'Output-Only' Vibration based Condition Monitoring of Dynamical Systems

Transcription

1 'Output-Only' Vibration based Condition Monitoring of Dynamical Systems Dr. Budhaditya Hazra Department of Civil Engineering, IIT GUWAHATI,

2 OUTLINE Introduction CIVIL STRUCTURES MODAL IDENTIFICATION Basic problem statement Blind source separation MECHANICAL SYSTEMS FAULT DETECTION Basic problem statement Synchrosqueezing transform Time varying auto-regressive modelling

3 Acceleration OUTPUT ONLY MODAL IDENTIFICATION INPUT data is a luxury Introduction Estimation of dynamic properties from response Natural frequency Damping Mode-shapes (ψ) ξ Time T ω = 1/T =

4 BLIND IDENTIFICATION Introduction Mathematical statement: Estimate A and s using the information in x Infinite sets of A and s yield same x Q is the modal response Identify ω i, ξ i, ψ using outputs only Synonymously used terms: Ambient modal identification, ambient vibration monitoring Traditional methods like SSI, NeXT-ERA, FDD etc. suffer from issues with model order, closely spaced modes, poor noise performance & poor damping estimates 2

5 BLIND SOURCE SEPARATION Mixing matrix A Background s 1 x 1 Sources Observations x 2 m sources (m = 2) s 2 n observations (n = 2) x = As Second Order Blind Identification is a popular BSS method 3

6 SECOND ORDER BSS Uses 2 nd order temporal statistics of signals STEPS: Orthogonalization: Unitary Transformation: Second order blind identification Belouchrani(1997) (Belouchrani 4

7 Formulation MODIFIED CROSS CORRELATION METHOD (MCC) Natural excitation technique allows forced responses to be cast into free responses (James & Farrar 1997) 5

8 MCC Formulation Orthogonalization: Windowing Unitary Factorization : Joint Diagonalization: Modified Cross-Correlation for blind Identification of Structures Journal of Engg Mech, ASCE, Hazra et al. (2010) 6

9 JOINT APPROXIMATE DIAGONALIZATION Transformation matrix: 7

10 JOINT APPROXIMATE DIAGONALIZATION Jacobi angles for JAD(Cardoso 1996) 8

11 WMCC Formulation SWT of measurement (r) and source (s r ) Shift invariance Transformation: Wavelet Covariance Matrix: 9

12 NUMERICAL EXAMPLE SNR =10 MAC avg MCC & WMCC outperform conventional modal ID methods like SSI for high damping. Similar conclusions can be drawn for performance in presence of noise & damping estimates 10

13 UNDERDETERMINED BSS EMD MCC TF transform ations Time domain BSS Hybrid BSS Applications: Separation of closely spaced modes, Underdetermined blind identification, Retuning of tuned mass dampers 11

14 HYBRID BSS-1: EMD-MCC Assumed mode shapes: Sinusoidal shape functions with stochastic shape parameters: Pseudo responses : Iterative update : Termination: Under-determined Blind Identification of Structures using Modified Cross Correlation Method. ASCE, Hazra et al. (2011) 14 12

15 Apron control tower (ACT) Results Pearson International Airport, Toronto Hybrid Time Frequency Blind Source Separation Towards Ambient System Identification of Structures. Hazra et al. (2011) 13

16 TABLE: Identified natural frequencies and damping for TMD restrained case using EMD-MCC (PARTIAL SENSOR) Results Under-determined Blind Identification of Structures using Modified Cross Correlation Method. ASCE, Hazra et al. (2011) 14

17 TABLE: Identified natural frequencies and damping for TMD unrestrained case using EMD-MCC Results Closely spaced mode Hybrid Time Frequency Blind Source Separation Towards Ambient System Identification of Structures. Hazra et al. (2011) 15

18 IDENIFIED MODE SHAPES Results Modes corresponding to 0.58 Hz & 0.68 Hz are closely spaced 16

19 SPARSE BSS Another way of solving the underdetermined problem Line of orientation = mode-shape 17

20 X 4 ω X 5 ω SPARSE BSS 20 19

21 f 4 6,v (t) f 4 6,v (t) SPARSE BSS 21 20

22 Closure on BSS based SHM BSS is a robust tool for SHM/ambient vibration monitoring BSS methods allow integrating time-frequency decompositions directly into one formulation The notion of under-determined BI using hybrid BSS is introduced in the field of ambient vibration monitoring EMD-MCC identifies full scale structures more accurately with fewer measurements compared to SSI Sparse-BSS can be used as a tool to solve underdetermined problems with applications to wireless SHM 21

23 Mechanical systems: Gearbox fault diagnosis Gearbox dynamics is difficult: rotor-dynamics, unbalance, misalignment, shaft vibration, gear meshing dynamics, bearing dynamics convolved effects Convolutive mixing problem: Limited success using BSS Gearbox fault diagnosis: Signal processing to generate features Pattern classification Operating conditions can also change: fluctuating rpms, loads 22

24 HISTORY & BACKGROUND Where it all came from? Gear-motors of Toronto airport baggage handling system June August

25 Processing of gearbox signals Traditional approaches: Fourier spectra, cepstrum, envelop spectrum Time frequency techniques: STFT, Wavelets, Wigner Ville distribution Parametric approaches: AR, ARMA, VARMA, KF, EKF based approaches Modern techniques: Empirical mode decomposition(emd), Hilbert-Huang transform, blind source separation (BSS) 24

26 Synchro-squeezing transform Motivation: Fuzzy frequency resolution of CWT around an instantaneous frequency Nonlinear squeezing to evaluate instantaneous frequencies and reduce smearing CWT SST 25

27 Basic steps in SST Calculate the CWT of the signal s(t) Calculate the instantaneous frequencies Apply Synchro-squeezing at frequency centers of successive bins 27 26

28 Signal decomposition IMF extraction around a curve ( ) The curve satisfies the inequality: Daubechies, Lu & Wu (2011) Oberlin & Meignen (2012) 27

29 NUMERICAL EXAMPLE 28 Results of decomposition

30 Fault detection: TVAR modelling TVAR coeff States State space model Kalman gain 29

31 Fault detection: example Signal: 3-sinusoids with baseband freq 320 Hz, 340 Hz & 360 Hz and with FM frequencies of 10 Hz, 30 Hz and 65 Hz concatenated end to end 30

32 Case study: DDS 31

33 DDS experiments AIM: Extraction of 6 states from the data & 2 fault conditions RAW ACCELREATION DATA 32

34 Case study: DDS Hazra et.al (2015) (Journal of vibration and Control) 33

35 Case study: DDS Hazra et.al (2015) (Journal of vibration and Control) 34

36 DDS data: Recursive CI s 35

37 Magnitude Magnitude Case study: DDS Automated widow selection using Sequential Karhunen Loeve Transform applied on the recursive CI s 20 Raw data Singular values x Samples of data x 10 4 Hazra et.al (2015) (Journal of vibration and Control) 36

38 Case study: DDS Hazra et.al (2015) (Journal of vibration and Control) 37

39 Case study: DDS Hazra et.al (2015) (Journal of vibration and Control) 38

40 Closure Synchro-squeezing transform is introduced in the context of rotating machinery diagnosis SST provides sharper frequency TF-representation than CWT SST is also able to decompose non-stationary AM-FM like signals accurately Sequential karhunen Loeve transform can be utilized for automatic window selection Time varying auto-regressive model applied on the extracted IMFs generates diagnostic feature space The framework facilitated separation of operating condition fluctuations and faulted states successfully 39

41 Acknowledgements Erasmus Mundus Euphrates IIT-Guwahati Prof. Paul Fanning, UCD Prof. Vikram Pakrashi, UCD

42 Thank you for patient hearing

43 EXTRA SLIDES 43

44 Automated window selection apriori New data Ross (2008) In the proposed approach we don t use raw data, we use condition indicators obtained recursively For example:

45 EXPERIMENTAL SET-UP & RESULTS adjustable tuning frame suspended mass air dampers Retuning tuned mass dampers based on ambient vibration measurements. Smart materials and tructures, Hazra et al. (2010) 45 25

46 EXPERIMENTAL SET-UP & RESULTS Retuning tuned mass dampers based on ambient vibration measurements. Smart materials and tructures, Hazra et al. (2010) 46 26

47 TMD RETUNING Retuning tuned mass dampers based on ambient vibration measurements. Smart materials and tructures, Hazra et al. (2010) 47 22

48 RETUNING ALGORITHM Primary structure estimation (frequency) : Modeshape: Iterative retuning : μ level retuning : (μ + σ) level retuning : Retuning tuned mass dampers based on ambient vibration measurements. Smart materials and tructures, Hazra et al. (2010) 48 23

49 EXAMPLE WITH SIMULATED DATA 6DOF spring-mass-dashpot system (5+TMD) Excitation: Elcentro ground motion (0.3g) ω (Hz) = 0.78, 0.99, 3.38, 7.10, 10.66, ω (Hz) identified = 0.80, 1.01, 3.42, 7.03, 10.74, Retuning tuned mass dampers based on ambient vibration measurements. Smart materials and tructures, Hazra et al. (2010)

50 EMPIRICAL MODE DECOMPOSITION 50 20

51 TABLE-1: Identified natural frequencies and damping for TMD restrained case (FULL SENSOR DATA) Results Hybrid Time Frequency Blind Source Separation Towards Ambient System Identification of Structures. Hazra et al. (2011) 37

52 f 4 6,0 f 4 6,12 SPARSE BSS f 5 6,0 f 5 6,

53 SPARSE BSS Assuming that the coefficients at the last scale level (j = s) are mono-component: Line of orientation yields the mode shape coefficient 18