The Roller Coaster of PZA Ying Zhang, MD, PhD Department of Molecular Microbiology & Immunology Bloomberg School of Public Health Johns Hopkins University Email: yzhang@jhsph.edu
The Fate of PZA and Interest in PZA PZA (prodrug) is dynamic, Yin-Yang (Up and Down) drug, converting to POA In and Out of cell Active and Not Active: ph, metabolic state of bacilli Slow and Fast Reverters Weak and Strong RIF, TMC207, PA-824 PZA INH, EMB, SM Persisters
PZA: A Unique Drug in Treatment of TB and MDR-TB PZA discovery: 1952 PZA in DOTS: 6 month therapy - The best therapy against TB -Initial phase (daily, 2 months) with 4 drugs: INH, RIF, PZA, EMB -Continuation phase (4 months) with 2 drugs: INH, RIF PZA is used throughout MDR-TB treatment for 18-24 months
Pyrazinamide (PZA): An unconventional and paradoxical drug A most important front-line TB drug, that plays a key role in shortening therapy, because PZA kills persister TB bacilli that are not killed by other TB drugs Despite its powerful sterilizing activity in shortening therapy, curiously, no activity against TB bacilli in vitro in culture medium when bacteria are growing PZA is opposite to common antibiotics
Special Bacterial Populations Theory (Mitchison Hypothesis) High Speed of bacterial growth Low A. Continuous growth D. Dormant INH (RIF, SM, EMB) RIF Semi-dormant PZA B. Spurts of C. Acid metabolism inhibition
Paradoxical Features of PZA PZA is active at acidic ph (ph 5.5) (McDermott 1954) MIC is high = 50-100 µg/ml at acid ph 5.5-6.0, and kills MTB slowly PZA kills old, dormant bacilli more effectively than actively growing bacilli (Zhang et al., 2002) PZA kills non-replicating persisters more effectively under hypoxic/anaerobic conditions (Wade and Zhang, 2004), by energy inhibitors (Zhang et al., 2003 JAC) In vivo (mice or humans), it has impressive sterilizing activity and is involved shortening the therapy (McDermott 1956) EBA studies in humans: INH has high EBA in first 3 days, PZA has poor in first 2 weeks
Walsh McDermott (1909-1981) - Founding father of IOM, National Academies Clinical evaluation of INH- (Lasker Award, 1955) Cornell mouse model of TB Persistence Work on PZA: (a) acid ph requirement (b) PZA-resistant TB lose PZase (c) unique sterilizing activity of PZA in mice
PZA achieves high sterilizing activity with INH - Basis for SCC From McCune R M, Tompsett R, McDermott W J Exp Med 1956; 104: 763-802.
History of PZA Unconventional discovery: In 1944, Chorine found nicotinamide (vitamin B3) had antimycobacterial activity in animal models-> in 1948, Lederle Lab made analogs of nicotinamide -> PZA Used in clinical treatment in 1952 (same year as INH), mainly used as a second-line drug for drug-resistant cases or relapse because of liver toxicity due to high dose and long term use Inspired by McDermott s studies, British MRC conducted clinical trials late 1970s and early 80s, PZA was found to shorten the therapy from previously 9-12 months to 6 months -> used as first-line drug -> Basis for modern short-course TB therapy
PZA Resistance In 1967, McDermott and colleagues showed that PZA-resistant strains lose pyrazinamidase/nicotinamidase enzyme activity
Cloning of TB pnca gene Cloning of pyrazinamidase gene (pnca) and found mutation in pnca gene is the major mechanism of PZA resistance (Scorpio and Zhang, 1996, Nature Medicine, 2:662-667)
Mechanism of PZA Resistance Mutations in pnca gene are the major mechanism of PZA resistance: 72-97%(85%), small number with low level R no pnca mutations M. bovis strains including BCG are naturally resistant to PZA and lack PZase enzyme, due to a single characteristic point mutation in pnca gene, at nt. 169 from C to G, causing His57Asp Rapid differentiation of M. bovis from MTB strains based on detecting the C to G point mutation in the pnca gene
How does PZA work? The role of acid ph (Zhang et al., 1999): Henderson-Hasselbalch equation showing the relation between ph and PZA activity: (Zhang et al., 2002) PZA kills old, dormant bacilli more effectively than actively growing bacilli (Zhang et al., 2002) POA disrupt membrane potential and inhibits transport (Zhang et al., 2003) PZA kills non-replicating persisters more effectively under hypoxic/anaerobic conditions (Wade and Zhang, 2004) PZA activity is enhanced by energy inhibitors (Zhang et al., 2003), iron (Somoskovi et al., 2004), UV, weak acids (Wade et al., 2006; Gu et al., 2008)
Mode of Action of PZA (2003) Model can explain unusual properties of PZA: Acid ph, preferential activity for non-replicating persisters, hypoxic conditions
Enhanced PZA activity by energy inhibitors Zhang et al. J Antimicrob Chemother 2003, 52:790-5 PZA=100 µg/ml; 5 day incubation at ph5.5
Synergy Between Diarylquinoline (J) and PZA (Andries et al., 2005, Science, 307: 223-7) Like DCCD, J compound Inhibits F1F0 H-ATPase
What is the target of PZA? Fas-I was proposed as a target of PZA by Zimhony et al., (Nat Med, 2000, 6: 1043-7) However, Boshoff et al. showed that Fas-I is the target of 5-Cl-PZA, but not the target of PZA (J. Bacteriol. 2002, 184: 2167-72)
A New Target of PZA: RpsA We identified a new target of PZA RpsA that binds to POA Overexpression of RpsA conferred 5-fold PZA resistance in MTB from 100 to 500 µg/ml PZA A low level PZA-resistant M. tuberculosis DHM444 (MIC 200-300 µg/ml PZA) without pnca mutations (Scorpio 1997), contained a 3-bp deletion (ΔGCC) alanine missing in the C-terminus of RpsA
Trans-translation and PZA Trans-translation rescues ribosomes stalled on defective mrnas and adds a specific peptide tag sequence encoded by tmrna to aberrant polypeptides for degradation by proteases. Trans-translation is dispensable during active growth but becomes important under stress conditions in managing stalled ribosomes or damaged mrna and proteins, involved in stress survival and virulence RpsA binds tmrna and facilitates trans-translation mediated by a complex of tmrna, SmpB, Ef-Tu, RpsA
POA inhibits trans-translation in MTB in a concentration-dependent manner Implication for developing new drugs that target trans-translation, to avoid acid ph so it can be used throughout therapy
A Revised New Model of PZA
Molecular Methods for Detecting Mutations in Drug Resistance Genes PCR, followed by DNA sequencing, PCR-RFLP (HapII-katG 315), SSCP, heteroduplex formation, WAVE-DHPLC, molecular beacons, hybridization (Line-Probe assay) tests in microarray and macroarray, real-time PCR (TaqMan) Line-Probe assays (Hain Lifescience GenoType MTBDRplus) currently being evaluated in the field with promising results Xpert MTB/RIF TB test Cepheid (New England Journal Medicine, 2010) 1,730 patients with suspected drug-sensitive or multidrug-resistant pulmonary TB, identified 98 percent of all confirmed TB cases and 98 percent of patients with RIF-resistant bacteria in less than two hours. Line-probe assay and Xpert will not work for PZA resistance detection
Rapid Detection of PZA Resistance: pnca sequencing for mutations PZA susceptibility testing is not performed, problem of DST at acid ph, survey no PZA resistance data Acid ph inhibits growth (25-30% strains) BACTEC PZA test (Gold standard) ph 6.0, MIC cutoff of 100 µg/ml has false resistance problem, too slow (2 weeks), expensive We propose to sequence pnca gene for all drug-resistant TB strains (Mayo Clinic in US) -good correlation w pnca mutations and PZA resistance (>85%) -current PZA susceptibility testing is time-consuming, unreliable and expensive
PZA and New TB Drug Candidates Indispensable, Synergy FDA approved drugs: -New rifamycin: rifapentine approved by FDA in 1998; Rifapentine at higher dose plus moxifloxacin and PZA can shorten TB therapy to 2 months in mice (PLoS Med. 2007;4:e344): Phase II -Linezolid: Phase I and II trials Drug candidates under clinical development: -New fluoroquinolones (Bayer): moxifloxacin/gatifloxacin, Phase II, III -Diarylquinoline (TMC207) (Tibotec, Johnson & Johnson): TMC207 showing good activity in mice and shorten treatment with INH+PZA to 2 month-> Phase II trial (MDR-TB and drug susceptible TB) -Nitroimidazoles: Phase II trials (a) Nitroimidazolepyran (PA-824) (TB Alliance): PA-824+Moxi+PZA more effective than current therapy INH+RIF+PZA in mice (b) OPC-67683 (Otsuka), a nitro-dihydro-imidazooxazole derivative, OPC +RIF+PZA shorten therapy to 2 months in mice -Ethambutol analog, SQ-109 (Sequella), Phase I trial
Learn from PZA: Synergy Power of Synergy through Collaborations and Partnerships
The Fate of PZA and Interest in PZA
Acknowledgements Zhang Lab Wanliang Shi Angelo Scorpio May M. Wade Zhonghe Sun Peihua Gu Akos Somoskovi NIAID, NIH Fudan University Xuelian Zhang Xin Jiang Honghai Wang Wenhong Zhang Diane Griffin Mike Klag
Thank You!