CCQM P58.1: Metrology for Clinical Sciences Diagnostic Formulation Meeting, 24 th Feb James Noble
Development of a Reference Immunoassay for ctni Cardiac Troponin I (ctni) is an important marker for the diagnosis of ACS and risk stratification The NPL metrology study is linked to the IFCC initiative for standardization and traceability of ctni measurements: Drivers: No reference method for value assignment MS not sensitive enough to determine clinically relevant levels (ng/l μg/l). Analytically more sensitive assays being developed to enhance initial diagnosis the need for improved assay performance and comparability.
Stakeholders and Project Drivers Quality of Life; Improved ctni measurement comparability Develop ctni RMP + associated standards IVD Directive (98/97/EU): Traceability for in vitro medical diagnostic devices IFCC WG-cTnI NPL CCQM - BAWG Metrological methods applied to other programs: ChemBio, TSB and NIRD NIST Assign ctni Standards Formulation: UK industrial Input International Metrology Community: NIBSC (WHO) BAM + PTB (Germany) IRMM (Euro) VNIIM (Russia) NMIJ (Japan) NIM (China) ISS (Italy) KRISS (South Korea) NMIA (Australia)
IFCC: Traceability for ctni Measurements (1) Multiple manufactures of ctni assays each with own standards and antibodies with different epitope specificities. Need to standardize ctni measurements to facilitate intercomparison of clinical studies. Traceable ctni SRM displays limited commutability therefore: Preparing secondary standard from AMI patients. Develop immunoassay RMP to support secondary standards. Characterise and prepare antibodies for RMP. Evaluate the effectiveness of this approach through round robin studies
IFCC: Traceability for ctni Measurements (2) Purified ctni SRM not suitable for standardizing all measurements: 1000.00 100.00 ctni (μg/l) 10.00 1.00 0.10 0.01 SP 1 SP 2 SP 3 SP 4 SP 5 SP 6 Serum Pools R. H. Christenson, S. H. Duh, et.al. Clinical Chemistry, 52:9, 2006, Pages 1685-1692.
BIPM: Metrology and the Development of a Immunoassay Reference Measurement Procedure The task of the BIPM is to ensure world-wide uniformity of measurements and their traceability to the International System of Units (SI). Reference System to be SI traceable. The ctni immunoassay RMP will be used by metrology institutes, reference laboratories and industry to assign concentrations to reference materials and manufacturers master calibrators. World-wide comparability through CCQM studies to evaluate robustness of RMP. RMP to be developed as a non-proprietary open access assay system that can be run in various laboratories using non-specialist equipment/techniques.
Proposed Reference Measurement System for human ctni Materials Procedures SI Unit Purified CIT standard NIST 2921 Serum-based commutable reference materials for ctni Target material e.g. manufacturer s working calibrator patient samples Reference measurement procedure: LC/MS and Amino Acid Analysis Reference immunoassay method Manufacturer s selected reference measurement procedure Manufacturer s standing measurement procedure to value assign the target material Slide prepared by Jill Tate, Royal Brisbane and Women s Hospital, QLD, Australia.
ctni Standardization of a Heterogeneous Protein Analyte Compared to small organic and inorganic molecules the standardization of proteins is more complex: Chemical heterogeneity: Post-translational modifications Protease digestion 3D Structure Protein complex formation These issues can be patient, sampling/processing and time dependent The measureand ctni can therefore be classed in terms of multiple isoforms: RMP should display equal reactivity to all ctni isoforms
Measurement Claim P58.1: The measurand ctni will be defined by the presence of both epitopes (fully characterised and mapped) that reside within the stable region of the molecule. Proposed Measurement Claim: To determine the concentration of human myocardial infarction marker ctni in the range of [ng/l-μg/l] using a defined non-competitive ELISA protocol with a controlled uncertainty. Measurand Definition: Detection mab ~ 41-49 Capture mab ~ 83-93 30 110 1 209 Stable region
Development of the ctni Immunoassay RMP NPL has experience in immunoassay metrology running previous CCQM intercomparison studies. Through internal research and intercomparison studies the sources of uncertainty in assigning ctni concentration with this method will be quantitated. NPL will be involved in the reference material assignment and commutability studies to assess the utility of this approach. USP Protein A reference Immunoassays Current funding round is supporting the development and robustness analysis of the ctni RMP
Cause and Effect Diagram showing Sources of Uncertainty Specificity Interferences Tertiary and quaternary structure Other effects (f other ) Variation in nonspecific binding Sample Volume Variation in phosphatase activity Reagent Volume(s) Variation in phosphatase binding Imprecision (C uncor ) Random variation in reading fluorescence Plate inhomogeneity Within- and between plate differences Estimation of calibration function C Result Homogeneity Statistical estimation Preparation of standards Loss (recovery, or dilution) or contamination Value of SRM Stability Correction (f cor ) Sample effects (f sampler ) Adapted from Borg et. al. Clin. Chem. Lab. Med. 2002; 40(5):509-519.
Performance criteria for the Secondary Reference ELISA Dynamic range to include the expected three (0.1 10 μg/l) serum standards and ctni cut-off (0.05 μg/l). Display equal reactivity with ctni isoforms and orthogonal methods. Multiple combinations of antibodies directed to epitopes both within and outside stable region tested. Capture mabs Detection mabs 19C7 267 MF4 19C7 + MF4 19C7 + 267 M18 X X X X X 560 X X X X X MF4 X X X M18 + 560 MF4 + 560 X X X M18 + 560 X X X X Possible range of serum standards 6 log (fluorescence) 5 4 Cut-off 3 1 2 3 4 5 log (ctni) (ng/l)
Further Biomarker Standardization Work Validate RMP immunoassay and commutability of the ctni standards. Characterise troponin complex and its interaction with selected antibodies for RMP. Develop methods to characterise the ctni measureand (St George s). Links to the JRP11 project: Traceability of Complex Biomolecules and Biomarkers in Diagnostics Effecting Measurement Comparability in Clinical Medicine If successful can the ctni standardization approach be applied to other complex protein biomarkers.
Acknowledgements Organisation + Input BAWG ctni WG Robert Porter NPL Simon Attree NPL Lili Wang: NIST Maurice Cox NPL David Bunk NIST Elaine Gray NIBSC Alexei Katrukha HyTest Adrian Bristow NIBSC Heinz Schimmel IRMM Jill Tate IFCC Publications: An international comparability study to determine the sources of uncertainty associated with a non-competitive sandwich fluorescent ELISA. Noble JE, et.al. Clin Chem Lab Med. 2008;46(7):1033-45. Standardization of troponin I measurements: an update. Panteghini M, Bunk DM, Christenson RH, Katrukha A, Porter RA, Schimmel H, Wang L, Tate JR; for the IFCC Working Group on Standardization of Troponin I. Clin Chem Lab Med. 2008, 46(11):1501-06. Thanks to the UK Government for funding the project through the Chemistry and Biology NMS Programme.