Barriere Area Eco-Depot Siting Analysis Open House Presentation December 15, 2009
Presentation Outline Introduction Project Background Review of Screening Analysis Identified Sites Next Steps
Purpose of Presentation Describe how an eco-depot will operate Update the community on the siting analysis work for an eco-depot Inform you of sites we are investigating further Obtain your feedback on our site selection process Use public input to determine preferred site
Project Background 2008 Solid Waste Management Plan (SWMP) identified the need to close several landfills including the Barriere landfill The SWMP identified the need to find operational efficiencies in the whole solid waste management process. Consolidation of transfer stations was a key part of this The Barriere landfill will be replaced by an Eco-depot Potential to consolidate solid waste management operations for the McLure and Agate Bay areas A site for an eco-depot in the Barriere area is now required
What is an Eco-Depot An eco-depot is a new and improved way of managing solid waste throughout the TNRD The site will allow users to efficiently separate recyclable and some hazardous waste from waste destined for landfill May include a compost site in the future Users will be charged tipping fees for waste to be sent to a landfill Offers one stop for all recycling and waste disposal Takes advantage of existing and future provincial product stewardship programs
Is an Eco-Depot the same as a Waste Transfer Station or a Landfill? The garbage transfer component is only one aspect of the eco-depot The eco-depot concept focuses on waste reduction through diversion and recycling rather than disposal Disposal is the final stage at an eco-depot after all materials have been recycled and diverted from the waste stream All residual waste will be hauled away to the Heffley Creek Landfill
What will be collected? Solid waste Recyclables Some hazardous waste Compost (yard waste) What won t be collected Slaughterhouse waste Contaminated soils
Site Design (Class 1 Site)
Class 2 Eco-depot site Logan Lake Existing transfer station in Logan Lake - 1500 tonnes per year Barriere area produces 8,700 MSW per year
Operational Characteristics Eco-depot will be open between 8 am and 6 pm (five days a week likely the same as current landfill) The Barriere eco-depot will handle about 8,700 tonnes of waste (Residential - 6700 tonnes, DLC 2000 tonnes) Estimate of 22,300 total vehicles attending the site per year (~85 per day) Waste will be transferred daily to Heffley Creek Landfill this will control odours and animal attraction B-Train trucks will be used to transfer waste
Site Identification Process Identify key site characteristics Develop analysis of areas that are not suitable for an eco-depot Identify areas that have some suitability Identify potential sites Further exploration of potential sites Consultation throughout
Consultation Consultation will be held with: District Council (November 16, 2009) General Public (tonight) First Nations (have had discussions with Simpcw regarding proposed sites) TNRD Board Regional Solid Waste Management Planning and Implementation Committee (RSWMPIC) Plan Monitoring Advisory Committee (PMAC)
Site Characteristics Flat 2 5 ha Convenient access (i.e. will major intersection upgrades be required) Relatively easy tenure Ease of operations Availability of power and other site services
Screening Analysis - Criteria Floodplains based on the 200 year floodplain Riparian Areas 30 m buffer of streams and other waterways Agricultural Land Reserves (ALR) Parks this included provincial parks in the area Existing Developments land that is already developed Parcel size <2.5 ha any parcel less than 2.5 ha is unsuitable First Nation Reserves Slopes >30%
Screening Analysis - Results
Potential Sites
Louis Creek Industrial Area Upper Site Was in ALR. ALR Exclusion has been received. Some sections of land have steep slopes
Louis Creek Industrial Area Upper Area Characteristics Advantages Flat land available Lower land costs Large parcel is available ALR exclusion has been processed May better serve residents who travel along Agate Bay Road Ability to consolidate some other transfer stations (i.e. McLure, Agate Bay) More isolated from surrounding development Large gravel reserve on the property which could be extracted Disadvantages Availability of services such as water Proximity to some residential areas Some minor environmental liabilities on the site though these are likely minor. Areas with environmental liabilities would remain under Tolko ownership. Other Issues Access requirements would need to be confirmed with the Ministry of Transportation
Louis Creek Industrial Area Lower Area
Louis Creek Industrial Area Lower Area Characteristics Advantages Zoned and designated for industrial Vendor willingness to sell Flat land available May better serve residents who travel along Agate Bay Road Ability to consolidate some other transfer stations (i.e. McLure, Agate Bay) Potential catalyst for development in industrial park Easier access Disadvantages Availability of services Proximity to some residential areas Environmental issues may need to be still addressed by the province (potential time delay)
Barriere Industrial Park
Barriere Industrial Park Site Characteristics Advantages Large sites available Services available Located in an existing industrial park Flat land Close to main area of Barriere Few regulatory issues Disadvantages May have visual impacts to nearby residential Less ability to consolidate operations due to location further north
Dixon Creek Road Site Area is in ALR
Dixon Creek Road Site Characteristics Advantages Large sites available Relatively isolated Disadvantages Poor road access Less ability to consolidate operations due to location further north Site is in the ALR and subject to steep slopes Nearby residential homes in the area
Site Ranking Louis Creek Industrial Area Upper Site Louis Creek Industrial Area Lower Site Barriere Industrial Park Dixon Creek Road Site
Next Steps Investigate each site further for potential benefits/barriers Review sites vs. likely key community concerns Further consultation with other stakeholders Identify preferred site Secure tenure
Questions?