SILICA NANOPARTICLES & RUBBER TOUGHENING A SYNERGY IN ADHESIVES & COMPOSITES S. Sprenger, A.J. Kinloch, A.C. Taylor Presented at a meeting of the Thermoset Resin Formulators Association at the Hilton Suites Chicago Magnificient Mile in Chicago, Illinois, September 15 through 16, 2008 1 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
TOPICS - Rubber-toughened thermosets - Surface-modified silica nanoparticles - RLP and nanoparticles: the synergy in epoxies - Adhesives & composites performance - Summary & Outlook Airbus A 380 2 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
RUBBER-TOUGHENING OF THERMOSETS - Well-known technology used in most structural epoxy adhesives, many prepreg and filament winding applications, some injection applications (e.g. VARTM) - Used for epoxies, vinyl esters, unsaturated polyester resins - Improved properties: - increased toughness, reduced brittleness - improved mechanical properties - Some drawbacks: - higher resin viscosity - lower Tg, modulus 3 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
RUBBER-TOUGHENING OF THERMOSETS: MECHANISM Cavitated particle Particle interfacial distance Crack Rubber particles Shear bands Rubber bridging Damage zone Typical rubber domain sizes 0.2-4 microns Kinloch et al., J. Mat. Sci 27, 2763-2769 (1992) 4 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
CLASSIC FUMED SILICA SILICA NANOPARTICLE 1.2 nm agglomerates, branched structures isolated particle (from Odegard thixotropic properties et al. Polymer 46 (2005), 553 5 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
THE nanoresins AG PROCESS Aqueous Sodium Silicate Solution Si O H Si Agglomeration, gelation, flocculation H X O Silica Sol Surface modification Matrix exchange particle concentrate Low viscous, waterclear, no sedimentation 6 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
PARTICLE SIZE AND DISTRIBUTION (TEM, SANS) particle density 0 20 40 60 80 100 particle size [nm] isolated, spherical, uniform particles 7 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
VISCOSITY η AS FUNCTION OF SiO 2 CONTENT (cycloaliphatic bisepoxide EEC; T = 25 C) low viscous, transparent products 8 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
NANO-TOUGHENING OF EPOXIES: MECHANISM I crack tip fracture surface data courtesy of IVW 9 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
NANO-TOUGHENING OF EPOXIES: MECHANISM I high deflection of crack growth with nanoparticles data courtesy of IVW 10 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
NANO-TOUGHENING OF EPOXIES: MECHANISM II glass microspheres in epoxy resins toughen: debonding and plastic void formation on the fracture surface similar mechanism with SiO 2 -nanoparticles! Kinloch et al, J. Mat. Sci. 20, 4169, 1985 11 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
NANO-TOUGHENING OF EPOXIES: FATIGUE dramatically improved fatigue properties by the addition of SiO 2 - nanoparticles DGEBA, anhydride cure 12 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
RUBBER TOUGHENING + SILICA NANOPARTICLES: THE SYNERGY - silica nanoparticles increase modulus, stiffness, compression strength, bending strength, fatigue properties and toughness - silica nanoparticles cannot replace rubber toughenig - combining combining rubber toughening with silica nanoparticles tough and stiff systems can be formulated - a synergy exists and toughness is increased further 13 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
RUBBER-TOUGHENED EPOXY WITH NANOPARTICLES picture courtesy of Army Research Lab rubber domains (from CTBN adduct) & silica nanoparticles 14 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
HEAT CURING EPOXY ADHESIVES 1 part paste adhesive 77.5 parts DGEBA/ Nanopox 37.5 parts CTBN adduct 2 parts fumed silica 4 parts Dicy 2 parts accelerator 15 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
ADHESIVES: LAP SHEAR STRENGTH (1 PART EPOXY) Control with no RLP: 11 MPa untreated automotive aluminium, cured 30 min 180 C 16 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
MODULUS 3 2,5 2 GPa 1,5 1 13 % RLP untoughened 0,5 0 DIN ISO 178 0 5 10 15 20 % nanosilica 1 part epoxy, cured 30 min 180 C 17 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
AMBIENT TEMPERATURE CURING EPOXY ADHESIVES A-part: DGEBA/Nanopox B-part: 66 % Polypox P 502 34 % ATBN Source: Aston Martin 18 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
ADHESIVES: FRACTURE ENERGY (2 PART EPOXY) G1c according to BS 7991 untreated automotive aluminium, cured 24 h RT + 2 h 60 C 19 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
ADHESIVES: ROLLER PEEL, WEDGE IMPACT (2 PART EPOXY) 2024 T3 aluminium; automotive steel, cured 24 h RT + 2 h 60 C 20 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
AMBIENT TEMPERATURE CURING EPOXY ADHESIVES A-part: DGEBA/DGEBF/ Nanopox 3 parts fumed silica (+CTBN-Adduct=23.7%) Source: Vestas B-part: 40 % ATBN 1300x16 30 % Polypox P 502 20 % Jeffamine D 400 10 % Isophoronediamine 21 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
LAP SHEAR STRENGTH AUTOMOTIVE STEEL 20 19 18 17 MPa 16 15 14 15.6 % RLP 23.7 % RLP 13 12 11 10 DIN 55-283 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 % nanosilica 2 part epoxy, supertough, very thixotropic, 24 h RT + 2 h 60 C 22 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
ADHESIVE FACTURE ENERGY G1c 5000 4500 4000 J/m2 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 15.6 % RLP 23.7 % RLP untreated automotive aluminium 500 0 BS 7991 0 5 10 15 % nanosilica 2 part epoxy, supertough, very thixotropic, 24 h RT + 2 h 60 C 23 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
LAP SHEAR STRENGTH GFRC 8 7 6 5 MPa 4 3 15.6 % RLP 23.7 % RLP 2 1 0 DIN 55-283 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 % nanosilica 2 part epoxy, supertough, very thixotropic, 24 h RT + 2 h 60 C 24 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
COMPOSITES: CFRC TOUGHNESS DGEBA, anhydride cure, 1 h 90 C, 2 h 160 C; VARTM 25 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
COMPOSITES: CFRC GIc VERSUS GIIc DGEBA, anhydride cure, 1 h 90 C, 2 h 160 C; VARTM 26 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
COMPOSITES: FRC TOUGHNESS summary of VARTM and RTM made laminates 27 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
COMPOSITES: CFRC FALLING DART TEST Control 30 J Impact 8 % CTBN, 10 % nanoparticles data courtesy of EADS TGMDA, aromatic amine cure, 2 h 180 C, RTM 28 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
SUMMARY - combining "classic" Hypro RLP (former Hycar RLP) toughening with Nanopox nanoparticles adhesives and composites with superior properties can be manufactured (tough and stiff!) - epoxy adhesives using the synergy between rubber toughening and silica nanoparticles are commercially available (automotive, aerospace, electronics,...) - composite parts for automotive, machine construction, sports equipment etc. are significantly improved using the synergy (such products are in the market since years) 29 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15
OUTLOOK: MAJOR CURRENT R&D ACTIVITIES - detailed investigation in the mechanisms of the synergy - vinyl ester resins with nanoparticles and rubber - 2 part epoxy adhesives for wind mill blade bonding - UV cured acrylic adhesives for automotive - glass fiber reinforced composites made with nanosilica and RLP modified vinyl ester resins 30 TRFA, Chicago Il, 2008-09-15