Building Maintenance Brian Wood, DipArch MCMI RIBA MRICS MBIFM FCIOB Department of Real Estate and Construction School of the Built Environment Oxford Brookes University )WILEY-BLACKWELL A John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., Publication
Contents Foreword by Professor Jim Smith Preface Acknowledgements xiii xiv xv 1 Introduction 1 Arrangement of this book 1 Problems 2 Checklists 2 Maintenance: what is it; what is it for? 3 Definitions 3 Shortcomings of definitions 5 Purposes of building maintenance 6 Context of building maintenance 7 Political 8 Economic 13 Social 14 Technological 15 Environmental 17 18 19 2 Design temptations 21 Design standards 27 Design team 29 Design quality 33 35 35 3 Maintenance planning 36 Strategy 36 What, where, when, how, (and how often), who and why 40 Why a maintenance plan? 40 What? 41
vi Q Contents Where? When? How? Who? Communication Case study: estate strategy in a UK university Background Issues Proposal Progress Assessment The client The key decision maker Reminder: the client pays the bills Wants and needs How to determine and differentiate wants and needs Practical application: example scenario Seeking advice When to seek advice? How often to seek advice How soon to seek advice From whom to seek advice Giving advice Taking advice Useful websites Expectations Functionality Standards Overproduction Transportation Waiting Inventory Motion Overprocessing Defects and rework Other 'wastes' Customer service Needs of the future: looking ahead A worked example - developing a checklist related to expectations Case study: maintenance delivery in a UK university Organisational context Priorities Monitoring and reporting 42 42 44 46 49 50 50 50 51 51 52 53 53 54 54 55 56 58 60 64 64 65 65 65 66 66 67 67 67 68 68 69 70 70 71 71 72 72 73 73 74 11 79 79 79 81 82
Contents vii Reflection 82 83 83 Websites 84 6 Day-to-day prioritisation 85 Basics 85 Getting by 85 Putting off 86 Maintenance and building inheritance 87 Heritage 87 The helpdesk 88 Today's needs 89 Tomorrow 89 Possible future scenarios 89 Major works 90 Minor works 91 The Intermediate form 92 Capital projects 92 Revenue works 93 Capitalised repairs 93 Planned maintenance 94 Response maintenance 94 Checklist application 95 Budgets, costs and contracts 96 Contracts 97 Procurement 98 Decision making and recording 98 100 100 7 Deterioration 102 Weather and climate 102 Processes 103 Rain and snow 104 Damp 105 Wind 107 Sun/ultraviolet light 108 Temperature changes 108 Durability 110 Decay 111 Wear and tear 113 Projecting from past performance 114 Data vs. information 115 Limitations 116 Functional obsolescence 117 Case study: a local authority 118 Background 118 Issues 119
viii Contents Action 119 Findings 120 Reflection 120 121 121 8 Building defects and avoidance 122 Avoidance of defects 123 Defects at the inception/pre-design stage 123 Defects at the design stage 124 Defects occurring during the construction stage 127 Defects while the building is in occupation 130 How to avoid defects 131 'Zero defects' 131 Repair/replace decisions 134 Specifications 135 137 138 Useful websites 138 9 Organising maintenance works 139 Organisation 139 Direct labour 139 Specialist contractors 142 General contractors 143 Selecting contractors 143 Procurement 144 Prices and pricing 144 Schedules of rates 145 Tenders and tendering 147 Contracts 147 Service level agreements 148 Case study: innovative building maintenance in a supermarket chain 148 Background 148 Context 148 Issues 149 Findings 149 Wider application 149 Statutory requirements 150 Development control: town and country planning 150 Building control: Building Regulations 151 Health and safety: Construction Design and Management Regulations 151 Work in progress 152 Supervision 153 Inspection 153 Payments 154 Feedback 154 155 155
Contents IX 10 Defect recognition and rectification: General Inspection Why? How? When? Where? Who should inspect? What is to be done? Recognition Recording Reporting Recognising, recording and reporting condition Extent Priority Rectification Defect rectification specifications Execution Follow-up Checklist: defect recognition and rectification 11 Defect recognition and rectification: Foundations, basements and external works Outline: general arrangement Symptoms Possible causes Rectification Avoidance Foundations Cracks Ground conditions Underpinning Avoidance of problems in future Basements and cellars Water table Underground streams Cracked pipes and drains Tree roots Ventilation Sloping sites External works Freestanding walls Retaining walls Fences Paths Steps and ramps Parking Soft landscaping Common areas generally 157 157 158 158 159 160 160 160 161 162 162 163 164 164 165 166 166 167 167 167 169 170 170 170 171 171 172 172 173 173 175 176 176 176 177 178 178 179 179 180 180 181 182 183 184 186 187 188
x ii Contents Useful websites 12 Defect recognition and rectification: External walls, doors and windows External walls and frames Symptoms and possible causes Rectification work Concrete Claddings Windows and external doors Swelling and sticking Shrinkage and gaps Distortion Weathering and detailing Metal windows Bay windows Doors Glass and glazing Double and triple glazing; replacement doors and windows; PVCu Cills, heads, reveals and canopies Decorations 13 Defect recognition and rectification: Chimneys, roofs and roofspaces, rainwater disposal Chimneys Pitched roofs Slates Clay tiles Concrete tiles Asbestos cement slates and sheets Fibre-cement Sheet metal roofs Other roofing materials Roof forms and related details Valleys Eaves Dormer windows and other penetrations Steps - flashings Gables Attics and roofspaces Pitched roof structures Flat roofs Lead Felt Asphalt Insulation 189 189 190 191 191 191 201 203 205 207 207 210 210 210 211 212 212 213 213 214 214 216 216 219 219 221 222 224 225 226 227 227 227 227 228 228 231 232 233 233 233 236 236 236 237 238
Contents xi 14 15 16 17 Protection Green roofs Rainwater disposal Helpful website Defect recognition and rectification: Floors, stairs and internal walls Ground floors Floor finishes Intermediate floors Stairs Handrails and balustrading Means of escape; protected routes Internal walls and finishes Defect recognition and rectification: Building services Plumbing: water, waste and soil Gas Gas usage Electrical and communication systems Heating, ventilation and air-conditioning Fire, security and other specialist services Security Upgrading and improvement Changing standards Incremental change Exponential change Step change Local or international standards What do we want? Similar organisations How to decide? How far to go? Move or improve? Mini case study Checklist The rehabilitation process Preparation Briefing Time: the essence 238 239 239 244 245 246 247 247 248 249 250 250 251 251 252 252 254 254 258 258 259 260 261 262 262 262 264 264 265 266 266 268 269 270 271 271 272 273 274 274 274 276 276 276 277
xii o Contents Place 278 Specifications 279 Decanting 279 Work in progress 281 Preparing to move back 282 Check 283 283 284 18 New life in the building 285 How was it for you? 285 The learning organisation 286 Techniques and timings 286 Periodic overview 287 Annual review 289 Formal feedback 291 Post-occupancy evaluation (POE) 292 Pros and cons: why POE? 293 Who should do POE? 294 Monitoring and refreshing 295 Documentation 296 Refreshing the building 296 Refreshing the organisation and staff 297 Time and tide 298 Checklist 298 299 299 Index 301