Evaluation and Repair of Earthquake Damage in Woodframe Buildings John Osteraas, PhD, PE Exponent Failure Analysis Associates
Agenda Introduction & Background Damage Assessment References The CUREE Woodframe Damage Assessment Project Research to-date Guidelines ATC-43 Comparison
Purpose of Post-EQ Damage Assessment Confirm safety assessment Document damage Determine significance of damage Provide basis for decision on what to do about damage
Need for Guidelines Engineering issues following Northridge What is damage? What constitutes an adequate inspection? What to look for Where to look When to look for concealed damage What constitutes appropriate repair Do nothing - accept damage Restore to pre-event event condition Upgrade to a better condition Demolish as uneconomical to repair Problem for steel, concrete, & woodframe buildings
Damage Assessment References Pre-Northridge ATC-20 1989 Post-Northridge SAC Steel Moment Frame Project 1995-2001 CUREE - CalTech Woodframe Project 1998-2003 ATC-43 / FEMA 306, 307, 308 1998 CUREE Earthquake Damage Assessment Project 1998-2007?
CUREE EDA Project Earthquake Damage Assessment and Repair for Woodframe Residential Construction (EDA) Objective to develop guidelines to be used by engineers, contractors, owners, insurance industry, building officials, and others for post- earthquake damage assessment and repair Applies to residential woodframe construction Modeled on ATC-20 and ATC-43 In progress
CUREE EDA Project Research to-date: Damage assessment and repair of walls where shear resistance is provided only by stucco and drywall refining understanding of damage mechanisms establishing correlations between visible damage and structural response assessing the efficacy of repair techniques for common types of earthquake damage Potential for earthquake-induced cracking of concrete slabs-on on-grade and foundations at sites that are geotechnically stable Efficacy of epoxy repair of cracks in unreinforced concrete slabs-on on-grade and foundations Refined understanding of seismic compression of fills
Stucco & Drywall Shearwalls Researchers: Chia-Ming Uang,, Andre Filiatrault, & Andrew Arnold, UCSD Publications EDA-03 - Cyclic Behavior and Repair of Stucco and Gypsum Sheathed Woodframe Walls Phase I EDA-07 - Cyclic Behavior and Repair of Stucco and Gypsum Sheathed Woodframe Walls Phase II
Section 6 Wall Elements Photo Credits: CUREE
Diagram Credit: CUREE Section 6 Wall Elements
oto Credit: CUREE
Stucco & Drywall Shearwalls 15 10 Load (kips) 5 0-5 -10-15 -3-2 -1 0 1 2 3 Drift (in) (a) Wall 3d
Surface Strains Workshop Panel: Bruce Bolt Paul Somerville Norman Abrahamson Aspasia Zerva Publication: EDA-04 Workshop Proceedings: Effect of Earthquake-Induced Transient Ground Surface Deformations on At-Grade Improvements,, A. Gupta, ed.
Surface Strains The magnitude of earthquake-induced transient ground surface strains at an arbitrary site can be reasonably estimated given the current state-of of-science The effect of surface strains on at-grade improvements would be inconsequential, except perhaps in the near fault region where large transient peak ground displacements may occur The reported observations of visible waves on the ground surface during strong ground shaking cannot be explained from a seismological perspective. Under special circumstances where the ground is extremely soft, it may be possible to observe the surface waves, however these waves would likely not be damaging to at- grade improvements, as the wavelength of these waves would be much larger than the dimensions of the at- grade improvements.
Epoxy Repair Contractor: Jay Crandall, National Association of Home Builders Research Center Report: EDA-01 Testing and Assessment of Epoxy Injection Crack Repair for Residential Concrete Stem Walls and Slabs-on on-grade
Photo Credits: CUREE
Seismic Compression Researcher: Jon Stewart, UCLA Publication: EDA-05 Seismic Compression of As-Compacted Fill Soils with Variable Levels of Fines Content and Fines Plasticity
CUREE EDA General Guidelines EDA-02 - General Guidelines for the Assessment and Repair of Earthquake Damage in Residential Woodframe Buildings Section 1 Introduction Section 2 Working with Engineers Section 3 Characterization of Ground Motion Damage Potential and Structural Vulnerabilities (in progress) Section 4 Geotechnical Aspects (in progress) Section 5 Foundations and Slabs-on-Grade Section 6 Wall Elements Section 7 Floors, Ceilings, and Roofs (in progress) Section 8 Fireplaces and Chimneys (in progress) Section 9 Mechanical Systems (in progress) Section 10 Glossary (in progress)
CUREE EDA General Guidelines Wall Elements Typical Chapter Outline Quick Guide What to look for Where to look When to call an engineer Repair guidelines Summary Limitations Description of typical wall construction Non-earthquake sources of wall damage Stucco Drywall Lath & Plaster Doors & windows Wood trim Earthquake-induced wall damage Stucco Drywall Lath & Plaster Doors & windows Assessment guidelines and methodology Exterior Interior Engineering assessment Establishing the cause and age of cracks Repair methodologies Crack repair Construction joints Engineered repairs Upgrades and Betterment
CUREE EDA Engineering Guidelines EDA-06 - Engineering Guidelines for the Assessment and Repair of Earthquake Damage in Residential Woodframe Buildings Section 1 Introduction Section 2 Client Interactions & Reporting Section 3 Characterization of Ground Motion Damage Potential and Structural Vulnerabilities Section 4 Geotechnical Aspects (completed) Section 5 Foundations and Slabs-on-Grade Section 6 Wall Elements Section 7 Floors, Ceilings, and Roofs Section 8 Fireplaces and Chimneys Section 9 Mechanical Systems Section 10 - Glossary
CUREE EDA Engineering Guidelines Geotechnical Aspects - Typical chapter outline Introduction Reconnaissance of Permanent Ground Deformation Examples of seismically-induced permanent ground deformation Site investigation Surface Fault Rupture Description Methods of investigation Damage, repair, and mitigation Soil Liquefaction Seismically-induced landslides Seismic Compression EQ-induced deformation of retaining Walls Overview of non-seismic ground deformation processes Consolidation settlement Immediate settlement Hydro-compression settlement Expansive soil movement Slope creep References
ATC-43/CUREE EDA Commonalities Characterization of ground motions & damage potential Investigation methodologies Guidelines for distinction between pre-existing existing conditions and earthquake damage Damage documentation guidelines Damage classification Component performance information Correlation between visible damage and structural behavior Repair alternatives
ATC-43/CUREE EDA Differences Construction type ATC-43 concrete & masonry walls CUREE EDA woodframe Components ATC-43 lateral load resisting wall elements CUREE EDA all building components, structural & non-structural
More Information Publications: ATC: www.atcouncil atcouncil.org CUREE: www.curee.org Presenter: John Osteraas: osteraas@exponent.com Business card for CUREE EDA Project mailing list
Questions?