Logistica Territoriale A. A. 2016-2017 http://didattica.uniroma2.it City Logistics: Urban Freight Surveys - Example of Rome DOCENTI Agostino Nuzzolo (nuzzolo@ing.uniroma2.it) Antonio Comi (comi@ing.uniroma2.it)
Policy assessment methodology Current Scenario Data collecting Models Ex-ante Assessment New Scenario Critical Issues Consultation New Current Scenario 2
Urban freight flows Choices and behaviour Location choice Residence Warehouse Actors behaviour End-consumer Wholesaler Retailer Trip choice Where to buy Which transport mode to use Which transport service type to use What time to restock Which type of vehicle to use Which delivery tour to follow Shops Large-scale retail Strategic/tactical horizon Large-Scale retailer Carrier Tactical/operative horizon Which transport service type to use What time to restock Which type of vehicle to use Which delivery tour to follow 3
Study area 16 Districts (traffic zones) 28 survey sections Freight ZTL 4
Study area Socio-economic characteristics Resident population and Workers Districts N. of census zones Area [km 2 ] Population Workers Resident Population Work force Employees Unemployed Total 5
Current regulation measures (1) The main regulations implemented concern: Activation of electronic gates (1 October 2001) to control access to the ZTL of the historical center, with the definition of the time windows and the access modes for the freight vehicles extension of the existing measures in the ZTL historical center to the districts Monti and Esquilino with the delimitation of the so called Freight ZTL permanent prohibition on access and circulation, starting from l January 2008, inside the Railway Ring alsofor the vehicles Pre-Euro 1 and Euro 1 6
Current regulation measures (2) In the Freight ZTL (Del. 856/2000 e Del. 44/2007), access rules: gross weight greater than 3.5 tons gross weight less than 3.5 tons 7
Dimension of the event (1/2) Vehicular flows (from automated counts) 256.965 vehic/day 37.875 vehic/day Total Freights 5,7% 59.185 vehic/day 223.524 vehic/day 8
Dimension of the event (2/2) Quantity ( from previous survey?) Clothing 29% Building materials 3% Foodstuffs 29% House optional 25% Hygiene /household products 2% Stationery 15% Other 15% Freight type Emission (t) Attraction (t) D Emission/attraction Clothing 262 1.260 20,8% House optional 1.127 4.618 24,4% Other 817 2.815 29,0% Stationery 1.053 3.568 29,5% Hygiene /household products 0 443 0,0% Building materials 157 539 29,1% Foodstuffs 54 6.626 0,8% Total 3.470 19.869 17,5% 9
Dimensions of the survey The survey was divided into: Flow counts (20/11/2007-28/11/2007) Freight ZTL survey period: 14 hours (from 7:00 to 21:00) Interviews to retailers of Freight ZTL about 575 interviews Interviews to carriers Freight ZTL about 502 interviews
Survey Counts Example of survey form 11
Urban flow composition Surveyed flow by time In Out Total 12
Traffic Counts Comparison with1999 Survey period: 7:00 18:00 Car flow: 1999: 176.000 2007: 230.000 Freight vehicles flow: 1999: 25.000 2007: 27.000 + 31% + 8%
Measured flows 256.965 vehic/day 37.875 vehic/day Total freight vehicles flow Survey Survey D (%) 1999 2008 25.247 27.449 + 9% 59.185 vehic/day 223.524 veihc/day + 1,6% for year 14
Flow composition Vehicle type Total motorcycles and scooters 156.134 cars 335.929 taxi 34.091 ATAC buses e AMA heavy vehicles 15.309 touristic buses 3.386 vans with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 1,5 t 18.673 vans with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 3,5 t 10.838 trucks with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 8,5 t 3.189 taxi 5,9% touristic buses 0,6% ATAC buses and AMA heavy vehicles 2,7% Total 577.549 vans with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 1,5 t 3,2% vans with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 3,5 t 1,9% Total Freight 5,7% trucks with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 8,5 t 0,6% motorcycles and scooters 27,0% cars 58,2% 15
Variation in the freight vehicle fleet Increase of light vehicles and decrease of heavy vehicles. Vehicle type Survey Survey 2007 1999 vans with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 1,5 t 57% 26% vans with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 3,5 t 33% 50% trucks with gross weight (p.t.t.) until 8,5 t 10% 22% Other freight vehicles 2% Totale 100% 100% 16
Survey Interview to economic operators Example of surveyed information identification data of the company; own account transport; type of deliveries to the clients; type of restock; type of park; main problems; suggestions to improve the freight transport in Roma center; 1 17
Survey Interview to economic operators 2 Example of survey form 18
Survey Interview to economic operators 3 19
Type of economic activities Activity type % Shop and public exercise 85% artisanal handicraft 13% Production unit or sale on public area 2% % cars 69% vans 25% trucks 6% Activity type employees Shop 2,98 artisanal handicraft 2,37 20
Type of economic activities From 100 to 200 m 2 27.4% Greater than 200 m 2 4.3% Warehouse area Sales area Less than 200 m 2 68.3% From 100 to 200 m 2 5.9% Greater than 200 m 2 0.8% No warehouse 22.1% Less than 100 m 2 71.2% 21
The restock 1/4 Distribution for restocking One or more times for week 30% Some months for year 4% Restocking frequency One or more times for month 11% One or more times for day 55% 22
Distribution Center Retailer Wholesale Own warehouse Production unit Other The restocking 2/4 Distribution of restocking by origin Distribution for restocking by time 23
On the roadside On private area Double park On sidewalk On loading/unload ing bay The restock 3/4 Characterization of park for restocking??? less than 10 minutes from 10 to 20 minutes greater than 20 minutes mean Rare Never Always Often No answer Total 24
The restock Restocking times Yes 10% Willingness to receive at different times from those opening 4/4 No 90% Surveyed delivery times Preferred delivery times 25
Survey Carriers 1 Example of surveyed information demographic information; characterization of the transport mode; characterization of the transport document; travel information; type of park; suggestions to improve the freight transport in Roma. 26
Survey Carriers 2 Example of survey form 27
Survey Carriers 3 28
The freight vehicle fleet Vehicle type/ Fueling type No answer Euro 1 Euro 2 Euro 3 Euro 4 Total Gasoline Diesel GPL Methane Total 29
Use of load/unload areas Often 16% No answer 10% Always 6% Never 35% Reasons for non-use of load/unload areas Rare 40% No answer 27% No answer 11% Distribution for restocking Missing 17% Occupied by vehicles 34% Occupied by other freight vehicles 11% 30
Transport demand Foodstuffs 29% Clothing 7% House optional 24% Building Material 3% Hygiene/ household products 2% Stationery 20% Other 15% Freight type Emission (t/g) Freight ZTL Attraction (t/g) D (emission/attraction) Clothing 38 1.075 3,5% House optional 88 2.864 3,1% Other 3 2.175 0,1% Stationery 31 2.476 1,3% Hygiene /household products 0,1 207 0,1% Building Material 0 468 0,0% Foodstuffs 34 5.234 0,6% Total 193 14.499 1,3% 31