CHILDREN S HOSPITAL MASTER PLAN AND MIMP October 30, 2007 Citizens Advisory Committee Proposed Alternatives
EIS Alternative No Build with Emergency Department Expansion* 1 45 th Ave 45 th St 44 th Ave 50 th St Sand Point Way *Emergency Department Expansion is part of current approved Master Plan
Characteristics 50 th St EIS Alternative 250 beds in 200 rooms No Build with Emergency Department Expansion Wedding Cake around MIO 90 Does not meet quantitative or qualitative program needs 44 th Ave 45 th Ave 45 th St 1 Sand Point Way
Concept Plan No Build: Existing Major Institution Overlay with Heights Emergency Department Expansion, part of current approved Master Plan, is not shown 1
EIS Alternative Proposed Concept Plan 2 45 th Ave 45 th St 44 th Ave 50 th St Sand Point Way
Characteristics 600 beds 50 th St EIS Alternative Proposed Concept Plan All beds south of Penny Drive Hospital Building MIO 240 ; MIO 50 north of Penny Drive East side 150 above grade 44 th Ave 100% program goal Meets quantitative and qualitative program goals Sand Point Way 24 bed nursing units 45 th Ave 45 th St 2
Concept Plan Proposed Major Institution Overlay with Heights 2
EIS Alternative with Hartmann MIO Height of 105 East to 160 West 3 45 th Ave 45 th St 44 th Ave 50 th St Sand Point Way
50 th St EIS Alternative with Hartmann MIO Height of 105 East to 160 West 600 beds with all beds south of Penny Drive Hospital building MIO 105 East to 160 West; MIO 50 North of Penny Drive 100% program goal Meets quantitative and qualitative program goals 44 th Ave Functions similar to Concept Plan 24 and 36 bed nursing units Sand Point Way Hartmann height reduced 45 th Ave 45 th St 3
EIS Alternative with Hartmann MIO Height of 105 East to 160 West 3
EIS Alternative with Hartmann Expanded Campus Option (north end Laurelon Terrace) 4 45 th Ave 45 th St 44 th Ave 50 th St 40 th Ave Sand Point Way
50 th St EIS Alternative with Hartmann Expanded Campus Option (north end Laurelon Terrace) 600 beds with all beds south of Penny Drive Hospital building MIO 105 East to 160 West; MIO 50 North of Penny Drive 100% program goal Meets quantitative and qualitative program goals Functions similar to Concept Plan 24 and 36 bed nursing units 44 th Ave Potential Laurelon Terrace development could modify option 4 by: Reduce MIO at existing southwest corner from 160 to 105 Create longer Sand Point horizontal Way distances Eliminate 45 th Street access in favor of 40 th Avenue 45 th Ave 45 th St 40 th Ave 4
EIS Alternative with Hartmann 4 * *Potential reduction to MIO 105 at southwest corner existing campus if development on Laurelon Terrace occurs
EIS Alternative Option 3 Modified 5 45 th Ave 45 th St 44 th Ave 50 th St Sand Point Way
50 th St EIS Alternative with Hartmann Option 3 Modified 600 beds with 132 beds north of Penny Drive Hospital building MIO 105 East to 160 West south of Penny Drive, MIO 90 north of Penny Drive 100% program goal Compromised functions 44 th Ave Long horizontal distances North nursing unit will not connect on all floors. Sand Point Way 24, 36 & 48 bed nursing units 45 th Ave 45 th St 5
EIS Alternative Option 3 Modified 5
EIS Alternative with Hartmann Design Strategies Nursing unit size increased from 24 to 36 beds, reducing number of floors Combined mechanical interstitial floors Consolidated portion of central plant into hospital Moved remaining central plant from north edge to Penny Drive Hartmann height reduced
EIS Alternative with Hartmann MIO Measurements per Seattle Municipal Code Designation MIO-37 MIO-50 MIO-65 MIO-70 MIO-90 MIO-105 MIO-160 MIO-200 MIO-240 Height Limit 37 feet 50 feet 65 feet 70 feet 90 feet 105 feet 160 feet 200 feet 240 feet Looking North Looking North Figure 1: Height Definition per Seattle Code Figure 2: Apparent Height due to slopes
EIS Alternative with Hartmann Comparative Elevations (looking North)
EIS Alternative with Hartmann Comparative cross sections through garages (looking North) Existing and Alternative 2
EIS Alternative with Hartmann Comparative cross sections through garages (looking North) Existing and Alternatives 2 through 5
CHILDREN S HOSPITAL MASTER PLAN AND MIMP October 30, 2007 Citizens Advisory Committee Proposed Alternatives