Modelling of potential hazards in agent-based safety risk analysis
|
|
- Heather Terry
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 MAREA: Mathematical Approach towards Resilience Engineering in ATM Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam Modelling of potential hazards in agent-based safety risk analysis Henk Blom Sybert Stroeve Tibor Bosse NLR and Delft University of Technology NLR VU Amsterdam 10 th USA/Europe ATM R&D Seminar, Chicago, June 10-13,
2 Modelling of potential hazards in agent-based safety risk analysis Agent-based safety risk analysis Potential hazards Identify model constructs Relation with models used in aviation Concluding remarks 2
3 Why Agent Based Modelling and Simulation? Powerful framework to model Complex Socio-Technical Systems Effective in partitioning the socio-technical system space Effective in modelling interactions and dependencies Capability to reveal and analyse emergent behaviour Proven to work in safety risk analysis of novel ATM ConOps: - TOPAZ (Traffic Organization and Perturbation AnalyZer) 3
4 Agent based safety risk analysis in TOPAZ (Traffic Organization and Perturnation AnalyZer) Modelling Semantics: Agent Based Modelling (ABM) Human performance modelling Modelling Syntax: Petri Net based Compositional Specification Risk Quantification: Rare Event Monte Carlo (MC) simulation Bias and Uncertainty Analysis: Differences between model and reality 4
5 Differences between model and reality Numerical precision Parameter values Aleatory uncertainty Epemistic uncertainty Model structural assumptions Hazards not modelled Operational concept differences 5
6 Bias & uncertainty analysis process Monte Carlo Simulation Model Risk sensitivities Risk point estimate Model-Reality Differences Bias & Uncertainty Assessment Risk expectation value Risk credibility interval Reality True risk
7 Pro s and Con s of modelling all hazards Pro: Emergent Behaviour is Captured through MC Con: Enlarges Model and Increases # of Parameters Optimal balance: Model hazards that influence emergent behaviour Else, consider to use Bias and Uncertainty analysis Development of an optimal approach requires understanding how to model each hazard in an agent based model! 7
8 Modelling of potential hazards in agent-based safety risk analysis Agent-based safety risk analysis Potential hazards Identify model constructs Relation with models used in aviation Concluding remarks 8
9 Identification of Hazards Hazard = Anything that may influence safety Events / conditions / performance aspects Humans / systems / environment Interactions TOPAZ Hazard Database Conducted safety assessments Hazard brainstorm sessions hazards 9
10 A Set of Generalised Hazards Selection of unique hazards Generalization of hazards Pilot mixes up ATC clearances Flight plans of ATC system and FMS differ Wrong waypoints in database Transponder sends wrong call-sign Risk of a conflict is underestimated Controller has wrong SA about intent of aircraft Contingency procedures have not been tested 525 Development (Set I) Validation (Set II) Weather forecast is wrong False alert of an airborne system Resolution of conflict leads to other conflicts Alert causes attentional tunneling Pilot validates without checking Track drop on controller HMI Animals on the runway 10
11 Clustering of Hazards Pilot performance 124 Controller performance 110 Speech-based communication 37 Traffic relations 33 Other 31 Aircraft systems 27 Surveillance system 27 Weather 27 ATC systems 25 ATC coordination 24 Infrastructure & environment 24 Datalink based communication 20 Navigation systems 16 11
12 Modelling of potential hazards in agent-based safety risk analysis Agent-based safety risk analysis Potential hazards Identify model constructs Relation with models used in aviation Concluding remarks 12
13 Matching Model Constructs to Hazards Adopt selected model constructs Phase 1: TOPAZ model constructs Phase 2: VU model constructs Phase 3: Novel model constructs Perform mental simulation of agent based model per hazard Each hazard tells a short story that should be mentally simulated Which model constructs are used in the mental simulation? Done by multiple experts in agent based modeling and simulation of socio-technical systems 2 from VU and 2 from NLR Iterate until the mental simulations of these experts coincide 13
14 TOPAZ Model Constructs C1 Human Information Processing C8 Human Error C2 Multi-Agent Situation Awareness C9 Decision Making C3 Task Identification C10 System Mode C4 Task Scheduling C11 Dynamic Variability C5 Task Execution C12 Stochastic Variability C6 Cognitive Control Mode C13 Contextual Condition C7 Task Load 14
15 Multi-Agent SA in ATM k ti, SA of agent i at time t about agent k Identity State Mode Intent k ti, k ti, k ti, k ti,
16 Multi-Agent SA Update types SA agent i Observation Communication SA agent k SA agent i SA agent k SA agent i Reasoning decision agent i 1
17 Multi Agent SA propagation
18 Hazard Example involving System Error (C10) and MA-SA (C2) Wrong waypoint in FMS database, e.g, due to update of FMS software, errors in database, outdated database Mental simulation Agents involved: Pilot and FMS Wrong waypoint in FMS database = System Mode Pilot enters Intent into FMS = Communication between agents FMS interprets this Intent using its database = MA-SA difference 18
19 TOPAZ Model Constructs Hazard Coverage Cultural differences between airlines... Controller is fatigued and sleepy... Lack of experience in degraded modes... Procedure change confusion Multi-agent SA Decision making... Not Covered Controller ignores an alert Multi-agent SA... Covered Partly Controller makes a reading error Human error Multi-agent SA Failure of GPS system System mode Pilot reports wrong position Human error Multi-agent SA Pilots do not react to controller call due to high workload Task identification Task scheduling Cognitive control mode 19
20 VU Model Constructs MC1 Object-oriented Attention MC7 Trust MC2 Experience-based Decision Making MC8 Formal Organisations MC3 Operator Functional State MC9 Learning MC4 Information Presentation MC10 Goal-oriented Attention MC5 Safety Culture MC11 Extended Mind MC6 Complex Beliefs in Situation Awareness 20
21 VU Model Constructs Hazard Coverage A jolly atmosphere on the frequency... Icing of the wings... Aircraft picks up beacons with similar frequencies... Negotiation problems Pilot-ATC Trust... Not Partly Pilots falling asleep Operator Functional State... Covered 212 Complex procedure causes R/T overload Operator Functional State Formal Organisation Controller is fatigued and sleepy Operator Functional State Clutter of audio messages Information Presentation Situation Awareness Controller has low confidence in validity of system alerts Trust 10 th USA/Europe ATM R&D Seminar (ATM2013), Chicago, June 10-13,
22 New Model Constructs NM2 Unstabilised Approach NM32 Merging or Splitting ATC Sectors NM3 Handling Inconsistent Information by a Technical System NM33 Changes in Visibility NM7 Group Emotion NM34 Weather Forecast Wrong NM14 Surprise/Confusion due to Complex or Unclear Procedures NM15 Surprise/Confusion due to Changes in Procedures NM21 Deciding when to take action NM31 Access Rights to an Information System NM35 Turbulence NM36 Icing NM38 Influence of Many Agents on Flight Planning NM40 Uncontrolled Aircraft 22
23 New Model Constructs Hazard Coverage Security Intrusion... Unmanned Arial Vehicles... Military Aircraft Shoots a Civil Aircraft Down... Standard R/T not adhered to Confusion Strong variation in view Weather... 6 Not Partly Covered 244 A jolly atmosphere on the frequency Operator Functional State Emotion Contagion Icing of the Wings Icing Unstabilised Approach Approach Aircraft picks up beacons with similar frequencies Handling of Inconsistent Info by a Technical System 23
24 Modelling of potential hazards in agent-based safety risk analysis Agent-based safety risk analysis Potential hazards Identify model constructs Relation with models used in aviation Concluding remarks 24
25 Hazard % based ranking of model constructs 25
26 Top-15 Model constructs/types commonly in use in aviation studies (1/2) Rank 1 (41.4%): C2 Multi-Agent SA (MA-SA): Multi Agent extension of Endsley s (1995) SA model Allows to systematically capture SA differences between agents Complementary extension ranks 10: MC6 - Complex beliefs in SA Rank 2 (19.9%): C10 - System mode: RAMS: Reliability, Availability, Maintainability and Safety of technical systems Rank 3 (18.0%): C8 - Human error 1st generation Human Reliability Analysis (HRA): Slips, Lapses and Mistakes (Reason, 1990) 2nd generation HRA incorporates effects such as captured by model constructs at ranks 1,2,4,7,9,
27 Top-15 Model constructs/types commonly in use in aviation studies (2/2) Rank 4 (14.3%): C1 - Human Information Processing Human performance simulation MIDAS, Air-MIDAS, PUMA, ACT-R, IMPRINT/ACT-R, D-OMAR Other related model constructs are at ranks 6-9,11-15 Rank 5 (8.6%): C11 - Dynamic Variability Simulation of aircraft trajectories in Aircraft performance models Human-In-The-Loop simulations Fast Time simulations 27
28 Other Model constructs/types in use in aviation studies Rank 17 (3.4%): Rank 20 (3.0%): Rank 22 (2.6%): Rank 25 (1.9%): Rank 26 (1.9%): Rank 29 (0.4%): Rank (0.4%) Rank 38 (0.4%): Formal Organization (MC8) Stochastic Variability (C12) Safety Culture (MC5) Task Load (C7) Extended Mind (MC11) Approach (NM2) Weather related (NM34-36) Uncontrolled aircraft (NM40) 28
29 Less common model constructs/types Rank 16 (3.4%): Rank 18 (3.4%): Rank 19 (3.0%): Rank 21 (3.0%): Rank 23 (2.6%): Rank 24 (2.3%): Rank 27 (0.8%): Rank 28 (0.8%): Rank 30 (0.4%): Rank 31 (0.4%): Rank 32 (0.4%): Rank 33 (0.4%): Visibility changes (NM33) Surprise / complex procedure (NM14) Surprise / changed procedure (NM15) Object Oriented Atttention (MC1) Learning (MC5) Information Presentation (MC4) Goal Oriented Attention (MC10) Access Rights (NM31) Tech. Syst. Handling Incons. Info (NM3) Group Emotion (NM7) Deciding when to take action (NM21) Merging or splitting ATC sectors (NM32) 29
30 Modelling of potential hazards in agent-based safety risk analysis Agent-based safety risk analysis Potential hazards Identify model constructs Relation with models used in aviation Concluding remarks 30
31 Wrap up of Model Constructs Identified 38 agent-based model constructs have been identified 13 TOPAZ model constructs 11 VU model constructs 14 new model constructs Result: considerable improvement in modelling hazards TOPAZ 81 Not Covered Covered Partly VU Not Partly Covered NEW 6 16 Not Partly Covered
32 Summary of findings Hazard data base guided model construct search very well Model construct ranking 1 is a multi agent extension of Endley s SA model (ATM2003 paper) Model constructs ranking 2 through 5 are familiar: System Mode (RAMS) Human error (first generation HRA) Human Information Processing (Wickens) Dynamic Variability (aircraft dynamics simulation) 10 model constructs open new directions, e.g. Surprise, Learning, Access Rights, Group Emotion. 32
33 Agent based modelling follow up Further integration of model constructs Validation of model constructs Test the coverage on the 2nd hazard set Apply model constructs to accident scenarios Conduct interviews with pilots and controllers Develop a balanced agent based modelling approach Model hazards having emergent effects Bias and Uncertainty Assessment for all other hazards 33
34 Resilience directed follow up Aim: To extend agent based modelling with model constructs that capture the ways how pilots and controllers provide a key source of resilience in handling hazards First step: Understanding how Pilots and Controllers do this Conduct Interviews with Pilots and Controllers regarding their operational way of handling each hazard Conduct statistical analysis of these responses, in order to identify the nature of pilot and controller responses to hazards Follow up step: To capture this in agent-based modelling, e.g. coordination. 34
35 Questions?
Human Reliability Assessment In ATM: the CARA tool
Human Reliability Assessment In ATM: the CARA tool Barry Kirwan EUROCONTROL Experimental Centre France barry.kirwan@eurocontrol.int What I m going to talk about CARA: Controller Action Reliability Assessment
More informationMETHODOLOGY FOR SAFETY RISK ASSESSMENT IN FUTURE AIR TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS
METHODOLOGY FOR SAFETY RISK ASSESSMENT IN FUTURE AIR TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT CONCEPT OF OPERATIONS BOJANA MIRKOVIĆ 1, TATJANA KRSTIĆ SIMIĆ 2, FEĐA NETJASOV 3, OBRAD BABIĆ 4 University of Belgrade - Faculty
More informationOJT INSTRUCTOR. Learning outcomes. Why study this course? Aim. ICAO Code 212
OJT INSTRUCTOR ICAO Code 212 ATC Operational Training 10 days Air Traffic Controllers The younger generation expects to know how they are achieving and they want to engage and take responsibility for their
More informationBlueprint. What is U-space?
Blueprint The demand for drone services is steadily increasing, with the potential to generate significant economic growth and societal benefits 1, as recognised in the 2015 EU Aviation Strategy 2, and
More informationFirst European Air traffic controller Selection Test (FEAST) package. Information to Candidates applying as Student Air Traffic Controllers
Information on the First European Air traffic controller Selection Test (FEAST) package Information to Candidates applying as Student Air Traffic Controllers Introduction You have applied for a position
More informationThe Effect of a Highly Automated Environment on Human Behaviour
The Effect of a Highly Automated Environment on Human Behaviour Plans and first results of the WP-E project ADAHR M.F.J. Koolloos R&D+i Department Ingenieria de Sistemas para la Defensa de España - Isdefe
More informationLife Cycle Assessment A product-oriented method for sustainability analysis. UNEP LCA Training Kit Module f Interpretation 1
Life Cycle Assessment A product-oriented method for sustainability analysis UNEP LCA Training Kit Module f Interpretation 1 ISO 14040 framework Life cycle assessment framework Goal and scope definition
More informationATC BASIC. Learning outcomes. Why study this course? Aim. ICAO Code 051
ATC BASIC ICAO Code 051 6 weeks Trainee ATCs (Maximum 12 per course) This course forms the prerequisite for all other Air Traffic Control Courses. trainee will have demonstrated competency with regards
More informationSESAR: a European initiative for an enhanced ATM system
domaine Recherche & SESAR: a European initiative for an enhanced ATM system General overview and spotlight on the SESAR operational concept Patrick DUJARDIN R&D Manager DSNA/DTI Toulouse - France Tokyo,
More informationThe International Pilot Training Consortium (IPTC) IPTC Case Study: Pilot Competencies
The International Pilot Training Consortium (IPTC) IPTC Case Study: Pilot Competencies Janeen Adrion Kochan, PhD World Aviation Training Conference 20 April 2016 Orlando, FL The International Pilot Training
More informationThe Search for Shared Situational Awareness for Enhanced Collaboration in Airport Systems
The Search for Shared Situational Awareness for Enhanced Collaboration in Airport Systems Jeffrey Schäfer Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences, Weesperzijde 190, 1091 DZ Amsterdam A R T I C L E I N
More informationMaster Plan edition 2
SESAR s first with Updated developments The Roadmap for Sustainable Air Traffic Management European ATM Master Plan edition 2 Executive Summary - Military October 2012 European Union The Roadmap for Sustainable
More informationEUROPEAN COMMISSION DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR ENERGY AND TRANSPORT MANDATE TO CEN/CENELEC/ETSI FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF
EUROPEAN COMMISSION DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR ENERGY AND TRANSPORT DIRECTORATE F - Air Transport Air Traffic Management Brussels, 12 July 2006 M/390 EN MANDATE TO CEN/CENELEC/ETSI FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF
More informationIn search of positive emergent behaviour in Trajectory Based Operations
In search of positive emergent behaviour in Trajectory Based Operations Henk A.P. Blom National Aerospace Laboratory NLR & Delft University of Technology blom@nlr.nl G.J. (Bert) Bakker National Aerospace
More informationSESAR The European ATM Improvement Programme. Regional ANC 2012 Preparatory Symposium Michael STANDAR Moscow March 2012
SESAR The European ATM Improvement Programme Regional ANC 2012 Preparatory Symposium Michael STANDAR Moscow 20-21 March 2012 SES II: builds on five pillars Performance Safety (EASA) Technology (SESAR)
More informationEnhancing the role of Human Factors in Safety Investigation and Analysis
Enhancing the role of Human Factors in Safety Investigation and Analysis Katie Berry Ph.D. Michael Sawyer Ph.D. March 14-18, 2016 Human Performance and Operations Procedures & Policies Human Performance
More informationSafety Nets Safety Forum June 2016 Brussels:
Safety Nets Safety Forum June 2016 Brussels: Findings, Strategies and Action Opportunities FROM THE INDUSTRY FOR THE INDUSTRY Released Issue V1.0 Issued: 22 June 2016 CONTENTS Executive Summary... 1 Chapter
More informationPotential Operational Benefits of Multi-layer Point Merge System on Dense TMA Operation
Potential Operational Benefits of Multi-layer Point Merge System on Dense TMA Operation Hybrid Arrival Trajectory Optimization Applied to Beijing Capital International Airport Man LIANG, Daniel DELAHAYE
More informationIncreasing ATM Efficiency with Assistant Based Speech Recognition (ABSR)
www.dlr.de/fl Chart 1 Increasing ATM Efficiency with Assistant Based Speech Recognition (ABSR) Hartmut Helmke, Oliver Ohneiser, Jörg Buxbaum, Christian Kern Supported by DLR Technology Marketing and Helmholtz
More informationConflict detection and resolution aid to controllers. Jean-Louis Garcia, DSNA
Conflict detection and resolution aid to controllers Jean-Louis Garcia, DSNA Objectives Improved ANS operations productivity Increased collaboration and operational predictability Enhanced safety and security
More informationSituation Awareness, Automation & Free Flight
Situation Awareness, Automation & Free Flight Mica R. Endsley Department of Aeronautics & Astronautics Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge, MA 02139 USA Keywords: Automation, Situation Awareness,
More informationNAS-Wide Performance: Impact of Select Uncertainty Factors and Implications for Experimental Design
Approved for Public Release: 12-0370. Distribution Unlimited. NAS-Wide Performance: Impact of Select Uncertainty Factors and Implications for Experimental Design Gareth O. Coville, MITRE Corporation Billy
More informationProject Overview: SMALL AIR TRANSPORT ROADMAP
http://sat-rdmp.eu/ Project Overview: In the SAT-Rdmp (Support Action) a Vision and Research Agenda on the development of a Small Aircraft Transportation system (SAT system) have been developed. The major
More information! Aviation Interview Process Checklist!!By: Kirsty Ferguson Pinstripe Solutions - Aviation Recruitment Specialist A must have Checklist for navigating the Aviation Industry recruitment processes. ! Resume
More informationJulie Evans HR Director Intelligent Energy Limited
Julie Evans HR Director Intelligent Energy Limited So why does change sometimes appear complicated? Why does change fail? Unclear Objectives Divisions in leaders / lack of alignment of leadership Too much
More informationVTOL UAV for Maritime ISR Role
VTOL UAV for Page -1 The Maritime Arena Challenge Peace keeping / LIC scenarios: Over the Horizon ISR missions Low risk / LCC operation HIC / War time: Missile Threat - Standoff range Surface Warfare Littoral
More informationMethods and Measurements for the Evaluation of ATM Tools in Real-Time Simulations and Field Tests
nd USA/EUROPE AIR TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT R&D SEMINAR Orlando,1 st - th December 199 Methods and Measurements for the Evaluation of ATM Tools in Real-Time Simulations and Field Tests Fred Schick German Aerospace
More informationConcept and prototype of a ground handling vehicle management system. Steffen Loth (German Aerospace Center - DLR) Member of
Concept and prototype of a ground handling vehicle management system Steffen Loth (German Aerospace Center - DLR) Outline Background Motivation, Projects, Partner, Airport Research Facility Hamburg, Vehicle
More informationSCHEDULE RISK ANALYSIS ESSENTIALS FOR PROJECT SUCCESS
SCHEDULE RISK ANALYSIS ESSENTIALS FOR PROJECT SUCCESS CSVA 2011 Conference Toronto, Ontario Nov 14-16, 2011 Laszlo A. Retfalvi P.Eng PMP PMI-RMP Retfalvi and Associates 1 Agenda of Session Key Take Aways
More informationPeople Make ATM Work
People Make ATM Work The Importance of Humans in Our Systems Shaping ATM in our region Dependent on people Plan-design-operate Regional agenda and growth Pressure on all parts of the ATM system Need to
More informationDELEGATION OF SEPARATION ASSURANCE TO AIRCRAFT: TOWARDS A FRAMEWORK FOR ANALYSING THE DIFFERENT CONCEPTS AND UNDERLYING PRINCIPLES
ICAS 2000 CONGRESS DELEGATION OF SEPARATION ASSURANCE TO AIRCRAFT: TOWARDS A FRAMEWORK FOR ANALYSING THE DIFFERENT CONCEPTS AND UNDERLYING PRINCIPLES Karim Zeghal Steria, BP 58, 78142 Velizy, seconded
More informationAir Traffic Management Capacity-Driven Operational Concept Through 2015
2 nd USA/EUROPE AIR TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT R&D SEMINAR Orlando,1 st - 4 th December 1998 Air Management Capacity-Driven Operational Concept Through 2015 Aslaug Haraldsdottir Robert W. Schwab Monica S. Alcabin
More informationMeasuring En Route Separation Assurance Performance. Ella Pinska, Brian Hickling
EUROCONTROL Safety R&D Seminar 2009, Munich, Germany Measuring En Route Separation Assurance Performance Ella Pinska, Brian Hickling Eurocontrol Experimental Centre Bretigny sur Orge, France ella.pinska-chauvin@eurocontrol.int
More informationSESAR Progress. Specific focus on ATC related WPs (WP4, WP5,WP10) Prepared for ODT by Bernard Brunner 17th September 2009
SESAR Progress Specific focus on ATC related WPs (WP4, WP5,WP10) Prepared for ODT by Bernard Brunner 17th September 2009 European Organisation for the Safety of Air Navigation Agenda General : Project
More informationSafety Risks in an Airworthiness Organisation
Safety Risks in an Airworthiness Organisation Belinda Swain Chief Airworthiness Engineer Rolls-Royce Plc May 2016 2016 Rolls-Royce plc The information in this document is the property of Rolls-Royce plc
More informationHuman-in the-loop Simulation in ATM. Sven Kaltenhäuser, Marcus Biella, Michael Schultz. Institute of Flight Guidance DLR Braunschweig
Human-in the-loop Simulation in ATM Sven Kaltenhäuser, Marcus Biella, Michael Schultz Institute of Flight Guidance DLR Braunschweig DLR.de Chart 2 Outline DLR Institute of Flight Guidance Modell and Simulation
More informationAirport Collaborative Decision Making Enhancing Airport Efficiency
Airport Collaborative Decision Making Enhancing Airport Efficiency David Gamper Director, Safety & Technical ACI World SWIFT Conference, Banff 18 September 2012 1 Airports are facing challenges Capacity
More informationImproving ATC Efficiency through an Implementation of a Multi Sector Planner Position
Improving ATC Efficiency through an Implementation of a Multi Sector Planner Position Almira Williams, Mark D. Rodgers, Stéphane Mondoloni CSSI, Inc., Washington, DC, USA Diana Liang FAA, Washington, DC,
More informationThe goal of the Flight Operations Risk Assessment System (FORAS)
Flight Operations Risk Assessment System (FORAS) Michael Hadjimichael John McCarthy Naval Research Laboratory 1 Olga Fridman Science Applications International Corporation 2 Abstract The goal of the Flight
More informationMAPP - The Marketing Action Plan Process
1 2 MAPP The Marketing Action Plan Process Accelerating Growth and Profitability Within Marketing Solutions Action Plan Marketing 210 Riverside Drive Boulder Creek, CA 95006 831-338-7790 rjm@actionplan.com
More informationPromoting a safety culture in maintenance
Safety is of paramount importance in high risk industries, the concept of safety culture is of growing importance in these industries as a means of reducing the potential for large-scale disasters, and
More informationJOB DESCRIPTION HIAL AMSL DAL. Air Traffic Control Officer (fixed-term for 3 years) Senior Air Traffic Control Officer (SATCO)
JOB DESCRIPTION HIAL AMSL DAL Job Title: Location: Line Manager: Air Traffic Control Officer (fixed-term for 3 years) Kirkwall Airport Senior Air Traffic Control Officer (SATCO) Purpose of the Role The
More informationEUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR THE SAFETY OF AIR NAVIGATION EUROCONTROL EUROCONTROL EXPERIMENTAL CENTRE
EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR THE SAFETY OF AIR NAVIGATION EUROCONTROL EUROCONTROL EXPERIMENTAL CENTRE Conflict Detection Tools Impact on Controller Taskload - Fast time study Issued: June 2010 The information
More informationSESAR Release 2 RESULTS
SESAR Release 2 RESULTS RESULTS SESAR Release 2 Table of Contents 01 Towards a business need driven release approach p.2 02 Release 2 : Some highlights p.4 03 Factsheets p.8 04 p.26 05 Glossary of terms
More informationADVISORY CIRCULAR FOR AIR OPERATORS
Cooperative Development of Operational Safety and Continuing Airworthiness Under ICAO Technical Co-operation Programme COSCAP-South Asia ADVISORY CIRCULAR FOR AIR OPERATORS Subject: INFORMATION TO OPERATORS
More informationAerodrome Safety Awareness
Aerodrome Safety Awareness Platzhalterbild 1/1 Breite Daniel Bircher Safety Officer Operations Zurich Airport 01.10.2010 Contents 1. Background 2. Legal Basis 3. User Requirements 4. Safety Awareness Concept
More informationMan-Machine Teaming in Autonomous Technologies and Systems
AUTOMOTIVE INFOCOM TRANSPORT, ENVIRONMENT & POWER ENGINEERING AERONAUTICS SPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY in Autonomous Technologies and Systems Analysis and predication of impact and challenges Prof. Dr. Harald
More informationMulti-Purpose Cockpit Display of Traffic Information: Overview and Development of Performance Requirements
Multi-Purpose Cockpit Display of Traffic Information: Overview and Development of Performance Requirements Hans Stassen, William J. Penhallegon, and Lesley A. Weitz The MITRE Corporation, McLean, VA, 22102-7508,
More informationLima FDA Seminar Presented by Paul DUBOIS AIRBUS - Airline SMS & FDA Assistance ANALYSIS WORKFLOW
Lima FDA Seminar Presented by Paul DUBOIS AIRBUS - Airline SMS & FDA Assistance ANALYSIS WORKFLOW ANALYSIS WORKFLOW Recording Downloading Processing Analysis Page 2 ANALYSIS WORKFLOW FDA Objectives Identify
More informationCOSPACE HAZOP REPORT (combined controller and pilot)
COSPACE HAZOP REPORT (combined controller and pilot) Date: Wednesday, March 15, 2006 Draft: V1.6 DRAFT CoSpace HAZOP (combined controller and pilot) Report, 11-12 September, 2005 1 DRAFT CoSpace HAZOP
More informationDesign of Aircraft Trajectories based on Trade-offs between Emission Sources
Design of Aircraft Trajectories based on Trade-offs between Emission Sources Banavar Sridhar and Neil Chen NASA Ames Research Center Moffett Field, CA, USA Hok Ng University of California, Santa Cruz,
More informationThe AIRPORT CDM. Bahrain October 2015
The AIRPORT CDM Bahrain 11-13 October 2015 Airport CDM a definition Airport CDM is a proven concept which aims at improving predictability, reducing delays, optimally utilizing the available capacities
More informationPublishable Final Activity Report
Contract No. TREN/04/FP6AE/SI2.374991/503192 D013 Title: Acronym: Contract Nr.: EUROPEAN AIRPORT MOVEMENT MANAGEMENT by A-SMGCS EMMA TREN/04/FP6AE/S12.374991/503192 Project Duration: from 29.03.2004 to
More informationHandling Difficult Project Situations. A Critical Skill for Every PM
Handling Difficult Project Situations A Critical Skill for Every PM Mark Waldof Consulting LLC 2015 This seminar provided by Mark Waldof Consulting LLC owner@manageprojectsbetter.com The latest version
More informationPerforming UAV Mission Planning, Design, & Optimization
Performing UAV Mission Planning, Design, & Optimization Russ Magazzu UAV Product Manager Pg 1 of 30 Agenda Unmanned aerial systems application areas capabilities STK 8 Aircraft Mission Modeler Pg 2 of
More informationFinal Project Report. Abstract. Document information
Final Project Report Document information Project Title QM-6 - ASAS Sequencing and Merging (TMA-8)) Project Number 05.06.06 Project Manager C-LVNL/ENAV Deliverable Name Final Project Report Deliverable
More informationCommission hearing on the preparation for RP3
Commission hearing on the preparation for RP3 14th December 2016 Brussels Discussion document Introduction The performance scheme is at the heart of Single European Sky (SES) policy and is a major driver
More informationPROBABILISTIC CONGESTION MANAGEMENT
PROBABILISTIC CONGESTION MANAGEMENT Craig Wanke, Lixia Song, Stephen Zobell, Daniel Greenbaum, and Sandeep Mulgund The MITRE Corporation, cwanke@mitre.org, McLean, VA Abstract A new approach to airspace
More informationA new framework for assessing systemic change in Katalyst: the pilot study in local agri-business network
A new framework for assessing systemic change in : the pilot study in local agri-business network Marcus Jenal, consultant March 2016 This is a much-shortened version of the final report of a study commissioned
More informationCapacity Planning and Assessment Additional considerations
Capacity Planning and Assessment Additional considerations Air Traffic Services System Capacity Seminar/Workshop Nairobi, Kenya, 8 10 June 2016 Raffaele Russo EUROCONTROL Operations Planning Summary Winter
More informationPractical Crew Resource Management (CRM) Standards: The Handy Guide
Practical Crew Resource Management (CRM) Standards: The Handy Guide This guide is a standardisation tool, developed by the Flight Crew Human Factors Advisory Panel (FCHF), to help National Aviation Authority
More informationCEOC - EUROLAB IFIA INTERNATIONAL SAFETY SEMINAR 2014 HOW SAFE DO YOU THINK YOU ARE? WHY INDEPENDENT TESTING IS IMPORTANT.
SPEECH 30 October 2014 CEOC - EUROLAB IFIA INTERNATIONAL SAFETY SEMINAR 2014 HOW SAFE DO YOU THINK YOU ARE? WHY INDEPENDENT TESTING IS IMPORTANT. 5 NOVEMBER 2014, 15.05-15.25, RESIDENCE PALACE, 155 RUE
More informationABSTRACT. (2) empirically assess the SA measure for use in investigating AA of various ATC
ABSTRACT MCCLERNON, CHRISTOPHER KYLE. Human performance effects of adaptive automation of various air traffic control information processing functions. (Under the direction of Dr. David B. Kaber.) Advanced
More informationLow Cost Aerial Mapping Alternatives for Natural Disasters in the Caribbean
Low Cost Aerial Mapping Alternatives for Natural Disasters in the Caribbean Raid Al-Tahir, Marcus Arthur, and Dexter Davis The University of the West Indies, Trinidad and Tobago Presentation Outline: The
More informationProject Planning & Management. Lecture 11 Project Risk Management
Lecture 11 Project Risk Management The Importance of Project Risk Management PMBOK definition of Project Risk An uncertain event or condition that, if it occurs, has a positive or negative effect on the
More informationUnderstanding the factors contributing to human behaviour leads to systemic safety improvements
Understanding the factors contributing to human behaviour leads to systemic safety improvements Christina (Missy) Rudin-Brown, Ph.D. Senior Human Factors Investigator / Analyst Presentation to System Safety
More informationHuman Factors of Unmanned Aviation: CERI 2006
Human Factors of Unmanned Aviation: CERI 2006 Jeff Goldfinger 775-428-6877 jgoldfinger@brandes-assoc.com Outline Where we were in 2004 What kind of humans? What kind of human computer interface? Where
More informationUAVs for or against Flight Safety? Prof. Dr. Imre MAKKAY MZ NDU Aviation and Air Defense Institute
UAVs for or against Flight Safety? Prof. Dr. Imre MAKKAY MZ NDU Aviation and Air Defense Institute UAVs for or against Flight Safety? Airline-,, General-,, Military Aviation Air Traffic Management UAS
More informationModified Cooper Harper Scales (MCH)
Modified Cooper Harper Scales (MCH) Wierwille and Casali 1986 Background and applications The modified Cooper Harper scale is a uni- dimensional measure that uses a decision tree to elicit operator mental
More informationUse of Controls Approaches for Verification, Validation and Certification of Distributed Mission Management Controls for Unmanned Systems
Use of Controls Approaches for Verification, Validation and Certification of Distributed Mission Management Controls for Unmanned Systems AFRL S5, 2017 Kayin Cannon (NGC), Prakash Sarathy(NGC), Irene Gregory(NASA
More informationApplication of the CARA HRA Tool to Air Traffic Management Safety Cases
Application of the CARA HRA Tool to Air Traffic Management Safety Cases W. Huw Gibson a* and Barry Kirwan b The University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK b Eurocontrol, Bretigny, France Abstract: Controller
More informationTechnical Standard Order
Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration Aircraft Certification Service Washington, D.C. TSO-C166a Effective Date: 12/21/06 Technical Standard Order Subject: Extended Squitter Automatic
More informationLiterature Review. HALA!-PhD Management Plan. Deliverable D4. February 2012 HALA! RESEARCH NETWORK
Application of the Theory of Formal Languages to the Modeling of Trajectory Uncertainty and the Analysis of its Impact in Future TBO Literature Review HALA!-PhD Management Plan Deliverable D4 February
More informationSafety Training *Print or save this presentation if you want, by clicking here to load a.pdf of this handout.
Safety Training *Print or save this presentation if you want, by clicking here to load a.pdf of this handout. The DOT Ground, IATA Air, and IMDG Ocean Regulations all require safety training. We will use
More informationModeling Trust in Critical Systems with Möbius KEN KEEFE SENIOR SOFTWARE ENGINEER LEAD MOBIUS DEVELOPER
Modeling Trust in Critical Systems with Möbius KEN KEEFE SENIOR SOFTWARE ENGINEER LEAD MOBIUS DEVELOPER Course Overview Objective: Give course attendees an intense introduction to modeling systems using
More informationHuman Failure. Overview. People are never 100% reliable. Andy Brazier. Types of human failure Slips Mistakes Violations
Human Failure Andy Brazier Tel: (+44) 01492 879813 Mob: (+44) 07984 284642 andy@abrisk.co.uk www.abrisk.co.uk 1 Overview Types of human failure Slips Mistakes Violations Causes of human failure Things
More informationDesigning HMIs for boat navigation
Designing HMIs for boat navigation Can the Contextual Control Model be used for benchmarking? Thomas Porathe Professor, Interaction design Department of Product design Norwegian University of Science and
More informationProject Management. Opportunity or Oxymoron? Stacy Munechika, PMP, PMI-ACP. PMI Rochester Chapter Professional Development Day May 2017
Project Management Opportunity or Oxymoron? Stacy Munechika, PMP, PMI-ACP PMI Rochester Chapter Professional Development Day May 2017 What makes project outcomes difficult to predict? Survey answers from
More informationExecutive summary. This initial paper looks at: The demands of finance profession and the challenges it faces
time for finance to take the reins: Are CFOs the CEOs-in-themaking? Executive summary Over the last twelve months or so, public attention has been trained on the role of finance professionals as never
More informationEngagement paper for Our Future Wellbeing Programmes
Engagement paper for Our Future Wellbeing Programmes Version Date Issued Summary of Changes 1.0 Document Created Author S. Joslyn and C. Williams TARGET READERSHIP This document has been distributed for
More informationADVISORY CIRCULAR TCAA-AC-OPS010B
ADVISORY CIRCULAR TCAA-AC-OPS010B March 2013 CREW RESOURCE MANAGEMENT TRAINING 1.0 PURPOSE 1.1 This Advisory Circular (AC) presents guidelines to air operators for developing, implementing, reinforcing,
More informationContextual note SESAR Solution description form for deployment planning
Purpose: Release 5 SESAR Solution #101 Contextual note SESAR Solution description form for deployment planning This contextual note introduces a SESAR Solution (for which maturity has been assessed as
More informationIDENTIFY RISK AND APPLY RISK MANAGEMENT PROCESSES CANDIDATE RESOURCE & ASSESSMENT BSBRSK401A
IDENTIFY RISK AND APPLY RISK MANAGEMENT PROCESSES CANDIDATE RESOURCE & ASSESSMENT BSBRSK401A Precision Group (Australia) Pty Ltd 9 Koppen Tce, Cairns, QLD, 4870 Email: info@precisiongroup.com.au Website:
More informationWHITE PAPER 6 ORGANIZATIONAL PRACTICES TO ADDRESS DISTRACTED DRIVING
WHITE PAPER 6 ORGANIZATIONAL PRACTICES TO ADDRESS DISTRACTED DRIVING Introduction In recent years, organizations have been challenged to take on a greater role in the driving safety of their employees.
More informationFinal Safety and Performance Requirements (SPR)
P04.07.07 Safety and Performance s (SPR) Document information Project Title Implementation of Dynamic Capacity Management in a High Density Area Project Number 04.07.07 Project Manager Deliverable Name
More informationSafety Management. System. Building an SMS. Module 10 Phased approach to SMS Implementation. Module 8 SMS planning. Module 9 SMS operation
Module N 7 Introduction to SMS Revision N 11 ICAO Safety Management Systems (SMS) Course 01/01/08 Building an SMS Safety Management Module 10 Phased approach to SMS Implementation System Module 8 SMS planning
More informationTHE HR GUIDE TO IDENTIFYING HIGH-POTENTIALS
THE HR GUIDE TO IDENTIFYING HIGH-POTENTIALS What makes a high-potential? Quite possibly not what you think. The HR Guide to Identifying High-Potentials 1 If you agree people are your most valuable asset
More informationAirport Construction Project Risk Management. Presented by: Mindy Price- Direct Effect Solutions
Airport Construction Project Risk Management Presented by: Mindy Price- Direct Effect Solutions Topics ACRP 01-22 Research Background Research Findings and Conclusions Project Risk Management Recommendations
More informationDESIGN OF A PROCEDURE ANALYSIS TOOL (PAT) FOR AFFORDABLE HUMAN FACTORS CERTIFICATION OF AVIATION DEVICES
DESIGN OF A PROCEDURE ANALYSIS TOOL (PAT) FOR AFFORDABLE HUMAN FACTORS CERTIFICATION OF AVIATION DEVICES New Regulation More thorough device certification DER Team Members: Heather Johnson, Houda Kerkoub,
More informationAn Objectives-Driven Process for Selecting Methods to Support Requirements Engineering Activities
An Objectives-Driven Process for Selecting Methods to Support Requirements Engineering Activities Lester O. Lobo and James D. Arthur Department of Computer Science, Virginia Tech Blacksburg, Virginia 24060,
More informationPreventing, reporting, evaluating, and mitigating Airside accidents and incidents at airports.
ANA - Aeroportos de Portugal, SA Preventing, reporting, evaluating, and mitigating Airside accidents and incidents at airports. Introduction Safety measures undertaken at the airport are grouped in the
More informationChallenges faced when taking strategic decisions. Results of 2010 Global Survey. Executive Summary
Challenges faced when taking strategic decisions Results of 2010 Global Survey Executive Summary December 2010 Introduction In the third quarter of 2010, launched its second global survey to obtain a greater
More informationICMA PRACTICES FOR EFFECTIVE LOCAL GOVERNMENT LEADERSHIP Approved by the ICMA Executive Board June 2017; effective November 2017
Reorganization The Credentialing Advisory Board proposed, and the Leadership Advisory and Executive Boards agreed, that the ICMA Practices should be organized as a narrative rather than a list. The following
More informationClean Sky 2 Joint Undertaking. 5 th Call for Proposals (CFP05): List and full description of Topics. Call Text. - November
Clean Sky 2 Joint Undertaking 5 th Call for Proposals (CFP05): List and full description of Topics Call Text - November 2016 - The present preliminary version of the Call Text is released for information
More informationH2020-SESAR WA 1: Exploratory Research
H2020-SESAR-2016-2 WA 1: Exploratory Research David Bowen and Olivia Nunez 22 nd March 2017 Topics in H2020-SESAR-2016-2 Work Area 1: Exploratory Research Work Area 2: Very Large Scale Demonstrations (VLD)
More informationManaging Human Factors in the Signalling Programme
Managing Human Factors in the Signalling Programme The latest development in the work of the Human Components Mapping Dr. Amanda C. Elliott Safety Team Banedanmark Presentation Outline Overall aim: To
More informationCollaborative Decision Making (CDM) Update
Collaborative Decision Making (CDM) Update 1 FAA CDM Office CDM Domestic combined with International Operations, includes International Data Sharing One Manager Two Full Time Team Leads, Two Part-Time
More informationSeven Principles for Performance
Seven Principles for Performance Measurement What is excellent performance measurement really based on? by Stacey Barr introduction There are seven principles which are the criteria that define excellence
More information