Enclosed please find the inspection report for the above-referenced location.

Transcription

1 January 7, 2010 Ted Sherman Saint Paul Public Schools 360 Colborne Street Saint Paul, MN RE: Nokomis Montessori School Asbestos Inspection Project # Dear Ted, Enclosed please find the inspection report for the above-referenced location. If you have any questions or require additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely,, INC. Jeff Carlson Director of Inspection Services JC/wb Enclosures cc File

2 ASBESTOS INSPECTION PROFILE Nokomis Montessori School 985 Ruth Street North Saint Paul, MN Submitted to: Ted Sherman Saint Paul Public Schools Submitted by: Institute for Environmental Assessment 9201 West Broadway North, Suite 600 Brooklyn Park, MN / Client #2001 Project #

3 INDEX SECTION I Asbestos Summary and Inspection Report SECTION II Floor Plans SECTION III Asbestos Laboratory Report SECTION IV Asbestos Inspector and Management Planner Licenses

4 SECTION I Asbestos Summary and Inspection Report

5 Asbestos Summary Nokomis Montessori School 985 Ruth Street North Saint Paul, MN On December 17, 2009, an inspection for asbestos-containing materials (ACM) was performed at the above-referenced location. The scope of the inspection included all accessible suspect ACM within the building. Since this was a limited inspection, there may be additional materials not identified on the report located within wall cavities, pipe chases and/or other inaccessible locations. Suspect ACM was identified and sampled for asbestos content. At the time of the inspection, the tunnels were inaccessible. Identified materials confirmed to be ACM include the following: Pre-formed pipe insulation and associated mudded fittings Millboard pipe insulation The following suspect materials were not sampled as part of the inspection. These materials are assumed to contain asbestos and shall be treated as ACM or sampled prior to disturbance to determine if they are ACM or not. Identified materials assumed to be ACM include the following: Mudded fittings on millboard insulation Boiler refractory Chalkboard adhesive Corkboard adhesive See the attached report for specific quantities and locations. Additionally, material may exist in the tunnel system, but the tunnels are not accessible. Destructive sampling was not performed as a part of this inspection. This inspection does not meet the requirements of the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA) or Minnesota OSHA (MNOSHA) for an asbestos demolition/renovation inspection. Bulk Samples of accessible suspect material were collected and analyzed in accordance with Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) sampling and analytical procedure requirements. Sampling was conducted in a manner determined by the inspector to be sufficient to identify whether the suspect materials are asbestos containing. Where deemed appropriate, prior sample results were used and are referenced in the report. Roof samples were not collected as part of this inspection. Suspect roofing materials should be handled as asbestos or sampled prior to disturbance to determine if they are ACM or not. Specific locations of these materials, as well as those suspect materials which were analyzed and were found not to contain asbestos, are identified in the attached report., INC Page 1 of 1

6 Nokomis Montessori School 985 Ruth Street North, Saint Paul, MN Inspection Dates: 12/17/2009 Chart B - Assessment of Asbestos-Containing Building Materials (ACBM) All asbestos-containing events listed here are to be inspected during each six-month periodic surveillance inspection for changes in condition. The Institute for Environmental Assessment () highly recommends an in depth "front end" inspection prior to any general renovation or remodeling to determine if those activities may disrupt building materials that may involve existing or undiscovered asbestos. Potentially inaccessible or exempt asbestos-containing materials not included in this plan may include: adhesives, caulking, putty, woven blankets, curtains, gloves and gaskets, electrical wiring insulation and heat shields above lights, paints and coatings, roofing felts, flashings and shingles, and mineral core fire doors. Damaged materials which require corrective action to reduce a potential hazard are indicated on Chart A. All non-damaged ACBM identified in Chart B should be monitored through scheduled inspections and removed prior to renovation or demolition activities, or when their condition deteriorates. District administration will direct another formal inspection by a federally certified inspector within three (3) years, and will maintain an ongoing file for each building. Specific recommendations on how to manage the different types of asbestos-containing material are identified in the Asbestos Management Plan. PLEASE NOTE: Based on EPA recommendations, materials analyzed utilizing PLM and found to contain between 0% and 10% should be assumed asbestos containing unless building owner wishes the laboratory to utilize "point counting." For samples analyzed prior to 1994 containing 1% or less (trace) of asbestos, resampling utilizing the 1993 EPA Test Method or point counting is strongly recommended for purposes of demolition or renovation before treating these materials as non-asbestos containing. Contact your local office for questions or additional information. EPA ASSESSMENT CATEGORIES: 1 = Damaged or significantly damaged TSI ACM. 5 = ACBM w/potential for damage. 2 = Damaged friable surfacing ACM. 6 = ACBM w/potential for significant damage. 3 = Significantly damaged friable surfacing ACM. 7 = Any remaining friable ACBM or friable suspected ACBM. 4 = Damaged or significantly damaged friable miscellaneous ACM. Event No. Material Type Location Estimated Amount Total Friable? % Asbestos EPA Assess. Category 17 B2A Millboard Pipe Insulation ROOM Lin. Ft. N 5 CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 18 A2A Mudded Pipe Joints on Millboard Insulation ROOM Joints N ASSUMED 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. Nokomis Montessori School Page 1

7 Nokomis Montessori School 985 Ruth Street North, Saint Paul, MN Inspection Dates: 12/17/2009 Event No. Material Type Location Estimated Amount Total Friable? % Asbestos EPA Assess. Category 19 X0C Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive 20 X0D Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive 21 B2A Millboard Pipe Insulation ROOM Lin. Ft. N 5 CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 22 A2A Mudded Pipe Joints on Millboard Insulation ROOM Joints N ASSUMED 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 23 X0C Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive 24 X0D Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive 25 B2A Millboard Pipe Insulation ROOM Lin. Ft. N 5 CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 26 A2A Mudded Pipe Joints on Millboard Insulation ROOM Joints N ASSUMED 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 27 X0C Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive Nokomis Montessori School Page 2

8 Nokomis Montessori School 985 Ruth Street North, Saint Paul, MN Inspection Dates: 12/17/2009 Event No. Material Type Location Estimated Amount Total Friable? % Asbestos EPA Assess. Category 28 X0D Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive 29 B2A Millboard Pipe Insulation ROOM Lin. Ft. N 5 CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 30 A2A Mudded Pipe Joints on Millboard Insulation ROOM Joints N ASSUMED 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 31 X0C Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive 32 X0D Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive 33 B2A Millboard Pipe Insulation ROOM Lin. Ft. N 5 CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 34 A2A Mudded Pipe Joints on Millboard Insulation ROOM Joints N ASSUMED 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 35 X0C Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive 36 X0D Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive Nokomis Montessori School Page 3

9 Nokomis Montessori School 985 Ruth Street North, Saint Paul, MN Inspection Dates: 12/17/2009 Event No. Material Type Location Estimated Amount Total Friable? % Asbestos EPA Assess. Category 37 B3A Pre-Formed Pipe Insulation ROOM Lin. Ft. N 20 CH, 30 AM 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL CHASE FEEDING HEATING LINE AT SOUTHEAST CORNER OF ROOM. 38 B2A Millboard Pipe Insulation ROOM Lin. Ft. N 5 CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 39 A2A Mudded Pipe Joints on Millboard Insulation ROOM Joints N ASSUMED 5 ESTIMATED IN WALL FEEDING SINK. 40 X0C Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive 41 X0D Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive 42 B3A Pre-Formed Pipe Insulation HALLWAY OUTSIDE ROOM Lin. Ft. Y 20 CH, 30 AM 1 OPEN END W/DEBRIS ON CEILING TILE ABOVE POWER PANELS. 44 B3A Pre-Formed Pipe Insulation BOYS' RESTROOM NEAR ROOM Lin. Ft. N 20 CH, 30 AM 5 ABOVE CEILING. VISIBLE FROM HALLWAY THROUGH HOLE IN WALL. 45 A3A Mudded Pipe Joints on Pre-formed Insulation BOYS' RESTROOM NEAR ROOM Joints N 70 AM 5 ABOVE CEILING. VISIBLE FROM HALLWAY THROUGH HOLE IN WALL. 46 B2A Millboard Pipe Insulation GIRLS' RESTROOM NEAR ROOM Lin. Ft. N 5 CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 5 ESTIMATED ABOVE CEILING. VISIBLE PENETRATION IN CHASE. Nokomis Montessori School Page 4

10 Nokomis Montessori School 985 Ruth Street North, Saint Paul, MN Inspection Dates: 12/17/2009 Event No. Material Type Location Estimated Amount Total Friable? % Asbestos EPA Assess. Category 48 X0C Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive 49 X0D Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive 52 X0C Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive 53 X0D Miscellaneous Material ROOM Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive 55 D2A Interior Boiler Insulation BOILER ROOM 30 Sq. Ft. N ASSUMED 5 Interior Refractory (1992) Nokomis Montessori School Page 5

11 Nokomis Montessori School 985 Ruth Street North, Saint Paul, MN Inspection Dates: 12/17/2009 Chart C - All Materials List The following list contains all events observed by the inspector, whether or not they actually contained asbestos, and are grouped by homogeneous area (material type). Homogeneous Area ID Code (Material Type) Event No. Location % Asbestos Sample No. Sample Location Estimated Total Amount A2A A3A A4A B2A Mudded Pipe Joints on Millboard Insulation Mudded Pipe Joints on Pre-formed Insulation Mudded Pipe Joints on Fiberglass Insulation Millboard Pipe Insulation Total Amount: 12 Joints 18 ROOM 100 ASSUMED 2 Joints 22 ROOM 101 ASSUMED 2 Joints 26 ROOM 102 ASSUMED 2 Joints 30 ROOM 103 ASSUMED 2 Joints 34 ROOM 104 ASSUMED 2 Joints 39 ROOM 105 ASSUMED 2 Joints Total Amount: 2 Joints 45 BOYS' RESTROOM NEAR ROOM AM 328A2A 2 Joints Total Amount: 2 Joints 50 ROOM 107 RESTROOM NONE DETECTED ML-17 2 Joints Total Amount: 106 Lin. Ft. 17 ROOM CH, 10 AM, 10 CR BOILER ROOM (WHITE OUTER LAYER) 16 Lin. Ft. 21 ROOM CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 16 Lin. Ft. 25 ROOM CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 16 Lin. Ft. 29 ROOM CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 16 Lin. Ft. 33 ROOM CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 16 Lin. Ft. Nokomis Montessori School Page 1

12 Chart C - All Materials List - Nokomis Montessori School (cont.) Homogeneous Area ID Code (Material Type) Event No. Location % Asbestos Sample No. Sample Location Estimated Total Amount 38 ROOM CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 16 Lin. Ft. 46 GIRLS' RESTROOM NEAR ROOM CH, 10 AM, 10 CR 10 Lin. Ft. B3A D1A D2A I2A I2B I2C Pre-Formed Pipe Insulation Boiler Gaskets Burner Gasket (1992) Interior Boiler Insulation Interior Refractory (1992) Total Amount: 15 Lin. Ft. 37 ROOM CH, 30 AM 8 Lin. Ft. 42 HALLWAY OUTSIDE ROOM CH, 30 AM 328A7A 1 Lin. Ft. 44 BOYS' RESTROOM NEAR ROOM CH, 30 AM 6 Lin. Ft. Total Amount: 2 Sq. Ft. 54 BOILER ROOM NONE DETECTED ML-11 2 Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 30 Sq. Ft. 55 BOILER ROOM ASSUMED 30 Sq. Ft. 2' x 2' Acoustical Ceiling Tile Total Amount: 20,000 Sq. Ft. Scattered Small Holes 2 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED NOK-5 NOK-5: END OF HALLWAY Sq. Ft. 2' x 2' Acoustical Ceiling Tile Nail & Pin Holes in Concentric Circles 2' x 2' Acoustical Ceiling Tile Chicken Scratch Total Amount: 700 Sq. Ft. 12 KITCHEN AREA NONE DETECTED ML-04 ML-04: KITCHEN. 700 Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 7,500 Sq. Ft. 16 ROOMS NONE DETECTED ML-09 ML-09: ROOM Sq. Ft. Nokomis Montessori School Page 2

13 Chart C - All Materials List - Nokomis Montessori School (cont.) Homogeneous Area ID Code (Material Type) Event No. Location % Asbestos Sample No. Sample Location Estimated Total Amount I2D K2A M0A N0A 2' x 2' Acoustical Ceiling Tile Fissures w/revealed Edge 12" x 12" Vinyl Floor Tile & Mastic White w/multi-colored Smudges (1992) Plaster Drywall/Joint Compound ORIGINAL BUILDING HALLWAY FROM ROOMS Total Amount: 1,200 Sq. Ft. NONE DETECTED ML-08 ML-08: OUTSIDE ROOM Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 25,000 Sq. Ft. 3 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED ML-02 ML-02: STORAGE ROOM Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 800 Sq. Ft. 43 BOYS' & GIRLS' RESTROOM NEAR ROOM 105 NONE DETECTED 200 Sq. Ft. 47 ROOM 107 NONE DETECTED ML-15, Sq. Ft. 51 ROOM 108 NONE DETECTED ML Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 10,000 Sq. Ft. 1 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED 511-H Sq. Ft. P0A Q0A Q0B Fire Door Wood - 1 Hr Rating (Warnock Hersey) Total Amount: 200 Sq. Ft. 10 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NEW 200 Sq. Ft. Carpet Mastic Total Amount: 10,000 Sq. Ft. Light Blue Berber Carpet 4 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED XX-10B XX-10B: ROOM Sq. Ft. Carpet Mastic Total Amount: 5,000 Sq. Ft. Multi-Colored Berber Carpet 5 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED ML-06 ML-06: MAIN OFFICE Sq. Ft. Nokomis Montessori School Page 3

14 Chart C - All Materials List - Nokomis Montessori School (cont.) Homogeneous Area ID Code (Material Type) Event No. Location % Asbestos Sample No. Sample Location Estimated Total Amount R0A V0A X0A X0B X0C Baseboard/Mopboard Adhesive Blue Baseboard Sink Undercoating Gray Miscellaneous Material Red Fire Stop Miscellaneous Material Total Amount: 1,000 Sq. Ft. 6 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED XX-11B XX-11B: GYMNASIUM Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 30 Sq. Ft. 11 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED ML-07 ML-07: TEACHERS' LOUNGE. 30 Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 200 Sq. Ft. 7 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED ML-03 ML-03: BOILER ROOM. 200 Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 100 Sq. Ft. Wired Window Glaze (1992) 8 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED ML-05 ML-05: ROOM Sq. Ft. Miscellaneous Material Wood Frame Chalkboard Adhesive Total Amount: 140 Sq. Ft. 19 ROOM 100 ASSUMED 20 Sq. Ft. 23 ROOM 101 ASSUMED 20 Sq. Ft. 27 ROOM 102 ASSUMED 20 Sq. Ft. 31 ROOM 103 ASSUMED 20 Sq. Ft. 35 ROOM 104 ASSUMED 20 Sq. Ft. 40 ROOM 105 ASSUMED 20 Sq. Ft. 48 ROOM 107 ASSUMED 10 Sq. Ft. 52 ROOM 108 ASSUMED 10 Sq. Ft. Nokomis Montessori School Page 4

15 Chart C - All Materials List - Nokomis Montessori School (cont.) Homogeneous Area ID Code (Material Type) Event No. Location % Asbestos Sample No. Sample Location Estimated Total Amount X0D X0E X0F X0G X0H Miscellaneous Material Wood Frame Corkboard Adhesive Miscellaneous Material Tectum Miscellaneous Material Gray Duct Seam Cement Miscellaneous Material Milkboard Adhesive Miscellaneous Material Tan Fire Stop Total Amount: 1,040 Sq. Ft. 20 ROOM 100 ASSUMED 130 Sq. Ft. 24 ROOM 101 ASSUMED 130 Sq. Ft. 28 ROOM 102 ASSUMED 130 Sq. Ft. 32 ROOM 103 ASSUMED 130 Sq. Ft. 36 ROOM 104 ASSUMED 130 Sq. Ft. 41 ROOM 105 ASSUMED 130 Sq. Ft. 49 ROOM 107 ASSUMED 130 Sq. Ft. 53 ROOM 108 ASSUMED 130 Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 1,600 Sq. Ft. 14 CAFETERIA/GYMNASIUM NONE DETECTED ML-10 ML-10: GYMNASIUM Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 5 Sq. Ft. 56 BOILER ROOM NONE DETECTED ML-01 ML-01: BOILER ROOM. 5 Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 300 Sq. Ft. 13 KITCHEN AREA NONE DETECTED ML-12 ML-12: KITCHEN. 300 Sq. Ft. Total Amount: 30 Sq. Ft. 9 THROUGHOUT BUILDING NONE DETECTED ML-13 ML-13: ROOM Sq. Ft. Nokomis Montessori School Page 5

16 SECTION II Floor Plans

17 A 1100A 1111A 1111B 1113A 1113B 1199A 1199B 1202A 1204A 1204B 1220B TA1 TA2 TA3 TA Nokomis Elementary - First Floor

18 Nokomis Elementary - Second Floor 2199A B A

19 SECTION III Asbestos Laboratory Report

20

21

22

23

24

25

26 SECTION IV Asbestos Inspector & Management Planner Licenses

27

28