Characteristics of the particulate matter in Riyadh city, Saudi Arabia

Similar documents
Dispersion of Respirable Particles Emitted from Surface Mining Operations

How safe is Beijing s Air Quality for Human Health? Naresh Kumar Θ

Air quality in the vicinity of a governmental school in Kuwait

Statistical analysis of ambient air PM10 contamination during winter periods for Ruse region, Bulgaria

Title: Peak Event Analysis: A Novel Empirical Method for the Evaluation of Elevated Particulate Events

MEAN ANNUAL EXPOSURE OF CHILDREN AGED 0-4 YEARS TO ATMOSPHERIC PARTICULATE POLLUTION

Study on the Seasonal Variation and Source Apportionment of PM 10 in Harbin, China

12. EMISSIONS OF SULPHUR DIOXIDE

Indicator Fact Sheet Signals 2001 Air Pollution

WILPINJONG COAL PTY LTD. Environment Protection Licence (EPL) 12425

WILPINJONG COAL PTY LTD. Environment Protection Licence (EPL) 12425

GRIMM Aerosol Technik Grimm Instrumentation The future of particle measurement Ing. Wolfgang Brunnhuber Environmental Division Manager

Chemical composition and source apportionment of PM 1.0, PM 2.5 and PM in the roadside environment of Hong Kong

WASHINGTON COUNTY. Air Quality PM2.5

HAQT- Helsinki AQ Testbed Ari Karppinen; Athens 6/2017

Understanding of the Heavily Episodes Using the

Near reference sensors and their application. February 13 th, 2017 Hannamari Jaakkola, Vaisala Oyj

TROPOSPHERIC AEROSOL PROGRAM - TAP

THE ULTIMATE Environmental fine dust measurement devices

ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS OF THE OPEN CAST MINING OPERATIONS AT SAMMAD URBAN AREAS NEAR TO LIMESTONE QUARRIES AMMAN 2010

Energy-Intensive Adaptation to Particulate Matter Pollution

Proceedings of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.8, 2011

FIDAS FINE DUST MONITORING SYSTEMS. Fidas the world s only certified optical fine dust measurement system with single particle analysis for PM 2.

Noise & air quality research in Amsterdam

Sand Mining and Transport: Potential Health Effects. Thomas M. Peters, PhD, CIH Associate Professor University of Iowa Iowa City, IA

The assessment is based upon the design ore production of 95 million tonnes / annum.

Source Contributions to Ambient PM 10 and Implications for Mitigation- a Case Study. Shanju Xie, Tom Clarkson and Neil Gimson ABSTRACT

LEZA Low Emission Zone in Amsterdam: Implementation and evaluation of effects on air quality by long-term monitoring

Counting the Way to Cleaner Air

Dependence of Mixed Aerosol Light Scattering Extinction on Relative Humidity in Beijing and Hong Kong

Corvallis Ozone and Aerosol Experiment (COAX)

Air Quality Monitoring at Dublin Airport: Annual Report for HSSE Department

Particulate Matter Rules Update BAAQMD BACWA Meeting

Environmental Health Report

INDOOR AIR QUALITY AND THE ADEQUACY OF CLEANING IN 25 FINNISH SCHOOLS

Initial Sand Mine and Processing Plant Particulate Levels. Crispin Pierce PhD University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire 20 January 2013

Chapter 3 - ATMOSPHERIC TRANSPORT AND MERCURY DEPOSITION

Impact of traffic composition and street canyon on the street level air quality and pedestrian exposure in Central, Hong Kong

TECHNICAL DATA SHEET

CEN/TC 264/WG 17 N 147

Aethalometer Black Carbon measurements, source apportionment model and its use in air pollution monitoring

Performance Standards for Indicative Ambient Particulate Monitors Environment Agency July 2012 Version 2

AIR EMISSIONS FROM TWO SWINE FINISHING BUILDING WITH FLUSHING: AMMONIA CHARACTERISTICS

Monthly Environmental Monitoring Report

Ambient Air Monitoring Systems

49 instead of 9 Filter Classes The Air Filter Standard ISO in an Overview.

Multi-site Time Series Analysis. Motivation and Methodology

Modelling wintertime PM 10 dispersion in Masterton, New Zealand: a tool for implementing national standards

A record of atmospheric 210 Pb accumulation in the industrial city

Evaluation of Port of Casablanca Operations on Air Quality in the Greater Metropolitan Area of Casablanca, Morocco

Relationship between quality of ambient air and respiratory diseases in the Polish population

2014/15. The ultimate Environmental Dust Measurement Devices (EDM) 30 years of scientific research a CHOOSE THE BEST TECHNOL

EFFECT OF METEOROLOGICAL CONDIATION ON NOx POLLUTION OF KOTA CITY, INDIA

WBEA Standard Operating Procedure

Air quality in the Mesogaia Plain in Eastern Attica before and after the opening of the Athens International Airport

Pittsburgh Modeling for the PM 2.5 NAAQS EPA Regional/State/Local Modelers Workshop. May 2, 2012

Recommended Protocol for Evaluating the Location of Sensitive Land Uses Adjacent to Major Roadways

Preliminary Field Evaluation of EPA Method CTM-039 (PM2.5 Stack Sampling Method) Michael D. Buser and Derek P. Whitelock

Air Pollution. GEOL 1350: Introduction To Meteorology

Effects of Ambient Temperature on the Performance of a Photovoltaic Solar System in a Tropical Area.

Excerpt of Thermal Power Guidelines for New Plants

Nova Scotia Air Zone Report. Nova Scotia Air Quality Unit, 2015

Short-term intra-urban variability of UFP number concentration and size distribution October 2013 campaign

ASSESSMENT OF TRAFFIC INDUCED POLLUTION FROM THE NEW HIGHWAY OF ATHENS (ATTIKI ODOS) Observatory of Athens, Athens, Greece

Implementation Issues for the PM 2.5 National Ambient Air Quality Standards PM 2.5 NAAQS

Integrating Renewable Fuel Heating Systems

PM status for 2012 and the main issues regarding the EMEP measurement program

Coincidence Factor Study Residential and Commercial & Industrial Lighting Measures. Prepared for; New England State Program Working Group (SPWG)

Bengalla Mining Company Pty Limited. Particulate Matter Control Best Practice Implementation Monitoring Programs

2008 Beltwide Cotton Conferences, Nashville, Tennessee, January 8-11, 2008

AIR POLLUTION IN KENYA J. KARUE 1, A.M. KINYUA 2, L. NJAU 3. P.O. Box 56160, Nairobi, Kenya

AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT IN THE NORTH WEST PROVINCE OF SOUTH AFRICA A SUCCESSFUL PARTNERSHIP WITH INDUSTRY

J. Sciare, and LSCE-CAE team. Laboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l'environnement (LSCE) Mix unit CNRS-CEA, Gif-sur-Yvette, France

2010 AIR POLLUTION CONTROL

The environmental impact of urban transport: a case study for a new road in Catania province

Source Apportionment of PM 2.5 at Three Urban Sites Along Utah s Wasatch Front

Maryland Clean Air Progress Report

Air Quality Statistics

Case study on pollution prediction through atmospheric dispersion modelling

10.0 AIR QUALITY AND CLIMATIC FACTORS

EXAMINATION OF TRAFFIC POLLUTION DISTRIBUTION IN A STREET CANYON USING THE NANTES 99 EXPERIMENTAL DATA AND COMPARISON WITH MODEL RESULTS

WEATHER MONITORING. Competitive rates available for long term hire. Hire rate Per week Per month

Air Pollution in NJ: Past,Present and thoughts about the Future

What is PM 2.5? DASH-Spatial Study Background. DASH Study Background. Ion Chromatography Analysis of PM 2.5

Ambient Air Monitoring

ASSESSMENT OF BIOAEROSOL DISTRIBUTIONS IN MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE TRANSFER STATION

ATM S 211 Final Examination June 4, 2007

HEAT RECUPERATION IN VENTILATION SYSTEM OF BASEMENT LABORATORY

STATE OF THE AIR QUALITY IN THE MAIN REGIONS OF PEARL RIVER DELTA

Physical, chemical and biological characteristics of dust storms in Ahvaz, Iran

Ambient Air Quality in Dhaka Bangladesh over Two Decades: Impacts of Policy on Air Quality

ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND EMISSION REDUCTION OF TPM, PM 2.5, AND SO 2 FROM NATURAL GAS AND FUEL OIL FIRED BOILER EXHAUSTS

Clean Air Health Benefits from Climate Change Mitigation Action George D. Thurston

Appendix B2. Air Dispersion Modeling

Air Quality in the Eastern Sierra

Use of the Superfund/Elutriator Method to Determine Asbestos Structure Concentrations in Beach Sand

Introduction to a Comprehensive Air Modeling/Optimization System (CAMOS)

The role of light duty vehicles in future air pollution: a case study of Sacramento

WIRELESS SENSOR NETWORKS FOR AIR- POLLUTION MONITORING IN CITIES

Transcription:

Environmental Health Risk VII 131 Characteristics of the particulate matter in Riyadh city, Saudi Arabia A. S. Modaihsh and M. O. Mahjoub Soil Science Department, College of Food Sciences and Agriculture, King Saud University, Saudi Arabia Abstract Increased concern about the impact of the so-called particulate matter on air quality and public health has occurred in recent years. This concern is based on the increased knowledge on the impact the smallest particles have on human health. The primary goal of this study is to carry out a comprehensive characterization of Riyadh bio-aerosol and aerosol samples of PM1, and PM2.5 and provide the scientific background for the further control of air pollution at Riyadh and to develop effective strategies to reduce the ambient concentrations of PM and reduce the deposition of this pollutant to the city. Real time ambient air quality was monitored at Riyadh airport. Mass concentrations of PM2.5 and PM10 (particulate matter smaller than 2.5 and 10 μm in diameter, respectively) for January April were measured. The concentrations of coarse (PM10), and fine (PM2.5) particulate matter were measured using a Grimm model EDM 365 aerosol spectrometer. Measurement of particulate matter concentrations were obtained at time intervals ranging from 1 s to 60 min. Measurement of particulates was done via laser-light scattering. The counts from each size classification are then converted to mass by a well-established equation. Results indicated that temporal variation observed either for PM10 or PM2.5. was associated mainly with the dust events. There is no significant temporal variation of influential metrological parameters. The ratio between PM10 and PM2.5 were found to be 0.25. Statistical analysis has shown a strong positive correlation between them. Keywords: PM10, PM2.5, dust storms, meteorological data, Saudi Arabia, Riyadh. doi:10.2495/ehr130121

132 Environmental Health Risk VII 1 Introduction Due to the increased knowledge on the impact the smallest particles have on human health, recent years have witnessed a growing concern about the so-called particulate matter. Since 1997, research on air pollution count aerosols as one of the six major air pollutants (EPA [1]). Particulate matters have been divided according to their origin into natural and anthropogenic aerosols (Barry and Chorley [2]). The major sources of anthropogenic aerosols include fuel combustion from automobiles, power plants, wood burning, industrial processes, and diesel powered vehicles such as buses and trucks. Soil-derived (mineral) dust particles can be a major part of the atmospheric PM 2.5 and PM 10 concentrations (Sudheer and Rengarajan [3]). To address the issue of atmospheric particulate matter in Riyadh city, El-Shobokshy [4, 5] conducted his pioneering study on particulate pollution in Saudi Arabia, but his studies concentrated only on atmospheric lead pollution in the city of Riyadh. In 1990, El-Shobokshy et al. [6] investigated the influence of meteorology on the concentration of inhalable particulates which are usually observed in the atmosphere of Riyadh at high concentrations. However, the studies mentioned above were based on a limited number of samples. No follow-up research to close the gap between the association of meteorological parameters, falling dust, Particulate matter concentration and health hazards has yet been performed. This is crucial if officials in the city are to develop strategies to reduce the impact of the deposition of Aeolian and ambient pollutants. This study aims to identify and quantify the source types contributing to ambient particulate matter, which is deposited within Riyadh. 2 Methods Traditional method of PM 10 dust measurement is based on a weight to volume measurement, where by the dust is collected on a filer and subsequently weighed. This method requires a rigid adherence to time consuming procedures. With the finer dust size fraction introduction (PM 2.5, PM 1 ) the problem is negligible mass compared to the large numbers of these particles. For these reason a newly developed Aerosol Spectrometer will be introduced for measurement of various PM particulates. In this study, the concentrations of coarse (PM10), and fine (PM2.5), particulate matter were measured using a Grimm model EDM 365 aerosol spectrometer (Grimm Aerosol Technik GmbH, Ainring, Germany). The device, an optical particle counter (OPC), is an instrument for real-time measurement of particulate matter. The particle size analyser/dust monitor determines the dustconcentration (counts/litre) through the optical-light-scattering method directly; however, the mass concentration is determined by extrapolation. The calculated mass concentration may be corrected to the specific aerosol measured with the gravimetric-correction factor (C-Factor). The advantages of this instrument over other real-time measurement instruments, such as TEOM or DMA devices, are its convenience, its low maintenance requirements, and its ability to run for long

Environmental Health Risk VII 133 periods without specific supervision. The ability to measure particulate matter concentrations in time intervals ranging from 1 s to 60 min is considered to be another advantage offered by the instrument. The validity of the measurements performed by the instrument has been evaluated by several studies (Burkart et al. [7]). The dust monitor was installed on the roof of the Meteorology and Environmental building near Riyadh airport. The dust monitor ran 24 hours a day continuously. 3 Results and discussion 3.1 Particulate mass concentration The concentrations of PM 10, and PM 2.5 were measured on 88 days from January 29 th through April 7th 2012. These measurement produced huge data and points for the concentration of PM 10 and PM 2.5, temperature and relative humidity data given for each week and covering this period. Figures 1 5 show the average daily concentration of PM 10, and PM 2.5 during different months of the study period. The overall mean value of PM 10 PM 2.5 were 563.37 µg/m 3 and 141.66 µg/m 3 respectively and the corresponding maximum values were 2371.23 µg/m 3 and 640.8 µg/m 3 and the corresponding minimum values were 91.6 and 21.49 µg/m 3. As shown in these figures, daily concentrations of both PM 10 and PM 2.5 measured at Riyadh airport were highly variable. Some very high concentrations (above 8000 and 2000 µg/ m 3 were occasionally measured for PM 10, and PM 2.5 respectively). The temporal variation observed either PM 10 or PM 2.5 was associated mainly with the dust events. The results of PM 10, and PM 2.5 concentrations, obtained in this study are little higher than those found in other studies. Results obtained by studies of PM 2.5 concentrations conducted in China by Ye et al. [8], reported a mean PM 2.5 concentration of 67.6 µg/m 3. Also He et al. [9] reported 89 µg/m 3 during the spring. These values are little less than the values reported in this study. On the other hand some other studies reported more or less similar results. For an example PM 10 concentrations higher than 3000 and produced by dust events were observed in a study conducted in Iraq, Kuwait and Saudi Arabia (Draxler et al. [10]). In contrast, Meng and Lu [11] observed mean PM 2.5 concentrations of up to 216.7 µg/m 3, which was higher than the results presented in this study (almost double). The explanation for this substantial difference is that the PM in the cited study is measured during winter months where fossil fuel combustions which considered as the primary source of fine particulate is highest In this study we observed that PM 10 and PM 2.5 concentrations mainly depend on dust storms occasions. Our study clearly indicated that the hourly mean PM 10 and PM 2.5 concentration increased significantly during dust storms. Since there is no universally accepted definition of dust storms in terms of hourly dust concentrations, we arbitrary choose the criterion suggested by Park et al. [12] who identified dust events as the peak PM 10 concentration exceeding one

134 Environmental Health Risk VII standard deviation of the annual mean concentration. Our criterion for dust storm events was an hourly mean PM 10 concentration exceeding one standard deviation of the mean concentration during the study period (Mean =563. 37 and standard deviation= 501. 78 µg/ m 3 ). Based on this criterion, from Jan 29th to April 7th 2012, we identified 1, 9, 13, and 6 dust events at January, February, March and April respectively. In comparison, Chung et al. [13], defined dust storms in terms of measured PM 10 concentration exceeds 190 μg m 3 for at least 2 h. Figure 1: Daily 24-hour average PM 10, and PM 2.5 concentration µg/m 3 (29/1 12/2).

Environmental Health Risk VII 135 Figure 2: Average PM 10, and PM 2.5 concentration µg/m 3 (13/2 26/2). 3.2 Relationships between PM 10, PM 2.5 The ratios of PM 10 and PM 2.5 concentration data during 29/1/2011 26/04/2012 were analyzed. The obtained results showed that the ratios vary between 0.18 and 0.46). The ratios between monthly mean PM 10 and PM 2.5 concentrations in February was between 0.19 and 0.31, in March were 0.18 0.45 and 0.20 0.39 in April. The daily averages of PM 2.5 /PM 10, ratios over the study showed that a little decrease was observed in the dust days. The mean PM 2.5 /PM10 ratio for the entire study period was 0.25. The mean values of these ratios during the dust days were 0.22.

136 Environmental Health Risk VII Figure 3: Average PM 10, and PM 2.5 concentration µg/ m 3 (27/2 11/3). The average PM 2.5 /PM 10 ratio observed here is much lower than those found in other studies. For example, He et al. [9] reported a mean PM 2.5 /PM 10 ratio of 0.64 for the entire study period. In addition, Ye et al. [8] reported a mean PM 2.5 /TSP ratio of 0.55 for the entire study period. The primary reason for this difference is that in the two studies cited, the PM 2.5 /PM 10 or PM 2.5 /TSP ratios were calculated for the entire year, including the autumn and winter. During these seasons, the fine fraction of particulate matter (i.e., PM 2.5 ) is highest because various sources primarily release finer particles during these seasons and therefore produce an increase in the PM 2.5 /PM 10 ratio. Accordingly, in the study of Ye et al. [8], the PM 2.5 /TSP ratio in winter increased to 0.73, whereas the ratio

Environmental Health Risk VII 137 decreased to 0.35 in the late spring. In the present study, the PM 2.5 /PM 10 ratio was the lowest during the dust events with slight increases in non-dust days. Therefore, these low ratios can be considered to represent dust events, the main component of which is expected to be coarse particles. Figure 4: Average PM 10, and PM 2.5 concentration µg/ m 3 (12/3 25/3).

138 Environmental Health Risk VII Figure 5: Average PM 10, and PM 2.5 concentration µg/m 3 (26/3 8/4). 3.3 Influence of meteorological parameters on particulate matter The relationship between ambient particulate matter data and meteorological factors, such as temperature, relative humidity, was statistically analyzed. Table 1 shows the descriptive statistics of particulate matter and meteorological factors. Table 2 depicts the relationship between particle concentrations (PM 10 and PM 2.5 ) and meteorological parameters (temperature, relative humidity). Very poor correlation was observed between particulate matters (PM 10, PM 2.5 ) and meteorological parameters (temperature and relative humidity). The PM 10 and PM 2.5 is found to be strongly correlated with each other and inversely correlated

Environmental Health Risk VII 139 with temperature with correlation coefficient of -0.43 and positively correlated with relative humidity, with a correlation coefficient of 0.28. Contrary to our results, several studies have confirmed the influence of meteorological conditions on PM concentrations (Giri et al. [14]; Kuang [15]). Atmospheric pressure, wind velocity temperature and humidity were found to be significant factors in influencing PM 10. The present study demonstrated that temperature and relative humidity showed insignificant correlation to PM concentrations. This may be due to the fact that means of the whole day of PM on one hand and the average temperature humidity on the other hand might cancel the variation between night and day. Therefore, we selected different data in one day and split it between day and night hours to test the influence of temperature and humidity on PM concentrations. The obtained results depicted in table 3 showed the daily variation of PM 10 and temperature during morning hours and evening hours separately in three different days. It was found that an inverse relationship exists between temperature and particulate data at relatively lower temperatures and a positive result with temperature and particulate matter exist under higher temperature. The correlation studies of the daily average of PM 10 and PM 2.5 concentration and various metrological factors at different seasons is needed to establish their relationship. Table 1: Date Descriptive statistics of particulate matter and meteorological factors. Equation r 2 Morning hours Evening hours Morning hours Evening hours 31/1/2012 y = 4.3483x 0. 2161 y = 3.215x 0. 2654 0.8493 0.7716 29/2/2012 y = 106. 9x -0. 282 y = 141.69x -0. 335 0.8119 0.8349 30/3/2012 y = 55.532x -0. 157 y = 61.708x -0. 226 0.8075 0.5097 Table 2: Spearman rank correlation coefficient of particulate data and meteorological factors. Parameters Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation N PM 10 (µg/m 3 ) 91.7 2371.2 563.37 501.78 88 PM 2.5 (µg/m 3 ) 21.5 640.8 141.66 131.86 88 TEMP. ( o C) 10.4 28.8 19.92 4.93 88 RH (%) 9.10 61.9 31.65 12.68 88 TEMP, RH, refers to temperature, relative humidity. Values were rounded to two decimal places.

140 Environmental Health Risk VII Table 3: Correlation coefficient of particulate data and meteorological factors. PM 10 PM 2.5 TEMP RH PM 10 1.000 PM 2.5 0.986** 1.00 TEMP -0.04-0.04 1.00 RH -0.29-0.58-0.16 1.00 **Correlation is significant at.01 level. Acknowledgement The authors extend their thanks to the National Plan for Science and Technology Saudi Arabia for financial support of project #08 ENV319-02 under the title Characteristics and Composition of the Falling Dust and Particulate Matter and its Health Hazards in Riyadh City, Saudi Arabia. References [1] EPA Air Trends- Criteria Pollutant. AIRNOW 2009. [2] Barry, R. G. and Richard J. Chorley, Atmosphere, Weather and Climate, Routledge, New York, 2000. [3] Sudheer, A. K and R. Rengarajan. Atmospheric Mineral Dust and Trace Metals over Urban Environment in Western India during Winter. Aerosol and Air Quality Research, 12: 923 933, 2012. [4] El-Shobokshy, G. M. A primary analysis of inhalable particulate lead in the ambient atmosphere of the city of Riyadh. Saudi Arabia. Atmospheric Environment 18, 2125 2130, 1984. [5] El-Shobokshy, G. M. Atmospheric lead pollution in areas of children schools in the city of Riyadh. 78 th Annual APCA Meeting, Detroit, Michigan, 16 21 June 1985. [6] El-Shobokshy, M. S., Al-Tamrah, S. A. and Hussei, F. M. Inhalable particulates and meteorological characteristics of the city of Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Atmospheric Environment, 24B (No 2): 261 265, 1990. [7] Burkart, J. G. Steiner, G. Reischl H. Mashanmer and R. Hitzenberger. Characterizing the performance of two optical particle counters (Grimm OPC1. 108 and OPC1. 109) under urban aerosol conditions. J. Aerosol Sci. 41 (10) 953 962, 2010. [8] Ye, B., J. Yang, H. Yao, Chan, C. K. Cadle, S. H. Chan, T. Mulawa, PA. Concentration and chemical composition of PM2.5 in Shanghai for a 1-year period. Atmospheric Environment 37, 499 510, 2003. [9] He, K., Yang, F., Ma, Y., Zhang, Q., Yao, X., Chan, C. K., Cadle, S., Chan, T., Mulawa, P., 2001. The characteristics of PM2.5 in Beijing, China. Atmospheric Environment 35, 4959 4970. [10] Draxler, R. R., Gillette, D. A., Kirkpatrick, J. S., Heller, J. Estimating PM10 air concentrations from dust storms in Iraq, Kuwait and Saudi Arabia. Atmospheric Environment 35, 4315 4330, 2001.

Environmental Health Risk VII 141 [11] Meng, Z., Lu, B.,. Dust events as a risk factor for daily hospitalization for respiratory and cardiovascular diseases in Minqin, China. Atmospheric Environment 41, 7048 7058, 2007. [12] Park, S. U., Park, M. S. and Chun, Y. A parameterization of dust concentration (PM 10 ) of dust events observed at Erdene in Mongolia using the monitored tower data, Science of the Total Environment 2951 2958, 2010. [13] Chung, Y. S., Kim, K. S., Park, K. H., Jugder, D., Tao, G., Observations of dust storms in China, Mongolia and associated dust falls in Korea in spring 2003. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution, Focus, 5. Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 15 35, 2005. [14] Giri, D., Krishna Murthy, V and Adhikary, P. R. The influence of meteorological conditions on PM10 concentrations in Kathmandu valley. Int. J. Environ. Res. 2(1): 1735 6865, 2008. [15] Kuang, L. Y. Spatial and seasonal variation of PM10 mass concentrations in Taiwan. Atmospheric Environment, 36, 3403 3411, 2002.