India Plenary session 4: Uptake of Clean Technologies: Disruption and Coexistence of New and Existing Technologies the Way Ahead Background Paper New Delhi
Disclaimer The observations presented herein are meant as background for the dialogue at the 16 th International Energy Forum. They have been prepared in collaboration with The Boston Consulting Group and should not be interpreted as the opinion of the International Energy Forum or The Boston Consulting Group on any given subject. 1
Introduction Market Context Energy related technology is evolving at a fast pace impacting operations and business models. To ensure a reliable and sustainable transition, clear and predictable policies are needed There is certain uncertainty related to which new technologies should be promoted, if any, and how to ensure limited impact on existing assets and technologies Policy makers face challenges around how to achieve a well-balanced regulatory framework to foster innovation balancing sustainable, cheap and reliable/secure energy Session Objectives Discuss the role of energy policy and the regulators in the technological progress in the sector Share experiences on potential initiatives that can be implemented to foster technological progress without endangering market stability and/or energy security Seek common goals that could be pushed in a coordinated manner at international level to foster introduction of new technologies in the energy sector Key Question: How can energy policy makers foster new technologies as a way to achieve long term energy strategy: cheap, sustainable, reliable and secure energy? 2
Fast technological progress allowing to produce and consume clean energy cheaper than ever Price reduction in different technologies Price in 08 = 100 100 Smart Meters 50 Smart Appliances EV batteries Utility-sacle PV Data storage 0 08 10 12 14 Sensors 16 Source: IEA. Based on BNEF (17), Utilities, Smart Thermostats and the Connected Home Opportunity; Holdowsky et al. (), Inside the Internet of Things; IEA (17), Renewables; Tracking Clean Energy Progress; World Energy Investment; Navigant Research (17), Market data: Demand Response. Global Capacity, Sites, Spending and Revenue Forecasts 3
Fostering a number of disruptions in the energy industry Internet of things and sensors Robotization Renewables and DER Smart grids Vehicle electrification Batteries Peer to peer trading Shale gas Smart energy efficiency Electrification of thermal load 4
At the same time, policy makers trying to reform the market through a set of initiatives No CO2 Illustrative example from Europe Innovation Energy independence Security of supply Can we have it all? Low prices No nuclear Competition New business models 5
A fundamental shift in power sector stack architecture is underway in the Power sector Residential, C&I Customers Customers Retailers Power plants-various Distribution Transmission Utilities Distribution Utilities Distribution Utilities Distribution Transmission Utilities Distribution Retailers and Aggregators Retail Customers consuming storing generating Industrials cogene, highest reliability, customized solutions Micro-grids Generation Centralized Generation Sources various sources Smart Grid meters, devices, systems, sensors: Tech solutions, services and systems to enable platform (e.g., MDMS, ADMS, DERMS) Transmission Source: BCG Research 6
Leading to shifts in investment and value pools 16 ($B) Investments in smart electricity infrastructure and software vs investment in global gas generation or the Indian power sector 60 +27% +14% 0 14 16 Global gas-fired India power sector power generation (16 investment) Other elecricity systems software EV chargers (16 investment) Industrial energy mgmnt. Smart gris infrastructure Building energy controls Smart meters Note: Calculations for investment in digital infrastructure and software based on Markets and Markets (16), Internet of Things in Utility Market; BNEF (16), Digital Energy Market Outlook Source: IEA 7
Renewables expected to gradually replace conventional technologies in the future power generation mix Worldwide installed power generation capacity 16- Net capacity additions 16- GW 11,960 CAGR 16- GW 1,769 6,677 8,647 9,725 6.5% 1.6% 0.9% 2.2% -2.6% 0.8% 1,0 1,199 413 589 271 103 16 25-210 Renewables Nuclear Oil Hydro Gas Coal 1. Bioenergy, Geothermal, CSP, Marine Source: IEA (17) World Energy Outlook (IEA New Policies Scenario), BCG analysis Gas Wind Solar PV Coal Hydro Other renewables 1 Nuclear Oil 8
Even in the most 'green' scenario traditional technologies will still play an important role in the mix by BCG Green Revolution Scenario Technology and regulation drive... Technology drives down costs of low-carbona technologies Regulatory push based on environmental concerns: clear push to limit CO2 Government play a strong role BCG Energy Scenario Model Total Primary Energy for Power Generation - mtoe (%) 5,961 6,143 5,319 5,455 5,535 5,178...Electrification, efficiency and renewables Solar and wind fully competitive by 25: Build-out rate ~0 GW/y Action on coal for power: active coal closure in OECD; China follows with 10y delay Investments in smart grids Solid push for energy efficiency Central coordination of efficiency standards and investment in efficient lighting, cooking and appliances Coal Oil 25 35 Gas Bioenergy Nuclear Other Renewables Baseline Source: BCG analysis (BCG Energy Scenario Model Dec 16); IEA (World Energy Outlook, New Policies Scenario) 9
Specially in developing economies: i.e., China and India BCG Green Revolution Scenario: total Primary Energy for power generation - K mtoe 2.0 non-oecd E.Europe/ Eurasia non-oecd Middle East non-oecd Africa non-oecd LATAM India Rest of non-oecd Asia China OECD Oceania OECD Europe OECD Americas 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 25 35 25 35 25 35 25 35 25 35 25 35 25 35 25 35 25 35 25 35 Coal Gas Bioenergy Baseline Oil Nuclear Other Renewables 10
Coal and Gas could still be predominant in a scenario of abundant and cheap unconventional gas BCG Blue Gas Economy Scenario Abundant unconventional gas drives The US leads the way Shale gas boom in China and Argentina A drop in gas prices Gas prices below 5$/mmbtu in exporting countries Gas prices below 10$/mmbtu in importing countries BCG Energy Scenario Model Total Primary Energy for power generation mtoe (%) 7,367 6,899 6,410 5,946 5,595 5,253 And a switch to gas Power, industry and buildings: switch in China and Argentina Decreased efficiency improvements in buildings: Slower deployment of building standards compared to Baseline Coal Oil Gas Nuclear 25 35 Bioenergy Other Renewables Baseline Actuals 11
Replacement of fuel sources is not new and takes time Major Sources in the US Energy Mix (1825-08) Consumption (in %) 100 Illustrative Wood & Biomass 80 Coal 60 Petroleum & NGLs Gas Hydroelectric Nuclear 0 Other Renewables 1825 1875 1900 1925 1950 1975 1990 00 08 12
The different policy choices do have an impact on prices Electricity prices in different countries Price ( cents/kwh) -45% 10.5.2 23.0 10.6.4 11.4 17.7 12.7 16.9 9.9 0 Germany Spain EU-28 UK France Transition towards RES resulting on electricity prices +% more expensive than less RES reliant countries Household Industrial Cheapest of major Western EU economies Heavily reliant on nuclear 13
A 'wait and see' strategy can allow to benefit from a cheaper and more mature technology: e.g., Mexico $/MWh 1 Solar PV: Auction prices Wind onshore: Auction price $/MWh 80 100 80 60 60 Mexico Mexico Mexico Mexico Mexico 0 12 14 16 18 0 12 14 16 18 Mexico started later than other countries in Renewable development and is now achieving some of the cheapest prices around the world 14
A new landscape of players is emerging DG players Digital innovators Equipment OEMs Others Contracting players Utilities "Utilities are crazy if they don't start offering customers innovative financing packages for solar and distributed generation because others will." Honda Executive
New environment impacting market capitalization of energy companies, limiting capacity to invest in large scale assets 02 07 12 17 ICT Energy Other Digital companies are now leaders by market capitalization Note: circle sizes relative to market capitalization in 2Q 17. Source: IEA 16
However, the energy industry still requires a significant amount of long term investment in the coming years Average yearly investments in power sector, 16 ($B) Europe 117 127 Eurasia North America 108 67 41 99 58 42-14% +2% 73 44 17-25 85 42 26- +% -3% 19 11 17-25 19 11 26- +0% +0% % Growth 17-25 Generation investments T&D investments 26- Central & South America 36 19 17 17-25 43 23 26- +% +18% Africa 42 22 17-25 77 37 39 26- +66% +97% Middle East 23 17-25 37 23 17-26- +71% 25 9 26- +54% Asia Pacific 392 232 160 422 237 185 +2% +16% Source: IEA World Energy Outlook 17, BCG analysis 17
Key Questions 1 2 Should policy regulate/constrain technological progress? Can technology in Energy be a source of competitive advantage for countries? 3 4 Is it possible to develop a leveled and sustainable regulatory framework to achieve the various goals and functionalities required (clean, cheap, access for all)? Is there a mature technology that should be promoted? 5 How to foster innovation and competition without compromising long term investment required? 6 What to do with previous investments and potential stranded assets? 18
India Plenary session 4: Uptake of Clean Technologies: Disruption and Coexistence of New and Existing Technologies the Way Ahead Background Paper New Delhi 19