Enforcement. Facilitator: Mark Dean
|
|
- Garry Johnston
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Enforcement Facilitator: Mark Dean 1
2 DREAM framework Outline The Enforcement Pyramid Options for remedies Early signs when enforcement mechanisms are not working 2
3 Reminder: The Power Of Incentives Most of economics can be summarised in four words: People respond to incentives. The rest is commentary. Steven Landsburg The Armchair Economist So in enforcement we must look at the incentives that exist now and that will result 6/23/15 3
4 Reminder: Hampton Principles Regulators, and the regulatory system as a whole, should use comprehensive risk assessment to concentrate resources on the areas that need them most All Regulations should be written so that they are easily understood, easily implemented, and easily enforced, and all interested parties should be consulted when they are being drafted Businesses should not have to give unnecessary information, nor give the same piece of information twice to the same or different regulators The few businesses that persistently break Regulations should be identified quickly and face proportionate and meaningful sanctions. It should be easy to determine non-compliance. Government and regulators should provide authoritative, accessible advice easily and cheaply so businesses know what is expected of them. When new policies are being developed, explicit consideration should be given to how they can be enforced using existing systems and data to minimise the Administrative Burden imposed. 4
5 Discussion Group 1: Examples of where approaches to enforcement have worked well / or not Group 2: What factors can make enforcement more challenging and how can you address these factors? 5
6 Challenges of Enforcing Regulation DETECTING Gaining of information on undesirable and non-compliant behaviour RESPONDING developing of enforcement policies, rules and tools to deal with the problems discovered ENFORCING application of policies, rules and tools on ground ASSESSING Measuring of success or failure in enforcement activities MODIFYING Adjusting tools and strategies so as to improve compliance and address problematic behaviour. 6
7 Detection- Challenges Hard to detect errant behaviour when Regulated community is extensive (e.g. environmental controls for whole population) Easy to hide rules being broken (often have to rely on tip-offs and whistleblowing) On some issues, hard to define compliance Lack of funding and resources So targeting of resources and effort key 7
8 Responding Enforcers may not have the full range of tools needed because of legal constraints E.g. may not have the power to take samples or issue on the spot fines May be hard to get government to take time to update relevant legislation Resource constraints for surveys and inspections Rules may be too vague, complex, long, or even too specific Do you need to be specific in order to enable prosecutions? Or are you aiming for broad promotion of best practice Rules be be too targeted or too inclusive (or under inclusive) We will discuss enforcement pyramid later Risk of creative compliance by firms Avoid one size fits all consider blended approach 8
9 Table of Eleven (Dutch Approach) 1. Knowledge of rules (familiarity and clarity) 2. Costs/ benefits (to those affected) 3. Extent of acceptance of policy (objective and effects) 4. Target group s respect for authority 5. Non-official (social) control (e.g. professional expectations, social norms) 6. Risk of being reported (consumer complaint, tip-offs, whistleblower) 7. Risk of inspection (records/ physical) 8. Risk of detection through inspection 9. Selectivity (the perceived risk that violation will be caught affected by hit-rate of inspections etc) 10. Risk of sanction (once caught) 11. Severity of sanction (direct costs of sanction, reputation etc) 9
10 Enforcement Strategies Informal techniques (education, advice, persuasion, negotiation) to PROMOTE compliance does not work for everyone excessive deterrence can have limited effect on behaviour and conflict with a learning based performance culture but builds constructive relationship between regulator and regulated Formal enforcement and prosecution to DETER noncompliance can be costly to prosecute but arguably provides strong incentives for management of firms to tackle infringement 10
11 Bounded Rationality The bounded rationality of organisations and top management means that many do not make rational cost-benefit calculations about compliance until something happens to bring the risks of non-compliance to their attention. Economic costs which do not draw attention to themselves by generating some kind of crisis are often overlooked by busy management Parker The Open Corporation 11
12 Macrory Review (2006) Recommended that a variety of sanctions, falling short of criminal prosecution, would enable regulators to deal effectively with non-compliance in cases where a criminal prosecution is not warranted The UK Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Act 2008 (RESA) provided regulators with new civil sanctioning powers Gives regulators the ability to respond on a case by case basis. 12
13 Civil Sanctions Options (1) Fixed monetary penalty (on the spot fine set to specific tariff) Variable monetary penalty (discretionary) Compliance notice (steps to take in specific time so offence does not continue or recur) Restoration notice (steps to take in specific time so situation restored to what it would have been if offence had not been committed) 13
14 Civil Sanction Options (2) Stop notice (prohibits regulated party from carrying on activity until specific steps have been completed) Enforcement undertakings (undertaking made by the regulated party to do something specific) (Prosecution still an option) 14
15 Enforcement Pyramid Ayres and Braithwaite 15
16 Reminder: Enforcement Strategies Regulated Self Assurance 16
17 Establishing and Following Correct Inspection Procedures No inspection without a purpose Consistent criteria about what to look for (e.g. checklists) and consistent guidance on responses Coaching and supervision from management Ensure procedures not so rigid that blatantly unfair outcomes result Logging of activities and results via (IT) Inspection Management Systems (allows this to be taken account of in later inspections) Requirements to record reasons for decisions Learning (from experience) mechanisms. (At same time need to avoid too much admin burden on inspectors and other regulator staff) 17
18 Assessment How do your organisations know how much noncompliant activity is slipping though the net? Challenges Measuring non-compliant behaviour beyond reach of regulatory authority, but that affects achievement of objectives e.g. environment Are laws and rules clear enough to make assessment? Temptation to focus on input activity rather than outcomes Where enforcement is spread across regulators Sometimes can use outcomes e.g. with pesticides in water, proxy measure of how much residues are in water 18
19 Modifications Need learning culture, not blame culture in regulator (and regulated?) Need not just to tinker with regulatory strategies as they are, but be willing to adopt new strategy (or mix) if needed (e.g. from command and control to industry-administered regulated self assurance). 19
20 Thoughts The decision about whether to go for preventative strategies or act-stage interventions or harm-stage interventions will depend on risk assessment When you have 90 percent of what you want, think twice before insisting on the other 10 percent Thomas Sowell Cost of perfection can be too high 20
21 Discussion What early warning signs might there be in your sectors that regulation is not working as it should? (Remember discussions about systemic risk building up in banking) 21
22 A more collaborative approach? Effective regulation should be viewed as producing desirable behaviour by the people involved; and Businesses should be encouraged to adopt ethical practice and regulatory systems and actions should support and incentivise this. Hodges 2016 BRE 22
23 Rationalised Regulatory Architecture High-level general principles (provided by the national regulator), which can be seen as akin to outcome based regulation; and Provision of detail at a lower (potentially non-regulator) tier, for example in guidance at sectoral (trade association), internal (group or corporate), or area (Chambers of Commerce for SMEs) level. 23
24 Moving to Principles/Performance Based Regulation: Enforcement Command and Control Principles Based Intervention strategy based on dialogue and trust (co-operate interest) Authority intervention should be risk based and management system oriented The intervention must be a supplement not a replacement of the industry`s own follow up The Intervention should be balanced between different purposes (Technical and operational safety issues and occupational safety and health) Stakeholder participation (inc workforce involvement) and collaboration are presumptions for the intervention Adequate use of enforcement mechanism
25 Developing Regulated Self Assurance Command and Control Principles Based Regulators enforcing strategy Control based checking of compliance Dialogue oriented approach Influencing compliance Driving compliance Type of relationship Adverse interest Policing approach Unannounced inspections Use of checklists Common interest and trust Announced supervision Focus on management systems and follow up verifications Involvement of stakeholders Non or minimum involvement of stakeholders Strong involvement of stakeholders in different arenas of cooperation; policy, industrial and entity level PT
26 Regulated Self Assurance Mechanisms Assurance schemes Industry registers Regulator supervision of industry/professions self regulation Accredited voluntary registration Company self regulation
27 Pre-Conditions for Successful Policy and Regulation Veracity (willing to embrace truth and facts) Neutrality (open & aware of assumptions) Willingness (determination to find best solution) Acceptance (deal with society/ economy as it is, not as you d like it to be) Reason (logical analysis of evidence) Concern for people (i.e. the real impact in the real world). Thanks for your attention. 22
28 Further Reading Understanding Regulation (Second Edition) Martin Baldwin, Martin Cave, Martin Lodge 23
Regulatory operating model
RAIL SAFETY Regulatory operating model NZ Transport Agency Published March 2017 (16-316) ISBN 978-1-98-851211-2 (print) ISBN 978-1-98-851212-9 (online) Copyright: March 2017 NZ Transport Agency If you
More informationRegulatory operating model
RAIL SAFETY Regulatory operating model NZ Transport Agency Published March 2017 Updated June 2018 (16-316) ISBN 978-1-98-851211-2 (print) ISBN 978-1-98-851212-9 (online) Copyright: March 2017 NZ Transport
More informationRegulatory Enforcement and Inspections
Regulatory Enforcement and Inspections The Business Perspective Natanel Haiman October 2012 1 What is BIAC? BIAC is the voice of business at the OECD Independent organisation officially recognised by the
More informationREFORMING INSPECTION OVERSIGHT: Alignment with global good practices and standards
REFORMING INSPECTION OVERSIGHT: Alignment with global good practices and standards I. International inspection standards Public-private dialogue on the inspection oversight system in Serbia has resulted
More informationBUSINESS COMPLIANCE WITH COMPETITION RULES
28 November 2011 BUSINESS COMPLIANCE WITH COMPETITION RULES KEY MESSAGES 1 2 3 Competition provides the best incentive for efficiency, encourages innovation and guarantees consumers the best choice for
More informationINDUSTRY SUPERVISION STRATEGY 2016
INDUSTRY SUPERVISION STRATEGY 2016 ANIMAL WELFARE TRUSTED RISK- HIGH INTEGRITY BASED OUTCOME FOCUSED WELCOME TO GRNSW S INDUSTRY SUPERVISION STRATEGY Introduction Greyhound Racing NSW (GRNSW) is both
More informationONR REGULATORS CODE SELF- ASSESSMENT REPORT 2018
ONR REGULATORS CODE SELF- ASSESSMENT REPORT 2018 May 2018 ONR Regulators Code Self-Assessment Report 2018 Office for Nuclear Regulation 2018 Contents Contents Progress against previous actions..1 Update
More informationRegulation Of Older Persons Care
Regulation Of Older Persons Care John Farrelly Head Of Programme HIQA 10th World Conference on Elder Abuse 22 April 2015 Dublin HIQA s Core Values Drive high quality & safe care for people using health
More informationICO s DP Regulatory Action Policy details the guiding principles supporting decisions on enforcement.
1 Regulators should carry out the their activities in a way that supports those they regulate to comply and grow 1.1 Regulators should avoid imposing unnecessary regulatory burdens through their regulatory
More informationIMPEL Project Developing a checklist for assessing legislation on practicability and enforceability
IMPEL Project Developing a checklist for assessing legislation on practicability and enforceability Project Recommendations 1. All actors at the different stages of the EU legislative and implementation
More informationBRIEFING NOTE BUILDING MINISTERS FORUM- SHERGOLD & WEIR REPORT APRIL 2018
1. INTRODUCTION The Building Ministers Forum (BMF) comprises the Australian Government, State and Territory Ministers with responsibility for building and construction. In mid-2017 the BMF requested an
More informationUse of Regulatory Tools
Page 1 of 10 Use of Regulatory Tools 1. Purpose and Scope... 2 2. Application... 2 3. Authority... 2 4. References... 2 5. The Civil Aviation Authority s regulatory tools... 3 6. Identifying appropriate
More informationRegulatory Compliance and Enforcement Framework
Contents 1. About us... 3 1.1 Our Mission and Values... 3 2. Relevant Legislation and Obligations... 4 3. Approach to Regulatory Compliance and Enforcement... 4 3.1 Our Approach... 4 3.2 Working with Stakeholders...
More informationPartial Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment (BRIA) TITLE OF PROPOSAL
Partial Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment (BRIA) TITLE OF PROPOSAL Better Environmental Regulation: Proposals for a new Integrated Framework of Environmental Regulation and Future Funding Arrangements
More informationStrategic plan
Strategic plan 2018-21 April 2018 Chair s foreword The Legal Services Board s vision is for legal services that everyone can access and trust. This strategy sets out how we will approach achieving this
More informationEnforcement and Inspections A Journey Towards Change BRDO and the UK context
Enforcement and Inspections A Journey Towards Change BRDO and the UK context Graham Russell Better Regulation Delivery Office OECD 29 th October 2012 A Journey Towards Change Good regulation supports growth
More informationAmCham EU s Recommendations on GDPR Implementation
AmCham EU s Recommendations on GDPR Implementation Ensuring a balanced and forwardlooking data protection framework in Europe Executive summary AmCham EU s recommendations for the implementation of the
More informationCity of Atlanta Ethics Office Work Plan
City of Atlanta Ethics Office 2010-2011 Work Plan The Ethics Officer, in conjunction with the City of Atlanta s Board of Ethics, proposes a two-year work plan for the calendar years 2010 and 2011. This
More informationENVIRONMENTAL AUDITING GUIDE TD 16/16/E
ENVIRONMENTAL AUDITING GUIDE MIDDLE EAST GASES ASSOCIATION (MEGA) European Business Center, Office BC 25 Dubai Investments Park, PO Box: 166 Dubai-UAE Tel: +971-4-8135525 / Fax: +971-4-8135575 / E-mail:
More informationSupply Chain Specialist
Role Title Job Family Supply Chain Specialist Supply Chain Competency Level Pay Range / Scale Principal Officer/Manager PO6 Purpose To support the council s category management approach to procurement
More informationEuropean Parliament resolution of 8 March 2011 on the revision of the General Product Safety Directive and market surveillance (2010/2085(INI))
P7_TA(2011)0076 General product safety and market surveillance European Parliament resolution of 8 March 2011 on the revision of the General Product Safety Directive and market surveillance (2010/2085(INI))
More informationMatters of special interest to the Subordinate Legislation Committee
Explanatory Memorandum to The Eggs and Chicks (Wales) Regulations 2009 (the 2009 Regulations ) which supersede the Eggs (Marketing Standards) Regulations 1995, as amended (the 1995 Regulations ) This Explanatory
More informationA Guide to the Health and
A Guide to the Workplace Health and Safety Legislation Contents Introduction... 2 In the Workplace... 6 Reporting Serious Bodily Injury and. Dangerous Incident... 9 Regulations and Codes of Practice...
More informationGuidelines for Pharmacovigilance Inspections
PHARMACY BOARD OF SIERRA LEONE Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance Inspections Guideline No. : PBSL/PVGCT/GDL/QPPV/04-2017 Effective Date. :27 th March, 2017 Version No. : 01 1 TABLE OF CONTENT TABLE OF CONTENT
More informationUKPHR guidance on CPD scheme for practitioners
2 nd edition September 2017 (1 st edition July 2014) UKPHR guidance on CPD scheme for practitioners PURPOSE OF THIS GUIDANCE UKPHR has a mandatory CPD requirement to which all practitioner registrants
More informationAnalysing the situation and problems Mini guide 1
Smarter Regulation of Waste in Europe (LIFE13 ENV-UK-000549) LIFE SMART Waste Project Action B14: Analysing the situation and problems Mini guide 1 Helping you to make the right decisions in complex environmental
More informationPractical Systems Review. A Self-Review Tool for Local Government to Evaluate the Capability and Performance of Compliance Systems
Practical Systems Review A Self-Review Tool for Local Government to Evaluate the Capability and Performance of Compliance Systems October 2012 Prepared for the Hunter & Central Coast Regional Environmental
More informationGroup Code of Ethics
Updated July 2016 Group Code of Ethics Introduction Eurofins' mission, vision and values set out the conditions for our long-term success and are a core part of the way we expect employees of the companies
More informationEA-7/04 Legal Compliance as a part of accredited ISO 14001: 2004 certification
Publication Reference EA-7/04 Legal Compliance as a part of Accredited ISO 14001: 2004 certification PURPOSE The text of this document has been produced by a working group in the European co-operation
More informationBehavioural Attributes Framework
Behavioural Attributes Framework There are eight attributes in the University of Cambridge Behavioural Attributes Framework: Communication; Relationship Building; Valuing Diversity; Achieving Results;
More informationRoundtable on. Competition Policy and Public Procurement
Intergovernmental Group of Experts on Competition Law and Policy Geneva, 9 11 July 2012 Roundtable on Competition Policy and Public Procurement Written contribution by Lithuania The views expressed are
More informationEU STRATEGY FOR CSR
9 January 2012 EU STRATEGY 2011-2014 FOR CSR 1 2 3 KEY MESSAGES CSR is driven by business, reflected in the growing number of companies integrating CSR into their business strategies, aware of the benefits
More informationFCA Mission Statement Consultation Responsible Finance Response - DRAFT 26 January 2017
FCA Mission Statement Consultation Responsible Finance Response - DRAFT 26 January 2017 Q1: Do you think our definition of a well-functioning market is complete? What other characteristics do you think
More information2011/MAG/WKSP1/009 Verification and Audit Techniques
2011/MAG/WKSP1/009 Verification and Audit Techniques Submitted by: Australia Self-Certification Pathfinder Phase 2: Capacity Building Workshop 2 Manila, Philippines 10 11 February 2011 Verification and
More informationGetting it right. Guide to Trade Practices Laws and the University. Why read this? The Commerce Act Overview
Getting it right Why read this? A range of trade practices laws apply to the University and associated organisations. Failure to comply with these laws can result in significant penalties and reputational
More informationEUROPEAN COMMISSION REGULATORY SCRUTINY BOARD OPINION
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, 11.4.2018 SEC(2018) 185 REGULATORY SCRUTINY BOARD OPINION Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Council Directive 93/13/EEC of 5
More informationRevised Competency Framework for HCPC Panellists
Tribunal Advisory Committee, 31 May 2017 Revised Competency Framework for HCPC Panellists Executive summary and recommendations Introduction 1. As part of preparation for establishing the Health and Care
More informationFramework for the implementation and enforcement of the principles of good practice in vertical relations in the food supply chain
Framework for the implementation and enforcement of the principles of good practice in vertical relations in the food supply chain 25 th January 2013 Signatories: AIM CELCAA ERRT EuroCommerce Euro Coop
More informationImproving Regulatory Quality
Improving Regulatory Quality Using the Regional Charter for Regulatory Quality Effectively: A Training Course for Practitioners in Arab Countries Thomas Larouche Policy Analyst Regulatory Policy Division
More informationFor issues involving bullying and/or harassment, reference should be made to the Dignity at Work and Study policy and procedures.
Grievance Procedure Grievance Principles Birkbeck is committed to fostering an environment where employees feel confident about raising issues and concerns in order to reach clear resolutions that support,
More informationAntitrust Compliance in Russia
Antitrust Compliance in Russia Preventing the violation of the antimonopoly legislation has been one of the priorities of the Federal Antimonopoly Service of Russia (hereinafter the FAS ) in the recent
More informationPolicies, Procedures, Guidelines and Protocols. Document Details
Policies, Procedures, Guidelines and Protocols Document Details Title Security Management Strategy Trust Ref No 2038-38676 Local Ref (optional) Main points the document The Strategy intends to reinforce
More informationCHRISTIAN AID GLOBAL COMPETENCY MODEL
CHRISTIAN AID GLOBAL COMPETENCY MODEL Christian Aid s global competency model describes the main skills and abilities that everyone needs to demonstrate in order to perform effectively in their role at
More informationCompetence Framework for Safeguarding Adults
Competence Framework for Safeguarding Adults Introduction This competency framework seeks to develop and demonstrate the competency of staff in delivering services that safeguard adults with care and support
More informationAnnex 2 - CLO Compliance Blue Print and covering letter
Annex 2 - CLO Compliance Blue Print and covering letter Dear Sir/Madam Final - July 24, 2010 The ultimate goal of European antitrust policy is to deter practices which restrict competition in the European
More informationPolicing Professional Profile Deputy Chief Constable
Policing Professional Profile Deputy Chief Constable Job Family: Core Rank Level: Force Leader Code: (for College use only) Role Purpose (This section summarises the key function of the role) The Deputy
More informationSAFETY AND HEALTH AUDIT STRATEGY Safety & Health Services Safety and Health Audit Strategy Version 1.0
SAFETY AND HEALTH AUDIT STRATEGY 2016-2019 Safety & Health Services Contents 1. INTRODUCTION... 1 2. AIMS AND OBJECTIVES... 1 3. DEFINITIONS... 1 AUDIT... 1 ASSURANCE... 1 AUDIT SPONSOR... 1 AUDIT OPINION...
More informationEnvironmental Regulatory Compliance Officer
POSITION VACANT Develop your career with Cairns Regional Council, an innovative employer that listens, respects and values your contribution. We re proud of our community and the key role you can play
More informationSubmission on the Working Outline of Ireland s National Action Plan on Business and Human Rights January 2016
Submission on the Working Outline of Ireland s National Action Plan on Business and Human Rights January 2016 Introduction: Chambers Ireland is the largest business network in the State. With members in
More informationONLINE PUBLIC CONSULTATION
DRAFT RECOMMENDATION OF THE COUNCIL ON PUBLIC INTEGRITY ONLINE PUBLIC CONSULTATION DEADLINE FOR COMMENT 22 MARCH 2016 The draft Recommendation of the Council on Public Integrity has been elaborated by
More informationMeeting environmental Justice A critical overview of environmental policies in the European Union
Meeting environmental Justice A critical overview of environmental policies in the European Union Keywords > Environmental Policies > Participation > Information > Contamination > Prevention > Precautionary
More informationConsultation - Training For Tomorrow: A new approach to continuing competence
Consultation - Training For Tomorrow: A new approach to continuing competence Consultation questionnaire form This form is designed to be completed electronically in MS Word. Please save it locally before
More informationKnowTheChain Information and Communications Technology Benchmark Methodology (Version 2 October)
KnowTheChain Information and Communications Technology Benchmark Methodology (Version 2 October) SCORED DISCLOSURE THEME 1 COMMITMENT AND GOVERNANCE 1.1 Commitment (1) has publicly demonstrated its commitment
More informationStriking the right balance: proposals for a Welsh Language Bill
Striking the right balance: proposals for a Welsh Language Bill Consultation response form Your name: Lyn Williams Organisation (if applicable): Natural Resources Wales e-mail/telephone number:lyn.williams@cyfoethnaturiolcymru.gov.uk
More informationQUALIFICATION HANDBOOK
QUALIFICATION HANDBOOK Level 4 NVQ Diploma in Spectator Safety Management (6852-04) October 2011 Version 1.0 Qualification at a glance Subject area City & Guilds number 6852 Spectator Safety Age group
More informationTotal employees by employment contract and gender
GRI Index GRI G4 index and applicable construction and real estate sector supplement Under GRI requirements, as a core responder, must comment on the most pertinent indicator per aspect. Where a material
More informationProposal for a Directive on Better Enforcement and Modernisation of EU Consumer Protection Rules
INTERACTIVE SOFTWARE FEDERATION OF EUROPE Europe s video games industry Proposal for a Transparency Register ID Number: 20586492362-11 Summary: ISFE welcomes the Commission s initiative to achieve a more
More informationARTICLE 29 Data Protection Working Party
ARTICLE 29 Data Protection Working Party 05/EN WP108 Working Document Establishing a Model Checklist Application for Approval of Binding Corporate Rules Adopted on April 14 th, 2005 This Working Party
More informationProposal for Public Space Protection Order Background Information
Newcastle City Council September 2016 Proposal for Public Space Protection Order Background Information Newcastle upon Tyne: Public Spaces Protection Order Background Information Introduction Newcastle
More informationJob title: Diversity & Inclusion Manager. Grade: PO 5. Role code: EBC0470. Status: Police Staff. Main purpose of the role:
Job title: Diversity & Inclusion Manager Grade: PO 5 Role code: EBC0470 Status: Police Staff Main purpose of the role: Develop, co-ordinate and implement the Forces Diversity & Inclusion Strategy, ensuring
More informationRoundtable on. Competition Policy and Public Procurement
Intergovernmental Group of Experts on Competition Law and Policy Geneva, 9 11 July 2012 Roundtable on Competition Policy and Public Procurement Written contribution by Sudan The views expressed are those
More informationBuilding Compliance Officer
Building Compliance Officer UNIT/TEAM Building Unit REPORTS TO Building Unit Manager ROLE PURPOSE As a member of Building Unit this role is responsible and accountable for the delivery of job specific
More informationChain of Responsibility
INFORMATION BULLETIN INTRODUCTION This bulletin provides information on the pioneering chain of responsibility laws being progressed by the National Road Transport Commission in conjunction with the road
More informationGENERAL STANDARD DISCLOSURES
GRI Index GRI G4 index and applicable construction and real estate sector supplement Under GRI requirements, as a core responder, Basil Read must comment on the most pertinent indicator per aspect. Where
More informationAssociation of Consulting Structural Engineers Victoria Inc. (ACSEV) Association Number A J PO BOX 467 BOX HILL VIC 3128
Association of Consulting Structural Engineers Victoria Inc. (ACSEV) Association Number A0026069J PO BOX 467 BOX HILL VIC 3128 Email: acsev@acsev.org.au 22 nd March 2018 Dear Sir / Madame, RE: Engineer
More informationPolicing Professional Profile
Policing Professional Profile Chief Constable Role Purpose: (This section summarises the key function of the role) The Chief Constable has overall responsibility for leading the Force, creating a vision
More informationTriple C Housing, Inc. Compliance Plan
Triple C Housing, Inc. Compliance Plan Adopted by Board of Directors on draft November 13, 2014 Overview Triple C Housing, Inc. is committed to its consumers, employees, contractual providers, vendors,
More informationSenior Compliance Officer. Financial Integrity. Regulatory Services. Manager Financial Integrity. Auckland and Wellington
Job Description Job Title: Business Unit: Business Group: Branch: Reporting to: Location: Senior Compliance Officer Financial Integrity Regulatory Services Policy, Regulation and Ethnic Affairs Branch
More informationAnnual Output Statement
Annual Output Statement 2010 Contents Section 1 Health and Safety Authority high level goals, aggregate impact indicator for each goal and programmes under each goal... 3 Section 2 Total budget for Health
More informationDER BINNENMARKT IST DER MOTOR DES WIRTSCHAFTSWACHSTUMS
DER BINNENMARKT IST DER MOTOR DES WIRTSCHAFTSWACHSTUMS Position der Wirtschaftskammer Österreich zur Binnenmarktstrategie für Waren und Dienstleistungen Jänner 2016 SINGLE MARKET INFORMATION TOOL (SMIT)
More information1. Purpose. This policy provides Employees with guidance on behaviours or actions that may be noncompliant with anti-trust or anti-competition laws.
Section: pg. 2 1. Purpose AET is committed to conducting our business with honesty and integrity. It is AET s policy to comply with all laws governing AET s global business operations and activities including
More informationBetter Regulation and Medicines. Chris Horsey Head of Better Regulation Department of Health, England ASMI Conference, Sydney, 12 November 2009
Better Regulation and Medicines Chris Horsey Head of Better Regulation Department of Health, England ASMI Conference, Sydney, 12 November 2009 Contents Policy and regulatory context Legacy of medicines
More informationHow FSC could improve the new Controlled Wood Standard 1
Position Paper: How FSC could improve the new Controlled Wood Standard 1 DRAFT 7 November 2016 Contents Certification requirements... 2 Update the standard so that it always fulfils the requirements of
More informationApprenticeship and Traineeship Compliance and Quality Assurance Policy
VRQA Apprenticeship and Traineeship Compliance and Quality Assurance Policy (Revieww date June 2013) Page 1 of 16 Contents Section 1: Introduction Section 2: The VRQA context 2.1 Transfer of functions
More informationRigorous, efficient and timely access to information is an important pillar of accountability for government.
Open and Accessible Government - Modernizing the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act Rigorous, efficient and timely access to information is an important pillar of accountability for government.
More informationMinister s Declaration
Explanatory Memorandum to The Control of Waste (Dealing with Seized Property) (England and Wales) Regulations 2015. This Explanatory Memorandum has been prepared by the Department for Natural Resources
More informationSenior Compliance Officer. Financial Integrity. Regulatory Services. Policy, Regulation and Ethnic Affairs Branch (PREA) Manager Financial Integrity
Job Description Job Title: Business Unit: Business Group: Branch: Reporting to: Location: Salary Range/Grade Senior Compliance Officer Financial Integrity Regulatory Services Policy, Regulation and Ethnic
More informationJOB DESCRIPTION. Monitoring and Control Officer. Economy, Transport & Environment
JOB DESCRIPTION Job Title Service Directorate Job Title of Line Manager Grade Monitoring and Control Officer Growth & Economy Economy, Transport & Environment Principal Enforcement & Monitoring Officer
More informationACTING IN THE SPIRIT OF SERVICE Information gathering and public trust
ACTING IN THE SPIRIT OF SERVICE Information gathering and public trust Model standards for information gathering associated with regulatory compliance, law enforcement and security functions. Effective
More informationMedicare Parts C and D General Compliance Training
Medicare Parts C and D General Compliance Training Developed by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Martin Health System Annual Compliance Education Rev. 10/2016 PREFACE The Centers for Medicare
More informationSummary. Legislation and reality. Findings from legislative evaluations
Summary Legislation and reality. Findings from legislative evaluations Background and objective Policy receives its legal formulation in laws. There are almost 1,800 laws in effect in the Netherlands.
More informationGROUP HEALTH & SAFETY POLICY
GROUP HEALTH & SAFETY POLICY FINDING YOUR WAY ROUND Chief Executive s Introduction 02 Who does this Policy Apply to? 03 What about other Policies and Procedures or other Requirements? 03 What is Expected
More informationCIH Awarding Organisation
CIH Awarding Organisation QUALIFICATION SNAPSHOT CIH Certificate in Housing Practice (QCF) The Qualification Reference Number is 600/2138/X Regulation start date: 01/06/2011 The Chartered Institute of
More informationCOMPLIANCE POLICY Public Use May 13, 2016
Public Use CONTENTS 1 PURPOSE... 3 2 SCOPE... 3 3 REFERENCES... 3 4 DEFINITIONS... 4 5 GUIDELINES... 4 6 RESPONSIBILITIES... 5 7 FINAL PROVISIONS... 7 8 CONTROL INFORMATION... 7 Public Use 2 1 PURPOSE
More informationExploring Bullying and Harassment in the CQC Summary Document July 2013
Exploring Bullying and Harassment in the CQC Summary Document July 2013 People Opportunities Limited Unit 1A, West Stockwith Park, Stockwith Road, Misterton, Doncaster, DN10 4ES Background to this summary
More informationHeavy Vehicle Transport Off-Farm Grain Carriers Code of Practice. Mass, Dimension, Load Restraint and Fatigue
Heavy Vehicle Off-Farm Grain Carriers Code of Practice Mass, Dimension, Load Restraint and Fatigue PREPARED BY: SARTA AUTHORISED BY: South Australian Road Association, South Australian Farmers Federation,
More informationRISK BASED REGULATORY PRACTICE & ITS IMPACT ON THE ECONOMY. Annual Regulatory Conference SEPTEMBER 2014
RISK BASED REGULATORY PRACTICE & ITS IMPACT ON THE ECONOMY Annual Regulatory Conference 2014 22 SEPTEMBER 2014 AGENDA BACKGROUND THE LINK BETWEEN REGULATION & COMPETITIVENESS RISK BASED REGULATION WAY
More informationOctober Your Business and Competition Law. How it helps you & what you need to know
October 2012 Your Business and Competition Law How it helps you & what you need to know Introduction Competition benefits everyone - businesses, consumers and the economy as a whole. It encourages businesses
More informationQualification Specification 601/3688/1 icq Level 3 Diploma in Management (RQF)
Qualification Specification 601/3688/1 icq Level 3 Diploma in Management (RQF) Qualification Details Title : icq Level 3 Diploma in Management (RQF) Awarding Organisation : ican Qualifications Limited
More informationJune PUBLIC OVERSIGHT OF THE AUDIT PROFESSION: Enhancing Credibility and Supporting Cooperation
Federation of European Accountants Fédération des Experts comptables Européens Briefing Paper Standing for trust and integrity June 2014 PUBLIC OVERSIGHT OF THE AUDIT PROFESSION: Enhancing Credibility
More informationCorporate Risk A directors responsibility. Overview of Health & Safety Legislation. Overview. Recent Changes. 1 April 2009 Stanley House
Corporate Risk A directors responsibility 1 April 2009 Stanley House Overview of Health & Safety Legislation Recent Changes Martin Crabtree Partner Overview Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 The European
More informationPERSONAL COMMUNICATION STYLES INVENTORY
PERSONAL COMMUNICATION STYLES INVENTORY Directing Style Personal Style Summary Strengths *Fast paced, quick thinker *Focused on action to achieve results *Does what is necessary to succeed *Fast decision
More information1.2 To minimise risk to clients by identifying, reporting and following up any safeguarding concerns.
Post: Lead Floating Support Worker Delegated Authority Level 7 Team: Responsible to: Responsible for: Pan London Offender Service Team Manager N/A Job Purpose The Pan London Offender Service provides advice
More informationNOT PROTECTIVELY MARKED JOB DESCRIPTION
JOB DESCRIPTION APPENDIX C Before completing this form, please read the BTP Guide to writing job descriptions for Police Staff roles Appendix B to the SOP. A. POST DETAILS: Job Title: OH Manager Current
More informationOEH response to the Independent Review of the Biodiversity Assessment Method Recommendation 12 of the biodiversity legislation review called for a
OEH response to the Independent Review of the Biodiversity Assessment Method Recommendation 12 of the biodiversity legislation review called for a single, scientifically-based, transparent, publicly-available
More informationControlling for Error, Fraud and Corruption (EFC)
Controlling for Error, Fraud and Corruption (EFC) Bangkok Meeting, World Bank March 2-4, 2010 Christian van Stolk Content 1. Introduction 2. A framework for combating EFC 3. Tools and instruments used
More informationAssessment Practice Standards. A practice development guide to understanding children s needs and family situations
Assessment Practice Standards A practice development guide to understanding children s needs and family situations Forward Bolton can be proud of a long history of effective multi-agency working to safeguard
More informationJC May Joint Committee Final Report on guidelines for complaints-handling for the securities (ESMA) and banking (EBA) sectors
JC 2014 43 27 May 2014 Joint Committee Final Report on guidelines for complaints-handling for the securities (ESMA) and banking (EBA) sectors 1 Contents 1. Overview... 4 2. Feedback statement... 5 Annex
More informationJC June Joint Committee Final Report on guidelines for complaints-handling for the securities (ESMA) and banking (EBA) sectors
JC 2014 43 13 June 2014 Joint Committee Final Report on guidelines for complaints-handling for the securities (ESMA) and banking (EBA) sectors 1 Contents 1. Overview... 4 2. Feedback statement... 5 Annex
More informationMini Plenary #3: Other methods of bid-rigging detection. Isabel López Gálvez, Head of Cartels and Leniency Unit - CNMC
Mini Plenary #3: Other methods of bid-rigging detection Isabel López Gálvez, Head of Cartels and Leniency Unit - CNMC Ottawa, 4 October 2017 Cartel enforcement Cartel prosecution, first priority at CNMC
More information