ECONOMIC TRENDS OF ITALIAN ELECTRICITY SECTOR SHORT TERMS STATISTICS

Similar documents
Electricity demand in Spain

Lesson learned about the integration of large amount of volatile Renewable Energy Resources

Electricity and heat statistics

Notes on energy and environmental markets at Overview of Italy and bordering countries

Energy: slight increase, 0.9% for electricity starting in January, gas up 4.7%

Finland Energy efficiency report

France Energy efficiency report

Bulgaria Energy efficiency report

Three Years of Italian Green Certificates: a First Assessment

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands November 2016

STUDY SUMMARY (F) CDC-1319

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands October 2016

Slovenia Energy efficiency report

Fondazione ISTUD Energia, Italia Nuovi competitors e fonti alternative

Renewable Portfolio Standards

Background paper. Electricity production from wind and solar photovoltaic power in the EU

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands May 2017

Competitive energy landscape in Europe

Portugal Energy efficiency report

FRAUNHOFER INSTITUTE FOR SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS ISE

Croatia Energy efficiency report

Har du brug for flere data? 2006 Energistatistik 2006 Data Kort

CHINA 2050 HIGH RENEWABLE ENERGY PENETRATION SCENARIO AND ROADMAP STUDY. Energy Research Institute National Development and Reform Commission

REVIEW OF THE IRISH GOVERNMENT S STRATEGY FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE EUROPEAN DIRECTIVE 2009/28

Long-term Market Analysis Nordics and Europe Executive summary

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands June 2017

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands March 2018

Data, tables, statistics and maps ENERGY STATISTICS

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands September 2018

Stranded Assets in the Utilities Sector as Europe Moves to a Low Carbon Society

FRAUNHOFER INSTITUTE FOR SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS ISE

138 ENVIRONMENTAL PROFILE OF SPAIN 2011

THE SPANISH ELECTRICITY SYSTEM

RES Revolution! How the Sun and the Wind changed the Italian Electricity Market

Increase compared to the previous month in the amount of withdrawal programmes on the DAM. DSM volumes down overall compared to the previous month

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands March 2016

An overview of the European Energy Markets

MACROECONOMIC IMPACTS OF THE LOW CARBON TRANSITION IN BELGIUM ANNEX 1 MAIN RESULTS

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands July 2017

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands September 2017

Recent trends and projections in EU greenhouse gas emissions

THE SPANISH ELECTRICITY SYSTEM

Netherlands Energy efficiency report

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands August 2017

Supporting and integrating RE-Electricity in Italy The GSE experience IEA DSM Task XVII Seoul, Korea, September 2008

21,363 MW 22,774 MW ONTARIO ENERGY REPORT Q JULY SEPT 2014 ELECTRICITY. Electricity Highlights Third Quarter Ontario s Power Grid

Data collected February 2019 Report published March 2019

Renewable Energy in The Netherlands January 2018

GHG emissions per capita. (tco 2. e/cap) Source: UNDP, data for 2015 Source: World Bank Indicators, data for 2012 Source: IEA, data for 2013

The German Electricity System

Renewable & Alternative Energy Resources: What s the difference? 2

Electricity tricity Market Priorities and Infrastructure Requirements Public Pow er Corporation S. A

Development of Renewable Energies in Tunisia

Highlights. Figure 1. World Marketed Energy Consumption by Region,

The 'Energiewende' and the 'transition énergétique' by 2030

ECONOMIC ANALYSIS. A. Macroeconomic Context

Capacity-based network tariffs for Italian electricity households

Quick overview. Energy balance Production of primary energy. Renewable energy. Electricity and district heating. Consumption review 2009

Energy policy support instruments for renewable energy sources: key principles & lessons learnt

Provisional Translation Global Warming

Work supported by WEC Global Partner CESI,Italy

Belgium Energy efficiency report

statistics Electricity information: Overview

Vattenfall s views on the electricity market 2005

KEY FIGURES June 2011

Electricity Supply. Monthly Energy Grid Output by Fuel Type (MWh)

U.S. Carbon Dioxide Emissions in 2009: A Retrospective Review

ELECTRICITY TRADE AGREEMENT. An Assessment of the Ontario-Quebec Electricity Trade Agreement

Renewable Energy: Wind Energy

United Kingdom energy efficiency report

Renewable energy in Europe. E-turn 21 workshop Cologne, 10 May 2006

Outlook for Renewable Energy Market

ACCELERATING GREEN ENERGY TOWARDS 2020 ACCELERATING GREEN ENERGY TOWARDS The Danish Energy Agreement of March 2012

FOSSIL FUEL POWER PLANTS: SOLUTIONS TO IMPROVE FLEXIBILITY

Power System Flexibility in the German and European Context

General overview for investors in Hungary s energy market

CONTENTS Support Mechanisms for the Renewables What is FIT? Alternative mechanisms of renewable energy promotion

Costs and benefits of deploying renewables

Trends and drivers in greenhouse gas emissions in the EU in 2016

Reference scenario with PRIMES

Slovenia Energy efficiency report

Italy energy efficiency report

Renewable Energy in Sweden an Overview

Energy in Kenya. Energy Scenarios Workshop July 24, 2013 Stanley Hotel

Gas and coal competition in the EU power sector. Sylvie Cornot-Gandolphe CEDIGAZ

California ISO. Q Report on Market Issues and Performance. February 10, Prepared by: Department of Market Monitoring

Denmark Energy efficiency report

Renewable Energy Sources Act. Progress Report 2007

Japan energy efficiency report

Making the Electricity System Work

Methodology for calculating subsidies to renewables

Power market integration, focusing on the CHP switch to biomass and electric heating to replace fossil-fuelled heating

Portugal Energy efficiency report

Energy Use in Ontario

A Green European Energy Market : The Role of Cross-border Trade

Statistical Data on Electricity in Italy Summary note DEMAND FOR ELECTRICITY UP IN 2015: +2.0%

Die Energiewende - Consequences of the energy transition on the German electricity market

Cyprus Energy efficiency report

PG&E s Role in California s Clean Energy Future. Emma Wendt Pacific Gas and Electric Company January 25, 2011

Latvia Energy efficiency report

Transcription:

NEWSLETTER January - March 2017 ECONOMIC TRENDS OF ITALIAN ELECTRICITY SECTOR SHORT TERMS STATISTICS In the first three months of 2017 data of national electricity sector has shown an increase in electricity consumption of 0.6% and in electricity production of 6.4%. The latter increase is mostly linked to largest production of January caused by stop for maintenance of numerous French nuclear groups. This led to a reduction of January net import and, consequently, to a reduction of net import/export balance of the first three months of the year. A comparison by sectors shows that in the first three months of 2017, compared to the same period of last year, production from renewable sources failed by 2% while production from fossil fuels rose by 11%. The decline in production by renewable sources is mainly due to the reduction of wind and hydro generation, while the increase of production by fossil fuels is due to the growth of natural gas production. Compared to the first three months of 2016, the production from renewable continuing the downward trend, although at lower rate, and the production from fossil continuing the upward trend, although at a more marked rate. With regard to incentive policies to renewable sources, in the period January- March 2017, the incentives amounted to 2.6 billion euro, with a decrease of 0.4 billion compared to the period January- March 2016. In terms of performance, the average price fixed on the power exchange in the first three months of 2017 considerably increased to 59.6 /MWh, compared to 41.0 /MWh of the same period of 2016, always because of stop of French nuclear groups and of the extraordinary cold wave that affected Europe in January 2017, which pushed the demand up. The final prices of electricity for the typical domestic consumer have been partially affected by this increase, with the consequent rise of the component Energy cost. The increase in production from fossil fuels has resulted in a rise in total greenhouse gas emissions. Finally, it should be noted a slight decrease both of consumption of electricity used per unit of GDP both of consumption of primary energy used per unit of GDP, consistent with the objectives of increase of energy efficiency. Even the electricity penetration is reduced. 1

Summary data Total electricity production and consumption 320,000 270,000 220,000 GWh 170,000 120,000 70,000 20,000-30,000 Difference Jan- 2016 Jan-Mar 16 Jan-Mar 17 Mar 17/16 Electricity production 275,649 66,165 70,426 4,261 Electricity consumption 290,948 73,606 74,049 444 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna data In the first three months of the year, compared to the same period of 2016, an increase in electricity production (+4.3 TWh, equal to +6.4%) occurred. At the same time, there was also a slight increase in electricity consumption (+0.4 TWh, equal to + 0.6%). The growing trend of production and consumption is in contrast, respectively, to stable and decrease values of the same period of the last year. Total electricity production and consumption- Percentage change of difference 7.0% 6.0% 5.0% % 4.0% 3.0% 2.0% 1.0% 0.0% Electricity production Electricity consumption Difference Jan-Mar 17/16 - % 6.4% 0.6% 2

Summary data Electricity production by renewable energy sources 120,000 100,000 80,000 GWh 60,000 40,000 20,000 0-20,000 2016 Jan-Mar 16 Jan-Mar 17 Difference Jan-Mar 17/16 Hydro 40,525 7,456 7,041-416 Geothermal 5,865 1,488 1,459-29 Biomass 17,992 4,612 4,516-96 Wind 17,455 5,865 5,311-554 Photovoltaic 22,545 3,977 4,592 615 TOTAL 104,382 23,398 22,919-480 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna data Between January-March 2017 compared to January-March 2016, the electricity production by renewable has registered a contraction of 480 GWh, continuing the downward trend of the same period of last year, although at lower rate. This decrease is mainly due to the contraction of wind (-554 GWh) and hydro (-416 GWh) productions, followed aloof by slight decrease of biomass and geothermal productions. The photovoltaic production (+615 GWh), however, is growing. 3

Summary data Electricity production by fossil fuels 180,000 160,000 140,000 120,000 GWh 100,000 80,000 60,000 40,000 20,000 0-20,000 2016 Jan-Mar 16 Jan-Mar 17 Difference Jan-Mar 17/16 Natural gas 121,743 29,740 35,357 5,617 Coal 31,664 8,465 8,015-450 Oil products and other fossil fuels 16,062 4,112 3,642-470 TOTAL 169,469 42,317 47,013 4,696 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna, Eurostat, Snam Rete Gas and MiSE data Between January-March 2017 compared to January-March 2016, the electricity production by fossil fuels registered a growth of 4,696 GWh, confirming the growing trend recorded in the same period of last year, although at a more marked rate. This increase is linked to the raise of production by natural gas (+5,617 GWh). By contrast, solid fuels and Oil products decreased by 450 and 470 GWh, respectively. 4

Summary data Electricity production by fossil fuels and renewable sources 310,000 260,000 210,000 GWh 160,000 110,000 60,000 10,000-40,000 2016 Jan-Mar 16 Jan-Mar 17 Difference Jan- Mar 17/16 Renewable sources 104,382 23,398 22,919-480 Fossil sources 169,469 42,317 47,013 4,696 TOTAL 273,851 65,715 69,932 4,216 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna data Between January-March 2017 compared to January-March 2016, the weight of production from fossil fuels on total production has risen from 64% to 67%. Instead, the weight of renewable generation on total production has fallen from 36% to 33%. 5

Summary data CO2 emissions from thermoelectric production 140 120 100 M t 80 60 40 20 0 Difference 1990 2016 Jan-Mar 16 Jan-Mar 17 Jan-Mar 17/16 CO2 emissions 126.2 96.0 24.4 26.0 1.6 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna, Eurostat, Snam Rete Gas, MiSE and ISPRA data In the first three months of the year, compared to the same period of 2016, CO 2 emissions from thermoelectric production increased by 1.6 million of tonnes, due to more emissions resulting from the wide growth of power generation from natural gas. This trend is in line to increase values of first three months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015 (+0.9 million of tonnes). 6

Summary data Electricity intensity 0.200 0.198 0.196 0.194 kwh/ 0.192 0.190 0.188 0.186 0.184 0.182 0.180 2015 2016 Electricity intensity 0.191 0.185 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna and Eurostat data Electricity intensity of 2016 is slightly decreased, compared to 2015, due to the reduction of electricity consumption and the simultaneous increase of GDP. This fall reflects a reduction in the amount of electricity used to produce wealth, consistent with the objectives of increase of energy efficiency. 7

Summary data Electricity penetration 23% 22% % 21% 20% 19% 18% 2016 Jan-Mar 16 Jan-Mar 17 Electricity penetration 21.9% 19.4% 18.9% Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna, Eurostat, Snam Rete Gas and MiSE data Between January-March 2017, electricity penetration stood at 18.9%, slightly down compared to 19.4% of the same period of last year. This drop indicates a decrease in electricity use in final energy consumption, since the percentage growth of electricity consumption of the period was smaller than the percentage growth of the total final energy consumption. 8

Summary data National Single Price (PUN) 100 90 80 70 /MWh 60 50 40 30 20 10 Hours 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 2016 39.9 36.8 34.5 33.5 33.4 35.2 40.3 45.8 49.8 48.8 46.2 44.4 41.1 39.9 41.6 43.5 45.9 49.3 52.4 54.4 52.8 48.6 45.0 41.1 Jua-Mar 2016 35.0 31.9 30.0 29.1 29.0 32.0 38.0 42.4 46.5 46.0 43.1 41.2 37.1 36.0 38.0 41.1 44.0 49.1 52.2 52.5 46.8 43.4 40.3 36.7 Jua-Mar 2017 51.1 47.6 45.4 43.8 43.6 46.9 54.3 63.5 69.5 67.4 64.3 61.2 56.8 55.0 56.7 59.1 62.3 67.9 75.4 73.7 67.5 61.3 57.0 53.4 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on GME data Between January-March 2017 compared to January-March 2016, the curve of PUN hourly average for each of the 24 hours of the day has shifted markedly upwards. This trend is in contrast to the downward trend recorded between January-March 2016 compared to January-March 2015. 9

Summary data Incentives for electricity production from RES Mld 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0-1 -2 2016 Jan-Mar 16 Jan-Mar 17 Difference Jan- Mar 17/16 Incentives for RES 13.4 3.0 2.6-0.4 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on AEEGSI and Terna data In the first three months of the year, compared to the same period of 2016, the incentives for electricity production from RES decreased of 0.4 billion of euro, reaching 2.6 billion of euro. In the first three months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, the incentives were slightly increased (+0.1 billion of euro). 10

Section 1 Framework of the sector Electricity consumption 30,000 120 29,000 115 28,000 27,000 110 GWh 26,000 25,000 24,000 105 100 95 Index number 23,000 22,000 90 21,000 85 20,000 average Jan-Mar 16 monthly aver. 2016 average Jan-Mar 17 Jan-17 Feb-17 Mar-17 Electricity consumptions - GWh 26,114 23,375 24,560 Average Jan-Mar 16 24,535 Monthly average 2016 24,246 Average Jan-Mar 17 24,683 Electricity consumptions index number 108 96 101 - average 2016 basis 100 80 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna data The graphic illustrates the evolution, in each of the three months of the 2017, of electricity consumption (left scale) and electricity consumption index number, made up on the basis of the average monthly value of 2016 (right scale). Moreover, the graphic draws monthly average electricity consumption in January-March 2016, year 2016 and January-March 2017 (left scale). In the first three months of the year, the average consumption amounted to 24,683 GWh, with a increase of 148 GWh compared to the same period of last year. 11

Section 1 Framework of the sector 20,000 19,000 18,000 17,000 16,000 15,000 14,000 13,000 12,000 11,000 average monthly average Jan-17 Feb-17 Mar-17 Jan-Mar 16 aver. 2016 Jan-Mar 17 Fossil Production - GWh 19,177 15,161 12,675 Average Jan-Mar 16 14,106 Monthly average 2016 14,122 Average Jan-Mar 17 15,671 GWh Electricity production by fossil fuel In January-March 2017 compared to the same period of last year, the average electricity production from renewable sources decreased by 160 GWh, while the average electricity production from fossil fuels increased by 1.565 GWh. 10,000 Electricity production by RES 9,500 9,000 8,500 GWh 8,000 7,500 7,000 6,500 6,000 media gen-mar 2016 media mens. 2016 media gen-mar 2017 gen-17 feb-17 mar-17 RES Production - GWh 7,468 6,634 8,816 Average Jan-Mar 16 7,799 Monthly average 2016 8,698 Average Jan-Mar 17 7,640 Index numbers of electricity production by fossil fuels and RES 150 140 130 Index number 120 110 100 90 80 70 60 Fossil production index number - average 2016 basis 100 RES Production index number - average 2016 basis 100 Jan-17 Feb-17 Mar-17 136 107 90 86 76 101 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna data The first two graphics illustrate fossil fuels production (graphic at the top) and RES production (graphic in the centre). Each of two graphics describes the trend of production (from fossil fuels or renewable, depending on the graphic) in each of three months of the 2017 and monthly average productions in January-March 2016, year 2016 and January-March 2017. Instead, the latest graphic below describes the trend, between January and March 2017, of fossil fuels and renewable production s index numbers, that take as basis the 2016 average production of fossil fuels and renewable production respectively. 12

Section 1 Framework of the sector Net import/export balance of electricity 5,000 190 4,500 170 GWh 4,000 3,500 3,000 2,500 150 130 110 90 Index number 2,000 70 1,500 50 1,000 average Jan-Mar 16 monthly aver. 2016 average Jan-Mar 17 Jan-17 Feb-17 Mar-17 Net import/export balance - GWh 1,270 3,185 4,747 Average Jan-Mar 16 4,310 Monthly average 2016 3,086 Average Jan-Mar 17 3,067 Net import/export balance of electricity index 41 103 154 number - average 2016 basis 100 30 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna data The graph illustrates the evolution, in each of the three months of 2017, of net import/export balance of electricity (left scale) and index number of net import/export balance, made up on the basis of the average monthly value of 2016 (right scale). Moreover, it describes monthly average of net import/ export balance of electricity in January-March 2016, year 2016 and January-March 2017 (left scale). Between January-March 2017 compared to January-March 2016, the monthly average of Italian net electricity import from foreign countries has fallen of 1.243 GWh. 13

Section 2 - Performance Trend of PUN - Brent / Gas price 80 200 75 180 70 65 160 /MWh 60 55 50 140 120 100 Index number 45 40 80 35 60 30 average Jan-Mar 16 monthly aver. 2016 average Jan-Mar 17 Jan-17 Feb-17 Mar-17 PUN - /MWh 75.8 57.4 45.5 Average Jan-Mar 16 PUN - /MWh 41.0 Monthly average 2016 PUN - /MWh 44.1 Average Jan-Mar 17 PUN - /MWh 59.6 PUN index num.- average 2016 basis 100 172.0 130.3 103.3 Brent index num. - average 2016 basis 100 128.5 129.2 120.8 Gas index num. - average 2016 basis 100 150.8 130.6 112.4 40 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on GME and CONFINDUSTRIA data The graphic illustrates the evolution, in each of three months of 2017, of PUN (left scale) and index numbers of PUN, Brent and Gas Natural, made up on the basis of 2016 average value of PUN, Brent and Natural gas, respectively (right scale). Moreover, it describes PUN monthly average in January- March 2016, year 2016 and January-March 2017 (left scale). Between January-March 2017, the PUN monthly average value increased reaching 59.6 /MWh, compared to 41.0 /MWh of the same period of 2016. The PUN monthly average of January-March 2017 is even higher compared to the average price of first three months of 2015 (53.5 /MWh). The graphic shows how the trend of PUN reflects mostly Natural Gas price, while it is decoupled from the price of Brent. 14

Section 2 - Performance Price of typical domestic consumer 195 193 191 189 /MWh 187 185 183 181 179 177 175 average I-II quar 2016 average 2016 average I-II quar 2017 I quar 17 II quar 17 Total electricity price - /MWh 186.3 191.8 Price average I-II quar 2016- /MWh 183.7 Price quarterly average 2016 - /MWh 184.6 Price average I-II quar 2017 - /MWh 189.1 130 Value of components 120 Index number 110 100 90 80 70 I quar 17 II quar 17 Energy I.N. - average 2016 basis 100 104.0 112.3 Network I.N. - average 2016 basis 100 119.5 119.5 System costs I.N. - average 2016 basis 100 82.4 78.7 Taxes I.N. - average 2016 basis 100 100.6 102.6 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on AEEGSI data The upper graph illustrates the trend of total electricity price for typical domestic consumer in the first two quarters of 2017 and quarterly average of this price of the first two quarters of 2016, entire 2016 and first two quarters of 2017. The lower graphic represents index numbers of four main cost components which are remunerated by electricity price paid from typical domestic consumer, that is Energy cost, Network costs, System costs and Taxes. Each of this index number uses the 2016 average of relative components as a basis. Average price of domestic consumer in the first two quarters of 2017 increased to 189.1 /MWh, compared to 183.7 /MWh of the same period of 2016, in contrast to downward trend recorded in the same period of last year (in the first two quarters of 2015 the average price was 186.2). Focusing on first two quarters of 2017, we can see how the electricity price trend mainly reflects the trend of electricity cost and partly also the trend of Taxes. We may also see that, in the first two quarters of 2017, System costs and Network Costs registered respectively a contraction and a stability, because of the start in 2017 of the second phase of tariff reform for domestic electricity customers, which was launched in 2016. The reform will be fully operational in 2018 when the full non-progressive structure will be applied not only to Network Costs, but also to System costs. 15

Section 2 - Performance CO2 emissions - value of emission credits 650 9 600 8 550 gco2/kwh 500 450 7 6 /tco2 400 350 5 300 4 250 2016 Jan-Mar 16 Jan-Mar 17 CO2 emissions of consumption - gco2/kwh 330 331 350 CO2 emissions of total production - gco2/kwh 348 369 368 CO2 emissions of thermoelectric production - gco2/kwh 566 576 552 Value of emission credits - /tco2 5.2 5.5 5.1 3 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna, Eurostat, Snam Rete Gas, MiSE, ISPRA and EEX data The graphic illustrates CO 2 emissions in relation to consumption, gross production and thermoelectric production (left scale) and the value of emission credits (right scale). Between January-March 2017 compared to January-March 2016, CO 2 emissions on consumption have increased of 19 gco 2 /kwh, CO 2 emissions on total production remained almost stable, while CO 2 emissions in relation to thermoelectric production have decreased of 24 gco 2 /kwh. In the first three months of 2017 compared to the same period of 2016, the value of emission credits decreased from 5.5 to 5.1 /tco 2, continuing the downward trend of the same period of last year, although at lower rate (in the first three months of 2015 the value of emission credits was at 7.0 / tco 2 ). 16

Section 3 Macroeconomic framework GDP - Primay energy intensity of GDP 393,000 105 392,000 100 391,000 M 390,000 95 toe/m 90 389,000 388,000 85 387,000 2015 2016 GDP quarterly average - M 388,751 392,172 GDP primary intensity - toe/m 99 96 80 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Terna, Eurostat, Snam Rete Gas and MiSE data The graphic illustrates the quarterly GDP average of 2016 and of 2017 (left scale) and the primary energy intensity of GDP, for the same periods of time (right scale). In line with the electricity intensity, also the primary energy intensity of 2016, compared to 2015, decreased from 99 toe/m to 96 toe/m, due to the reduction of primary energy consumption and the simultaneous increase of GDP in the period. This fall reflects a reduction in the amount of primary energy consumption used to produce wealth, consistent with the objectives of increase of energy efficiency. 17

Section 3 Macroeconomic framework Consumer price index - Price of typical domestic consumer 200 109 195 107 190 105 /MWh 185 180 103 101 Index number 99 175 97 170 average 2015 average 2016 I quar 16 II quar 16 III quar 16 IV quar 16 I quar 17 Total electricity price- /MWh 188.4 179.0 186.6 184.5 186.3 Price quarterly average 2015 - /MWh 186.8 Price quarterly average 2016 - /MWh 184.6 Total electricity price I.N. - average 2015 basis 100 100.8 95.8 99.9 98.7 99.7 Consumer price I.N. - average 2015 basis 100 99.7 99.9 100.3 100.2 101.0 95 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Istat and AEEGSI data On the left scale, the graphic illustrates the trend of electricity price for typical domestic consumer between the first quarter of 2016 and the first quarter of 2017 and the quarterly average of this price in 2015 and 2016. The right scale describes the trends of index number of electricity price for typical consumer and the index number of consumer price index, calculated on the basis of the 2015 average electricity price for typical consumer and consumer price index, respectively. Index number of electricity price for typical domestic consumer, that is a nominal value, between the first quarter of 2016 and the first quarter of 2017 decreased by 1.1%, against a rise of index number of consumer price index equal to 1.3%. 18

Section 4 European comparison Electricity production 700,000 600,000 GWh 500,000 400,000 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 United Italy Germany Spain France Kingdom Electricity production 2015 270,703 620,685 266,572 544,176 320,229 Electricity production 2016 275,649 617,281 262,238 530,138 318,619 Net import/export balance of electricity 60,000 40,000 20,000 GWh 0-20,000-40,000-60,000-80,000 Italy German y Spain France United Kingdo m Net import/export balance 2015 46,381-48,284-173 -64,326 20,893 Net import/export balance 2016 37,026-50,524 7,627-41,862 17,465 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Eurostat data Compared to the main European countries, it is evident that Italy, despite its surplus of installed production capacity, imports a significant amount of electricity compared to internal production. We can also note that in 2016 Spain has registered a net import of 7,627 GWh, compared to net export of 173 GWh of 2015. Since 2012 (as you can see in the first Newsletter), Spain was a net exporter of electricity. Gradually, however, between 2012 and 2015, its net export declined until it became in 2016 a net importer. Focusing only on the production, in 2016 compared to 2015, all countries considered in the analysis, except Italy, experienced a reduction in production, with France which registered the largest decrease (-14,038 GWh). 19

Section 4 European comparison Thermoelectric production GWh 450,000 400,000 350,000 300,000 250,000 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 0 Italy German y Spain France United Kingdo m Thermoelectric production 2015 180,871 379,420 120,283 41,875 200,579 Thermoelectric production 2016 187,461 386,452 106,064 54,437 198,887 Thermoelectric nuclear production 450,000 400,000 GWh 350,000 300,000 250,000 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 0 United Italy Germany Spain France Kingdom Nuclear production 2015 0 86,767 54,957 416,796 63,895 Nuclear production 2016 0 80,038 56,099 383,943 65,148 RES production 160,000 140,000 GWh 120,000 100,000 80,000 60,000 40,000 20,000 0 Italy Germany Spain France United Kingdom RES production 2015 88,477 148,224 88,262 80,856 53,387 RES production 2016 86,404 144,754 97,159 87,250 51,642 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Eurostat data Note: biomass production is included in thermoelectric production In 2016, compared to 2015, France and Germany have experienced a decrease of nuclear production and a growth of thermoelectric production. Instead about renewable production, while France has registered a growth, Germany have experienced a decline. Finally, we note that Spain has experienced the largest contraction in thermoelectric production (-14,219 GWh) and the largest increase in renewable production (+8,898 GWh). United Kingdom has registered only an increase in nuclear production. 20

Section 4 European comparison GDP in chain-linked volumes 3,000,000 2,500,000 M 2,000,000 1,500,000 1,000,000 500,000 0 United Italy Germany Spain France Kingdom GDP 2015 1,555,006 2,791,109 1,068,283 2,094,983 2,023,577 GDP 2016 1,568,687 2,843,033 1,102,851 2,119,632 2,060,123 Electricity intensity 0.2600 0.2400 kwh / 0.2200 0.2000 0.1800 0.1600 0.1400 United Italy Germany Spain France Kingdom Electricity intensity 2015 0.1901 0.1928 0.2208 0.2086 0.1526 Electricity intensity 2016 0.1855 0.1876 0.2163 0.2100 0.1484 Source: Elettricità Futura elaborations on Eurostat data All five countries considered in the analysis, in 2016 compared to 2015, have experienced an increase in GDP. Germany leads the group (+51,924 million ), followed at a distance by UK (+36,546 million ), by Spain (+34,568 million ), by France (+24,649 million ) and queued Italy (+13,681 million ). About electricity intensity, Italy and Germany are halfway between United Kingdom, which is the bestperforming country, and countries less-performing (Spain and France). 21

GLOSSARY Biomass When the distinction isn t useful, in general reference is made to biomass (solid), biogas, bio liquid and biodegradable waste. Brent price It is the Brent spot price in $ per barrel. CO 2 emissions Carbon dioxide emissions, following to combustion of fossil fuels and non-biodegradable wastes, in order to produce electricity. CO 2 emission allowances and credits Emission allowances of European Emission Trading Scheme (EU ETS) are CO 2 emission rights, in order to comply with EU ETS compensation obligations. Each allowance is equal to 1 ton of CO 2, namely it can be used to compensate the equivalent of 1 metric ton of CO 2 emission. Allowances are tradable and, according to the scheme in force since 2013, they are partly allocated through public auctions, where they are also called emission credits. Since 2013, the credit value is the auction awarding price of 3rd phase (2013 2020), on the European Transitional Common Auction Platform (EU T-CAP). The emission credits price of a given period is calculated as average of awarding prices of auctions carried out during that period, weighted by the exchanged volumes. Components of the price of electricity for customers of enhanced protection These are the main four components paid through the price of electricity bill paid by customers of enhanced protection and fixed by AEEGSI (Italian Regulatory Authority for Electricity Gas and Water). These components are: The energy cost, given by cost of purchasing electricity; The network costs, to cover the infrastructures costs necessary to transmission, distribution and metering services and costs related to the provision of such services; The system costs, to cover different costs, mostly addressed to support electricity production from RES; Taxes on electricity supply, as excise tax and value added tax (VAT). Consumer price index For the purpose of this analysis, the national consumer price index (NIC) with tobaccos has been used. ISTAT (Italian National Institute of Statistics) supplies this index with 2015 as basis. This index is a measure of inflation trend in the country, since it is build as weighed average of prices of goods and services of a specific basket taken as a reference. Electricity consumption They are equal to the demand for electricity on the grid, net of grid losses. 22

Electricity intensity In this newsletter, it is the ratio between electricity consumption and raw GDP in chain-linked volumes, with 2010 as reference year. It represents the amount of electricity used per unit of wealth produced, so it is an indicator of the level of efficiency. Any increase of this indicator, however, could be linked to a reduction of GDP. It was decided to take the raw GDP for consistency of comparison between the GDP and electricity consumption, whose monthly time series is not seasonally adjusted. Electricity penetration In this newsletter, it is the ratio between electricity consumptions and the total final energy consumption. It is an indicator of how much of the final energy consumption is met through electricity vector (so called electrification of consumptions). Electricity production Total electricity production. In this newsletter electricity production is considered, net of auxiliary services. Electricity production by fossil fuels Electricity production by solid fuels, natural gas, derived gases, crude oil and its derivatives (fuel oil, diesel oil, etc ) Electricity production by renewable energy sources The electricity production by renewable hydro (without pumping), geothermal, wind, solar and photovoltaic and biomass, biogas, bio liquid and biodegradable wastes. Exception is the production of electricity from renewable energy sources used for European comparison that does not include biomass. Enhanced protection service It is the service of electricity supply in economic and contractual conditions laid down by AEEGSI (Italian Regulatory Authority for Electricity, Gas and Water). European comparison In order to carry out the quarterly comparison between the main four European countries, monthly Eurostat data are taken as reference. Yearly monthly values sum, regularly published by European statistical office, not necessarily corresponds to final annual data. Fossil fuels In this newsletter fossil fuels are solid fuels, natural gas, derived gases, crude oil and his derivatives (fuel oil, diesel oil, etc ). Gas Price In this newsletter, the price at the point of virtual exchange (PSV) is considered. Prices refers to Day-Ahead products, namely related to the day-after delivery. 23

GDP and GDP in chain-linked volumes with reference year 2010 In general term, GDP is the total value of goods and services produced within a country in a specific time interval (usually quarterly and yearly), both by residents and not residents and addressed to final uses (final consumption, investments, net exports). Therefore, it is not counted in the production for intermediate consumptions, which represents the value of goods and services used and converted in the production process for new goods and services. The gross domestic product used in this analysis is the raw GDP in chain-linked volumes with reference year 2010. The GDP is defined raw when it is not adjusted for calendar effects and seasonal fluctuations. Instead the GDP in chain-linked volumes with reference year 2010 is a measure of real GDP as it provides a measure of GDP over time in terms of volume, that is, excluding underlying prices dynamic, through a system of chain index. From September 2014 Eurostat and the individual statistical offices in Europe, have begun to calculate the GDP with the new European system of national and regional accounts, European System of Accounts 2010 (Sec2010), in place of Sec95 and introduced the series of raw GDP in chain-linked volumes with reference year 2010. Incentives for RES In general, the amounts of money used to support the production of electricity from renewable energy sources. Incentive for RES have been estimated by using data from AEEGSI (Italian Regulatory Authority for Electricity, Gas and Water) and/or from Counter of Renewable costs and Counter of Photovoltaic costs, which are available on GSE website. National Single Price (PUN) In this newsletter, it is the hourly average - for each of the 24 hours of the day - of the purchase price of electricity, weighted with hourly purchases, net purchases of pumping hydro and areas abroad. The monthly PUN is calculated as an average of PUN for each hour of the month weighted to the quantities purchased. Net import/export balance In this newsletter, it represents the difference between national electricity imports from foreign countries and national electricity exports to foreign countries. Primary energy intensity of GDP In this newsletter, it is the ratio between total gross inland consumption of energy and raw GDP in chain-linked volumes with reference year 2010. It express the amount of primary energy per unit of wealth produced. It was decided to take the raw GDP for consistency of comparison between GDP and the gross inland consumption of energy, which time series are not seasonally adjusted. Renewable energy sources (RES) In this newsletter, renewable energy sources are renewable hydroelectric (without pumping), geothermal, wind, solar and photovoltaic and biomass, biogas, bio liquid and biodegradable wastes. 24

Thermoelectric production Electricity production by combustion processes. In this Newsletter it includes not only the energy produced from fossil fuels, but also from biomass, biogas, bio liquids, non-biodegradable wastes and nuclear. In the section on European comparisons, it is preferred to separate thermoelectric production from nuclear from the remaining thermoelectric production. Thermoelectric sources In general, fossil fuels, biomass, biogas, bio liquid, non-biodegradable wastes, geothermal and nuclear to produce electricity. Typical domestic consumer As a part of enhanced protection service, Typical domestic consumer is the residential domestic customer, typically a family, with a connection capacity up to 3 kw and 2,700 kwh of annual consumption. Typical domestic consumer price It is the price of electricity paid by residential domestic customer, typically a family, with a connection capacity up to 3 kw and 2,700 kwh of annual consumption. The Newsletter is edited by the research department of Elettricità Futura. For clarification requests send an email to info@elettricitafutura.it, indicating in the subject of the email Newsletter. 25

Roma: Via Benozzo Gozzoli, 24-00142 Tel. +39 06 8537281 Fax +39 06 85356431 Milano: Via G.B. Pergolesi, 27-20124 Tel. +39 02 6692673 www.elettricitafutura.it - info@elettricitafutura.it