India Plenary session 2: Sustainable and Inclusive Growth: Energy Access and Affordability New Delhi Background Paper
Disclaimer The observations presented herein are meant as background for the dialogue at the 16 th International Energy Forum. They have been prepared in collaboration with The Boston Consulting Group and should not be interpreted as the opinion of the International Energy Forum or The Boston Consulting Group on any given subject. IEF16 Plenary session 2 1
Introduction Market Context Energy Access is a key enabler for achieving Sustainable economic, environmental, health and social development There are 1.2B people globally without electricity access where Renewable and micro-grids can play an important role Investment in clean energy is on the rise and countries are taking these measures seriously Session Objectives To understand key enablers, drivers and benefits of Sustainable energy access To explore how renewables and micro-grids could help fill the energy access gap and what the key challenges are Overview of where the world is headed in terms of technological investments in this space Key Question: How can universal energy access and affordability be promoted, can the energy-water-food nexus create new opportunities? IEF16 Plenary session 2 2
Energy Access is a key enabler for Sustainable Development 1. No poverty 17. Partnerships for the goals 2. Zero hunger 16. Peace and justice strong institutions 15. Life on land 7. Affordable and clean energy 3. Good health and well being 4. Quality education 14. Life below water 5. Gender equality 13. Climate action 6. Clean water and sanitation 12. Responsible construction and production 8. Decent work and economic growth 11. Sustainable cities and communities 9. Industry innovation and infrastructure 10. Reduced inequalities Source: United Nations IEF16 Plenary session 2 3
Energy Access: What it means to society? Water access and purification Basic infrastructure Clean/efficient cooking Storage and flexibility Household energy needs Well-being and health Energy Access Household Work Institute Community Powering medical equipment Lightning for students Education and live hoods Enhance vocational training and skill development Digital learning aids E-learning New business opportunities Efficiency inexistent businesses (Productivity, time and savings) Source: BCG Research IEF16 Plenary session 2 4
Sustainable Energy Access creates significant benefits in four dimensions Economic Environment Health Social Improved productivity Extended operation hours of small businesses More mobile connectivity Time savings for fuel purchases incl. Fuel savings Reduced greenhouse gas emissions (CO2 and black carbon) Less landfill from disposable kerosene lanterns Reduction of fire hazards Reduce exposure to particulate matter Reduce risk of accidental ingestion of kerosene Reduce risk of compromised visual health Longer hours of better illumination Improved education Improved safety Improved social cohesion and leisure quality Job creation in supply chain Source: BCG Research IEF16 Plenary session 2 5
There are 1.2B people globally without electricity access Half of them are in Africa People without access to electricity in 2014 (M) Central and South Asia 302M <30 30-60 60-90 >90 South America 22M South East Asia and Pacific 210M Africa 634M Source: IEA WEO IEF16 Plenary session 2 6
Sub-Saharan Africa is the (single) geography with a large population expected not to have access to power by 2050 Billions of people without electricity access 2 266M expected not to have access to power by 2050 1 Forecast Sub-Saharan Africa 0 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 East Asia Latin America Middle East & North Africa Southeast Asia & Pacific South & Central Asia Sub-Saharan Africa Note: A scenario with high GDP growth but lower increase in population Source: World Energy Council IEF16 Plenary session 2 7
Renewable and micro-grids are the local measures to reinforce Energy Access Leveraging brand and financing to be an advocate for transition to low-carbon economy Macro level National/ Global Transition to green electricity in major emitting countries Global agreements to fight climate change User-centric perspective choosing the best solution to expand clean energy access (technology-agnostic) and create ecosystem Micro level Local Large-scale solar farm connected to grid Replacing diesel generators with renewable sources Mini-grid/ off-grid Clean cookstoves Reduced GHG emissions (direct climate impact) Improved living conditions (foundation's beneficiaries) IEF16 Plenary session 2 8
Renewables and micro-grids are facing some challenges in developing countries Challenges Large-scale solar (grid connected) Replacing diesel generators Off-grid/minigrid solutions Clean cook stoves Pico solar/solar Home Systems Barriers Policy framework and support policies Openness to (foreign) investors CapEx financing CapEx financing Regulation (e.g., mandatory replacement, capital subsidy also for solar and storage) Customer awareness CapEx Financing (e.g.,high tariffs) Uncertainty around grid connection Uncertain/low customer demand Technical problems High O&M costs Awareness/Educ.: Consumer adoption and correct usage Stove design Distribution (stoves and fuel) Financing (CapEx & OpEx) CapEx Financing/Customer lease financing Distribution Regulation (VAT and import levies) Notes: Global impact estimates take into account current household expenditure and affordability of clean systems. Lower-bound estimates. Source: IFC; Hystra; CSE; BCG Analysis IEF16 Plenary session 2 9
Renewable energy is a credible solution to some of these issues and will help increase access to electricity Structural issues resulting in underinvestment Heavy investments with long lead times Unreliable sourcing and high distribution costs Operational issues Selected opportunities for renewable energy in Africa Smaller, more flexible investments with shorter payback time Increased investment appetite both from developed countries and from African governments as well (>$7B invested in RE in 2015) Near unlimited capacity of solar PV energy (>10 TW in Africa) Technology cost decreases (-80% in last 5 years in India for Solar), RES today already competitive versus fossil fuel in selected areas by 2030 likely one of cheapest power in >50% of African countries More mature, newer technology including off-grid technology to mitigate power shortages Renewables could help diversify energy supply and ensure the best use of available regional resources especially in rural areas Regulatory framework and other (country) risks Strong international lobby and committed from selected local governments, acceleration of RE agenda since COP 21 New Initiatives launched (e.g., Africa Renewable Energy Initiative) Some specific country risks remain, but positive long-term outlook (e.g., borrowing in local currency, political stability) IEF16 Plenary session 2 10
Clean Energy Investment equals B334$ in 2017 Investment in clean energy B$ x5 324 321 360 325 334 276 291 269 182 205 207 130 62 88 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Source: Bloomberg New Energy Finance IEF16 Plenary session 2 11
Onshore wind and solar PV are leading the race, but energy storage can be a game changer Production cost High Moderate Tidal energy Emerging Hydroelectric Geothermal energy Solar CSP Offshore wind Under Development Energy storage Solar photovoltaic Biomass Onshore wind Mature Development status of the sector s technology IEF16 Plenary session 2 12
Wind and Solar reported 80% of total investments Energy storage and smart technologies gaining critical mass Clean Energy investment by technology in 2017 B$ 107 49 15% 17 5% 334 161 32% 48% Solar PV Wind Storage & Smart Others 1 Total 1. Biomass, biofuels, marine, geothermal, small hydro Source: BNEF 2017 IEF16 Plenary session 2 13
26 countries worldwide with >B1$ clean energy investments in 2017 (I) B$ 132.6 Top 10 countries 56.9 23.4 14.6 11.0 10.3 9.0 6.2 6.2 5.0 China America Japan Germany India UK Austr Mexico Brazil FR Source: BNEF IEF16 Plenary session 2 14
26 countries worldwide with >B1$ clean energy investments in 2017 (II) B$ Other 16 countries with >B1$ 4.0 3.5 3.3 2.9 2.6 2.5 2.3 2.2 2.0 1.8 1.7 1.5 1.2 1.1 1.0 1.0 Sweden Canada Egypt Netherlands South Korea Italy Turkey Norway Switzerland Austria Taiwan UAE Argentina Chile Spain Indonesia Source: BNEF IEF16 Plenary session 2 15
Micro-grid is the most viable option in most developing countries Indicative levelized costs of electricity for a traditional grid vs. micro-grid and off-grid technologies in sub-saharan Africa (2013) Cost of extending a traditional electricity grid to an isolated community Cost of installing a micro-grid and off-grid with different distributed generation technologies $/MWh Grid extension costs 1 Electricity price 249 $/MWh 334 306 Fuel and O&M costs Investment costs 261 247 89 130 On-grid supply 1 km of lines per community 3km of lines per community Generator ($1/litre) Solar PV Small hydro Small wind 1. Costs of grid extension are calculated as the average cost of extending the medium-voltage grid a certain distance (e.g., 1 km) to each community on a levelized cost basis. Note: Costs are indicative and could vary significantly depending on local conditions such as electricity tariffs, population density and the delivered cost of diesel Source: World Energy Outlook 2014 IEF16 Plenary session 2 16
60% of new generation to be connected to micro-grids or off grid if full electricity access is to be achieved Generation requirements for universal electricity access, 2030 TWh 462 80 24 952 221 40 13 7 4 94 172 245 87 48 112 400 85 Off-grid Micro grid 187 195 380 Traditional grid Sub-Saharan Africa India Other Asia Rest of the World World 1. Includes OECD and transition economies Source: IEA (Estimates 2010) IEF16 Plenary session 2 17
Key Questions 1 How can governments provide a conducive environment for new technologies to grow and support sustainable energy access for all? 2 What role must traditional energy companies play and why would it be of critical importance for them to make sustainable energy access a success? 3 What innovative business models can help sustain robust investments into Renewables and Micro-grids? IEF16 Plenary session 2 18
India Plenary session 2: Sustainable and Inclusive Growth: Energy Access and Affordability New Delhi Background Paper IEF16 Plenary session 2 19