Testing Activity-Based Model Component Transferability at the Individual Component and System Level
|
|
- Pamela Kelly
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Testing Activity-Based Model Component Transferability at the Individual Component and System Level Martin Milkovits, Corresponding Author Cambridge Systematics, Inc. Phone: (617) Thomas Rossi Cambridge Systematics, Inc. Phone: (617) Word Count = 1,830 words + 3 * 250 (tables and figures) = 2,580 equivalent words Prepared for presentation Innovations in Travel Modeling 2016 Conference Submitted: October 9, 2015
2 Abstract Transferring model parameters from one region to another is an attractive alternative to conducting a local survey, processing the data, and estimating a new set of model parameters. Transferring a complex model, such as an activity-based model (ABM) presents opportunities and challenges. The greater number of components, parameters, and implementation complexity makes an ABM especially tempting to transfer as opposed to develop anew. ABMs are typically more highly specified, include more segments, and model more aspects of travel than a trip-based model, so the risk of unrepresented regional differences could be lower. But, ABMs also represent more decisions, e.g. trip chaining and intra-household coordination, and so the opportunity for non-represented differences is higher. This paper presents a transferability test between activity-based models developed for the Houston- Galveston and the Twin Cities regions. These regions have obvious differences, but the similarity in the implemented model structures and availability of rich survey data for testing present a good opportunity to contribute to transferability testing and activity-based modelling. The transferability tests examine individual component predictive power as well as the propagation of deviations through the entire model system. Transferability is evaluated by comparing the aggregate and cross-classified transferred model results with the estimated model results and household survey data. Statement of Innovation This research brief provides a background on the opportunities and challenges to transferring activitybased models and the value of comparing the transferability of not only individual components, but the entire model system. A case study transferring activity-based models from the Twin Cities to the Houston-Galveston region is presented and the transferability approaches, tests, and expected results are described.
3 Introduction Transferring model parameters from one region to another is an attractive alternative to conducting a local survey, processing the data, and estimating a new set of model parameters. Surveys are very resource intensive, and traditional phone-based surveys are becoming harder to undertake because of the trend away from land-lines towards mobile phones. Estimating new models from a data set is an important means to advance the state of the practice, but that is a luxury that many regional planning agencies cannot afford. But, transferring model structures and parameters is risky if the two regions differ substantially in aspects that are not well represented in the model. Transferring a complex model such as an activity-based model (ABM) presents opportunities and challenges. The greater number of components, parameters, and implementation complexity makes an ABM especially tempting to transfer as opposed to develop anew. ABMs are typically more highly specified, include more segments, and model more aspects of travel than a trip-based model, so the risk of unrepresented regional differences could be lower. But, ABMs also represent more decisions, e.g. trip chaining and intra-household coordination, and so the opportunity for non-represented differences is higher. Motivation and Challenges A model transferability test is a valuable exercise for the model being transferred and a test of an activity-based model transferability is valuable to the state of the practice. An evaluation of the predictive performance in a new region will assess the unobserved aspects of the model and also if the model is over-calibrated. Beyond this, the test should also offer insights for the type of models, many of the activity-based models are recent constructions and have not had the level of use as trip-based models. The recent Guide for Travel Model Transfer explained that most transferability research has focused on trip generation and mode choice, but not destination choice and posits that destination choice models may be inherently non-transferable [1]. A previous ABM transferability study evaluated the transferability of individual models by estimating an additional model term and examining the statistical significance [2]. Models representing activity planning and sequencing were found to be more transferrable than models representing specific travel (e.g. mode) and destination decisions. This paper examines the transferability of ABM components based with a different structure than those examined in the previous work and considers the model at the system level. ABMs are still evolving and there is not a consensus as to which aspects of daily activity planning are critical and how they should be represented. ABMs contain many components with both downstream and circular dependences (where logsums are involved). Upstream component errors may propagate through the system, or they may be stifled. In some ways, a transferability test is similar to a backcasting test where a calibrated model is run with data from the previous model update and the predictive power is evaluated. Transferability tests also involve many of the same challenges as backcasting. Differences in data formats, socio-economic data, modal skim data, and travel demand software all present obstacles to transferring model parameters, and the model results to be compared are often summarized differently and involve a lot of effort to normalize. Another reason why it is unsurprising that few models have been transferred for the sake of testing is the availability of validation data. After all, if the target region has a household survey with
4 activity diaries collected and summarized, it makes more sense to estimate a new set of models rather than transfer parameters and risk running with the wrong regional biases. Model Region Overview The two recent activity-based model deployments by the Metropolitan Council of the Twin Cities (Met Council) in Minnesota and the Houston-Galveston Area Council (H-GAC) in Texas present a unique opportunity to conduct a transferability test of an ABM. Both models were developed using TourCast and Cube and have similar input file requirements. The two models were estimated using local survey data and, while there are some similarities in the model structures, there were no model parameters transferred from one region to the other. A key advantage to using these two models for transferability testing is that they both underwent a comprehensive validation and thus have a complete set of validation spreadsheets with survey data summaries attached for comparison [3]. Table 1 shows a comparison between the two regions. There are notable differences: Houston is larger, has a single central city and substantially warmer in the winter. The Twin Cities have a higher non-auto mode share and lower per capita vehicle-miles traveled (VMT). Some of these differences will be represented in the input data, such as the better transit service in the Twin Cities, but others will not (e.g. temperature) though the impacts of such differences may be reflected in the behavioral data used to estimated the models. Table 1: Comparison between Houston and the Twin Cities HOUSTON TWIN CITIES METRO AREA POPULATION (2011) 6,051,850 3,389,049 CENTRAL CITY POPULATION (2011) 2,145, ,753 / 288,448 ESTIMATED VMT 160M (2010) 66.5M (2005) PUBLIC TRANSIT PASSENGERS (2012) 77.6M 81.1M BIKE TOUR MODE SHARE 0.6% 1.3% AVG. TEMPERATURE - JAN. (F) 63 / / 8 AVG. TEMPERATURE - JULY (F) 94 / / 64 AVG. ANNUAL SNOWFALL (INCHES) Methodology The transferability test focuses on the activity-based model components. The activity-based model component flow chart for the H-GAC model is shown in Figure 1. The Met Council ABM includes an additional component that models the household ownership of a transit pass and toll transponder, which is required to access the MnPASS managed lane system in the Twin Cities. The Met Council pass ownership model outputs are used in mode choice to identify the appropriate highway skim (including managed lanes or not) and to adjust the transit fare.
5 The assignment procedures differ between the two regions. Met Council segments auto trips by mode, two income categories (lowest and all other income categories), work / non-work tour purpose, and toll transponder ownership, which is used in assignment to exclude single-occupancy vehicles without transponders from using the managed lanes. H-GAC segments auto trips by mode, work / non-work tour purpose, and has varying levels of household income segmentation depending on the mode and tour purpose. We are most interested in the transferability of the ABM components so the local assignment routine and trip table segmentation will be used. Producing trip tables with different segmentation is a trivial change in the TourCast configuration files. Figure 1: H-GAC Activity-Based Model Components The transferability test takes input data from region A and runs the activity-based model components with parameters estimated from region B; the results from the intermediate components and the highway and transit assignment are then compared with the results from region A s model. Initially, the calibrated parameters from region B are used to run the model and potentially the unadjusted
6 parameters from region B will be used as well. The input data required are the zonal data, which includes socio-economic data and aggregate accessibilities, synthetic population, and highway skim data. Zonal data is used in several of the components, particularly the long-term components and the tour destination choice components that use socio-economic data as part of the size functions. The H-GAC model utilizes employment data with more segmentation than Met Council, and so H-GAC data is aggregated to Met Council input formats rather than disaggregating the Met Council employment for each zone, i.e. H-GAC is region A and Met Council is region B. The synthetic population is generated by a different process in each region, but produces the same eight person types: three child types, two worker types, two non-worker types and adult students. Household income is grouped into five categories and the category thresholds differ slightly between the two regions, as shown in Table 2. However, the inconsistencies of the middle-income ranges are not very concerning because most income-related model parameters are related to the highest and lowest ranges, which are more similar. Based on the initial model results, we may rerun the population synthesizer and adjust the income ranges. Table 2: Income Categories by Region Income Categories Houston Twin Cities Income 1 <$20,000 <$25,000 Income 2 $20,000 - $39,999 $25,000 - $49,999 Income 3 $40,000 - $69,999 $50,000 - $74,999 Income 4 $70,000 - $99,999 $75,000 - $99,999 Income 5 >=$100,000 >=$100,000 Once the input data is reformatted, the results of each ABM component are examined in sequence to identify where the transferred model results deviate from the original model. Considering the overall results are also interesting, but each step needs to be examined to see where the deviation begins and how it propagates. The reports from the comprehensive validation are used to identify the deviations. The validation reports compare multiple cross-classifications and help identify if a particular aspect of the component is deviating. Table 3 shows an example comparison of average vehicles by household size and income from the vehicle availability validation spreadsheet, which also includes comparisons by county, number of workers, and children.
7 Table 3: Example Validation Report From H-GAC Vehicle Availability Component Expanded Household Survey HHSize Model HHSize HHIncome Total <$ ,000- $39,999 $40,000- $69,999 $70,000- $99,999 >$100,000 Total HHIncome 20,000- $40,000- $70,000- Total <$20000 $39,999 $69,999 $99,999 >$100,000 Total Percentage Difference (model - survey)/survey HHIncome 20,000- $40,000- $70,000- Total <$20000 HHSize $39,999 $69,999 $99,999 >$100,000 Total 0% -15% -15% -22% -12% -5% 1 3% -3% -6% 4% -3% -1% 2 7% -8% -5% -1% -6% 8% 3-34% -43% -41% -52% -53% -35% 4+ 5% -18% -22% -15% 5% 8% Two metrics are used to compare transferability for individual components: root mean square error (RMSE) and relative aggregate transfer error (RATE). RMSE is used to measure the difference between the predicted and observed shares from the household survey. RATE is a ratio of the RMSE between the estimated and transferred components and is used to compare the change in predictive power between the transferred and estimated model. To evaluate the propagation of deviations through the model system, we take advantage of the TourCast plug-and-play model design and replace transferred components with ones from the original model and compare the RMSE and RATE of downstream components. If a transferred component has a particularly large RMSE, we may swap that component with the estimated component so that downstream comparisons are worthwhile. Expected Outcomes An ABM transferability test will provide valuable insights not only into the specific models that are tested, but also into how well an ABM represents the factors influencing how people make travel decisions and thus the potential for transferring ABMs. These insights will be described through an examination of model result deviations and the propagation of deviations throughout the model.
8 Moreover, the identification of unobserved differences between these two regions will inform model transferability in general. Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the staff from H-GAC, particularly Chris van Slyke and Chi-Ping Lam, and the staff of Met Council, particularly Jonathan Ehrlich and Mark Filipi, for their support and permission to use the regional models for this study. References [1] T. Rossi and C. Bhat, "Guide for Travel Model Transfer," Federal Highway Administration, Washington, DC, [2] J. L. Bowman, M. Bradley and J. Castiglione, "Making advanced travel forecasting models affordable through model transferability," Prepared for Federal Highway Administration, US Department of Transportation,, Washington, DC, [3] M. Milkovits, A. Kuppam, D. Kurth and T. Rossi, Comprehensive Validation of an Activity-Based Model - Experiences from Houston-Galveston Area Council's Activity-Based Model Development, Washington, DC: TRB 94th Annual Meeting, 2015.
COMPREHENSIVE VALIDATION OF AN ACTIVITY-BASED MODEL EXPERIENCES FROM HOUSTON-GALVESTON AREA COUNCIL S ACTIVITY-BASED MODEL DEVELOPMENT
Milkovits, Kuppam, Kurth, Rossi 0 0 0 0 0 COMPREHENSIVE VALIDATION OF AN ACTIVITY-BASED MODEL EXPERIENCES FROM HOUSTON-GALVESTON AREA COUNCIL S ACTIVITY-BASED MODEL DEVELOPMENT Marty Milkovits, Corresponding
More informationFreight Transportation Planning and Modeling Spring 2012
Freight Model Validation Techniques Abstract Several reviews of validation techniques for statewide passenger and freight models have been published over the past several years. In this paper I synthesize
More informationActivity-Based Model Future Mobility Experiments Experiments with AV-Exclusive Facilities
Activity-Based Model Future Mobility Experiments Experiments with AV-Exclusive Facilities presented by Marty Milkovits, Cambridge Systematics, Inc. October 17, 2017 Outline Previous Work Scenario: AVs
More informationModeling Truck Movements: A Comparison between the Quick Response Freight Manual (QRFM) and Tour-Based Approaches
International Journal of Engineering Science Invention ISSN (Online): 2319 6734, ISSN (Print): 2319 6726 Volume 5 Issue 11 November 2016 PP. 45-51 Modeling Truck Movements: A Comparison between the Quick
More informationTravel Demand Forecasting User Guide
Travel Demand Forecasting User Guide A Supplement to the Regional Transitway Guidelines Metropolitan Council February 2012 This document supplements the Project Development, Leadership, and Oversight discussion
More informationHighest Priority Performance Measures for the TPP
Highest Priority Performance Measures for the TPP The following list of measures are the highest priority performance measures as identified by modal working groups. These groups consist of staff from
More informationDatabase and Travel Demand Model
Database and Travel Demand Model 7 The CMP legislation requires every CMA, in consultation with the regional transportation planning agency (the Metropolitan Transportation Commission (MTC) in the Bay
More informationConstruction Alternative Screening with Regional Travel Demand Model
Construction Alternative Screening with Regional Travel Demand Model By: Marty Milkovits (Corresponding Author) Cambridge Systematics, Inc. 100 CambridgePark Drive, Suite 400 Cambridge, MA 02140 Phone:
More informationAPPENDIX H: TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL VALIDATION AND ANALYSIS
APPENDIX H: TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL VALIDATION AND ANALYSIS Travel demand models (TDM) simulate current travel conditions and forecast future travel patterns and conditions based on planned system improvements
More informationSpecial Events Travel Surveys and Model Development
Special Events Travel Surveys and Model Development Authors: Arun Kuppam (Corresponding Author), Rachel Copperman, Jason Lemp, Thomas Rossi, Cambridge Systematics, Inc., 9015 Mountain Ridge Drive, Suite
More informationAnalysis of Transportation Greenhouse Gas Reduction Strategies in Massachusetts Using the EERPAT Tool
Analysis of Transportation Greenhouse Gas Reduction Strategies in Massachusetts Using the EERPAT Tool Christopher D. Porter, Cambridge Systematics, Inc., 100 CambridgePark Drive, Suite 400, Cambridge,
More informationTransportation Modeling Forum. June 13, 2012
Transportation Modeling Forum June 13, 2012 Forum Agenda Activity-Based Model Overview Comparing the ABM with Four-Step Model ABM Structure, Components and Flow 2 Activity-Based Model Overview Clint Daniels
More informationNew Starts Transit Modeling Improvements in a Tour-Based Framework Suzanne Childress (corresponding author), Erik Sabina (DRCOG) Manish Jain (AECOM)
New Starts Transit Modeling Improvements in a Tour-Based Framework Suzanne Childress (corresponding author), Erik Sabina (DRCOG) Manish Jain (AECOM) The Denver Regional Council of Governments (DRCOG) employs
More informationRefined Statewide California Transportation Model. Progress Report November 2009
Refined Statewide California Transportation Model Progress Report November 2009 Study area - the State of California. Forecast trips made on a typical fall / spring weekday i.e. when schools are in session.
More informationA Comparison of CEMDAP Activity-Based Model With DFWRTM 4-Step Model
A Comparison of CEMDAP Activity-Based Model With DFWRTM 4-Step Model Arash Mirzaei P.E. NCTCOG - Arlington, Texas and Naveen Eluru UT Austin - Austin, Texas for 11 th TRB National Transportation Planning
More informationFlorida Multimodal Statewide Freight Model
Florida Multimodal Statewide Freight Model Model inputs and structure, and integration with regional truck-touring models Presented by Colin Smith, RSG Freight Issues in Florida Florida has a large, complex,
More informationFlorida Freight Supplychain Intermodal Model
Florida Freight Supplychain Intermodal Model Innovations in Travel Modeling 2014 April 29, 2014 Introduction Support freight plan development Office of Freight Logistics and Passenger Operations Evaluate
More informationMaryland Statewide Transportation Model (MSTM)
Maryland State Highway Administration (MD SHA) Maryland Statewide Transportation Model (MSTM) TRB Meeting Federal Surface Transportation Requirements in Statewide and Metropolitan Transportation Planning:
More information9. TRAVEL FORECAST MODEL DEVELOPMENT
9. TRAVEL FORECAST MODEL DEVELOPMENT To examine the existing transportation system and accurately predict impacts of future growth, a travel demand model is necessary. A travel demand model is a computer
More informationTreasure Coast Regional Planning Model ABM Development (TCRPM4)
Treasure Coast Regional Planning Model ABM Development (TCRPM4) presented to Southeast Florida Model Users Group presented by Ken Kaltenbach, The Corradino Group September 19, 2014 TRCPM Model Structure
More information2040 Transportation Policy Plan Conversion to Performance Based Planning Basis. 25 th Annual CTS Transportation Research Conference May 21, 2014
2040 Transportation Policy Plan Conversion to Performance Based Planning Basis 25 th Annual CTS Transportation Research Conference May 21, 2014 1 About the plan Long-range transportation plan for the Twin
More informationINTERSTATE CORRIDOR PLANNING
INTERSTATE CORRIDOR PLANNING Prioritization of Corridor Studies July 29, 2015 Importance of the Interstate System Texas is an integral part of the national interstate system. The interstate system provides
More informationAn Integrated Transport - Economics Model for Ontario
An Integrated Transport - Economics Model for Ontario by Sundar Damodaran, Ph.D., P.Eng. Ministry of Transportation, Ontario Paper prepared for presentation at the Travel Demand Modeling: Applications
More informationTravel Demand Modeling At NCTCOG
Travel Demand Modeling At NCTCOG Arash Mirzaei North Central Texas Council Of Governments For University of Texas at Arlington ITE Student Chapter March 9, 2005 Agenda Background DFW Regional Model Structure
More informationCongestion Management Process (CMP)
Congestion Management Process (CMP) Introduction The Congestion Management Process (CMP) is a systematic, data-driven, and regionally accepted approach that aims to improve the performance of the transportation
More informationAppendix L Greenhouse Gas 4-part Strategy
Appendix L Greenhouse Gas 4-part Strategy Supplementary information regarding options for further reducing greenhouse gas emissions in the Puget Sound region State and Federal Greenhouse Gas Emissions
More informationStandardization of Travel Demand Models
Standardization of Travel Demand Models TNMUG Meeting November 14, 2013 The North Carolina Experience Leta F. Huntsinger, Ph.D., P.E. and Rhett Fussell, P.E. Background } North Carolina Profile } 18 MPOs,
More informationTHE TRANSITION FROM DIARY-BASED TO SMARTPHONE-BASED TRAVEL SURVEY DATA: IMPLICATIONS FOR TRAVEL DEMAND MODELING
THE TRANSITION FROM DIARY-BASED TO SMARTPHONE-BASED TRAVEL SURVEY DATA: IMPLICATIONS FOR TRAVEL DEMAND MODELING 0 0 0 Mark Bradley RSG Railroad Row White River Junction, VT 000 Tel: --; Fax: 0--00; E-mail:
More informationTransportation Model Report
1. Introduction The traffic impacts of the future developments in the IL130/High Cross Road corridor for different scenarios were analyzed using a Travel Demand Model (TDM). A four step modeling process
More informationWisconsin Statewide Model
Wisconsin Statewide Model Outline of a Proposed Approach presented by Kimon Proussaloglou Cambridge Systematics, Inc. January 12, 2004 Project Team Wisconsin DOT Doug Dalton, Project Manager Don Uelmen,
More informationCHAPTER 7. TRAVEL PATTERNS AND TRAVEL FORECASTING
CHAPTER 7. TRAVEL PATTERNS AND TRAVEL FORECASTING TRAVEL PATTERNS Northwest Arkansas has experienced unprecedented growth in population and employment in the past 25 years. The economic vitality and diversity
More informationRegional Evaluation Decision tool for Smart Growth
Regional Evaluation Decision tool for Smart Growth Maren Outwater, Robert Cervero, Jerry Walters, Colin Smith, Christopher Gray, Rich Kuzmyak Objectives This project is one of the SHRP 2 Capacity projects
More informationUsing Activity-based Travel Models to Inform Climate Action Plans
Using Activity-based Travel Models to Inform Climate Action Plans Harold Brazil Metropolitan Transportation Commission Public Sector Climate Task Force November 1, 2012 DLA Piper, East Palo Alto, CA 1
More informationAPPENDIX TRAVEL DEMAND MODELING OVERVIEW MAJOR FEATURES OF THE MODEL
APPENDIX A TRAVEL DEMAND MODELING OVERVIEW The model set that the Central Transportation Planning Staff (CTPS), the Boston Region Metropolitan Planning Organization s (MPO) technical staff, uses for forecasting
More informationSONG - Homework #2. Transportation Network Development System Analysis. The main objectives of this assignment are to help student
SONG - Homework #2 Transportation Network Development System Analysis The main objectives of this assignment are to help student learn to draw implications of alternative policies on transportation network
More informationCalifornia Statewide Interregional Integrated Modeling (SIIM) Framework. California STDM. HBA Specto Incorporated ULTRANS, UC Davis
California Statewide Interregional Integrated Modeling (SIIM) Framework California STDM HBA Specto Incorporated ULTRANS, UC Davis SIIM Advisory Group Meeting June 2010 model-wide economic / demographic
More informationSmart Growth Impact Fees
Smart Growth Impact Fees Presentation to National Impact Fee Roundtable October 10, 2008 Deb Galardi, Galardi Consulting Donald Samdahl, Fehr & Peers Smart Growth and Impact Fees Enhanced ability to fund
More informationACTIVITY-BASED MODEL DESIGN AND WORK PLAN
ACTIVITY-BASED MODEL DESIGN AND WORK PLAN Draft Final Report Incorporating: Technical Memorandum 1 State of the Practice Technical Memorandum 2 Recommended Model Design Technical Memorandum 3 Implementation
More informationDEMONSTRATION OF AN ACTIVITY-BASED MODEL SYSTEM FOR PORTLAND
DEMONSTRATION OF AN ACTIVITY-BASED MODEL SYSTEM FOR PORTLAND JOHN L. BOWMAN, PH. D. 5 Beals Street, Apartment 3 Brookline, MA 02446, USA T: (617) 232-3478 * E-mail:john_l_bowman@alum.mit.edu MARK BRADLEY
More informationTransit Land Use Multiplier Analysis: A Kentucky Example
Transit Land Use Multiplier Analysis: A Kentucky Example Extended Abstract # 30 Lewison Lem, Rami Chami, and Dylan Tucker Jack Faucett Associates, Inc., 4550 Montgomery Avenue, Suite 300N, Bethesda, MD
More information8.0 Chapter 8 Alternatives Analysis
8.0 Chapter 8 Alternatives Analysis The primary purpose for using CORSIM in the context of this manual is to guide the design process and program delivery. To this point in the manual, you have been given
More informationMINIMUM TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL CALIBRATION and VALIDATION GUIDELINES FOR STATE OF TENNESSEE UPDATED 2012
MINIMUM TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL CALIBRATION and VALIDATION GUIDELINES FOR STATE OF TENNESSEE UPDATED 2012 By: Dr. Fred Wegmann Dr. Jerry Everett Center for Transportation Research University of Tennessee Knoxville,
More informationPerformance Measures for Transportation Planning Part 1
Performance Measures for Transportation Planning Part 1 Flint, MI July 12, 2011 Brian Betlyon FHWA Resource Center Overview Performance Measurement in Transportation Planning Module Outcomes Describe performance
More informationActivity-Based Modeling: National Experience
Activity-Based Modeling: National Experience presented to Panel on Activity-Based Models presented by Joel Freedman, PB May 26, 2010 Presentation Topics Applications of Activity-Based Models From: San
More informationSustainable Transportation Performance Measures
Sustainable Transportation Performance Measures Christopher Forinash EPA Office of Sustainable Communities Conference on Performance Measures for Transportation and Livable Communities Austin, Texas 7
More informationOvercoming Barriers to Mixed-Use Infill Development: Let s Get Trip Generation Right
Overcoming Barriers to Mixed-Use Infill Development: Let s Get Trip Generation Right By: Matt Goyne, Mackenzie Watten, and Dennis Lee with Fehr & Peers Please contact Matt Goyne at m.goyne@fehrandpeers.com
More informationAssociation for Commuter Transportation Recommendations to USDOT on MAP-21 Performance Measures
Association for Commuter Transportation 1341 G Street, NW, 10th Floor Washington, DC 20005 Tel: 202.719.5331 www.actweb.org Association for Commuter Transportation Recommendations to USDOT on MAP-21 Performance
More informationAlternative High Occupancy/Toll Lane Pricing Strategies and their Effect on Market Share
Alternative High Occupancy/Toll Lane Pricing Strategies and their Effect on Market Share Michael Janson and David Levinson High Occupancy/Toll (HOT) Lanes typically charge a varying to single occupant
More informationDRCOG s Land Use and Travel Demand Models. Presentation to the Institute of Transportation Engineers Colorado/Wyoming Section 12 December 2014
DRCOG s Land Use and Travel Demand Models Presentation to the Institute of Transportation Engineers Colorado/Wyoming Section 12 December 2014 The Dirty Secret Essentially, all models are wrong, but some
More informationActivity Based Model Calibration
NOVEMBER 2015 Activity Based Model Calibration Coordinated Travel Regional Activity Based Modeling Platform (CT-RAMP) for Atlanta Regional Commission Prepared for: Atlanta Regional Commission 40 Courtland
More informationPRELIMINARY REVIEW COPY
PRELIMINARY REVIEW COPY 1. Report No. FHWA/TX-06/0-5176-S Technical Report Documentation Page 2. Government 3. Recipient s Catalog No. Accession No. 4. Title and Subtitle Conversion of Volunteer-Collected
More informationReducing CO2 and Energy Use Through Livable Communities: What s s Possible and Next Steps
Reducing CO2 and Energy Use Through Livable Communities: What s s Possible and Next Steps November 12, 2010 By Michael Replogle, Global Policy Director and Founder Institute for Transportation and Development
More informationAppendix P. Economic Impact Analysis and Competitive Analysis. Economic Impact Analysis and Competitive Analysis.
Appendix P Economic Impact Analysis and Competitive Analysis Appendix Contents Economic Impact Analysis and Competitive Analysis Economic Impact Analysis and Competitive Analysis Introduction and Summary
More informationTHE SACRAMENTO ACTIVITY-BASED TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL: ESTIMATION AND VALIDATION RESULTS
THE SACRAMENTO ACTIVITY-BASED TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL: ESTIMATION AND VALIDATION RESULTS Presented at the 2006 European Transport Conference, Strasbourg, France, September 2006 Corrected draft, September 13,
More informationPresentation To: HRTPO Passenger Rail Task Force
Presentation To: HRTPO Passenger Rail Task Force HRTPO Norfolk-Richmond Passenger Rail Ridership and Revenue Forecasts Presentation By December 17, 2013 Transportation Economics & Management Systems, Inc.
More informationCHAPTER 9 TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL SUMMARY
CHAPTER 9 TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL SUMMARY This chapter describes the OKI / MVRPC regional travel demand model, used to support traffic and transit forecasts for the NSTI study. This model is based on version
More informationChapter #9 TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL
Chapter #9 TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL TABLE OF CONTENTS 9.0 Travel Demand Model...9-1 9.1 Introduction...9-1 9.2 Overview...9-1 9.2.1 Study Area...9-1 9.2.2 Travel Demand Modeling Process...9-3 9.3 The Memphis
More informationUrban Transportation Planning Prof Dr. V. Thamizh Arasan Department of Civil Engineering Indian Institute Of Technology, Madras
Urban Transportation Planning Prof Dr. V. Thamizh Arasan Department of Civil Engineering Indian Institute Of Technology, Madras Lecture No. # 14 Modal Split Analysis Contd. This is lecture 14 on urban
More informationExploring Google s Passive Data for Origin-Destination Demand Estimation
Exploring Google s Passive Data for Origin-Destination Demand Estimation 2018 SF Bay Area ITE/ITS CA Joint Transportation Workshop Bhargava Sana SAN FRANCISCO COUNTY TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY May 2, 2018
More informationTravel Demand Model Questions
Travel Demand Model Questions Are we using the right kind of tools to address the scenarios we are trying to analyze? Are we missing tools? Are we working at the appropriate level of spatial, temporal
More informationSERPM 7/DTA Application FSUTMS Users Group Meeting
SERPM 7/DTA Application FSUTMS Users Group Meeting Ana Elias, PhD, PE, PTOE Leigh Ann White, PE, PTOE June, 2015 www.jacobs.com worldwide Agenda 1. Mesoscopic Modelling and Cube Avenue Principles 2. Background
More informationNovember 16, Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments National Capital Region Transportation Planning Board. Review of FTA Summit Software
Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments National Capital Region Transportation Planning Board Review of FTA Summit Software November 16, 2007 8300 Boone Blvd, Suite 700 Vienna, VA 22182 (703) 847-3071
More informationTampa, Florida: High Resolution Simulation of Urban Travel and Network Performance for Estimating Mobile Source Emissions
74 Tampa, Florida: High Resolution Simulation of Urban Travel and Network Performance for Estimating Mobile Source Emissions Authors: Sashikanth Gurram, Abdul R. Pinjari, and Amy L. Stuart 74.1 Introduction
More informationScenario Planning in an Uncertain Future
Scenario Planning in an Uncertain Future Maren Outwater June 21, 2017 The Next 100 Million People in the U.S. US population growing at higher rate than rest of world s developed nations For transportation
More informationAIR QUALITY CONFORMITY ANALYSIS: VISUALIZE 2045 SCOPE OF WORK
December 14, 2017 AIR QUALITY CONFORMITY ANALYSIS: VISUALIZE 2045 SCOPE OF WORK I. INTRODUCTION Projects solicited for the quadrennial update of the region s transportation plan, Visualize 2045, and the
More informationSERPM 8 Project Update
SERPM 8 Project Update presented to RTTAC-MS presented by Cambridge Systematics, Inc. Jay Evans, Marty Milkovits, Tom Rossi September 27, 2017 1 Outline Schedule Data status 2015 employment data* Synthetic
More informationChapter 14 Work Program
Chapter 14 Work Program The Metropolitan Council will carry out or participate in many studies and plans over the next three years. This is not an exhaustive list of all work to be completed by the Metropolitan
More informationEnergy Savings by replacing old facility o Energy savings o Emissions
Dubuque Intermodal Transportation Center Cost / Benefit Analysis Input values used in this analysis are taken from the U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) guidance on the preparation of Cost Benefit
More informationTransport Model for Scotland. Kevin Lumsden MVA
1. INTRODUCTION Transport Model for Scotland Kevin Lumsden MVA Transport Model for Scotland (TMfS) is a multi-modal transport demand and assignment model with an interactive Land Use model. The model area
More information1003 K Street NW, Suite 209 Washington, DC MEMORANDUM. Matthew Ridgway, Nat Bottigheimer, and Alex Rixey, Fehr & Peers
1003 K Street NW, Suite 209 Washington, DC 20001 202.854.2750 MEMORANDUM Date: To: From: Subject: Eric Graye, M-NCPPC Matthew Ridgway, Nat Bottigheimer, and Alex Rixey, Fehr & Peers Performance Metrics
More information4 th TRB International Conference on Innovations in Travel Modeling April 30, Vidya Mysore. presented at. Moderator
presented at 4 th TRB International Conference on Innovations in Travel Modeling April 30, 2012 Moderator Vidya Mysore Vidya.mysore@dot.state.fl.us Florida DOT 5/16/2012 Agenda Overview Recent Advances
More informationDISAGGREGATE TREATMENT OF PURPOSE, TIME OF DAY AND LOCATION IN AN ACTIVITY-BASED REGIONAL TRAVEL FORECASTING MODEL
DISAGGREGATE TREATMENT OF PURPOSE, TIME OF DAY AND LOCATION IN AN ACTIVITY-BASED REGIONAL TRAVEL FORECASTING MODEL Presented at the 2005 European Transport Conference, Strasbourg, France, October 2005
More informationResidential Multifamily res. Retail Industrial Vacant
Land Use Zone Residential Multifamily res. Retail Industrial Vacant Residential Multifamily res. Retail Industrial Vacant Residential Multifamily res. Retail Industrial Vacant Make and use coefficients
More informationNCHRP 20-83(5) Climate Change and the Highway System: Impacts and Adaptation Approaches
NCHRP 20-83(5) Climate Change and the Highway System: Impacts and Adaptation Approaches Professor Michael D. Meyer Frederick R. Dickerson Professor School of Civil and Environmental Engineering Georgia
More informationProject Title: Using Truck GPS Data for Freight Performance Analysis in the Twin Cities Metro Area Prepared by: Chen-Fu Liao (PI) Task Due: 12/31/2013
Project Title: Using Truck GPS Data for Freight Performance Analysis in the Twin Cities Metro Area Prepared by: Chen-Fu Liao (PI) Task Due: 12/31/2013 TASK #5: IDENTIFY FREIGHT NODE, FREIGHT SIGNIFICANT
More informationAnalysis of Options for Reducing Transportation Greenhouse Gas Emissions in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic
Analysis of Options for Reducing Transportation Greenhouse Gas Emissions in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic Christopher D. Porter, Cambridge Systematics, Inc., 100 CambridgePark Drive, Suite 400, Cambridge,
More informationINTEGRATION OF THE NATIONAL LONG DISTANCE PASSENGER TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL WITH THE TENNESSEE STATEWIDE MODEL AND CALIBRATION TO BIG DATA
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 INTEGRATION OF THE NATIONAL LONG DISTANCE PASSENGER TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL
More informationTransportation A Conversation on Regional Transportation. Tacoma City Manager April 15, Update to the Regional Transportation Plan
Transportation 2040 Update to the Regional Transportation Plan A Conversation on Regional Transportation Tacoma City Manager April 15, 2009 1 Puget Sound Regional Council The Region: 4 counties 82 cities
More informationTransform 66 Multimodal Project: Prioritization Process and Evaluation Criteria Approved March 3, 2016
Transform 66 Multimodal Project: Prioritization Process and Evaluation Criteria Approved March 3, 2016 The Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) for the Transform 66: Inside the Beltway Project directs NVTC to
More informationDraft Update Presented to the Grand Forks East Grand Forks MPO TAC
GRAND FORKS EAST GRAND FORKS 2015 TRAVEL DEMAND MODEL UPDATE DRAFT REPORT Draft Update Presented to the Grand Forks East Grand Forks MPO TAC August 9 th 2017 Diomo Motuba, PhD Advanced Traffic Analysis
More informationVehicle Miles Traveled Trends and Implications for the US Interstate Highway System
Vehicle Miles Traveled Trends and Implications for the US Interstate Highway System The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine Transportation Research Board Future Interstate Study Steven
More informationEmerging Research Needs in Congestion Pricing
Emerging Research Needs in Congestion Pricing Impact of ETC on Managed Lanes Users Trey Baker Consultant, Advisory Services, WSP USA Chair, TRB Standing Committee on Congestion Pricing IBTTA & TRB Joint
More informationFindings from a Road Pricing Experiment
Findings from a Road Pricing Experiment Los Angeles Congestion Pricing Workshop June 27, 2008 Project Background Long-Term Finance Reform Long-run viability of existing transportation finance approaches
More informationRegional Performance Measures Annual Progress Report TPO Board - 2/4/2016 Presentation by: Chris Wichman, Senior Planner
2015 TPO Board - 2/4/2016 Presentation by: Chris Wichman, Senior Planner Overview History and definition of performance-based planning & programming Review of 2015 TPO Board Action Requested 2 History
More informationChris Gray (WRCOG), Chris Tzeng (WRCOG), Sarah Dominguez (SCAG), Mike Gainor (SCAG)
TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM Date: 12.17.18 To: Chris Gray (WRCOG), Chris Tzeng (WRCOG), Sarah Dominguez (SCAG), Mike Gainor (SCAG) From: Ronald T. Milam, AICP, PTP and Jason Pack, PE Subject: Review and Assessment
More informationMid-South Regional Travel Surveys & Model Update
Mid-South Regional Travel Surveys & Model Update May 9, 2014 Presented to the Mid-South Travel Survey and Model Update Steering Committee By: Thomas Rossi, Anurag Komanduri, and Brent Selby, Cambridge
More informationBelgian OOH survey Ready for the future
Belgian OOH survey 2017- Ready for the future What does the market need? Reliable OOH-survey Covers the whole country Survey with up to date data High granularity Compatible with DOOH Integration of visibility
More informationNew Mexico Statewide Model
New Mexico Statewide Model Fifth Largest State in land area 2005 Population 1.97 million 42% of state in Albuquerque and Santa Fe area Outside urban areas population density very low New Mexico Planning
More informationPorter, D.R., Performance Standards for Growth Management. PAS Report 461. APA Planning Press: Chicago, IL. ed
Porter, D.R., Performance Standards for Growth Management. PAS Report 461. APA Planning Press: Chicago, IL. ed. 1996. The first five chapters of this report discuss the various performance measures, including
More informationState of the Practice - How Public Transportation is addressed in Traffic Impact Studies ITE Transit and Traffic Impact Studies Committee
State of the Practice - How Public Transportation is addressed in Traffic Impact Studies ITE Transit and Traffic Impact Studies Committee Purpose of Report Relevant Literature Survey Results Current and
More informationA Win/Win Strategy: Fixing Transportation and Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions in Massachusetts
Northeastern University Dukakis Center for Urban & Regional Policy A Win/Win Strategy: Fixing Transportation and Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions in Massachusetts E2/T4MA/NRDC EcoSalon Full Speed Ahead:
More informationMid-South Regional Travel Surveys & Model Update
Mid-South Regional Travel Surveys & Model Update October 16, 2014 Presented to the Mid-South Travel Survey and Model Update Steering Committee By: Thomas Rossi and Anurag Komanduri, Cambridge Systematics
More informationreport final Decennial Model Update Executive Summary Contra Costa Transportation Authority Cambridge Systematics, Inc.
final report prepared for Contra Costa Transportation Authority prepared by with Dowling Associates Caliper Corporation June 2003 Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction... ES-1 2.0 Data Development... ES-5
More informationKentucky Statewide Travel Model (KYSTM) Rob Bostrom Wilbur Smith Associates Combined Kentucky-Tennessee Model Users Group Meeting Bowling Green, KY
Kentucky Statewide Travel Model (KYSTM) Rob Bostrom Wilbur Smith Associates Combined Kentucky-Tennessee Model Users Group Meeting Bowling Green, KY October 26, 2006 Presentation Overview Overview of statewide
More information2011 Sherman-Denison Work Place and Special Generator Travel Survey Technical Summary
2011 Sherman-Denison Work Place and Special Generator Travel Survey Technical Summary Prepared by by the Texas Texas A&M A&M Transportation Institute February January 2019 2014 2011 Sherman-Denison Work
More informationChapter IX Regional Performance
Chapter IX Regional Performance In recent years, performance-based planning and project programming have increasingly been employed by the North Central Texas Council of Governments (NCTCOG) in the development
More informationManagement and Integration of Data and Modeling at Santa Clara County Congestion Management Agency
Management and Integration of Data and Modeling at Santa Clara County Congestion Management Agency VTA Modeling and GIS Group Peter Chen ITE SF Bay Area Annual Modeling Workshop April 29, 2015 Outlines
More informationAdaptation of HERS-ST Models for the South Carolina Interactive Interstate Management System
Adaptation of HERS-ST Models for the South Carolina Interactive Interstate Management System presented to the Transportation Research Board HERS Modeling and Data Integration Conference presented by William
More informationNORTHERN VIRGINIA TRANSPORTATION PLAN
NORTHERN VIRGINIA TRANSPORTATION PLAN November 2012 Table of Contents TransAction 2040 Plan Area...1 Communities and Facilities Covered in TransAction 2040... 1 TransAction 2040 Plan Methodology...2 Individual
More informationSynthetic Household Travel Data Using Consumer and Mobile Phone Data IDEA Program Final Report NCHRP-184
Synthetic Household Travel Data Using Consumer and Mobile Phone Data IDEA Program Final Report NCHRP-184 Prepared for the IDEA Program Transportation Research Board The National Academies Josephine D.
More information