Climate change and Australia s plantations REGIONAL REPORT 6: Victoria and southern New South Wales Radiata pine plantations
Introduction Plantations have been managed for wood production in Australia for over 1 years, and silvicultural practices for establishment and growth are welldeveloped, particularly for the more established parts of the industry such as the softwood sector (Snowdon and James 27). Australia s climate is becoming more variable, and this represents a potential opportunity or threat to the viability of Australia s plantations, and may mean changes in management or location of plantations may be required to capitalise on opportunities and reduce threats. The bulk of Australia s pine plantations are located in cool temperate south western and south eastern Australia (Figure 1). This report summarises the possible consequences of more variable climate for softwood plantations in eastern and central Victoria and southern NSW pine plantations by 23, in terms of stand productivity and wood properties, the likelihood of stand failure due to drought and implications of this for final stems per hectare, risks from fire and risks and impacts of pests. The report also presents possible adaptation strategies to reduce negative impacts of climate change on plantation productivity. This work was done as part of a FWPA-funded project, and more details can be found in the project final report, Adaptation strategies to manage risk in Australia s temperate plantations. Figure 1 Current distribution of eucalypt plantations in Australia (National Forest Inventory 212), and the focal region for this report (blue box).
23 Victoria and southern NSW Regional Scorecard 23 Volume change with no elevated CO 2 (Medium fertility, deep soils) Least favourable Median Most favourable Percentage change in production from current < -25-25 - -15-15 - -5-5 - 5 5-15 15-25 >25 Adjusted Coefficient of Variation Increase in high FDDI days <.1.1 -.2.2 -.3.3 -.4.4 -.5.5 -.6 >.6-5 6-1 11-15 16-2 21-25 26-3 Key Points Climate The climate is predicted to be warmer and drier with average temperature increases of.74 degrees and a 7 decrease in rainfall. Stand Volume and survival In the absence of an elevated CO2 response, we can anticipate either no change or in decreases up to -25 in some parts along the coast or the dry inland regions. Areas that are potentially limited by cold temperatures may see increases in productivity as temperatures warm. There are some plantation failures predicted in this region in the dry inland regions and the colder areas where but without the modelling capacity to predict mortality in Pinus radiata it is not possible to determine the within stand level of mortality. The adjusted coefficient of variation (measure of variation independent of mean size) is relatively low across the southern part of the estate, indicating there has been little shift in the inherent variability the region. In the hot dry inland, cold mountain regions, variability is high, indicating small shifts in climate can impact significantly on production. It is likely small changes in silviculture will mitigate reduced productivity in most regions. In the dry inland regions, adaptation options are limited. Fire risk There are moderate increases in risky fire weather (forest fire danger index, FFDI, >25) are predicted for the majority of the estate. There are some significant increases in the dry inland areas and some coastal areas Changes in fire weather and intensity are in summer, with a possible lengthening of the fire season into August to April. Pest risk The range of key pests are unlikely to change much by 23. Dothistromarisk is unlikely to change except for small decreases in the east coast by 25. Big increases inessigellarisk are predicted for the south coast region by 25. Number of rotations where there was plantation failure (out of 1) 1-76 75-51 5-26 25-1 Optimum climatic suitability: defoliating pests Pest spp 23 25 D. septosporum E. californica S. noctilio Dothistroma EI > 24 Essigella Sirex EI > 69 EI > 2 No change Increased risk Greatly increased risk Overview
Key points Production Shallow soil Deep soil Shallow soil Current production Least favourable Median Most favourable Current production Legend Volume m 3 ha -1 Value High : 2 Low : 4 23 Volume change with no elevated CO 2 Where there is no response to elevated Least favourable Median Most favourable Percentage change in production from current < -25-25 - -15-15 - -5-5 - 5 5-15 15-25 > 25 23 Volume change with elevated CO 2 Current production Least favourable Median Most favourable CO2 production is predicted to range from losses up to 25 to positive responses of 25. The southern parts of the estate are generally predicted to remain similar under the median scenario with decreases of up to 25 in the least favourable scenario. These areas are amongst the more productive parts of the region. The colder areas around the Australian Alps are likely to see increases in production as the temperature limitations are reduced. Inland areas around Shepparton and Echuca and the east between Sale and Bairnsdale are likely to incur significant reductions in productivity. In regions where productivity is predicted to decrease (less than 25 loss), adaption through changes in silviculture may mitigate the potential losses in production. In the dry inland regions, silvicultural adaption options are limited and are unlikely to improve production substantially. Deep soil Current production Least favourable Median Most favourable Legend Volume m 3 ha -1 Value Percentage change in production from current High : 2 < -25-25 - -15-15 - -5-5 - 5 5-15 15-25 > 25 Where there is predicted response to elevated CO2, productions is positive across both deep and shallow soils, bar some inland regions (Shepparton to Echuca). This area is likely to be significantly impacted under the least favourable and median futures. It is predicted adaptation options will be limited. Low : 4 The largest increases are generally seen where production is low and small absolute gains can result in a large percentage increase.
Site A Frequency Silvicultural options to address changes in production Effects in change in stocking and thinning on production and diameter distributions Site B Frequency Effects in change in stocking and thinning on production and diameter distributions Site C Frequency 3 25 2 15 1 5 6 5 4 3 2 1 5 4 3 2 1 Site C SPH13 (Original) SPH16 (Option 1) SPH13 2 Thin (Option 2) 2 4 6 8 1 12 Volume m 3 ha -1 Site B Site A 11 115 12 125 13 135 14 145 15 Volume m 3 ha -1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Volume m 3 ha -1 2 4 6 8 1 12 Diameter cm Effects in change in stocking and thinning on production and diameter distributions Frequency Frequency Frequency 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 4 6 8 1 12 5 4 3 2 1 5 4 3 2 1 All three reference sites are predicted to experience a drop in production. Results include output from 5 future climates. Silviculture Original -plant 13sph, 3 thinnings (age 11, 19, 26), clearfall age 35 Option 1 -plant 16sph, 3 thinnings (age 11, 19, 26), clearfall age 35 Option2 - plant 13sph, 2 thinnings (age 15, 26), clearfall age 35 b. Diameter cm 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 11 Volume m 3 ha -1 Two 35 Year Rotations (Original) Three 23 Year Rotations (Option 1) Site A: Modelling suggests increasing the stocking to 16ph at planting can increase productivity (~2.5) but diameters were on average lower (46.1cm compared to the original option 48cm). The biggest productivity gains were seen when the number of thinnings was reduced to 2 and delayed several years (~5). This resulted in average diameters of 48cm. Site B: Modelling suggests there will be a small proportion of plantation failure (~5) during severe drought (two consecutive years). Where plantations survived, the biggest productivity gains were seen when the number of thinnings was reduced to 2 and delayed several years (~11), followed by increasing the stocking to 16sph (~2.5). Diameter distributions were broadly similar with diameters ~45cm. Site C: At some locations there will be a high proportion of failures irrespective of silviculture, giving a bi-modal distribution of yields, with those that fail during critically dry years at one end of the scale and those that survive yielding modest production. Shorter rotations (23 years compared to 35) reduced the number of plantation failures by limiting exposure to drought, and increased productivity on average by 23. Silvicultural Options
Silviculture and Wood Properties Site A SPH13 (Original) Reject F4 MGP1 MGP12 MGP15 Site B SPH13 (Original) Reject F4 MGP1 MGP12 MGP15 Site c SPH13 (Original) Reject F4 MGP1 MGP12 MGP15 Potential Board Output Density (kg m -3 ) SPH16 (Option1) No. Boards (1 x 4mm) SPH16 (Option1) SPH16 (Option1) SPH13 2 thin (Option2) MGP15 MGP12 SPH13 2 thin (Option2) SPH13 2 thin (Option2) Reject Original 511-556 21 71 14 5 Option1 55-547 21 71 14 5 Option2 497-538 25 8 8 8 Density (kg m -3 ) No. Boards (1 x 4mm) MGP15 MGP12 Reject Original 48-56 21 71 14 Option1 475-51 21 71 14 5 Option2 477-5 25 56 28 Density (kg m -3 ) No. Boards (1 x 4mm) MGP15 MGP12 Reject Original 486-569 12 75 8 Option1 486-568 12 83 8 Option2 473-556 13 77 15 SiteA: Option 2, with the highest growth rates,had lower density overall. The Original and Option 1 treatments had similar numbers of predicted boards and MGP15 boards. Option 2 had the highest percentage of MGP15 boards and greatest number of predicted boards. Site B: Option 2, with the highest growth rates,had lower density overall. The Original and Option 1 treatments had similar numbers of predicted boards and MGP15 boards. Option 2 had the lowest percentage of MGP15 boards but the greatest number of predicted boards. Site C: The predicted overall density was highly variable for all treatments at this marginal site. Option 3, with lower sph and two thinnings had lower density overall. The number of boards were generally low for all treatments as the logs are small and growth rates low. Option 1 had the highest percentage of MGP15 boards.
FIRE DANGER: Median and 99 FFDI for Victoria and southern NSW Fire Fire danger is characterised using the Forest Fire Danger Index (FFDI) For Victoria and Southern NSW FFDI is not predicted to change much during autumn and but median FFDI may increase from August to April The number of days with FFDI>25 suggests a lengthening of the fire season at both ends with the largest increases inland of the Australian Alps. Change in days with FFDI>25 for worse case (left) and best case (right) climate change Risk Factor Days 3 Management Strategy Comments Fire weather Regional fire response plans Climate change is expected to change the frequency and intensity of fires but not the nature of fire Fuel loads Fire spread Cleanup debris from under plantations Prune branches Weed control Landscape design to limit fire spread and aid suppression Maybe a strategyfor high risk areas Opportunities to avoid fire by relocating plantation estate were not identified Fire Danger Adaptation Strategies
difference in final volume (control-defoliated) 5-5 -1-15 -2 Pests Defoliation at 311 years years 2 4 6 8 1 Fertility High Med Low (1769) (1739) (159) Defoliation 5-5 -1-15 -2 Defoliation at 8 years 19 years 2 4 6 8 1 Fertility High (1769) Med (1739) Low (159) Higher rainfall site Production Pests: difference in final volume (control-defoliated) 5-5 -1-15 -2 2 4 6 8 1 Fertility High (1229) Med(1215) Low (116) Fertility Lower rainfall site Effects Figure of a single 11. Effectof defoliation asingle on final early stand (3 years)- volume or(age later 35) (8for years)-age a wetter defoliationevent and drier site. The onmore finalnegative stand volume,(age the number 15) thefor a greater wetter the and impact. drierhigh, site. The medium moreand negative low indicates the number, site fertility the larger levels. the impact. Numbers High, in brackets med and indicate low indicate predicted sitefinal fertility stand levels. volume Numbers in the inabsence bracketsof indicate defoliation predicted (including finalthinnings) stand volume in the absence of defoliation(including thinnings) Pest damage may amplify negative effects of climate change on stand productivity. Pest damage in the region includes defoliation, stem and root damage (Table 2). For 2 indicative sites (wetter and drier, and either low. medium or high fertility), we predict that, for stands experiencing defoliation: Maximum reduction in final volume will average 1 at these sites (~11-17 m3/ha), with greatest impact occurring when defoliation >6, site fertility is low and at drier sites (Figure 11) There will be considerable between-site variability in responses Later age defoliation will have a greater impact than early age defoliation. Multiple defoliations will have a substantially greater impact on volume than single events (Figure 12) particularly at lower fertility sites We do not have enough information to predict the impacts on productivity of other pest types 5-5 -1-15 -2 2 4 6 8 1 High Med Low (1229) (1215) (116) Lower rainfall Higher rainfall difference in final volume (control-defoliated) -5-1 -15-2 -25 High Med Low Site fertility -5-1 -15-2 -25 One defoliaton Three defoliations High Med Low Site fertility Rotation-length Figure 12. Rotation-length effects of a single versus effects 36 ofdefoliations single versus starting 3 6 at age defoliations 19, for a lower starting and higher at rainfall agesite 8, and for 3 afertility levels lower and higher rainfall site and three fertility levels
Possible effects of climate change on abundance of current key pests in the region Key pests Montereypine aphid Damage type Defoliation Damage age Warmer temps Post canopy closure Ips bark beetle Stem damage Post canopy closure Sirexwood wasp Phytophthora cinnamomi Stem damage Post canopy closure generajon mortality generajon mortality generajon mortality Root damage <2years of age lifecycles per season heatwaves Drought Storms abundance if low humidity abundance abundance spores and growth abundance dueto heavy rain abundance abundance lifecycles per season Defoliating insects and stem borers are likely to be favoured by warmer mean temperatures but generally not by heatwaves Foliar diseases will be favoured by warmer mean temperatures but increasing droughts will likely reduce the abundance and distribution of these pests Stem borers are attracted to stressed trees and may amplify drought impacts Management strategies to control pest impacts are limited (Table 3), and include fertilising to promote crown recovery, thinning to manage drought stress or reduce humidity, managing slash to reduce overwintering sites, continued use of the Sirex biological control agent, and monitoring/controlling insect populations Risks from climate change Table 3. Possible management strategies for reducing the impacts of pests on stand productivity Damage type Defoliation Stem damage All Management strategy Fertilise to promote crown recovery Maintain biological control agent for Monterey pine aphid Thin plantations to manage drought stress Reduce slash to manage population build-up Maintain biological control agent for Sirexand Ips Monitor populations and control when populations are high Comments May increase drought mortality risk Can help manage drought risk Requires understanding of threshold population numbers for risk monitoring and modelling Adaptation strategies
Methods CLIMATE: Historical climate data were obtained from the Bureau of Meteorology s Data drill, consisting of interpolated grids splined using data from meteorological station records at a scale of.5 degrees, covering the years 1975 25. We used the Climate Futures Framework (Whetton et al 212) to select climate models that represented the worst case, most likely and best case climate futures for the main temperate plantation regions in Australia, resulting in 4 5 climate models being run per region, using an A2 emissions scenario. A regular grid of.1 degree was used across all regions, and climate data were generated centred around 23 and 25. We used the McVicar et al (28) mean wind data set in the fire danger modelling. PRODUCTIVITY AND DROUGHT: Productivity estimates were updated from previous analyses, using the process-based model CABALA. Six standard soil types were set up (low, medium and high fertility for each of shallow and deep soil depth) to provide broad representation of soils in each plantation region. The silvicultural regime was a 35 year rotation planted at 13 stems/ha (sph), an at-planting fertiliser application and thinning at ages 11 (to 75 sph), 19 (to 45 sph) and 26 (to 25 sph). Twenty separate rotations were simulated by running the model with 2 different planting dates over a 3 year block of weather. For each region simulations included the factorial combination of 6 soils, 5 climate models, 3 timeframes and 2 planting dates. The number of surviving rotations out of 2 was calculated to estimate probability of plantation failure. The coefficient of variation provided a measure of inherent variability in the region. For all combinations, the model was run assuming either no acclimation or full acclimation of photosynthesis to higher atmospheric CO 2 concentration, reflecting the high uncertainty around how plantations will respond to higher CO 2. WOOD PROPERTIES: the wood properties model CAMBIUM was used to examine consequences of climate for basic density. The analyses were performed on a subset of sites in the region. The number of 1 x 4 mm boards in a range of structural grades was estimated. The sites used for wood properties modelling are the same as those used for sliviclutural modelling. FIRE: The Forest Fire Danger Meter model (McArthur 1967) was used to calculate daily forest fire danger index, which was used to characterise fire danger. Fire damage days were calculated as the number of days with plantation fire intensity above 4 kw/m. PESTS: Tables of key plantation pests were produced and potential responses to climate were summarised using literature review. The niche model CLIMEX was used to examine potential changes in the distribution of 3 pine pests. The process-based model CABALA was used at selected high and low productivity sites in each region to identify stand responses to defoliation, using the methods described above. ADAPTATION: CABALA was used to examine how silviculture might be used to manage productivity.. The silvicultural options were (1) original (plant at 13 sph, 3 thinnings, clearfall at age 35); (2) Option 1 (plant at 16 sph, 3 thinnings, clearfall at age 35); (3) Option 2 (plant at 13 sph, 2 thinnings, clearfall at age 35). Stand volume and wood properties were estimated for a subset of indicative sites per region. For fire and pests risk management, adaptation strategies are suggested based on literature and expert advice. Further information: Libby Pinkard CSIRO Land and Water Private Bag 12, Hobart, 71 Australia Libby.Pinkard@csiro.au Jody Bruce CSIRO Land and Water Private Bag 12, Hobart, 71 Australia Jody.Bruce@csiro.au References: Whetton, P., Hennessy, K., Clarke, J., McInnes, K., Kent, D.S., 212. Use of Representative Climate Futures in impact and adaptation assessment. Climatic Change 115, 433-442. McVicar, T.R., Van Niel, T.G., Li, L.T., Roderick, M.L., Rayner, D.P., Ricciardulli, L., Donohue, R.J., 28. Wind speed climatology and trends for Australia, 1975 26: Capturing the stilling phenomenon and comparison with near-surface reanalysis output. Geophysical Research Letters 35.
Other project outputs: FINAL PROJECT REPORT: Adaptation strategies to manage risk in Australia s temperate plantations. Final report to FWPA prepared by CSIRO. (http://www.fwpa.com.au/rd-and-e/resources/418-adaptation-strategies-to-managerisk-in-australia-s-plantations.html) Regional report 1: South west Western Australia eucalypt plantations Regional report 2: South west Western Australia radiata pine plantations Regional report 3: Green Triangle eucalypt plantations Regional report 4: Green Triangle radiata pine plantations Regional report 5: Eastern Victoria/southern NSW eucalypt plantations Regional report 6: Eastern Victoria/southern NSW radiata pine plantations Regional report 7: Northern NSW radiata pine plantations Regional report 8: Tasmania eucalypt plantations Regional report 9: Tasmania radiata pine plantations Spatial database: all data generated in the project is available via a spatial database (https://data.csiro.au/dap/) Updated CABALA model, contact: Jody Bruce CSIRO Land and Water Private Bag 12, Hobart, 71, Australia Jody.Bruce@csiro.au Citation Pinkard E, Bruce J, Battaglia M, Matthews S, Drew D, Downes, G (214). Climate change and Australia s Plantations. Regional report 6. Eastern Victoria/southern NSW Radiata pine plantations. CSIRO Copyright and disclaimer 215 CSIRO To the extent permitted by law, all rights are reserved and no part of this publication covered by copyright may be reproduced or copied in any form or by any means except with the written permission of CSIRO. Important disclaimer CSIRO advises that the information contained in this publication comprises general statements based on scientific research. The reader is advised and needs to be aware that such information may be incomplete or unable to be used in any specific situation. No reliance or actions must therefore be made on that information without seeking prior expert professional, scientific and technical advice. To the extent permitted by law, CSIRO (including its employees and consultants) excludes all liability to any person for any consequences, including but not limited to all losses, damages, costs, expenses and any other compensation, arising directly or indirectly from using this publication (in part or in whole) and any information or material contained in it.