PileMedic for Repair and Strengthening of Columns & Underwater Piles How can we fix these piers in a day while maintaining traffic? Mo Ehsani, Ph.D., P.E., S.E. President, QuakeWrap, Inc., and Professor Emeritus of Civil Engineering, Univ. of Arizona November 2010 2 Why Repair/Strengthen? Carry larger loads Correct construction errors/omissions Replace deteriorated materials (steel, concrete, etc. ) Accidental damage (e.g. truck hitting a girder) Comply with new code requirements (e.g. ties for confining R/C columns) Blast Protection History & Background of FRP 100% FRP Hull 3 Corvette C1-1953 FRP Products Fiber Reinforced Polymer (FRP) Why is it called FRP? It is a Polymer (i.e. epoxy, vinyl ester, etc.) that has been reinforced with a Fiber (e.g. carbon, glass, etc.) FRP does not have the same strength in all directions; these types of materials are called anisotropic Reinforcing Fiber (Glass, Carbon, Kevlar, etc.) Interphase Coupling Agent 5 Polymer Resin Matrix Page 1
FRP Version 1.0 Introduced March 1990 History of FRP in Repair & Retrofit 1988-89 1990 1993-94 1997-98 2004-05 2009-10 Beams Columns Masonry Walls PCCP (Large Dia. Pipes) Blast Mitigation SuperLaminate 7 8 Original Concept Demonstration Blast Protection 9 10 Fort Bragg, N.C. Wet Layup Process: Saturation of Fabric 11 12 Page 2
Sample QuakeWrap Projects Advantages of FRP Testing + R&D Condo, FL Chimney, AL Bridge, NM Museum, CA Bldg, PR High Tensile Strength (3-5 times stronger than Steel) Low Weight (no foundation adjustments required) Anisotropic (strength depends on fiber orientation) Corrosion Resistance & Acid Protection Waterproof Excellent Fatigue Behavior Speed of Construction Versatility Odorless & Non-Toxic (QuakeWrap Products) Low Cost Bridge, IN Pipe, Costa Rica Bldg, AK13 14 Applications of FRP Tension Reinforcement -- recall that shear is resisted as diagonal tension Confinement Water & Chemical Resistance Barrier Corrosion Protection through Closure Against Oxygen Penetration recall that O 2 is the fuel for corrosion process R/C Columns 15 16 Failure of R/C Columns Concrete Confined with QuakeWrap Stress Confined f c Unconfined 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Strain (%) 17 18 Page 3
Retrofit of R/C Columns with Steel Jackets Retrofit of Columns with QuakeWrap Flexural Reinforcement Shear/Confinement Reinforcement Southern California 19 20 Testing of Control Column Specimen Control Specimen Repaired & Re-Tested 21 22 Testing of Retrofitted Companion Specimen Comparison of Column Specimens Control Control: Repaired & Re-Tested Retrofitted Companion 23 24 Page 4
Corroded Bridge Column Indiana Project B-28198 Oklahoma City Project IM-40-4(354)151 3-ft Diameter x 35-ft Columns 25 26 Oklahoma City Project IM- 40-4(354)1514(354)151 Bay View Drive Bridge Ft. Lauderdale, FL 3-ft Diameter x 35-ft Columns 27 28 History of FRP in Repair & Retrofit Sandwich Construction of PipeMedic Laminates (Patent Pending) 1988-89 1990 1993-94 1997-98 2004-05 2009-10 Beams Columns Masonry Walls PCCP (Large Dia. Pipes) Blast Mitigation SuperLaminate Multi-Axial Reinforcement Thickness 0.01-0.025 inch Tensile Strength up to 155,000 psi Infinite combinations of strength & stiffness can be produced ISO 9000 Certified 29 30 Page 5
FRP Version Rewriting 1.0 the story 20 years later FRP Version 2.0 Advantages of SuperLaminates Laminates manufactured in plant Significantly reduces construction time Improves quality; stronger than wet layup Material properties known in advance Less dependent on experience of field crew Local contractors can be easily trained/certified Offers solutions which are impossible with wet layup 31 Confinement of Square Columns with SuperLaminates Structural Shell No Finished Surface Required Circular or Square Columns Retrofit of Steel Columns in existing frame Wrap laminate in a cylindrical shape around column Secure the top end Fill annular space with concrete or grout Can construct a composite steelconcrete column Increase axial & buckling load for column 33 34 Concrete Confined with PileMedic Stress f c Unconfined or cast in a jacket with seams 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Confined in PileMedic Strain (%) Effect of Confining Pressure on Concrete Strength Assume: concrete cylinder with 100 in 2 of area Compressive strength of concrete (f c ) = 5000 psi Strength of cylinder = 5000 x 100 = 500,000 pounds (or 500 kips) Now assume cylinder is confined with PileMedic : Confining pressure = 800 psi f cc = 5000 + (4.1 x 800) = 8280 psi Strength of cylinder = 8280 x 100 = 828 kips The 328 kips gain in strength is due to confinement effect! 35 36 Page 6
Repair of Corrosion-Damaged Steel Columns Repair of Corroded Bridge Piles 37 38 Current Pile Repair System PileMedic for Encapsulation of Underwater Piles The Jacket that Fits All! 39 40 Conventional vs. PileMedic Jacket Pile Jacket Systems Available to Date 41 42 Page 7
Comparison of Tensile Strength with Conventional Jackets PileMedic PLC150.10 PileMedic PLC100.60 PileMedic PLG60.60 Five File Star PileForm F MFG FRP Pile Sleeves Five Star Rock Water Fox Indust. FX-70 Denso Sea Shield 400 BASF APE Jacket 0 40000 80000 120000 160000 Tensile Strength, psi 43 Design Data: 12x12 inch pile f c = 4000 psi Ignore reinforcing steel Design Example P n = 0.85 f c (12x12) = 490 kips Encapsulated Pile: 18 inch diameter Fill with 4000 psi grout 18 1800 1800 1200 1200 600 0 490 12 12 774 k due to confinement 865 865 Pile Ordinary Jacket PileMedic Same pile encapsulated in PileMedic, P n = 1639 kips 44 1639 Advantages of Repair Using PileMedic 3-4 times stronger than steel No weak seams along the sides Provides structural confinement Increases axial capacity beyond original strength Does not corrode No metallic bolts or straps Grout can be pressurized to fill all voids and cracks No custom manufacturing one size fits all Wraps directly on pile > Small annular space Available in carbon or glass Aesthetically pleasing Limited use or no need for costly divers Repair of Underwater Piles 45 46 Utility Pole Repair Pressurized Injection of Resin into Wooden Utility Pole 47 The resin fills all crevices & cracks!! 48 Page 8
Advantages of Repair of Utility Poles with PileMedic Back to the bridge piers. Fills all voids & crevices in wood Strengthens pole beyond original capacity Maintains the shape of pole Prevents against future decay of wood Easily installed by utility company crew Ideal for strengthening or emergency repairs Green Technology 49 50 Green Sustainable Technology Trenchless (No excavation) A 24-inch (600 mm) access is sufficient Non-Toxic & No VOC Chemicals Light-Weight Materials > Easy Shipping Fast Construction w/ Small Crew Thank you for your Attention! Questions? www.quakewrap.com Email: Mo@QuakeWrap.com Toll Free: (866) QuakeWrap[782-5397] 51 52 Page 9