Right decision, wrong reasons
|
|
- Naomi Palmer
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Right decision, wrong reasons Economic issues in the Poundland/99p Stores merger 28 November 2015
2 A wise and sensible decision
3 for in my view the wrong reasons Failure to properly assess barriers to entry/expansion No analysis of real question of interest particularly in a Phase 2 context
4 Entry and expansion
5 Hard to think of a market where entry and expansion are easier (1) Small high street stores Lots of vacancies
6 Hard to think of a market where entry and expansion are easier (2) Easy to get hold of stock Fit out costs trivial Leases easy to arrange Low-skilled staff on minimum wage
7 Levels of entry/expansion are extremely high at a national level CMA s revenue impact analysis had 596 Poundland stores facing 923 entry events within 0.5 miles over the last 5 years and p stores facing 345 entry events within 0.5 miles over the last 5 years
8 and the parties presented extensive evidence on options in each overlap area Retailer Key Competing Retailers within the Watford Retail Area (c 3m Number on Map Retailer Name Number of Competing Retailer Units 1 Tesco Stores 1 2 Asda Stores 1 3 Morrisons Stores 1 4 Sainsburys Stores 2 5 Tesco Convenience Stores 6 9 Poundland P Stores 1 11 B&M Stores 1 13 Poundworld/Discount UK Stores 1 15 Wilkinsons Stores 1 17 Best One Stores 1 18 Costcutter Stores 6 19 Musgrave Stores Nisa Stores 3 22 Premier Stores 4 23 Spar Stores 3 26 Iceland Stores 1 28 Boots Stores 3 29 Superdrug Stores 2 31 WH Smith Stores 3 32 Rymans Stores 2 33 Card Factory 1 34 Argos 1 35 Marks and Spencer 1 36 Primark 1 37 Greggs Total 3 64 Maps of retail sites in each local area GOAD data on vacant sites in each High Street (marked in purple)
9 The barriers to entry analysis in full
10 Failure to acknowledge this is a problem for the rest of the analysis Low barriers to entry sufficient to clear merger by themselves remaining analysis superfluous CMA s proposed analytical framework makes little sense when there are low barriers to entry Important to start with a view on entry barriers when considering how to approach case Joint Merger Guidelines place entry barriers after efficiencies does this make sense?
11 What the CMA did and why I don t like it
12 Two approaches to the key merger issue Would prices have gone up after the merger? 1. Simulation approach 2. Outcomes approach CMA did this I prefer this
13 Simulation approaches Full merger simulation Proxy merger simulation (GUPPI, UPP, IPR etc.) Demand estimation (or other way to back out cross-price elasticities) Diversion ratio estimates Marginal costs (or margins) Margins Can t do this data limitations Model of competition Change in ownership structure Assumption of differentiated Bertrand Assumption on cost passthrough (shape of demand curve CMA did this
14 Proxy merger simulation uses common data Proxy merger simulation (GUPPI, UPP, IPR etc.) Aggregate diversion ratio estimates Margins Assumption of differentiated Bertrand Formula (which variants?) Based on revenue impact analysis Adjusted with data from CC survey Parties estimates of variable margins Used linear IPR
15 of which the most difficult data point is the aggregate diversion ratio 1. Identify competing fascia 2. Assume DR = 0 for stores more than 1 mile apart Proximity weight Give a store a weighting of 1 if it was between 0 and 0.5 miles away Give a store a weighting of 0.5 if it was between 0.5 and 1 miles away Fascia weight Give an SPP (Poundworld or 99p store) a weighting of 1 Give a B&M, Bargain Buys, Home Bargains and Wilkinson a weighting of 0.5 Tesco and Asda - weighting of 0.5 Weights drawn from qualitative findings of revenue impact analysis cross-checked against survey evidence.. except for supermarkets, which were added on the basis of benchmarking
16 which then feeds in to the calculation of the national IPR Aggregate diversion ratio 10% from Poundland to 99p Stores and 21% from 99p Stores to Poundland Use variable margins and relative prices NB Aggregate DR takes account of proportion of overlap areas Aggregate price increase c. 1%-2% No problem! Really? Groceries found problems at 0.6% per local area
17 This approach has many problems Aggregate diversion ratio essentially made up Largely arbitrary fascia weights Largely arbitrary proximity weights Results impossible to interpret No attempt to calibrate results Whole number fascia counting is clear But how do we interpret the observation that 150 stores faced less than 1 competitor pre-merger and 292 postmerger? What is meant by a quarter of a competitor? Data available over on competitor set over time from revenue impact analysis Extensive entry means can see differences in aggregate diversions (using CMA approach) Could test impact of predictions on reality
18 particularly failing to deal with easy entry The whole approach is static IPR analysis gives price prediction based on no change in market structure When entry is easy, this approach makes no sense Entry question is different If, post-merger, the merging parties were to increase their prices, would rivals enter in response, to an extent that would offset the price increase? We used to explore this question. Apparently we don t any more. Why not? CMA doesn t recognise this adequately we expected that the expansion of competitors would reduce the aggregate diversion ratio between the Parties compared to the aggregate diversion ratio between Poundland and these expanding competitors (6.152) This is again a static analysis assumes entry plans are fixed but entry plans would not be static in response to any price change this would just create more profitable opportunities is this basically a Phase 1 approach?
19 5 x 100 does not equal 1 x 500 CMA appears to differentiate between the following situations 1. A 5% price increase in 100 locations 2. A 1% price increase in 500 locations This appears to be an SLC in 100 areas This appears to be fine blame the lawyers?
20 My preferred approach
21 A PCA approach is data-based way Would prices have gone up after the merger? 1. Cross-sectional PCA do areas of high concentration have worse performance? 2. Time series PCA do increases in average level of local concentration give rise to reduced performance (or vice versa) We did this CMA could have done this, but didn t of answering the merger question
22 Cross-sectional PCA Performance f Concentration Store characteristics Local area characteristics Proxied by gross margin (cf Groceries) and variable margin - can t use price as national pricing policies Various measures SPP, all VGM, VGM+, presence or absence Size, sales/sq ft., store type, age, time since refurbishment, recently opened Unemployment rate, average earnings, population density, % ethnic minority OLS approach plus IV using doughnut instruments, i.e. population just outside catchment (cf Groceries) argued correlated with concentration as in rivals catchments but not with margins no effect of concentration on margins
23 CMA criticisms not sensible in my view If PQRS is set nationally, then the gross and variable margins and ranges of products will not be determined at the local level so you can t do a PCA (Final Report, Appendix E) True if policy is identical everywhere (e.g. price) Not true if policy is differs but not due to competition but due to e.g. size Margins capture all other factors a la Groceries CMA does its own X-sectional PCA on other characteristics (gross margin, range, store refurbishments etc.) (Appendix F) CMA concludes there is no variation in the offer locally this is the conclusion of our PCA rejection of our approach seems strange Shouldn t include sales/sq ft. (Phase 1 Decision) Demographic controls largely insignificant (Phase 1 Decision) Endogeneity problem instruments used suffer from weak instruments (Phase 1 Decision) Fair enough, but CMA redid the analysis without it no difference So what? Sometimes instruments are weak, sometimes not, results don t change
24 and endogeneity concern irrelevant in the merger context Endogeneity issue: high margin areas (unobserved) attracts entry, distorts pure estimate of concentration effect Argued that need to control for this using instruments I disagree we should be trying to estimate the post-entry effect why are we assuming entry won t happen? IV approach OLS approach Measures effect of change in number of fascia absent entry Standard approach (e.g. Groceries) is to do this but this is the right question Measures combination of change in concentration and any offsetting entry and good instruments are rarely available
25 One relevant criticism remains Cost or demand factors mean that offer doesn t change locally today Might change to local flexing tomorrow? (NB Poundland approach unchanged in 25 years) National price level set at average level of competition could reduce offer across the board CMA approach bottom up analysis of costs of flexing (e.g. complexity, brand damage) CMA approach revenue diversion analysis
26 could deal with this using time series PCA Source: Companies House, data not available for 2002 There has been material change in the proportion of competed stores over the past 5 years see entry chart We only had data on competition from 99p Stores CMA had full competitor dataset Did this lead to any change in performance, here measured by margin?
27 CMA didn t try to explore this We accepted that there had been little change in Poundland s gross margins over time and also that since 2000, Poundland had faced increased competition (in terms of a greater number of local overlaps) from both SPP and VGM retailers. However, this analysis does not control for other factors that have also changed over this period. For example, Poundland has significantly expanded its network of stores and the sector has seen shifts in consumer behaviour. We considered that without controlling for these other factors, it was not possible to identify a relationship between gross margins and intensity of competition. Poundland has significantly expanded its network of stores The sector has seen shifts in consumer behaviour Why would this affect margins? Why can t you control for this? Why would this affect margins? What is a potential factor that exactly offsets the massive reduction in concentration? (As a matter of balance of probabilities.) This criticism affects the revenue impact analysis as well Counsel of despair?
28 Conclusion
29 Methodology and precedent troubling Aggregate diversion ratio approach is worrying Heavily assumption driven, no idea how to interpret the results, no attempt at calibration to reality Potentially relevant where you can t do a PCA (not the case) Like trying to do a Phase 1 approach in Phase 2? Rejection of PCA is worrying Approach to entry is terrifying Contradicts identical approach used in previous cases e.g. Groceries Internally inconsistent arguments within CMA report, which comes to the same conclusion on X-sectional PCA Endogeneity concern is not relevant with low barriers to entry Over 1,000 entries in 5 years still not enough for barriers to be low can we imagine a situation with lower barriers? Entire methodology assumes static concentration picture Choice not to write up awkward evidence? If so, why? even if outcome was correct
30 Frontier Economics Limited in Europe is a member of the Frontier Economics network, which consists of separate companies based in Europe (Brussels, Cologne, London and Madrid) and Australia (Melbourne & Sydney). The companies are independently owned, and legal commitments entered into by any one company do not impose any obligations on other companies in the network. All views expressed in this document are the views of Frontier Economics Limited.
31 FRONTIER ECONOMICS EUROPE LTD. BRUSSELS COLOGNE LONDON MADRID Frontier Economics Ltd, 71 High Holborn, London, WC1V 6DA Tel. +44 (0) Fax. +44 (0)
The G roceries Groceries Remittal Decision Decision Some concerns 12 November 2010
The Groceries Remittal Decision Some concerns 12 November 2010 Disclaimer My views Not the views of Frontier Or of Tesco My conclusion: the remedy is unsafe Based on a misreading of the analysis in the
More informationReport on Premises Assurance Model selfassessment
Report on Premises Assurance Model selfassessment questions Southern Health NHS Foundation Trust Report generated on 24/07/2013 Contents Current year Overview Results by section: scores, strengths and
More informationInternational energy price comparisons study
International energy price comparisons study PRESENTATION TO CREG GENERAL COUNCIL 26 October 2011 Agenda Purpose and scope Methodology Electricity and gas price comparisons Households SME Industry Summary
More informationCUSTOMER CENTRICITY INDEX. March Which are the most effective levers to create customer loyalty?
CUSTOMER CENTRICITY INDEX March 2016 Which are the most effective levers to create customer loyalty? 2 CUSTOMER CENTRICITY INDEX The dunnhumby Customer Centricity Index (CCI) identifies the key drivers
More informationRevisiting the hypothetical monopolist test, and the role of common sense market definitions
Revisiting the hypothetical monopolist test, and the role of common sense market definitions Bea Pros and Cons conference 2017 3 November 2017 Professor Amelia Fletcher Centre for Competition Policy University
More informationBOOTS/ALLIANCE UNICHEM
Mannheim, ACE 2006 BOOTS/ALLIANCE UNICHEM Local Market Analysis OVERVIEW 2 1. Introduction: Boots/AU merger implications 1.1 Horizontal issues 1.2 Vertical issues 2. Local market analysis 2.1 Isochrones
More informationNisa Retail / Co-operative Group Merger Inquiry
Nisa Retail / Co-operative Group Merger Inquiry ACS (the Association of Convenience Stores) welcomes the opportunity to contribute to the CMA s inquiry into the proposed merger between Nisa Retail and
More informationUnilateral Effects In Horizontal Mergers. Jeffrey Prisbrey Charles River Associates April 28, 2016
Unilateral Effects In Horizontal Mergers Jeffrey Prisbrey Charles River Associates April 28, 2016 Types of Mergers Horizontal The products of the firms are substitutes Vertical The products of the firms
More informationDefining Product Markets in the UK Grocery Industry
SEPTEMBER 2008, RELEASE ONE Defining Product Markets in the UK Grocery Industry Kate Collyer Andrew Taylor U.K. Competition Commission Defining Product Markets in the UK Groceries Industry Kate Collyer
More informationEdexcel Economics A-level
Edexcel Economics A-level Unit 3: Business Behaviour Topic 3: Market Structures and Contestability 3.3 Oligopoly Notes Characteristics of an oligopoly: High barriers to entry and exit There are high barriers
More informationTaking stock of the OFT s approach in supermarket mergers
Agenda Advancing economics in business Taking stock of the OFT s approach in supermarket mergers In 2008 the UK Office of Fair Trading (OFT) accepted undertakings from the Co-op for it to sell more than
More informationEmpirical Applications in Transport Economics. Philippe Gagnepain. Office: Tel:
Empirical Applications in Transport Economics Philippe Gagnepain Office: 15.2.57 Tel: 91 624 5732 philippe@eco.uc3m.es Section 2: Alliances, mergers, and collusion Increasing competition in many transportation
More informationMark Scheme (Results) Summer 2007
Mark Scheme (Results) Summer 2007 GCE GCE Economics (6354) Paper 1 Edexcel Limited. Registered in England and Wales No. 4496750 Registered Office: One90 High Holborn, London WC1V 7BH 6354 Mark Scheme
More informationBriefing. Mobile prices in Austria
1 Frontier Economics May 2015 Briefing Water Energy Environment Retail and Consumer Transport Financial services Healthcare Telecoms Media Post Competition policy Policy analysis and design Regulation
More informationEmissions trading/tradable pollution permits
Emissions trading/tradable pollution permits The objective is to get students to understand why an trading scheme can be an effective way of, superior in some ways to carbon taxes or quotas. It is important
More informationCapacity building workshop on the ex post evaluation of competition authorities enforcement decisions: A methodological summary
Capacity building workshop on the ex post evaluation of competition authorities enforcement decisions: A methodological summary PETER ORMOSI OECD WP2 26 OCTOBER 2015 Outline Difference in differences (diff
More informationMark scheme (Results) Summer Pearson Edexcel GCE AS Level in Business (8BS0/02) Paper 02 Managing Business Activities
scheme (Results) Summer 2016 Pearson Edexcel GCE AS Level in Business (8BS0/02) Paper 02 Managing Business Activities Edexcel and BTEC Qualifications Edexcel and BTEC qualifications are awarded by Pearson,
More informationAQA Economics A-level
AQA Economics A-level Microeconomics Topic 5: Perfect Competition, Imperfectly Competitive Markets and Monopoly 5.5 Oligopoly Notes Characteristics of an oligopoly: High barriers to entry and exit There
More informationA level: Economics B. Paper 1 practice papers
i A level: Economics B Paper 1 practice papers Markets and how they work By Gerald Wood Contents These three Paper 1 practice papers have the following key features: 1. They are laid out in the general
More informationFranchises and Fascias: Who is leading the way in the world of food retailing? How do Symbol Fascias stack up versus the bigger players.
The study results disclosed in this report may not be used for advertising, marketing, or promotional purposes without the prior written consent of Harris Interactive. s and brand names are trademarks
More informationCASE ME/6752/18 INITIAL SUBMISSION. J Sainsbury plc. ASDA Group Limited
CASE ME/6752/18 INITIAL SUBMISSION J Sainsbury plc ASDA Group Limited 10 October 2018 Initial Submission I Introduction (1) On 30 April 2018, J Sainsbury plc ( Sainsbury s ) and Walmart Inc. ( Walmart
More informationEvaluating Advertising Return on Investment. Quantifying the return on investment in advertising is important for several reasons:
pty ltd acn 094 521 614 Evaluating Advertising Return on Investment Charlie Nelson October 2003 Introduction Quantifying the return on investment in advertising is important for several reasons: Determining
More informationMARK SCHEME for the October/November 2010 question paper for the guidance of teachers 9708 ECONOMICS
UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS GCE Advanced Subsidiary Level and GCE Advanced Level MARK SCHEME for the October/November 2010 question paper for the guidance of teachers 9708 ECONOMICS
More informationEfficient regime for the expansion of renewable energies, further development of the energy-only market and preservation of EU-ETS
Efficient regime for the expansion of renewable energies, further development of the energy-only market and preservation of EU-ETS ABASTRACT OF A STUDY FOR RWE AG June 2013 Frontier Economics Ltd/r2b.
More informationJune 2003 SAFEWAY MERGER INQUIRIES: REMEDIES STATEMENT
21-03 24 June 2003 SAFEWAY MERGER INQUIRIES: REMEDIES STATEMENT The Competition Commission has sent remedies letters to the main parties in the Safeway merger inquiries. These inquiries concern the mergers
More informationEconomic potential of smart metering in Germany
Economic potential of smart metering in Germany David Bothe, Jens Perner, Christoph Riechmann 9 October 21 Our analysis Goal Approach Exemplary implementation of cost-benefit-analysis for the economic
More informationEdexcel (B) Economics A-level
Edexcel (B) Economics A-level Theme 4: Making Markets Work 4.1 Competition and Market Power 4.1.1 Spectrum of competition Notes Characteristics of monopoly, oligopoly, imperfect and perfect competition
More informationLimited distribution: a self-assessment exercise
Limited distribution: a self-assessment exercise Jan Peter van der Veer Partner, RBB Economics jan.peter.vanderveer@rbbecon.com 20 Oc tober 2011 About RBB Economics Largest independent competition consultancy
More informationEdexcel (B) Economics A-level
Edexcel (B) Economics A-level Theme 4: Making Markets Work 4.2 Market Power and Market Failure 4.2.1 Market failure Notes Significance of market power: o Cartels, collusion, restrictive practices and tacit
More informationMARK SCHEME for the May/June 2012 question paper for the guidance of teachers 9708 ECONOMICS
UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS GCE Advanced Subsidiary Level and GCE Advanced Level MARK SCHEME for the May/June 2012 question paper for the guidance of teachers 9708 ECONOMICS 9708/43
More informationMARK SCHEME for the May/June 2012 question paper for the guidance of teachers 9708 ECONOMICS
UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS GCE Advanced Subsidiary Level and GCE Advanced Level MARK SCHEME for the May/June 2012 question paper for the guidance of teachers 9708 ECONOMICS 9708/41
More informationEconomics: Introduction
Economics: Introduction Study notes for the Introduction To Economics (section 1) and introduction to Miceconomics (section 2) By Nils Österberg for nilsnotes On HL paper two there are usually three out
More informationTesco / Booker Merger Inquiry
Tesco / Booker Merger Inquiry ACS (the Association of Convenience Stores) welcomes the opportunity to contribute to the CMA s inquiry into the proposed merger between Tesco and Booker. ACS represents around
More informationChoosing Among Tools for Assessing Unilateral Merger Effects
Choosing Among Tools for Assessing Unilateral Merger Effects BIICL 10 th Anniversary Merger Conference 18 October 2012 Gregory J. Werden Senior Economic Counsel Antitrust Division U.S. Department of Justice
More informationADVANCED General Certificate of Education January Economics. Assessment Unit A2 1. Business Economics [AE211] FRIDAY 28 JANUARY, AFTERNOON
ADVANCED General Certificate of Education January 2011 Economics Assessment Unit A2 1 Business Economics [AE211] FRIDAY 28 JANUARY, AFTERNOON MARK SCHEME 6364.01 General Marking Instructions This mark
More informationWe apply economics to markets, organisations and policies.
OUR STRATEGY WORK We apply economics to markets, organisations and policies. Frontier is an economics consultancy that understands the intricacies and interrelationship between markets, organisations and
More informationCompetition and Monopoly in Markets
Competition and Monopoly in Markets What is a market structure? A market structure describes the characteristics of a market that can affect the behaviour of businesses and also affect the welfare of consumers.
More informationSAMPLE RESOURCE. porter s five forces. business strategy. Top Trumps
business porter s five forces Top Trumps Resources for Courses Teacher Instructions This activity is best done after a brief introduction to Porter s five forces a model which can be used to analyse the
More informationNPD in an environment of range rationalisation.
NEW PRODUCT STUDY: NPD in an environment of range rationalisation. NICHOLAS HILL ADAM VINE-HALL TIM EALES OCTOBER 2016 New Products - What s the Story? The number of items stocked in an average Supermarket
More informationAre consumers getting what they REALLY want?
Are consumers getting what they REALLY want? Initial Findings from a Major Survey of Consumer Satisfaction with their Local Selection of Grocery Stores Report of early findings from a major new study by
More informationWHy contractors. Take Bad Jobs
WHy contractors Take Bad Jobs The Truth About Why Contractors Take Bad Jobs It happens. Always has. Always will. It s part of a contractor s life. Sometimes it s a surprise, sometimes you saw it coming
More informationUnderstanding UPP. Alternative to Market Definition, B.E. Journal of Theoretical Economics, forthcoming.
Understanding UPP Roy J. Epstein and Daniel L. Rubinfeld Published Version, B.E. Journal of Theoretical Economics: Policies and Perspectives, Volume 10, Issue 1, 2010 Introduction The standard economic
More informationAQA Economics AS-level
AQA Economics AS-level Microeconomics Topic 4: Competitive and Concentrated Markets 4.4 Monopoly and monopoly power Notes A pure monopoly is the sole seller in a market. In the UK, when one firm dominates
More informationAS Economics. Economics Paper 1: The Operation of markets and market failure Final Mark scheme. 7135/1 June Version/Stage: v1.
AS Economics Economics Paper 1: The Operation of markets and market failure Final Mark scheme 7135/1 June 2017 Version/Stage: v1.0 Mark schemes are prepared by the Lead Assessment Writer and considered,
More informationINTERNAL AND EXTERNAL ANALYSIS OF ASDA 1 INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL ANALYSIS OF ASDA. Name. Course Instructor Institution Location Date of Submission
INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL ANALYSIS OF ASDA 1 INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL ANALYSIS OF ASDA Name Course Instructor Institution Location Date of Submission INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL ANALYSIS OF ASDA 2 Table of Contents
More informationUNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS General Certificate of Education Advanced Level
UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS General Certificate of Education Advanced Level *8178552153* ECONOMICS 9708/41 Paper 4 Data Response and Essays (Supplement) October/November 2013 Additional
More informationStrategy is the way a business operates in order to achieve its aims and objectives.
Chapter 6 Strategy and implementation Business objectives and strategy Strategy is the way a business operates in order to achieve its aims and objectives. There are two sides to strategy - the first is
More informationDevelopments in Unilateral Effects Analysis: Price Pressure Tests
Developments in Unilateral Effects Analysis: Price Pressure Tests Andrew Swan & Richard Murgatroyd, RBB Economics 1 Abstract Arguably the most significant development in horizontal merger assessment in
More informationWebrooming vs Showrooming. a report by PushON ecommerce. Delivered.
Webrooming vs Showrooming a report by PushON ecommerce. Delivered. Introduction Retail has undergone immense change in recent years, driven largely by online and mobile technology. The growth of online
More informationLoyalty penalties and the limits of competitive markets
Loyalty penalties and the limits of competitive markets In December 2018, the UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) published its response to a Citizens Advice super-complaint relating to loyalty
More informationECONOMICS 103. Topic 3: Supply, Demand & Equilibrium
ECONOMICS 103 Topic 3: Supply, Demand & Equilibrium Assumptions of the competitive market model: all agents are price takers, homogeneous products. Demand & supply: determinants of demand & supply, demand
More informationThe 10 Big Mistakes People Make When Running Customer Surveys
The 10 Big Mistakes People Make When Running Customer Surveys If you want to understand what drives customer loyalty for your business and how to align your business to improve customer loyalty, Genroe
More informationMark Scheme (Results) January 2011
Mark Scheme (Results) January 2011 GCE GCE Business Studies (6BS02/01) Unit 2A: Managing the Business Paper 01 Edexcel Limited. Registered in England and Wales No. 4496750 Registered Office: One90 High
More informationMark Scheme (Results) Summer Pearson Edexcel GCE In Business (9BS0) Paper 2: Business activities, decisions and strategy
Mark Scheme (Results) Summer 2017 Pearson Edexcel GCE In Business (9BS0) Paper 2: Business activities, decisions and strategy Edexcel and BTEC Qualifications Edexcel and BTEC qualifications are awarded
More informationTowards an effects based approach to price discrimination. Anne Perrot «Pros and Cons 2005» Stockholm
Towards an effects based approach to price discrimination Anne Perrot «Pros and Cons 2005» Stockholm Introduction Price discrimination = individualisation of prices for economists, unfairness for lawyers.
More informationEdexcel (A) Economics A-level
Edexcel (A) Economics A-level Theme 3: Business Behaviour & the Labour Market 3.4 Market Structures 3.4.4 Oligopoly Notes Characteristics of an oligopoly: High barriers to entry and exit There are high
More informationADVANCED General Certificate of Education Economics Assessment Unit A2 1. assessing. Business Economics [AE211] FRIDAY 20 MAY, MORNING
ADVANCED General Certificate of Education 2011 Economics Assessment Unit A2 1 assessing Business Economics [AE211] FRIDAY 20 MAY, MORNING MARK SCHEME 6655.01 General Marking Instructions This mark scheme
More informationIf the industry s short-run supply curve equals the horizontal sum of individual firms short-run supply curves, which of the following may we infer?
Microeconomics, Module 8: Competition: Long Run (Chapter 7) Illustrative Test Questions (The attached PDF file has better formatting.) Question 8.1: Long Run Equilibrium When is a competitive profit-maximizing
More informationGUARANTEEING SATISFACTION INVESTING TO WIN CUSTOMERS AND GROW MARKET SHARE
GUARANTEEING SATISFACTION INVESTING TO WIN CUSTOMERS AND GROW MARKET SHARE In the past, sales growth in retail came from developing an effective store concept and rolling it out across hundreds of locations.
More informationMark Scheme (Results) January 2011
Mark Scheme (Results) January 2011 GCE GCE Economics & Business (6EB02) Paper 01 Edexcel Limited. Registered in England and Wales No. 4496 50 7 Registered Office: One90 High Holborn, London WC1V 7BH Edexcel
More informationPublic goods. Public Economics. Carlo Fiorio Bocconi University
Public Economics Bocconi University carlo.fiorio@unibocconi.it http://www.econpubblica.uni-bocconi.it/fiorio Academic Year 2006/2006 Today s questions What is a public good? Why does the state produce
More informationBCG Full Case Example
Modified: May 22, 2018 BCG Full Case Example Summary This is an example of a full Case example provided by BCG to an MBA Consulting Club. It is likely a Case that BCG used in interviews in the past, but
More informationWhat is good mental health in the city workplace and how do we measure it?
What is good mental health in the city workplace and how do we measure it? Report for the City Mental Health Alliance March 2015 1. Introduction Context and objectives The City Mental Health Alliance (CMHA)
More informationEstimating Discrete Choice Models of Demand. Data
Estimating Discrete Choice Models of Demand Aggregate (market) aggregate (market-level) quantity prices + characteristics (+advertising) distribution of demographics (optional) sample from distribution
More informationVersion 1.0: abc. General Certificate of Education. Applied Business 8616/8619. The Marketing Environment. Mark Scheme
Version 1.0: 0708 abc General Certificate of Education Applied Business 8616/8619 BS11 The Marketing Environment Mark Scheme 008 examination - June series Mark schemes are prepared by the Principal Examiner
More informationEconomics of Industrial Organization. Lecture 12: Mergers
Economics of Industrial Organization Lecture 12: Mergers Mergers Thus far we have talked about industry dynamics in terms of firms entering and exiting the industry, and have assumed that all these firms
More informationCan Analysis of Dominance be taken UPPwards? Possible Lessons from Mergers
Can Analysis of Dominance be taken UPPwards? Possible Lessons from Mergers Amelia Fletcher ESRC Centre for Competition Policy www.competitionpolicy.ac.uk Today s essay question Over the last decade we
More informationMark Scheme (Results) Winter 2010
Scheme (Results) Winter 2010 GCE GCE Economics (6EC03/01) Edexcel Limited. Registered in England and Wales No. 4496750 Registered Office: One90 High Holborn, London WC1V 7BH General ing Guidance All candidates
More informationMark Scheme (Results) Winter 2010
Scheme (Results) Winter 2010 GCE GCE Economics (6EC03/01) Edexcel Limited. Registered in England and Wales No. 4496750 Registered Office: One90 High Holborn, London WC1V 7BH General ing Guidance All candidates
More informationCompetition and Market Authority's energy market investigation inquiry one off evidence session
Angus Brendan MacNeil MP Chair, Energy and Climate Change Committee House of Commons London SW1H 9NB 29th June 2016 Competition and Market Authority's energy market investigation inquiry one off evidence
More informationECON 1602 (B 09A): BASIC ECONOMIC CONCEPTS: MICROECONOMICS
1 EXERCISE SHEET 4 ECON 1602 (B 09A): BASIC ECONOMIC CONCEPTS: MICROECONOMICS Here are some more questions, which reflect some of the work done in the final three lectures this term on the theory of the
More informationHow are small specialist stores existing in a market so widely dominated by large chain firms like Tesco and Asda?
How are small specialist stores existing in a market so widely dominated by large chain firms like Tesco and Asda? Jessica Harris Abstract: In this essay I will argue that the oligopoly that dominates
More information1 http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/110.asp Microeconomics looks closely at the behavior of individual participants in the economy. While it does aggregate the observations it makes and draws general
More informationCash Flow if you re out of money, you re out of business.
Cash Flow if you re out of money, you re out of business. Thanks for downloading this Cash Flow Cheat Sheet from SmartBusinessPlans.com.au Cash Flow is probably the most important aspect of keeping a business
More informationJoven Liew Jia Wen Industrial Economics I Notes. What is competition?
Industrial Economics I Notes What is competition? Competition in markets is generally considered a good thing (welfare economics) Competition authorities look at whether change in market structure or firm
More informationThe Joint OFT / CC Commentary on Retail Mergers: FAQ. November RBB Economics
1 The Joint OFT / CC Commentary on Retail Mergers: FAQ November 2011 RBB Economics The Joint OFT / CC Commentary on Retail Mergers: FAQs 4 5 10 FAQs on Retail Mergers 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Is this a separate
More informationTHE Marketing Plan. SCORE Chapter 37 Houston, Texas
THE Marketing Plan SCORE Chapter 37 Houston, Texas 1 Why Plan? Establish direction Identify obstacles Set goals & objectives Take an objective view Communicates owner s ideas - Tells a story 2 Part of
More informationBRITISH BUSINESS IN THE DIGITAL AGE
BRITISH BUSINESS IN THE DIGITAL AGE 1 BRITISH BUSINESS IN THE DIGITAL AGE A report into the current and future state of digital commerce in Britain Neil Stewart CEO Salmon The aim of this study is to explore
More informationMARK SCHEME for the October/November 2015 series 9708 ECONOMICS
CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS Cambridge International Advanced Level MARK SCHEME for the October/November 2015 series 9708 ECONOMICS 9708/42 Paper 4 (Data Response and Essays Supplement), maximum
More informationMark Scheme (Results) Summer Pearson Edexcel GCE in Economics & Business (6EB02/01) Unit 2B: Business Economics
Mark Scheme (Results) Summer 2016 Pearson Edexcel GCE in Economics & Business (6EB02/01) Unit 2B: Business Economics Edexcel and BTEC Qualifications Edexcel and BTEC qualifications are awarded by Pearson,
More informationMark Scheme (Results) Winter 2010
Scheme (Results) Winter 2010 GCE GCE Business Studies (6BS04) Unit 4: Making Business Decisions Edexcel Limited. Registered in England and Wales No. 4496750 Registered Office: One90 High Holborn, London
More informationGAINING CUSTOMER CONFIDENCE. Data Hygiene Insight
GAINING CUSTOMER CONFIDENCE COVERING A tiny bit about REaD Group A changing world Gaining customer confidence Gaining customer consent MY HYPOTHESIS FOR TODAY Theses are changing times population, trading
More informationMorning Time allowed: 1 hour 30 minutes
Please write clearly in block capitals. Centre number Candidate number Surname Forename(s) Candidate signature AS ECONOMICS Paper 1 The operation of markets and market failure Monday 15 May 2017 Morning
More informationAt P = $120, Q = 1,000, and marginal revenue is ,000 = $100
Microeconomics, monopoly, final exam practice problems (The attached PDF file has better formatting.) *Question 1.1: Marginal Revenue Assume the demand curve is linear.! At P = $100, total revenue is $200,000.!
More information6th October 1998 OECD ROUND TABLE ON RETAIL BUYING POWER OCTOBER 29-30, 1998 BIAC ROOM DOCUMENT
Business and Industry Advisory Committee to the OECD OECD Comité Consultatif Economique et Industriel Auprès de l l OCDE 6th October 1998 OECD ROUND TABLE ON RETAIL BUYING POWER OCTOBER 29-30, 1998 BIAC
More informationGrowing our business the Co-op Way: Wholesale - Nisa acquisition A leader s briefing guide. November 2017
Growing our business the Co-op Way: Wholesale - Nisa acquisition A leader s briefing guide November 2017 What this pack is for: To help you brief your teams on our successful wholesale acquisition of Nisa
More informationAnalyzing Organizations Strategically Undergraduate Level Professor: G. Tyge Payne, PhD
Analyzing Organizations Strategically Undergraduate Level Professor: G. Tyge Payne, PhD Overview of Organizational Strategic Analysis Projects The strategic analysis projects are designed to allow you
More informationMethodological issues in the regulation of mobile voice call termination
Methodological issues in the regulation of mobile voice call termination A response to Oftel s Review of Mobile Voice Call Termination Markets July 003 Summary In May 003 Oftel published a consultation
More informationIdentifying the growth opportunities for your retail brands. Strategic Brand Planning. ConversionModel Customer dynamics redefined TNS 2013
Identifying the growth opportunities for your retail brands Strategic Brand Planning TNS 2013 ConversionModel Customer dynamics redefined Maximising your growth with ConversionModel With brand planning
More informationReading Guide: Merger Retrospective: Waterstone s and Ottakar s (Booksellers in U.K. and Quebec)
Reading Guide: Merger Retrospective: Waterstone s and Ottakar s (Booksellers in U.K. and Quebec) This reading guide helps both non-presenters and presenters prepare for class. It offers broad and specific
More informationProducer Theory - Monopoly
Producer Theory - Monopoly Mark Dean Lecture Notes for Fall 2009 Introductory Microeconomics - Brown University 1 Introduction Up until now, we have assumed that all the agents in our economies are price
More informationFood and Drink Federation Sales Directors Forum. Leeds Marriott Hotel 15 th July 2014
Food and Drink Federation Sales Directors Forum Leeds Marriott Hotel 15 th July 2014 MARKET REVIEW FOCUS ON PRICE AND PROMOTIONS Food & Drink Federation 15 th July 2015 Leeds Copyright 2012 The Nielsen
More informationEco 300 Intermediate Micro
Eco 300 Intermediate Micro Instructor: Amalia Jerison Office Hours: T 12:00-1:00, Th 12:00-1:00, and by appointment BA 127A, aj4575@albany.edu A. Jerison (BA 127A) Eco 300 Spring 2010 1 / 61 Monopoly Market
More informationClient Briefing. A matter of definition
Frontier Economics Client Briefing Water Energy Climate Change Transport Telecoms Media Competition policy Policy analysis and design Regulation Strategy Contract design and evaluation Dispute support
More informationExam #2 (100 Points Total) Answer Key
Exam #2 (100 Points Total) Answer Key 1. A Pareto efficient outcome may not be good, but a Pareto inefficient outcome is in some meaningful sense bad. (a) (5 points) Give an example or otherwise explain,
More informationGUIDELINE FOR WRITING A BUSINESS PLAN
GUIDELINE FOR WRITING A BUSINESS PLAN Copyright CERIM This project is implemented through the CENTRAL EUROPE Programme co-financed by the ERDF. DIRECTORY WRITING A BUSINESS PLAN 3 1. Why you need to write
More informationSubmitted to the United States Postal Regulatory Commission, September 12, 2018
Comments of American Consumer Institute Center for Citizen Research Docket No. RM2017-1 Institutional Cost Contribution Requirement for Competitive Products Submitted to the United States Postal Regulatory
More informationMICROECONOMIC FOUNDATIONS OF COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS. Townley, Chapter 4
MICROECONOMIC FOUNDATIONS OF COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS Townley, Chapter 4 Review of Basic Microeconomics Slides cover the following topics from textbook: Input markets. Decision making on the margin. Pricing
More informationAccounting for Overheads - Marginal Costing
Accounting for Overheads - Marginal Costing Marginal cost is the variable cost of one unit of product or service. Marginal costing is an alternative method of costing to absorption costing. In marginal
More informationChapter 5 Aims and objectives. Vision statements
Chapter 5 Aims and objectives Vision statements Sometimes a successful business really does start with a vision. Ray Kroc, the man who brought McDonalds restaurants to the world, entered a small hamburger
More information