Status Working Group Balancing Users Group 30/03/17
Agenda 2017 workplan FCR: status project R1 Batteries afrr: status pilot project R2 Non CIPU mfrr: results of the new R3Standard and R3flex products mfrr: BidLadder pilot project status update FCR-aFRR-mFRR: extension of bilateral 2nd market possibilities 2
2017 Workplan
Overview 2017 Go Live Deliverable stakeholders WG balancing Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Okt Nov Dec R1 Batteries R2 Non-CIPU Transition phase I Transition phase II testing R3: Bid ladder/toe Design New CIPU? MVAR 2nd markets? Marginal Pricing for Bal. Energy RT bal. info Dyn. Dimensioning LFC Block Agreement Dossier Volume 2018 Balancing Rules 4
R1 batteries Scope Open R1 market to batteries New Rx availability control based on activation tests Harmonised market rules between CIPU & Non CIPU Transition period between 01/05 and 01/09 1/05 group concept/work around nomination procedure 1/09 new prequalification all assets 31/12 deadline automatic test signals/nomination procedure 5
R2 non CIPU Scope Actility/EDF Luminus/Next Kraftwerke 4 MW Down & 1MW Up (day) / 0,5 MW Up (night) TSO/DSO Toe/ Baselining / performance Real simulations Stakeholders involvement Dedicated workshop November/beginning December 6
R3 Scope Further development bid ladder Design processes for activation price for R3 non CIPU => go live dependent on Toe legal framework Stakeholders involvement May June discussion with stakeholders on new procedures Regular update on bid ladder developments 7
CIPU Scope New contractual framework: outage agent scheduling agent Redispatching service provider Red zones - > Quid ID constraints for IDPR Data exchange schedules & review procedures Prepare new BE Grid code Stakeholders involvement As from June dedicated TF new CIPU under umbrella of WG balancing End December publication Design Note?? 8
MVAR Scope Assess further development MVAR product for 2019 Compliancy design vs System Operations Guideline Stakeholders involvement Dependent on outcome internal assessment Detailed discussions with stakeholders as from Q4 2017 (?) 9
2nd markets Scope Assess extension ID 2 nd market for CIPU Assess development DA & ID 2 nd market for CIPU Deliverables 31/03 report on pro s and con s & implementation plan 31/12 implementation in function of plan Stakeholders involvement Draft conclusions on TF balancing 10/02 Consultation in Feb/March via list of questions 10
Marginal pricing for Bal Energy Scope Study on PAC for R2/R3 Implementation plan Pre-conditions/options Deliverables 31/12 consulted report Stakeholders involvement Q4 2017 11
RT balancing info Scope real time imbalance position per BRP Deliverables Study Project proposal Implementation plan Stakeholders involvement Q4 2017 TF balancing 12
Dynamic Dimensioning Scope Assess new dimensioning methodology Dynamic vs. static Deliverables 30/06 CBA 31/10 publication of PoC & implementation plan Stakeholders involvement TF balancing June & October (informative) Dedicated workshop early 2018 13
LFC Block agreement Scope Implementation SO GL Deadline mid 2018 Deliverables Dimensioning methodology process for reserve restoration Stakeholders involvement TF balancing December 14
Dossier volume & Balancing Rules Scope Volumes 2018 BR: implementation 1/1/2018 (2 nd markets, R3,.. (?) ) Planning Dossier volume Mid may: submission dossier volume to CREG by Elia June/July Consultation by CREG Planning Balancing Rules Early September: submission BR by Elia to CREG September/October: consultation by CREG 15
FCR: status project R1 Batteries
Scope of new FCR product design consulted in Q4 2016 In scope Out of scope Product opening to assets with limited energy Small assets: centralized frequency measurements & pool concept Market Rules Harmonization (CIPU/nonCIPU) New availability control DA/ID nomination process Capacity & energy tests New prequalification test & process Energy constraint Harmonization of activation control Contractual Harmonization Merge of GFA CIPU & non CIPU ID/DA secondary market (2017) virtual metering for small delivery points 17
FCR design implementation track Test signal via ICCP connection implemented at ELIA s side Publication final version GFA (03/04) Entry into force new GFA FCR All assets prequalified in FCR groups All tests on FCR groups triggered using ICCP connection march April May June July Aug Sept oct Nov Dec. 14/03 IT Workshop with market parties Deadline GFA signature (13/04) Transition period - prequalification Assets prequalified before 1 st may 17 have 4 months to pass new prequalification tests Supplier chose how he groups its current portfolio into FCR providing Groups Transition period implementation of automatic test signal at supplier s side Phone call + email unless ICCP requested by supplier before 31/12 One solution per supplier no combination of both options possible Phase A nomination process with XL files Phase B BMAP B2C Phase C BMAP 2018 B2B 18
afrr: status Pilot Project R2 Non CIPU
Pilot project R2 non-cipu Objective: assessment of participation of R2 non-cipu for the secondary reserves. Timings: Implementation and prequalification test: before the 23 rd of July Participation phase: July September Conclusion and drafting report: October December. Status Contracts signed with 3 partners: Actility, EDFLuminus and Next Kraftwerke o o Different technologies: Biogas, CHP, water pumps, 4 MW Down & 1 MW Up (07h00-19h00) and 0,5 MW (19h00-07h00) Real-time communications between partners and Elia is currently set up. Additional information to ARPs in practice: o o ARPs informed at beginning of the participation phase that there could be a possible activation in their perimeter. NEW: Before each Tuesday (17h00) of week (W+1) for week W, notification sent by Elia to the concerned ARPs concerning aggregated impact per 1/4h in their balancing perimeter of activated energy of R2 non CIPU resources based on BSP information (indicative, not used for remuneration). Deliverable: Final report shall be published by end 2017 20
mfrr: results of new R3Standard and R3Flex products
Result first 4 months of R3 flex and R3 standard tender New products: attracted new volumes with, as a result, a good liquidity Market dynamics: offered volumes are moving upwards while reservation prices are moving downwards 22
mfrr: BidLadder Pilot Project status update
BidLadder Pilot Project Status Update About the contractual/regulatory framework: ARP-contract o Approval by CREG and VREG o Formal notification of contract update towards ARPs ongoing General Framework Tertiary Control Non-Reserved Power (i.e. the Bidladder contract ) o Public consultation ongoing (8/3/2017 31/3/2017), cf. Elia website Balancing rules: CREG decision awaited General Framework R3 non-cipu will be reviewed as well as from end of April, but only for aspects linked to Combo R3- BidLadder About the GO-Live: GO-Live on 1/7/2017 IT-implementation for ProBid communication can start as from now (requirements available on elia.be) Simulation test can start as from 22/05 No Transfer of Energy, therefore only the following two situations are allowed: o market party that has signed GFA (i.e. BSP) = Supplier = BRPsource = BRP of market party that has signed GFA o a pure bilateral agreement covering all ToE-related aspects exists between the above mentioned parties 24
FCR-aFRR-mFRR: Extension of bilateral 2 nd market possibilities
Context As Is and possible implementation The bilateral 2 nd market for reserve allows BSPs to bilaterally exchange reserve obligation D-1 13:30 As Is 2 nd Market DA Transfer of R1, R2, R3 Only for CIPU units Possible implementation Market opening Open to non CIPU units D-1 16:30 H-1 2 nd Market ID Transfer of R1, R2, R3 Only for CIPU units Only in case of FO Market opening Open to non CIPU units Extension outside FO for CIPU 26
Milestones 10/02: TF Bal 1 - present solution - request feedback 30/03: TF Bal 2 present feedback & conclusion 07/04: Publish study on feedback and conclusion Jan Feb March April December Go Live Study & collect feedback WG Balancing Implementation 27
Implementation proposal following stakeholder survey Different scenario proposed to the stakeholders Scenario C (full opening of bilateral 2 nd market) satisfies stakeholders and will be implemented 28
Status TFiSR Users Group 30/03/17
Taskforce Implementation Strategic Reserve (1/3) Taskforce isr 7/02/2017: Ministerial Decree fixing the volumes for winter 2017/2018 and beyond: Elia explained its understanding of the Ministerial Decree and how this would be incorporated in the tendering procedure: It gives instruction to Elia to constitute a strategic reserve of 900MW for three years; There is no distinction between production and The volume is firm for winter 2017-2018, but can be pro-rata modified for winter 2018-2019 and 2019-2020 if production units return to the market. Procedure for Constitution for Strategic Reserve Elia presented the results of the public consultation on the Procedure for Constitution for Strategic Reserve Elia presented the Calendar for the SR 2017 tender The call for Candidates was launched on 15/2 The call for tender was launched on 15/3 30
Taskforce Implementation Strategic Reserve (2/3). Functioning rules 2017/2018 Elia explained the changes its has proposed as answered in the Creg public consultation on the draft decision There was no final Creg decision at that date. Following The final Creg decision (9/2/2017) additional changes have to be introduced in Functioning rules: The exclusion of SDR delivery points that offered Ancillary Services in the past (since 1/11/2015), to participate in SDR from 1/11/2018 (existing points can be switched twice a year) The intention to exclude SDR delivery points from participating in Ancillary Services as from 1/11/2017 (to be defined by Balancing Rules) The request by Creg for additional chapter in Functioning rules fixing the modalities for SGR units that would return to the market This addendum has been introduced to Creg by Elia on 17/3. Creg took draft decision on 23/3 and launched public consultation. Elia organised ad hoc isr taskforce (30/3) to inform stakeholders. 31
Taskforce Implementation Strategic Reserve (3/3) Working Group : Demand Response Study Elia launched a working group demand Response Study with the aim of establishing a methodology to asses Demand Response participation in the context of the yearly adequacy assessment. The consultant E-Cube was selected to assist in this project. The volume of market based Demand Response will be taken into account when assessing the volume needs for Strategic Reserves for winter 2018/2019 and beyond. A methodology will be proposed to the isr taskforce of April 20th. The Study itself will be conducted in May and June 2017 and final results will be presented beginning of July. Until now 4 workshops with interested stakeholders have been held and 2 more are planned. 32
deadlines in Procedure for Constitution 2017 Entry into force Ministerial Decree 15/1/2017 Call for Tender 15/3/2017 Elia report analysis offers 1/6/2017 Contracts signed 31/10/2017 Call for Candidates 15/2/2017 Deadline Submission offers 18/4/2017 CREG advice reasonability prices 14/7/2017 2017 jan feb mrt apr mei jun jul aug sep okt nov dec 2017 20/3/2017 Request certification SDR Pref 7/4/2017 Certification issuing 29/5/2017 Checklist Submetering & CDS 18/8/2017 Deadline Order Submeter 7/3/2017 Submission Application 15/2/2017 Publication final Functioning Rules & Procedure for Constitution 16/10/2017 Deadline Submeter Commissioning 33