11 February 2009 Tackling U.S. Energy Challenges and Opportunities Preliminary Recommendations for Enhancing Energy Innovation 8 th CMI Meeting, Princeton University Laura Diaz, Kelly Sims Gallagher, Matthew Bunn, and Charles Jones
Overview 1. Context 2. Short-term ERD&D Budget Recommendations for DOE 3. Improving Management and Coordination 4. Stimulating Private Sector Investment 5. Expanding international Cooperation 6. Increasing and Targeting Incentives for Large-scale Deployment 1
Context of the ERD3 Project Funded by the Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Part of the ETIP Group. Directed by Kelly Sims Gallagher John Holdren and Henry Lee are co-principal investigators Robert Stowe is the Associate Director Managed by: Laura Diaz ERD3 staffed by three post-doctoral fellows: Melissa Chan Charles Skuk Jones Jose Condor Draw on other ETIP Fellows and research assistants Helped by a distinguished Advisory Committee with 20 members from academia, industry, and NGOs. Project will last for three years (completion in December 2010). John F. Kennedy School of Government Harvard U. 2
Context of our Understanding of Innovation The stages of energy-technology innovation Research & Development Demonstration Early Deployment Widespread Diffusion Relatively modest investments to find out what improvements are possible. Larger investments to find out how the most promising possibilities work out at larger scales. Government role in early deployment is critical. Determined in the marketplace, based on characteristics & information arising from previous stages, and on cost & price signals. Private sector engagement increases further down the chain It is crucial to assess the system as a whole 3
Refrigerator/Freezer RD&D and Efficiency Standards A successful story of coordination Kilowatt-hours and cost in 2003 U.S.$ 2,200 Cubic feet 22 2,000 1,800 18 1,600 1,400 1,200 1,000 800 600 400 volume use $999 cost $1,272 1978 CA Standard $894 1980 CA Standard 1987 CA Standard $576 1990 NECA 1993 DOE 2001 DOE $463 14 10 6 200 2 1947 1955 1963 1971 1979 1987 1995 2003 Brown et al. 2005 4
Context of the Role of the U.S Government A simplistic picture Congress Deployment - Tax credits - Loan guarantees - Federal cap-and-trade proposal States A mixture -Building codes - Electricity regulation, e.g. RPS - Siting permission - RD&D Department of Energy (and other Depts.) Mainly RD&D - National Labs - Partnerships - Appliance standards - Administering guarantees International cooperation State, DOE, Commerce, etc. EPA, NHTSA Waste, air and water quality - National CAFE standards - CO 2 emission control - CO 2 injection Lack of a strategy and coordination between agencies reduces efficiency 5
Policy Alignment is Essential to Speed up Technology Deployment New Energy and Climate Whitehouse Coordinator, Energy Secretary, Science Advisor, and others must coordinate a unified approach Million of Year 2007$ 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 Wind ERD3 funding in 2007 in the United States (by energy source) Solar ERD3 support for fossil, renewable and nuclear energy Biomass Hydro Geothermal Other (landfill, etc) and program direction Coal Oil & Gas Nuclear Financial Support for Deployment Tax-Related Deployment Subsidies Direct Deployment Expenditures RD&D Other RD&D DOE Data from Federal Financial Interventions and Subsidies in Energy Markets 2007 (EIA) & Gallagher 2008 6
Context of the Recommendations Essential ingredients, and short-term recommendations for budgets Timing and objective Informing the process at a crucial time Content Key initiatives needed to start upgrading the U.S. energy-technology innovation system Short-term budget recommendations for DOE - We have ongoing detailed work on the design of long-term portfolios of investments in ERD&D which include a bottom-up expert elicitation and modeling Relationship with American Recovery and Reinvestment Act 2009 Stimulus package being discussed addresses many of the recommendations, e.g.: - CCS demos - Funding for storage and geothermal - Deployment (production tax credits, transmission funding) We are recommending minimum feasible levels for FY 2010 http://belfercenter.ksg.harvard.edu/publication/18826/tackling_us_energy_challenges_and_opportunities.html 7
8000 Department of Energy RD&D Budgets 1978-2009R FY 2009 request was 45% of that in 1978 Post Arab- OPEC Oil Embargo 1973-1974 million 2007$ 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 Fission Efficiency Fossil (including CCT demo) Hydrogen (EERE) Clean Coal Technology Program, government/industry joint venture 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 PCAST report released Fusion Renewables Electricty T&D 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 Energy Security and Independence Act Energy Policy Act 2007 2008 Gallagher, 2008 2009 request 8
DOE ERD&D Budget Recommendations for Fiscal Year 2010 Longer-term recommendations to come from more detailed analysis Area Basic Energy Sciences Fossil Energy Electric Transmission & Distribution Energy Efficiency Renewable Energy Hydrogen (part of EERE) Nuclear Fission Nuclear Fusion Total BES + ERD&D FY08 in current million $ 1,177 676 102 520 730 211 472 287 4,173 Suggested for FY10 in current million $ 1,500 1,700 220 770 850 220 350 450 6,060 9
Improving Management and Coordination Need for a coherent strategy, coordination, and new mechanisms Develop, publish, and implement a U.S. energy-innovation strategy Coherent strategy using a wide range of policy tools across the chain Strategy balancing the role of the public and private sectors, and integrating international cooperation Improve energy policy coordination government-wide Recently created post for Whitehouse Coordinator for Energy and Climate Change is an important step Need to delineate its role, and that of other key actors (OSTP, DOE, etc.) Create mechanisms to manage demonstration projects and high-risk, high-potential R&D The government should create mechanisms to adequately manage technology demonstration projects A mechanism to fund high-risk high-potential R&D is needed. ARPA-E might serve this function 10
Encouraging Private Sector Investment Policy certainty, R&D tax credits, and improve partnerships Set economy-wide carbon constraints Make permanent and expand Research and Experimentation tax credits In 1980s, the United States had the most generous R&D tax credit; by 2004 it was the 17 th most generous country Adopt good partnership models Work on this area is ongoing 11
Strengthening International Cooperation Current effort is small and uncoordinated Many drivers for international cooperation Share costs and risks of basic research (e.g. ITER) Increase the utilization of facilities Share the costs of technologies expected to provide public benefits (e.g. CCS, fission R&D) Promote interaction and discussion with partner countries But most importantly, the environmental, macroeconomic, and national-security risks of the energy sector are global Government should develop a cooperation strategy with priorities Administration should take early cooperation steps with China Make an early Presidential trip to China with energy and climate change high on the agenda, followed by high-level meetings Set up a major cooperative effort in CCS; Establish a U.S.-China Center for Clean Power Innovation Set up new cooperation mechanisms in advanced vehicles, batteries, renewables, and efficiency 12
Targeting and Better Coordinating Deployment Incentives Options for sectoral approaches Economy-wide carbon constraints Electricity sector Obama advocated a national RPS of 10% of renewable electricity by 2012, and 25% by 2025 Investment tax credits have been extended to 2016, production tax credits likely to be extended for 3 years Assess the effectiveness of loan guarantees Evaluate how to best incentivize needed investments in transmission and distribution Transportation sector Consider - Replacing CAFE standards with CO 2 emission standards - Creating a feebate system to promote the purchase of efficient vehicles - Setting a floor on oil prices - Setting a federal mandate for a fraction of vehicles sold to be flex-fuel, or plug-in hybrids - Promoting mass transport: e.g. expanding bus and subway, reducing public transportation fares, building a high-speed intercity rail Buildings sector Consider - Encouraging states to place stringent building codes and DSM programs - Retrofitting public and low-income buildings 13
Thank you for your attention. www.energytechnologypolicy.org 14