Atomic composition of Diamond-Like Carbon Film coated at over 100 μm/h by using Microwave-excited high-density near plasma Michigan Institute for Plasma Science and Engineering (MIPSE) 3 rd Annual Graduate Student Symposium, October 3rd Michigan State University, USA Yasuyuki TAKAOKA, Hiroyuki KOUSAKA, Noritsugu UMEHARA DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING, NAGOYA UNIVERSITY 1 Furo-cho, Chikusa-ku, Nagoya,Japan
Recent progress of DLC high hardness Diamond-like carbon (DLC) ~ amorphous carbon ~ diamond graphite low friction coefficient high wear resistance sp 3 sp DLC has excellent material properties high corrosion resistance DLC has gathered wider and wider attention in industry automobile parts cutting tool valve watch http://www.nippon-itf.co.jp http://casio.jp/wat/
Background Further saving of fuel and electric power consumed by machines is required. Requrement to tribology:decrease of energy loss due to friction Key technology:a low friction carbon film: DLC (Diamond-Like Carbon) Problem:high cost of coating limited application Cost reduction Application to wider variety of machince parts Expand the merit of energy saving by DLC Lofwfriction
Industrial demand : One-piece flow process Conventional 上カバー取り付け真空引き成膜上カバー取外し Our proposal (new method) Flow ワークの流れ of parts Part Gas Exhaust DLC ワークガス排気 DLC 膜 1000 parts in 1 batch Deposition rate:1 µm/h Batch process Huge cost of large equipment Not just in time Microwave &DC bias マイクロ波ランチャー Microwave マイクロ波投入 injection 1 parts in 1 batch Deposition rate (requirement: 100-1000 µm/h Inline (One-piece flow) process by ultra-high speed coating Cheaper cost of smaller equipment JUST in time suitable for low cost mass production such as automobile parts
T. Okamoto, et. al., Proc. International Tribology Conference HIROSHIMA 011, D-14 (CD-ROM). MVP Microwave-sheath Voltage combination Plasma MVP is sustained by microwave propagation along plasma-sheath interface, where the metal is negatively biased for expansion of sheath layer. Previous results of DLC coating by MVP H. Kousaka, et. al., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 44 (005) L1154 L1157. Such a high density plasma(>10 1 cm -3 ) gave a considerably high deposition rate of 188 µm/h, hardness of 1.9 GPa.
Required condition for SWP generation 1 e 0 e = m n e pe ε ω (m e : electron mass, e: electron charge, c: speed of light, ω: excitation frequency, n e : electron density, ε 0 : permittivity of vacuum, ε d : relative permittivity of quartz) 1/ 1 ) 1 ( + = ω ε ω ω ω ω ε d pe pe d z c k + - + - - - 0 ) (1 > + ω ε ω d pe.45 GHz, ε d =3.7 ---- n e >3.0 10 11 cm 3.45 GHz, ε d =1.0 ---- n e >1.7 10 11 cm 3 Wave number in the z direction Surface Wave-excited Plasma (SWP)
Motivation of this work 1. Film properties of DLC film coated at such high rate are unknown.. Substrate temperature often increases above 00, which is the tempering temperature of many steels typically used for mechanical elements. Purpose 1. Compare atomic composition of DC and MVP deposition at same environment in order to understand the characteristics of DLC film coated at over 100 μm/h.. Confirm whether the substrates was softened or not during DLC coating at temperatures higher than 00.
Experimental apparatus Vacuum chamber Quartz window CH 4 Ar H TMS GND DC DC power supply Pressure gage (Baratron) Leak valve 0 mm Specimen 5 mm MFC Quartz window Exhaust Valve Radiation thermometer (IR-CAPCS) Rotary pump Mechanical booster pump Microwave.45GHz.45 GHz microwaves can be introduced via coaxial waveguide and quartz plate. The top of the substrate is connected to a high voltage DC power supply to apply a negative voltage.
Substrate 13 13 t5 mm Substrate: Typically used for sliding parts of automobiles SCM415 (Cr,Mo containing alloy steel block) Tempered at 00 to get Vickers hardness 700 HV This substrate could have been softened if the substrate temperature exceed 00.
Comparison of DC, MVP(DC+MW) GND DC Exhaust Pressure gage (Baratron) Leak valve Vacuum chamber DC power supply Valve Quartz window 0 mm Specimen 5 mm CH 4 Ar H TMS MFC Quartz window Radiation thermometer (IR-CAPCS) By injecting microwave, pulse current became 90 times larger than DC plasma because plasma density increased. Rotary pump DC Mechanical booster pump Microwave.45GHz Frequency 500 Hz, Duty ratio 50 % Bias voltage 100V/div Current 0.01A/div MVP(DC+MW) Bias voltage 100V/div Current 0.5A/div Microwave power(forward) 400W/div Microwave power(reflect) 400W/div Frequency 500 Hz, Duty ratio 50 % 0.01 A 0.9 A 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5.0 Time t, msec 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5.0 Time t, msec
Comparison of DC, MVP(DC+MW) Movies : Ar plasma generation by methods. DC DC -500 V MVP(DC+MW) DC -500 V, MW 500 W
Coating conditions DC DC+Heater DC+MW Gas flow, sccm Ar CH 4 TMS 40 00 0 Total gas flow Q total, sccm Pressure P, Pa Deposition time t, sec. 750 60 75 100 1 Peak power 1 kw Microwave Pulse frequency 500 Hz (.45 GHz) Duty ratio 50% Bias Voltage Pulse frequency Duty ratio -500 V 500 Hz 50% Temperature T, C 80 70 70 DLC film thickness: 500nm In the coating of DC plasma with additional heating, maximum substrate temperature during coating becomes the same as 70 of the microwave-enhanced case. 1 sec 100 sec 750 sec Tempering temperature Substrate could have been softened.
Results ~Comparison of deposition methods~ Deposition rate D, µm/h 00 150 100 50 0 DC(80 ) 50 nm 535 nm.5 µm/h 1.6 µm/h DC (80 ) DC+Heater 540 nm 545 nm DC+MW DC+Heater 50 nm 530 nm 156 µm/h DC+MW Hardness H, GPa 30 5 0 15 10 5 0 11.8 GPa DC (80 ) 19.1 GPa DC+Heater 0.8 GPa DC+MW Deposition rate and film hardness considerably increased by injecting microwave. Comparing the two DC plasma cases, hardness was increased with the increase of substrate temperature.
Results & Discussion ~Atomic composition~ Atomic composition, at.% % 80 60 40 0 0 DC(80 ) DC+Heater DC+MW DLC coating by ECR-CVD Y. Konishi, et. al., Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics, Research B 118 (1996) 31-317 C O Si H N It is considered that the increase of film hardness by additional heating was caused by the decrease of hydrogen content. Hardness H, GPa 30 5 0 15 10 5 0 11.8 GPa DC (80 ) Measurements: ERDA,XPS 19.1 GPa DC+Heater 0.8 GPa DC+MW Comparing the cases: DC plasma and DC with microwave plasma, hardness value were almost the same. However, both of the hydrogen and silicon contents decreased, while the carbon content significantly increased by injecting microwave.
Results ~Substrate hardness after DLC coating~ Measurement : Micro hardness tester Indentation load 0.3 kgf, Indentation depth 5~6 µm 1 sec 100 sec 750 sec Vickers hardness H, HV 800 700 600 500 The decrease of substrate hardness did not occur in the coating by microwave-excited high-density near plasma even though the maximum substrate temperature exceeded 00 during coating. It is expected that substrate softening can be avoided if high-temperature period is enough short. 400 Untreated DC (80 ) DC+Heater DC+MW
Results ~Tempering parameter~ Hardness H, HV 750 700 650 600 550 500 DC+MW DC(80 ) Critical value for softening of alloy steel (SCM415), P=774 DC+Heater baseline (Tempering DC(80 ) data of SCM415 alloy steel) DC+Heater DC+MW 7000 7500 8000 8500 9000 9500 10000 Tempering parameter P Tempering parameter P=T(log t + C) T : Temperature [K] t : time [hrs.] C : Material constant C=15 (for SCM415) J.H. Hollomon and L. D. Jaffe, Trans. AIME, 1945, vol. 16, p. 3. Tempering parameter did not exceed the critical value (P=774) above which the alloy steel substrate softens in the coating by microwave-excited plasma.
Conclusion ~Comparison of film properties~ 1. The deposition rate and hardness of the DLC deposited by DC plasma were.5 µm/h and 11.8 GPa, respectively; on the other hand, the deposition rate and hardness of the DLC deposited by microwave-excited high-density near plasma were 156 µm/h and 0.8 GPa, respectively.. Comparing the DC plasma and DC with microwave plasma cases, both of the hydrogen and sillicon contents decreased, while the carbon content significantly increased by injecting microwave. 3. The decrease of substrate hardness did not occur in the coating by microwave-excited high-density near plasma even though the substrate temperature increase up to 70 during coating. This is because tempering parameter did not exceed the critical value (774) above which the alloy steel substrate softens.
Friction test ~ In ambient air ~ DLC coated disk against SUJ ball (bearing steel) Specimen DC(80 ) DC+MW SKH51(substrate) Ball SUJ SUJ SUJ Disk DLC (DC 80 ) on SKH 51 substrate DLC (DC+MW 70 ) on SKH 51 substrate SKH 51 Load, N 0.5 0.5 0.5 Rotation speed, rpm 100.0 100.0 100.0 Sliding speed, mm/s 6. 6. 6. Rotation radius.5 mm In ambient air Temperature : Humidity : 53%RH Maximum Hertzian contact pressure P max : ~ 433 MPa Friction coefficient μ 1. 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0. 0.0 Worn out DC(80 ) DC+MW SKH 51 μ = 0.11 0 1000 000 3000 4000 5000 Number of sliding cycles N, cycle DLC film coated by DC method rapidly worn out. Friction coefficient became almost same value with substrate. DLC film coated by DC with microwave plasma showed low friction of µ = 0.11.
Friction test ~ In ambient air ~ OMS images for balls and DLC-coated disks Ball(SUJ) [x 50] Sliding direction 00 µm 00 µm 00 µm Disk [x 100] 100 µm DC+MW 100 µm DC (80 ) SKH 51