ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE DELIVERY AND OPERATIONS DIVISION CONTRACTS AND SPECIFICATIONS SECTION TABULATION OF BIDS

Transcription

1 ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE DELIVERY AND OPERATIONS DIVISION CONTRACTS AND SPECIFICATIONS SECTION TABULATION OF BIDS CONTRACT # TRACS No. Project No. County District Gross Length Net Length Prepared By: 191 GE 139 H870101C 191-C-(221)T GREENLEE SOUTHEAST 12 Patton Samuel James Highway Termini Location Work Description SAFORD-SPRINGERVILLE HIGHWAY (US 191) BACK COUNTRY BYWAY - MP 151 Pavement Rehabilitation

2 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 1 of 15 BID RESULTS FOR Bid Opening Date : 4/13/2018, Prequalification Required, Engineer Specialist : Patton Samuel James Completion Date: 140 Working Days The proposed project is located in Graham and Greenlee County on US 191. The work begins at MP and extends to MP The work includes the milling of existing pavement and replacing it with asphaltic concrete end product, placement of an asphaltic concrete friction course, crack sealing, removing and replacing guardrail, placement and compaction of shoulder build up, applying pavement markings, traffic control, signing and other related work. Bid Rank Department Estimate Bid Amount Contractor Extended Sum of s % $3,991, % $4,309, % $4,338, % $4,668, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC W. Happy Valley Road, Ste. 141 #496 Glendale, AZ FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. 115 S. 48TH STREET TEMPE, AZ CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC 1234 E. AIRPORT ROAD SAFFORD, AZ DEPARTMENT ESTIMATE $3,991, $4,309, $4,338, $4,668, % $4,813, % $4,845, FANN CONTRACTING, INC PO BOX 4356 PRESCOTT, AZ FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVING 1302 W. Drivers Way Tempe, AZ $4,813, $4,845, Winning Bidder is 14.5% Under Department Estimate (Difference = ($677,343.66))

3 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 2 of EACH REMOVE (BCT) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $5, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $4, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $10, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $5, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $4, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $5, % L.FT. REMOVE GUARD RAIL Bid Rank Department Estimate $3.000 $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $4.500 $1, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $5.000 $1, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $5.240 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $5.000 $1, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $5.000 $1, % SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (2") Bid Rank Department Estimate 2, $2.250 $5, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $1.850 $4, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $5.000 $13, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $2.250 $5, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $26, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $7, % SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (2 1/2") Bid Rank Department Estimate 2, $2.250 $6, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.800 $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.500 $4, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $1.170 $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $3.800 $10, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1.000 $2, % SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (3") Bid Rank Department Estimate 202, $1.750 $353, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $1.000 $202, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.300 $262, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $1.230 $248, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $1.850 $373, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2.000 $404, % SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (4 1/2" TO 6") Bid Rank Department Estimate 15, $4.000 $61, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $1.750 $26, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2.600 $39, %

4 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 3 of SQ.YD. REMOVE BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT (MILLING) (4 1/2" TO 6") Bid Rank Department Estimate 15, $4.000 $61, CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $1.700 $26, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $3.800 $58, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $45, % L.FT. SHOULDER BUILD-UP (MILLED AC) Bid Rank Department Estimate 25, $0.750 $19, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.100 $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.700 $17, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.450 $11, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.310 $7, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.400 $10, % HOUR SHOULDER BUILD-UP (COMPACTION) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $3, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $3, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $2, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $4, % CU.YD. ROADWAY EXCAVATION Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $9, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $1, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $8, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $5, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $9, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $2, % CU.YD. AGGREGATE BASE, CLASS 2 Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $9, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $5, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $6, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $8, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $11, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $3, % TON EMULSIFIED ASPHALT (FOR FOG COAT) ( Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $16, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $26, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $11, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $12, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $16, %

5 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 4 of TON EMULSIFIED ASPHALT (FOR FOG COAT) ( Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $16, FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $19, % TON BITUMINOUS TACK COAT Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $67, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $67, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $56, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $52, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $33, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $67, % HOUR APPLY BITUMINOUS TACK COAT Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $44, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $66, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $26, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $44, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $44, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $56, % TON BLOTTER MATERIAL Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $3, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $2, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $8, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $3, % TON ASPHALT BINDER (PG 64-22) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $ $818, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $613, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $777, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $782, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $687, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $613, % TON ASPHALTIC CONCRETE (MISCELLANEOUS STRUCTURAL) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $112, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $73, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $75, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $128, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $108, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $94, %

6 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 5 of TON ASPHALTIC CONCRETE FRICTION COURSE (ASPHALT-RUBBER) Bid Rank Department Estimate 6, $ $263, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $181, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $200, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $297, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $307, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $300, % TON ASPHALT RUBBER MATERIAL (FOR AR-ACFC) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $357, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $238, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $282, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $336, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $342, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $297, % TON MINERAL ADMIXTURE (FOR AR-ACFC) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $5, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $5, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $5, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $5, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $5, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $5, % TON ASPHALTIC CONCRETE (3/4" MIX) (END PRODUCT) Bid Rank Department Estimate 32, $ $1,142, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $1,191, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $881, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $938, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $1,207, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $1,289, % TON MINERAL ADMIXTURE Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $27, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $27, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $27, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $27, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $27, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $27, % EACH SLIP BASE (NEW) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $2, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $2, %

7 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 6 of EACH SLIP BASE (NEW) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $2, CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $2, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $2, % L.FT. SIGN POST (PERFORATED) (2 1/2 S) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $9.750 $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $ % L.FT. SIGN POST (PERFORATED) (2 1/2 T) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $2, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $3, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $2, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $2, % EACH FOUNDATION FOR SIGN POST (CONCRETE) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $4, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $4, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $5, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $4, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $4, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $4, % SQ.FT. WARNING, MARKER, OR REGULATORY SIGN PANEL Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $4, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $4, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $4, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $5, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $4, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $3, % SQ.FT. SIGN PANEL (HINGED) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $ %

8 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 7 of SQ.FT. SIGN PANEL (HINGED) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $ FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $ % SQ.FT. FLAT SHEET ALUMINUM SIGN PANEL Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $3, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $3, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $4, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $4, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $4, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $3, % L.SUM MISCELLANEOUS WORK (SIGNS) Bid Rank Department Estimate $4, $4, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $3, $3, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $5, $5, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $3, $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $3, $3, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $5, $5, % L.FT. TEMPORARY PAINTED MARKING (STRIPE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 231, $0.120 $27, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.090 $20, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $34, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.160 $36, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.100 $23, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.150 $34, % EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE II, VERT.PANEL, TUBULAR MARKER) Bid Rank Department Estimate 5, $0.250 $1, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.150 $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.120 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.120 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.750 $3, % EACH-DAY BARRICADE (TYPE III, HIGH LEVEL FLAG TREES) Bid Rank Department Estimate $0.500 $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.400 $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.450 $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.350 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.430 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1.000 $ %

9 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 8 of EACH-DAY PORTABLE SIGN STANDS (RIGID) Bid Rank Department Estimate $0.500 $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.200 $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.200 $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.250 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.180 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1.000 $ % EACH-DAY PORTABLE SIGN STANDS (SPRING TYPE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 3, $0.600 $2, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.450 $1, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.500 $1, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.400 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.430 $1, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1.000 $3, % EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE A) Bid Rank Department Estimate 4, $0.150 $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.150 $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.200 $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.200 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.150 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.250 $1, % EACH-DAY WARNING LIGHTS (TYPE C) Bid Rank Department Estimate 5, $0.200 $1, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.200 $1, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.200 $1, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.200 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.180 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.250 $1, % EACH-DAY TRAFFIC CONE (28 INCHES) Bid Rank Department Estimate 14, $0.250 $3, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.200 $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.200 $2, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.150 $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.180 $2, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.250 $3, % EACH-DAY EMBEDDED SIGN POST Bid Rank Department Estimate 7, $0.150 $1, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.300 $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $1, %

10 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 9 of EACH-DAY EMBEDDED SIGN POST Bid Rank Department Estimate 7, $0.150 $1, CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.150 $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.120 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.250 $1, % EACH-DAY TRUCK MOUNTED ATTENUATOR Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $21, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $27, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $4, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $1, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $7, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $11, % EACH-DAY TEMPORARY SIGN (LESS THAN 10 S.F.) Bid Rank Department Estimate $0.600 $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.350 $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.500 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.310 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1.000 $ % EACH-DAY TEMPORARY SIGN (10 S.F. OR MORE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 6, $0.500 $3, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.400 $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.450 $3, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.650 $4, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.450 $3, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1.000 $6, % EACH-DAY FLASHING ARROW PANEL Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $ % EACH-DAY CHANGEABLE MESSAGE BOARD (CONTRACTOR FURNISHED) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $12, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $14, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $17, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $12, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $15, %

11 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 10 of EACH-DAY CHANGEABLE MESSAGE BOARD (CONTRACTOR FURNISHED) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $12, FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $15, % HOUR PILOT VEHICLE WITH DRIVER Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $ $63, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $63, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $48, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $58, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $53, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $61, % HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (CIVILIAN) Bid Rank Department Estimate 3, $ $129, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $110, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $86, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $133, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $121, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $117, % HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (LOCAL ENFORCEMENT OFFICER) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $ $119, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $91, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $93, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $129, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $130, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $119, % HOUR FLAGGING SERVICES (DPS) Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $ $111, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $111, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $111, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $111, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $111, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $111, % EACH DELINEATOR ASSEMBLY (FLEXIBLE) (CONCRETE FOUNDATION) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $50, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $35, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $55, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $43, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $40, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $39, %

12 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 11 of L.FT. PAVEMENT MARKING (WHITE EXTRUDED THERMOPLASTIC) (0.090") Bid Rank Department Estimate 204, $0.350 $71, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.300 $61, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $71, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.390 $79, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.340 $69, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.340 $69, % L.FT. PAVEMENT MARKING (YELLOW EXTRUDED THERMOPLASTIC) (0.090") Bid Rank Department Estimate 147, $0.350 $51, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.300 $44, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $51, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.390 $57, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.340 $49, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.340 $49, % L.FT. PAVEMENT MARKING (TRANSVERSE) (THERMOPLASTIC) (ALKYD) (0.090") Bid Rank Department Estimate $7.000 $1, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $1.650 $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.000 $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $1.970 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $2.000 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $ % EACH PAVEMENT SYMBOL (EXTRUDED THERMOPLASTIC) (ALKYD) (0.090") Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $1, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $1, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $1, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $2, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $2, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $1, % EACH PAVEMENT MARKER, RECESSED, TYPE D Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $5.500 $8, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $4.600 $7, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $5.000 $8, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $5.570 $8, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $5.000 $8, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $6.000 $9, % EACH PAVEMENT MARKER, RECESSED, TYPE G Bid Rank Department Estimate $5.500 $2, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $4.600 $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $5.000 $2, %

13 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 12 of EACH PAVEMENT MARKER, RECESSED, TYPE G Bid Rank Department Estimate $5.500 $2, CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $5.570 $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $5.000 $2, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $6.000 $3, % L.FT. PERMANENT PAVEMENT MARKING (PAINTED) (WHITE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 133, $0.110 $14, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.090 $11, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $19, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.100 $13, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.100 $13, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.130 $17, % L.FT. PERMANENT PAVEMENT MARKING (PAINTED) (YELLOW) Bid Rank Department Estimate 98, $0.110 $10, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.090 $8, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $14, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.100 $9, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.100 $9, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.130 $12, % EACH PERMANENT PAVEMENT MARKING (PAINTED SYMBOL) (ARROW) Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $ N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $ % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $ % ACRE SEEDING (CLASS II) Bid Rank Department Estimate $3, $12, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $3, $15, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $4, $16, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $4, $19, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $4, $18, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $4, $18, % L.FT. EROSION CONTROL (WATTLES) (9") Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $1.750 $3, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $2.000 $3, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $2.000 $3, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $2.310 $4, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $2.000 $3, %

14 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 13 of L.FT. EROSION CONTROL (WATTLES) (9") Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $1.750 $3, FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $2.500 $4, % L.SUM MOBILIZATION Bid Rank Department Estimate $424, $424, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $375, $375, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $615, $615, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $430, $430, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $577, $577, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $548, $548, % L.FT. GUARD RAIL, W-BEAM, SINGLE FACE Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $ $26, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $22, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $26, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $27, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $26, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $33, % EACH GUARD RAIL TERMINAL (TANGENT TYPE) Bid Rank Department Estimate $2, $35, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $2, $36, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3, $49, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $3, $42, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $3, $47, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3, $45, % L.FT. RECONSTRUCT GUARDRAIL WITH NEW POSTS, BLOCKS, AND HARDWARE Bid Rank Department Estimate $ $5, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $ $6, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $ $8, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $ $7, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $ $7, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $ $8, % HOUR CONTRACTOR BASED ON-THE-JOB TRAINING Bid Rank Department Estimate 1, $3.000 $3, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $3.000 $3, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.000 $3, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $3.000 $3, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $3.000 $3, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $3.000 $3, %

15 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 14 of LB. MISCELLANEOUS WORK (SEAL CRACKS IN AC PAVEMENT)(POLYMER MODIFIED ASHPALT-RUBBER CRACK SEALANT) Bid Rank Department Estimate 6, $2.000 $12, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $2.000 $12, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $3.000 $18, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $3.750 $22, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $4.000 $24, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $6.500 $39, % L.SUM CONTRACTOR QUALITY CONTROL Bid Rank Department Estimate $31, $31, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $75, $75, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $125, $125, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $43, $43, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $55, $55, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $85, $85, % SQ.YD. MISCELLANEOUS WORK (CONTROL OF NOXIOUS PLANTS)(MANUAL/MECHANICAL METHODS) Bid Rank Department Estimate 7, $0.590 $4, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.900 $6, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $1.000 $7, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $1.130 $8, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $1.000 $7, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1.000 $7, % SQ.YD. MISCELLANEOUS WORK (CONTROL OF NOXIOUS PLANTS)(HERBICIDE) Bid Rank Department Estimate 9, $0.490 $4, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.300 $2, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.350 $3, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.500 $4, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.600 $5, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $1.000 $9, % L.SUM CONSTRUCTION SURVEYING AND LAYOUT Bid Rank Department Estimate $27, $27, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $25, $25, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $50, $50, % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $30, $30, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $40, $40, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $50, $50, % L.FT. GROUND-IN RUMBLE STRIP (6 INCH) Bid Rank Department Estimate 63, $0.120 $7, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.130 $8, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.100 $6, %

16 Printed: 5/23/2018 Page 15 of L.FT. GROUND-IN RUMBLE STRIP (6 INCH) Bid Rank Department Estimate 63, $0.120 $7, CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.130 $8, % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.100 $6, % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.100 $6, % L.FT. GROUND-IN RUMBLE STRIP (8 INCH) Bid Rank Department Estimate 6, $0.300 $1, N.G.U CONTRACTING, INC. $0.160 $1, % 2 FNF CONSTRUCTION, INC. $0.150 $ % 3 CKC CONSTRUCTION & MATERIALS LLC $0.130 $ % 4 FANN CONTRACTING, INC $0.100 $ % 5 FISHER SAND & GRAVEL CO. DBA SOUTHWEST ASPHALT PAVIN $0.250 $1, %