DR Call. Friday, January 26, 2018

Transcription

1 DR Call Friday, January 26,

2 Agenda Council News & Events Announcements/What s Coming Up? Issues/Topics Demand Response Update Resource Adequacy Update Diablo Canyon Decision CCA Resource Adequacy Policy Resolution E-4907 CAISO Update Discussion/Q&A 2

3 Council News & Events EM&V-NMEC Forum: How do NMEC, M&V and EM&V inter-relate in the new 60% third-party paradigm for energy efficiency? Tuesday, February 13 from 10:00am-5:00pm REGISTER to attend the webinar (in-person at the Pacific Energy Center is sold out) No-Host Happy Hour to Follow at Tempest 3

4 Council News & Events Save the Date! Council Spring Symposium April 26 at the David Brower Center, Berkeley Council s Fall Conference October 25 at the Scottish Rite Center, Oakland 4

5 Council News & Events Newsletters switching to Bi-Weekly Previously, they were every 3 weeks. Now they will be opposite our Policy Calls for more consistent updates Not receiving the Newsletter? kkimick@cedmc.org to be added to the list 5

6 CAISO Launches New Webpage Jan 24 CAISO launched new webpage to track historical and real-time GHG emissions from generation resources News Release New Webpage 6

7 SCE DRAM 4 RFO SCE DRAM 4 RFO Jan 25 RFO Launched (DRAM RFO Website) Feb 1 Pre-Bid Web Conference (Joint IOUs) 10:00am; Skype link (presentation only): Call-in Information: Dial-in: Participant Passcode: Feb 20 Offer Submittal Deadline; 12:00 Noon PT 7

8 SCE and SDG&E IDER Pilots Approved at December 14 CPUC meeting SDG&E IDER RFO Jan 10 RFO Launched (dedicated RFO website) Jan 26 Pre-Bid Conference (register on RFO website) Feb 9 Bids Due SCE IDER RFO Jan 12 RFO Launched (dedicated RFO website) Jan 19 Pre-Bid Conference (details TBA) Feb 1 Bids Due 8

9 What s Coming Up? Jan 26: SDG&E IDER Bidders Conference 1:00-4:00pm at CP East Auditorium A 8680 Balboa Ave, San Diego To register in-person, the following information to BOTH SDG&E and the IE: Company name, and Attendees names, titles and contact information IDERIncentivePilotRFO@semprautilities.com and Barbara.Sands@PAConsulting.com Attend by webinar, # password: Participant dial in (toll-free): (844) Conference ID / Meeting Number:

10 What s Coming Up? Jan 29: CAISO ESDER2 Implementation Call 1:00-2:00pm at Telephone Only: , code # Phase 2 implementation scheduled for 10/1/18 Impacts DR settlements baseline approvals, performance calculations, performance submittals Agenda and presentation will be posted here 10

11 What s Coming Up? Feb 2: CAISO Market Surveillance Committee 10am-5pm at CAISO Phone Participation: , Access Code: ## Web Connection: FRACMOO discussion on the agenda 11

12 What s Coming Up? Feb 5: PG&E Webinar on Residential AutoDR 10:00-11:00am Attend the webinar, meeting # Agenda: Participant dial in (800) Overview of Program Objectives of stakeholder process Draft timeline Next steps 12

13 What s Coming Up? Feb 7: CAISO FRACMOO Phase 2 Meeting 10:00am 4:00pm at CAISO, Folsom RSVP by COB Feb 5 if attending in person Documents available on FRACMOO webpage Written comments due Feb 21 initiativecomments@caiso.com 13

14 What s Coming Up? Feb 14 CPUC Workshop on managing the reliability cap (per D , OP 12) 10:00am-5:00pm at CPUC, Golden Gate Room Conference Phone Line: Participant Code: Proposals for managing the MWs under the cap Contact Garima.Vashishtha@cpuc.ca.gov by COB Friday, January 19 if you plan to present a proposal (prefer collaborations with other parties) 14

15 What s Coming Up? Feb 15 CPUC Workshop on DR pilot for low income customers (D , Page 146) 10:00am-5:00pm in CPUC Auditorium Conference Phone Line: Participant Code: Straw Proposal by January 31 General Agenda (More details to come) High-level guidelines and goals for $2.5 million DR pilot targeting low income/disadvantaged communities, as well as stakeholder ideas for pilot strategies. 15

16 Demand Response (R ) Customer Data Access Committee met 1/18 Updates on Solution 3: SCE expects Q2 implementation SDG&E on target for end of February launch PG&E finished development and testing; targeting February go-live date Expansion to Other DERs CPUC White Paper in the works What types of data do DERS need/what frequency? 16

17 Demand Response (R ) CDAC Next Steps: Feb 8 (target): Call to discuss White Paper with CDAC in advance of distribution to service list Early-Mid March: Next CDAC meeting 17

18 Demand Response (R ) Resolution E-4906 issued Jan 24; on CPUC agenda for March 1, 2018 Approves IOU prohibited resources restrictions for DR programs and associated Verification Plan Comments due February 19, 2018 See Comment Letter 18

19 Demand Response (R ) Highlights from Resolution E-4906: Customer attestations: Aggregators can use their own forms for existing customers in 2018; in future, use Utilities forms if there are changes Only submit one attestation form per attestation scenario for customers with multiple service accounts on one property Default Adjustment Value: Verification administrator should not approve customer s operational change; should be utility 19

20 Demand Response (R ) More Highlights from Resolution E-4906: All customers under the Type I violation scenario are bound by the 60-day cure period. Proposal to Install Meters and Loggers: DRAM exempt from cost burdens until 2020 DRAM cycle Sampling methodology: Sample customers within each program, rather than by program and attestations scenario as proposed by the consultant 20

21 Demand Response (A ) Filings to implement changes to DR programs to comply with D AL Protests due 2/12. SDG&E Advice Letter 3176-E (BIP) PG&E Advice Letter 5218-E (BIP) PG&E Advice Letter 5217-E (Smart-AC) SDG&E Compliance Filing (CBP Price Triggers) 21

22 Resource Adequacy (R ) Scoping Memo Issued January 18 Jan 30: Comments due Feb 16: Track 1 proposals for additional RA program changes for 2019 compliance year due February: ED workshop(s) Proceeding co-assigned to ALJ Peter Allen and ALJ Debbie Chiv. 22

23 Resource Adequacy (R ) Track 1: System, local and flexible capacity requirements for the next year and time-sensitive refinements to RA program CAISO FRACMOO 2 Part of Track 1 or 2 Refinements under consideration include: cost allocation issues due to load migration, reducing backstop procurement, updates to ELCC modeling, alignment of RA hours with CAISO availability assessment hours Track 1 to conclude by end of June

24 Resource Adequacy (R ) Track 2: Multi-Year local RA requirements and refinements to local area rules Track 2 is expected to conclude Dec 31, Will consider proposals (Due June 6, 2018) on further refinements to RA program Track 3: 2020 program year requirements for System, Local, and Flexible RA. CPUC may revisit RA counting rules for weather-sensitive and local demand response resources. Track 3 is expected to be concluded by June

25 Resource Adequacy (R ) Immediate Schedule: Jan 30: Comments on Ruling Feb 16: Track 1 proposals Feb 22-23: Workshop on Energy Division and party proposals March 7: Comments on workshop and proposals March 16: Reply Comments May 2018: Proposed Decision re Track 1 June 2018: Final Decision re Track 25

26 Diablo Canyon (R ) Final Decision adopted on Jan 11 Diablo Canyon to close Unit 1 by 2024, and Unit 2 by 2025 Referred all replacement procurement to IRP proceeding Employee retraining, retention approved Tax recovery for local jurisdictions not approved Proceeding is closed. 26

27 CCA Policy Notes Resolution E-4907 CCA implementation plans need to align with RA forecasting process to avoid cost-shifting of RA purchases made by the IOUs Establishes waiting period for new and expanding CCAs in order to align with RA process Helpful FAQ 27

28 CAISO Update January 16 ESDER Meeting Update Meeting materials on CAISO ESDER Initiative page Agenda Items: Review potential scope items for DR Presentation on Load Shift (STEM) Presentation on Battery Storage Project (Powin Energy) Presentation on Market Models for Batteries (PG&E) Review scope for Multiple-Use Applications Review scope for non-generator Resource 28

29 CAISO Update ESDER Meeting Scope Items for DR: High Priority Items: DR Modeling limitations Variable DR weather sensitive loads Removing single LSE requirement and DLA discussion Load Shift Lower Priority Items: Recognition of BTM electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) load curtailment 24x7 participation requirement for DERs 29

30 CAISO Update ESDER Meeting Items out of Scope: Wholesale market participation model for micro grid RDRR economic buy-back of day-ahead awards Long discussion on commitment cost enhancements suggested reading: DR and Storage Action Plan 30

31 CAISO Update ESDER Comments January 26: Council submitting comments on ESDER stakeholder meeting Support for CAISO prioritization of our top issues Concern about RA Scoping Memo not prioritizing weather sensitive loads Need to better understand (training?) if there are implications for PDR from commitment cost initiatives (CCE3 and CCEDEBE) 31

32 ESDER Comments (cont) Concern about load shift proposal Direct metering and ability to symmetrically increase and decrease load throughout the day Definition too narrow and creates resource preferences Support proposal to allow direct metering of EVSE for purposes of participating in PDR, and expand this option to other resources in the future Easy to implement due to MGO framework in place Ties into broader policy implications Continues CAISO's process to maximize the value of DERs, including sources of flexible consumption 32

33 Discussion + Q&A Thanks and see you in a couple weeks! 33