resource consent application by The New Zealand Refining Company Limited under
More informationThe approach to managing natural hazards in this Plan is to: set out a clear regional framework for natural hazard management,
9 Natural Hazards 9.1 Scope and Background This chapter establishes an overall framework for natural hazard management under the RMA. It also sets out the division of responsibilities between the Regional
More informationHarbour Constructions
Harbour Constructions River and Coastal morphology: They provide morphological services based on one-, two- and threedimensional computer models. These models are used to answer the questions of clients
More informationMeasured environmental impacts of dredging operations S.J. Priestley
Measured environmental impacts of dredging operations S.J. Priestley Abstract Recent dredging operations in the port of Auckland, New Zealand were preceded by detailed environmental impact assessments.
More information7 Section 32 Summary for the Natural Hazards Chapter
7 Section 32 Summary for the Natural Hazards Chapter The purpose of this section is to present a summary of the evaluation of the objectives, policies and methods of the Natural Hazards Chapter of the
More informationLETTER F. City of Del Mar
LETTER F City of Del Mar F-1 The comment provides introductory statements and does not raise a specific issue related to the adequacy of the EIR. Therefore, no specific response is provided. F-2 The assumption
More informationBEFORE THE MANAWATU- WANGANUI REGIONAL COUNCIL. IN THE MATTER of the Resource Management Act 1991
BEFORE THE MANAWATU- WANGANUI REGIONAL COUNCIL IN THE MATTER of the Resource Management Act 1991 AND IN THE MATTER of Submissions and Further Submissions lodged by Meridian Energy Limited to the Manawatu-Wanganui
More informationPart 8 Natural hazards
Part 8 Natural hazards Contents Page 8.1 Introduction... 3 8.2 Resource management issue... 3 8.3 Objectives and policies... 3 8.4 Resource management strategy... 5 8.5 Rules - restricted discretionary
More informationThe planned conversion of part of the Port of
South Port of Copenhagen: Clean-up of Contaminated Sediments NIELS LYKKEBERG & HELGE GRAVESEN, Carl Bro a/s, Glostrup, Denmark KAJ HOLM JØRGENSEN, Port of Copenhagen, Denmark A BSTRACT The planned conversion
More informationEnvironmental Impacts. Installation of Seawater Desalination Plant at Thalayadi
Environmental Impacts Installation of Seawater Desalination Plant at Thalayadi SWRO Plant Location The proposed land identified to establish SWRO plant is located in: Vadamarachchi East Divisional Secretariat
More informationLouisiana Coastal Area Mississippi River Hydrodynamic and Delta Management Study
Louisiana Coastal Area Mississippi River Hydrodynamic and Delta Management Study Cherie Price - USACE Brian Vosburg - CPRA US Army Corps of Engineers Presentation Outline MS River Hydrodynamic and Delta
More informationSalt Dispersion in Delaware Bay
Salt Dispersion in Delaware Bay Maria Aristizabal Robert Chant This work has been supported by NSF, Rutgers University and a Dupont fellowship. Delaware Estuary Science and environmental summit Jan 27-30
More informationCoastal Resources Limited (CRL) Application for Marine Dumping Consent
Conditions Report Coastal Resources Limited (CRL) Application for Marine Dumping Consent November 2018 Table of Contents Table of Contents... 2 List of abbreviations... 3 Introduction... 4 Background...
More informationDynamic Humber. Department of Geography, Environment and Earth Sciences
Dynamic Humber Department of Geography, Environment and Earth Sciences Investigating the long-term impact of environmental change on the physical, social and economic state of the Humber estuary and East
More informationBAY OF ISLANDS PLANNING LIMITED 2 Totara Place, Kerikeri PO Box 795
Far North District Council John Butler Centre Kerikeri Road Kerikeri Attention Ms Louise Wilson 30 May 2018 Dear Louise, BAY OF ISLANDS PLANNING LIMITED 2 Totara Place, Kerikeri PO Box 795 Kerikeri Phone
More informationYumbah Nyamat Works Approval Application October Appendix H. GHD (2018) Mixing Zone Predictions report
Yumbah Nyamat Works Approval Application October 2018 Appendix H GHD (2018) Mixing Zone Predictions report Yumbah Aquaculture Limited Nyamat - Planning & Works Approval Mixing Zone Predictions September
More informationThe ecological value of such designs is generally the closest to that of a natural tidal bank.
The designs There are four different categories for designing estuary edges: Bioengineered designs These designs rely entirely on plants for long-term protection from erosion. Bioengineering techniques
More informationEnvironmental Assessment Appendix H: Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines Evaluation. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers New York District
Environmental Assessment Appendix H: Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines Evaluation U.S. Army Corps of Engineers New York District January 2004 APPENDIX H SECTION 404(b)(1) GUIDELINES EVALUATION SECTION 404(b)(1)
More informationEnvironmental Protection (NJDEP) The Louis Berger Group, Inc.
Hydraulic Modeling for Preliminary Evaluation of Potential Flooding Impacts for Various Dredging, Capping and Armoring Scenarios of The Lower Passaic River Restoration Abdulai Fofanah, PE, D.WRE, CFM Murat
More informationCOASTAL PROTECTION, LANDSCAPING AND INFRASTRUCTURAL WORKS IN MAURITIUS BAIE DU TOMBEAU SITE CONTENTS
COASTAL PROTECTION, LANDSCAPING AND INFRASTRUCTURAL WORKS IN MAURITIUS BAIE DU TOMBEAU SITE CONTENTS Chapter Description Page EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 INTRODUCTION 1-1 1.1 General 1-1 1.1.1 Need for EIA 1-1
More informationCRITERIA AND METHODOLOGY FOR DETERMINING OUTSTANDING FRESHWATER BODIES
CRITERIA AND METHODOLOGY FOR DETERMINING OUTSTANDING FRESHWATER BODIES Literature Review One, Part Two: Summary Report December 2015 Contents 1. Executive summary 1 2. Purpose 1 3. Documents reviewed 2
More informationHRPP 331. Application and inter-comparison of estuary morphological models
HRPP 331 Application and inter-comparison of estuary morphological models Paul Norton, Andrew J. Manning, Ian Townend, Andrew Lane and Harshinie Karunarathna Reproduced from a paper presented at 42nd Defra
More informationSTATEMENT OF EVIDENCE OF DR BRIAN STEWART (ECOLOGY PEER REVIEW AND TURBIDITY) 12 FEBRUARY 2018
BEFORE THE NORTHLAND REGIONAL COUNCIL IN THE MATTER OF the Resource Management Act 1991 ( RMA ) AND IN THE MATTER OF APPLICATION NO. a resource consent application by The New Zealand Refining Company Ltd
More informationCOASTAL SHORE PROTECTION WITH LIVING SHORELINES
COASTAL SHORE PROTECTION WITH LIVING SHORELINES Role of the Army Corps Regulatory Program UCONN, Clear Living Shorelines II Workshop June 24, 2015 Groton CT Cori M. Rose Senior Project Manager/PWS cori.m.rose@usace.army.mil
More informationI213. Westhaven Tamaki Herenga Waka Precinct
I213. Westhaven Tamaki Herenga Waka Precinct I213.1. Precinct description The Westhaven Tamaki Herenga Waka Precinct is located at the western edge of the city centre and comprises the land and coastal
More informationBEFORE THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY AT WELLINGTON
BEFORE THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AUTHORITY AT WELLINGTON IN THE MATTER of the Exclusive Economic Zone and Continental Shelf (Environmental Effects) Act 2012 (EEZ Act) AND IN THE MATTER of an application
More informationDistribution Restriction Statement Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited.
CECW-EH-D Regulation No. 1110-2-1404 Department of the Army U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Washington, DC 20314-1000 Engineering and Design HYDRAULIC DESIGN OF DEEP-DRAFT NAVIGATION PROJECTS Distribution
More informationPopulation and biomass survey of pipi (Paphies australis) on Mair Bank, Whangarei Harbour, 2014.
Population and biomass survey of pipi (Paphies australis) on Mair Bank, Whangarei Harbour, 2014. Prepared by Matt. D. M. Pawley Prepared for: Northland Regional Council Whangarei, New Zealand Contact:
More informationINDEPENDENT REVIEW OF THE BUND WALL AT THE PORT OF GLADSTONE. April 2014
INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF THE BUND WALL AT THE PORT OF GLADSTONE April 2014 Commonwealth of Australia 2014 This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may
More informationREDUCING UNCERTAINTY IN PREDICTION OF DUNE EROSION DURING EXTREME CONDITIONS
REDUCING UNCERTAINTY IN PREDICTION OF DUNE EROSION DURING EXTREME CONDITIONS C. (Kees) den Heijer 1,2, Ad J.H.M. Reniers u, Jan van de Graaff 1 and Pieter H.A.J.M. van Gelder 1 Coastal dunes protect low
More informationModelling Environmental Effects of Marine Renewables. Dr Louise Kregting & Dr Björn Elsäßer
Modelling Environmental Effects of Marine Renewables Dr Louise Kregting & Dr Björn Elsäßer AWATEA 19 th May 2016 SPACE SCHOOL OF Planning Architecture & Civil Engineering Environmental Concerns of Large
More informationVI. WATER QUALITY MODELING
VI. WATER QUALITY MODELING As was mentioned previously in Chapter V, the Hamblin Pond/Jehu Pond and Quashnet River sub-systems of Waquoit Bay were a part of the larger hydrodynamic model of the Waquoit
More informationPhiladelphia Water Department 9/24/13
Philadelphia Water Department 9/24/13 Need for PWD to develop water quality models of Delaware and tidal Schuylkill Rivers Overview of data collection and modeling efforts Hydrodynamics and water quality
More informationOngoing and Completed Studies
Attachment 2 Ongoing and Completed Studies 2014 Monitoring and Analysis Plan November 2013 Attachment 2 Ongoing and Completed Studies 1 Introduction In 2013, the small interdisciplinary study groups for
More informationFortnightly Water Quality Report
0 Fortnightly Water Quality Report Ichthys Nearshore Environmental Monitoring Program Weeks 79/80: 24 February 2014 to March 2014 Weeks 79/80: 24 February 2014 to 9 March 2014 Prepared for INPEX October
More informationAT A GLANCE. Cairns Shipping Development Project. Revised Draft Environmental Impact Statement Fact Sheet July 2017.
Cairns Shipping Development Project Revised Draft Environmental Impact Statement Fact Sheet July 2017 AT A GLANCE > An additional 70 cruise ships into Port of Cairns each year by 2031 > Project design
More informationI202. Central Wharves Precinct
I202. Central Wharves Precinct I202.1. Precinct description The zoning of the land within the Central Wharves Precinct is the Business City Centre Zone and the underlying zoning of the part of the Central
More informationName Assessor or Approver Date
T: +44 (0)1224 295579 F: +44 (0)1224 295524 E: ms.majorprojects@gov.scot MARINE SCOTLAND LICENSING OPERATIONS TEAM S (MS-LOT) ASSESSMENT OF THE PROJECT S IMPLICATIONS FOR A DESIGNATED NATURE CONSERVATION
More informationImpacts of Dredging and Reclamation to Benthic Primary Producer Habitat (BPPH)
Section 9.2 Impacts of Dredging and Reclamation to Benthic Primary Producer Habitat (BPPH) Section 9.2.1 The management goals for BPPH are to: Management Goals for BPPH Maintain the abundance, diversity,
More informationSUMMARY OF EVIDENCE AND SUPPLEMENTARY COMMENTS OF BAS VEENDRICK. DATED 24 April 2018
BEFORE THE CANTERBURY REGIONAL COUNCIL AND THE ASHBURTON DISTRICT COUNCIL IN THE MATTER of the Resource Management Act 1991 AND IN THE MATTER of resource consent applications by Rangitata Diversion Race
More informationCLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION STRATEGY
12 th Trilateral Governmental Conference on the Protection of the WaddenSea Tønder, 5 February 2014 Ministerial Council Declaration, Annex 4 CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION STRATEGY Final Annex 4: MCD 2014 Climate
More informationEffects on Flood Levels from the Proposed Whakatane Marina
Effects on Flood Levels from the Proposed Whakatane Marina Peter West, Graduate Engineer Environment Bay of Plenty September 2004 5 Quay Street P O Box 364 Whakatane NEW ZEALAND ISSN 1176-5550 Working
More informationEFFECTIVENESS OF SILT SCREEN IN FRONT OF INDUSTRIAL WATER INTAKE
EFFECTIVENESS OF SILT SCREEN IN FRONT OF INDUSTRIAL WATER INTAKE Y.S. Wu 1, E. Neo 2, M. Jain 3 and C.A. Tan 4 ABSTRACT A Silt screen (curtain) is one of the most common mitigation measure used to contain
More informationCOASTAL PROTECTION, LANDSCAPING AND INFRASTRUCTURAL WORKS IN MAURITIUS CASE NOYALE SITE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT CONTENTS
COASTAL PROTECTION, LANDSCAPING AND INFRASTRUCTURAL WORKS IN MAURITIUS CASE NOYALE SITE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT CONTENTS Chapter Description Page EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 INTRODUCTION 1-1 1.1
More informationDRAFT PROPOSED SECTION 32 CHAPTER 5 NATURAL HAZARDS
DRAFT PROPOSED SECTION 32 CHAPTER 5 NATURAL HAZARDS 1 Supplementary Report to s32 report supporting second part of the draft Natural Hazards chapter This report provides an addendum to the Section 32 Natural
More informationChapter 8.0 Coastal Processes, Sediment Transport and Contamination
Chapter 8.0 Coastal Processes, Sediment Transport and Contamination www.tidallagoonswanseabay.com www.tidallagooncardiff.com 8.0 Coastal Processes, Sediment Transport and Contamination 8.1 Overview of
More informationUnderstanding the State Planning Policy July 2017 Changes to state interest statements, policies and assessment benchmarks
Understanding the State Planning Policy July 2017 Changes to state statements, policies and assessment benchmarks This fact sheet outlines the key policy changes to the state statements, policies and assessment
More informationAppendix G.16 Hatch Report Pacific NorthWest LNG LNG Jetty Propeller Scour Analysis
Appendix G.16 Hatch Report Pacific NorthWest LNG LNG Jetty Propeller Scour Analysis Pacific Northwest LNG - LNG Jetty Propeller Scour Analysis - December 11, 2014 Pacific Northwest LNG LNG Jetty Propeller
More informationEXECUTIVE SUMMARY. The major results and conclusions from the study are given below in three sections which focus in turn on:
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1. BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES The current area under sugarcane production in South Africa is some 400 000 ha. There is increased need to quantify the impact of sugarcane production on
More informationWater Quality Implication of a severn Barrage
Water Quality Implication of a severn Barrage by Reza Ahmadian, Bettina Bockelmann-Evans and Roger A. Falconer Hydro-environmental Research Centre School of Engineering, Cardiff University 1 General Challenges
More informationMonitoring and Modelling techniques for Marine Renewable Energy
Monitoring and Modelling techniques for Marine Renewable Energy Joe McGovern MIEI B.Eng. NUI Galway Final Project Workshop Thurso, Caithness 23 September 2015 Agenda Modelling: current research in Marine
More informationPreparing for the Impacts of Climate Change on Facilities and Channels
Preparing for the Impacts of Climate Change on Facilities and Channels Martin Mannion Maritime Project Director Halcrow Houston, TX AAPA Climate Change Workshop, Houston TX November 12 2008 1 Outline Sustainability
More informationPower Plants in northern Germany Project examples for optimizing intakes and outfalls
(Initial page layout) Power Plants in northern Germany Project examples for optimizing intakes and outfalls O. Stoschek* * Coastal and Estuarine Dynamics Department, DHI, Agern Allé 5, Hørsholm, Denmark,
More informationWelsh Assembly Government Consultation Document Secondary legislation under the Marine & Coastal Access Act 2009: Part 4 Marine Licensing
Marine Consents Unit Welsh Assembly Government Cathays Park Cardiff CF10 3NQ mcu@wales.gsi.gov.uk 29 th November 2010 Dear Sir/Madam Welsh Assembly Government Consultation Document Secondary legislation
More informationAustralia Pacific LNG Project Supplemental information to the EIS. Coastal Environment - Pipeline
Australia Pacific LNG Project Supplemental information to the EIS Coastal Environment - Pipeline Disclaimer This report has been prepared on behalf of and for the exclusive use of, and is subject to and
More informationWORK PROGRAMME on CO-OPERATION IN THE FIELD OF CLIMATE CHANGE VULNERABILITY, RISK ASSESSMENT, ADAPTATION AND MITIGATION Between THE MINISTRY OF
WORK PROGRAMME on CO-OPERATION IN THE FIELD OF CLIMATE CHANGE VULNERABILITY, RISK ASSESSMENT, ADAPTATION AND MITIGATION Between THE MINISTRY OF SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF CUBA
More informationPROPOSED WHARF AND DREDGING PROJECT RESOURCE CONSENT APPLICATIONS AND DESCRIPTION AND ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS ON THE ENVIRONMENT: VOLUME 1
PROPOSED WHARF AND DREDGING PROJECT RESOURCE CONSENT APPLICATIONS AND DESCRIPTION AND ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS ON THE ENVIRONMENT: VOLUME 1 PREPARED FOR PORT OF NAPIER LTD NOVEMBER 2017 PROPOSED WHARF AND
More information1 INTRODUCTION 2 MOTIVATION FOR THE PRESENT EXPERIMENT. Dynamics of the Salt-Freshwater Mixing Zone in Ocean Beaches. N. Cartwright 1 and P.
Second International Conference on Saltwater Intrusion and Coastal Aquifers Monitoring, Modeling, and Management. Mérida, Mexico, March 3 April, 3 Dynamics of the Salt-Freshwater Mixing Zone in Ocean Beaches
More informationWELSH GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE CLIMATE CHANGE, ENVIRONMENT AND RURAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE REPORT:
WELSH GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE CLIMATE CHANGE, ENVIRONMENT AND RURAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEE REPORT: FEEDBACK ON THE WELSH GOVERNMENT S DRAFT WELSH NATIONAL MARINE PLAN JUNE 2018 Background
More informationParlee Beach Water Quality Summary
Parlee Beach Water Quality Summary Introduction This document presents a summary of the report of the Steering Committee for the Parlee Beach Water Quality project. The Committee was comprised of representatives
More information4. FISH PASSAGE CONCEPTS
Feasibility Study for Restoration of Titlow Lagoon Fish Passage South Puget Sound Salmon Enhancement Group 4. FISH PASSAGE CONCEPTS Fish passage could be improved by rehabilitating the existing fish passage,
More information8. HYDROGRAPHICAL CONDITIONS
64 state of the seas 8. HYDROGRAPHICAL CONDITIONS Key Messages A substantial proportion of the Northern Ireland coastline has been altered by coastal defence structures. This is particularly prevalent
More informationFortnightly Water Quality Report
Fortnightly Water Quality Report Ichthys Nearshore Environmental Monitoring Program Weeks 20/21: to 20 January 2013 Weeks 20/21: 7 to 20 January 2013 Prepared for INPEX June 2013 Fortnightly Water Quality
More informationAdditional analyses of 2009 oceanographic data
APPENDIX H5.4 Additional analyses of 2009 oceanographic data 1 Olympic Dam Expansion Supplementary Environmental Impact Statement 2010 Memorandum From: Daniel Botelho To: David Wiltshire; James Brook Date:
More informationCOASTAL VULNERABILITY IN FUTURE WORLDS
RISES AM RESPONSES TO COASTAL CLIMATE CHANGE: INNOVATIVE STRATEGIES FOR HIGH END SCENARIOS ADAPTATION AND MITIGATION COASTAL VULNERABILITY IN FUTURE WORLDS Coordinator: Prof. A. Sanchez-Arcilla European
More informationBig Sarasota Pass and New Pass Inlet Management Plan 2008 Peer Review Report
Table of Contents Consolidated Report on Peer Reviews... Pages 2-17 Executive Summary. Page 2 Introduction... Page 5 Physical and Environmental Data Page 5 Numerical Modeling. Page 7 Coastal Engineering.
More informationUniversity of Waikato INTERCOAST Doctoral Scholarships Research Project List
UNIVERSITY OF WAIKATO INTERCOAST DOCTORAL SCHOLARSHIP RESEARCH PROJECT LIST The University of Waikato and the University of Bremen are seeking top-quality doctoral students to undertake projects that will
More informationCRITICAL ASSESSMENT OF MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AND POLICIES FOR STORMWATER AND SEDIMENT PONDS IN SOUTH CAROLINA
CRITICAL ASSESSMENT OF MANAGEMENT PRACTICES AND POLICIES FOR STORMWATER AND SEDIMENT PONDS IN SOUTH CAROLINA Md K. Huda 1 and Michael E. Meadows 2 AUTHORS: 1. Former Doctoral Student, Department of Civil
More informationOutput characteristics of tidal current power stations during spring and neap cycles
Output characteristics of tidal current power stations during spring and neap cycles Clarke J A, Grant A D and Johnstone C M Energy Systems Research Unit, Department of Mechanical Engineering University
More informationOperative Part VI Annexes 26 February Annex 1: Resource Management (Marine Pollution) Regulations 1998
Operative Part VI Annexes 26 February 2011 PART VI ANNEXES Annex 1: Resource Management (Marine Pollution) Regulations 1998 This annex is Sections 2-15 and Schedules 3-4 of the Resource Management (Marine
More information(No. of pages excluding this page = 10)
SPECIALIST CONSULTANT STUDIES 3-65 BIG ISLAND MINING PTY LTD (No. of pages excluding this page = 10) Ltd BIG ISLAND MINING PTY LTD 3-66 SPECIALIST CONSULTANT STUDIES This page has intentionally been left
More informationApril 11, Kimberly Prillhart Planning Director Resource management Agency County of Ventura 800 South Victoria Avenue Ventura, CA 93009
April 11, 2012 Kimberly Prillhart Planning Director Resource management Agency County of Ventura 800 South Victoria Avenue Ventura, CA 93009 RE: April 12, 2012 Hearing on Mosler Rock- Ojai Quarry Reclamation
More informationFinal Report. Severn Barrage Costing Exercise. The Renewable Energy Forum Ltd. IPA Energy + Water Consulting
Final Report Severn Barrage Costing Exercise to The Renewable Energy Forum Ltd March 2008 IPA Energy + Water Consulting Severn Barrage Costing Exercise to The Renewable Energy Forum Ltd IPA Energy + Water
More informationAPPENDIX N RICHARD SIMONDS GROUNDWATER REPORT
APPENDIX N RICHARD SIMONDS GROUNDWATER REPORT Technical memo - Specialist Unit To: Nicola Broadbent, Team Leader - North West Resource Consenting Unit, Auckland Council From: Richard Simonds, Senior Specialist
More informationEnvironmental aspects of Cork harbour dredging. Report no
DOCUMENT PRODUCED BY: Van Oord Dredging & Marine Contractors - Engineering Department CLIENT: PROJECT NO. 20.3432 DOCUMENT TITLE Environmental aspects of Cork harbour dredging Report no. 2929718 Rev. Prepared
More informationScalpay, Isle of Skye
Scalpay, Isle of Skye REPORT WRITTEN BY AUTODEPOMOD MODELLIN G REPORT 12.2016V1 ENVIRONMENTA L ANALYST) ENVIRONMENTAL MAN AGER) Registered in Scotland No. 138843 Registered Office, 1st Floor, Admiralty
More informationDissolved Oxygen in the Clyde
Dissolved Oxygen in the Clyde OceanMet Unit, Marine Science SEPA Ted Schlicke Introduction Description of Clyde estuary Factors affecting Dissolved Oxygen (DO) in water Data analysis- 40 years and >30k
More informationHydraulic and Sediment Transport Modeling Strategy
Appendix B Hydraulic and Sediment Transport May 2014 Technical Memorandum Channel Capacity Report September 2014 San Joaquin River Restoration Program Hydraulic and Sediment Transport The San Joaquin River
More informationAPPLICATION OF 1-D HEC-RAS MODEL IN DESIGN OF CHANNELS
APPLICATION OF 1-D HEC-RAS MODEL IN DESIGN OF CHANNELS Darshan J. Mehta * Mr. Manthan Ramani Mr. Maulik Joshi Asst. Prof., CED, S.S.A.S.I.T, Surat U.G, Student, CED, S.S.A.S.I.T, Surat U.G, Student, CED,
More informationWhere the Ocean Meets Land. Coastal Engineering
Where the Ocean Meets Land Coastal Engineering Photo credit : Rio Tinto Alcan Our Expertise MARINAS AND HARBOURS Design and repair of breakwaters Sedimentation and dredging studies Navigation guidelines
More informationSection 10 Marine Impacts and Management
Section 10 Marine Impacts and Management 10 Marine Impact Assessment and Management 10.1 Introduction This chapter provides an assessment of impacts that the construction and operation of the proposed
More informationWater Quality Modelling for all existing & currently proposed salmon farm sites in Bantry Bay
Water Quality Modelling for all existing & currently proposed salmon farm sites in Bantry Bay IBE0744/R07/Rev03/NS Marine Harvest Ireland February 2016 rpsgroup.com/ireland Water Quality Modelling for
More informationSouthern African Coastal Vulnerability Assessment. Dr Christo Rautenbach
Southern African Coastal Vulnerability Assessment Dr Christo Rautenbach 1 Content layout Introduction to coastal vulnerability Climate change Consequences on the coast Vulnerability and risk on coastal
More informationTransport of Suspended Solids in Dammam (Saudi Arabia) Coastal Areas: Fish Market Works
J. Water Resource and Protection, 2010, 2, 540-544 doi:10.4236/jwarp.2010.26061 Published Online June 2010 (http://www.scirp.org/journal/jwarp) Transport of Suspended Solids in Dammam (Saudi Arabia) Coastal
More information