March 29, Subject: Hawai'i Electric Light Energy Cost Adjustment Factor for April 2016

Transcription

1 JAY IGNACIO, P. E. President The Honorable Chair and Members of the Hawai'i Public Utilities Commission Kekuanaoa Building, First Floor 465 South King Street Honolulu, Hawai'i March 29, 2016 w...i -r m 0 Dear Commissioners: Subject: Hawai'i Electric Light Energy Cost Adjustment Factor for April 2016 Hawai'i Electric Light Company, Inc.'s ("Hawai'i Electric Light") energy cost adjustment factor for April 2016 is cents per kilowatt-hour ("kwh"), a decrease of cents per kwh from last month. A residential customer consuming 500 kwh of electricity will be paying $150.76, a decrease of $3.50 compared to the rates effective March 1, The decrease in the typical residential bill is due to the decrease in the energy cost adjustment factor (-$2.02), the decrease in the Purchased Power Adjustment Clause rate (-$0.09), and the credit for the SolarSaver Adjustment (-$1.39). Hawai'i Electric Light's fuel composite cost of generation decreased cents per million BTU to cents per million BTU. The composite cost of distributed generation decreased cents per kwh to cents per kwh. The composite cost of purchased energy decreased cents per kwh to cents per kwh. The attached sheets set forth the energy cost adjustment in cents per kwh for each rate schedule that is applicable for pro rata use beginning April 1, Sincerely, Attachments cc: Division of Consumer Advocacy Hawai'i Electric Light PO BOX 1027 I HILO, HI

2 ATTACHMENT 1 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY, INC. ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT FACTOR EFFECTIVE DATES 3/01/16 4/01/16 Change Composite Cost Generation, /mmbtu (76.00) Dispersed Generation Energy, /kwh (2.065) Purchased Energy, /kwh (0.094) Residential Schedule "R" Energy Cost Adjustment - /kwh (4.311) (4.715) (0.404) Others - "G,J,P,F" Energy Cost Adjustment - /kwh (4.311) (4.715) (0.404) Residential Customer with: 500 KWH Consumption - $/Bill $ $ ($3.50) 600 KWH Consumption - $/Bill $ $ ($4.19)

3 ATTACHMENT 2 SHEET 1 OF 2 Line 1 Effective Date April 1, Supercedes Factors of March 1, 2016 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY, INC. ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT (ECA) FILING ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT (ECA) FILING - April 1, 2016 (Page 1 of 2) CENTRAL STATION WITH WIND/HYDRO COMPONENT FUEL PRICES, /mmbtu 3 4 Hill Industrial Puna Industrial Keahole Diesel a Keahole ULSD 1, Waimea ULSD Diesel 1, Hilo Diesel a Hilo (Kanoelehua) ULSD Diesel 1 1, Puna Diesel DG ENERGY COMPONENT 10 Wind COMPOSITE COST OF DG 11 Hydro 0.00 ENERGY, /kwh % Input to System kwh Mix BTU MIX, % WEIGHTED COMPOSITE DG ENERGY COST, 13 Hill Industrial /kwh (Lines 35 x 36) Puna Industrial Keahole Diesel BASE DG ENERGY COMPOSITE COS a Keahole ULSD Waimea ULSD Diesel Base % Input to System kwh Mix Hilo Diesel WEIGHTED BASE DG ENERGY COST, 17a Hilo (Kanoelehua) ULSD Diesel Puna Diesel /kwh (Line 38 x 39) Wind Hydro Cost Less Base (Line 37-40) ( ) Loss Factor COMPOSITE COST OF GENERATION, 43 Revenue Tax Req Multiplier CENTRAL STATION + WIND/HYDRO /mmb DG FACTOR, /kwh 22 % Input to System kwh Mix (Line 41 x 42 x 43) ( ) EFFICIENCY FACTOR, mmbtu/kwh (A) (B) (C) (D) Percent of Eff Factor Centrl Stn + Weighted Fuel Type mmbtu/kwh Wind/Hydro Eff Factor 23 Industrial Diesel Other (Lines 23, 24, 25): Col(B) x Col(C) = Col(D) 26 Weighted Efficiency Factor, mmbtu/kwh [Lines 23(D) + 24(D) + 25(D)] WEIGHTED COMPOSITE CENTRAL STATION + WIND/HYDRO GENERATION COST, /kwh (Lines (21 x 22 x 26)) BASE CENTRAL STATION + WIND/HYDRO GENERATION COST, /mmbtu 1, Base % Input to Sys kwh Mix Efficiency Factor, mmbtu/kwh WEIGHTED BASE CENTRAL STATION + WIND/HYDRO GENERATION COST /kwh (Lines (28 x 29 x 30)) SUMMARY OF 32 COST LESS BASE (Line 27-31) ( ) TOTAL GENERATION FACTOR, /kwh 33 Revenue Tax Req Multiplier Cntrl Stn+Wind/Hydro (line 34) ( ) 34 CENTRAL STATION + WIND/HYDRO 46 DG (line 44) ( ) GENERATION FACTOR, 47 TOTAL GENERATION FACTOR, /kwh (Line (32 x 33)) ( ) /kwh (lines ) ( ) 1 Hilo ULSD same location as Kanoelehua ULSD GENERATION COMPONENT HELCO ECAC eff filed with price updatev1a.xlsm

4 ATTACHMENT 2 SHEET 2 OF 2 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY, INC. ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT (ECA) FILING ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT (ECA) FILING - April 1, 2016 (Page 2 of 2) Line PURCHASED ENERGY COMPONENT PURCHASED ENERGY PRICE, /kwh 48 HEP PGV On Peak PGV Off Peak PGV - Add'l 5 MW On Peak PGV - Add'l 5 MW Off Peak PGV - Add'l 8 MW On Peak PGV - Add'l 8 MW Off Peak Wailuku Hydro On Peak Wailuku Hydro Off Peak Hawi Renewable Dev. On Peak Hawi Renewable Dev. Off Peak Tawhiri (Pakini Nui) On Peak Tawhiri (Pakini Nui) Off Peak Small Hydro (>100 KW) On Peak Small Hydro (>100 KW) Off Peak Sch Q Hydro (<100 KW) FIT PURCHASED ENERGY KWH MIX, % 66 HEP PGV On Peak PGV Off Peak PGV - Addt'l On Peak PGV - Addt'l Off Peak PGV - Add'l 8 MW On Peak PGV - Add'l 8 MW Off Peak Wailuku Hydro On Peak Wailuku Hydro Off Peak Hawi Renewable Dev. On Peak Hawi Renewable Dev. Off Peak Tawhiri (Pakini Nui) On Peak Tawhiri (Pakini Nui) Off Peak Small Hydro (>100 KW) On Peak Small Hydro (>100 KW) Off Peak Sch Q Hydro (<100 KW) FIT COMPOSITE COST OF PURCHASED ENERGY, /kwh % Input to System kwh Mix WEIGHTED COMPOSITE PURCHASED ENERGY COST, /kwh (Lines (84 x 85)) BASE PURCHASED ENERGY COMPOSITE COST, /kwh Base % Input to Sys kwh Mix WEIGHTED BASE PURCHASED ENERGY COST, /kwh (Lines (87 x 88)) COST LESS BASE (Lines (86-89)) ( ) 91 Loss Factor Revenue Tax Req Multiplier PURCHASED ENERGY FACTOR, /kwh ( ) (Lines (90 x 91 x 92)) Line SYSTEM COMPOSITE 94 GENERATION AND PURCHASED ENERGY FACTOR, /kwh (Lines ( )) ( ) 95 Not Used Not Used ECA Reconciliation Adjustment ECA FACTOR, /kwh (4.715) (Lines ( )) HELCO ECAC eff filed with price updatev1a.xlsm

5 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 1 OF 10 Hawaii Electric Light Company, Inc. FUEL OIL INVENTORY PRICES FOR April 1, 2016 INDUSTRIAL FUEL COSTS: HILO PUNA Average Industrial Fuel Cost - $/BBL Land Transportation Cost - $/BBL Industrial Costs For Filing - $/BBL Conversion Factors - mmbtu/bbl Industrial Costs For Filing - /mmbtu DIESEL FUEL COSTS: KEAHOLE PUNA CT-3 HILO Average Diesel Fuel Cost - $/BBL Land Transportation Cost - $/BBL Diesel Costs For Filing - $/BBL Conversion Factors - mmbtu/bbl Diesel Costs For Filing - /mmbtu DISPERSED ULSD FUEL COSTS: KEAHOLE WAIMEA HILO GENERATION Average ULSD Fuel Cost - $/BBL Land Transportation Cost - $/BBL ULSD Costs For Filing - $/BBL Conversion Factors - mmbtu/bbl ULSD Costs For Filing - /mmbtu 1, , , , Dispersed Generation, cents per kwh COMPOSITE COST OF DISP. GEN. BBls Fuel: $/BBl Inv Cost: Fuel $ (Prod Sim Consumption x Unit Cost) 7, Net kwh (from Prod Sim) 70,000 cents/kwh:

6 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 2 OF 10 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 SHIPMAN INDUSTRIAL HILL INDUSTRIAL COST PER BARREL BBL COST BBL COST EXCL LT LT Total Balance at 02/29/ , , Less: Est'd Inventory Addn Purchases: Estimate xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Actual xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Transfers out: Estimate xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Actual xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Transfers in: Estimate (55,495) (1,714,844.32) Actual ,448 1,768, Consumed: Estimate ,576 1,602, Actual (46,641) (1,415,587.97) Balance Per G/L 02/29/ , , Purchases xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Transfer out xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Transfer in ,866 1,585, Consumed (42,213) (1,271,801.71) /31/ ,371 1,299, Inv From Offsite/Transfers Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel 03/31/ ,371 1,299, Reverse Fuel Balance xxxxxx 0.00 xxxxxxxx (1,299,616.95) Fuel Avg Price xxxxxx 0.00 xxxxxxxx 1,306, /30/2013 Avg Price ,371 1,306, Weighted Avg Cost/BBL by Location #DIV/0! Weighted Avg Avg Cost #DIV/0!

7 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 3 OF 10 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 PUNA INDUSTRIAL LAND COST PER BARREL BBL COST TRANSP EXCLUDE LT LT TOTAL Balance at 02/29/2016 8, , , Less: Est'd Inventory Addition Purchases: Estimate Actual Transfers out: Estimate Actual xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Transfers in: Estimate Actual Consumed: Estimate , Actual (321) (170,093.98) (605.64) Balance Per G/L 02/29/2016 8, , , Purchases Transfer out xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Transfer in Consumed (3) (90.38) (5.65) /31/2016 8, , , Inventory From Offsite/Transfers Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel Avg Price 8, , , Reverse Fuel Balance xxxxxxxxxxxx (254,492.75) xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Fuel Avg Price xxxxxxxxxxxx 248, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx 04/01/2016 Avg Price 8, , , Weighted Avg Cost/BBL by Location Weighted Avg Avg Cost

8 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 4 OF 10 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 KEAHOLE CT COST LAND COST PER BARREL HS Diesel BBL GALLONS EXCLUDE LT TRANSP EXCLUD LT LT TOTAL Balance at 02/29/ , ,904, ,830, ,745.1 Less: Est'd Inventory Addition Purchases: Estimate Actual Transfers out: Estimate Actual xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Transfers in: Estimate (37,569.6) (1,577,924.0) (2,219,150.7) (100,416.1) Actual 37, ,584, ,211, , Consumed: Estimate 42, ,799, ,007, , Actual (43,194.8) (1,814,181.0) (3,047,128.1) (119,341.2) Balance Per G/L 02/29/ , ,896,906 2,783, , Purchases Transfer out xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Transfer in 43, ,816, ,407, , Consumed (48,414.8) (2,033,421.0) (2,983,602.7) (126,632.52) /31/ , ,680,287 2,207, , Inventory From Offsite/Transfers Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel Avg Price 40, ,680,287 2,207, , Reverse Fuel Balance xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (2,207,653.8) xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Fuel Avg Price xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx 2,215,156.0 xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx 04/01/2016 Avg Price 40, ,680,287 2,215, , Weighted Avg Cost/BBL by Location Weighted Avg Avg Cost

9 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 5 OF 10 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 PUNA CT 3 COST LAND COST PER BARREL HS Diesel BBL GALLONS EXCLUD LT TRANSP EXCL LT LT TOTAL Balance at 02/29/2016 2, , , ,244.6 Less: Est'd Inven Addition Purchases: Estimate Actual Transfers out: Estimate Actual xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Transfers in: Estimate , , Actual , , Consumed: Estimate 1, , , ,809.2 Actual (1,216.3) (51,086.0) (142,759.0) (1,372.5) Balance Per G/L 02/29/2016 3, , , , Purchases Transfer out xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Transfer in (56.3) (2,366.0) (3,392.4) (67.4) Consumed (197.0) (8,273) (12,138.83) (226.50) /31/2016 3, , , , Inven From Offsite/Transfers Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel 03/31/2016 3, , , , Reverse Fuel Balance Fuel Avg Price xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (221,845.07) xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx 199, xxxxxxxxxxxx 04/01/2016 Avg Price 3, , , , Weighted Avg Cost/BBL by Location Weighted Avg Avg Cost

10 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 6 OF 10 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 TOTAL HILO HS DIESEL COST LAND COST PER BARREL HS Diesel BBL GALLONS EXCLUDE LT TRANSP EXCL LT LT TOTAL Balance at 02/29/ ,909 95, Less: Est'd Inven Addition Purchases: Estimate Actual Transfers out: Estimate Actual xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Transfers in: Estimate Actual Consumed: Estimate Actual Balance Per G/L 02/29/ ,295 88, , Purchases Transfer out xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Transfer in Consumed /31/2016 1, ,311 66, Inven From Offsite/Transfers Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel Avg Price 1, ,311 66, Reverse Fuel Balance xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx 66, xxxxxxxxxxxx Fuel Avg Price xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx 61, xxxxxxxxxxxx 04/01/2016 Avg Price 1, ,311 61, Weighted Avg Cost/BBL by Location Weighted Avg Avg Cost

11 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 7 OF 10 KEAHOLE DIESEL COST LAND COST PER BARREL ULSD BBL GALLONS EXCLUDE LT TRANSP EXCLUD LT LT TOTAL Balance at 02/29/2016 1, , , Less: Est'd Inventory Addition 0.0 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 Purchases: Estimate (379.1) (15,921) (20,761.00) (1,013.18) Actual ,875 20, Transfers out: Estimate Actual xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Transfers in: Estimate (179) 0.00 (11.39) Actual , Consumed: Estimate ,519 32, Actual (346.9) (14,568) (31,048.28) 4, Balance Per G/L 02/29/2016 2, , , , Purchases Estimated Purchases ,980 9, Transfer in Consumed (318.9) (13,395) (23,202.82) (834.19) /31/2016 1, , , , Inventory From Offsite/Transfers Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel Avg Price 1, , , , Reverse Fuel Balance xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx (137,297.36) xxxxxxxxxxxx Fuel Avg Price xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx 138, xxxxxxxxxxxx 04/01/2016 Avg Price 1, , , , Weighted Avg Cost/BBL by Location Weighted Avg Avg Cost

12 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 8 OF 10 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 WAIMEA DIESEL COST LAND COST PER BARREL ULSD BBL GALLONS EXCLUDE LT TRANSP LT TOTAL Balance at 02/29/2016 1, , , , Less: Est'd Inven Addition Purchases: Estimate (23,848) (31,097.80) (1,264.34) Actual 23, , Transfers out: Estimate Actual xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx Transfers in: Estimate Actual , , Consumed: Estimate ,450 44, , Actual (503.8) (21,160) (19,122.96) (1,136.98) Balance Per G/L 02/29/2016 1, , , , ULSD Purchases ,937 9, Estimated Purchases ,980 9, Transfer in xxxxxxxxxxxx (2,309) #DIV/0! Consumed (296.0) (12,430) (21,531.25) (634.68) /31/2016 1, , , , Inven From Offsite/Transfers Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel Avg Price 1, , , , Reverse Fuel Balance xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx (102,077.89) xxxxxxxxxxxx Fuel Avg Price xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx 103, xxxxxxxxxxxx 04/01/2016 Avg Price 1, , , , Weighted Avg Cost/BBL by Location Weighted Avg Avg Cost

13 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 9 OF 10 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 KANOELEHUA DIESEL COST LAND ULSD BBL GALLONS EXCLUDE LT TRANSP Balance at 02/29/2016 1, , , ,287.7 Less: Est'd Inventory Addition Purchases: Estimate (190.0) (7,980) (13,556.42) (174.78) Actual ,932 10, Transfers out: Estimate x x x Actual x x x Transfers in: Estimate Actual (53) Consumed: Estimate ,228 15, Actual (155.0) (6,509) (28,400.84) (433.10) Balance Per G/L 02/29/2016 1, , , , ULSD Purchases #DIV/0! Estimated Purchases 0 Transfer in (4) (152) 0.00 (3.33) Consumed (76.3) (3,203) (5,548.24) (131.33) /31/2016 1, ,996 98, , Inventory From Offsite/Transfers Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel Avg Price 1, ,996 98, , Reverse Fuel Balance x x (98,996.73) x Fuel Avg Price x x 96, x 04/01/2016 Avg Price 1, ,996 96, , Weighted Avg Cost/BBL by Location Weighted Avg Avg Cost

14 ATTACHMENT 3 SHEET 10 OF 10 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT CO., INC. Estimated Weighted Average March 2016 DISPERSED GENERATION BBL GALLONS COST COST/BBL Balance at 02/29/ ,518 4, Less: Est'd Inven Addition 0.0 XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Purchases: Estimate (31.9) (1,340) (1,747.36) Actual ,333 3, Consumed: Estimate ,616 3, Actual (30.0) (1,260) (2,527.59) xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Balance Per G/L 02/29/ ,867 6, Purchases Transfer out Transfer in xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx Consumed (7.8) (326) (564.70) /31/ ,541 6, Est'd Inventory Addition Fuel 03/31/ ,541 6, Reverse Fuel Balance xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx (6,134.04) xxxx Fuel Avg Price xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx 6, xxxx 04/01/2016 Avg Price ,541 6,

15 ATTACHMENT 4 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY, INC. CONTRACT PRICES EFFECTIVE March 1, 2016 TYPE OF OIL BURNED Hill Industrial Puna Industrial INDUSTRIAL * /MBTU $/BBL /MBTU $/BBL Tax Ocean Transportation Storage Wharfage Hilo Diesel Waimea Diesel DIESEL * /MBTU $/BBL /MBTU $/BBL Tax Ocean Transportation Storage Wharfage Kona Diesel CT3 Diesel /MBTU $/BBL /MBTU $/BBL Tax Ocean Transportation Storage Wharfage ULSD ULSD ** /MBTU $/BBL Tax Ocean Transportation Storage Wharfage Tax includes HGET, Hawaii Use Tax, Liquid Fuel Tax, LUST Tax and Environmental Response Tax. Note: Since the components above are not accounted for separately in inventory, contract prices for the current month are being provided. Contract prices are considered accurate pending actual delivery of fuel. * Land Transportation Costs are shown in Attachment 3, Sheet 1. ** ULSD includes Waimea, Kanoelehua, and Keahole. Reference: Decision and Order No , Docket No

16 ATTACHMENT 5 SHEET 1 OF 1 Hawaii Electric Light Company, Inc. PURCHASED POWER PRICES FOR April 1, 2016 April 1, 2016 ( /kwh) Floor Rates ( /kwh) PGV (25 MW) - on peak PGV (22 MW) - off peak WAILUKU HYDRO - on peak Other: (<100 KW) Sch Q Rate April 1, 2016 ( /kwh) Floor Rates ( /kwh) HEP PGV Addtl 5 MW - on peak off peak PGV Addtl 8 MW - on peak off peak

17 ATTACHMENT 6 SHEET 1 OF 1 Hawaii Electric Light Company, Inc. Energy Cost Reconciliation Adjustment April 1, 2016 Line No. Description Amount 1 Amount to be returned or collected $282,600 2 Monthly Amount ( 1 / 3 x Line 1) $94,200 3 Revenue Tax Divisor Total (Line 2 / Line 3) $103,386 5 Estimated MWh Sales (April 1, 2016) 83,198 mwh 6 Adjustment (Line 4 / Line 5) /kwh

18 ATTACHMENT 7 HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY, INC Cumulative Reconciliation Balance (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) FOA Rec FOA Rec Month-end YTD FOA Adjust Less Try to Actual Cumulative Month Reconciliation Qtr Variance Variance Collect Collect Balance November (373,000) [3] 8,070 (381,070) 124, ,960 (208,168) December , ,559 (83,609) January , ,173 33,564 February 534,600 [4] 5, ,280 (178,200) (180,037) 382,807 March (178,200) (176,746) 206,061 April (178,200) (179,220) 26,841 May (1,118,800) [1] (7,543) (1,111,257) 372, ,805 (710,611) June 372, ,321 (325,290) July 372, ,805 75,515 August (421,800) [2] 12,240 (434,040) 140, ,649 (209,876) September 140, ,054 (60,822) October 140, ,611 81,789 November 791,200 [3] 44, ,825 (263,733) (262,906) 565,708 December (263,733) (256,311) 309,397 January 16 (263,733) (264,541) 44,856 February (282,600) [4] 10,260 (292,860) 94,200 95,382 (152,622) March 94,200 April 94,200 NOTES: Col(1): Quarterly FOA reconciliation amounts. (Refer to Attachment 6) A positive number is an over-collection. A negative number is an under-collection. Col(2): FOA reconciliation adjustment variance accumulated during the last three months, starting with the fourth prior month; the difference between the estimated recorded sales used to derive the $/kwh adjustment and the actual recorded sales. (Col(5)-Col(4)) Col(3): FOA reconciliation generated in the current quarter. The YTD FOA reconciliation difference minus the adjustment variance. Col(1)-Col(2) Col(4): Amount that the FOA reconciliation adjustment is trying to collect. (Col(1) * 1/3) Col(5): Actual collected amount. (recorded sales * $/kwh adjustment/ ) Col(6): Cumulative balance of the FOA reconciliation (Previous balance + Col(3) + Col(5))

19 ATTACHMENT 8 Hawaii Electric Light Company, Inc. Residential Bill at 500 KWH/Month Consumption $250 $245 $240 $235 $230 $225 $220 $215 $210 $205 $200 $195 $190 $185 $180 $175 $170 $165 $160 $155 $150 $145 $140 $135 $130 $125 Jan 2014 Feb Mar Apr May June July August September October November December Jan 2015 Feb Mar Apr May June July August September October November December Jan 2016 Feb Mar Apr Dollars per Month

20 ATTACHMENT 9A HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY, INC. FUEL OIL ADJUSTMENT FACTOR DATA EFFECTIVE DATE FUEL FACTOR CENTS / KWH RESIDENTIAL & RESIDENTIAL BILL ($) KWH January 1, January 3, February 1, March 1, April 1, April 9, May 1, June 1, July 1, August 1, September 1, October 1, November 1, December 1, January 1, February 1, March 1, April 1, May 1, June 1, July 1, August 1, September 1, October 1, November 1, December 1, January 1, February 1, March 1, April 1, May 1, June 1, July 1, August 1, September 1, October 1, November 1, December 1, January 1, February 1, March 1, April 1, May 1, June 8, July 1, August 1, September 1, October 1, November 1, December 1, January 1, February 1, March 1, April 1,

21 ATTACHMENT 9B HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY, INC. RESIDENTIAL SURCHARGE DATA EFFECTIVE DATE DESCRIPTION OF SURCHARGE RATE 01/01/12-12/31/12 RESIDENTIAL PBF SURCHARGE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 01/01/12-04/08/12 INTERIM RATE INCREASE 2010 TEST YEAR 1.74 PERCENT ON BASE 04/01/12-04/08/12 FIRM CAPACITY SURCHARGE PERCENT ON BASE 04/01/12-04/30/12 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 04/09/12 FINAL RATE INCREASE (1.28%), DOCKET NO (2010 TEST YEAR) 04/09/12-7/31/2012 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 05/01/12 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 06/18/12-5/31/2013 REVENUE BALANCING ACCOUNT RATE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 8/1/ /31/2012 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 11/1/2012 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 01/01/13 RESIDENTIAL PBF SURCHARGE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 02/01/13 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 04/01/13-04/30/13 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 05/01/13-03/31/14 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 05/01/13-07/31/2013 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 6/1/2013 RBA RATE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 7/1/2013 RESIDENTIAL PBF SURCHARGE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 8/1/2013-8/31/2013 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 9/1/2013-9/30/2013 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 10/1/ /31/2013 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 11/1/ /30/2013 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 12/1/ /31/2013 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 1/1/2014-1/31/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 2/1/2014-2/28/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 3/1/2014-3/31/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 4/1/2014-4/30/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 4/1/2014-4/30/2014 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 5/1/2014-5/31/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 5/1/2014-5/31/2014 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 6/1/2014-6/30/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 6/1/2014-5/31/15 RBA RATE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 7/1/2014-7/31/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 7/1/2014 RESIDENTIAL PBF SURCHARGE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 8/1/2014-8/31/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 9/1/2014-9/30/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 10/1/ /31/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 11/1/ /30/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 12/1/ /31/2014 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 12/1/2014 RESIDENTIAL PBF SURCHARGE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 12/1/2014-6/30/15 GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE FEE DOLLARS/MONTH 1/1/2015-1/31/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 2/1/2015-2/28/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 3/1/2015-3/31/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 4/1/2015-4/30/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 4/1/2015-4/30/2015 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 5/1/2015-5/31/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 5/1/2015 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 6/1/2015-6/30/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 6/1/2015-6/7/2015 RBA RATE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 6/8/2015 RBA RATE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 7/1/2015-7/31/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 7/1/2015 RESIDENTIAL PBF SURCHARGE ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH 7/1/ /31/2015 GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE FEE DOLLARS/MONTH 8/1/2015-8/31/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 9/1/2015-9/30/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 10/1/ /31/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 11/1/ /30/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 12/1/ /31/2015 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 1/1/2016-1/31/2016 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 1/1/2016 GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE FEE DOLLARS/MONTH 2/1/2016-2/29/16 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 3/1/2016-3/31/16 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 4/1/2016-4/30/16 PURCHASED POWER ADJUSTMENT CLAUSE CENTS/KWH 4/1/2016-4/30/16 SOLARSAVER ADJUSTMENT CENTS/KWH **Base charges include customer charge, demand charge, energy charge, power factor adjustment, voltage discount, and minimum charge.

22 ATTACHMENT 10 Hawaii Electric Light Company, Inc. Calculations of the Average Residential Customer Bill Rate Charge ($) at 500 Kwh 3/01/16 4/01/16 3/01/16 4/01/16 Difference Base Rates effective date: 4/9/2012 4/9/2012 Base Fuel Energy Charge /kwh $81.24 $81.24 $0.00 Non-fuel Fuel Energy Charge /kwh $62.72 $62.72 $0.00 First 300 kwh per month /kwh $33.61 $33.61 $0.00 Next 700 kwh per month /kwh $29.11 $29.11 $0.00 Customer Charge $ $10.50 $10.50 $0.00 Total Base Charges $ $ $0.00 RBA Rate Adjustment /kwh $6.99 $6.99 $0.00 Purchased Power Adj. Clause /kwh $10.70 $ $0.09 PBF Surcharge /kwh $2.37 $2.37 $0.00 DSM Adjustment /kwh $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 SolarSaver Adjustment /kwh (0.2779) $0.00 -$1.39 -$1.39 Energy Cost Adjustment /kwh (4.3110) (4.7150) -$ $ $2.02 Green Infrastructure Fee $ $1.30 $1.30 $0.00 Avg Residential Bill at 500 kwh $ $ Increase (Decrease -) -$3.50 % Change -2.27% Rate Charge ($) at 600 Kwh 3/01/16 4/01/16 3/01/16 4/01/16 Difference Base Rates effective date: 4/9/2012 4/9/2012 Base Fuel/Energy Charge /kwh $97.49 $97.49 $0.00 Non-fuel Fuel Energy Charge /kwh $77.27 $77.27 $0.00 First 300 kwh per month /kwh $33.61 $33.61 $0.00 Next 700 kwh per month /kwh $43.66 $43.66 $0.00 Customer Charge $ $10.50 $10.50 $0.00 Total Base Charges $ $ $0.00 RBA Rate Adjustment /kwh $8.38 $8.38 $0.00 Purchased Power Adj. Clause /kwh $12.84 $ $0.10 PBF Surcharge /kwh $2.85 $2.85 $0.00 DSM Adjustment /kwh $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 SolarSaver Adjustment /kwh (0.2779) $0.00 -$1.67 -$1.67 Energy Cost Adjustment /kwh (4.3110) (4.7150) -$ $ $2.42 Green Infrastructure Fee $ $1.30 $1.30 $0.00 Avg Residential Bill at 600 kwh $ $ Increase (Decrease -) -$4.19 % Change -2.27%