HERITAGE DEVELOPMENT BOARD OF THE CITY OF SAINT JOHN WEDNESDAY JULY 10 TH, 2013 The meeting of the Heritage Development Board was held in the 10 th Floor Boardroom of City Hall, commencing at 5:30 pm. IN ATTENDANCE: Leona Laracey, Chair Gordon Hewitt, 1 st Vice Chair Scott Rinehart Bob Boyce Councillor Donna Reardon Patrick McCaffrey, 2 nd Vice Chair Colin Waldschutz Alex Pesold Jill Flecknell, Recording Secretary Mark Reade, Senior Planner REGRETS: Amy Poffenroth, Acting Commissioner Alice Fudge, Heritage Analyst Jim Bezanson, Secretary/Heritage Development Officer Elizabeth McGahan ITEM 1.0 AGENDA The following item was added for discussion under Other Business: 7.1 Mount Pleasant Demolitions MOVED by Patrick McCaffrey, SECONDED by Donna Reardon to approve the agenda as amended. ITEM 2.0 MINUTES ITEM 2.1 MINUTES OF THE JUNE 26 TH, 2013 MEETING MOVED by Donna Reardon, SECONDED by Colin Waldschutz to approve the June 26 th, 2013 minutes as circulated.
Heritage Development Board Minutes - 2 - July 10 th, 2013 ITEM 3.0 BUSINESS ARISING There was no business arising. ITEM 4.0 INTRODUCTION OF APPLICANTS/GUESTS Holly Singh was present representing Thandi s, 33 Canterbury Street. ITEM 5.0 CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS AND GRANTS ITEM 5.1A APPLICATION FOR A HERITAGE PERMIT 2013-45A EXCHANGE ON GERMAIN C/O LISA OLAND, 117 GERMAIN STREET Leona Laracey advised that the application is for a Certificate of Appropriateness to a projecting sign on the existing wrought iron bracket, for which Ms. Oland has provided a revised drawing. ITEM 5.1B APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2013-45A EXCHANGE ON GERMAIN C/O LISA OLAND, 117 GERMAIN STREET MOVED by Donna Reardon, SECONDED by Patrick McCaffrey to approve the following: Install new 20 high x 40 wide projecting sign, double sided/sandblasted, made from Western Red Cedar using approved heritage colours to match building, 22k Gold Leaf lettering, as per attached sketch. To be installed on existing wrought iron bracket. EXCHANGE on Germain DESIGNER CONSIGNMENT Planning Appeal Board on or before July 25, 2013.
Heritage Development Board Minutes - 3 - July 10 th, 2013 ITEM 5.2A APPLICATION FOR A HERITAGE PERMIT 2013-47 MICHAEL C. WALLACE, 24 QUEEN STREET Leona Laracey advised that the application is for a Certificate of Appropriateness to repair/replace wooden trim, prepare and stain south and north facades using a previously approved heritage color scheme. ITEM 5.2B APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2013-47 MICHAEL C. WALLACE, 24 QUEEN STREET MOVED by Donna Reardon, SECONDED by Gord Hewitt to approve the following: Remove loose and deteriorated paint from wood siding and trim components on south and north facades, using infra-red heat guns or hand scrapers. DO NOT USE OPEN FLAME of propane torch (flame may wick into building with disastrous results); Repair, and/or replace as necessary, any deteriorated wood siding or trim components or deteriorated window or door components, matching originals in size, materials and detailing; Prime and paint wooden shingles and trim of south and north facades, using the an approved heritage colour scheme in keeping with the Practical Conservation Guidelines for Paint & Colour. Planning Appeal Board on or before July 25 th, 2013. The Board requested that the applicant submit their approved colour scheme, to ensure that it is on file. ITEM 5.2C APPLICATION FOR A HERITAGE CONSERVATION GRANT 13-47 MICHAEL C. WALLACE, 24 QUEEN STREET Leona Laracey advised that the application is for a Heritage Conservation Grant to repair/replace wooden trim, prepare and stain south and north facades using a previously approved heritage color scheme. There is a Conservation Plan in place for the building located in the Trinity Royal Heritage Conservation Area.
Heritage Development Board Minutes - 4 - July 10 th, 2013 MOVED by Donna Reardon, SECONDED by Scott Rinehart to approve a Heritage Conservation Grant of 15% up to a maximum of $600.00 based on project estimates, to repair/replace wooden trim, prepare and stain south and north facades using a previously approved heritage color scheme. ITEM 5.3A APPLICATION FOR A HERITAGE PERMIT 2013-48 CAROLYN LAWTON, 266 LANCASTER AVENUE Leona Laracey advised that the application is for a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace two wood storm windows on the East facade and remove, repair, repaint and reinstall thirty existing storm windows from the East and West facades of the building. ITEM 5.3B APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2013-48 CAROLYN LAWTON, 266 LANCASTER AVENUE MOVED by Donna Reardon, SECONDED by Patrick McCaffrey to approve the following: Remove thirty original storm windows from east and west facade of the building, repair, scrape, paint using a previously approved heritage colour scheme and reinstall; Remove two original storm windows and replace to match;. Planning Appeal Board on or before July 24 th, 2013. The Board requested that the applicant submit their approved colour scheme, to ensure that it is on file. ITEM 5.3C APPLICATION FOR A HERITAGE CONSERVATION GRANT 13-48 AND GRANT RENEWAL FOR 12-41A CAROLYN LAWTON, 266 LANCASTER AVENUE Leona Laracey advised that the application is for a Heritage Conservation Grant to remove/repair/repaint/reinstall thirty storm windows on the East and West facade as well as replace/paint two new wood storm windows to match existing on the East facade. The application also includes a Heritage Grant Renewal for previously approved work
Heritage Development Board Minutes - 5 - July 10 th, 2013 outlined in Certificate of Appropriateness 12-41A which includes: replacing deteriorated wood components on the East facade, scraping, cleaning and repainting the front and East facade. There is a Conservation Plan in place for the building located in the Lancaster Avenue Heritage Conservation Area. MOVED by Donna Reardon, SECONDED by Patrick McCaffrey to approve a Heritage Conservation Grant for up to a maximum of $4,470.00 based project estimates provided and on the work outlined in Certificate of Appropriateness [13-48] & Certificate of Appropriateness [12-41A] for 266 Lancaster Avenue. ITEM 5.4A APPLICATION FOR A HERITAGE PERMIT 2013-49 THANDI S C/O HOLLY SINGH, 33 CANTERBURY STREET Leona Laracey advised that the application is for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove the existing paintings from the side of the building, reinstall eight 4 x 8 framed paintings using non-corrosive fasteners secured into the mortar joints. ITEM 5.4B APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2013-49 THANDI S C/O HOLLY SINGH, 33 CANTERBURY STREET MOVED by Bob Boyce, SECONDED by Patrick McCaffrey to approve the following: Remove six paintings from wall; Artist Sarah Griffin to paint eight new framed paintings (approximately 4 x 8 ) of: Stompin Tom Connors Alden Nowlan Miller Brittain Donald Sutherland Walter Pidgeon Louis B Mayer Abraham Gresner Fred Ross Install framed paintings with non-corrosive fasteners securely into the mortar joints.
Heritage Development Board Minutes - 6 - July 10 th, 2013 Planning Appeal Board on or before July 25 th, 2013. Holly Singh advised the Board that Artist Sarah Griffin will be painting the eight panels maintaining the Heritage palette and each painting will have a brief biography underneath. Ms Singh explained that at some point they will light the paintings as well, at which time she will apply for a Certificate of Appropriateness. She invited the Heritage Development Board to the unveiling of the new paintings which is scheduled to take place sometime in September. ITEM 5.5A APPLICATION FOR A HERITAGE PERMIT 2013-50 VIVIAN MACDONALD, 153 CANTERBURY STREET Leona Laracey advised that the application is for a Certificate of Appropriateness to repoint brickwork on the front facade of the Canterbury entrance. ITEM 5.5B APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS 2013-50 VIVIAN MACDONALD, 153 CANTERBURY STREET MOVED by Donna Reardon, SECONDED by Patrick McCaffrey to approve the following: Remove loose and deteriorated mortar using hand tools and rotary grinder with 0.80 blade ONLY on middle of horizontal joints: DO NOT USE ON VERTICAL JOINTS. Repoint existing bricks/lay salvaged bricks using lime-based mortar, consisting of: 1 part White Portland (type 10- grey is not acceptable); 2 parts hydrated lime (high calcium soaked minimum 24 hours); and 8 parts screened sand (mix the lime and sand to create roughage, or rough stuff, then add White Portland just prior to use). *Note: Measures or precautions need to be undertaken to ensure mortar is allowed to cure a minimum of 28 days at no less than 10 degrees Celsius and no greater than 28 degrees Celsius ambient temperature. Wash down masonry wall using an approved mild restoration cleaner [Sure Klean 600];
Heritage Development Board Minutes - 7 - July 10 th, 2013 Planning Appeal Board on or before July 25 th, 2013. ITEM 5.5C APPLICATION FOR A HERITAGE CONSERVATION GRANT 13-50 VIVIAN MACDONALD, 153 CANTERBURY STREET Leona Laracey advised that the application is for a Heritage Conservation Grant for repointing of brickwork on the front facade of the Canterbury entrance. There is a Conservation Plan in place for the building located in the Trinity Royal Heritage Conservation Area. MOVED by Donna Reardon, SECONDED by Scott Rinehart to approve a Heritage Conservation Grant of a funding ratio of 25% up to a maximum of $1625.00 for repointing of brickwork on the front facade of the building on Canterbury Street. ITEM 6.0 REPORTS There were no reports. ITEM 7.0 OTHER BUSINESS 7.1 MOUNT PLEASANT DEMOLITION Chair Leona Laracey advised the Board that she had been contacted by the media concerning the demolition of buildings on Mount Pleasant Avenue. She explained that while the buildings were not in a designated Heritage Conservation Area, that there is significant heritage inventory in that area as it is Saint John s oldest suburb. Ms. Laracey explained that it is the Heritage Development Board s obligation to alert Common Council of properties that should be protected. Bob Boyce questioned if photographic records were kept by the City and noted that it was the Board s mandate to maintain a photographic record for the community. The Board held a discussion concerning the potential for the development of providing the option for citizens to upload their historical photos to the City of Saint John website. The Board held a brief discussion concerning enforcement and shared their concerns around illegal parking lots, specifically Germain Street. Members developed a team to arrange a meeting with the Building Inspections department to discuss their concerns with temporary parking lots and the lack of enforcement in the Heritage Area. ITEM 8.0 NEXT MEETING The next regular Board meeting will be held July 24 th, 2013 at 5:30pm.
Heritage Development Board Minutes - 8 - July 10 th, 2013 ITEM 9.0 ADJOURNMENT There being no further business, the meeting adjourned 6:18 PM Amy Poffenroth, P.Eng, MBA Acting Commissioner, Growth & Community Development Services