Best Practices for the Use of International Standards in Vaccine Testing Dianna Wilkinson

Transcription

1 Best Practices for the Use of International Standards in Vaccine Testing Dianna Wilkinson DCVMN Regional Training Workshop Hyderabad, May, 2018

2 Biologicals substances which cannot be fully characterized by physicochemical means alone, and which therefore require the use of some form of bioassay The includes, but is not restricted to proteins, antigens, vaccines, antisera, blood products and nucleic acids. 2

3 Biological Complex composition Requires biological or immunological assay for characterization. The assays are usually comparative rather than absolute A reference standard is critical in defining the qualitative nature or relative magnitude of the biological or immunological response 3

4 WHO Biological Reference Standards classed as biological Developed to enable the results of biological assay or immunological assays to be expressed in the same way throughout the world i.e. Global Assay harmonisation 4

5 WHO Nomenclature for Biological References International Standard (IS) International Reference Reagent (IRR) Secondary Standard or other Reference Material 5

6 WHO International Standard (IS) Highest order of reference for biological materials and medicines Project initiation is endorsed by WHO ECBS Quantifies relative potency in a specific but arbitrarily defined International Unit (IU) Allows direct comparison between different assays and methodologies Controls all steps of the assay, ideally Behaves in similar way to the clinical or biological material under test 6

7 WHO International Standard (IS) Freeze-dried for long-term stability and shipment at ambient temperature 7

8 Number of Laboratories WHO International Standards Example of assay harmonisation over time 1 st HCV RNA NAT study (copies/ml) th HCV RNA NAT study (IU/ml) Log 10 3 Log a b 17b a Log10 IU/ml Quantitative Assays Qualitative Assays 8 Example courtesy of Clare Morris, Virology NIBSC

9 WHO International Standards & Assays Can Evolve Example Based on subtype B virus 9 Example courtesy of Clare Morris, Virology NIBSC

10 WHO International Reference Reagent (IRR) WHO biological reference standard, the activity of which is defined by WHO in terms of a unit This category of reference standard is intended to be interim and replacement of the reference reagents may not envisaged. May not fully meet the requirements to become an IS, but serves to be useful in assay standardisation and control 10

11 WHO International Reference Reagent (IRR) IRR Examples Anti-HPV 16 was initially established by ECBS as an IRR (10 units per ampoule) until additional stability studies could be performed. It was subsequently established as an IS with 10 IU per ampoule JE antibody preparation- No unitage assigned EBOV RNA IRRs - freeze-dried synthetic preparations assigned units but development needed for long-term stability anti-ebov antibody IRR limited numbers of frozen aliquots. This served as the interim standard while we continued to establish the anti-ebov antibody IS (Now in the catalogue). 11

12 Secondary Standard or other Reference Material A reference material that has been directly calibrated against the WHO International Standard and is itself assigned a unitage in IU A secondary standard may be used in the calibration of tertiary reference materials (calibration and validation of assay systems) e.g. assay calibrators, in-run controls, proficiency study samples The IU is traceable back to the International Standard and carries with it an uncertainty of measurement. 12

13 WHO Publications on the development and establishment of biological reference preparations.. 13

14 WHO Biological Reference Standards 14

15 WHO Manual for the establishment of national and other secondary standards for vaccines WHO/IVB/11.03 Planning Material selection and processing Quality aspects Calibration against current IS Statistical analysis Stability Collaborative study report and other documents Storage and stability monitoring Custodian laboratory responsibilities Labelling Instructions for use Dispatch of standards Planning for batch replacement 50B7ED58DD?sequence=1

16 WHO manual for the preparation of secondary reference materials for in vitro diagnostic assays designed for infectious disease nucleic acid or antigen detection: calibration to WHO International Standards WHO Expert Committee on Biological Standardization Sixty-seventh report Annex_6.pdf?ua=1 16

17 Calibration of Secondary Standards for HPV assays Chapter 9 aboratory_manual who_ivb_2009_2010.pdf 17

18 Calibration of Secondary Standards for Specific Vaccines 18

19 ECBS Reports for Collaborative Studies f?ua=1 19

20 ECBS Reports for Collaborative Studies 20

21 ECBS Reports for Collaborative Studies 21

22 ECBS Reports for Collaborative Studies 22

23 WHO International Standard (IS) Are quantified in International Units (IU s) assigned following a multicentre collaborative study using multiple assays Study Report presented to WHO ECBS ECBS endorses the establishment of the IS Supply should last years Intended for calibration of secondary references 23

24 24 Calibration of Secondary Standards Secondary Standards may be prepared and calibrated at the Regional level National level Multi-centre level Within a single lab Batch may be large or small, but should be large enough to avoid frequent replacement Freeze-dried, frozen liquid, liquid but should be suitably stable Should follow the principles (If not the stringent requirements) of establishing WHO reference preparations Commutable

25 Calibration of Secondary Standards A protocol should be prepared and agreed The design of the study should consider representation of all assays that will be using the 2 ndary standard repeat testing using fresh samples simultaneous testing of all materials within each assay replicates of at least one sample should be included to enable estimation of the within-assay variability Choice of diluent(s) (matrix effects) and dilution series Calibration software- e.g. Parallel line analysis. Requires statistical support 25

26 Calibration of Secondary Standards Flow chart of process (annex A WHO/IVB/11.03) Planning e.g. calculation of amount of material required based on anticipated usage; deciding on assay methods; gathering details of prospective participants Selection of source vaccine(s) (pre-fill) Characterization of source bulk vaccine(s). Performed by one or a few labs (e.g. the donor of the material) If there are multiple candidate vaccines, then each candidate should be characterised. One or more candidate vaccines may subsequently be selected for the collaborative study Processing of final container (e.g. filling vials or ampoules with known precision, freeze-drying if applicable). Multiple candidates may need to be prepared. Continued

27 Calibration of Secondary Standards Flow chart of process (annex A WHO/IVB/11.03) Continued (Pre-study) Characterization of candidate secondary standard(s) e.g. appearance and potency to ensure that the candidate(s) is/are suitable for evaluation Calibration against IS (i.e. collaborative study or validation if on a smaller scale) Statistical analysis Evaluation of estimated stability (if undertaken) Preparation of collaborative study report (or validation report if smaller scale study) Establishment as reference standard Preparation of Instructions for use and Distribution e.g. cold chain

28 Calibration of Secondary Standards Flow chart of process (annex A WHO/IVB/11.03) Continued Consideration of how the Batch will be replaced 28

29 Some Issues and Difficulties in Biological Standardisation 29

30 Issues and Difficulties Beware of the variants Example Group O (2001 study) Group O caused some concern because it could not be detected by early versions of the HIV-1 test kits. More advanced HIV tests have now been developed to detect both Group O and Group N 30 Example courtesy of Clare Morris, Virology NIBSC

31 Issues and Difficulties Beware of the variants Example HBsAg Some genotypic differences observed Importance of multiple assay representation WHO HBsAg genotype panel is available (PEI) 31

32 Issues and Difficulties Reference vaccines may be product specific e.g. HepB and HPV vaccines i.e. It may not be suitable or possible to establish an International Standard for all vaccines for a given pathogen 32

33 Issues and Difficulties Cases where there is no International Standard for a given vaccine It may be necessary to assign an other unit to the secondary standard until an IS is established. 33

34 Issues and Difficulties Commutability 34

35 Issues and Difficulties Lack of source material E.g. Rabies IgG replacement material 35

36 WHO Collaborative Study to establish the 7th IS for Rabies Vaccine 36

37 WHO Collaborative Study to establish the 7th IS for Rabies Vaccine 15 participants from 13 countries Argentina Belgium Canada France (2) Germany India (2) Mexico Russia Serbia S Africa Thailand UK USA 25 data sets returned on NIH (10), ELISA (8), SRD (6) and serology (1) assays Study samples included 6 th IS as calibrant Coded duplicates of the candidate 7 th IS Coded liquid bulk (for in in vitro assays only) 5 th IS (limited numbers were available for NIH)

38 WHO Collaborative Study to establish the 7th IS for Rabies Vaccine Data analysis is underway Draft report to be sent to participants for comments Stability study is underway Study report to be submitted to WHO ECBS in October 2018 ~10,000 ampoules have been produced

39 THANK YOU Dianna Wilkinson DCVMN Regional Training Workshop Hyderabad, May, 2018