Worker, Operator, Bystander and Resident Exposure and Risk Assessment

Similar documents
Worker, Operator, Bystander and Resident Exposure and Risk Assessment

Food Safety and Dietary Risk Assessment

DIE AKADEMIE FRESENIUS

Behaviour of Pesticides in Air, Soil and Water

Aquatic and Terrestrial Ecotoxicology and Risk Management

Environmental Risk Assessment of Biocides

FOOD SAFETY AND DIETARY RISK ASSESSMENT

Behaviour of Pesticides in Air, Soil and Water

Behaviour of Pesticides in Air, Soil and Water

Aquatic and Terrestrial Ecotoxicology and Risk Management

BEHAVIOUR OF PESTICIDES IN AIR, SOIL AND WATER

BEHAVIOUR OF PESTICIDES IN AIR, SOIL AND WATER

Novel Food. Updated Programme. The Experts

Biopesticides Biofertilisers Biostimulants

Health Claims and Functional Ingredients

Assessment, Regulation, Testing, Modelling and Prediction

Pesticide Residues in Food

Residues of Food Contact Materials in Food

Manuela Tiramani. European Conference on Safe Use of Plant Protection Products June 18 19, Berlin

DIE AKADEMIE FRESENIUS

Nanomaterials DIE AKADEMIE FRESENIUS. 27 and 28 November 2018 in Mainz/Germany. Where Experts Meet!

TOPICS: THE EXPERTS: 27 and 28 November 2012 Mainz (near Frankfurt)/Germany. Mixture Toxicity on 26 November 2012 (optional) New: Breakout Session on

PPE for Pesticide Operators: Risk Assessment, PPE Requirements and Labeling

Aggregate Exposure: Acropolis and links to other projects

Computer Validation - Introduction to Risk Management - The GAMP 5 Approach

TRENDS IN FILLING TECHNOLOGY

DIE AKADEMIE FRESENIUS

Computer Validation - Introduction to Risk Management - The GAMP 5 Approach

ICH Q 9 Training Course November 2015, Heidelberg, Germany. ICH Q 10 Training Course November 2015, Heidelberg, Germany ECA

Improve your Quality Reviews

GPA Europe. Sponsor us here. Questions? For any additional information, please contact: Stay up to date with us. GPA Europe Newsletter >> Follow us

Computer Validation - Introduction to Risk Management - The GAMP 5 Approach

Invitation to the Seminar on Risk Management in International Factoring Mexico City, Mexico December 2015

@ Privacy Policy: By registering for this event, I accept the processing

Behaviour of Pesticides in Air, Soil and Water

Public Procurement Requirements for ESI Funds

GMP-compliant Product Transfer

Feed Safety 10 YEARS. International Fresenius Conference. 27 to 28 October 2005 Cologne/Germany. Highlights: DIE AKADEMIE FRESENIUS

ABCUL Annual Conference & AGM 2011

Audit Trail Review for Computerised Systems in Analytical Laboratories

Cumulative assessment groups, their implementation in the nondietary risk assessment and their timelines

please fill out here:

EU Law for Non-Lawyers

Main Sponsor: partners profesional: media partners:

Isolator Technology Workshop Engineering - Validation - Operation

GMP meets Regulatory Affairs

Sponsor & Exhibit Opportunities MSC User Meeting D-A-CH May 13-14, Berlin, Germany

Requirements for a GMP-compliant Data Life Cycle May 2016, Berlin, Germany. Karl-Heinz Menges Regierungspräsidium Darmstadt

european cement research academy Programme 2011 Seminars, training course and conference

OSHA 10-Hour AND OSHA 30-Hour General Industry Voluntary Compliance Courses

International SAP Conference for Product Safety and Stewardship. September 30 - October 1, 2013, Frankfurt, Germany

REGISTRATION FORM. The EMBO Meeting September 2013 in Amsterdam

Machinery for Pesticide Application: Impoving spraying equipment to achieve sustainable use of pesticide

Establishing the Self Inspections and Controls for Ensuring Audits to Confirm Effective Laboratory Data Integrity, Data Integrity Controls,

Update on Chinese food contact standard framework

5 to 8 June 2012 Château de Neuville-Bosc, near Paris, France

Information & Registration

GMP for Medical Devices

The Caribbean Association of Judicial Officers Conference Port of Spain, Trinidad June 25 27, 2009

8 th Seminar in the series: EU Banking and Financial Law: The State of Integration in the EU Financial Sector

Statistical Design Space Development from Design of Experiment to granules Expert of Solids Certification Seminar March 11 to 12, 2014

State of the Art and alternative approach to indicators

Alliances, Partnerships & Collaborative Arrangements

First European Geothermal Review Geothermal Energy for Electric Power Production

Sponsorship & Tradeshow Opportunities

October 6th, 2017 De Doelen - ICC, Rotterdam, The Netherlands

How to Use Simplified Cost Options for ESI Funds? Implementation, Calculation Methods, Control and Audit

Mastering European Regulation

Achieving CMMS Data Integrity

Dear Sir / Madam. GSK is moving to Electronic Invoicing

Efficient Supplier Qualification

European Institute of Public Administration (EIPA) O.L. Vrouweplein 22 NL-6211 HE Maastricht

International User Convention LucaNet.World 24-25/11/2016 // Berlin

From Accounting to Management (Planning, Organizing and Achieving Best Practices)

EIRMA 2018 CTO Forum Building a 360 Innovation Ecosystem

CXI 360 Europe Executive Study Tour May 2019 EXECUTIVE STUDY TOUR INFORMATION BROCHURE

Internal audit. and risk. management. When Citizens Complain. For ombudsmen, commissioners and complaint handlers. Strengthening governance worldwide

From Project to Multi-Project Management Round Table Meeting, Istituto Piero Pirelli, Milan, 1 st April 2005

PROJECT MANAGEMENT AND COMPLIANCE: Planning, Scheduling and Control

Project Policy & Financial Appraisal

Internal audit. and risk. management. When Citizens Complain. For ombudsmen, commissioners and complaint handlers. Strengthening governance worldwide

EXHIBITOR & SPONSORSHIP INFORMATION 2016

On Thursday, June 28, 2018, JAY-Z & BEYONCÉ will hit the Olympiastadion Berlin on their OTR Tour II.

Pesticide Behaviour in Soils, Water and Air

INTERNAL AUDIT: PRINCIPLES, PROCEDURES AND PRACTICE IN THE EU MEMBER STATES Warsaw (PL), October 2007

Invitation to the 5 th IFCN Dairy Economic Workshop

Managing Financial Risk in an Economic Downturn

The. The dates of. this year s were very. attendees. goals. are quickly Tracy Long these rooms. Scott Bennett

A practical one day course on SYSC for employees working within investment management, or in irms providing support services.

PROTEIN CHROMATOGRAPHY - ENGINEERING FUNDAMENTALS AND MEASUREMENT FOR PROCESS DEVELOPMENT AND SCALE-UP MAY 27TH TO JUNE 1ST 2018, VIENNA, AUSTRIA

MASTERCLASS IN SCREENING, SCOPING AND ENVIRONMENTAL STATEMENT REVIEW

26-28, 2017 KAUFFMAN FOUNDATION KANSAS CITY, MO

MODULE 11 Pharmacovigilance March 2017 POST-GRADUATE PROGRAMME IN PHARMACEUTICAL MEDICINE & MEDICINES DEVELOPMENT SCIENCES

2.1 Contracts in MEYER HOSEN AG s online shop may only be concluded in German.

Project Scheduling, Cost Planning & Value Engineering Skills

THE INVESTMENT ASSOCIATION

Employment Law Belgium

- Leveraging Suppliers - Computer Systems Validation Master Class

Audit Trail Review / Data Integrity

SAVCA 2018 Private Equity in Southern Africa Conference February 2018 Spier Wine Farm, Stellenbosch, South Africa. Sponsorship Prospectus

Transcription:

DIE AKADEMIE FRESENIUS Where Experts Meet! 4 th International Fresenius Conference Worker, Operator, Bystander and Resident Exposure and Risk Assessment 1 and 2 December 2016 in Mainz/Germany Highlights Regulatory issues Further developments of EFSA GD on exposure assessment EFSA update EU Greenhouse Model Derivation of the acute acceptable operator exposure level (AAOEL) Generation of field data to refine the EFSA bystander/resident assessment EU Transfer Coefficient (TC) Operator exposure in China and the U.S. Updated programme! Speakers Route of exposure A novel approach to test dislodgeable foliar residue for dermal absorption Biomonitoring Results of the Institute of Occupational Medicine (IOM) resident biomonitoring study Epidemiology Linking exposure and epidemiology Food Quality Protection Act (FQPA) uncertainty factor Mitigation and management of risks Negligible exposure Operators, workers and personal protective equipment (PPE) Closed tractor cabins and closed application techniques Manoj Aggarwal Dow AgroSciences Carol J. Burns Burns Epidemiology Consulting Marloes Busschers Dutch Board for the Authorisation of Plant Protection Products and Biocides (Ctgb) Clare Butler Ellis Silsoe Spray Applications Unit Neil A. Byron Exponent Agathi N. Charistou Benaki Phytopathological Institute Jeffrey L. Dawson U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Eva Cohen Gómez Spanish National Institute of Safety and Hygiene at Work (INSHT) Reinhard Frießleben Bayer CropScience Karen Galea British Institute of Occupational Medicine (IOM) Martyn Griffiths Bayer Frédérique Istace European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) Curt Lunchick Bayer CropScience Thierry Mercier French Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health and Safety (ANSES) Luciano Merolla Dow AgroSciences Alistair Morriss Dow AgroSciences Tharacad Ramanarayanan Syngenta Crop Protection Dirk Rautmann Julius Kühn-Institut (JKI) René Schreiber German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) Chuanjiang Tao Chinese Ministry of Agriculture (ICAMA) Panagiotis Theodoris Heinrich Wicke Bayer CropScience

The Programme Get-Together on Wednesday, 30 November 2016 Will you arrive on Wednesday? Come to the hotel bar at 8 p.m. and meet other participants and experts in a relaxed atmosphere. Thursday, 1 December 2016 8.30 Registration and coffee 9.00 Welcome address by Akademie Fresenius and introduction by the Chairs Alistair Morriss, Dow AgroSciences, and Neil A. Byron, Exponent, UK Regulatory issues in the EU 9.10 Joint development of a European Greenhouse Model Database (e.g. exposure studies, data, scenarios and statistics) Predictive exposure model (e.g. exposure routes, calculations, tiered approach work clothes and personal protective equipment) Examples using the developed Greenhouse exposure calculator René Schreiber, Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), Germany 9.35 Derivation of the acute acceptable operator exposure level (AAOEL) a regulator s point of view Marloes Busschers, Board for the Authorisation of Plant Protection Products and Biocides (Ctgb), The Netherlands 10.00 ECPA s position on establishing the relevant acute endpoint for non-dietary risk assessment, i.e. the AAOEL Luciano Merolla, Dow AgroSciences, UK 10.25 Panel discussion 10.45 Coffee break 11.15 Further developments of EFSA GD on exposure assessment Frédérique Istace, European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), Italy 11.40 Questions and answers 11.50 A novel approach to test dislodgeable foliar residue for dermal absorption within OECD 428 test guideline Relevant dermal absorption for re-entry workers risk assessment Refinement of re-entry workers risk assessments with relevant dermal absorption values Manoj Aggarwal, Dow AgroSciences, UK 12.15 Generation of an EU Transfer Coefficient associated with harvesting activities in vineyards Design and conduct of re-entry exposure studies in European vineyards Exposure of workers to dislodgeable foliar residues Provisional results and proposal for use in risk assessment Heinrich Wicke, Bayer CropScience, Germany 12.40 Panel discussion 13.00 Lunch 14.30 Developments in resident and bystander exposure assessment Clare Butler Ellis, Silsoe Spray Applications Unit, UK 14.55 Generation of field data to refine the EFSA bystander/resident assessment associated with airblast applications Alistair Morriss, Dow AgroSciences, UK on behalf of ECPA Biomonitoring 15.20 Biological monitoring of pesticide exposure in residents results from UK study Karen Galea, Institute of Occupational Medicine (IOM), UK 15.45 Panel discussion 16.15 Coffee break Epidemiology 16.45 Linking exposure and epidemiology industry perspective Carol J. Burns, Burns Epidemiology Consulting, USA 17.10 Defining a reasonable certainty of no harm and the Food Quality Protection Act (FQPA) uncertainty factor: the congressional intent Certainty versus uncertainty Use of uncertainty factors Data quality requirements and Weight of Evidence Curt Lunchick, Bayer, USA 17.35 The use of alternative risk assessment approaches in the US chlorpyrifos case study Jeffrey L. Dawson, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), USA 18.00 Panel discussion 18.30 End of the first conference day

19.15 Departure time for the evening event After the first conference day Akademie Fresenius would like to invite you to a leisurely evening in the Old Town of Mainz. You have the opportunity of better getting to know other participants you met during the day over a relaxed meal and wine from the region in the historic restaurant Heiliggeist. Friday, 2 December 2016 Chairs: Alistair Morriss and Neil A. Byron Regulatory issues around the globe 8.30 Development of an operator exposure model in China Chuanjiang Tao, Ministry of Agriculture (ICAMA), China 8.55 Questions and answers 9.05 The development of the CropLife Principles of Regulation tool for operator exposure Use of the tool for exposure and risk assessment for handlers and applicators of PPP Global use of the tool, especially in developing countries Transparency of calculations and update with scenario specific data to fit local regulatory needs Tharacad Ramanarayanan, Syngenta Crop Protection, USA Mitigation and management of risks 9.30 Insight to the topic of negligible exposure a manager s point of view Panagiotis Theodoris, Greece 9.55 Negligible exposure: an industry view Guidance from Commission Practical use of the guidance Key concerns on the applicability of the guidance Martyn Griffiths, Bayer, France 10.20 Panel discussion 10.40 Coffee break 11.10 Operators, workers and personal protective equipment (PPE) Thierry Mercier, French Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health and Safety (ANSES), France 11.35 Non-dietary exposure assessment for PPPs and the respective risk mitigation measures considered in Greece Exposure assessment tools used for operator, worker, resident & bystander exposure assessment; comparison of the exposure outcomes using different models Refinement possibilities Risk mitigation measures considered in Greece Agathi N. Charistou, Benaki Phytopathological Institute, Greece 12.00 Update on the standardisation of protective clothing requirements view from Spain Experience in the development of EN/ISO standards in the field of protective clothing against pesticides Advantages of the harmonisation of requirements of protective clothing to protect against pesticides Eva Cohen Gómez, National Institute of Safety and Hygiene at Work (INSHT), Spain 12.25 Short break 12.40 Closed systems, including closed tractor cabins and closed application techniques view from authority Testing and approval of closed systems for filling PPP Testing of cabins (self-propelled sprayers and tractors) following EN 15696-1 Consideration of closed systems in the authorisation procedure for PPP Dirk Rautmann, Julius Kühn-Institute, Germany 13.05 Focus on closed systems, including closed tractor cabins and closed application techniques view from industry Closed transfer systems during mixing and loading Closed systems during application of PPP Progress in the area of application technique and future requirements for safe applications of PPP Reinhard Frießleben, Bayer CropScience, Germany 13.30 Panel discussion 14.20 Lunch and end of the conference Information available online at: www.akademie-fresenius.com/2339

The Experts Manoj Aggarwal is a Senior Toxicologist at Dow AgroSciences in the UK with many years of industry experience as regulatory and risk assessor. Carol J. Burns is President of Burns Epidemiology Consulting and an adjunct professor of epidemiology at the Central Michigan University College of Medicine, having previously worked in occupational epidemiology at the Dow Chemical Company for two decades. Marloes Busschers is a Senior Toxicologist and Human Health Risk Assessor at the Board for the Authorisation of Plant Protection Products and Biocides (Ctgb) in the Netherlands. Clare Butler Ellis is the Research Manager of Silsoe Spray Applications Unit. It became an independent R&D business in 2016, allowing it to continue the work it does for the agrochemical and agricultural engineering industries, as well as government, regulators and growers.. Neil A. Byron is working as a Senior Managing Scientist in Exponent UK s Health Sciences Center for Chemical Regulation and Food Safety. Prior to joining Exponent he was with the UK s CRD for 18 years. Agathi N. Charistou is a Regulatory Toxicologist in the Laboratory of Toxicological Control of Pesticides in the Department of Pesticides Control at Benaki Phytopathological Institute in Greece. Jeffrey L. Dawson is Acting Deputy Director at the U.S. EPA, Office of Pesticide Programmes, Health Effects Division and responsible for the development of risk assessments for non-dietary exposure to pesticides including workers and for all manner of residential exposures. Eva Cohen Gómez is Head of the Technical Unit of Protective Clothing at the Protective Equipment Department of the National Centre for Protective Equipment and Work Conditions (CNMP) at the National Institute of Safety and Hygiene at Work (INSHT) in Seville. Reinhard Frießleben is Head of the Global Application Technology at Bayer CropScience in Monheim. Since 1990 he has been working in various functions in the agrochemical industry. He has been Head of the German Phytomedical Society (DPG) working group Application Technology since 2000. Karen Galea is Head of the Exposure Science Section of the Institute of Occupational Medicine (IOM) in the UK. She is responsible for a team of human exposure scientists and leads a wide variety of research projects, mainly focussed on exposure assessment relating to health risks. Martyn Griffiths is EMEA Regulatory Strategy Manager at Bayer in Lyon. His involvement in crop protection started 26 years ago. He held a number of positions including responsibility for registrations in China, Taiwan and Korea. He is chairman of ECPA Regulatory Policy Team. Frédérique Istace is an Officer in the Pesticide Unit of the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) in Parma. Curt Lunchick is the Product Safety Senior Pontificator and responsible for assessing occupational and residential exposure and risk at Bayer CropScience and Bayer Animal Health in North America. He is involved with the development of the North America Operator Exposure database. Thierry Mercier is Deputy of the department at ANSES in charge of the evaluation and coordination of pesticides, biocides and fertilizers risk assessments since July 2010. Previously, he was Deputy Head of the Crops and Environment Department at AFSSA, and Regulatory Toxicologist at INRA. Luciano Merolla is a Regulatory Toxicologist and Human Health Risk Assessor at Dow AgroSciences in UK. He has worked in the personal care, tobacco and agrochemical industries for the past 12 years as toxicologist and risk assessor. Alistair Morriss is a Risk Assessor, in the Human Health Assessment team at Dow AgroSciences in UK since 2010. Prior to this he worked in contract research organisations for 8 years specialising in operator exposure studies as well as residue and environmental fate studies. He is Chairman of the ECPA OBEEG. Tharacad Ramanarayanan is a Technical Leader at Sygenta, leading the Operator and Consumer risk assessment team for North America. He has 18 years of experience in human and environmental exposure and risk assessment. He is a member of CropLife International Operator Exposure group. Dirk Rautmann is Deputy Head of the Institute for Application Techniques in Plan Protection at the Julius Kühn-Institute. Since 1987 he has been working on all aspects of plant protection equipment, drift and drift reduction, dust drift from sowing machines and seed treatment. René Schreiber works as a Risk Assessor for evaluating the toxicology of PPP and performs risk assessments to determine safe use for operators, workers, residents and bystanders in a regulatory context at the BfR in Berlin. Chuanjiang Tao has been working in the Institute for the Control of Agrochemicals at the Ministry of Agriculture (ICAMA) in Beijing since 1993, in the Residue Division, Health and Environment Division, and Health Division successively. His function is to review pesticide registration dossiers and to develop risk assessment tools. Panagiotis Theodoris has an agronomy background Heinrich Wicke is an Occupational and Residential Exposure Expert for PPP at Bayer CropScience. He has a long standing global expertise in the non-dietary safety of PPP in different positions in the agrochemical industry and was involved in the development of exposure models and risk assessment approaches.

About Who do you meet? Groups that should take part: Managing directors, boards of directors, managers, consultants and scientists in the fields of Research & development Human exposure & risk assessment Toxicology Registration Marketing & distribution Product stewardship & responsible care Human and consumer safety Sectors that should take part: Agrochemical industry Research institutes Authorities Professional associations Contract laboratories Trade Exhibition Our conference provides you with the opportunity of presenting your company in a trade display. Present your products and services and reach out to your specific target groups. We would be happy to provide you with information on all the various options available from displaying product information to an exhibition stand with no further obligation on your part. Use the attached fax reply sheet to request our information material. Or simply call us. We would be more than pleased to assist you personally. Rebecca Keuters phone: +49 231 75896-76 rkeuters@akademie-fresenius.de The Organiser For over 20 years, Akademie Fresenius has been your partner for practice-orientated training on all the latest topics surrounding the safety and quality of food, consumer goods and chemical products along the whole production chain. Our portfolio not only includes international conferences but also offers national trade meetings, intensive practical seminars and training in small work groups. Our events are designed to promote an active exchange amongst our participants and offer the perfect platform for bringing the industry, the scientific sector, the authorities and the consulting field together. Excellent service, all-inclusive. Our wide-ranging advanced training opportunities contribute to giving our customers the competitive edge in all quality assurance, risk assessment, legal, production and technical questions. Akademie Fresenius is a joint venture between Cognos, one of the largest private and independent education groups in Germany, and SGS Institut Fresenius, one of the leading German providers of chemical laboratory analysis. You can find details on upcoming and new events at www.akademie-fresenius.com Do you have any questions? Programme and conceptual design Sabine Mummenbrauer phone: +49 231 75896-82 smummenbrauer@akademie-fresenius.de Organisation and participant management Stephanie Lagemann phone: +49 231 75896-77 slagemann@akademie-fresenius.de

Registration By web www.akademie-fresenius.com/2339 By email registration@akademie-fresenius.com By fax +49 231 75896-53 Hotline +49 231 75896-50 Die Akademie Fresenius GmbH Alter Hellweg 46, 44379 Dortmund Participation I would like to take part in the 4 th International Fresenius Conference Worker, Operator, Bystander and Resident Exposure, 1 to 2 December 2016 in Mainz/Germany. Fee: 1,795.00 plus VAT. I am a representative of an authority or a public university and therefore eligible for a reduced fee of 795.00 plus VAT per person (please provide evidence). The reduced fee cannot be combined with other rebates. I would like to take part in the evening event on 1 December 2016 (included in the above price). Event Documentation Unfortunately, I am unable to attend. Please send me the complete documentation for 295.00 plus VAT. Trade Exhibition Please send me information on exhibition possibilities during the event. Your Account Number (if available): Title / First name / Name Position Department Phone / Fax Email Company (complete company name including legal form) Street / Number or P.O. Box / Building ZIP-code / City / Country Your order number / Cost unit (if required) Your VAT ID No. (for registrations from EU countries except Germany) Date Signature Billing Address (only if different from the above address) Terms of Participation and Purchase The registration fee includes the event participation, event documentation, lunch, coffee breaks, beverages as well as the evening event. You will receive written confirmation of your registration. Upon receiving our invoice, please transfer the amount due without further deductions before the event begins. The price of the conference documentation includes a hard copy of the documentation as weii as an access code to the secure Akademie Fresenius download area. Both the documents and the secure access code will be dispatched around two weeks after the event and as soon as advance payment has been received. Group Reductions For joint bookings received from one company we grant a 15% discount from the third participant onwards. Terms of Cancellation Written cancellations or transfers will be accepted free of charge up to four weeks prior to the start of the event. After this date and up to a week prior to the start of the event we will reimburse 50% of the registration fee. We cannot, unfortunately, provide refunds for later cancellations. Please note that you can name a substitute free of charge at any time. General Terms and Conditions By registering, you agree to our General Terms and Conditions as well as to our Privacy Policy. You can find our GTC on the internet (www. akademie-fresenius.com/general-terms) or receive them on request. Personal Data The Akademie Fresenius will keep your personal data for the purpose of organising this event. We will under no circumstances use your data for commercial trade purposes. In signing this form you consent to our occasionally contacting you by mail, email, fax or phone (please strike through if unwanted) in order to provide you with further information from our company. You can, of course, withdraw your consent whenever you wish. Occasionally we go around taking photos at our event. These are then published anonymously on our website. Further information can be found at: www.akademie-fresenius.com/dataprotection. Picture Credit PL.TH - Fotolia.com, tupungato Venue/Event Hotel Atrium Hotel Mainz Flugplatzstraße 44, 55126 Mainz/Germany Phone: +49 6131 491-0, Fax: +49 6131 491-128 info@atrium-mainz.de, www.atrium-mainz.de We have reserved a limited number of rooms for our participants at reduced rates at the hotel. These rooms can be booked up to four weeks prior to the start of the event. Please book early and directly through the hotel quoting Fresenius as reference.