Collusion and Unilateral Price Announcements. Antonio Capobianco Senior Expert on Competition Law, OECD Competition Division

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Collusion and Unilateral Price Announcements. Antonio Capobianco Senior Expert on Competition Law, OECD Competition Division"

Transcription

1 Collusion and Unilateral Price Announcements Antonio Capobianco Senior Expert on Competition Law, OECD Competition Division 1

2 COLLUSION AND MARKET TRANSPARENCY Greater transparency in the market is generally a factor that enhances efficiency and, as such, it is welcome by competition agencies. However, market transparency can also produce anticompetitive effects by facilitating collusion or providing firms with focal points around which to align tacitly their behavior. Market transparency is a necessary attribute for the model of perfect competition as it increases efficiency by reducing customers search costs and allowing suppliers to benchmark their performance with that of their competitors. Markets operate more efficiently when participants convey information about their prices and offerings, allowing customers to choose between competing products and suppliers, thereby increasing competition between sellers. Knowledge about future price developments, for example, allows customers to plan their purchases accordingly. Similarly, disclosing information about the performance of a company and its future business strategy allows securities markets to operate efficiently by providing current and potential investors with relevant data concerning that company. Market transparency can either facilitate collusion or competition, depending on the circumstances: On the one hand, market transparency should be encouraged. Increased knowledge of market conditions mostly benefits consumers, who can choose between competing products with a better understanding of the product characteristics; customers can also compare terms and conditions of the various offerings and freely choose the most suitable one for their needs. Enhanced transparency benefits consumers by lowering search costs. On the supply-side, the knowledge of the market and its key features (e.g., characteristics of demand, available production capacity, investment plans, etc.) facilitates the development of efficient and effective commercial strategies by market players. New entrants or fringe players may benefit from this information and enter the market more effectively and compete more fiercely against incumbents. Increased transparency, on the other hand, is one of the factors required to reach a collusive understanding and make sure that it is sustainable over time. Transparency generally contributes to the ease of reaching an agreement, and decreases incentives to cheat by reducing the time before cheating is detected. In order to reach terms of coordination, to monitor compliance with such terms and to effectively punish deviations, companies 2

3 need to acquire detailed knowledge of competitors pricing and/or output strategies. The artificial removal of the uncertainty about competitors actions, which is at the basis of the competitive process, can in itself eliminate the normal competitive rivalry. This is particularly the case in highly concentrated markets where increased transparency enables companies to better predict or anticipate the conduct of their competitors and thus align themselves to it. COMPETITORS COMMUNICATIONS A CHALLENGING AREA FOR ANTITRUST ENFORCERS Explicit collusion, resulting from "naked" cartels to fix prices, allocate of customers or rig bids is almost universally condemned as unlawful. Conversely, conduct resulting purely from oligopolistic interdependence (tacit collusion) is generally not seen as a violation of competition law. It is also undisputed, however, that between explicit and tacit collusion there are situations in which firms engage in a range of practices that may help them to reduce strategic uncertainty and align their conduct more effectively. There are various strategies that firms can put in place to this purpose. These include artificially increasing market transparency by exchanging information with competitors or setting up more formalized industrywide information sharing systems, as well as engaging in unilateral communications to the market (e.g. via press releases or other media) about future strategies, such as planned price increases, capacity, output limitations or other future conduct. In doing so, firms offer focal points on which competitors can align themselves, which can result in higher prices and harm for social welfare. There can be considerable uncertainty surrounding the issue of whether/when competition law should intervene against unilateral disclosures of information (as opposed to reciprocal exchanges of information). There is little guidance from enforcement authorities and courts and the economic literature is at times equivocal. Making a distinction between purely unilateral conduct, such as unilateral communications (or signalling) which falls outside of the reach of competition laws, and coordinated conduct which could, in principle, fall within these laws, can be a difficult task for competition enforcers. While explicit collusion is viewed by most competition authorities as one of the most serious violations of competition law, tacit collusion or conscious parallel behavior are, on the contrary, not considered as illegal despite the fact that the outcome can be the same as in explicit collusion cases: prices jointly rise to the supra-competitive levels and possibly to the monopoly level. This raises an enforcement dilemma on 3

4 how to deal with those practices which do not amount to explicit collusion but favor tacit collusion. UNILATERAL ANNOUNCEMENTS Unilateral announcements include any communications made by firms to the market (e.g. via press releases or other media communications) to inform the market about strategies, products and developments of the company. Indeed, a unilateral disclosure is not an exchange of information in any well-founded sense but a mere one-way communication. As such, unilateral disclosures present a unique enforcement question because the disclosures are not agreements themselves and, thus, must be solely analyzed based on their potential to facilitate tacit concerted activity. Given the potential pro- and anti-competitive effects of unilateral announcements, competition agencies face the challenge of deciding which are, on balance, harmful. Whether the anticompetitive effects of unilateral disclosure of information outweigh any efficiency-enhancing effects is highly fact specific. Bright line rules are therefore difficult to establish. Nevertheless, certain factors, such as the nature, content and context of the disclosure, allow for general categorizations that may be used as starting points in competitive analysis. Unilateral announcements can function as signalling devices by which they can indirectly communicate their intentions. Such information disclosure, and the resulting transparency it creates, may also be used by firms to monitor and enforce already existing collusive agreements. The result may have potentially anticompetitive effects on the market. However, in dealing with these practices, competition agencies face significant challenges in discerning unilateral communications used for the purposes of facilitating collusion or aligning of behavior from genuine unilateral practices with potentially pro-competitive effects. The competitive assessment of such cases can only be fact specific. Nevertheless, several elements may be used as general indicators as to the competitive effects of unilateral information disclosure. Private disclosure between competitors has generally very few pro-competitive effects. On the other hand, public disclosure of information to both sellers and buyers is principally viewed as positive, in particular if the information has commitment value, meaning that it can be reliably traded upon. In terms of content, the disclosure of current or future price information carries greater anticompetitive potential than disclosure of past price information. Equally significant, the context in which the information disclosure occurs is essential for the assessment of its potential effects. Disclosure 4

5 in concentrated, oligopolistic markets with homogenous products carries much greater likelihood of anticompetitive effects than announcements made in markets with a competitive supply structure and with heterogeneous products. PRIVATE ANNOUNCEMENTS VS. PUBLIC ANNOUNCEMENTS, AND INVITATIONS TO COLLUDE It is generally accepted that private announcements, which are directed to competitors only, do not have efficiency reasons and can only be motivated by the intention to help rivals to coordinate on a particular collusive price. Conversely, public announcements, which are directed to both rival firms and consumers, may provide significant benefits to customers. This positive effect is generally considered stronger than the collusive effects of the announcements. The reason the distinction between public market transparency and private market transparency should have a bearing on defining a sound policy is that the economic literature associates with public disclosures a number of pro-competitive effects which are not associated with private communications. First and foremost, increased transparency and better knowledge of market conditions benefit consumers. In 1961, Stigler emphasised the importance of search costs for consumers. Buyers need to identify sellers and their prices, while customers need to search for knowledge on the quality of goods. The more information is available on the market (i.e. on the products and services and their suppliers), the better placed consumers are to choose between competing products, as they will have a greater understanding of the product characteristics. Consumers can knowledgeably compare terms and conditions of the various offerings and freely choose the most suitable one for their needs. The positive effects of price advertising are generally considered outweighing in magnitude the collusive effects of the announcements. In these circumstances, enhanced market transparency through disclosure to the public can benefit consumers by lowering consumers search costs. Reinforcing the conclusion of traditional economics, behavioral economics have shown that better informed consumers can be instrumental in developing vigorous competition between suppliers This stream of literature has also shown that information asymmetries and absence of information may not only distort consumer behavior but may also adversely impact competition and competitive outcomes. In these circumstances, increased transparency may improve social welfare. From a more empirical and pragmatic perspective, if the intention of unilateral announcements is to provide focal pricing points for competitors, private communications are significantly less costly and more effective than public announcements. Moreover, 5

6 public announcements are by definitions visible. As such, they increase the risk of detection by competition enforces, and facilitate the evidence gathering exercise should these practices be investigated at a later stage. Not every public announcement, however, is necessarily pro-competitive. Public announcements might be harmful to competition if the public communication includes an invitation to collude. Invitations to collude are generally understood as unilateral solicitations to enter into unlawful horizontal price-fixing or market allocation agreements. While private communications can always be construed as invitations to collude, public announcements can also be construed as invitations to collude depending on how the communication is formulated. This would generally be the case of announcements which: (i) contain not only information which must, as a matter of commercial policy, be conveyed to customers but also information which is not intended for that audience, for example including references to specific competitors; (ii) disclose more information about that it is strictly necessary for the purpose of the announcement; (iii) make the behaviour announced contingent on what other market players or the industry at large will do; and (iv) include threats (e.g. a price war) in case other market players do not accept the invitation to collude. THE LEGAL TREATMENT OF UNILATERAL ANNOUNCEMENTS In pursuing unilateral disclosure of information with anticompetitive effects, competition agencies have generally relied on legal concepts derived from the prosecution of cartels, such as agreement or concerted practice. Some jurisdictions, where these concepts have either been interpreted too narrowly or been altogether absent, have introduced specific provisions dealing with unilateral announcements. Some jurisdictions rely on the concept of agreement and look at whether an agreement can be inferred from evidence suggesting that competitors have not acted independently. Other jurisdictions, in particular those in the European Union, rely on the concept of concerted practice, which allow them to deal with practices that, while anticompetitive, do not amount to an agreement. Proving that a unilateral disclosure of information constitutes an agreement restricting competition can be difficult, in particular in jurisdictions where the concept of an agreement has been interpreted narrowly. In the United States, on the other hand, in light of the challenges with applying Section 1 of the Sherman Act to these practices, the enforcement agencies have often relied on the concept of an invitation to collude under Section 5 of the FTC 6

7 Act and Section 2 of the Sherman Act. Two recent cases in the US clearly illustrate the meaning of invitation to collude. In Valassis Communications, 1 the FTC challenged the announcement made by Valassis president and chief executive officer, in a public call with analysts, detailing its strategy to increase prices. In order to regain market shares lost in the previous years to its competitor News America, Valassis decided to communicate to News America an offer to cease competing for News America customers, provided that the latter ceased competing for Valassis customers. If accepted, both firms could raise prices within their respective protected customer bases and end their price war. Valassis proposed that prices be restored by both firms to the pre-price war levels and described how business with shared customers and outstanding bids to News America s customers would be handled. Valassis would monitor News America s response, looking for concrete evidence of reciprocity in short order. If News America continued to compete for Valassis customers and market share, then the price war would resume. To resolve these allegations, Valassis entered into a consent order with the FTC that prohibits unilateral communications, both public and private, concerning the company s willingness to refrain from competing with rivals or to co-ordinate pricing with them. The FTC case against U-Haul 2 involved both private and public communications. According to the complaint, U-Haul s CEO instructed U- Haul s regional managers and dealers to reach out privately to their counterparts at Budget (U-Haul closest competitors in the market for consumer truck rental) to exhort them to match U-Haul s higher rates. A year later, U-Haul s CEO allegedly instructed managers to raise their rates, anticipating that Budget will come up. But Budget did not immediately follow. Then, during a conference call with stock analysts, in response to a question about U-Haul s pricing strategies, U-Haul s CEO explained that U- Haul was trying to show price leadership for the good of the entire industry. He said that U-Haul was attempting to indicate to competitors that they should not throw the money away, and that they should [p]rice at cost at least. The CEO then indicated that he had instructed U-Haul managers to wait a while longer for Budget to respond and that he was optimistic that Budget would respond by raising prices. He also added that 1 2 Valassis Communications, 2006, FTC File No Matter of U-Haul Int l, Inc and AMERCO, 2010, FTC File No

8 Budget need not match the U-Haul prices exactly, but could lag behind by 3 5 percent. MANDATORY DISCLOSURES OF INFORMATION In many jurisdictions information disclosure is mandated by laws or sector regulations. This is the case of securities rules and regulations, under which public companies are required to disclose regularly vast amounts of corporate and financial information. In addition to complying with regulatory requirements, private and public firms are strongly encouraged to provide additional information to stakeholders and potential investors. This is particularly the case after the announcement of quarterly results, when executives are often subject to detailed questions by financial analysts seeking to determine the future outlook of the company. Unilateral communication of company information therefore happens both regularly and legitimately, and to a large extent produces the beneficial effects of transparency described above. Nevertheless, these forms of communication might expose the company to antirust liability in light of the risk of collusion that they may create. As the context of the communication is so determinative of its legitimacy, per se rules are less helpful in this respect. Despite this need for case-by-case analysis, given the large amounts of legitimate, and in some cases required, information that firms disclose to the general public, it would be useful for enforcers to provide guidelines and safe harbours that would allow companies to steer clear of infringing competition laws. In principal, these guidelines should take into account the modern demand on firms to provide information to the public and investors as well as the specific conditions of each industry. 8

Discussion Points. Presented by the Business and Industry Advisory Committee (BIAC) to the OECD Competition Committee

Discussion Points. Presented by the Business and Industry Advisory Committee (BIAC) to the OECD Competition Committee The Voice of OECD Business Discussion Points Presented by the Business and Industry Advisory Committee (BIAC) to the OECD Competition Committee Cartels: Approaches to Cartel Investigations * (for the OECD

More information

Price signaling. An economic perspective. Raphaël De Coninck

Price signaling. An economic perspective. Raphaël De Coninck An economic perspective 1 Overview Coordination and information Economics of coordination Potential anticompetitive effects and efficiencies of information exchanges Public announcements Invitation to

More information

Pricing algorithms: the digital collusion scenarios

Pricing algorithms: the digital collusion scenarios Pricing algorithms: the digital collusion scenarios The classic digital cartel This category serves as a reminder that price fixing cartels are illegal, irrespective of the means by which they are implemented

More information

Re: Draft Anti-Pricing Monopoly Regulation

Re: Draft Anti-Pricing Monopoly Regulation DRAFT 8/31/09 BY EMAIL xueq@ndrc.gov.cn AND FEDEX Department of Price Supervision No. 38 Yuetan Nanjie Beijing 100824 China Dear Sir/Madam: Re: Draft Anti-Pricing Monopoly Regulation The Section of International

More information

COMPETITION LAW POLICY & GUIDELINES

COMPETITION LAW POLICY & GUIDELINES COMPETITION LAW POLICY & GUIDELINES Australian Financial Markets Association www.afma.com.au COMPETITION LAW POLICY & GUIDELINES Version 2 January 2018 Australian Financial Markets Association Enquiries

More information

ANDY GAVIL: Hi. I am Andy Gavil. I m a professor of law at Howard University

ANDY GAVIL: Hi. I am Andy Gavil. I m a professor of law at Howard University ANDY GAVIL: Hi. I am Andy Gavil. I m a professor of law at Howard University School of Law in Washington, and I m here today with Michael Turner of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission to talk about proving

More information

Information exchanges and joint negotiations EU position. Keith Jones (London)

Information exchanges and joint negotiations EU position. Keith Jones (London) Information exchanges and joint negotiations EU position Keith Jones (London) Agenda Topics for Today 1. Information exchange 2. Joint negotiations 2 Both are Horizontal Co-Operation Agreements Agreements

More information

Regional Competition Center for Latin America presents: Guidelines on exchanges of information among competitors

Regional Competition Center for Latin America presents: Guidelines on exchanges of information among competitors Regional Competition Center for Latin America presents: Guidelines on exchanges of information among competitors Rosa M. Abrantes-Metz* NYU Stern School of Business 1 One of the main objectives of the

More information

PROOF OF AN AGREEMENT

PROOF OF AN AGREEMENT PROOF OF AN AGREEMENT Circumstantial Evidence Relevant to the Existence of an Agreement in Violation of Section 1 Presented by: Mark Glueck Richard Higgins Presented to: Date: July 12 th, 2012 Location:

More information

AQA Economics A-level

AQA Economics A-level AQA Economics A-level Microeconomics Topic 5: Perfect Competition, Imperfectly Competitive Markets and Monopoly 5.5 Oligopoly Notes Characteristics of an oligopoly: High barriers to entry and exit There

More information

SD ASSOCIATION ANTITRUST POLICY AND GUIDELINES

SD ASSOCIATION ANTITRUST POLICY AND GUIDELINES SD ASSOCIATION ANTITRUST POLICY AND GUIDELINES The purpose of this Antitrust Policy and Guidelines is to provide a brief overview of the antitrust and competition laws applicable to the SD Association

More information

THE ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE PROGRAMME OF THE ITALCEMENTI GROUP

THE ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE PROGRAMME OF THE ITALCEMENTI GROUP THE ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE PROGRAMME OF THE ITALCEMENTI GROUP 1 This document is intended to provide you with the presentation of the Antitrust Compliance Programme ( A.C.P. ) devised and organised, with

More information

Information Exchange and Hub and Spoke Cartels. Sean-Paul Brankin Crowell & Moring

Information Exchange and Hub and Spoke Cartels. Sean-Paul Brankin Crowell & Moring Information Exchange and Hub and Spoke Cartels Sean-Paul Brankin Crowell & Moring 19 October 2012 1 2011 Horizontal Guidance: A Step Forward 2 Where We Were It is common practice in many industries for

More information

INTERNATIONAL DIGITAL PUBLISHING FORUM ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY AND GUIDELINES

INTERNATIONAL DIGITAL PUBLISHING FORUM ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY AND GUIDELINES INTERNATIONAL DIGITAL PUBLISHING FORUM ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY AND GUIDELINES It is the policy of the International Digital Publishing Forum ("IDPF" or "the Forum") to comply with all antitrust and

More information

GUIDE TO COMPETITION LAW FEBRUARY 2014

GUIDE TO COMPETITION LAW FEBRUARY 2014 GUIDE TO COMPETITION LAW FEBRUARY 2014 GUIDE TO COMPETITION LAW 2 TABLE OF CONTENT 1 Introduction 3 1.1 Why did SMARTRAC develop this Guide to Competition Law 3 1.2 To whom this guide applies 3 1.3 What

More information

ARAB AIR CARRIERS ORGANIZATION COMPETITION LAW COMPLIANCE

ARAB AIR CARRIERS ORGANIZATION COMPETITION LAW COMPLIANCE ARAB AIR CARRIERS ORGANIZATION COMPETITION LAW COMPLIANCE POLICY July 2012 CONTENTS PAGE MESSAGE FROM THE SECRETARY GENERAL 1 1. WHY IS COMPETITION LAW COMPLIANCE IMPORTANT? 2 2. EXCHANGING COMPETITIVELY

More information

Collusion and horizontal agreements

Collusion and horizontal agreements Collusion and horizontal agreements Main ingredients of collusion Situation where firms set prices above the competitive level, which can be obtained either by explicit or by tacit collusion. But not so

More information

Executive Summary of the Roundtable on Algorithms and Collusion Annex to the Summary Record of the 127th meeting of the Competition Committee

Executive Summary of the Roundtable on Algorithms and Collusion Annex to the Summary Record of the 127th meeting of the Competition Committee Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development DAF/COMP/M(2017)1/ANN3/FINAL DIRECTORATE FOR FINANCIAL AND ENTERPRISE AFFAIRS COMPETITION COMMITTEE English - Or. English 26 September 2018 Annex

More information

Introduction. The findings. The wider context ANTITRUST

Introduction. The findings. The wider context ANTITRUST The Energy Sector Inquiry: conclusions and way forward ( 1 ) Eleonora WÄKTARE, Kristóf KOVÁCS and Alexander GEE, Directorate-General for Competition, unit B-1 Introduction On 10 January 2007, after an

More information

Edexcel (A) Economics A-level

Edexcel (A) Economics A-level Edexcel (A) Economics A-level Theme 3: Business Behaviour & the Labour Market 3.4 Market Structures 3.4.4 Oligopoly Notes Characteristics of an oligopoly: High barriers to entry and exit There are high

More information

DESIGNING TENDERS TO REDUCE BID RIGGING. Helping governments to obtain best value for money COMPETITION THE KEY TO PRODUCTIVITY AND GROWTH

DESIGNING TENDERS TO REDUCE BID RIGGING. Helping governments to obtain best value for money COMPETITION THE KEY TO PRODUCTIVITY AND GROWTH DESIGNING TENDERS TO REDUCE BID RIGGING Helping governments to obtain best value for money COMPETITION THE KEY TO PRODUCTIVITY AND GROWTH 2 Tender design can play an important role in preventing bid-rigging,

More information

The Exchange of Commercially Sensitive Information. Some legal and economic issues

The Exchange of Commercially Sensitive Information. Some legal and economic issues The Exchange of Commercially Sensitive Information Some legal and economic issues ACLE Law & Economics Seminar 13 February 2006 Rein Wesseling 1/16/2014 4:36:36 PM Queries Detailed and specific market

More information

Competition Law360 10/8/2010

Competition Law360 10/8/2010 AVOIDING BAD MOVES LESSONS FROM U-HAUL Competition Law360 Anita Stork Cortlin Lannin 10/8/2010 This summer, the Federal Trade Commission signaled it would continue to aggressively pursue so-called invitation

More information

Chapter 15 Oligopoly

Chapter 15 Oligopoly Goldwasser AP Microeconomics Chapter 15 Oligopoly BEFORE YOU READ THE CHAPTER Summary This chapter explores oligopoly, a market structure characterized by a few firms producing a product that mayor may

More information

Antitrust Compliance Guidelines. Approved by the PODS Board of Directors April 21, 2011

Antitrust Compliance Guidelines. Approved by the PODS Board of Directors April 21, 2011 Antitrust Compliance Guidelines Approved by the PODS Board of Directors April 21, 2011 PODS Antitrust Compliance Guidelines One of the major goals of the Pipeline Open Data Standard Association (PODS)

More information

ECN 3103 INDUSTRIAL ORGANISATION

ECN 3103 INDUSTRIAL ORGANISATION ECN 3103 INDUSTRIAL ORGANISATION 6. Collusion and Cartel Policy Mr. Sydney Armstrong Lecturer 1 The University of Guyana 1 Semester 1, 2016 Introduction Definition (Collusion) Collusion is when some or

More information

PRICE FIXING, BID RIGGING, AND MARKET ALLOCATION SCHEMES: WHAT THEY ARE AND WHAT TO LOOK FOR

PRICE FIXING, BID RIGGING, AND MARKET ALLOCATION SCHEMES: WHAT THEY ARE AND WHAT TO LOOK FOR PRICE FIXING, BID RIGGING, AND MARKET ALLOCATION SCHEMES: WHAT THEY ARE AND WHAT TO LOOK FOR An Antitrust Primer This primer briefly describes the most common antitrust violations and outlines those conditions

More information

Agency Name: Superintendencia de Industria y Comercio Date:

Agency Name: Superintendencia de Industria y Comercio Date: Agency Name: Superintendencia de Industria y Comercio Date: Single-Product Loyalty Discounts and Rebates This part of the questionnaire seeks information on ICN members analysis and treatment of loyalty

More information

152ternet Collaborations Among Competitors: A Framework For Analysis

152ternet Collaborations Among Competitors: A Framework For Analysis PARTNERSHIP INCLVDING PROFESSIONAL CORPORATIONS TO OUR CLIENTS 152ternet Collaborations Among Competitors: A Framework For July 11, 2000 Much has recently been reported in the press about Internet ventures

More information

(Text with EEA relevance) (2009/C 45/02) I. INTRODUCTION

(Text with EEA relevance) (2009/C 45/02) I. INTRODUCTION Communication from the Commission Guidance on the Commission's enforcement priorities in applying Article 82 of the EC Treaty to abusive exclusionary conduct by dominant undertakings (Text with EEA relevance)

More information

Promoting Consumer Welfare By Preventing Unfair Conduct

Promoting Consumer Welfare By Preventing Unfair Conduct Promoting Consumer Welfare By Preventing Unfair Conduct Timothy T. Hughes Office of International Affairs Federal Trade Commission Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. September 23, 2010 1 Many Countries Link Competition

More information

! lecture 7:! competition and collusion!!

! lecture 7:! competition and collusion!! ! lecture 7:! competition and collusion!! the story so far Natural monopoly: Definitions (Ideal) Pricing solutions Regulation in practice Regulation under asymmetric information Competition policy: Introduction

More information

THE USE OF ECONOMIC EVIDENCE IN BID RIGGING CASES

THE USE OF ECONOMIC EVIDENCE IN BID RIGGING CASES THE USE OF ECONOMIC EVIDENCE IN BID RIGGING CASES Antonio Buttà Italian Competition Authority Public Procurement & Competition Policy 4 July 2017 The views expressed here are personal and do not necessarily

More information

Algorithms and Collusion - Summaries of Contributions

Algorithms and Collusion - Summaries of Contributions Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development DAF/COMP/WD(2017)2 16 June 2017 DIRECTORATE FOR FINANCIAL AND ENTERPRISE AFFAIRS COMPETITION COMMITTEE English - Or. English Cancels & replaces the

More information

CPI Antitrust Journal September 2010 (1)

CPI Antitrust Journal September 2010 (1) CPI Antitrust Journal September 2010 (1) Information Exchanges Among Competitors: The Commission Takes a New Look Andreas Reindl www.competitionpolicyinternational.com Competition Policy International,

More information

Roundtable on. Competition Policy and Public Procurement

Roundtable on. Competition Policy and Public Procurement Intergovernmental Group of Experts on Competition Law and Policy Geneva, 9 11 July 2012 Roundtable on Competition Policy and Public Procurement Written contribution by Lithuania The views expressed are

More information

Single-Product Loyalty Discounts and Rebates

Single-Product Loyalty Discounts and Rebates Agency Name: Turkish Competition Authority Date: 3.11.2008 Single-Product Loyalty Discounts and Rebates This part of the questionnaire seeks information on ICN members analysis and treatment of loyalty

More information

Concerted Practices and Algorithmic Coordination: Does the Proposed CP Prohibition Compute?

Concerted Practices and Algorithmic Coordination: Does the Proposed CP Prohibition Compute? Concerted Practices and Algorithmic Coordination: Does the Proposed CP Prohibition Compute? LCA Competition and Consumer Law Workshop Melbourne, 5 August 2017 ROB NICHOLLS BRENT FISSE Overview 2 Algorithmic

More information

Information Exchange and Hub & Spoke Cartels. Sean-Paul Brankin, Crowell & Moring and Edward Anderson, Sainsburys

Information Exchange and Hub & Spoke Cartels. Sean-Paul Brankin, Crowell & Moring and Edward Anderson, Sainsburys Information Exchange and Hub & Spoke Cartels Sean-Paul Brankin, Crowell & Moring and Edward Anderson, Sainsburys March 29, 2011 1 This time last year 2 A fashionable infringement Finland Grocery retailers

More information

How Antitrust Agencies Analyze M&A

How Antitrust Agencies Analyze M&A practicallaw.com PLC Corporate & Securities PLC Finance PLC Law Department CONTENTS Horizontal Mergers Market Definition Market Shares and Concentration Competitive Effects Powerful Buyers Entry Analysis

More information

On the Art 82 enforcement priorities Effects on consumer welfare

On the Art 82 enforcement priorities Effects on consumer welfare Competition Day Brno, May 13, 2009 On the Art 82 enforcement priorities Effects on consumer welfare Damien Neven, Chief Economist * DG COMP, European Commission *The views expressed are those of the authors

More information

The graphics on the cover depict the Chinese character for competition. It features two identical human forms facing each other, denoting the concept

The graphics on the cover depict the Chinese character for competition. It features two identical human forms facing each other, denoting the concept The graphics on the cover depict the Chinese character for competition. It features two identical human forms facing each other, denoting the concept of competition on a level-playing field. 01 CONTENTS

More information

Avoiding Antitrust Traps in Investor and Analyst Calls

Avoiding Antitrust Traps in Investor and Analyst Calls Avoiding Antitrust Traps in Investor and Analyst Calls June 24,2010 Richard Steuer rsteuer@mayerbrown.com (212) 506-2530 Jodi Simala jsimala@mayerbrown.com (312) 701-7920 John Roberti jroberti@mayerbrown.com

More information

Report on the Federal Trade Commission Workshop on Slotting Allowances and Other Marketing Practices in the Grocery Industry

Report on the Federal Trade Commission Workshop on Slotting Allowances and Other Marketing Practices in the Grocery Industry Report on the Federal Trade Commission Workshop on Slotting Allowances and Other Marketing Practices in the Grocery Industry A Report by Federal Trade Commission Staff February 2001 INTRODUCTION AND EXECUTIVE

More information

COLLABORATIONS WITH COMPETITORS AND ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE. Donald P. Gallo, Esq. Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren s.c. November 26, 2012

COLLABORATIONS WITH COMPETITORS AND ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE. Donald P. Gallo, Esq. Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren s.c. November 26, 2012 COLLABORATIONS WITH COMPETITORS AND ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE By Donald P. Gallo, Esq. Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren s.c. November 26, 2012 When considering a joint venture or other collaboration with a competitor,

More information

Competition Issues in Aftermarkets - Note from Italy

Competition Issues in Aftermarkets - Note from Italy Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development DAF/COMP/WD(2017)4 2 June 2017 DIRECTORATE FOR FINANCIAL AND ENTERPRISE AFFAIRS COMPETITION COMMITTEE English - Or. English 21-23 June 2017 This document

More information

INTERNATIONAL SECURITIES ASSOCIATION FOR INSTITUTIONAL TRADE COMMUNICATION ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY

INTERNATIONAL SECURITIES ASSOCIATION FOR INSTITUTIONAL TRADE COMMUNICATION ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY INTERNATIONAL SECURITIES ASSOCIATION FOR INSTITUTIONAL TRADE COMMUNICATION 1.0 Antitrust Compliance Policy ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY The policy of the International Securities Association for Institutional

More information

Gathering, handling and assessing evidence EU-China Competition Week Beijing, 14 March 2014

Gathering, handling and assessing evidence EU-China Competition Week Beijing, 14 March 2014 Gathering, handling and assessing evidence EU-China Competition Week Beijing, 14 March 2014 Johan Sahl Deputy Head of Unit, Cartels and Mergers Swedish Competition Authority The Swedish Competition Authority

More information

Lecture 11 Imperfect Competition

Lecture 11 Imperfect Competition Lecture 11 Imperfect Competition Business 5017 Managerial Economics Kam Yu Fall 2013 Outline 1 Introduction 2 Monopolistic Competition 3 Oligopoly Modelling Reality The Stackelberg Leadership Model Collusion

More information

Agency Name: Office of Competition and Consumer Protection, Poland Date: December 16, 2008 Tying & Bundled Discounting

Agency Name: Office of Competition and Consumer Protection, Poland Date: December 16, 2008 Tying & Bundled Discounting Agency Name: Office of Competition and Consumer Protection, Poland Date: December 16, 2008 Tying & Bundled Discounting This part of the questionnaire seeks information on ICN members analysis and treatment

More information

Economics of Strategy Fifth Edition. The Dynamics of Pricing Rivalry

Economics of Strategy Fifth Edition. The Dynamics of Pricing Rivalry Economics of Strategy Fifth Edition Besanko, Dranove, Shanley, and Schaefer Chapter 10 The Dynamics of Pricing Rivalry Slides by: Richard Ponarul, California State University, Chico Copyright 2010 John

More information

ICN Mergers Working Group Coordinated Effects. Adrian Proctor Economic Adviser, Mergers, OFT

ICN Mergers Working Group Coordinated Effects. Adrian Proctor Economic Adviser, Mergers, OFT ICN Mergers Working Group Coordinated Effects Adrian Proctor Economic Adviser, Mergers, OFT 1 Structure of the presentation Introduction Potential Focal points for Coordination Risk factors for all focal

More information

Response to Queensland Productivity Commission

Response to Queensland Productivity Commission Draft Report: Electricity Pricing in Queensland 11 March 2016 Stanwell Corporation Limited ABN 37 078 848 674 Issues Paper: Electricity Pricing in Queensland 1 Summary While the terms of reference for

More information

Regional Competition Center for Latin America presents Guideline on Coordinated Effects Study in Merger Cases

Regional Competition Center for Latin America presents Guideline on Coordinated Effects Study in Merger Cases Regional Competition Center for Latin America presents Guideline on Coordinated Effects Study in Merger Cases Prepared by the CRCLA With an introduction by Competition Policy International This month,

More information

China, Xiaomen,

China, Xiaomen, PROSECUTING CARTELS: THE USE OF INDIRECT AND DIRECT EVIDENCE Kamil Nejezchleb The Czech Competition Authority Cartel Department China, Xiaomen, 19. 10. 2017 OUTLINE Prosecuting cartels general introduction

More information

Comments from ACCA January 2009

Comments from ACCA January 2009 AUDIT FIRM GOVERNANCE Evidence Gathering Consultation Paper issued by the Audit Firm Governance Working Group in a project for the Financial Reporting Council Comments from ACCA January 2009 ACCA (the

More information

WHAT EVERY BUSINESS SHOULD KNOW ABOUT PRICE DISCRIMINATION

WHAT EVERY BUSINESS SHOULD KNOW ABOUT PRICE DISCRIMINATION KEELEY, KUENN & REID WHAT EVERY BUSINESS SHOULD KNOW ABOUT PRICE DISCRIMINATION Prepared by the Law Firm of KEELEY, KUENN & REID 150 North Wacker Drive, Suite 1100 Chicago, IL 60606 (312) 782-1829 FAX

More information

competition policy r Palgrave Publishers Ltd 1

competition policy r Palgrave Publishers Ltd 1 Definition Competition policy, also known as antitrust policy in the United States, is a body of legislated law designed to promote and maintain competition in markets. Abstract This article discusses

More information

FERRELLGAS ANTITRUST LAW COMPLIANCE HANDBOOK

FERRELLGAS ANTITRUST LAW COMPLIANCE HANDBOOK FERRELLGAS ANTITRUST LAW COMPLIANCE HANDBOOK To: All Ferrellgas Employees Our Company is committed to full compliance with the letter and spirit of all laws that apply to our business. We take particular

More information

If you would like to provide us with your thoughts on what ACM should focus on, please get in touch by sending an to

If you would like to provide us with your thoughts on what ACM should focus on, please get in touch by sending an  to 1/5 June 2016 Introduction The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) creates opportunities and options for businesses and consumers. By fighting against unfair competition and making it

More information

Information Exchange and Hub & Spoke Cartels

Information Exchange and Hub & Spoke Cartels Information Exchange and Hub & Spoke Cartels Sean-Paul Brankin Crowell & Moring 25 March 2010 1 A fashionable infringement Finland Grocery retailers (2008) France Palais Parisiens (2006) Germany Drugstore

More information

Edexcel (B) Economics A-level

Edexcel (B) Economics A-level Edexcel (B) Economics A-level Theme 4: Making Markets Work 4.2 Market Power and Market Failure 4.2.1 Market failure Notes Significance of market power: o Cartels, collusion, restrictive practices and tacit

More information

THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE GUIDELINES

THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE GUIDELINES THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE GUIDELINES Introduction The American Institute of Architects and its members are committed to full compliance with all laws and regulations, and

More information

Antitrust Compliance Procedures

Antitrust Compliance Procedures Antitrust Compliance Procedures Adopted by the Northeast Gas Association Board of Directors June 4, 2003 Objective The Northeast Gas Association (NGA) and its member companies are committed to full compliance

More information

ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE GUIDELINES

ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE GUIDELINES ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE GUIDELINES I. POLICY It is the policy of the SMART CARD ALLIANCE to comply fully with the antitrust laws applicable to trade association activities. In furtherance of this policy,

More information

DRAFT COMMISSION GUIDELINES ON THE ASSESSMENT OF NON- HORIZONTAL MERGERS

DRAFT COMMISSION GUIDELINES ON THE ASSESSMENT OF NON- HORIZONTAL MERGERS POSITION PAPER 18 May 2007 DRAFT COMMISSION GUIDELINES ON THE ASSESSMENT OF NON- HORIZONTAL MERGERS 1. INTRODUCTION In 2004 the EU Commission announced that it would issue guidelines regarding the treatment

More information

The Reform of Article 82: Reactions to the DG-Competition Discussion Paper on the Application of Article 82 of the Treaty to Exclusionary Abuses

The Reform of Article 82: Reactions to the DG-Competition Discussion Paper on the Application of Article 82 of the Treaty to Exclusionary Abuses The Reform of Article 82: Reactions to the DG-Competition Discussion Paper on the Application of Article 82 of the Treaty to Exclusionary Abuses - prepared by the Competition Law Forum s Article 82 Review

More information

Edexcel Economics A-level

Edexcel Economics A-level Edexcel Economics A-level Unit 3: Business Behaviour Topic 3: Market Structures and Contestability 3.3 Oligopoly Notes Characteristics of an oligopoly: High barriers to entry and exit There are high barriers

More information

1. Purpose. This policy provides Employees with guidance on behaviours or actions that may be noncompliant with anti-trust or anti-competition laws.

1. Purpose. This policy provides Employees with guidance on behaviours or actions that may be noncompliant with anti-trust or anti-competition laws. Section: pg. 2 1. Purpose AET is committed to conducting our business with honesty and integrity. It is AET s policy to comply with all laws governing AET s global business operations and activities including

More information

THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE STATEMENT AND PROCEDURES

THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE STATEMENT AND PROCEDURES THE AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE STATEMENT AND PROCEDURES September 2002 The American Institute of Architects 1735 New York Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20006 AIA Info Central (800)

More information

Chapter 7 Market Structures

Chapter 7 Market Structures Chapter 7 Market Structures Section 1 Competition 2 Perfect Competition Perfect competition is when a large number of buyers and sellers exchange identical products under five conditions. There should

More information

Economic Fundamentals:

Economic Fundamentals: Economic Fundamentals: Vertical and Coordinated Effects in Mergers Debra J. Aron, Ph.D. Navigant Economics Northwestern University May 27, 2016 Disclaimer This presentation covers only a sampling of the

More information

Noncooperative Collusion

Noncooperative Collusion Noncooperative Collusion The Cournot Oligopoly model was a single-period noncooperative model. In most models of imperfect competition, it is true that if firms independently try to maximize their short-term

More information

A Rational Approach towards Abuse of Collective Market. Dominance in Antitrust Law. Zhan Hao, Song Ying &Tian Chen

A Rational Approach towards Abuse of Collective Market. Dominance in Antitrust Law. Zhan Hao, Song Ying &Tian Chen A Rational Approach towards Abuse of Collective Market Dominance in Antitrust Law Zhan Hao, Song Ying &Tian Chen 1. Introduction The concept of abuse of collective market dominance ( Collective Abuse )stems

More information

Group Code of Ethics

Group Code of Ethics Updated July 2016 Group Code of Ethics Introduction Eurofins' mission, vision and values set out the conditions for our long-term success and are a core part of the way we expect employees of the companies

More information

CEMEX. Global Antitrust Compliance Policy

CEMEX. Global Antitrust Compliance Policy CEMEX Global Antitrust Compliance Policy We at CEMEX have a long-standing commitment to ethics and integrity, which allows us to conduct our business in a fair and transparent manner. All business strategies

More information

September Introduction

September Introduction MAS Enhances Corporate Governance For Banks And Insurers Introduction...1 Regulations...1 On 8, the Monetary Authority of Singapore ( MAS ) issued two sets of regulations on corporate governance. These

More information

ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY

ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY ANTITRUST COMPLIANCE POLICY 1 Objective: Antitrust or competition laws are designed to preserve and foster fair and honest competition in the marketplace. 2 Applicability/Scope: All Team Schein Members

More information

Gates Industrial Corporation plc Global Antitrust and Fair Competition Principles

Gates Industrial Corporation plc Global Antitrust and Fair Competition Principles Gates Industrial Corporation plc Global Antitrust and Fair Competition Principles August 2017 Dear Colleagues, As a leading global manufacturer, Gates business activities are subject to a variety of statutory

More information

Collusion. Sotiris Georganas. February Sotiris Georganas () Collusion February / 31

Collusion. Sotiris Georganas. February Sotiris Georganas () Collusion February / 31 Collusion Sotiris Georganas February 2012 Sotiris Georganas () Collusion February 2012 1 / 31 Outline 1 Cartels 2 The incentive for cartel formation The scope for collusion in the Cournot model 3 Game

More information

Avoiding the Big Cs in Meetings with Competitors: From Cartels to Comparisons

Avoiding the Big Cs in Meetings with Competitors: From Cartels to Comparisons Avoiding the Big Cs in Meetings with Competitors: From Cartels to Comparisons Chris Compton Registrar Summit June 5, 2008 Meetings of Competitors: Occasions of Sin The legal environment: cartel enforcement

More information

Connecting public procurement and competition policies: the challenge of implementation

Connecting public procurement and competition policies: the challenge of implementation Connecting public procurement and competition policies: the challenge of implementation Graciela Miralles Senior Economist Competition Policy Team WBG Trade and Competitiveness Global Practice Rome July

More information

Market Survival Market Structure Simulation

Market Survival Market Structure Simulation Market Survival Market Structure Simulation The Profit Maximization Assumption: This is the assumption in business and economics that firms are motivated to maximize profit. Step #1: Distribution of Roles

More information

AAOE Anti-Trust Policy

AAOE Anti-Trust Policy 2016 AAOE Anti-Trust Policy WHY DISCUSSIONS OF PRICE/COST ARE NOT PERMITTED ON THE LISTSERVES OR DURING AAOE SPONSORED ACTIVITIES AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF ORTHOPAEDIC EXECUTIVES 6602 East 75th Street, Suite

More information

COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION. Notice. Guidelines on the application of Article 81(3) of the Treaty (2004/C 101/08)

COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION. Notice. Guidelines on the application of Article 81(3) of the Treaty (2004/C 101/08) 27.4.2004 Official Journal of the European Union C 101/97 COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION Notice Guidelines on the application of Article 81(3) of the Treaty (2004/C 101/08) (Text with EEA relevance)

More information

Prohibition of the abuse of a dominant position

Prohibition of the abuse of a dominant position Mrs Blanca Rodriguez Galindo Head of the International Relations Unit Directorate-General for Competition European Commission Prohibition of the abuse of a dominant position The International Symposium

More information

Antitrust and You: Antitrust Compliance Procedures

Antitrust and You: Antitrust Compliance Procedures Antitrust and You: Antitrust Compliance Procedures Objective The American Gas Association (AGA) and its member companies are committed to full compliance with all laws and regulations, and to maintaining

More information

BUSINESS COMPLIANCE WITH COMPETITION RULES

BUSINESS COMPLIANCE WITH COMPETITION RULES 28 November 2011 BUSINESS COMPLIANCE WITH COMPETITION RULES KEY MESSAGES 1 2 3 Competition provides the best incentive for efficiency, encourages innovation and guarantees consumers the best choice for

More information

Joven Liew Jia Wen Industrial Economics I Notes. What is competition?

Joven Liew Jia Wen Industrial Economics I Notes. What is competition? Industrial Economics I Notes What is competition? Competition in markets is generally considered a good thing (welfare economics) Competition authorities look at whether change in market structure or firm

More information

Jet-Kingfisher Merger Competition Issues

Jet-Kingfisher Merger Competition Issues A-380 Jet-Kingfisher Merger Competition Issues Comdt. (Retd.) M.M. Sharma * Blatant or sensational promotion associated with Jet-Kingfisher merger has left market with innumerable doubts be it be the stakeholders

More information

OFT issues guidance on competition law and its application to public bodies

OFT issues guidance on competition law and its application to public bodies Briefing 12/10 March 2012 OFT issues guidance on competition law and its application to public bodies To: All contacts in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland Key issues Guidance on competition

More information

Doing Deals: Avoiding Antitrust Pitfalls During Due Diligence and Transition Planning

Doing Deals: Avoiding Antitrust Pitfalls During Due Diligence and Transition Planning Doing Deals: Avoiding Antitrust Pitfalls During Due Diligence and Transition Planning 5 When competitors start considering a merger, they should involve their antitrust counsel from the beginning. Managing

More information

micro2 first module Competition in prices Bertrand competition (1883) Bertrand equilibrium Paradox resolutions The Bertrand paradox Oligopoly part IIΙ

micro2 first module Competition in prices Bertrand competition (1883) Bertrand equilibrium Paradox resolutions The Bertrand paradox Oligopoly part IIΙ Kosmas Marinakis, Ph.D. Competition in prices Oligopoly Lecture 11 Oligopoly part IIΙ micro2 first module Previously we assumed that competition was in quantities and were the choice variables for each

More information

Basic Economics Chapter 17

Basic Economics Chapter 17 1 Basic Economics Chapter 17 Oligopoly Oligopoly: (1) only a few sellers (2) offer similar or identical products (3) interdependent Game theory (how people behave in strategic situations): (1) choose among

More information

Competition Law. Information exchanges between competitors: the Italian Competition Authority s recent practice

Competition Law. Information exchanges between competitors: the Italian Competition Authority s recent practice Competition Law Antitrust law and policy in a global marketinsight Information exchanges between competitors: the Italian Competition Authority s recent practice By Antonio Capobianco and Stefano Fratta

More information

Managerial Economics Prof. Trupti Mishra S.J.M School of Management Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay. Lecture - 33 Oligopoly (Contd )

Managerial Economics Prof. Trupti Mishra S.J.M School of Management Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay. Lecture - 33 Oligopoly (Contd ) Managerial Economics Prof. Trupti Mishra S.J.M School of Management Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay Lecture - 33 Oligopoly (Contd ) We will continue our discussion on theory of Oligopoly, typically

More information

Concurring Statement of Commissioner Joshua D. Wright In the Matter of Ferrellgas Partners, L.P. Docket No FTC File No.

Concurring Statement of Commissioner Joshua D. Wright In the Matter of Ferrellgas Partners, L.P. Docket No FTC File No. Concurring Statement of Commissioner Joshua D. Wright In the Matter of Ferrellgas Partners, L.P. Docket No. 9360 FTC File No. 111 0195 October 31, 2014 The Commission has voted to accept proposed Consent

More information

First impressions on the Revised US and UK Merger Guidelines

First impressions on the Revised US and UK Merger Guidelines GRC Conference, 29th September, Brussels First impressions on the Revised US and UK Merger Guidelines Damien Neven* Chief Competition Economist DG COMP, European Commission *The views expressed are my

More information

Market Structures. Perfect competition Monopolistic Competition Oligopoly Monopoly

Market Structures. Perfect competition Monopolistic Competition Oligopoly Monopoly Market Structures The classification of market structures can be arranged along a continuum, ranging from perfect competition, the most competitive market, to monopoly, the lease competitive: Perfect competition

More information

THE EU MERGER REGULATION: SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES

THE EU MERGER REGULATION: SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES THE EU MERGER REGULATION: SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES FOURTH EDITION By ALISTAIR LINDSAY Barrister, Monckton Chambers ALISON BERRIDGE Barrister, Monckton Chambers MAXWELL THOMSON REUTERS PAGE Preface v Dedication

More information