Packaged Refrigerant Based Energy Storage (RBES) Air Conditioning System Ram Narayanamurthy Ice Energy, Inc. this technology provides some of the largest opportunities we have right now to address the peak demand situation. (The) benefits extend beyond being able to downsize the distributed solar systems on residential but most exciting is it is retrofittable, meaning we can address both retrofit and new construction. - Joe Desmond, Chairman, California Energy Commission
Peak Demand Challenges the Reliability of Electricity Supply Demand (GW) 50 A/C is > 45 50% of peak demand 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 Typical Summer Day Load Profile Residential A/C Commercial A/C Commercial Lighting Base load commercial, residential, industrial Off-peak Mid Peak On-Peak Mid-Peak 6 a.m. 12 noon 6 p.m. Utilities and states recognize that peak demand is the problem Air conditioning is the root cause Air-Cooled systems suffer highest inefficiency at peak times Ice Storage Air Conditioning answers the challenge Peak [demand] poses one of the most significant challenges to ensuring reliable electricity supplies.
Cycle Schematic of the RBES EVAPORATOR COIL (INDOOR) CONDENSER Refrigerant Pump Metering Valve Ice Bank Heat Exchanger COMPRESSOR ICE TANK Complements conventional refrigerant based air conditioning systems Controlled by existing thermostat: Transparent to user No change in behavior required
Connection Diagram Ice Tank with Refrigerant Management System Standard Cooling 45 F Ice Melt 46 F Standard Cooling 115 F Ice Make 25 F Ice Melt 48 F, 96 PSI Ice Make 90 F
T-S Diagram, Conventional Cycle 250 R22 T [ F] 200 150 100 50-0 -50-100 T=115 T=45 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8-150 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 s [Btu/lbm-R]
T-S Diagram, Ice Making 250 R22 T [ F] 200 150 100 50-0 -50-100 T=90 T=25 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8-150 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 s [Btu/lbm-R]
Thermodynamic COP Comparison COP Comparison 4.5 4 Coefficient of Performance 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 Conventional RBES Ice Make
A Better Air Conditioner with Improved Reliability Duct Air Flow 5 to 7.5 Ton Evaporator Coil RBES unit Draws just 300W on-peak 50 Ton-hours of storage 7.5 Tons for 6 hours continuous Improves overall A/C performance 45 ton-hours RBES Condensing Unit 5-Ton As Outdoor Temperatures Rise o RBES cooling capacity remains constant at 7.5-Tons o Evaporator coils cannot freeze-up o Superior latent heat removal
Part Load Configuration Duct Air Flow 7.5 Ton Evaporator Coils Adds thermal capacity to existing systems RBES 7.5 Ton (50 Ton Hr.) Additional condenser unit, RBES, and 2nd evaporator coil is added to existing air handler system Condenser Unit 7.5 Ton Condenser Unit 5 Ton Combination of RBES and Condensing Unit Provides a Total of 15 Tons of Cooling Capacity
Air-Conditioning System Sizing Single Family Home Air Conditioner Performance (~3000 sq.ft in Denver) - Design Day of 93 F, Indoor 75 F, 50% RH (40% overdesign for design day) House Cooling Load (Tons) 5T CU capacity (Tons) CU Power (KW) 7 6 ASHRAE 2% Design Day 5 4 3 2 Normal a/c systems are 40% + overdesigned for 1 peak day. Hence, a 7.5 Ton RBES can replace up to a 10 Ton a/c in many situations 0 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 Outside Temp (F)
Serves Commercial, Government, and Residential Markets Commercial Offices (1, 2, 3 stories) Retail merchandise and services (small and big box) Food Service chains Fast Food Government Offices and facilities (1, 2, 3 stories) Schools and Education Military facilities Big Box Retail Residential Semi custom homes (>2500 sq. ft.) Mid range production homes (1600-2500 sq. ft.) Energy Star and Net-Zero, Solar PV
Energy Analysis At all three locations, compressor and condenser fan power totals in the range of 4 9 KW were displaced with power consumption of miscellaneous RBES System components of less than 350 W Refrigeration and Thermal Test Center (RTTC)
Dramatic peak shift translates to $ savings
July Peak Results hot, dry climate Data from an air-conditioning contractor on a hot 2 day stretch in July (100 F max) RBES still displaces first stage completely 8+ KW displaced
Energy Efficiency Anaheim California installation is energy neutral On Sep. 19, RBES ran for 4 hrs and displaced 22KWh Ice Make Power Consumption 20.49 kwh Ice Melt and parasitic power 1.37 kwh Net Energy Efficiency 0.6% Colorado installation showed 35% energy efficiency (12.5T, 11EER RTU) on a shoulder day in September (17 th ) 53.7 kwh of RTU power displaced by 36.83 kwh of RBES power (RTU is a 2 stage unit) Ice Make used 34.83 kwh Ice Cooling used 1.99 kwh RTU power displaced 53.7 kwh Similar savings present in dry climates
Energy Savings over optimal DX systems in different climates The comparison is between verified 3 rd party (ETL) data for a RBES system compared to manufacturer data for a packaged DX system
Optimal DX System Assumptions Includes: Standard ASHRAE and CEC performance equations Characterizes a DX system at new condition, under full load Does NOT include (approx impact): DX partial load performance, cycle losses (18%) Rooftop temperature effect (10%) Psychometric factors (5%) Partial melt savings (3%) Traditional DX oversizing (20%) Equipment degradation (5-25%)
All degradation factors considered
RBES Breakeven Energy Usage at 15º F Delta Ambient 30.0% EER +4.1 Energy Efficiency Gain From Day vs. Night Temperature Differential % Energy Efficiency Gain 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% -5.0% -10.0% +3.5 +2.8 +2.0 +1.2 +.05 5 -.05 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 Day vs. Night Temperature Differential EER (change) at 95ºF (35 C) shows energy savings for areas with an average day-night delta greater than 15ºF (Max Min Temp Diff) Typical gain is (15%) over the performance of a COP 3.5 (10.3 EER) rooftop unit (RTU) at an ambient temperature of 95ºF and rooftop temperature of 105ºF Results validated by field performance data
Energy savings achievable in majority of climate zones EER @95-0.5 +0.5 +1.2 +2.0 +2.8 +3.5 +4.1 Temp Range
Building Energy & Sustainable Design Benefits LEED Sustainable Building Certification (1-5 Points) Credits in E & A Category Innovative Application Points Exceptional reduction in source energy of 20% - 43% (Source: California Energy Commission) BuildingGreen Top 10 Green Building Product of the Year
Energy Storage Complements PV Renewable Energy The problem: Cooling demand lags solar production
Daily Cycle of Solar PV on a Standard Building Load 25 Standard Commercial Building Load Profile 20 PV Output kw Demand 15 10 5 Net Demand 0-5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 Time of Day
Energy Analysis Software Modeling
Air Quality Benefits Study conducted for a Western US Air Quality Management District (SMAQD) Calculated the benefit of a RBES system for Emissions Reduction Based on replacing peaking power plant (mainly natural gas) emissions with base load (hydro, nuclear) 40% reduction in CO 2 reductions ~ 56% lower NOx emission rate during off-peak 2-3 RBES modules equivalent to taking 1 vehicle off the road
Growing Industry Recognition BuildingGreen: Top-10 Green Building Product of 2005 BuildingGreen, Inc., publisher of GreenSpec Product Directory and Environmental Building News, selected Ice Energy s RBES 50 as a 2005 Top-10 Green Building product. This fourth annual award, announced at the U.S. Green Building Council s Greenbuild Conference in Atlanta, recognizes the most exciting products added to the GreenSpec Directory during the past year. ASHRAE / ARI Product of the Year for Energy Management Award, 2004 The RBES was recognized as the Product of the Year for Energy Management by ASHRAE and ARI at the 2004 AHR Expo in Anaheim, California. The eight winning companies were featured in the January 2004 edition of ASHRAE Journal. World s Best Technology, Gold Award, 2004 The RBES 50 product was selected for the Gold Award by the Federal Laboratories Consortium for Technology Transfer and the National Association of Seed and Venture Funds World s Best Technology Symposium in 2004. Over 60 participating technologies, considered to be the best of the best, were submitted by the nation s most advanced research facilities and top universities.
Thank You For additional details, please contact: Ram Narayanamurthy ram@ice-energy.com 1-970-545-3630