Survey of Neural Networks in Digital Pathology and Pathology Workflow

Similar documents
background digitalization

NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH CLINICAL LABORATORY EVALUATION PROGRAM. Crosswalk of adopted revisions to Cytopathology Standards

Streamline Pre-Analytic Orchard Pathology Processes

Sectra Digital Pathology Solution

Informatics in the Anatomical Pathology Laboratory: Making It Work for You

Uniform Labeling of Blocks and Slides in Surgical Pathology

Integrating Digital Pathology with your AP-LIS

2013 Continuing Compliance Master Series Checklist Updates for Anatomic Pathology. Gerald A. Hoeltge, MD, FCAP July 17,

Pathology Solution IVD US. Philips IntelliSite HER2/neu IHC Digital Manual Read

WORKFLOW WITHOUT THE WORK. Power Express Clinical Automation Solution

TOTAL TISSUE DIAGNOSTICS PATHOS DELTA. World s first hybrid tissue processor (microwave + conventional) A fully automatic system to fit your workflow

J. Mark Tuthill, MD Division of Pathology Informatics Henry Ford Hospital Detroit, MI

WORKFLOW WITHOUT THE WORK

Surgical/Cytology Specimen Collection and Handling

2010 NORTH AMERICAN TISSUE DIAGNOSTICS PRODUCT LINE STRATEGY AWARD

Smart digital pathology. Share expertise in real time, not just images

M1741 Validating a Whole Slide Imaging System A Case Based Approach to the CAP Guidelines

GenomeMe. GeneAb TM BRAF V600E. Clone: IHC600 Source: Mouse Monoclonal Positive Control: Colorectal Adenocarcinoma

Digital pathology: the Swedish project

GETTING THE MOST OUT OF BARCODING IN YOUR PATHOLOGY LABORATORY LORETTA SAYLES HT(ASCP) SAYLES LAB CONSULTING

Histology Pattern Recognition Software in Investigative Pathology

Ariol. Clinical IHC and FISH Breast Marker Analysis Quality. Efficiency. Confidence.

TheraLin. Universal Tissue Fixative Enabling Molecular Pathology

Accelerating the Pace of Understanding

Prepublication Requirements

APPENDIX: TECHNICAL and OPERATIONAL ISSUES of the NEPTUNE. The FDA has not approved the use of WSI for the making primary

College of American Pathologists Laboratory Accreditation Program. AP for Histotechs and Secretaries. Learning Objectives

SOP# version e1.0 Material Handling and Documentation TMA's from Paraffin Embedded Tissue Blocks

Preanalytical Variables in Blood Collection: Impact on Precision Medicine

What Does Lean Surgical Pathology Look Like?

Pathology Facilities and Potential for Collaboration. The University of Western Australia

Image Analysis. Tools for basic and translational research. visualize analyze interpret report archive customize

TECHNOLOGIES & SERVICES FOR THERAPEUTIC ANTIBODY DEVELOPMENT

Central Laboratory Services. Anatomic Pathology Histology Services

Automation in the Histology Lab

Getting the most out of going digital: Top 5 tips for digital pathology implementation success

PATIENT PATHOLOGIST CEREBRO SPECIMEN TRACKING AND WORKFLOW MANAGEMENT. Patient Safety. Productivity. Flexibility.

Completing the performance picture.

Appendix B. The Curriculum in Cytotechnology for Entry-level Competencies

Overview of Immunohistochemistry

Tailored automation solutions that fit. Automation system solutions component overview

Leo Serrano, FACHE, DLM(ASCP) Operations Manager FirstPath Laboratory Services Pompano Beach, Florida

Boost turnaround time for faster diagnosis

Tailored automation solutions that fit. Automation system solutions component overview

Accelerating the Adoption of Companion Diagnostics

BEYOND A BETTER BOX DI-60 INTEGRATED SLIDE PROCESSING SYSTEM. Seamless Integration

The Little Book of Identification and Tracking for Diagnostics

AUTOMATED HEMATOLOGY IN THE CLINICAL LAB

Introduction to histology and its methods of study

NEW STAINS IN TISSUE DIAGNOSIS

Automated Breast Volumes. Simplified.

Make the move to automated embedding

Special Section Cleveland Clinic Abu Dhabi Experiences From Opening the First American Greenfield Tertiary Care Hospital in the Middle East, Part II

Integrated Radiology & Pathology Diagnostic Services: The Time is Now at UCLA

GenASIs TM Cytogenetics Suite

WARREN ALPERT CENTER S DIGITAL IMAGING LABORATORY

Carl Zeiss MicroImaging AIS. Digital Pathology The Future. Andrew Lesniak Director, Product Management

EARLY ONLINE RELEASE

A Pragmatic Revolution for Histology Laboratories. Start with the end in mind.

Session: Innovative Technologies

Regulatory Challenges and Opportunities for Digital Pathology

PATIENT PATHOLOGIST CEREBRO SPECIMEN TRACKING AND WORKFLOW MANAGEMENT. Patient Safety. Productivity. Flexibility.

Preparing an RFP for a Digital Pathology System

Parameter assisted HE colored tissue image classification

Laboratory Accreditation Test Validation: A Brave New World for Anatomic Pathology

THE ESSENTIAL ELEMENT of a

Telepathology. and The Future of Pathology (or Why did we change our Practice Model) Jagdish Butany, MBBS, MS, FRCPC

Using Human Tissue in Translational Research and Clinical Trials

Preparation of tissues for study

Digital Cytopathology & Interactive Case Discussion

Le banche dei tessuti

Automation In Life Sciences and Diagnostics Applications

Image Analysis in Current Clinical Practice OBJECTIVES. ACCME/Disclosures 4/11/2016. Liron Pantanowitz MD

Inspecting Cytopathology

GenomeMe. GeneAbTM Her2/Neu. Clone: IHC002 Source: Mouse Monoclonal Positive Control: Breast Carcinoma

MANAGEMENT BRIEF. How Automation is Revolutionizing White Cell Differential Analysis.

Developing an Accurate and Precise Companion Diagnostic Assay for Targeted Therapies in DLBCL

Digital Slide Sharing and Consultative Strategies and Tactics Pathology Informatics 2011 October 6, 2011

5/8/2017 BEYOND THE BENCH: CAREER GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE HISTOLOGY TECHNICIAN OBJECTIVES

School of Allied Medical Sciences. Course Description Guide Associate in Medical Laboratory Sciences. Page 1 of 15

BioView. Karyotype Suite

Data Mining for Genomic- Phenomic Correlations

Comparing the Quality of Fixation for Gel-based Formalin (Formagel) versus Traditional Liquid-Based Formalin for Immunohistochemistry

DIGITAL PATHOLOGY: TECHNOLOGIES AND GLOBAL MARKETS

Imagine... fully automated embedding with the highest quality blocks. Tissue-Tek AutoTEC a120 & Paraform. Automated Embedding System

Landing Cyto System. Automated platform for GYN (compliant with The Bethesda System) and non-gyn cytology. Automated abnormal cell detection

Transforming Microbiology at DynaLIFE MEDICAL LABS

UE Biopathologie et Biobanking

Applied Spectral Imaging

Cell Imaging Analysis: Our journey to Hematology Productivity

Automating Data Analysis Workflows - Why Data Management is Important in an Era of HPDA

Automatic detection of plasmonic nanoparticles in tissue sections

Risk Mitigation in Breast Predictive Factor Testing. Elizabeth H Hammond MD

GenomeMe. GeneAb TM Collagen Type IV. Clone: IHC549 Source: Mouse Monoclonal Positive Control: Lung, Muscle

UNIVERSITY OF PATHOLOGY INFORMATICS CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION PROGRAM. Course Program Syllabus

NIST Medical Imaging Informatics Activities. Medical Imaging

Applying Artificial Intelligence to Medical Imaging

CloudPath LABORATORY INFORMATION MANAGEMENT SYSTEM

Intersection of LEAN and the LIS. Megan Schmidt. Product Manager, Sunquest Information Systems, Inc. Patrick O Sullivan

LDT Review: The New York Experience

Transcription:

Survey of Neural Networks in Digital Pathology and Pathology Workflow Christianne Dinsmore 1 1 Department of Computing and Digital Media DePaul University Chicago, IL Abstract Digital pathology has already transformed the anatomic pathology laboratory. Digital slides now allow pathologists to access specimens and related clinical data from anywhere in the world, which permits more efficient workflow, enhanced communication between physicians, widely-accessible educational opportunities, and improved data management for research applications. Pathology images require data filtering, estimation, intuition, quantification and hypothesis testing. The difficulty of this analysis is compounded by an increasing need to be able to reproduce the diagnosis and interpretation of the stained tissue. Pathologists are able to view raw images and associate the image with knowledge of anatomy, cell theory, and oncology training. In this survey, we will explore the use of neural networks in digital pathology and the potential for use in the laboratory workflow to improve turnaround time for specimen processing and diagnosis. 1

1 Introduction The practice of anatomic pathology is a practice of medicine which diagnoses disease based on examination of bodily organs and tissues. The process begins with the receipt of a pathology specimen which is inspected by a pathologist to obtain diagnostic information prior to processing the specimen for microscopic examination. The traditional pathology workflow requires manual acquisition, transportation, and storage of glass slides. In order to streamline the workflow and to enable communication and education between pathology laboratories, whole-slide digital imaging has emerged as a method to increase efficiencies in the laboratory workflow, pathologist communication, education, and research. The most popular staining method for tissue is hematoxylin and eosin, commonly known as H&E. This staining process colors the nuclei of cells blue while the counterstain colors proteins, cytoplasm, and other cell structures pink. In a clinical laboratory, all tissue is initially stained with H&E. If the pathologist requires additional information to distinguish between two similar types of cancer, special and/or advanced stains may be ordered. Figure 1: H&E stained lung tissue (1) Each laboratory has differing volumes depending on their specialty, however, data from several clinical laboratories shows that the average ratio of H&E slides to advanced/special stain slides are 7.5:1. Table 1: Slide volume for Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. customers (2) Laboratory Annual H&E Volume Annual Advanced/Special Volume Dynacare 200,000 52,200 Hackensack Medical Center 156,000 30.550 Alegent Health 130,000 19,750 Good Samaritan, West Islip 204,000 22,000 Tricore Reference Laboratories 300,000 37,000 Quantification and qualification is the foundation of microscopic pathological diagnosis. With the introduction of digital pathology and whole slide image scanning, analytical applications are being undertaken to enhance the slide image, perform cell counts, estimate 2

protein expression in immunohistochemical assays, and other tasks to quantify, classify, and analyze the specimen to aid in diagnosis (3). For example, the College of American Pathology requires a count of lymph nodes, dimensions of the specimen, and dimensions of the tumor as part of the pathological report for lung tissue specimens (4). Gathering this information, however, requires tedious and time-consuming work from the pathologist. What if the process of classification could be automated? What if there was a method of analyzing H&E stained slides to correctly alert the pathologist to order advanced stains? What if automated image analysis could reduce the pathology workload, leaving pathologists more time to focus on more difficult morphologies and research? The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is heavily involved with the pathology community to ensure that based on scientific evidence, the probable benefits to a patient s health from the use of such devices outweigh any possible risks and will provide clinically significant results (5). Research in the use of neural networks and image processing is moving toward algorithms that can assist pathologists by providing clinically relevant classification of malignant and normal tissue. 2 Image classification Neural networks are the center of research for disease classification activities. In 2001, the National Laboratory for Novel Software Technology found that an artificial neural network ensemble was able to identify lung cancer cells in the images of needle biopsies (6). The neural algorithm used is the fast adaptive neural classifier (FANNC) which uses adaptive resonance theory and field theory. The algorithm requires one-pass learning and has incremental learning ability. When new instances are fed, it does not retrain on the entire training set, it simply learns the knowledge encoded in those instances and adjusts the network as necessary. The FANNC network is composed of four layers of units using a sigmoid function with Gaussian weights to connect the input units with the second-layer units. The second-layer units classify the inputs internally and the third-layer units classify the outputs internally. The associations between the two layers are used to implement supervised learning. Except for the connections between the first- and second-layer units, all of the connections are bidirectional and allow for feedback (7). Figure 2: The architecture of FANNC (7) 3

Assuming that instances input to the input units are, where k is the index of the instance, and n is the number of input units, the value input to the second-layer unit j from the first-layer unit I is Equation 1: Value input from first- to second-layer input (7) ( ) where is the responsive center and is the responsive characteristic width of the Gaussian weight connecting units i and j. The dynamic property of a Gaussian weight is determined by the responsive center and responsive characteristic width, which means that learned knowledge can be encoded in the weight through those two parameters. The second-layer activation function is: Equation 2: Second-layer activation function (7) ( ) where is the bias unit of j and f is the sigmoid function. Another function, called the leakage competition, is performed on all of the second-layer units. The output of the winners is transferred to the third-layer units. The third-layer activation function is: Equation 3: Third-layer activation function (7) ( ) where is the activation value of the second-layer unit j, which must be a winner in the competition and a connection to unit h. is the feed-forward weight connecting unit j to h and f is the sigmoid function. The error between the real network output and predicted output is computed using the average squared error (7). By applying the FANNC algorithm, the National Laboratory for Novel Software Technology was able to design a procedure which performs automatic pathology diagnosis using needle biopsy images with a high rate of overall identification and a low rate of false identification for adenocarcinoma, squamous cell carcinoma, small cell carcinoma, and large cell carcinoma (6). 3 Laboratory workflow The histology workflow begins again when the pathologists determine there are cells of interest, but the specificity of the disease cannot be determined from a hematoxylin and eosin stain. The pathologist submits a requisition to have additional stains, such as Helicobacter pylori, Synaptophysin and Glypican 3 (2). These stains are specifically designed to determine the presence of highly specific antibodies, proteins, and cellular structures in paraffin-embedded 4

tissue. The requisition is sent back to the accessioning personnel who enter the order into the laboratory information system. A histologist must then retrieve the tissue block from a storage location and cut additional slides for staining. Depending on the laboratory, the storage location may be on-site or may be at another facility. Some laboratories are not equipped to perform special stains, so the slides must be sent out via courier to a reference lab to complete the staining process. Lapses in patient safety have been linked to issues in histology workflow. Workflow analysis must be performed to understand the impact of quality issues on patient outcomes. In hematology, pressure to improve productivity and reduce costs led St. Joseph s Medical Center in Towson, Maryland to purchase a Beckman Coulter LH 1500 hematology system which automates the processes of sample sorting, loading and unloading of cassettes, rerun and reflex testing, sample storage, and sample tracking. The implementation of an automated system reduced the slide review rate by 23% (8). The Ventana Symphony automated H&E staining platform helped Oklahoma University reduce average time from gross station to assembled case by 12% and increased mean quarterly productivity by 8.5% (9). Dr. Lewis Hassell found that mobile viewing of digital slides on an ipad device reduces slide evaluation time with only 3% of cases having clinically significant discrepancies in diagnosis (10). These studies show positive results for providing automation in a laboratory workflow. 5 The future The development of a predictive algorithm that could process raw whole-slide images of tissue stained with hematoxylin and eosin, determine if the image contains artifacts that would lead a pathologist to order additional stains, and perform the requisition process automatically would result in significant time savings for the pathology laboratory. The proposed histology workflow, which combines automation in digital pathology and laboratory workflow, involves automation of H&E processing, reflex ordering, and archival of blocks and slides. When a specimen is received by the laboratory, the tissue is processed normally and H&E slides are cut from the block. Each microtome workstation will have a method of preparing uncut blocks and slides for storage by an automated storage system. The slides would be loaded onto the Ventana Symphony platform for H&E staining. Upon completion of the stain run, a whole slide imaging system would create images of each slide. Image analysis software would then review the slide image and classify the image as one that is likely to require additional staining or one that does not require additional analysis. Images that cannot be classified by the software are sent to a pathologist for review. Upon review of the unknown slide, the pathologist would either order more slides or make a diagnosis, thereby providing the analysis software with further training examples. When a slide image is classified as requiring additional slides, a reflex order request would be sent to the laboratory information system. The system would request retrieval of the archived block and route the block to the microtomy technician to cut and stain the additional slides. The additional slides would be processed on the advanced or special staining platforms and scanned to create a whole slide image. The image would be routed to the assigned pathologist for review and the slide would be archived using the automated system. If the pathologist wishes to view the physical slide under the microscope, he or she would make a request and the slide would be retrieved and routed. 5

A process similar to the cytology workflow may be used to ensure that a random sampling of classified normal and non-normal H&E slides are reviewed to provide additional safety and quality to the automated system. The Ventana VANTAGE workflow solution could track whether or not the special stain was needed, which would feed the neural network to provide feedback to the image processing algorithms regarding the correctness of each classification. Combined with an intelligent specimen storage model, the proposed system has the potential to significantly reduce staffing needs specific to the retrieval and re-processing of tissue. Additional Stains Needed No Additional Stains needed Process Tissue H&E Stain Stain and Capture Image Analyze Image Store Slide Receive Specimen Accession/Order In LIS Create Slides Legend H&E Process Advanced/Special Stain Advanced Stain Process Both Store/ Retrieve Block Advanced Stain and Capture Image Figure 3: Proposed neural-network driven workflow Review Image And Diagnose The introduction of automation and the ability for the neural network driven analysis software would decrease turnaround time for most specimens significantly. Further work must be performed to determine if such a system can be designed and at what cost. The combination of digital pathology, workflow management, and neural networks has the potential to provide a whole new level of diagnostic excellence. 6

References 1. Wikipedia Contributors. H&E stain. Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. [Online] November 4, 2011. [Cited: November 6, 2011.] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/h%26e_stain. 2. Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. VentanaForce. Salesforce. [Online] November 2011. [Cited: November 7, 2011.] Available to internal Ventana employess only. 3. Benefits of Digital Pathology. Tecotzky, Raymond. 8, s.l. : Advance: For Administrators of the Laboratory, 2008, Vol. 17, p. 40. 4. Butnor, Kelly J., et al., et al. Protocol for the Examination of Specimens from Patients with Primary Non-Small Cell Carcinoma, Small Cell Carcinoma, or Carcinoid Tumor of the Lung. [Online] February 1, 2011. [Cited: November 6, 2011.] http://www.cap.org/apps/docs/committees/cancer/cancer_protocols/2011/lung_11protocol.pdf. Lung 3.1.0.0. 5. Food and Drug Administration. CFR - Code of Federal Regulations Title 21, Volume 8. Part 860 -- Medical Device Classification Procedures. [Online] April 1, 2011. [Cited: 11 6, 2011.] http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/cfrsearch.cfm?fr=860.7. 21CFR860.7. 6. Lung cancer cell identification based on artificial neural network ensembles. Zhou, Zhi Hua, et al., et al. 1, Nanjing : Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, 2001, Vol. 24. S0933-3657(01)00094-X. 7. FANNC: A Fast Neural Network Classifier. Zhou, Z.-H., et al., et al. 1, Nanjing : Knowledge and Information Systems, 2000, Vol. 2. 10.1007/s101150050006. 8. Workflow improvement and impact of the new Beckman coulter LH 1500 high throughput automated hematology workcell. La Porta, AD, Bowden, AS and Barr, S. 2, Towson : Laboratory hematology : official publication of the International Society for Laboratory Hematology, 2004, Vol. 10. 10.1532/LH96.04022. 9. The combined positive impact of Lean methodology and Ventana Symphony autostainer on histology lab workflow. Yip, Clinton, et al., et al. 2, Oklahoma : BMC Clinical Pathology, 2010, Vol. 10. doi:10.1186/1472-6890-10-2. 10. Use of mobile high-resolution device for remote frozen section evaluation of whole slide images. Hassell, Lewis A, Fung, Kar Ming and Ramey, Joel. 41, Oklahoma : J Pathol Inform, 2011, Vol. 2. DOI: 10.4103/2153-3539.84276. 11. Wikipedia Contributors. Workflow. Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. [Online] October 21, 2011. [Cited: November 7, 2011.] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/workflow. 12. Computer-assisted image classification: use of neural networks in anatomic pathology. Becker, L. Robert. 2-3, Washington, DC : Cancer Letters, 1993, Vol. 77. 10.1016/0304-3835(94)90093-0. 13. Toward automated workflow analysis and visualization in clinical environments. Vankipuram, Mirthra, et al., et al. 3, Phoenix : Journal of Biomedical Informatics, 2009, Vol. 44. doi:10.1016/j.jbi.2010.05.015. 14. Hidden Markov Models. Eddy, Sean R. Montpellier : Current Opinion in Structural Biology, 2003, Vol. 6. 15. Smyth, Padhraic. Hidden Markov Models and Neural Networks for Fault Detection in Dynamic Systems. [Presentation] Pasadena : California Institute of Technology, 1994. 7