Comparison of Conventional and Alternative Project Delivery Methods: What s in an Acronym? PNWS AWWA May, 2013
|
|
- Linette Polly Shelton
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Comparison of Conventional and Alternative Project Delivery Methods: What s in an Acronym? PNWS AWWA May, 2013
2 Outline Alternative Delivery Options Oregon and Washington Legal Context Things an Owner Should Consider
3 Outline Alternative Delivery Options Oregon and Washington Legal Context Things an Owner Should Consider
4 There are a wide range of options to delivery projects PROJECT DELIVERY MODEL SPECTRUM Design Bid - Build Construction Manager General Contractor (General Contractor Construction Manager) Design / Build Design/Build/ Operate Pipelines Pump Stations Reservoirs Treatment Plants $5 - $10 M $200 - $300 M
5 Traditional DBB Delivery is a Well Established Process Owner Operations Designer Construction Manager Contractor Subcontractor Subcontractor Subcontractor
6 The DBB process is linear with design, bidding, construction in series Project Definition Predesign Final Design Construction Startup Facility Plan Predesign Report Bidding and Award
7 Some Problems with Traditional Delivery Owner holds all risk for performance and budget Owner in the middle of all disputes Low bid can lead to contentious environment or low quality Timeline long can exceed project needs
8 GCCM or CMGC Brings Qualifications to Contractor Selection Owner Operations Designer CMGC/GCCM Subcontractor Subcontractor Subcontractor
9 Role of CMGC/GCCM Provide constructability review Provide Cost Estimating Develop Construction Packages Manage and control execution of work Bid packages or self-perform Meet budget and schedule
10 In CMGC, Contractor is selected early and a Guaranteed Maximum Price is Set Between 30-90% Design Project Definition Predesign Final Design Construction Startup CMGC Selection GMP Development Cost of work (open book) Agreed-upon contingency Competitively developed margin
11 Construction Packages are Competitively Bid and Constructed Project Definition Predesign Final Design Construction Startup Subcontractor Subcontractor Subcontractor Option to self-perform
12 Final Cost > GMP: Pain Share Final Cost < GMP: Gain Share Project Definition Predesign Final Design Construction Startup Final Cost
13 Why is CMGC Utilized? Most like traditional DBB Construction input into design process Earlier assurance of cost depending on structure Contractor not selected on low-bid Easier to attract bidders
14 Typical Shortcomings of CMGC Approach Owner still in the middle between engineer and contractor Final contractor pricing can still often has sticker shock despite involvement
15 Design Build Integrates Engineering and Construction Design Build Owner Operations Design Builder Subcontractor Subcontractor Subcontractor
16 Why is Design/Build Typically Utilized? Owner gets out of the middle of designer and contractor One entity guaranties price, schedule, quality, performance Cost savings less construction administration shorter overall schedule
17 DBO Adds Operations to Single- Point Responsibility Design Build - Operate Owner Design/ Build/ Operator Long-term warranty of performance Adds operations into integrated team Fixes long-term costs in addition to DB price, schedule, quality and performance guarantees Subcontractor Operator Subcontractor Subcontractor
18 Why is DBO Typically Utilized? Owner wants long-term life-cycle costs to be basis of decision making Risk for long-term performance shifted to DBO operator Long-term operating costs fixed
19 Multiple variations on the DB/DBO theme tailors procurement to client needs Lump Sum / bid 2 Step / Phased / GMP / Progressive
20 In Lump Sum DB/DBO, Price is Set at Time of Selection Project Definition Predesign Final Design Construction Startup Bid Price Allowances often used for undefined areas in bid
21 Performance or Prescriptive Lump Sum DB/DBO depending on amount of Owner-specified design Project Definition Predesign Final Design Construction Startup Performance Based Prescriptive
22 In Phased DB/DBO, Design is Progressed Before Price is Set Project Definition Predesign Final Design Construction Startup Selection Price
23 Progressive DB is Like CMGC with same Designer & Contractor Select Design Build Firm design construct start-up Preliminary Design process selection hydraulics pipe routing site constraints land acquisition Design Development 30% to 60% permitting quality definition constructability review operations input and lifecycle costing design progression Develop & Negotiate GMP prequalify subs finalize vendor selection develop bid packages GMP Design Completion permits & other approvals finish design construction mobilization & staging finalize bid packages Construction solicit bids manage construction compliance with specifications project controls project reviews commissioning & start-up
24 Agenda Brief Introduction to CH2M HILL Alternative Delivery Options Oregon and Washington Legal Context Things an Owner Should Consider
25 All forms of Alternative Delivery in Oregon are done as Exemption to Public Works Bidding Applicable rules in ORS 279C Must be unlikely to encourage favoritism or substantially diminish competition Must result in substantial cost savings
26 Three Steps are Required in Oregon to Utilize Alternative Delivery Prepare findings report to justify alternative delivery Hold a public hearing Prepare report after project is complete Compare actual to estimated costs Successes and failures Objective assessment of results compared to findings
27 Findings Must Provide Justification for Decision to Use Alternative Delivery Operation, budget, financial data Public benefits Value engineering Specialized expertise required Public safety Market conditions Technical complexity Funding sources
28 Selection Process in Oregon for Alternative Delivery is Unconstrained Any desired procedure (qualifications, value, price) Consistent with local procurement policies
29 Two Types of Authority for Alternative Delivery in Washington RCW Service Agreements for Water Pollution Control Facilities RCW Alternative Delivery Procedure under Public Contracting
30 Service Agreements for WPCF s (RCW ) Applicable only to water pollution control facilities Applicable to one or more of: Design, construct, operate, finance, maintain, own
31 RCW Administrative Requirements Formal selection process with evaluation criteria Department of Ecology review of final service agreement for compliance with certain other RCW s Public notice and hearing Finding that it is in public interest to enter into agreement
32 RCW Authority: Sunsets 2013 Under Legislative Review!!! The Capital Projects Advisory Review Board (CPARB) established the Project Review Committee (PRC) to oversee alternative delivery PRC grants permission: project specific approval 3 year approval for any project that meets criteria Application must show that agency has experience and qualifications to carry out the alternative delivery contracting
33 Alternative Public Contracting Not Restricted to WPCF Under RCW Design-build for projects greater than $10,000,000, AND design-build critical to construction or technology methodology; OR design is repetitive or incidental to construction, OR operator involvement not critical during design
34 Alternative Public Contracting Not Restricted to WPCF Under RCW GC/CM for any size project where complex scheduling, phasing or coordination, OR occupied facility that must continue operations during construction, OR construction input during design critical to success, OR complex or technical work environment, OR historical structure
35 DB Selection under RCW Formal selection process with criteria Can be either best value or lowest price of responsive qualified bidders Honorarium required for losing bidders
36 GC/CM Selection Under RCW Formal process with evaluation criteria Negotiations with highest ranked respondent
37 Restrictions are Imposed by RCW for GC/CM Execution Self-performance restricted to 30% of job, must be competitively bid, and work normally done by contractor Subcontracts must be competitively bid Maximum Allowable Construction Cost (MACC) set after 90% design documents
38 Agenda Oregon and Washington Legal Context Alternative Delivery Options Things an Owner Should Consider
39 What Issues Do Clients Typically Consider When Evaluating Delivery Models? Issues: Schedule How can the procurement process be varied if schedule is critical? Selection Criteria What criteria are important to success? What s the best indicator of future performance? Design Effort How much pre-design is required to ensure you get what you want (versus performance specifications)? Price How do you evaluate proposals beyond price? Does low price always win? Scope What elements of the projects should be DB versus traditional delivery? Design Approvals How much oversight of design should you have? Risk Sharing How are risks best shared? Quality How do you ensure quality? Control/Risk Sharing Cost Time Complexity
40 The Project Delivery Spectrum Owner Comfort Zones Owner maintains most control and keeps most of the risk result : owner gets prescribed project? DB/O firm assumes some control and shares proportionate risk result : owner gets defined performance Owner s Control/Risk Sharing DB/O Firm s (traditional) (Alternative)
41 The Design-Build Spectrum Owner Comfort Zones Typical 5-year project involves multiple, discrete steps result : predictability, traditional engineering? The same 5 year project might take 2 or 3 years involving parallel activities result : team approach, joint responsibility, less time Owner s Slower Control/Risk Sharing Time DB/O Firm s Faster (traditional) (alternative)
42 The Project Delivery Spectrum Owner Comfort Zones Fixed design fees and low-bid contracting result : change order potential, potentially lower first price? Single project price, often in combination with performance guarantee result : no change orders, predictable price Owner s Slower Price Only Control/Risk Sharing Time Cost DB/O Firm s Faster Best Value (traditional) (alternative)
43 The Project Delivery Spectrum Owner Comfort Zones Relatively straightforward projects result : known approaches and solutions, little opportunity for improvement? Complex projects with technical challenges result : innovation varying approaches; out-of-box thinking Owner s Slower Control/Risk Sharing Time DB/O Firm s Faster Price Only Standard Approach (traditional) Cost Complexity (alternative) Best Value Innovation
44 The Project Delivery Spectrum Owner Comfort Zones The project delivery for this profile...? will be different than for this profile Owner s Slower Control/Risk Sharing Time DB/O Firm s Faster Price Only Standard Approach (traditional) Cost Complexity (alternative) Best Value Innovation
45 Whatever delivery option is best for an owner, it can be delivered! PROJECT DELIVERY MODEL SPECTRUM Design Bid - Build CMGC GCCM Design / Build Design/Build/ Operate Pipelines Pump Stations Reservoirs Treatment Plants $5 - $10 M $200 - $300 M
Seattle Public Schools Office of Internal Audit. Internal Audit Report Construction Management Practices
Seattle Public Schools Office of Internal Audit Issue Date: December 5, 2017 Introduction and Background In accordance with the fiscal year 2018 capital audit plan, we have completed an audit of the district
More informationProgressive Design Build
Progressive Design Build July 19, 2018 Ash Dhingra P.E.,S.E TRADITIONAL PROCUREMENT Design-Bid-Build (DBB) Design to 100%, procurement (bid), and construction proceed sequentially Construction contract
More informationTime to Build! What to Expect On Your Upcoming Design and Construction Journey PRESENTED TO
Time to Build! What to Expect On Your Upcoming and Journey PRESENTED TO Christopher is an award-winning architect with more than 20 years of diversified architectural experience in design of projects from
More informationAPPENDIX D Forms for Analytical Delivery Decision Approach (Tier 1)
APPENDIX D Forms for Analytical Delivery Decision Approach (Tier 1) The first tier in the systematic approach developed in this guidebook is the Analytical Delivery Decision Approach discussed in Chapter
More informationProject Delivery Selection Matrix If the Project Delivery Approach Fits, Use It
Project Delivery Selection Matrix If the Project Delivery Approach Fits, Use It Jim Mallorey, P.E. Metro Wastewater Reclamation District Chris Harper - University of Colorado Boulder January 23, 2014 1
More informationLessons Learned from Walla Walla: Eastern WA s Largest GC/CM Water Project
Lessons Learned from Walla Walla: Eastern WA s Largest GC/CM Water Project Pierre Kwan, PE HDR Frank Nicholson, PE City of Walla Walla Amy Jenne Apollo, Inc. 2017 PNWS-AWWA Conference Background GC/CM
More informationEXHIBIT A. 1) General:
1) General: EXHIBIT A FINDINGS OF FACT FOR EXEMPTION FROM COMPETITIVE BIDDING AND USE OF THE CONSTRUCTION MANAGER/GENERAL CONTRACTOR (CM/GC) METHOD OF CONTRACTING FOR TILLAMOOK PUD OPERATIONS CENTER AND
More informationSCADA System Procurement Alternatives
SCADA System Procurement Alternatives 2017 Automation Committee Seminar August 24, 2017 Terry M. Draper, PE, PMP Discussion Topics SCADA Overview System Hardware / Software Procurement Additional System
More informationRisks Associated with Alternative Delivery Methods. Managing Expectations. Presented by Dan Becker, CCM, PMP, CCE
Risks Associated with Alternative Delivery Methods Managing Expectations Presented by Dan Becker, CCM, PMP, CCE 1 3 Primary Methods for Delivering Projects in WA and OR Design/Bid/Build Design/Build CM
More informationWATERTOWN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS SCHOOL BUILDING COMMITTEE MEETING: OCTOBER 3, 2018
SCHOOL BUILDING COMMITTEE MEETING: OCTOBER 3, 2018 Types of Public Construction Delivery Methods Available: Design-Bid-Build (DBB) under M.G.L Ch. 149 Overview Pros Cons Construction Management at Risk
More informationSecuring & Implementing Legislative Authority for Alternative Delivery of Projects at Sound Transit
Securing & Implementing Legislative Authority for Alternative Delivery of Projects at Sound Transit Chad Brown Sound Transit Construction Manager Seattle, WA Howard Hillinger Parametrix, Inc. Principal
More informationPartnering for Alternative Delivery Projects
Partnering for Alternative Delivery Projects Presented by: Renee L. Hoekstra, CVS Managing Partner RHA, LLC Julie Kliewer, PhD, P.E. State Construction & Materials Engineer - ADOT Training Objectives Understanding
More informationPublic Building Commission of Chicago Terms and Tools for Public Capital Development and Financing
Project Delivery Methods January 30, 2012 Public Building Commission of Chicago Terms and Tools for Public Capital Development and Financing Terms Capital Project Capital Program Prioritized Capital Plan
More informationAPPENDIX D Forms for the Analytical Delivery Decision Approach (Tier 1)
APPENDIX D Forms for the Analytical Delivery Decision Approach (Tier 1) The first tier in the systematic approach developed in this guidebook is the Analytical Delivery Decision Approach discussed in Chapter
More informationDesign Process 101. Michael Barnard, AIA, NCARB. animalsheltering.org/expo #AnimalCareExpo. Copyright
Design Process 101 Michael Barnard, AIA, NCARB animalsheltering.org/expo #AnimalCareExpo Copyright 1 Design and Construction Process Needs Assessment Conceptual Design Schematic Design Design Development
More informationEVOLUTION OF DESIGN BUILD IN THE W/WW INDUSTRY
EVOLUTION OF DESIGN BUILD IN THE W/WW INDUSTRY Thomas O. Crowley, P.E. Carollo Engineers Southwest Section AWWA October 17, 2017 Agenda Project Delivery Overview Oklahoma Legislation Project Delivery Methods
More informationProject Delivery Systems
Project Delivery Systems National Society of Professional Engineers Alaska Society of Professional Engineers 2011 Western and Pacific Region Annual Meeting and Conference Jeffrey Callahan April 1, 2011
More informationPhase 1B Report on Water Treatment Plant Improvements Project Delivery Options
56 Exchange Terrace, Fourth Floor Providence, Rhode Island 02903 tel: 401 751-5360 fax: 401 751-5499 October 31, 2008 Ms. Julia A. Forgue, P.E. Director City of Newport Department of Utilities 70 Halsey
More informationProgressive Design-Build Discussion
Presentation for: Progressive Discussion February 4, 2011 1 Project Delivery Options Design-Bid-Build Construction Management at Risk Lump Sum Progressive DESIGNER BUILDER DESIGNER CM TRADITIONAL DELIVERY
More informationChapter 4 State Requirements for Educational Facilities Section 4.1
providential cause, other impending danger to life safety, or pursuant to Section 1013.46(1)(b), F.S., the board can declare an emergency, can negotiate a contract with a design-build firm, design professional,
More informationPROFESSIONAL PRACTICE 544
PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE 544 April 20, 2015 Contracting Methods Alternative Project Delivery Methods Michael J. Hanahan, Esq. Schiff Hardin LLP 233 S. Wacker, Ste. 6600 Chicago, IL 60606 312-258-5701 mhanahan@schiffhardin.com
More information1/4/2014. Alternative Project Delivery Methods 1. Agenda
Steven. C. Thweatt Assistant Vice Chancellor Facilities Management University of Colorado @ Boulder Steven.thweatt@colorado.edu Introduction Fun in the air More Fun in Chattanooga Licensed Architect Georgia
More informationDesign-Build (DB) and Construction Manager / General Contractor (CMGC)
Design-Build (DB) and Construction Manager / General Contractor (CMGC) IDOT and Industry Preliminary Joint Review for Proposed Legislation December 18, 2012 Welcome Introductions Agenda Purpose Definitions
More informationAdditional information summarizing the alternatives and development of this recommendation by staff is attached.
Date: July 5, 206 To: Public Works Commission From: John Tensen Subject: Lander Street Contract Delivery Strategy Issue Public Works Commission recommendation for approval to proceed with a Construction
More informationAlternate Project Delivery Experience at UOSA and PWCSA
Alternate Project Delivery Experience at UOSA and PWCSA Bob Angelotti, Director of Technical Services at UOSA Samer Beidas, Director of Engineering and Planning at PWCSA Presented at the VWEA 2015 Education
More informationCommittee Meeting. Procurement Processes for Professional Services and Contractors
Citizen s i Oversight Committee Meeting Procurement Processes for Professional Services and Contractors March 2, 2011 1 Procurement Process for Professional Services 2 Procurement Process for Professional
More informationTampa Bay Water is a wholesale water
FWRJ Utilizing The Engineer-Procure-Construction Management Procurement Process To Get A Bang Without Going Bust Suzannah Folsom, Jonathan Kennedy, Jerry Russell, and Eric Peters Tampa Bay Water is a wholesale
More informationProfessional Practice 544
Spring Semester 2017 Professional Practice 544 Michael J. Hanahan Partner Schiff Hardin LLP 233 S. Wacker, Ste. 6600 Chicago, IL 60606 312-258-5701 mhanahan@schiffhardin.com Schiff Hardin LLP. All rights
More information45. Feedlot construction delivery
Client Des i gn/ Builder Design Consultant Construction Sub-contractors and suppliers FEEDLOT DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION 45. Feedlot construction delivery AUTHORS: Rod Davis and Ross Stafford Introduction
More informationA Primer Indianapolis, Indiana June 16, 2010
Alternative Project Delivery Methods A Primer Indianapolis, Indiana June 16, 2010 Michael Kenig, Holder Construction Company, Past chair of AGC of America s s Project Delivery Committee Jayne O Donnell,
More informationProfessional Practice 544
Spring Semester 2018 Professional Practice 544 Michael J. Hanahan Partner Schiff Hardin LLP 233 S. Wacker, Ste. 6600 Chicago, IL 60606 312-258-5701 mhanahan@schiffhardin.com Schiff Hardin LLP. All rights
More informationTHE MUNICIPAL WATER AND WASTEWATER DESIGN-BUILD HANDBOOK. Third Edition Expanded to Include Design-Build-Operate
THE MUNICIPAL WATER AND WASTEWATER DESIGN-BUILD HANDBOOK Third Edition Expanded to Include Design-Build-Operate ABOUT THE WATER DESIGN-BUILD COUNCIL The Water Design-Build Council seeks to advance the
More informationALTERNATIVE CONTRACTING METHODS
ALTERNATIVE CONTRACTING METHODS Conventional Design-Bid-Build Design/Build Negotiated General Contractor By Jeff Warner, AIA, LEED AP Principal, ALSC Architects CONVENTIONAL DESIGN-BID-BUILD The most traditional
More informationFACILITY PROJECT BIDDING OPTIONS OVERVIEW
FACILITY PROJECT BIDDING OPTIONS OVERVIEW A Presentation to the Board of Education Galt Joint Union High School District February 14, 2017 January 10, 2017 GHSD Measure E Bidding Options Overview 2 Overview
More informationLease-Leaseback Project Delivery Method
Lease-Leaseback Project Delivery Method ASBA Technical Meeting & Tradeshow Winter 2013 Presented by: Mark Baginski Principal Verde Design, Inc. James Moore V.P. of Pre-Construction Services Robert A. Bothman,
More informationRESOLUTION NO. A RESOLUTION EXEMPTING THE DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION OF WTP , VINE
RESOLUTION NO. 6583 A RESOLUTION EXEMPTING THE DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION OF WTP- 17-02, VINE STREET WATER TREATMENT PLANT ( WTP) IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT FROM THE COMPETITIVE BIDDING PROCESS AND APPROVING AN
More informationIs Your District Ready For the New Law?
Is Your District Ready For the New Law? Ben Pintabona Operations Manager Scaparotti Construction Group Craig Weise Construction Reform Program Director Ohio School Facilities Commission Sylvia Gillis,
More informationDesign/Build Institute of America Rocky Mountain Region Water/Wastewater Committee. Project Delivery Selection Approach
Design/Build Institute of America Rocky Mountain Region Water/Wastewater Committee Project Delivery Selection Approach Overview This document provides an approach for water and wastewater project delivery
More informationAlternative Project Delivery Methods and Procurement
Alternative Project Delivery Methods and Procurement Board of Airport Commissioners Meeting 2 June 2014 Presented by: Roger A. Johnson, Deputy Executive Director Definitions Project Delivery Method o The
More informationDesign-Build Data Sourcebook
Design-Build Data Sourcebook What Is Design-Build? It s the fastest growing, most cost and time efficient method used to deliver construction projects in America. Design-build saves time and money by encouraging
More informationAlternative Delivery for Municipal Water & Wastewater Projects in 2012
Alternative Delivery for Municipal Water & Wastewater Projects in 2012 a OWEA 2012 Making a Pass at Going Green Looking Towards the Future June 20, 2012 Dennis Tinkler, P.E. Agenda Ohio s Methods of Performing
More informationConstruction Manager at Risk Delivery Method
County of Alameda Board of Supervisors Transportation and Planning Committee May 4, 2015 Caroline Judy, Acting Director Construction Manager at Risk Delivery Method Briefing and Discussion Purpose Briefing
More informationChoosing a Project Delivery Method. A Design-Build Done Right Primer
Choosing a Project Delivery Method A Design-Build Done Right Primer DESIGN-BUILD DONE RIGHT PRIMER 1 Choosing a Project Delivery Method A DESIGN-BUILD DONE RIGHT PRIMER A DESIGN-BUILD INSTITUTE OF AMERICA
More informationSeattle Public Utilities. Seattle Public Utilities Design-Build. Build-Operate Treatment Facility Projects
NWCCC Seatac June 27, 2001 Providing water, solid waste, drainage, engineering and customer services Seattle Public Utilities Design-Build Build-Operate Treatment Facility Projects Elizabeth S. Kelly,
More informationALTERNATIVE PROJECT DELIVERY METHODS DO THEY SAVE TIME AND MONEY?
ALTERNATIVE PROJECT DELIVERY METHODS DO THEY SAVE TIME AND MONEY? Gordon Culp Smith Culp Consulting SmithCulp.com INTRODUCTION Are there alternative methods for delivering water and wastewater treatment
More informationSession THREE. Face 2 Face (4 hours) Stage 1 Initial actions & appraisals: Self-directed (6 hours)
Session THREE Face 2 Face (4 hours) Stage 1 Initial actions & appraisals: What type of tendering methods are there? What does qualification mean? Do you (the MC) bid for every job? Do you (the MC) price
More informationAN OWNER S GUIDE TO PROJECT DELIVERY METHODS: CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA
AN OWNER S GUIDE TO PROJECT DELIVERY METHODS: CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA PREFACE This document is an introductory guide for owners who face the choice of delivery methods for their
More informationJim Porter is the Director of Public Works for the County of San Mateo. The Department of Public Works has a staff of over 300 and performs a wide
Jim Porter is the Director of Public Works for the County of San Mateo. The Department of Public Works has a staff of over 300 and performs a wide array of design, construction, construction administration,
More informationChoosing Delivery Method
Page 1 of 12 Advancing Professional Construction and Program Management Worldwide home contact us site map Search Find-A-CM/PM My Account Sign In Bookstore Career Center Home Choosing Delivery Method Choosing
More informationPresented By: Jeffrey T. Folden, P.E. Chief, Innovative Contracting Division
Presented By: Jeffrey T. Folden, P.E. Chief, Innovative Contracting Division Project Delivery Methods Design-Bid-Build (DBB) Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity (ID/IQ) Construction Management at Risk
More informationLB 889 The Political Subdivisions Construction Alternatives Act
1 LB 889 The Political Subdivisions Construction Alternatives Act What cities, villages, counties, state colleges, community colleges, and school districts need to know about their construction options.
More informationPROVING OUR PROFESSIONALISM
PROVING OUR PROFESSIONALISM 49 TH ANNUAL CONFERENCE MAY 22-25, 2016 ORLANDO, FLORIDA DESIGN-BUILD 101 Joanne Flick, CPPO, CPPB TODAY S TOPICS Project Delivery Overview Comparing Project Delivery Methods
More informationReport on Effectiveness of the Construction Manager at Risk Project Delivery Method
Report on Effectiveness of the Construction Manager at Risk Project Delivery Method The project management plans described below, establish several elements or criteria for university project staff to
More informationPROGRESSIVE DESIGN-BUILD. Praful M. Kulkarni, AIA Iraj Ghaemi, P.E. J. Brandon Dekker, M.S., DBIA
PROGRESSIVE DESIGN-BUILD Praful M. Kulkarni, AIA Iraj Ghaemi, P.E. J. Brandon Dekker, M.S., DBIA ADVANTAGES/DISADVANTAGES DESIGN BID BUILD (HARD BID) The traditional project delivery method, which customarily
More informationCONSTRUCTION CONTRACTING GUIDELINES Revised January 2017 I. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS AND PROCEDURES
THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS SYSTEM OFFICE OF GENERAL COUNSEL CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTING GUIDELINES Revised January 2017 The Rules and Regulations of the Board of Regents of The University of Texas System for
More informationConstruction Project Delivery Methods Overview and Comparison. Operations Division
Construction Project Delivery Methods Overview and Comparison Operations Division 1 Four Types of Delivery Methods Design/Bid/Build (CM Multi-Prime) CM at Risk Design/Build Lease/Leaseback 2 Considerations
More informationConstruction Project Delivery Methods
Construction Project Delivery Methods Purchasing Requirements and Applications 9/20/2012 1 General Purchasing Requirements 9/20/2012 2 Governmental Purchasing Requirements Law: Texas Education Code 44.031
More informationALTERNATE FORMS OF PROJECT DELIVERY
ALTERNATE FORMS OF PROJECT DELIVERY 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 BACKGROUND.1 In the building industry today, conventional methods of project delivery are being challenged by Clients, Consultants and Contractors
More informationCMAA has met the standards and requirements of the Registered Continuing Education Program. Credit earned on completion of this program will be
Thanks to our host CMAA has met the standards and requirements of the Registered Continuing Education Program. Credit earned on completion of this program will be reported to RCEP at RCEP.net. A certificate
More informationICOC Procurement Briefing
ICOC Procurement Briefing How we acquire goods and services Overview Procurement of Professional Services Engineering, architecture, design build, construction manager Projects < $2 million use continuing
More informationA , Standard Form of Agreement Between Owner and Contractor where the basis of payment is a Stipulated Sum
A101 2007, Standard Form of Agreement Between Owner and Contractor where the basis of payment is a Stipulated Sum AIA Document A101 2007 is a standard form of agreement between owner and contractor for
More informationPioneering Alternative Project Delivery in Ohio
Pioneering Alternative Project Delivery in Ohio Ali Bahar, PE Principal Engineer Metropolitan Sewer District of Greater Cincinnati Tim Koch, PE, Vice President, Brown and Caldwell 1 Agenda Construction
More informationAIA Contract Documents
AIA Contract Documents Contract Relationship Diagrams April 2017 Conventional (A201) Design-Bid-Build For use when the s project is divided into separate contracts for design () and construction (Contractor).
More informationAlternative Project Delivery for America s Water Infrastructure
Alternative Project Delivery for America s Water Infrastructure Cal Rozario PMP Design-Build Chief Engineer HDR Water & Natural Resources Business Group TOPICS Traditional Project Delivery Brief History
More informationIntegrated Project Delivery
2014 HDR Architecture, 2014 HDR, Inc., all all rights reserved. Integrated Project Delivery It s A New World, And How It Can Benefit Municipal Owners Rich Atoulikian, PMP, PE Rich.Atoulikian@hdrinc.com
More information5/21/13 PROCUREMENT 5/21/13. Agenda. Common Tendering Systems Procurement Methods
PROCUREMENT 5/21/13 Agenda Common Tendering Systems Procurement Methods 1 Agenda Common Tendering Systems Procurement Methods Common Tendering Systems Competitive / Open-bid: (Qualified) contractors are
More informationRequest for Proposal for GC/CM Consultant Services Ferndale School District. Secondary High School GC/CM Program. October 19, 2018
Request for Proposal for GC/CM Consultant Services Ferndale School District Secondary High School GC/CM Program October 19, 2018 The Ferndale School District is requesting proposals for project management,
More informationConstruction Documents Education Program
PLANNING AND PRE-DESIGN THE CONSTRUCTION SPECIFICATIONS INSTITUTE 110 South Union Street, Suite 100 Alexandria, VA 22314-3351 www.csinet.org CDEP 1.0.1: 03-1 Copyright Materials This presentation is protected
More informationEXHIBIT 6 Preconstruction Work
EXHIBIT 6 Preconstruction Work The following tasks shall be accomplished by the CM/GC as part of its obligations during the preconstruction phase. The work is to be coordinated with the services requirements
More informationECI: Two-Stage Contracts
ECI: Two-Stage Contracts Client and Contractor Considerations Michael Creedon Special Counsel ECI in Infrastructure and Major Projects Summit 2010 Sydney, 17 June 2010 Sessions Outline Introduction /
More informationOhio s Qualifications-Based Selection Law (as amended by Sub. H.B. 153, 129 th Ohio General Assembly, effective Sept. 28, 2011)
Ohio s Qualifications-Based Selection Law (as amended by Sub. H.B. 153, 129 th Ohio General Assembly, effective Sept. 28, 2011) Sec. 153.65. As used in sections 153.65 to 153.73 of the Revised Code: (A)(1)
More informationConsensusDocs. Catalog. Updated Docs Inside
ConsensusDocs ConsensusDocs Contracts Catalog Updated Docs Inside ConsensusDocs Keeping You Ahead of the Cur ve ConsensusDocs... Building A Better Way! Whether working at the office, from the road or even
More informationProject Delivery Method
City Green - Project Delivery Method Roswell City Council Work Session September 14, 2016 Agenda Debrief on HPC Work Session Project Schedule Update Alternative Project Delivery Methods Discussion / Direction
More informationThe Greater Toronto Electrical Contractors Association endorses the following CCDC/CCA Documents
The Greater Toronto Electrical Contractors Association endorses the following CCDC/CCA Documents CCDC Standard Construction Documents CCDC 2-1994 Stipulated Price Contract Standard prime contract between
More informationConstruction Contracts
Construction Contracts By Dr. Ibrahim Assakkaf Construction Contracts By Dr. Ibrahim Assakkaf 1 The Need Web-based Contracts Supporting scheduling Controlling Regulating Analyzing Auditing the procurement
More informationProcurement Documents for Progressive Design-Build Projects
Procurement Documents for Progressive Design-Build Projects March 22, 2013 John Awezec, P.E., DBIA HDR Engineering, Inc. John Doller, P.E. Carollo Engineers, Inc. Peter Hughes Executive Director WDBC Model
More informationREQUEST FOR PROPOSAL FOR CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT SERVICES NOT AT RISK FOR THE. St. Charles County Ambulance District
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL FOR CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT SERVICES NOT AT RISK FOR THE St. Charles County Ambulance District Base 3 & Training Facility Construction 4169 Old Mill Parkway St. Peters, MO 63376 September
More informationAlternative Delivery Methods in the Post-Davis World
CASBO 2017 Annual Conference April 2017 Alternative Delivery Methods in the Post-Davis World Alan Reising Long Beach Unified School District areising@lbschools.net Phil Henderson Orbach Huff Suarez & Henderson
More informationConsensusDocs. ConsensusDocs CONTRACTS CATALOG. Updated Docs Inside. ou Ah. ead o f the Cur v. e K
CONTRACTS CATALOG Updated Docs Inside ou Ah ead o f the Cur v e gy epin e K ... BUILDING A BETTER WAY! Whether working at the office, from the road or even at home, the platform provides instant access
More informationSchool Construction: Contract Basics OSBA BONDS, BALLOTS AND BUILDINGS CONFERENCE FEBRUARY 09, 2018
School Construction: Contract Basics OSBA BONDS, BALLOTS AND BUILDINGS CONFERENCE FEBRUARY 09, 2018 Who we are Presenters Rob Wilkinson, Partner, Ball Janik LLP Scott Rogers, CPPB, Senior Project Manager,
More informationCommunity Workshop October 17, 2015
Community Workshop October 17, 2015 Goals for Workshop Education for attendees How City builds projects now Why a different method is being pursued for WRF Other workshops (not today) Architecture Treatment
More informationSTATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND MENTAL HEALTH
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND MENTAL HEALTH REQUEST FOR QUOTES FOR CONSULTING SERVICES TO IDENTIFY REQUIREMENTS FOR A SAMH FINANCIAL AND SERVICES ACCOUNTABILITY
More informationCM/GC Contracting Lessons Learned from Portland and San Francisco
CM/GC Contracting Lessons Learned from Portland and San Francisco Lance Erz, TriMet Robin M Reitzes, SF City Attorney s Office American Public Transportation Association Legal Affairs Seminar February
More informationREQUEST FOR PROPOSALS. Construction Manager CM Services Pre-Construction and Construction Services
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS Construction Manager CM Services Pre-Construction and Construction Services Big Sky Fire Department Station 1 Project Big Sky Fire District OWNER Big Sky, Montana November 2016 Request
More informationAlternative Delivery Methods for Construction Projects at WATER AND WASTEWATER SUMMIT 2012 LAS VEGAS, NV MAY 3, 2012
Alternative Delivery Methods for Construction Projects at WATER AND WASTEWATER SUMMIT 2012 LAS VEGAS, NV MAY 3, 2012 Presenter Nilaksh Kothari, P.E. General Manager Manitowoc, Wisconsin Outline of Presentation
More informationImplementing Design-Build On a Small Scale Everett s East Clearwell Roof Replacement
Richard Hefti, P.E., City of Everett, and Patrick Weber, P.E., Brown and Caldwell Implementing Design-Build On a Small Scale Everett s East Clearwell Roof Replacement April 27, 2018 Background: Everett
More informationAudio Sessions. Session 4 PROCUREMENT. Construction Contract Administration Education Program
Audio Sessions Session 4 PROCUREMENT Construction Contract Administration Education Program Certified Construction Contract Administrator (CCCA) Preparatory Course 2011 The Construction Specifications
More informationProgressive Design-Build
November 15,2016 Progressive Design-Build A Smart Alternative to Lease/Lease back? PRESENTERS Praful Kulkarni, AIA Rebekah Gladson, FAIA, DBIA Robynne T. Parkinson, JD, DBIA Presentation Outline Value
More informationAdvance Collaborate Enrich
Job Order Contracting 101 A Facilities Management Tool Sponsored by the Center for Job Order Contracting Excellence and The National Association of State Facilities Administrators Job Order Contracting
More informationCM AT RISK VS. DESIGN BID BUILD
CM AT RISK VS. DESIGN BID BUILD A TEXAS CASE STUDY ON PROCUREMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION September 28, 2010 Acknowledgement Mike Adams, P.E Executive Director of Engineering and Utilities City of Midlothian
More informationDEFINING THE SPECTRUM OF PROJECT DELIVERY OPTIONS AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR YOUR PROJECT 2017 Airport Construction Strategy Summit
DEFINING THE SPECTRUM OF PROJECT DELIVERY OPTIONS AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR YOUR PROJECT 2017 Special Thanks To: DEFINING THE SPECTRUM OF PROJECT DELIVERY OPTIONS AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR YOUR PROJECT
More informationQualifications Based Selection of Contractors
Qualifications Based Selection of Contractors AGC of America Project Delivery Committee QBS Working Group 1 Table of Contents QBS & The Industry: An Introduction Pages 3-4 Selection Criteria for QBS Page
More informationTeam Structures and Project Performance in the Design-Build / Integrated Project Delivery Marketplace. Mark E. Alpert, P.E.
Team Structures and Project Performance in the Design-Build / Integrated Project Delivery Marketplace Mark E. Alpert, P.E., DBIA CH2M HILL Introduction Team Structure Agenda Engineer-lead Integrated design-build
More informationSubcontract Management Certification Program (ScMCP ) SUBCONTRACT MANAGEMENT TECHNICAL COMPETENCIES. SUBCONTRACT MANAGER (ScM)
Competency 1. Determination of How Best to Satisfy Requirements for the Mission Area a. Provide proactive business advice on requirements documentation based on analysis of requirements and performance-based
More informationAdvanced Construction Techniques
Alaskan Way Viaduct Replacement Program Organization University of Washington Date October 20, 2011 Presentation Overview SR 99 south end viaduct replacement. Design-build contracting. SR 99 tunnel project.
More informationDate: January 28, TriMet Contract Review Board. Daniel W. Blocher, P.E.
Date: January 28, 2015 To: From: Subject: TriMet Contract Review Board Daniel W. Blocher, P.E. Evaluation of Public Improvement Project Not Contracted By Low Bidding West Segment of the Portland Milwaukie
More informationBIDDING REQUIREMENTS
BIDDING REQUIREMENTS The Purchasing Department is responsible for overseeing the competitive bid process and maintaining its integrity. The bidding process introduces the element of competition directly
More informationProgressive Design-Build
Progressive Design-Build A Design-Build Done Right TM Primer Progressive Design-Build 1 What is Progressive Design-build? Progressive Design-Build A DESIGN-BUILD DONE RIGHT TM PRIMER A DESIGN-BUILD INSTITUTE
More informationProject phases II. Tendering-constructionoperation
Project phases II. -constructionoperation Construction management 2. Lepel BME Department of Construction Technology and Management 09.03.2016 Project phases time Inception initiation Preliminary analysis
More informationCHAPTER 2 DEVELOPMENT AND ORGANIZATION OF PROJECTS
CHAPTER 2 DEVELOPMENT AND ORGANIZATION OF PROJECTS 1) THE LIFE CYCLE OF A CONSTR. PROJECT: 1.1:CONCEPT AND FEASIBILITY STUDIES: THE START Recognition of a need for a new facility conceptual analyses Technical
More information