Mark Lutkenhoff, PIA for Asbestos, Physical Plant. From: Zach Hansmann, Environmental Coordinator, EHS

Transcription

1 MEMORANDUM To: Mark Lutkenhoff, PIA for Asbestos, Physical Plant From: Zach Hansmann, Environmental Coordinator, EHS Date: September 22, 2011 RE: Clinical Center Skim Coat Plaster Clarification: Bldg 200 Clinic Wing It was recently brought to my attention that the original Clinical Center building inspection performed by Fishbeck, Thompson, Carr, and Huber (FTC&H) in February of 2008 improperly sampled Homogenous Area number 7 - Drywall with paster skim coat. Specifically, samples were not collected from each building and building construction history was not taken into consideration. Of the eight original samples collected, only one tested positive for asbestos. This single positive sample was collected in building 202, which is not connected to builings 200 or 201 in any way. As a result of this poor inspection 359,980 square feet of this material was identified as asbestos containing material (ACM) throughout all three buildings. DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH AND SAFETY Office of Environmental Compliance Michigan State University 150 Giltner Hall East Lansing, MI / Fax: 517/ On September 14, 2011 I collected additional samples from building 200 in an attempt to further delineate the extent of the asbestos containing drywall and plaster skim coat. All samples collected in this building tested negative for asbestos. Please update your copies of the asbestos inspection report for Clinical Center Building 200 to identify HA #7 Drywall with plaster skim coat as a non-asbestos containing material. I have attached a bulk sample log, bulk sample analytical results, sample location maps, and a building history map to this memo. Please let me know if you have any questions. 9/22/ of 15

2 MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY - ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH AND SAFETY BULK SAMPLE LOG DATE: 9/14/2011 BUILDING: Clinical Center - Clinic Wing (Bldg #200) INSPECTOR: Zach Hansmann ASBESTOS TOTAL MATERIAL MATERIAL MATERIAL DETECTED* SAMPLE HA # FOOTAGE TYPE CONDITION F/NF ACM (Y/N) (Y/N) # SAMPLE LOCATION 1 N N 1-1 closet wall in A101B HA DESCRIPTION: NOTES: N 1-2 corner in A101 at service counter Skim plaster on corner bead 2 N HA DESCRIPTION: NOTES: Drywall with plaster skim coat N 2-1 closet wall in A101B N 2-2 northeast wall in A100A N 2-3 east wall above ceiling in A144A N 2-4 southeast wall in A143 N 2-5 east wall of A116 N 2-6 northeast corner of AM130 N 2-7 north corner in AM205 N 2-8 west walll in AM235 3 N N 3-1 drywall joint compound near stair 8 HA DESCRIPTION: NOTES: N 3-2 drywall joint compound outside A-117-MD Drywall joint compound N 3-3 drywall joint compound outside A-117-MD (AC2 door) HA DESCRIPTION: NOTES: HA DESCRIPTION: NOTES: Page 1 of 1 9/22/ of 15

3 BULK SAMPLE ANALYTICAL REPORT Fibertec IHS Project # NVLAP Accreditation # Client Name: Project Name: Summary: Michigan State University Clinical Center - A Wing 13 Submitted Bulk Samples, 29 Sample Layers Analyzed. Date Sampled: 9/14/2011 Client P.O. #: N/A Date Submitted: 9/14/2011 C.O.C. #: Date Analyzed: 9/15/2011 Fibertec Sample No. Client I.D. No. Description / Location Asbestos Type Non-Asbestos Containing Portion Analyst White granular material, skim plaster NAD Non-fibrous material 97% on corner bead, closet wall in Cellulose fibers 3% A101B White granular material, skim plaster NAD Non-fibrous material 97% on corner bead, corner in A101 at Cellulose fibers 3% service counter over plaster and drywall, closet wall in A101B. Layer 1 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 85% Cellulose fibers 15% Brown fibrous material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, closet wall in A101B. Layer 2 of 3. NAD Cellulose fibers 90% Non-fibrous material 10% White tabular material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, closet wall in A101B. Layer 3 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 97% Cellulose fibers 3% over plaster and drywall, NE wall in A100A. Layer 1 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 85% Cellulose fibers 15% Brown fibrous material, skim plaster NAD Cellulose fibers 90% over plaster and drywall, NE wall in Non-fibrous material 10% A100A. Layer 2 of Holloway Drive, Holt, Michigan Page 1 of 6 Telephone: (517) Facsimile: (517) /22/ of 15

4 BULK SAMPLE ANALYTICAL REPORT Fibertec IHS Project # NVLAP Accreditation # Client Name: Project Name: Summary: Michigan State University Clinical Center - A Wing 13 Submitted Bulk Samples, 29 Sample Layers Analyzed. Date Sampled: 9/14/2011 Client P.O. #: N/A Date Submitted: 9/14/2011 C.O.C. #: Date Analyzed: 9/15/2011 Fibertec Sample No. Client I.D. No. Description / Location Asbestos Type Non-Asbestos-Containing Portion Analyst White tabular material, skim plaster NAD Non-fibrous material 97% over plaster and drywall, NE wall in Cellulose fibers 3% A100A. Layer 3 of NAD Non-fibrous material 90% over plaster and drywall, E wall Cellulose fibers 10% above ceiling in A144A. Layer 1 of Gray cementitious material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, E wall above ceiling in A144A. Layer 2 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 97% Cellulose fibers 3% White tabular material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, E wall above ceiling in A144A. Layer 3 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 95% Cellulose fibers 5% over plaster and drywall, SE wall in A143. Layer 1 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 85% Cellulose fibers 15% Brown fibrous material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, SE wall in A143. Layer 2 of 3. NAD Cellulose fibers 95% Non-fibrous material 5% White tabular material, skim plaster NAD Non-fibrous material 97% over plaster and drywall, SE wall in Cellulose fibers 3% A143. Layer 3 of Holloway Drive, Holt, Michigan Page 2 of 6 Telephone: (517) Facsimile: (517) /22/ of 15

5 BULK SAMPLE ANALYTICAL REPORT Fibertec IHS Project # NVLAP Accreditation # Client Name: Project Name: Summary: Michigan State University Clinical Center - A Wing 13 Submitted Bulk Samples, 29 Sample Layers Analyzed. Date Sampled: 9/14/2011 Client P.O. #: N/A Date Submitted: 9/14/2011 C.O.C. #: Date Analyzed: 9/15/2011 Fibertec Sample No. Client I.D. No. Description / Location Asbestos Type Non-Asbestos-Containing Portion Analyst NAD Non-fibrous material 85% over plaster and drywall, E wall of Cellulose fibers 15% A116. Layer 1 of Brown fibrous material, skim plaster NAD Cellulose fibers 95% over plaster and drywall, E wall of Non-fibrous material 5% A116. Layer 2 of White granular material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, E wall of A116. Layer 3 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 95% Cellulose fibers 5% over plaster and drywall, NW corner of AM130. Layer 1 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 85% Cellulose fibers 15% Brown fibrous material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, NW corner of AM130. Layer 2 of 3. NAD Cellulose fibers 95% Non-fibrous material 5% White tabular material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, NW corner of AM130. Layer 3 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 95% Cellulose fibers 5% NAD Non-fibrous material 85% over plaster and drywall, N wall in Cellulose fibers 15% AM205. Layer 1 of Holloway Drive, Holt, Michigan Page 3 of 6 Telephone: (517) Facsimile: (517) /22/ of 15

6 BULK SAMPLE ANALYTICAL REPORT Fibertec IHS Project # NVLAP Accreditation # Client Name: Project Name: Summary: Michigan State University Clinical Center - A Wing 13 Submitted Bulk Samples, 29 Sample Layers Analyzed. Date Sampled: 9/14/2011 Client P.O. #: N/A Date Submitted: 9/14/2011 C.O.C. #: Date Analyzed: 9/15/2011 Fibertec Sample No. Client I.D. No. Description / Location Asbestos Type Non-Asbestos-Containing Portion Analyst Brown fibrous material, skim plaster NAD Cellulose fibers 95% over plaster and drywall, N wall in Non-fibrous material 5% AM205. Layer 2 of White tabular material, skim plaster NAD Non-fibrous material 95% over plaster and drywall, N wall in Cellulose fibers 5% AM205. Layer 3 of over plaster and drywall, W wall in AM235. Layer 1 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 85% Cellulose fibers 15% Brown fibrous material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, W wall in AM235. Layer 2 of 3. NAD Cellulose fibers 95% Non-fibrous material 5% White tabular material, skim plaster over plaster and drywall, W wall in AM235. Layer 3 of 3. NAD Non-fibrous material 95% Cellulose fibers 5% Tan granular material, drywall joint compound, near Stair 8. NAD Non-fibrous material 95% Cellulose fibers 5% Tan granular material, drywall joint NAD Non-fibrous material 92% compound, outside of A-117-MD. Cellulose fibers 8% 1914 Holloway Drive, Holt, Michigan Page 4 of 6 Telephone: (517) Facsimile: (517) /22/ of 15

7 BULK SAMPLE ANALYTICAL REPORT Fibertec IHS Project # NVLAP Accreditation # Client Name: Project Name: Summary: Michigan State University Clinical Center - A Wing 13 Submitted Bulk Samples, 29 Sample Layers Analyzed. Date Sampled: 9/14/2011 Client P.O. #: N/A Date Submitted: 9/14/2011 C.O.C. #: Date Analyzed: 9/15/2011 Fibertec Sample No. Client I.D. No. Description / Location Asbestos Type Non-Asbestos-Containing Portion Analyst Tan granular material, drywall joint NAD Non-fibrous material 95% compound, outside of A-114-MD Cellulose fibers 5% (ACZ door) Holloway Drive, Holt, Michigan Page 5 of 6 Telephone: (517) Facsimile: (517) /22/ of 15

8 Comments Bulk samples are analyzed using the USEPA Test Method EPA/600/R-93/116. The constituent percent reported represents an estimate of the area percent of the component. The test report relates only to items tested. This report is not intended to be used as a product endorsement by NVLAP or any agency of the U.S. Government. Fine fibers like those in floor tile may not be discernible by this method. This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written approval of the laboratory. Individual sample layers are homogeneous, unless otherwise noted. Test items were received in acceptable condition. Revision 4.0 dated 12/8/2010. If no asbestos was/were detected in the sample/samples the acronym NAD (no asbestos detected) will appear in the Asbestos Type column of the report. Approved Signatory: Date: 9/19/ Holloway Drive, Holt, Michigan Page 6 of 6 Telephone: (517) Facsimile: (517) /22/ of 15

9 TO BUILDING 201 AM100 78SF A102 93SF A108I A108H A108G A109A A109B 49SF A108J 134SF A108B A108C A108D A108E 140SF A110F 88SF A110C A108A 135SF AM SF A107 A108K 37SF A106B A SF A106C 203SF A106A 61SF A110G A110H A110I A110J 136SF A110K 199SF A110E 388SF A109C 31SF A100B 82SF A SF A100A 78SF A101C 98SF A144A 118SF AM142 86SF A101B 177SF A101A 1 A SF A140G A140H A140I A140J 136SF A SF A140K 30SF A140D A140C A140B A140A 151SF A142E 284SF A140F 284SF A138A 203SF A138C 61SF A138B A142D A142C A142B A142A 135SF A SF A SF A SF A141A A141B 49SF A141C 31SF A142H A142G A142I A142J 151SF A143 A142K 32SF A139 AM140 94SF A112A 72SF A114E A114F 128SF A114D A112D A113A 57SF A113B 179SF AM112 MECH 211SF A114A 72SF A114B A114C A114G 58SF A112AA 25SF A114L 66SF A114J A114H 173SF A115D A115C 143SF A115CA A115F 23SF A115E A115G 120SF A115K 37SF A115J 36SF A SF A115M 1560SF A114M A115B A117HB 73SF A117HA 83SF A115MA 211SF AM SF A116 43SF A117C 155SF A117 78SF A117D 44SF A117A 632SF A117F 153SF A117E 99SF A117H 290SF A117I 279SF A117G 36SF A117J 141SF A117P 99SF A SF A117N 92SF A117M 104SF A117L 104SF A117K 203SF A118F 128SF A118E 96SF A118D A118G 86SF A118B 83SF A118C 122SF A118A 167SF A118J 83SF A118K 88SF A SF A135A 399SF A135B 382SF AM SF A SF A137K 180SF A137L 98SF A134 MT 194SF A133 WT 274SF A131 64SF A130 87SF AM130 77SF A130A 46SF A130B 36SF A130C 164SF A SF HW1 1123SF HW2 1526SF HW3 354SF HW4 276SF HW6 932SF HW7 1200SF HW9 337SF HW10 607SF SW1 SW2 205SF SW3 178SF SW4 147SF SW11 159SF SW10 204SF SW9 SW8 192SF A118P 254SF A118H 88SF A118O 100SF A118M 95SF A118L 198SF A118N 100SF A118Q 110SF D100B 54SF D100C 74SF A128D A110D 83SF A110A 121SF A112C 467SF A112 A SF A SF A110B 97SF A SF A105 26SF A103A MT 176SF A103B WT 139SF A103C UT 62SF A111 A SF A108M 107SF A109D 381SF A109E 61SF A110M A108F 38SF A137J 139SF A137N A137M 280SF V1 41SF EP4 EP3 81SF EP2 77SF EP1 81SF HW17 191SF HW8 683SF HW5 243SF A SF A SF FIRST FLOOR PLAN - NORTH 200N S ORIG. DRAWN BY SHEET APPROVED BY DATE SCALE BUILDING NO. ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES PHYSICAL PLANT DIVISION OF LAST REVISED ON LAST REVISED BY LAST EXPORTED 12 DVC SDF " = 30' EJS O_0200_01_BASE.DWG Last Export Date: 7/15/2011 Filename: O_0200_01_BASE.dwg 9/22/ of 15

10 UP 6R A118A A118M A118H 95SF 167SF A118L 88SF 198SF A131 AM130 A118 64SF 77SF 540SF HW9 337SF EP4 A130 A118J A118K SW8 83SF 88SF 192SF 87SF HW10 D100B 607SF 54SF A SF D100C 74SF A130C 164SF A128D 51SF D100 D100A 1150SF 283SF A SF D102F 48SF A128A 66SF D102A 172SF D SF A127 A128B 290SF 59SF D102E 47SF A126 D102B 579SF 296SF D102D 68SF D102C 38SF D SF A125B 121SF A SF D105 A125A 228SF 274SF A SF A123 SW5 180SF 156SF D SF D108 99SF D SF FIRST FLOOR PLAN - SOUTH SW12 227SF D SF D118 53SF D SF D130A D130C 36SF 32SF D106 30SF D129 37SF D SF D125 39SF HW11 809SF D SF D130B D130D 32SF 36SF D128 80SF D127 2 D SF D SF D SF D120 2 D SF D134 50SF D SF D SF D141A 181SF E149 69SF E146 61SF E145 65SF E SF D SF D136 42SF D139 83SF E SF D120B 58SF D120A 56SF HW13 525SF E148 99SF D SF D157 13SF D137 23SF D SF D147 45SF D142A 1 D SF E155 1 E SF E142 52SF E130A E150A 47SF E138 81SF 45SF E SF E135A 136SF E SF HW16 207SF D SF HW14 58SF D151 48SF D SF E109 D SF E127A 65SF E SF D SF D146 46SF E107 E127B 97SF E120A 45SF E120B 231SF E127C 96SF E114 57SF E105 E SF E112A 52SF E SF E120C 579SF E127E 56SF E127D 606SF E SF E116 53SF E127G 14SF HW SF E103 E SF 1 SW7 160SF E127F 7SF TO RADIOLOGY E SF Last Export Date: 7/15/2011 Filename: O_0200_01_BASE.dwg SW6 211SF N S O_0200_01_BASE.DWG ORIG. DRAWN BY APPROVED BY DATE SCALE LAST REVISED ON LAST REVISED BY LAST EXPORTED BUILDING NO. SHEET 4 OF RJR " = 30' SDF DVC PHYSICAL PLANT DIVISION ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES 12 9/22/ of 15

11 Last Export Date: 5/8/2009 Filename: O_0200_MR1_BASE.dwg 9/22/ of 15

12 Last Export Date: 5/8/2009 Filename: O_0200_MR1_BASE.dwg 9/22/ of 15

13 A SF A235A 135SF A235B A235C A235D A235E 132SF A235F 130SF A235G A235H A235I 134SF A235J 147SF A SF A231A 59SF A231C 199SF A233G A233I A233J 136SF A233H A SF A233F 132SF A233E 130SF A SF A231B A234A A234B 49SF A234C 31SF A233D A233B A233A 151SF A233C A233K 30SF A232 A236 AM235 78SF A235K 32SF AM227 85SF A229 WT 200SF A230 MT 126SF A228 18SF A227I A227H A227G A227D A227C A227B A227A 135SF A SF A227K 32SF A227J 151SF A223A 59SF A223B A SF A223C 199SF A225G A225H A225I A225J 136SF A SF A225E 284SF A227F A227E 141SF A225D A225C A225B A225A 151SF A226C 31SF A226B 49SF A226A A SF AM225 94SF A219A 96SF A221B 212SF A221C 253SF A SF A220A 1 A SF A225K 30SF A224 A219AA 24SF A218 28SF A217KC 158SF A221A 79SF A217KA 144SF A217KE 149SF A217M 130SF A217MA 118SF A219B 140SF A217N 136SF A217O 135SF A217A 606SF A SF A217H 74SF A217G 103SF A217D 103SF A217C 74SF A217B 152SF A217CA 114SF A217E 82SF A217F 83SF A217HA 114SF A217I 153SF A217J 194SF A217KB 99SF A217L 93SF A217P 134SF A206G 127SF A206P 126SF A206N 111SF AM SF A206O 132SF A216 MT 206SF A201A 193SF A SF A202A 104SF A202G 153SF A202B 1558SF AM SF A202BA 339SF A SF A202E A202D A202C 136SF A202F 231SF A203K 126SF A203L 180SF A203M 45SF A203MA 30SF A203N A SF A203R 57SF A203YA 32SF A203XA 32SF A203Y A203X 95SF A203TA A203UA A203WA A203W A203F 206SF A203A 39SF A203B 28SF A203C 27SF A203T 74SF A203S 142SF A203J 47SF A203Z 168SF A203Q 84SF AM204A 212SF A203D 258SF A203E 1361SF A203P 17SF A203U 252SF A SF A204I 304SF A204TA 127SF A204TB 61SF A204T 442SF A204S 307SF A204O 315SF A204R 95SF A204M 206SF A204L 273SF A204K 582SF A204J 81SF A204KE 74SF A204U 109SF A204KB 62SF A204KA 84SF A204QAH 28SF A204QA 181SF A204Q 97SF A204RA 25SF A204RB 24SF A204RC 24SF A204N 361SF A204MA 15SF A204MB 14SF A204MC 14SF A204MD 14SF A204W 140SF A204KD 14SF A204C 149SF A204E 327SF A204H 79SF A204PA 181SF A204AA 28SF A204P 97SF A SF AM205 2 A205C 479SF A205A 25SF A205H 192SF A205HA 166SF A205HB 63SF A205K 2 A205M 85SF A205L 122SF A205N 86SF A205G 514SF A205F 144SF A205DB 76SF A205D 145SF A205DA 17SF A205E A205I 24SF A205B 727SF A205J A205P 21SF A205HC 89SF A205HD 93SF A206K 459SF A SF A206J 471SF A206D 223SF A206E 290SF A206F 78SF AM206 88SF A206B 55SF A206C A206A 172SF A206H 21SF A214B 269SF A209 89SF A SF A210 4 A208B 1086SF A214 WT 173SF A214AA 21SF SW1 158SF SW2 171SF SW3 156SF SW4 153SF SW11 161SF SW10 168SF SW9 156SF SW8 162SF HW1 2298SF HW2 14 HW3 2580SF HW4 654SF A217KD 167SF A206NA 26SF A206MA 26SF A215 WT 200SF A215A UT 63SF A SF EP1 72SF EP2 88SF EP3 81SF EP4 HW8 1200SF HW6 245SF HW9 594SF HW10 435SF HW7 564SF HW11 109SF A SF A233L 82SF A207C 73SF A207A A207B 72SF A206M 93SF A206Q 98SF A206L 95SF 200N S ORIG. DRAWN BY SHEET APPROVED BY DATE SCALE BUILDING NO. ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES PHYSICAL PLANT DIVISION OF LAST REVISED ON LAST REVISED BY LAST EXPORTED 5 12 DVC SDF " = 30' GHK O_0200_02_BASE.DWG Last Export Date: 7/15/2011 Filename: O_0200_02_BASE.dwg 9/22/ of 15

14 A205K SECOND FLOOR PLAN - SOUTH 200S A219B 140SF A SF A217O 135SF A217C 74SF A217D 103SF A217B 152SF A217E A217CA 82SF 114SF A215A 63SF A206N AM SF 198SF UT 200N202 ORIG A205H 192SF A205HA 166SF A205L A205HB 63SF 122SF A205HC HW10 89SF 435SF A206G A206F 127SF 78SF A206E A SF A206D 649SF 223SF A207C A207B 73SF 72SF A206B A206A 55SF 172SF A207 A207A 142SF A206C HW3 2580SF A206M 93SF A206P A206O AM206 EP4 126SF 132SF A206Q 88SF A206L 98SF 95SF A214B 269SF A209 A208 89SF 108SF A SF A210 4 A214AA 21SF A SF A SF A SF A213B 192SF A213A A212A 14SF 157SF HW5 549SF WT SW5 158SF A205G 514SF A206H 21SF A206J 471SF A206K 459SF A208B 1086SF AM SF SW8 162SF SW6 211SF Last Export Date: 7/15/2011 Filename: O_0200_02_BASE.dwg O_0200_02_BASE.DWG DRAWN BY APPROVED BY DATE SCALE LAST REVISED ON LAST REVISED BY LAST EXPORTED BUILDING NO. SHEET OF RJR 7/12/11 1" = 30' SDF DVC PHYSICAL PLANT DIVISION ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES 12 9/22/ of 15

15 9/22/ of 15