British Institute of Energy Economics 25 September 2007 Energy White Paper 2007 Vicky Pryce Director General, Economics, BERR Joint Head of the Government Economic Service
Our key long term challenges Tackling climate change Ensuring secure, clean and affordable energy 2
Stern Review conclusions: taking action now is good economics As a result of climate change the loss to world GDP could be at least 5% and up to 20% in the worst case scenarios Expected cost of cutting emissions consistent with 550ppm CO2e stabilisation trajectory averages 1% of GDP per year Macroeconomic models: 1% of GDP in 2050, range +/- 3% Resource cost: 1% of GDP in 2050, range 1% to +3.5% 3
The climate change challenge I Energy-Related CO2 Emissions by Region in the Reference Scenario (IEA, WEO 2006) 4
The climate change challenge II Our goal is to put the UK on a path to cutting carbon dioxide emissions by at least 60% by about 2050 160 140 120 100 2050 target Heat Transport Energy 80 60 40 20 0 2005 2050 5
The security of supply challenge I Domestic energy Imported gas 300 Imported oil Imported coal Million tonnes of oil equivalent 250 200 150 100 50 0 Import dependency 2005 2020 6
The security of supply challenge II Substantial investment needed in: Electricity power stations and networks Gas import and storage infrastructure M egaw att 90,000 80,000 70,000 60,000 50,000 40,000 30,000 20,000 10,000 0 Generation capacity 2005 2016 2025 Expected increase in demand Closures Existing Capacity 7
Analytical process for appraisal of White Paper policy options Clear definition of counterfactuals Consideration of alternative policy options Cost-benefit analysis of all options, including carbon cost-effectiveness Inter-Departmental peer review of analysis, including panel of Government Chief Economists External peer review of key analysis, including expert academics and consultants 8
Analytical evidence base for the White Paper: examples Evaluation of supplier obligation policy options: report for DTI and Defra Review of distributed generation: report Impact of banding the renewables obligation: costs of electricity production Reform of the renewables obligation. What is the likely impact of changes? Nuclear power generation cost-benefit analysis Review of UK oil refining capacity for Department of Trade and Industry Dynamics of GB electricity generation investment: prices, security of supply, CO2 emissions and policy options An assessment of the potential measures to improve gas security of supply Updated energy and carbon emissions projections: the energy white paper The UK MARKAL energy model in the 2007 energy white paper Report on modelling the macroeconomic impacts of achieving the UK's carbon emission reduction goal 9
The framework Principles Climate change and energy security are international issues, requiring international action as well as in the UK Independently regulated competitive markets are the most cost-effective and efficient way to deliver our goals But we need to correct market failures to align the objectives of market participants with our energy policy goals, e.g. through a carbon price 10
The framework Action An international framework to tackle climate change Legally binding carbon targets for whole UK economy More progress in achieving competitive and transparent international markets More energy saving More support for low carbon technologies Right conditions for investment 11
International energy and climate strategy Our international energy and climate change strategy is designed to ensure security of energy supply and accelerate the transition to a low-carbon economy. Our international strategy is built around four main elements Promote open, competitive markets Take action to put a value on carbon emissions Drive investment to accelerate the deployment of low carbon technologies Promote policies to improve energy efficiency 12
Putting a value on CO 2 emissions strengthening the EU ETS We want: Early decisions on emissions caps Caps consistent with 2020 commitments Increased auctioning in future phases Inclusion of CCS within EU ETS scope Inclusion of aviation within EU ETS Consider expansion to surface transport Consider scope for harmonisation Effective international linking in the future 13
At home, we need to: Save energy Develop cleaner energy supplies Secure reliable energy supplies at prices set in competitive markets 14
UK marginal CO 2 abatement cost curve in 2020 15
Saving energy Improving information and advice Better billing Smart meters and real time displays CO 2 calculator Regulation Zero carbon new homes More energy efficient appliances Doubling of suppliers obligation to reduce carbon emissions Energy Performance Certificates Carbon Reduction Commitment Transport EU mandatory targets to improve car fuel efficiency Inclusion of aviation in the EU ETS 16
Cleaner energy: heat and distributed energy Distributed Generation package Biomass strategy Further work on heat options 17
Levelised cost of electricity generation* * Based on November 2006 fuel price projections and a CO 2 price of 25/tCO 2 18
Cleaner energy: electricity generation Policy Strengthened EU ETS to provide price signals Strengthening of the RO and banding Demonstration of CCS operational by 2011-2014 Consultation on the option to build new nuclear power stations Energy technology support and skills 19
Rationale for supporting clean technologies Illustrative experience curve for a new technology Marginal cost of producing a unit of energy This area represents the support necessary to bring forward the development of the new technology. Established technology with carbon price. Established technology. New clean technology. 20
Cleaner energy: electricity in 2050 2050: Generation mix consistent with achieving a 60% reduction in total UK carbon emissions TWh 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 Imports Oil Renewables CCS Gas Coal 0 Today 2050: High fuel prices 2050: Low fuel prices Nuclear Note: For illustrative purposes, in the modelling scenarios presented, companies are allowed nuclear power as an investment option 21
Cleaner energy - transport Transport Low Carbon Transport Innovation Strategy Renewable Transport Fuel Obligation 5% by 2010-11 Potential for higher Obligation later if sustainable Technology Energy Technologies Institute for R&D into low carbon energy - minimum budget of around 600m The Environmental Transformation Fund will be established from April 2008 for UK and international demonstration and deployment of new energy technologies and energy efficiency 22
Security of supply: oil and gas Energy saving Open and competitive markets Maximise UKCS production Lower carbon electricity mix Planning reforms to facilitate gas imports and storage Oil stocking and effective emergency arrangements 23
Projected supply/demand balance in UK gas market 800 700 600 mcm/day 500 400 300 200 100 0 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 2012/13 2013/14 2014/15 2015/16 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 Peak demand (seasonal normal) Peak deliverability (only committed projects) Peak demand (1-in-50) Peak deliverability (modelled outcome) 24
Security of supply: electricity Strengthened EU ETS for more regulatory clarity Planning reforms Improved market information Strengthened Renewables Obligation Demonstration of carbon capture and storage Decision on new nuclear this year after consultation 25
Projected supply/demand balance in the power generation sector Derated Peak Capacity Margin - Base Case 20% 18% 16% 14% 12% 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% Well Functioning Imperfect Market 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 26
Impact of our measures on CO 2 emissions Projected carbon emissions and carbon impact of our proposals Million tonnes of carbon (MtC) 180 170 160 150 140 130 120 110 Baseline projections w ithout Energy White Paper measures Low impact of measures High impact of measures 26-32% reduction on 1990 levels Together with the EU ETS, we estimate our measures will save 23-33 million tonnes of carbon in 2020 100 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 27
Implementation Consultations (nuclear, renewables, gas) Legislation UK (climate change bill, energy bill, planning) EU (EU ETS, emissions reduction, renewables) International negotiation: post 2012 carbon regime Implementation of measures 28