INNOVATIVE PROJECT FIA LBIP Project 6218029 Report: SCHIRP: Second Broadcast Fertilization Application. March, 2004 Annette van Niejenhuis, RPF Tree Improvement and Research Coordinator Western Forest Products Limited Saanich Forestry Centre 8067 East Saanich Road Saanichton, BC V8M 1K1
Executive Summary Forest productivity of many coastal forests has been improved by fertilizer application. The Salal Cedar Hemlock Integrated Research Program (SCHIRP) was launched to verify and quantify this response. The R600 SCHIRP installation was established to determine the response of conifers to fertilization applications during stand establishment. This installation includes two species, western redcedar and western hemlock, on two ecosystems, the S1ch and S1ha on northern Vancouver Island receiving either no fertilizer or a full fertilization regime. The project addresses the problem of predicting response to silviculture treatments; the number one problem identified in British Columbia s 2000 gap analysis, and will assist in investment decisions. Analysis of the 15-year foliar nutrient concentrations indicated that all treated plots were moderately to severely nutrient deficient for nitrogen. Foliar nutrient concentrations of phosphorous revealed slightly deficient to adequate levels. Thus, a broadcast application of nitrogen was undertaken. Introduction Forest productivity is improved by the deployment of fertilizers in many ecosystems. Greater volume and value of wood at final harvest and reduced time to operability are realized from this treatment. This has been welldocumented for Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco), particularly in mid- to late-rotation (Miller and Harrington 1979, Miller and Reukema 1974, Miller and Pienaar 1973). Other benefits include reduced time to freedom from regulatory adjacency constraints when fertilizer is applied to stands during the stand establishment phase. Salal-dominated ecosystems in the stand establishment phase have proven to respond favourably to fertilizer applications on northern Vancouver Island (Blevins and Prescott 2002, Bradley et al 2000, Prescott and Brown 1998, Prescott 1996, Prescott and Weetman 1994, Weetman et al 1994, Weetman et al 1989). The favourable response initially reported from northern Vancouver Island studies for time of plant treatment has been confirmed for these ecosystems on the west coast of Vancouver Island. The response to fertilization at the sapling stage has been illustrated by western hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla (Raf.) Sarg.), western redcedar (Thuja plicata Donn ex D. Don), and Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis (Bong.) Carr.) on northern Vancouver Island, and confirmed in operational fertilization monitoring plots on southern Vancouver Island (van Niejenhuis 2003) and central Vancouver Island (van Niejenhuis 2004). The SCHIRP installation is a long-term project that has seen significant investment and repeated monitoring since its establishment in 1988. This trial is the oldest of a set of trials looking at the question of improving productivity on these site types. Analysis of the 15 year data indicates that the phosphorous treatment effect is still apparent in foliar analysis, and slightly deficient or adequate levels of foliar phosphorous are reported (Negrave 2004). However, the nitrogen treatment effect, as expected from results of the demonstration trials (Blevins and Prescott 2002), is no longer apparent on S1ch sites (Negrave 2004). Comparison of the foliar nitrogen content in the summaries provided by Negrave (2004) indicate that though a fertilizer effect is still apparent on the S1ha plots, moderate to very severe nitrogen deficiency is indicated here as well (Ballard and Carter 1986). This project addresses the problem of predicting response to silviculture treatments, the number one problem identified in British Columbia s 2000 gap analysis. This is re-iterated in the Forest Productivity Council s Forest Productivity Strategy for 2001 2005. There the criteria to determine forest productivity priorities are listed as The potential influence that project or activity results may have on supply of timber and non-timber resources. Influence on forest management investment decisions. These projects will provide information to these criteria. Forest managers dealing with these site types continually seek the latest information to assist in the development of best management practices for these site types. Objectives Western Forest Products Limited has championed fertilizer research in coastal British Columbia for nearly two decades. This project will continue that work by implementing the fertilization recommendations of the 15-year analysis. This will effectively deliver the full fertilizer treatment to all initially fertilized plots in the trial. Page 2
Methods The SCHIRP Installation consists of two interlocking (one set of control plots used for both trials) randomized block designs examining species, planting density, scarification, and fertilization on two ecosystems. Details of the design and rationale are included in previous SCHIRP publications (Negrave 2004, Blevins and Prescott 2002, Prescott 1996, Prescott and Weetman 1994). This design will be maintained with nitrogen re-fertilization of all treatment plots. Hand application of urea occurred between February 12 and March 24 of 2004. The rate was nitrogen at 225 kg/ha. Amounts of urea were weighed, packaged, and labelled for each plot, as per Table 1. Table 1: Urea applications. Density Plot Area Urea (%N) Kg N (@225 kg/ha) Kg Urea per plot (@ 225 kg N/ha) # Plots Total Urea (kg) Total Area (ha) 500 sph 2,880 m 2 46.6 64.8 139 16 2,224 4.6 1500 sph 1,764 m 2 46.6 39.69 85 16 1,360 2.8 2500 sph 1,296 m 2 46.6 29.16 63 32 2,016 4.1 5,600 11.6 Results All treatment plots (F1) received a second broadcast fertilization treatment before the 2004 growing season. The treatment regime for treated plots is summarized in the workplan summary (APPENDIX 1). No changes are noted for the map, as all F1 plots and buffers were fully fertilized as per prescription. The map is appended to the report. Discussion and Conclusion The SCHIRP installation provides valuable information and aids the development of the forest fertilization strategy on northern Vancouver Island. This latest fertilizer application completes the intended fertilization regime, as defined at this time. Further monitoring will verify whether this fertilization strategy is adequate. Further monitoring will also verify the projected volume response from this fertilization strategy. To date this installation adequately compared the many factors in this factorial design. This second broadcast treatment cannot be tested against plots with only a single broadcast treatment and the controls, because the design did not conceive of this at the outset. Too few replicates would be available, and the design would fail. Operational fertilization monitoring plots may provide some answers to this, but again replication limits those findings. This will be discussed with the silvicultural foresters and the SCHIRP research team to determine the value in providing further information to this issue. Page 3
Literature Cited Ballard, T.M. and R.E. Carter. 1986. Evaluating forest stand nutrient status. Prov. B.C. Land Management Report Number 20. 60 pp. Bradley, R.L., B.D. Titus, C.M. Prescott, and J.N. Bennett. 2000. Improvement of nutritional site quality 13 years after single application of fertiliser N and P on regenerating cedar-hemlock cutovers on northern Vancouver Island, B.C. Plant and Soil 223: 195 206. Blevins, L.L. and C.E. Prescott. 2002. Salal Cedar Hemlock Integrated Research Program Update #2: Silviculture practices for regeneration of cedar-hemlock sites in coastal British Columbia. Fac. For. U.B.C. Vancouver, B.C. 62 pp. Miller, R.E. and C.A. Harrington. 1979. Response to urea and ammonium nitrate fertilization in an 80-year-old Douglas-fir stand. USDA For. Serv. PNW Res. Note PNW-330. 5 pp. Miller, R.E. and D.L. Reukema. 1974. Seventy-five-year-old Douglas-fir on High-quality site respond to nitrogen fertilizer. USDA For. Serv. Res. Note PNW-237. Miller, R.E. and L.V. Pienaar. 1973. Seven-year response of 35-year old Douglas-fir to nitrogen fertilization. USDA For. Serv. Res. Pap. PNW-165. 24 pp. Negrave, R.W. 2004. Effects of establishment density, fertilization, and scarification on growth and foliar nutrient concentrations of juvenile western redcedar and western hemlock plantations on CH and HA sites. Unpubl. Doc. FIA LBIP 6218025. Prescott, C.E. 1996. Salal Cedar Hemlock Integrated Research Program Update #1: December 1996. Fac. For. U.B.C. Vancouver, B.C. 49 pp. Prescott, C.E. and S.M. Brown. 1998. Five-year growth response of western redcedar, western hemlock, and amabilis fir to chemical and organic fertilizers. Can. J. For. Res. 28: 1328 1334. Prescott, C.E. and G.F. Weetman. 1994. Salal Cedar Hemlock Integrated Research Program: A Synthesis. Fac. For. U.B.C. Vancouver, B.C. 85 pp. van Niejenhuis, A. 2004. TFL 19 fertilization treatment impacts : salal-dominated cedar hemlock stands. Unpubl. Doc. FIA LBIP 6219012. van Niejenhuis, A. 2003. Jordan River Operational Fertilization Monitoring. Two Year Interim Report. Unpubl. Doc. Weetman, G.F., R. Fournier, J. Barker, and E. Schnorbus-Panozzo. 1989. Foliar analysis and response of fertilized chlorotic western hemlock and western redcedar reproduction on salal-dominated cutovers on Vancouver Island. Can. J. For. Res. 19: 1512 1520. Page 4
APPENDIX 1: Workplan summary. Year Activity Rationale / Comment <1988 Screening trials, demonstration trials, literature reviews, needs assessment. fertilization treatments. 1987-88 Establishment of area-based fertilization and scarification trials for volume analysis: Plant 128 plots 4 reps Cw F0 Sc0 CH 2500 sph 4 reps Cw F1 Sc0 CH 2500 sph 4 reps Cw F0 Sc1 CH 2500 sph 4 reps Cw F1 Sc1 CH 2500 sph 4 reps Cw F0 Sc0 CH 1500 sph 4 reps Cw F1 Sc0 CH 1500 sph 4 reps Cw F0 Sc0 CH 500 sph 4 reps Cw F1 Sc0 CH 500 sph 4 reps Hw F0 Sc0 CH 2500 sph 4 reps Hw F1 Sc0 CH 2500 sph 4 reps Hw F0 Sc1 CH 2500 sph 4 reps Hw F1 Sc1 CH 2500 sph 4 reps Hw F0 Sc0 CH 1500 sph 4 reps Hw F1 Sc0 CH 1500 sph 4 reps Hw F0 Sc0 CH 500 sph 4 reps Hw F1 Sc0 CH 500 sph 4 reps Cw F0 Sc0 HA 2500 sph 4 reps Cw F1 Sc0 HA 2500 sph 4 reps Cw F0 Sc1 HA 2500 sph 4 reps Cw F1 Sc1 HA 2500 sph 4 reps Cw F0 Sc0 HA 1500 sph 4 reps Cw F1 Sc0 HA 1500 sph 4 reps Cw F0 Sc0 HA 500 sph 4 reps Cw F1 Sc0 HA 500 sph 4 reps Hw F0 Sc0 HA 2500 sph 4 reps Hw F1 Sc0 HA 2500 sph 4 reps Hw F0 Sc1 HA 2500 sph 4 reps Hw F1 Sc1 HA 2500 sph 4 reps Hw F0 Sc0 HA 1500 sph 4 reps Hw F1 Sc0 HA 1500 sph 4 reps Hw F0 Sc0 HA 500 sph 4 reps Hw F1 Sc0 HA 500 sph Determine the probability of response of Cw and Hw to Determine the effect of fertilization and scarification on salaldominated second-growth plantations. Fertilizer Application: 60 g Nutricoat controlled release fertilizer raked into a 15 cm radius around each seedling at planting. (N @ 10 g, P @ 2.5 g, K @ 5 g) 1988 1-yr Measures and height analysis 1989 2-yr Measures and height analysis 1990 3-yr Measures and height analysis 1992 5-yr Measures and height analysis Very significant fertilizer effects indicated, continue with project to quantify results. Foliar nutrient analysis 1993 (spring) Broadcast fertilizer application (hand): All F1 plots treated. 1994 SCHIRP Synthesis Extension 1994 7-yr Measures and height analysis 1996 SCHIRP Update 1 Extension Nutrient analysis indicated need for N and P on all treatment plots. Prescription based on screening trial results: N @ 225 kg/ha, P @ 75 kg/ha, Urea ammonium phosphate.. Page 5
Year Activity Rationale / Comment Field Guide Extension 1997 10-yr measures and volume Very significant fertilizer effects analysis indicated, significant scarification effects, continue with project. 1999 Workshop Extension 2002 SCHIRP Update 2 Extension Workshop Extension Stand Management Co-operative Extension Tour Stop 15-yr measures Foliar nutrient measures 2003 BC J.E.M. Stand Establishment Decision Aid (SEDA) Extension 2004 15-yr Volume analysis Very significant fertilizer effects indicated, continue with project to verify volume projections. Foliar nutrient analysis 2004 (spring) Broadcast fertilizer application (hand). All F1 plots treated. Future plans 2004 CSC Tour Extension 2005 Workshop Extension 17-yr Volume analysis 2007 20-yr Volume analysis 2008 Workshop Extension 2012 25-yr Volume analysis Nutrient analysis indicated need for N on many treatment plots. Prescription based on screening trial results. Urea @ N 225 kg/ha. This workplan does not include the associated ecological studies, including mycorrhizae, soil fauna, and others that have been carried out at this installation and reported in numerous publications. These associated trials have added to the knowledge and understanding of the ecosystems in question. For more information and copies of many of the reports, go to http://www.forestry.ubc.ca/schirp/homepage.html. Page 6