Construction of Control Chart Based on Six Sigma Initiatives for Regression

Similar documents
Evaluating the statistical power of goodness-of-fit tests for health and medicine survey data

A Group Decision Making Method for Determining the Importance of Customer Needs Based on Customer- Oriented Approach

A SIMULATION STUDY OF QUALITY INDEX IN MACHINE-COMPONF~T GROUPING

Identifying Factors that Affect the Downtime of a Production Process

EARLY STRENGTH TEST FOR QUALITY CONTROL OF CONCRETE

A Scenario-Based Objective Function for an M/M/K Queuing Model with Priority (A Case Study in the Gear Box Production Factory)

MULTIPLE FACILITY LOCATION ANALYSIS PROBLEM WITH WEIGHTED EUCLIDEAN DISTANCE. Dileep R. Sule and Anuj A. Davalbhakta Louisiana Tech University

Supplier selection and evaluation using multicriteria decision analysis

Guidelines on Disclosure of CO 2 Emissions from Transportation & Distribution

Evaluating Clustering Methods for Multi-Echelon (r,q) Policy Setting

Calculation and Prediction of Energy Consumption for Highway Transportation

LIFE CYCLE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS ASSESSMENT FOR RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS IN CHINA

Sources of information

Research on the Evaluation of Corporate Social Responsibility under the Background of Low Carbon Economy

Sporlan Valve Company

Analysis Online Shopping Behavior of Consumer Using Decision Tree Leiyue Yao 1, a, Jianying Xiong 2,b

Experiments with Protocols for Service Negotiation

PSO Approach for Dynamic Economic Load Dispatch Problem

Numerical Analysis about Urban Climate Change by Urbanization in Shanghai

Fiber length of pulp and paper by automated optical analyzer using polarized light

Evaluating The Performance Of Refrigerant Flow Distributors

Spot Welding Parameter Optimization To Improve Weld Characteristics For Dissimilar Metals

Journals Evaluation and the Application Based on Entropy-TOPSIS

EVALUATING THE PERFORMANCE OF SUPPLY CHAIN SIMULATIONS WITH TRADEOFFS BETWEEN MULITPLE OBJECTIVES. Pattita Suwanruji S. T. Enns

TRAFFIC SIGNAL CONTROL FOR REDUCING VEHICLE CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS ON AN URBAN ROAD NETWORK

Improvement on the properties of gypsum particleboard by adding cement*

COMPARISON ANALYSIS AMONG DIFFERENT CALCULATION METHODS FOR THE STATIC STABILITY EVALUATION OF TAILING DAM

Application of Ant colony Algorithm in Cloud Resource Scheduling Based on Three Constraint Conditions

Product Innovation Risk Management based on Bayesian Decision Theory

Numerical Flow Analysis of an Axial Flow Pump

Logistics Management. Where We Are Now CHAPTER ELEVEN. Measurement. Organizational. Sustainability. Management. Globalization. Culture/Ethics Change

The ranks of Indonesian and Japanese industrial sectors: A further study

Elastic Lateral Features of a New Glass Fiber Reinforced Gypsum Wall

Study on Productive Process Model Basic Oxygen Furnace Steelmaking Based on RBF Neural Network

A Two-Echelon Inventory Model for Single-Vender and Multi-Buyer System Through Common Replenishment Epochs

Development and production of an Aggregated SPPI. Final Technical Implementation Report

Optimal Issuing Policies for Substitutable Fresh Agricultural Products under Equal Ordering Policy

Emission Reduction Technique from Thermal Power Plant By Load Dispatch

Evaluation Method for Enterprises EPR Project Risks

A MODEL TO ANALYZE COST OF QUALITY FOR SUPPLY CHAIN DESIGN CONSIDERING MATERIAL FLOW

San Juan National Forest - American Marten Snow Track Index Evaluation.doc 1

Fast Algorithm for Prediction of Airfoil Anti-icing Heat Load *

Using Semi-Empirical Models to Design Timber Platform Frame for Stability

An Analysis on Stability of Competitive Contractual Strategic Alliance Based on the Modified Lotka-Voterra Model

Supplier Quality Performance Measurement System*

Planning of work schedules for toll booth collectors

A Longer Tail?: Estimating The Shape of Amazon s Sales Distribution Curve in Erik Brynjolfsson, Yu (Jeffrey) Hu, Michael D.

Do not turn over until you are told to do so by the Invigilator.

A Two-layer Time Window Assignment Vehicle Routing Problem

1 Basic concepts for quantitative policy analysis

The Credit Risk Assessment Model of Internet Supply Chain Finance: Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Model with the Principle of Variable Weight

The Credit Risk Assessment Model of Internet Supply Chain Finance: Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Model with the Principle of Variable Weight

Integration DEA into Six Sigma Methodology for Performance Evaluation of Yazd Science and Technology Park Technological Companies

RIGOROUS MODELING OF A HIGH PRESSURE ETHYLENE-VINYL ACETATE (EVA) COPOLYMERIZATION AUTOCLAVE REACTOR. I-Lung Chien, Tze Wei Kan and Bo-Shuo Chen

Background Statement for SEMI Draft Document 4771B New Standard: TEST METHOD FOR EQUIPMENT FAN FILTER UNIT (EFFU) PARTICLE REMOVAL

EVALUATION METHODOLOGY OF BUS RAPID TRANSIT (BRT) OPERATION

Consumption capability analysis for Micro-blog users based on data mining

SIMULATION RESULTS ON BUFFER ALLOCATION IN A CONTINUOUS FLOW TRANSFER LINE WITH THREE UNRELIABLE MACHINES

Journal of Service Science 2013 Volume 6, Number 1

Özlem Coşgun Fatih University, Department of Industrial Engineering, Istanbul, 34500, Turkey

Research on the Process of Runoff and Sediment-production in the Shunjiagou Small Watershed by Applying Automatic Measurement System

A NATURAL CIRCULATION EXPERIMENT OF PASSIVE RESIDUAL HEAT REMOVAL HEAT EXCHANGER FOR AP1000

1. Introduction Definitions 4. -Turnover 4

Evaluation of Quality Management Performance in Office of President using Modified Public Sector Management Quality Award (PMQA) Model

Production Scheduling for Parallel Machines Using Genetic Algorithms

AHP and Value Engineering Application in Electrical Equipment Procurement Hong-qing ZHANG

CONFLICT RESOLUTION IN WATER RESOURCES ALLOCATION

Optimization of Resistance Spot Weld Parameters using Grey Relational Analysis

Bulletin of Energy Economics.

Practical Application Of Pressure-Dependent EPANET Extension

RANKING OF VENDORS BASED ON CRITERIA BY MCDM-MATRIX METHOD-A CASE STUDY FOR COMMERCIAL VEHICLES IN AN AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY

High impact force attenuation of reinforced concrete systems

Experimental Validation of a Suspension Rig for Analyzing Road-induced Noise

FIN DESIGN FOR FIN-AND-TUBE HEAT EXCHANGER WITH MICROGROOVE SMALL DIAMETER TUBES FOR AIR CONDITIONER

DEVELOPMENT OF DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM FOR SELECTING QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS AND MANAGEMENT TOOLS

COMPETITIVENESS CALCULATION OF EDUCATIONAL SERVICES IN CHINESE CITY ZHENJIANG

Field Burning of Crop Residues

Spatial difference of regional carbon emissions in China

Final Report Bilateral Comparison Report on Hardness Measurement Rockwell scale A and B Between PTB and NIMT

Plan. IV. How to enhance energy security by partnerships with private companies: Brazil and Russia examples. China and India examples

On Effect of Delayed Differentiation on a Multiproduct Vendor Buyer Integrated Inventory System with Rework

Objectives Definition

A NOVEL PARTICLE SWARM OPTIMIZATION APPROACH FOR SOFTWARE EFFORT ESTIMATION

Analyses Based on Combining Similar Information from Multiple Surveys

Development of a Tool Management System for Energy Sector Company

Development of an Asphalt Pavement Distress Evaluation Method for Freeways in China

Job Description. Department/School: Faculty of Humanities & Social Sciences Grade: 6 Department/Placements Office

To manage leave, meeting institutional requirements and treating individual staff members fairly and consistently.

Optimum Generation Scheduling for Thermal Power Plants using Artificial Neural Network

Formability Analysis of Crca-IS2 Sheet to Eliminates the Defects during Deep Draw

A TABU SEARCH FOR MULTIPLE MULTI-LEVEL REDUNDANCY ALLOCATION PROBLEM IN SERIES-PARALLEL SYSTEMS

A Hybrid Approach for Web Service Selection

Simulation of Steady-State and Dynamic Behaviour of a Plate Heat Exchanger

K vary over their feasible values. This allows

Prediction algorithm for users Retweet Times

Proceedings of the 2010 Winter Simulation Conference B. Johansson, S. Jain, J. Montoya-Torres, J. Hugan, and E. Yücesan, eds.

A Batch Splitting Job Shop Scheduling Problem with bounded batch sizes under Multiple-resource Constraints using Genetic Algorithm

Regression model for heat consumption monitoring and forecasting

The research on modeling of coal supply chain based on objectoriented Petri net and optimization

Risk Assessment Using AHP in South Indian Construction Companies: A Case Study

Transcription:

2018 IJSRST Volume 4 Issue 2 Prnt ISSN: 2395-6011 Onlne ISSN: 2395-602X Themed Secton: Scence and Technology Constructon of Control Chart Based on Sx Sgma Intatves for Regresson ABSTRACT R. Radhakrshnan 1, P. Balamurugan 2 1 Advsor, Maharaja Group of Insttutons, Perundura, Tamlnadu, Inda 2 Department of Statstcs, Government Arts College (Autonomous), Salem, Tamlnadu, Inda A control chart s a statstcal devce used for the study and control of repettve process. W.A. Shewhart [21] of Bell Telephone Laboratores suggested control charts based on the 3 sgma lmts. Now the companes n developed and developng countres started applyng Sx Sgma ntatves n ther manufacturng process, whch results n lesser number of defects. The companes practcng Sx Sgma ntatves are expected to produce 3.4 or less number of defects per mllon opportuntes, a concept suggested by Motorola [22]. If the companes practcng Sx Sgma ntatves use the control lmts suggested by Shewhart, then no pont fall outsde the control lmts because of the mprovement n the qualty of the process. In ths paper an attempt s made to construct a control chart based on sx sgma ntatves for Regresson specally desgned for the companes applyng Sx Sgma ntatves n ther organzaton. Sutable Table 2 s also constructed and presented for the engneers to take quck decsons. Keywords: Control Chart, Process control, Sx Sgma, Sx Sgma Qualty Level. I. INTRODUCTION The concept of Sx Sgma was ntroduced by Motorola [22] by the engneer M.Harry who analyzed varatons n outcomes of the company s nternal procedures and realzed that by measurng varatons t wll be possble to mprove the workng of the system. The procedure was amed at takng acton to mprove the overall performance. The companes, whch are practcng Sx Sgma, are expected to produce 3.4 or less number of defects per mllon opportuntes. Radhakrshnan and Svakumaran [15-20] used the concept of Sx Sgma n the constructon of samplng plans such as sngle, double and repettve group samplng plans ndexed through Sx Sgma Qualty Levels (SSQLs) wth Posson dstrbuton as the base lne dstrbuton. Radhakrshnan [2] suggested sngle samplng plan ndexed through Sx Sgma qualty levels (SSQLs) based on Intervened Random Effect Posson Dstrbuton and Weghted Posson Dstrbuton as the base lne dstrbutons. Radhakrshnan and Balamurugan [3-14] constructed control charts based on sx sgma ntatves for defects, mean, average fracton defectves, number of defectves, X bar usng standard devaton, Exponentally Weghted Movng Average (EWMA), proporton defectves number of defectves, Fracton defectves, Standard devaton wth varable sample sze, average number of nonconformtes per multple unts and number of defects - average number of defects per unt. The control charts orgnated by W.A. Shewhart [21] was based on 3 sgma control lmts. If the same charts are used for the products of the companes whch adopt sx sgma ntatves n the process, then no pont wll fall outsde the control lmts because of the mprovement n the qualty. So a separate control chart s requred to montor the outcomes of the companes, whch adopt sx sgma ntatves. IJSRST1841264 Receved : 07 Feb 2018 Accepted : 17 Feb 2018 January-February-2018 [ (4) 2: 1142-1147] 1142

In ths paper an attempt s made to construct a control chart based on sx sgma ntatves for Regresson. Sutable Table 3 s also constructed and presented for the engneers to take quck decsons. II. CONCEPTS AND TERMINOLOGIES Upper specfcaton lmt (USL) It s the greatest amount specfed by the producer for a process or product to have the acceptable performance. Lower specfcaton lmt (LSL) It s the smallest amount specfed by the producer for a process or product to have the acceptable performance. Tolerance level (TL) It s the dfference between USL and LSL, TL = USL- LSL Process capablty (Cp) Ths s the rato of tolerance level to sx tmes standard devaton of the process. TL USL LSL cp 6 6 Parameters for Regresson (a & b): The parameter a s an ntersecton pont of the ftted center lne wth the vertcal axs and the parameter b s the slope of the ftted center lne. Qualty Control Constant ( C6 ) The constant C6 ntroduced n ths paper to determne the control lmts based on sx sgma ntatves for Regresson chart. Subgroup sze (n & N) It s the choce of the sample sze n and the frequency of samplng and N s the total number of samples. III. CONSTRUCTION OF CONTROL CHART BASED ON SIX SIGMA INITIATIVES FOR REGRESSION Fx the tolerance level (TL) and process capablty (CP) to determne the process standard devaton ( ). Apply the value of 6 & 6 n the control lmts a C 6 6 b a C 6 6 b, to get the control lmts based on sx sgma ntatves for Regresson chart. The value of C6 s obtaned usng p(z z ) 1, 3.4 x 10 6 6 1 1 and z s a standard normal varate. For a specfed TL and CP of the process, the value of (termed as from c p 6 ) s calculated TL usng a C program and presented n 6 Table 3 for varous combnatons of TL and CP. Further the value of C6 s also obtaned usng the procedure gven above and presented n Table 3 for varous combnatons of TL and CP. The control lmts based on sx sgma ntatves for Regresson chart are UCL 6 6 6 Central Lne CL LCL 6 6 6 6 a C b ab a C b IV. CONDITIONS FOR APPLICATION Human nvolvement should be less n the manufacturng process The company adopts Sx sgma qualty ntatves n ts processes V. EXAMPLE The example provded by Amtava Mtra [1] s consdered here. The followng data are the course of machnng the dameter of steel hubs, tool wear s gradual and the sample X and the range R for 25 such samples wth subgroup sze 4: Internatonal Journal of Scentfc Research n Scence and Technology (www.jsrst.com) 1143

Sample Average Table 1. Sample mean and Range for tool wear data (n mm) Range Sample Average Range Sample Average Range X R X R X R 1 36.2 8.0 10 52.6 7.8 19 64.2 13.5 2 42.4 11.8 11 50.4 11.3 20 61.4 9.4 3 38.6 6.2 12 59.5 15.1 21 66.7 16.6 4 45.5 14.3 13 60.5 11.7 22 63.2 12.2 5 53.1 16.2 14 53.8 8.8 23 62.1 10.5 6 46.7 9.5 15 54.5 12.8 24 64.5 12.6 7 55.4 10.2 16 61.2 14.5 25 69.6 14.7 8 42.8 12.0 17 60.4 12.0 9 57.3 13.9 18 63.8 10.4 Table 2. Calculatons for determnng Trend chart for tool wear data (n mm) Sample Average X X 2 R 1 36.2 36.2 1 8.0 2 42.4 84.8 4 11.8 3 38.6 115.8 9 6.2 4 45.5 182.0 16 14.3 5 53.1 265.5 25 16.2 6 46.7 280.2 36 9.5 7 55.4 387.8 49 10.2 8 42.8 342.4 64 12.0 9 57.3 515.7 81 13.9 10 52.6 526.0 100 7.8 11 50.4 554.4 121 11.3 12 59.5 714.0 144 15.1 13 60.5 786.5 169 11.7 14 53.8 753.2 196 8.8 15 54.5 817.5 225 12.8 16 61.2 979.2 256 14.5 17 60.4 1026.8 289 12.0 18 63.8 1148.4 324 10.4 19 64.2 1219.8 361 13.5 20 61.4 1228.0 400 9.4 21 66.7 1400.7 441 16.6 22 63.2 1390.4 484 12.2 23 62.1 1428.3 529 10.5 24 64.5 1548.0 576 12.6 25 69.6 1740.0 625 14.7 Internatonal Journal of Scentfc Research n Scence and Technology (www.jsrst.com) 1144

325 X 1386.4 X 19,471.6 2 5525 R 296 Three Sgma Control lmts for Regresson chart The 3σ control lmts suggested by Shewhart (1931) are 2 & 2 a A R b a A R b From the resultng Fgure 1, t s clear that the process s n control, snce the entre subgroup numbers le nsde the control lmts. Control lmts based on sx sgma ntatves for Regresson chart For a gven TL = 10.4 (USL-LSL =16.6-6.2) & Cp = 1.5, t s found from the Table-3 that the value of 6 s 1.16. The control lmts based on sx sgma ntatves for Regresson chart for a specfed TL and C6 are & a C 6 6 b a C 6 6 b wth From the resultng Fgure 1, the sample numbers 5, 7, 9, 12 and 13 goes above the upper control lmt and the sample numbers 1, 3, 8, 23 and 24 goes below the lower control lmt. Therefore the process does not exhbt statstcal control. Fgure 1. Comparson of the process: 3 lmts and control lmts usng sx sgma ntatves VI. CONCLUSION In ths paper, a procedure s gven to construct a control chart based on sx sgma ntatves for Regresson wth an example. It s found that the process was not n control even when sx sgma ntatves are adopted. It s very clear from the comparson that when the process s centered wth reduced varaton many ponts fall outsde the control lmts than the 3 sgma control lmts, whch ndcate that the process s not n the level t was expected. So a correcton n the process s very much requred to reduce the varatons. The charts suggested n ths paper wll be very useful for the companes practcng Sx Sgma ntatves n ther process. These charts wll replace the exstng Shewhart [21] control charts n future when all the companes started mplementng sx sgma ntatves n ther organzaton. Internatonal Journal of Scentfc Research n Scence and Technology (www.jsrst.com) 1145

VII. REFERENCES [1]. Amtava Mtra, 2001, "Fundamentals of Qualty control and mprovement", Pearson Educaton, Asa. [2]. Radhakrshnan, R., 2009, "Constructon of Sx Sgma Based Samplng Plans", a D.Sc. Thess submtted to Bharathar Unversty, Combatore, Inda. [3]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2009a. "Sx sgma based Attrbute control charts for defects", Proceedngs of the 2009 Internatonal Marketng n Asa Pacfc: Issues and Challenges, GRD School of Commerce and Internatonal Busness, Combatore, Tamlnadu, Inda and Jontly Organzed by Unversty of central Lancashre, Nov 4-5, pp. 348-353. [4]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2009b. "Constructon of control charts based on sx sgma ntatves", Proceedngs of the 2009 Internatonal Conference on Trends n Informaton Technology and Busness Intellgence (ITBI 2009), Insttute of Management Technology, Nagpur, Inda. Nov 4-6, pp. 356-361. [5]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2009c. "Sx sgma based u chart", Proceedngs of the 2009 Internatonal Conference on Innovatve Practces n Management (IPM 2009), Paava Engneerng College, Namakkal, Tamlnadu, Inda. Dec 31st, pp. 365-367. [6]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2010a. "Sx Sgma based Control charts for the number of defectves", Proceedngs of the 2010 Internatonal Conference on Industral Engneerng and Operatons Management (IEOM 2010) organzed by Bangladesh Socety of Mechancal Engneers, Dhaka, Bangladesh, Jan 9-10, pp. 92. [7]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2010b. "Constructon of sx sgma based XBar control chart usng standard devaton", Internatonal Journal of Statstcs and System, Volume 6, Number 1, Issue date 2nd Week January, (accepted for publcaton). [8]. Radhakrshnan R. and Balamurugan, P. 2010c. "Sx Sgma based Exponentally Weghted Movng Average Control Chart", Indan journal of Scence and Technology, Issue No: 9 10, Vol. 3, pp. 1052 1055. [9]. Radhakrshnan R. and Balamurugan, P. 2010d. "Control charts based on sx sgma Intatves for proporton defectves and number of defectves", Internatonal Journal of Manufacturng Scence and Engneerng, Volume.1 No.2., (July December), pp: 49-53. [10]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2011a. "Sx sgma based Control Chart for Fracton Defectves", Journal of Testng and Evaluaton, Volume 39, Issue 4, Issue date 11th July, (accepted for publcaton). [11]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2011b. "Constructon of control chart based on sx sgma ntatves for standard devaton wth varable sample sze", Proceedngs of the 2011 Natonal conference on Trends and Research n Management, Oxford Engneerng College, Trchy, Tamlnadu, Inda, 28th January, 2011, pp. 218-222. [12]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2011c. "Constructon of control charts based on sx sgma Intatves for average number of nonconformtes per multple unts", Internatonal Journal of Industral Engneerng & Technology, Volume 3, Number 1, pp.99-105. [13]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2011d. "Constructon of control chart based on sx sgma ntatves for number of defectves", Proceedngs of the 2011 Internatonal conference on Global Challenges of Emergent Inda - A Management Perspectve, Vvekanandha Insttute of Informaton & Management Studes (VIIMS), Trchencode, Internatonal Journal of Scentfc Research n Scence and Technology (www.jsrst.com) 1146

Namakkal, Tamlnadu, Inda, 14-15, February (Accepted for publcaton n Proceedngs). [14]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Balamurugan, P. 2011e. "Constructon of control charts based on sx sgma Intatves for the number of defects and average number of defects per unt", Journal of Modern Appled Statstcal Methods, (Accepted for publcaton). [15]. Radhakrshnan, R., and Svakumaran, P.K., 2008a, "Constructon and Selecton of Sx Sgma Samplng Plan Indexed through Sx Sgma Qualty Level," Internatonal Journal of Statstcs and Systems, 3(2), 53-159. [16]. Radhakrshnan, R., and Svakumaran, P.K., "Constructon of Sx Sgma Repettve Group Samplng Plan", Internatonal Journal of Mathematcs and Computaton, 1(N08), 2008b, 75-83. [17]. Radhakrshnan, R., and Svakumaran, P.K., 2008c, "Constructon and Selecton of Condtonal Double Samplng Plan ndexed through Sx Sgma Qualty Levels," Sr Lankan Journal of Appled Statstcs, 9, 74-83. [18]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Svakumaran, P.K., 2009a, "Constructon of Sx Sgma Double Samplng Plans", Proc. of Natonal Semnar IT and Busness Intellgence (ITBI-08), Nagpur, Inda. [19]. Radhakrshnan, R., and Svakumaran, P.K., 2009b, "Constructon of Double Samplng Plans through Sx Sgma Qualty Levels," Proc. of the IEEE Second Internatonal Jont Conference on Computatonal Scences and Optmzaton (IEEECSO2009), Sanya, Hanan, Chna, 1027-1030., Aprl 24-26. [20]. Radhakrshnan, R. and Svakumaran, P.K., 2010, "Constructon and Selecton of Tghtened- Normal-Tghtened Schemes of Type TNT- (n1,n2; c) ndexed through Sx Sgma Qualty Levels", Proceedngs of the 2010 Internatonal Conference on Industral Engneerng and Operatons Management (IEOM 2010), Dhaka, Bangladesh, Jan 9-10, 2010. [21]. Shewhart, W.A., 1931, "Economc Control of Qualty of Manufactured Product", New York: Van Nostrand. [22]. Motorola: http://www.motorola.com TL C p Table 3. 6 Values for a specfed Cp and TL 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 1.0 1.68 1.7 1.72 1.73 1.75 1.1 1.53 1.55 1.56 1.58 1.59 1.2 1.40 1.42 1.43 1.44 1.46 1.3 1.29 1.31 1.32 1.33 1.35 1.4 1.20 1.21 1.23 1.24 1.25 1.5 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.16 1.17 1.6 1.05 1.06 1.07 1.08 1.09 1.7 0.99 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.8 0.94 0.94 0.95 0.96 0.97 1.9 0.89 0.89 0.90 0.91 0.92 2.0 0.84 0.85 0.86 0.87 0.88 2.1 0.80 0.81 0.82 0.83 0.83 2.2 0.77 0.77 0.78 0.79 0.80 2.3 0.73 0.74 0.75 0.75 0.76 2.4 0.70 0.71 0.72 0.72 0.73 2.5 0.67 0.68 0.69 0.69 0.70 Internatonal Journal of Scentfc Research n Scence and Technology (www.jsrst.com) 1147